Hitachi vs. Segate vs. WD Scorpio

Hello,
I'm about to upgrade my Unibody Macbook Pro (late 2008) with a brand new 500 GB HD - 7200 RPM. I have been searching for an answer but people are "always" a fan of something.
Anyway, I'm considering these following Drives:
1- Seagate Momentus 7200 500GB 7200RPM
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/redirect?linkcode=ur2&camp=1789&tag=macrumors-20&creative=9325&path=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.amazon.c om%2FSeagate-Momentus-7200RPM-Internal-ST9500420AS-Bare%2Fdp%2FB001R4BBLU%2Fref% 3Dsr_17%3Fie%3DUTF8%26s%3Delectronics%26qid%3D1269978037%26sr%3D8-7
2- Hitachi 500GB Travelstar SATA 7200
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/redirect?linkcode=ur2&camp=1789&tag=macrumors-20&creative=9325&path=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.amazon.c om%2FHitachi-Travelstar-Internal-HD20500IDK-7K%2Fdp%2FB002FYJQB8%2Fref%3Ddp_cp_o b_e_title2%3Fie%3DUTF8%26qid%3D1269970419%26sr%3D8-1-fkmr1
3- WD Scorpio Blue ( Although it's 5400 RPM huge number of people recommended it)
http://wdc.com/en/products/products.asp?driveid=803
So, I'd like to share your experiences with each of the ones above, in order to be sure while placing my next order
Thanks,
Rashid

I would choose Seagate or Hitachi. I think I would lean more to the Hitachi drives right now.
If everyone is a fan of something, then you need to do some Google research and make your own decision. You can find some reviews at:
Storage Review
Tom's Hardware Review
Bare Feats

Similar Messages

  • WD scorpio black 500 7200rpm running very slow on MBP 8.1

    hi guys,
    recently change my hitachi 5400rpm in to WD scorpio black 7200rpm, but now my MBP (early 20111) running very slow and laggy, slower than the hitachi. it takes hours just to install mountain lion (system said 30minutes left but in reality it takes hours) and more than 60secs to booting.. i really need ur help guys. thx

    hi guys,
    recently change my hitachi 5400rpm in to WD scorpio black 7200rpm, but now my MBP (early 20111) running very slow and laggy, slower than the hitachi. it takes hours just to install mountain lion (system said 30minutes left but in reality it takes hours) and more than 60secs to booting.. i really need ur help guys. thx

  • The hard drive on my 2009 midyear 13" MBP died. I found this on Amazon and want to know if it is a good replacement choice:  Western Digital WD Scorpio Black 750 GB SATA 3 GB/s 7200 RPM 16 MB Cache Internal Bulk/OEM 2.5-Inch Mobile Hard Drive

    The hard drive on my 2009 midyear 13" MBP died. I found this on Amazon and want to know if it is a good replacement choice:  Western Digital WD Scorpio Black 750 GB SATA 3 GB/s 7200 RPM 16 MB Cache Internal Bulk/OEM 2.5-Inch Mobile Hard Drive

    If you are going to upgrade your harddisk, why not upgrade to SSD harddisk. You macbook pro supports SATA II SSD drives acccording to these Specs. SATA III is backward compatible with SATA II, so you can buy SATA III drive if you can't find SATA II drives.
    Upgrading to SATA II SSD drive you give you super fast performence.
    These are a few Segate SSD drives from amazon, that are not that expensive, I guess.
    As for Western Digital vs Segate comparison, I second clintonfrombirmingham's suggestion. Western Digital never works for me.
    *** After the harddisk upgrade
    Install latest OS if possible
    Update your EFI firmware
    and clean NVRAM http://support.apple.com/kb/ht1379

  • WD Scorpio 320Gb startup problem

    Hi, I have a brand new Penryn macbook, and a WD Scorpio 320Gb 2,5" sata disk I have tried to install.
    The problem is this:
    When I boot up the mac, the macbook only finds the disk about 50% of the startups. Alto when I put the macbook in sleep/hibernate, it only works about 50% of my tries.
    However, the disk starts every time I have tried to use it with an usb-adapter.
    The original 160Gb Apple/Hitachi disk seems to work 100%, but I have to try it a bit more. Have only booted it a couple of times.
    Typically the WD Disk starts up just fine, and could do a one or to hibernates ok, but when I starts up macbook from sleep, and the disk doesent power up correct, I have to hold down power button to shut it down. If I then try to power it of, I have tro try like 5 times to get it able to find the disk.
    So, have anybody installed a 320Gb WD disk in a penryn macbook with sucsess? Is it just my disk that is not working, or is it a issue between the 320Gb WD disk and the penryn macbook?

