High Definition or Standard Definition Timeline?

When editing a program for cable TV playback that will be shown in standard definition 4 x 3 aspect ratio, MPEG2, 720 x 480, what settings should be used for the timeline?  It seems to me that it should be some sort of standard definition timeline 720 x 480 non-square pixel.  I would like to see in my client monitor what the home viewer will see.  Is there any reason to use a high definition timeline, then convert it?  There will be no reuse of the program on the web or in future reruns.  No fancy animations or pans and zooms.  Source material will be mixed.  It seems to me that graphics made on a high definition timeline will also look bad when converted for standard definition playback.
Would DVCPRO50 be the best choice, can ProRes be set up for this, or something else?

If we shoot HD then we edit in HD and we prefer PR422 to most alternatives most of the time.
I would edit in whatever you have the most of. DVCPro50 and PR422 are both codecs. It is one or the other.
What do you have the most of? codec? HD? SD?
We prefer to convert any and all source footage that isn't PR422 to PR422 when working in PR422. I wouldn't bother with DVCPro50 unless that is what most of your footage is. Is this on tape/card? How are you getting the footage into FC? DVCPro50 is a SD codec while PR422 can be either. If most of your footage is HD you will have to render all HD footage that you are adding into a SD timeline.
Converting  HD to SD is not a guaranteed quality hit.
Setting all the frame controls to best in Compressor will usually solve most conversion/quality issues but depending on the length of your show this can take a lot of time compared to good or better(and the results are never as good).
An alternative:
We have had success with exporting our HD sequence(self-contained or reference)/reimporting into FC and then adding it to a 16x9 or 4x3 SD sequence and rendering. Export your new SD master and then compress for your final deliverable.
Keep in mind that HD is rectangular while SD can be rectangular(16x9) or square(4x3). When you down-convert to your SD deliverable you will have to letterbox your HD or 16x9 footage into a 4x3 SD window(unless you plan to render and/or scale all of the footage as you add it into a 4x3 sequence).

Similar Messages

  • Hi I just updated from Snow Leopard to Mountain Lion. I write DVD's using Final Cut Pro, creating a DVD that plays HD and Standard Definition on one disk. My problem is when I used load the disk on my G5 it would ask if you want High Definition or Standar

    Hi I just updated from Snow Leopard to Mountain Lion.
    I write DVD's using Final Cut Pro, creating a DVD that plays HD and Standard Definition on one disk.
    My problem is when I used load the disk on my G5 it would ask if you want High Definition or Standard Definition, now it just defaults to Standard Definition.(I'm using Apple's DVD Player)
    Can I fix this problem?

    Addendum: I read on a post here (http://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?t=420169) about removing some kext files in order to trick OSX into thinking that there were no FireWire ports.
    I followed the instructions and removed from /System/Library/Extensions/ the following files:
    IOFireWireSerialBusProtocolTransport.kext
    IOFireWireAVC.kext
    IOFireWireFamily.kext
    IOFireWireIP.kext
    IOFireWireSBP2.kext
    I restarted and BAM...Snow Leopard booted crazy fast and the mouse and keyboard worked instantly.
    The System Profiler says "No FireWire ports were found."
    So this tells me that the FW port is probably the culprit and is messing up the installation.
    So how do I hack the Mountain Lion installer and tell it to ignore the FW port, which is obviously quite dead? Or is there something I can do to the Base system that is similar?

  • Why isn't my high definition video converting to standard definition?

