Help with RAW files and custom white balance.

ive long had this issue with RAW shooting and adobe photoshop and lightroom, my main subject is a saltwater reef aquarium that is lit by artificial lighting, i shoot canon and use the custom white balance setting to get everything looking proper and it works good.. to an extent.. if i shoot jpg the photos all turn out as shot, if i shoot RAW the white balance in adobe programs is totally messed up and you cant fix it.. if i use DPP by canon, its perfect and looks just as shot or just a a jpg would look.. my question is how can i get adobe lilightroom to render my RAW files correctly.
below are all 3 images, first one was converted and exported to jpg in canon DPP without any adjustments and is what the photo should look like, second has been exported from photoshop, and 3rd i added a link to the actual RAW file. why cant my lightroom interpret these properly?
heres a link to the actual RAW file
https://www.dropbox.com/s/5a39ctllwgrem7a/_MG_8971.CR2
this was a raw converted in canon dpp, and its what the aquarium looks like, and is what the photo should look like. just to note, any other editing or viewing program besides adobe products all render the image correctly.
this is what photoshop and lightroom do to my Raw files, theres no way to adjust anything to get even remotely close to correct..

The white-balance Temperature of this image as computed by the camera is way beyond the 50,000K upper limit as you can see when you open the file in LR or ACR, so Adobe cannot reach the As Shot WB temperature number and stops at 50,000K which is still too blue -- although EXIFtool says:  Color Temp As Shot : 10900, so maybe Adobe's wildly high 50,000K number is based on a faulty camera profile that exaggerates blues:
However, using the Camera Standard makes things not nearly so garish blue, and it is possible to use Photoshop to neutralize things even more:
However, as you say, other raw converters do ok with this image despite the high WB temperature, so I think the Canon T3/1100D profile needs some work, but probably won't get it since it is not a high-end camera.
For example, here is the default conversion from LibRaw that is part of RawDigger, and in my opinion is an improvement on the camera rendering though perhaps lacks a bit of saturation:
As another example, here is RawTherapee's conversion, after I neutralized the auto-tone and color values it applies by default, and appears to be a bit too saturated but that could be easily adjusted:
I would agree that Adobe is doing something wrong with this camera in this lighting.  A clue is the bright green color of the top-central coral which seems to be yellow in the non-Adobe renderings.

Similar Messages

  • Help with Raw Files

    I'm using an Imac with 2.1 Ghz PowerPC G5 processor, running OS X 10.5.8 and Photoshop CS2.  I just bought a Nikon D300s and would like to work with raw files.  Adobe tells me I need CS5 which means I would need to buy an new computer.  Is there anyway around this?

    You'll need to convert your raw files to DNG with Adobe's free converter: http://www.adobe.com/products/dng/

  • Help with referenced files and importing

    This might be more complex than can be addressed here, but I'm struggling with the organization of aperture.
    Because I'm not sure I want use aperture forever, and because I occasionally like to use other photo editors, I've opted for a referenced file setup. I typically arrange my pictures into year/month sub folders, with additional folders for special subjects, like my kids. I've been doing this for a long time, it works for me, and I don't want to change.
    Problem #1 - avoiding duplicates when I import. When I stick the card in my computer I want to copy just the new files to the directory I specify. Image capture only looks for duplicates in the target directory, which is no help if I'm importing files to "November" from a card that has files that were previously imported to "October." The easiest solution would be to delete the images off of the card after importing, but I can't do that - my wife also wants to copy the pix to her computer and she may not copy for several weeks or months at a time.
    I tried using aperture's import feature to copy files directly from my camera's memory card. The import worked, but when I tried to locate the files on disk, aperture told me there were no referenced files. Any idea where they are?
    Problem #2 - import. Is there any way to make Aperture watch referenced directories and automatically add new files to the the appropriate project? It's a pain to keep manually importing files.
    Problem #3 - Organization. Is there any way to set up aperture so that a project = a physical folder on my drive? I get that Aperture is trying to abstract the physical location of my files, but I don't want them abstracted. Also, why is my aperture primary library 6.2 GB when I do all my work with referenced files? Where are my edited files stored? Are these in the primary library? Where are the files from my photostreams (from my phone) stored?
    Would any or all of these issues be resolved by moving to a managed file set up?
    Finally, if I can't get Aperture working the way I need it, any insight into how I'd use it as an external editor to something like Picasa? I really like the aperture editing tools - that's why I bought it. But the workflow is just killing me.
    Any insights would be appreciated. Thanks.