    It sounds like it may be the new drive itself. See if you can get it replaced.
    -Bmer
    Mac Owners Support Group - Join us @ MacOSG.com
      Mac611 Mobile Mac Support - about.Mac611.com
       iTunes:MacOSG Podcast | YouTube.MacOSG.com
                       An Apple User Group 
    Have an iPhone or iPod touch? Enter Mac611.com in Safari on it for 'mobile Mac support.'

  • Hitachi, Western Digital or Hitachi

    I want to buy me a new hard disk but which?
    Hitachi : http://www.amazon.de/gp/product/B003DN3A3U/ref=ox_sc_act_title_1?ie=UTF8&m=A3JWK AKR8XB7XF
    Samsung : http://www.amazon.de/Samsung-HM500JJ-500GB-interne-Festplatte/dp/B0046REG5S/ref= cm_cr_pr_product_top
    Western Digital : http://www.amazon.de/Western-Digital-WD3200BEKT-Scorpio-Festplatte/dp/B001CO3EKQ /ref=cm_cr_pr_product_top
    I hope you can help me

    They all look identical to me, just different manufacturers. The WD drive is only a 320GB capacity drive, however, the other two are both 500GB. The Scorpio Black is an amazing drive, always gets great reviews and they have the best manufacturer's warranty in the business. I don't know of any manufacturer that offers a 5-year warranty on their drives.
    I'm a big fan of the Hitachi drives, personally. I have numerous Travelstar drives "in service" on my own personal machines and many users that I support. I find that in the states they're $10-20 less than the comparable Scorpio Black and give identical performance.
    Do you need the 500GB storage?

  • WD Scorpio Black in MacBook Pro 13"

    During the last two months my Macbook pro turned slow, so I found that the source of this trouble was the Hitachi stock HDD.
    I Want to uprgrade my HDD to WD Scorpio Black, but I have read that 7200 rpm HDD have overheating, noise, etc. issues
    is that true?
    Recomendatiions accepted
    PD: I will use it to run FCPX. Logic Adobe  etc...

    I suggest you go to the OWC website and look at what is available.  They are Mac specialists and all of the 2.5" SATA HDDs will be compatible with you MBP.  Personally I suggest you put in the largest and fastest you can afford for maximum performance.  I have a 750GB 7200 rpm Seagate.  There will be others who are advocates of other brands.  OWC will stand behind the wares they sell, so its hard to go wrong with any of the choices available.
    Ciao.

  • Problem Installing Snow Leopard 10.6.3 onto a new WD Scorpio Black 320 HD

    HELP! I just upgraded my hard drive from the stock Hitachi to a WD Scorpio Black.
    I have the Macbook Pro (mid 2009) 5'4 model, 2.54 Ghz.
    Everything went well, I formatted the drive by partitioning it to one partition. I tried to install SL from a brand new DVD I got at the apple store. The installation failed, so then I created a bootable USB copy of the SL DVD just in case the dvd drive is causing the issue.
    Now It's been over an hour and a half and the progress bar says "about 25 minutes" left. The log has not reported any errors, I wonder, what am I doing wrong??> Thanks guys
    BTW my macbook is no longer under warranty, apple store tried to install SL on the first drive I tried which was a Momentus LP and so that's why I got the WD Scorpio Black 320GB. Thanks again!

    Buy Disk Warrior. Pick up a kit to swap and replace the hard drive (new drive plus empty external case) and be sure to clone and run Disk Warrior on weekly schedule.
    http://www.macsales.com/firewire - look for MacBook Pro kits
    There were some 500GB drives that all had firmware issues
    I'd check the MacBook Pro forum and support
    http:/www.apple.com/support/macbookpro

