Help picking out a new video camcorder...what format do I use?

Help! I want to purchase a new HD video camcorder. I want a good unit with a limit being close to the $1,000 range. I will make some short movies and am struggling with what to purchase. I use FCE 4.01 for most of my editing, and sometimes I will use iMovie as well.
My struggle is the format. I've read so much stuff that I'm confused on what to purchase. I've used MiniDV in the past, yet there are a number of other formats out now and it appears that many of them will not work with my gear.
Can someone just give me a straight answer, do I stay with a tape unit, even though they are phasing this out? Or do I purchase another type of format. It needs to work with my MAC and not have any problems, hangups, or have to go through various steps and other programs to be able to use it. So simplicity is important. But I also don't want to be hard headed if I need to use another format.
Your help is very much appreciated.
Mike

Mike Domke wrote:
.. AVCHD... I can use it, but it must be converted even though my MAC and FCE support the AVCHD format.
'supports' means: import from. - then, under the hood, out of your control, hidden in the woods.. ooops... - AVCHD gets converted into an edit-intermediate. you can not edit AVCHD natively on a Mac with iM or FCE. this transformation is mainly lossless. only thing, you'll notice: the content from you 8GB-SDcard grabs 40-60GBs on your Mac! => so high compressed is AVCHD, and for edit, you need each frame of video free accessible.. files get expanded..
As for easy to use, the HDV on miniDV tape is smooth. The biggest drawback is the length of time that it takes to import into the computer. And of course the fact that it is outdated.
naw, not outdated.. on a semi-pro level, tape is still #1. and that real-time import.. as a hobbyist, I'm not in a hurry..
biggest advantage: actually HDV is the ONLY format which allows to play-out your HiDef projects back to some media (=tiny miniDVtapes) .. AVCHD is one-way-only.. when edit done, then...? BluRay? extra costs, 'cause 3rd party solutions needed. MediaCenter? Extra.. AppleTV? No support of FullHD.. yet. Tape, Holocrystal, The Cloud...? Nope. AVCHD-sourced-projects can only be stored on harddrives. and even more harddrives.. you need additional harddrives for backups of the harddrives .. ... .. ... ...
I was actually thinking Canon based on all the reviews I have been reading.
they have an excellent reputation (some miniDVs acted iffy..) , Canon builds its own components, Canon is a brand in professional broadcasting.. I like them.. allthough my actual cam is a Sony :)))

Similar Messages

  • Need Help Picking Out A New Graphic Card

    I have a nVidia GeForce 5200 graphics card in my PowerMac G5 1.6mhz (AGP) that I'd like to upgrade. Does anyone have some recommendations for a better card that doesn't cost more than $200. I'm wanting to get better performance when using programs like Final Cut Pro and Motion. The current card doesn't cut it very well.
    Also, has anyone seen some side-by-side benchmarks for all the various cards. I'm having a hard time finding comparisons to my current card. I'm just curious as to how much faster a new card would be.
    Thanks much,
    Ray

    $200 will be a problem. In order of speed, starting with the fastest:
    ATI Radeon® X800 XT MAC Edition RoHS 256MB AGP
    NVIDIA GeForce 6800 Ultra 256 MB DDL (AGP)
    NVIDIA GeForce 6800 GT 256 MB DDL (AGP)
    ATI Radeon™ 9800 Pro Mac Special Edition
    ATI Radeon® 9600 Pro PC & MAC Edition 256MB
    Look for them at
    <http://www.welovemacs.com/g5video.html>
    <http://eshop.macsales.com/shop/video/hardware/>
    <http://shop.ati.com/searchresults.asp?dept_id=31>
    Speed comparisons
    <http://www.barefeats.com/radx800.html>

  • I have picked out a moderately priced camcorder (Sony HDR-CX260V High Definition Handycam) andwant to know if it produces files that easily integrate with FCP X on Lion. Thanks.

    I have picked out a moderately priced camcorder (Sony HDR-CX260V High Definition Handycam) andwant to know if it produces files that easily integrate with FCP X on Lion. Thanks.

    Download the free 30 day trial of FCP X to find out for certain.
    http://www.apple.com/uk/finalcutpro/trial/

  • I have 2007 mac pro i need a new graphic card what kind can i use?

    have 2007 mac pro i need a new graphic card what kind can i use?

    http://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?t=1345150
    http://blog.macsales.com/6856-owc-reveals-which-radeon-video-cards-work-with-200 6-2009-mac-pros

  • Is there an app or way that you can take a single frame out of a video shot on the iPhone and use it as a picture?