    It is not as complex as you are making it.  Aperture is not per se an editor.  It is for storing and organizing, and quickly decoding RAW images.  It is a pretty good editor, but it has the feature to allow you to specify an External Editor to which you can send images for more complex editing, and back -- all from within Aperture.
    You don't want to have your images referenced so you can also edit them with other programs.  That destroys the non destructive design of Aperture.  If you want Referenced images, you mostly want them so they can be on a different hard drive from that used by the Library for keeping track and storing the adjustments, and not so other programs can access them.
    You need to read further as to how and why Aperture works the way it does.
    Ernie

  • Need help with raw files

    I have reinstalled and updated CS5 but I am unable to open camera raw files for my Canon Rebel T4i. I get the following message:
    Could not complete your request because the file appears to be from a camera model which is not supported by the installed version of Camera Raw.
    Please visit the Camera Raw help documentation for additional information.

    Camera Raw is an Adobe plugin for Photoshop, Photoshop Elements and Lightroom which processes Raw files. Camera Raw must be updated for every new make and model of camera which enters the market. Thus Camera Raw is frequently updated but not all versions of Camera Raw are compatible with all versions of Photoshop.
    See http://blogs.adobe.com/crawlspace/2011/03/why-doesnt-my-version-of-photoshop-or-lightroom- support-my-camera.html
    According to http://helpx.adobe.com/creative-suite/kb/camera-raw-plug-supported-cameras.html
    the Rebel T4i was first supported in Camera Raw 7.1.
    Camera Raw 7+ is only compatible with CS6 and higher.
    http://helpx.adobe.com/x-productkb/global/camera-raw-compatible-applications.html
    Your choices:
    Upgrade to CS6
    Join the Cloud
    Convert all your T4i Raw files to DNGs using Adobe's free DNG converter
    http://www.adobe.com/products/photoshop/extend.displayTab2.html
    Then edit the DNGs in your existing CS5.

  • Need help with Raw file converter for ps6 on windows xp

    I had to re-install my CS6  on my computer and now I can't get any of the raw files open.  I'm not on the cloud and am running Windows xp, service pack 3.  Can anyone help?

    Thanks Richard.  I made sure that I was totally up to date via help-updates on all programs (cs6 & bridge) and it still doesn't work.  Any other thoughts?   I remember vaguely that I had this problem before and had to download a new file.  I tried looking on Adobe site and the suggestion is the raw conversion  8.3.  Downloaded that (said it was for windows xp, serv. pack 3) and I can see the file but when I click on that it comes up as a .pf file and I"m not sure where to go from here ... or if I have now messed up everything really well.
    Yes, XP is on the way out of my life as I need a new computer so this maybe the push that I need.  But in the meantime, I really need to process some images.
    Any other thoughts?
    Noella

  • Help with merging files and calling SOAP adapter in BPM

    Hello All,
    I have a scenario, where am merging a header file and item file and calling a webservice in ECC. The requirement is that the no. of calls to the webservice depends on the no. of lines in the header file. Mapping is developed according to this rule and the operation mapping is also set for multiple messages. Testing the mapping produces required results.
    But when I run the scenario invoking BPM to merge the files with 2 lines in header records the webservice is called just once. On further analysis into SXMB_MONI_BPE, MESSAGES_OUPUT table in the mapping step has 2 messages. The instance ID of the message gone out shows a checkered flag with processed successfully status, but the second line is stuck in status "Transfer To Process Engine" .
    Any thoughts what I should be doing to push second message out automatically.
    Prashanth

    Hi Prashanth,
       to find out what has happened to the message try checking the workflow log,
    i.e., select the message with the 'Transfer to Process Engine" status in SXI_MONITOR and drill down in the outbound PE column.
    Once in the workflow log select 'List with Technical Detailsu2019'.
    Regards
    Kenny

  • HELP WITH VIDEO FILES AND PUTTING ON ITUNESSS!!!!!!!!!!

    hey...i need help with my video ipod and itunes....i recently had sum problem with my ipod and i had to restore it...and when i hooked it up to itunes all the songs got back on it...its just that the videos never got updated with the songs....the videos are converted and were workin fine....now when i select the folder to put it into the itunes it says processing and nuttin happens...this is drivin me crazy anyone know how to fix this ****??
    THX
    5g ipod video    

    ok...i just uninstalled itunes and installed the previous version...and it worked fine....

  • Help with Lost Files and Previews!

    Hi all!
    I'm in a bit of a panic. I imported a folder into Lightroom and made standard previews.
    I have large standard sized previews (and some 1:1 previews) on top of my mini thumbnails.
    The I did something very very stupid... I accidentally deleted my original photos!!!!
    The original photos are gone for good (yes, I stupidly emptied the trash).
    Of course it's now appearing in Red in my Lightroom library.
    So here's the help I need.... I still have the large standard size previews in Lightroom. It's not as big as my original files but it's better than nothing!
    How can I convert my existing previews into JPG files? I tried Exporting the files, but Lightroom returns an error. It seems to look for the original files.
    Is there a way for me to pull out and save these standard previews?
    Thanks!
    Leo

    What kind of computer are you on? If you haven't done much with your computer since and your disk is not nearly full, you may be able to retrieve them.
    If it's windows, I've used freeundelete:
    http://www.pcworld.com/downloads/file/fid,25465-order,1-page,1-c,alldownloads/description. html
    There is a thread about getting the previews but I don't remember the details.
    And after you do those two things, it's time to review your procedures. Like don't delete the files from your camera card UNTIL you do a backup? Which LR can do if you like.