    What I'm describing here, I've successfully accomplished many, many times using Premiere Pro CS5 and now Premiere Pro CS6. Now, for the first time ever, it's not working and I'm completely baffled. (This is a high-end Windows 7 64-Bit machine with 16GB RAM running Premiere Pro CS6.)
    Here's a basic summary of my workflow. Nothing out of the ordinary here.
    1. I shoot my video using a high definition camcorder (the same one I've been working with for the past year or two.
    2. I import my high definition video into a 1920x1080 sequence in Premiere Pro CS6.
    3. I edit my sequence until I'm happy.
    4. I enter and name my Encore chapter markers in the sequence.
    5. I create my Encore project and import the sequence as a timeline and set up my menus and such.
    6. I build my Encore project, first into a standard definition DVD image file (so I can later burn SD-DVDs) and then build it again into a high definition Blu-ray image file (so I can later burn Blu-rays).
    The Blu-ray burn is turning out just fine.
    But the video in the DVD burn is all black. I can jump around from chapter to chapter and I can hear the sound, but the video doesn't show up!
    I tried this a couple times thinking that maybe Encore just messed up the SD-DVD creation process but I got the same result each time. When I preview the project in Encore, it all looks just right.
    So I figured, okay, something's not working when I import the sequence.
    I went back to Premiere Pro thinking I'd just export my 1920x1080 sequence into a widescreen standard definition AVI and create a new sequence just for the standard definition DVD.
    The exported AVI is black as well!!
    I don't get it. Why on earth won't my high definition video convert properly to standard definition?
    The high definition sequence looks completely normal in Premiere Pro. What could I possibly be overlooking??
    One final note. Just as another test, I copied and pasted the sequence in Premier Pro, truncated it to a couple minutes (the full sequence is 90 minutes long), and exported to a widescreen AVI again.
    It just finished, I tried playing it back in Windows, and it, too, is all black, sound but no video.
    Like I said, this is nothing new for me. I've done it countless times with other projects. I could really use some assistance with this one.

    So I exported my completed high definition sequence to an MP4 and re-imported back into Premiere Pro. Right-clicked it and created a sequence from the clip. Then I imported my chapters from the old sequence into the new one.
    I returned to Encore, modified my project to work off the newly created sequence (what a pain having to recreate all the scene links) and voila, it had no trouble making a DVD this time.
    So I guess I'll get out of the bad habit of my old routine and create a sequence the "right" way from now on. Funny how we get used to doing something one way and stop thinking outside the box after a while.
    Jim, I don't see how that's necessary. As long as I create an Encore project based on a good high definition sequence, I have never had to do anything other than have Encore build a standard definition DVD based on the high definition sequences. It has always done the conversion for me and produced really good DVDs. Once I create a DVD image that I'm satisfied with, I simply have Encore build a Blu-ray image using the exact same project, and that works perfectly as well. I suppose I may be missing something here but it all works and works well, so I don't see a reason to create two projects when one works well.
    On a separate note, is it just me or doesn't everybody think it's high time that Adobe offer a feature to import markers from one sequence into another. I can do it automatically but I have to use a macro that I created separate and apart from Premiere Pro. For that matter, I think Encore should also offer a feature to remap all scene links to a new sequence instead of forcing me to fix them one by one myself.
    Anyway, thanks to all of you for pointing me in the right direction!

  • Standard Definition vs. High Definition Video on Mobile Me

    Can anyone tell me whether a video shot with a high definition camcorder, then edited in imovie 09 and shared to mobile me via IM 09 look better when played on mobile me than one shot with a standard definition camcorder?
    I have a video shot by a friend in standard def, edited in IM 09 and embedded on a web page. Had it been shot with a high def, would the quality on the web be better than what is seen here?:
    http://web.mac.com/pyrrhonist/Pyrrhonist/Clown_Video.html
    Dennis

    What codec is used for MobilMe. The Apple site only talks about Photos on MobilMe!
    H.264
    Does MobileMe recompress your uploaded video like the other services?
    No it is h.264. Not converted to Flash like YouTube. Plays in QuickTime Player.
    Can those with Windows view with Firefox and/or IE?
    Yes, but they are prompted to download QuickTime player if they don't already have it
    What is the frame-size for Medium and Large?
    Large - 960x540 (in widescreen)
    Large - 720x540 (4:3)
    Medium - 640x360 (in widescreen)
    Medium - 640x480 (4:3)
    What is maximum the frame-rate for Medium and Large?
    I have never seen a maximum
    Why would one need to download since it is streaming video?
    It takes a long time to stream. I have found that if I provide the option to download, a lot of people think something is wrong and they try to download it rather than waiting for it to start streaming. People expect streaming video to start right away. Most will not wait 5 minutes.
    Downloading takes a long time, too.