  • WD Scorpio Blue still spinning

    Hi everyone,
    I've been reading this forum through for almost two days, tried everything but nothing helps. Here is my problem:
    I've bought WD Scorpio Blue 640GB a replaced with it my previous Hitachi factory HDD. The Hitachi HDD was perfectly calm, I didn`t even know that it spins. The WD HDD spins all the time at full speed. It never slows and thats really annoying. There are several topic where people have the same problem, but there is no solution working for me.
    I`ve tried to:
    verify disk permissions and repair them,
    use HDAPM with Lingon (http://mymacfixes.blogspot.com/2009/06/how-do-i-stop-clicking-noise-from-hard.ht ml),
    disable the Sudden Motion Sensor (pmset -a sms 0),
    uncheck "Put the HDD to sleep when possible,
    maybe even something more I cant remeber now, but the HDD is still spinning. My problem isnt clickinkg or any other head parking issue. It just still spinns.
    If anyone of you can provide me with a solution (link etc.), I will be gratefull. I have one 3,5 WD external drive which is not doing this sound so I hope WD is not producing just 2,5'' HDDs with this sound. Its not usual (compared to my other 3 notebooks I have/used to have).
    Just to make sure, I have a clean install of Lion. In Activity Monitor there is no CPU or disk activity, but it still keeps spinning...
    Thanks for any help!
    Charlie

    Fixingclip wrote:
    I'm no tekkie but could it be anything to do with the way the original dive was cloned? I use Carbon Copy Cloner.....?
    The problem is I didn't clone the drive, I've installed it regularly...
    Well guys, it seems to me there is nothing more we can do about it. I'm removing the disc and sending it to the reseller. I will let you know once I get any reply.
    I'm pretty shure my next internal drive (I don't blame them for external drives, they seem to work allright) won't be WD, although they say on their website that Scorpio Blue is "optimized for operation with Mac OS X" and "tested for compatibility". I really don't know how could they say the drive is "ultra quiet"...
    I was wondering if you have found an alternative solution, that means an internal drive withou any ShockGuard or AdvancedFormat technology, 500GB in size, that will be really quiet. I know the best way is the SSD but it's still too expensive and the minimum size I need is 400GB. I have been looking all over this forum and found many threads, but none of them seems useful to me.

  • 7200RPM 200GB Hitachi Travelstar

    Hey there
    I'm new to this forum...
    Has anyone tried the 7200RPM 200GB Hitachi Travelstar in the 12" Powerbook..
    After 5 years of very happy computing, I am upgrading my poor battered laptop.. It now has the max ram and I want to speed up the drive.. I have read about the heat and battery issues but will try it anyway..
    Cool forum BTW
    Billy

    Unless I am mistaken, Hitachi's 2.5" 7200 RPM 200GB Travelstar is a Serial ATA drive, which is not compatible with any PowerBook since they use Parallel ATA (aka IDE).
    The largest compatible 7200RPM drive currently available is the 100GB Travelstar. However, if you want the capacity, then Western Digital's 250GB 5400RPM Scorpio is the largest you can get, and the speed isn't too bad. Other good but less capacious alternatives are the 5400RPM 160GB offerings from Hitachi and Seagate.
    Unless you are doing highly disk intensive work, the speed difference between 5400RPM and 7200RPM should be hardly noticeable in day-to-day usage.

  • Expanding my MDD 867mhz with a segate Barracuda 120GB

    Hi. I'm running Logic Pro on my Mac G4 MDD 876mhz. I want to upgrade my system and have more capacity on the drives. I like to have all my audiosamples (+40 G) on one internal slave HD. I'm currently running the 40G HD that came with the computer. Memory is 1GB DDR/SDRAM. I've bought a Segate Barracuda 120 GB 7200 ATA 100 HD, this disk is going to be my slave HD cause the system is yust runnig fine on the original 40 G disk. How to install the 120G HD? Can I use it along side the 40G HD? If yes, there is no need for reinstallation OSX? I've read that the MDD is capable of running 2 G DDR/SDRAM, will it make mine work faster if I put in 2 x 512 extra?
    G4 876 mhz   Mac OS X (10.3)   </span<br>
    G4 876 mhz   Mac OS X (10.3)  