  • Need Help with RAW File in Elements 9

    I have Nikons D7000, D60 and Elements 9.  Elements 9 recognizes NEF file from D60 but not from D7000.  How do I fix this problem? 

    I apologize for being dense here.  Where do I open Full Edit and clock the menu Help Updates?  I don't recognize this term in any of the D7000 menus.  Do I do this in Elements 9?  I don't recognize the term RAW "plug in."  I am not sure what plug in you are speaking to.  Thanks so much for your help and patience. 

  • Help with jar files and running them

    I have been trying to figure out how to run executable java files, now I have heard that a million and one people have asked this already. Though when I see the answer to these questions I am still quite confused, I would like to understand some things. First thing is how do you even save your java code as a jar file. Secondly, what is a jar file. Thirdly, I have seen many people talking about batch files, what are they? And finally, I have used many "wrappers" and I still cannot get it to work. Plz help

    A quick google search gave me [url http://neptune.netcomp.monash.edu.au/JavaHelp/howto/jar.htm]this website about jars.

  • Please help with RTAV files and Telecini import

    Hello,
    I am trying to archive old 16mm films. I purchased a telecini and i am importing in to a Panasonic DVD video recorder and burning on to DVD. I am not sure this is important. The challenge I have is that when I put the DVD in my Powerbook g4 it opens the DVD and reads as a RTAV file. When I open the RTAV file the file is empty. I have never experienced this before and I don't even know what an RTAV file is. Please excuse my ignorance if this is basic.
    The second question I have is....I would like to import from the telecini directly in to Imove. My powerbook does not recognize the telecini which I expected. I think I need software to recognize the telecini and bridge to Imovie. Any suggestions?
    Thanks!!!
    Carla

    welcome Carla to the  iMovie boards..
    your question stumbles into some hurdles.. :
    The Panasonic dvd-corder is one of the rare devices, which allow aside the 'standard' dvd-r/w usage of socalled DVD-Ram.. which creates RTAV files.. and which are NOT readable by your Mac (=empty) ..
    so, to solve your rtav problem, use 'normal' dvd-r/+r/-rw or +rw .. (I like re-writable disks for 'transport' issues.. after transfer, erase and re-use them) ...
    I guess, your telecini (cozy name ) device offers an analogue output.. if you have a manufacturers site url, post it here, maybe we find some additional info .. if so, you need a converter device, whch converts from analogue to digital.. there are some devices, Canopus, EyeTV which are supported by iM ...
    finally: I would let do the conversion by some professional service, which allows 'transfer' to miniDV .. best quality and best compatibility..
    ahh, forgot to mention: and if you use dvd-r in your Panasonic instead of DVD-Ram, to convert such stuff, the usual reply is....... :
    DVDs are in a socalled delivery format (mpeg2), which isn't meant and made for any processing as editing...
    for using the iLife apps, you have to convert'em first, in recommended order, choose one of the following tools/workarounds:
    DVDxDV (free trial, 25$, Pro: 90$)
    Apple mpeg2 plugin (19$) + Streamclip (free)
    VisualHub (23.32$)
    Drop2DV (free, requires installation of ffmpeg parts, google for it...)
    Cinematize >60$
    Mpeg2Works >25$ + Apple plug-in
    Toast 6/7/8 allows converting to dv/insert dvd, hit apple-k
    connect a miniDV Camcorder with analogue input to a DVD-player and transfer disk to tape/use as converter
    http://danslagle.com/mac/iMovie/tips_tricks/6010.shtml
    http://danslagle.com/mac/iMovie/tips_tricks/6018.shtml
    http://karsten.schluter.googlepages.com/convertdvdstodvs
    none of these methods or tools override copy protection/DRM mechanisms.. advice on 'ripping' is a violation of the ToU of this board ..
    +be nice to copy rights ...+

  • Working with RAW Files and JPG

    I have a high end digital camera that takes pictures in RAW format as well as JPG format. When I import the photos, it only imports the JPG format. Is there a way to import RAW photo's into iPhoto?

    It does (and should by default). However after it stores them in the ORIGINALS folder, it creates a .jpg copy in the MODIFIED folder and uses that by the looks of things. (Use Spotlight or Finder to see if you've actually imported any raw's).
    You should see the RAW's displayed in the iPhoto window after import. If not, check the connection settings in your camera menu ... and make sure you are using a program or creative mode (my 20D does not take raw's in the preset or Green mode).
    To work on RAW's you'd need to go Adobe Photoshop with Adobe Camera Raw (incl.in CS2) or Apple Aperture.... now significantly cheaper.