  • Standard definition (DV) video or high definition (HD)

    Does anyone know a method to determine whether imported imovie files is standard definition (DV) video or high definition (HD)?
    Thanks

    In addition to what Shippey said, the DV files will be imported as in the DV file container and HDV or HDAVC will be converted to AIC and placed in an MOV file container. (I.e., you can simply look at the file extension and tell the difference when the options are limited to DV or HD camcorder imports and not including the possibility of HDD or DVD SD files.)

  • Importing a high-definition clip produces a timeline much longer than the video

    I have begun importing high-definition clips in MOV format into my Premier CS4.  I use a hard-disk based video recorder ( a DTE technology FS-100) whichbreaks the video up into 2GB clips each with a duration of 2 minutes, 18 seconds. and 8 frames (2:18.8).  However, Premier thinks that the clip is about 37 minutes long.  When I play the clip in the editor, the video freezes and the sound stops at 2:18.8 with the remaining ~35 minutes showing the same frame.
    I can get around this by manually cutting each clip down to 2:18.8, but I shouldn't have to do this.  By the way, when I import standard definition video from the same recorder I don't have this problem; Premier determines the correct length of the clip.
    Any ideas of what is going on and how to correct?
    Thanks!

    I thought it was a little odd though as you can re-time the clip through the properties menu of the clip and the audio links with it and slows down. I had jsut hoped the same would apply when I just tried using a smoother effect on it.
    Thanks for your help anyway.

  • If a video is in high definition, does it take up more space than it would in standard definition

    I have freed enough space to hold a standard definition version of the series that I want to buy, but I wanted to get the high defintion version, so I was wondering wether there is any difference.

    Yes, there is. High-Def is much bigger.
    If you had say something that was 1.5GB in Standard, it would be probably about 4GB in HD

  • Standard Definition to High Definition and iTunes Upgrades

    If you have already purchased something in standard definition, is it possible to upgrade standard definition to high definition tv programmes without paying the full price?
    Also, I had purchased the Downton Abbey soundtrack by John Lunn, however it has been re-released with new tracks.  If I want these additional tracks, can I be entitled to an upgrade, and pay the difference as I would like them all on one album and not on two separate albums.
    Regards,
    Tristan

    Sorry but no, there is no upgrade from SD to HD movies or TV shows.  Nor can you "upgrade" an album if it was re-released as a new version with new content. The content owners do not allow these services.
    Regards.

  • Incorporate standard definition footage in a high def sequence

    Hi everybody
    Hope someone can help me out on this one.
    I have to incorporate standard definition footage 720x576 PAL 25fps, in my HD sequence 1920x1080 25fps (my HD is XDCAM EX 1080p25 in .mov files)
    What's the best way to do this?
    Unfortunately I don't have a cool AJA Xena 2KE to do the upconversion via hardware
    so all I'm left with is "software"
    Do I simply import the PAL footage on my HD sequence and upscale it? (something like 250% you can immagine what the footage looks like!)
    Do I need something like Magic Bullet instant HD?
    Can I upscale with after effects or media econder?
    Pleaz help
    Thank you!!!
    p.s. I captured the PAL from BetaSP tapes

    hi joe
    thanks for your reply
    actually my question about hardware was just out of curiosity
    I will download the Instant HD trial version and see some results
    It's a pretty discomforting thing trying to mix SD and HD!
    And in the end we end up with an IMX tape
    take care