    i wish I had the talent to understand music apps like Logic Pro.
    i am an old MIDI man, still using sheet music, MIDI keyboard and finale notepad.
    anywho. are you running 10.4? Core Audio is a part of Tiger, maybe the Core Audio element is having problems with slow disk access. just an idea
    if you cannot put a faster HD in the ATA100 drive carrier (the two drives in rear of MDD are ATA100 channel) you can aim for a SATA drive.
    for about $60 you can get an SIIG 4channel SATA150 PCI controller. you can then put the card in an open PCI slot, put 1 or 2 SATA HD's in the front HD carrier, of course dont forget the power convertors, and make sure nothing gets caught or crimped. I helped a buddy put two 200GB Hitachi 7200rpm 8MB SATA HD's in his MDD 1Ghz about 6 months ago. I have no idea how he did it, but He got them striped as RAID 0 for serious HD usage for his desktop video and Final Cut projects.
    MORE ram is always better. especially with heavy cpu access programs. 2GB of RAM is max for the MDD, and I bet Logic pro will run so much better with more RAM. Less pageouts and less VM usage by the OS. The OS uses part of the Boot Drive for VM if you dont have enough Real system RAM. that could cause some of the issues. The RAM is decent now. you can get 512MB for less than $80 if you look around. Always get the good Mac stuff though. Crucial, RAMJET, OWC, TransIntl.com... I did the bad thing and got some CHEAP stuff for $39 and thought Hey its CHEAP. boy it was crappy. My Mac barely worked with it. ok sorry or the Rant.
    send an email about your Mac music stuff.
    otherwise good luck dude.
    LUKE
    [email protected]
    [email protected]

  • Western Digital Scorpio Blue 640 Drive draws too much power in a MacBookPro

    I just received a Western Digital 640 gb (WD6400BEVT) Scorpio Blue Drive for my MacBookPro. I've noticed that the drives "Throttles" a lot, i.e. seems to accelerate/spin and slow down/stop in a way I've never seen in any other drive, and I've been through lots. It wouldn't be a problem if the computer didn't seem to be sluggish in response, much more sluggish than with the 200G Hitachi drive I had before. I will sometimes start typing something and the computer will be slow to react; I also see the spinning ball much more often.
    I contacted WD and was told that "It is quite possible that the computer cannot manage the capacity and energy demand of this drive. If the previous drive was under 250 GB, a 640 GB drive will encounter these issues."
    I'd never hear of this problem, and I'm really confused since the new drive has a lower rated energy requirement (it's a 5400 rpm vs 7200) than the previous drive. Has anyone else had these problems? Can someone tell me whether this is reality or obfuscation on the part of Western Digital?
    Message was edited by: jdcineaste

    Hi Brody - what makes you think the 640Gb isn't a 'notebook' drive? I've a 640Gb one that's been in my Macbook Pro, although now it's in my Samsung Netbook.
    The unit worked perfectly fine in my late 2008 unit? It's a 9.5mm unit that as far as I know adheres to the 2.5" SATA specifications? Like I say, worked fine in mine.
    This is the unit in question: http://www.overclockers.co.uk/showproduct.php?prodid=HD-322-WD&groupid=701&catid =14&subcat=896
    ...or full specifications here: http://www.wdc.com/en/products/products.asp?driveid=683
    Even WD's spec says 'Big Capacity for Mobile Computing'.
    Personally I doubt whether this issue is with power - it's probably more to do with the random pausing that some machines experience with certain drives. I had it before I upgraded to an SSD back when I had a 500Gb 5400RPM Seagate Momentus for example - you can read about my experiences with there here: http://www.markc.me.uk/MarkC/Blog/Entries/2009/6/13Macbook_Pro_Hard_DiskUpgrade.html
    I know that doesn't help the original poster that much unfortunately, but I don't think it's an issue with the drive being inherently incompatible with the Macbooks/Laptops as such. Saying that, the OP has a 2.33Ghz MBP and I don't think the pausing issues apply that far back, well not in the same manner anyways.

  • Hitachi Touro Desk 2GB USB 3.0 incompatible with the W520

    I bought one of these:
    http://www.ebuyer.com/275652-touro-desk-pro-black-2-tb-3-5in-7200-rpm-htoldeb20001bbb-in-0s03240
    for the purpose of doing regular windows system images so I can restore the complete system in case of problems.
    Surprisingly, the crystal mark shows the USB drive being faster than my internal WD 750GB Scorpio Black, which I always thought was dog slow.
    However, this drive does not work with the W520 and windows system image.  You always get:
       The backup failed.
       The request could not be performed because of an I/O device error. (0x8007045D).
    First Hitachi told me that this was a known Microsoft incompatibility with all 512E drives (i.e. 4k blocks physically, 512k logicaly), which is false as I have two other 2GB 512E drives which work just fine (Vertbatim and a WD) with system image.
    Then they said it must be the computer chipset and USB drivers (both are up to date).
    So its RMA.
    See the details here: http://www.blogger.com/blogger.g?blogID=912095636414664130#editor/target=post;postID=715913504833881...