    Is there an app or way that you can take a single frame out of a video shot on the iPhone and use it as a picture?

    I don't know if there is an app, but you can take a snapshot of the video.  I do this all the time.   You just need to hold down the power and home key once and it will take a snapshot.

  • I want to format my hard drive so i can have files bigger than 4GB what format should I use?

    I have a new hard drive that I want to format so it will work with both mac and PC (windows) but I have files that are bigger than 4GB, what format should I use?
    It needs to work with both PC and mac because I need to go between two computers etc

    If both of these computers are connect to the same router, both are in your home or place of work (Both are in the same location), it is very easy to Network them so you don't have to use DropBox or the external drive to share files between them.
    MickAUS2012 wrote:
    yea thanks for that,  i have drop box so i use that for some of my smaller files. Im just new to the mac so this is all a learning experince thanks for all your help everyone!

  • What format do I use for internal drive?

    I want to install a new internal harddrive into my Macbook.  What format should I use for it?
    Mac OS Extended (Journaled)
    Mac OS Extended
    Mac OS Extended (Case-sensitive, Journaled)
    Mac OS Extended (Case-sensitive)
    MS-DOS (FAT)
    ExFAT
    I know MS-DOS(FAT) is what I should use for external to work on mac and windows.  Can't remember which to use for the internal.  I have an Intel-based Mac.
    Thanks for your help.

    I use SuperDuper for cloning my OSX volumes and it does not change the size of the destination partition to the size of the source partition.
    So, you can make the destination partitions size to your liking and the cloning will not change it afterwards.
    Keep in mind that SuperDuper or Carbon Copy Cloner cannot clone a BootCamp Windows partition to a new harddisk, only OSX partitions.
    But Parallels doesn't need to have a Windows partitions but is mostly just two files plus the Parallels app on your OSX partition.
    And therefor it would be cloned with the rest of the OSX.
    Stefan

  • What format do I use to post on youtube so that IPhone and Androids can play it?

    adobe premiere pro cs6: What format do I use to post on youtube so that IPhone and Androids can play it?
    how do I fix it so it will play
    I tryed
    h.264 youtube hd 720,
    h.264 andriod phone
    here is the youtube video play's fine on pc but will not play on Andriod or Iphone at all
    Jillian Jensen My Dedication Video - YouTube
    if someone can tell me what setting I need to do or what I need to do so it will play
    I have tryed to 10 diffrent ones and none seam to work

    It could very well be due to copyrighted content.
    “Videos are not available on this platform” error message - YouTube Help

  • What format can i use on my apple tv for films

    what format can i use on my apple tv for films  .. whats best

    Video formats supported
    H.264 video up to 1080p, 30 frames per second, High or Main Profile level 4.0 or lower, Baseline profile level 3.0 or lower with AAC-LC audio up to 160 Kbps per channel, 48kHz, stereo audio in .m4v, .mp4, and .mov file formats
    MPEG-4 video up to 2.5 Mbps, 640 by 480 pixels, 30 frames per second, Simple Profile with AAC-LC audio up to 160 Kbps, 48kHz, stereo audio in .m4v, .mp4, and .mov file formats
    Motion JPEG (M-JPEG) up to 35 Mbps, 1280 by 720 pixels, 30 frames per second, audio in ulaw, PCM stereo audio in .avi file format
    Audio formats supported
    HE-AAC (V1), AAC (16 to 320 Kbps), protected AAC (from iTunes Store), MP3 (16 to 320 Kbps), MP3 VBR, Audible (formats 2, 3, and 4), Apple Lossless, AIFF, and WAV; Dolby Digital 5.1 surround sound pass-through
    Photo formats
    JPEG, GIF, TIFF.

  • What format i should use for my external hard drive that can be used interchangeably between mac and pc?

    What format i should use for my external hard drive that can be used interchangeably between mac and pc?