  • Authoring standard definition bluray video

    Hello everyone. I downloaded adobe premiere elements 13 and have read portions of its manual that apply to my question. The manual suggests that standard definition bluray video can be created using the mpeg 2 codec. However, I tried but was unable to do this: I could only see options for high definition bluray video! Therefore, can someone explain briefly how this is done. I would also like to know whether or not the H 264 codec can be used to create standard definition bluray video and if so, what bitrate values are provided for this task.Finally, I would like to know what audio codecs could be used in creating standard definition bluray video?

    stevee12
    Thanks for the reply.
    Bottom line:
    You can get an export to file from Premiere Elements that is said to be a H.264 Blu-ray file type (in earlier version MPEG2 Blu-ray as well).
    Before export, the export settings can be customized for various settings including Frame Size 720 x 576.
    The Premiere Elements burn to Blu-ray process is characterized by resolution to give 1920 x 1080 16:9 display. No user customization of the burn to presets.
    Further comments...
    With regard to what you wrote (post 4)
    it then means that standard definition video resolutions(e.g 720x576) can not be created on bluray discs by adobe premiere elements.
    True.
    With regard to
    I am now confused because the adobe premiere elements manual states that mpeg 2 standard definition video of about 10 hours in duration can be written to a 25gb single layer bluray disc!
    What it does not say is as what. Can be taken as
    a. You have a Timeline content of MPEG2 "standard definition widescreen - 720 x 576 16:9" and you burn it to a Blu-ray disc giving you the Blu-ray disc format on Blu-ray disc (25 GB), giving the 1920 x 1080 16:9 display
    or
    b. You have a Timeline content of MPEG2  10 hours "standard definition widescreen - 720 x 576 16:9", and you export it as a file 720 x 576 16:9 which is saved to the computer hard drive. Then you burn that file to a Blu-ray disc as data disc with 3rd party software to get the file on the Blu-ray disc in the same format before and after the burn to.
    I will see if I can find that quote in the program's PDF Help where I assume you found it.
    Please let me know if you have questions or need clarification on this.
    ATR

  • Play iTunes video on STANDARD definition TV?

    This seems as if it should be a simple question, but I haven't had much luck researching an answer!
    I've got a lot of my own homemade videos stored in iTunes. I can easily play them back on my host iMac G5, or over my home network to my MacBook.
    But is there any way to play them over my regular standard-definition TV?
    I've done this by connecting a composite video adapter to the MacBook and cabling it to the TV; it works fine, but ties up the MacBook. I've also transferred them to my iPod and connected that to the TV, which also works fine but isn't very convenient. I'd like to be able to just play videos off the iMac without any extra steps -- the same way you can play audio through an Airport Express connected to a stereo.
    I know an AppleTV would do exactly what I want... IF I had a high-definition TV, but I don't. I've read about adapters for connecting an AppleTV to an SD TV, but they seem both expensive and kludgy. I also know that the AppleTV works with a standard-def TV if your TV has component inputs, but mine doesn't. So the AppleTV doesn't seem to be a solution.
    Any recommendations for a way to do this that definitely works? Thanks...

    Yes, I know, an AppleTV-like device would be exactly what I need... except that I need one that has composite outputs, rather than component and HDMI.
    Are you saying there ain't no such animal, from Roku, Slim Devices, Linksys, anybody...?
    Another thought: Does the Mac mini work with the same type of composite video output adapter I use with my MacBook? If so, it might be more cost-effective to buy a mini and dedicate it for TV use rather than buying an AppleTV plus an HDTV set. (I know I'm going to have to go to HDTV eventually, but the fact is that most standard-definition content looks worse on HDTV than it does on SDTV...)

  • I am trying to convert a standard definition AVI file 720x576 widescreen file into a full sized Quicktime file in imovie but having cropping issues

    Hi
    I am trying to convert a standard definition AVI file 720x576 (16:9)  file into a full sized Quicktime file in imovie 11. When importing the file I get two options either import as large 960 x540 or full original size. So I choose full original size but when I drag this imported clip to my timeline the bottom of the clip has been cut off? I tried to export it as a quicktime file thinking that perhaps it might resize to the original size but of course that was wishful thinking
    Any ideas appreciated?