  • Help with material group and customer

    this is what i'm trying to do. i've segregated all my ferts into material groups. now when i go into va01 to create sales order and enter customer, i want it the system to suggest material that is only relevant for that customer, by material group, not by sales view which is the current setting. is there a way i can link customer to a material group? and if i do that will it suggest material for that customer when i goto the line item to enter material??

    Dear Friend,
    Frist difference Dynamic Product Proposal & Listing / Exclusion:
    Dynamic Product Proposal is just list of Materials that is proposed as soon as you enter Customer Code in Sales Order. Customer can order materials that are not contained in Dynamic Product Proposal. It is for ease of Order Entry.
    Listing / Exclusion is a List of maintained in system which restricts Customer to Order mateirals not mentioned in LIsting,
    Thus in your case List / Exclusion is better option
    As far as Config is concerned if you want to restrict the Materials based on Customer Code then no config. changes is required because the standard table 001 (Customer / Material) is already available.
    Just maintain Condition Record in VB01 & try to create Sales Order. You will clearly see the effect.
    Only config. you will need is this:
    IMG - Sales and Distribution - Basic Functions - Listing/Exclusion - Activate listing/exclusion by sales document type (To activate Listing / exclution for your Sales Document Type. Maintain A00001 & B00001 here.
    Hope this helps.. .
    Thanks,
    Jignesh Mehta

  • Help with .h2p files and converting them

    I recently purchessed a group of loops. They downloaded in a format called .h2p. I converted one to a .wav file hoping it would open in garageband. I have read online that these files are only read by Deva. Is there a way to convert them so that they arent just for deva into .wav or .mp3 files? When I changed it from .h2p to .wav garageband said that Error -36 had occured. Please help! Thanks. FYI: I am really bad at computers and stuff like it so pretend I'm stupid. ;-)

    A quick google search gave me [url http://neptune.netcomp.monash.edu.au/JavaHelp/howto/jar.htm]this website about jars.

  • Losing Custom White Balance

    I wasn't sure where to post this, so I'm starting here.
    I've been having an issue with RAW (actually Nikon .NEF) files containing custom white balances and software on my Mac. I shoot Infrared images with the white balance set to make the green foliage go white, making the sky go kind of coppery. When I look at the thumbnails of these files in either the Finder, Photoshop (CS2, CS3), iPhoto (07 and 08), Nikon View, or Adobe Lightroom they look correct. As soon as I want to edit them, they lose the white balance I set in favor of looking black and red (what the camera actually "saw") and there's no way I've found to get the custom white balance back.
    I tried it on a friend's PC laptop using the free version of Nikon View and it worked like it should. I was able to save the images as TIFFs and open them on my Mac.
    Anyone else ever seen this occur or have any suggestions?

    What you're seeing in the thumbnails are actually jpeg previews of the files based on what the finder imagines the file ought to look like not the contents of the files themselves.
    When you open the file for the first time you see the RAW file without any adjustments. Depending on what software you use the settings may or may not be maintained on subsequent opens.
    You need to make your RAW adjustments and then export the file as a TIFF/JPEG or just keep it RAW.
    Check out the Aperture and iPhoto forums for more info.
    M.
    Message was edited by: Moich

Maybe you are looking for

  • Xserve G5 with infiniband server

    Hi, I have recently been tasked to set up a G5 xserve server with 15 nodes. The nodes are connected through a voltaire infiniband ISR-9024 switch. Naturally I have no documentation for any of them of them . I have been able to connect to the switch b

  • Multiple Albums, one song?

    Is there any way to tag one song as being on more than one album? And example is I have the Elvis song "In the Ghetto" in my library twice, once as part of he "Elvis in Memphis" album and again as part of "30", greatest hits collection. It would be n

  • Runtime Error: INSERT_REPORT_LINE_TOO_LONG

    Hi All, I am working on a system that was recently moved to a new server. Ever since it was moved, I am getting an ABAP dump with the error INSERT_REPORT_LINE_TOO_LONG and exception CX_SY_WRITE_SRC_LINE_TOO_LONG. The error short-text is: ABAP program

  • Anyone want to participate in a class action against Verizon Wireless?

    I upgraded two of our phones to iPhone 6s, and purchased three iPhones for our children.  I talked to Verizon representatives on the phone and also using online chat.   I was told over and over that the monthly line access fees for the five lines wou

  • Pulseaudio: /run/user/ myuid /pulse gets owned by root "randomly"

    Hi, I'm sorry I think it's impossible that this hasn't come up yet, but I'm unable to find anything related. Since a month or so I have a weird problem with the ownership of /run/user/<myuid>/pulse/* From time to time those files get owned by root wi