    Usually Fat32/MS-DOS as mentioned, but that has several limitatiuns, like 4GB filesize limit.
    One option is MacDrive for you PCs... allows them to Read/Write HFS+...
    http://www.mediafour.com/products/macdrive/
    More options...
    NTFS-3G Stable Read/Write Driver...
    http://www.ntfs-3g.org/
    MacFUSE: Full Read-Write NTFS for Mac OS X, Among Others...
    http://www.osnews.com/story/16930

  • Help to pick-out a new windows 8 touch screen laptop

    I Don't need to most expensive or the cheapest. I guess I want the most bang for my buck. I am not up-to-date on my PCs so I need your help. Just reply with your thoughts and ideas. I've always had Hp but it has been 3 years since I have bought a new laptop. I have a few android tablets but no new laptop. The main one I use now is a 64 bit windows 7 with 2.2GHz duel core 17" screen and 4gb ram. It still works just fine but I'm thinking about a faster PC and want the touch screen like my tablets. No resistive touch screens if they even make them anymore.
    Looking for the following
    windows 8
    touch screen
    i7 or same in amd
    8 gb or more ram
    not sure about the rest
    Please give me your opinion or advice. if you could buy anything at best buy, which ones and why? PS I game on the PS3 (soon on the PS4) but not on the PC and I don't like lag or buffering in any way.
    Solved!
    Go to Solution.

    hmmm, from what you are telling me, I would suggest this laptop:
    http://www.bestbuy.com/site/Asus+-+15.6%22+Touch-Screen+Laptop+-+8GB+Memory+-+750GB+Hard+Drive+-+Bla...
    I would suggest because I am an asus fan myself, I have always used them as my go to manufacturer with my motherboards on any custom built PC i put together. They are a very reputable name, and are very well made. It should meet all your needs, has 750 GBs of hard drive space (gives you enough room for all the HD pictures and videos!) as well as plenty of ram and an i7 Processor. The ONLY thing i see that might be slightly better is a couple of the sony vaios have solid state drives, and that is a nice plus. Faster boot times, faster read/write speeds. But as you said you didn't want something to make you spend more if it was not a big difference and while it would be a difference, I don't see it being THAT big of a difference for yourself. If you can find a local best buy that has that Asus, I would suggest going in to check it out if its on display. Get a feel for it and see if you like the keyboard. That is a big MUST on buying a laptop, making sure you like the keyboard!
    I hope this helped! post any other questions if you like!
    Even though I work for best buy, my posts and thoughts are that of my own and do NOT represent best buy in ANY WAY.

  • Help picking out an Amp

    I just bought two of these subs, (Kicker - Comp 12" Single-Voice-Coil 4-Ohm Subwoofer) and i was just wondering if you could help me pick out an amp that you sell, i've been looking at a few, but i still don't understand them very well and would really enjoy some advice from someone with more experience than me. I just want an amp that will let these speakers perform as best as they can, i would prefer to stay in a price range up to $250-$300. thank you

    No problem.  Those particular subs are rated @ 150W RMS and have a single 4 ohm voice coil.  That means that you are looking for either a 2 channel amp that is rated for at least 150W RMS per channel @ 4 ohm (most 2 channelaamps can't be bridged to 2 ohms) or a mono amp that is rated for at least 300W RMS @ 2ohm (2 ohm is what you get when you wire 2 of those subs in parallel) and I will break them down below.
    2 channel amps:
    Kenwood KAC-7205
    Power Acoustik 
    Mono amps:
    Alpine MRP-M500
    Clarion XR2110
    Infinity REF1300A
    Kenwood KAC-8105D
    Of all those amps, I only have experience with the Kenwoods and the Alpine so you might want to read the reviews and get the opinion of your local Autotechs to see what they think.  I personally would probably go with the Alpine and a parallel sub setup with the amp tuned down a little more than normal.  
    While I am employed by Best Buy, all of my posts here are in a non-official capacity. Any information or recommendations that are given are done so in an attempt to help in any way that I can and are not an official part of my job. If you feel that I have helped, feel free to give me Kudos or mark my post as a solution...I like to know how well I am doing.

  • Help reg what formats to be used for my new 4tb mini stack to back up my macbook and 2 external hard disks