    Hi No I have just checked its definitely a PAL 16;9 project. I am also slightly confused because when importing the video into the project it has squashed it into 4:3 format even though my file is 16:9?

  • Working with Canon 5D standard definition video

    I'm facing an odd situation.
    Just started editing a documentary shot with a Canon 5D camera. The picture looks great. The only thing is, the cameraman decided that this is a video and he didn't need to shoot HD! I don't know why he thought that, since the main reason people use the Canon 5D is to get a full HD frame. Anyhow, I've been presented now with hours of brilliant interviews that can't be redone, all with a frame size of 640x480 running at 25 frames per second. I need to figure out how to edit these and create a broadcast master at the end. 25fps is not the issue, it's the frame size and video compression that I need to deal with.
    The Canon 5D generates Quicktime files with an H.264/Mpeg4 compression. I need to convert these files to a format better suited to editing and mastering for broadcast. An HD master is, of course, impossible, but 640x480 is even smaller than the standard 720x576 frame size that one gets on regular standard definition PAL video.
    I found a transcoding plugin for the Canon 5D, but it only works with files shot in the HD format, which get converted to Apple ProRes in the FCP's 'log and transfer' window. I've been unable to find any instructions on how to work with standard definition files.
    I imported the native H.264 files into the FCP, and found, of course, that I can play the video quite smoothly as it is. There's even a timeline setting that allows me to edit without rendering. But I'm afraid that if I work with the native files, I won't be able to master them to tape at the end.
    Any pointers on how best to go about this would be most useful!

    Try using Compressor to convert to the standard PAL frame size using DV50. Good luck and whip the cameraperson.

  • Please recommend a tapeless camcorder to use with Apple iMovie5, standard definition 4:3.

    I'm still using Apple iMovie5 and a Power PC to make standard definition 4:3
    aspect ratio DVD's for industrial training purposes. Historically, I've used
    miniDV camcorders to aquire the raw content. I want to go tapeless, but still keep
    everything else the same. Any specific suggestions for camcorders that aquire in
    SD 4:3 with files compatible with iMovie5 (like .mov files)?? In other words, I
    need to replace the miniDV capture process and go with something that easily
    imports into iMovie 5, std def, with 4:3.  Help please!!!
    Thanks! Also, I do not need a real high end camera.  Something under $600 preferable.
    <Edited by Host>

    The nearest we can get to an answer about the very old iMovie 5 and what types of cameras and video types it supported is here:
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT2264#

  • HD and Standard Definition footage FCE4

    Hey everyone well i have just bought Final Cut Express4 and am ready to start logging HD Footage as well as Standard Definition Footage,
    i want all my project in the timeline in 4/3 Aspect!
    so is it possible to log HD Footage as 4/3 aspect in FCE4? if this is possible then what should should i set my Easy Setup Menu as?????
    Basically i am a full rookie and want to have a timeline all in 4/3 aspect.
    i have a Sony FX7 HD Camcorder if that's any help?
    i really need someones help!!!!
    many thanks!!.

    Hi(Bonjour)!
    You can mix HDV and DV in a project, but the con-conform one have to be scaled to fit the screen.
    So Capture all your material in thier respective format (easy setup).
    Now, to edit your 4:3 DV sequence: choose easy setup DV NTSC.
    Put your DV clips in the timeline as usal but when your insert your HDV one, set the scale to something like 30%. The HDV clip should fit the screen at top and bottom, but you'll loose the right or left edge because of the 16:9 aspect ratio. Use the wireframe view to position (pan) such clips to best suit the compisiton in canvas.
    You'll need to render intensively with a such process.
    Michel Boissonneault

Maybe you are looking for