    Hey Guys,
    I need an advice from you experts regarding the different formats to be used to format my New 4 Tb ministack from OWC. I  have a  Mid 2010 Intel macbook pro with 500gb hard disk using Mountain lion and two external hard disk from Samsung and Iomega 1Tb each. I want to format this ministack into 4 partitions each of 1Tb each.
    1) 1 Tb for time machine to back up my macbook pro.
    2) 1 Tb of  Free space to be used to store extra data using both windows and mac os.
    3) 1 Tb for Samsung back up
    4) 1 Tb for my Iomega back up
    I know that for 1st option i need to format the partition (volume) to Mac os extended (journalled). I need help for  others.For  the 1 Tb free space, can i use NTFS so that i can use it on my wifes windows laptop and use a third a party application like tuxera NTFS for use on my macbook which i am already using to use my samsung and Iomega Ext HDD.
    Also  What format is required for these  two 1 Tb volumes dedicated for external hard disk backups and  how can i back up my external hard disks to these formatted volumes. Do i need to  format them to Mac os extended (journalled) as well as i shall be using macbook pro to back up these hard disks.
    Which would be the best software to back up these Ext hdd,can i use time machine? or CCC ?
    Your help help shall be gretaly appreciated.
    Thanks in advance.

    Get Disk Warrior that will repair the problems without requiring that you reformat the drive - $99.00 on a bootable CD. Will not work on a FAT formatted drive.
    You will need to use Drag and Drop to save your files by copying them from the bad drive to a good one.
    To reprep the drive:
    Drive Preparation
    1. Open Disk Utility in your Utilities folder.
    2. After DU loads select your hard drive (this is the entry with the mfgr.'s ID and size) from the left side list. Click on the Partition tab in the DU main window.
    3. Under the Volume Scheme heading set the number of partitions from the drop down menu to one. Click on the Options button, set the partition scheme to GUID then click on the OK button. Set the format type to Mac OS Extended (Journaled.) Click on the Partition button and wait until the process has completed.
    4. Select the volume you just created (this is the sub-entry under the drive entry) from the left side list. Click on the Erase tab in the DU main window.
    5. Set the format type to Mac OS Extended (Journaled.) Click on the Security button, check the button for Zero Data and click on OK to return to the Erase window.
    6. Click on the Erase button. The format process can take up to several hours depending upon the drive size.

  • What format should I use to archive camcorder videos.

    I've seen many different variations of my question on the forums, but nothing answering all my questions. So, here goes.
    I have a minidv camcorder and I've been ripping the video to dv files using imovie hd 6. I then put together the clips that should be together and tell imovie to convert those clips into one. My question is the format. I have been using dv, but for an hour minidv tape, it's over 10 gig. I then copy these dv files to my external drive and back them up with mozy.
    My question is what format "should" I be archiving them to? I plan on keeping them forever of course. And there might be a day that I go to mess with them, maybe add some effects. I'm no video editor, but I'm finding that the mac has such awesome (and easy for a beginner) tools that I actually want to mess with video.
    There are so many formats, but I don't want to lose quality to save hd space. If I were to convert them to mov or mpeg4, would the quality be as good. What about size, would the size be much different?
    Sorry for the large post. I'm a little lost when it comes to this stuff, but I'm trying to learn.
    Thanks.

    Cool, thanks. I had a feeling at least one person was going to say that, but I wanted to make sure. With the price of external hard drive's dropping like they are, and mozy being so cheap, might as well use the space and keep the quality.
    Thanks again...

  • Is there any way out to share videos on whats app

    Hello, how can we share videos on whats ap through nokia Lumia 625.

    Hi hitu123,
    With regards to your concern about the video sharing on WhatsApp on your Lumia 625, it's best to check with the publisher to confirm the availability of this feature. You can contact them here:
    http://www.whatsapp.com/contact/

Maybe you are looking for

  • Problam with magic bullet instant hd advance

    after i changed my sd video to 1080p and added magic bullet instant hd advance i set it so that it renders in h.264 codecs but every time i tryed i got this message.

  • Debugging toplink.jar

    I'm trying to debug into a UnitOfWork.commit call and I've attached source.jar to toplink.jar in Eclipse 3.0.1. Problem: Eclipse can't find publicinterface.UnitOfWork in source.jar. There is no publicinterface folder in source.jar. Questions: 1. Why

  • Can any tell me what is EDN in SAP

    can any tell me what is EDN in SAP

  • IPhoto 9.2.3 crashes when importing jpeg files in OS 10.6.8

    iPhoto 9.2.3 crashes when importing jpeg files in OS 10.6.8. Has worked perfectly until recently. Camera: Sony. Help! Thanks

  • Slow bluetooth detection after powerbook wake-up

    Hello! When I am using my Powerbook at home, it is connected to an external screen and I am using it with an Apple bluetooth keyboard and a Logitech bluetooth mouse. My problem is that every time I wake up my Powerbook from sleep, it takes approximat