    The issue could be related to drive firmware not compatible with system board.
    You must update the hard drive firmware then check it may resolve the issue.
    Best Regards,
    Tanuj
    Did someone help you today? Press the star on the left to thank them with a Kudo!
    If you find a post helpful and it answers your question, please mark it as an "Accepted Solution".! This will help the rest of the Community with similar issues identify the verified solution and benefit from it.
    Follow @LenovoForums on Twitter!

  • High noise and vibration levels after Hitachi 7k500 upgrade. Advice needed

    A couple days ago I upgraded my mid 2010 MBP 13 stock hdd(Hitachi 5400rpm 250gb) to a new one (Hitachi 7200rpm 500gb 7k500). I am still amazed by how much faster and more responsive system has gone.
    I was expected some increase in noise and vibration of the system, but it does I am starting to get a bit annoying. Vibration gets on my nerves- the levels are nowhere high, but there was no vibration in my stock HDD. In addition, the noise of the system on idle has roughly doubled- both fan and HDD are humming at the same level. The system is still very quite, but I could not help noticing it anyway.
    I tried replacing the old HDD and found out that the problems were not present with it (=I am not likely to have made some awful mistakes putting the hard drive in). Then I tried tightening all the screws as hard as possible and putting some rubberized washers on the corners of the HDD to ensure snuggly fit. All efforts rendered no change. Are there any other methods to reduce noise and vibration?
    Furthermore, I still have one day to return the 7k500 without any loss. Should I get WD Scorpio Blue 500gb instead? I have read user reports of similar problems with WD SB 640gb drives as well. Since these drives are essentially the same, I would expect similar problems with 500gb as well.

    Did you return it? I have the same drive and agree it is a bit noisier than the original Hitachi 5400 drive it replaced. But it is also noticeably faster and also, the noise seems to vary probably depending on internal temperature. I'm not noticing vibration.
    Also, I wonder if the increased noise is par for the course with these 7200 rpm drives? Is the Seagate 7200.4 drive quieter? The reason I went with the Hitachi though is the salesperson at OWC said the Hitachi's were definitely more reliable.

  • WD Scorpio Black 320 GB 7200 RPM Not Working

    Don't know if anyone else has experienced this, but worth a shot.
    I just purchased a WD 320 GB 7200 RPM Scorpio Black. It will not work in my brand new macbook. The original apple hard drive works fine, I have a USB->SATA adapter, hooked it up, was able to clone the old hard drive onto the WD drive. It boots up perfectly fine when I boot via USB using the adapter.
    When it is installed, however, the hard drive keeps spinning up and down and up and down...to the point where it takes 25 minutes just to boot. I disabled the sudden motion sensor via pmset, reformatted the drive, reinstalled Leopard, had the drive replaced via RMA, used the drive jumpers to limit spinnup voltage, all to no avail.
    Still the same situation. Drive works perfectly fine via USB on this computer and others, but will not work when connected to SATA on this macbook.
    My theory is that it may draw too much power, being a 7200 RPM drive and is being constantly disabled do to overcurrent then enabled again, causing the spin up/down. Maybe this is why you cannot order one of these from apple with a 7200 RPM drive? In any event, I give up. WD can't think of anything and I am stumped. If anyone has any thoughts, let me know before I return the drive, otherwise, it's going back and I am getting a 5400 RPM drive. If you are considering buying one for your macbook, beware.

    Here are some important updates:
    Got a new WD Scorpio 5400 320 gB SATA II drive! YAY! Ohhh wait....this one is having the exact same issue: won't work connected internally, will work connected externally. I did some more poking around and this is what I found:
    I also get I/O errors after booting from a linux live CD, so it must not be software related, it has to be a compatibility problem with the SATA controller and the WD hard drives. I have tried 3 WD hard drives, which all work on other computers and on this brand new macbook when connected externally. Only when connected internally. Original Mac Hitachi drive works fine.
    I called apple support and was informed, to my dismay, that "we do not guarantee non-apple hard drives will work with your macbook. The macbook may not be compatible with this drive." YAY! So the RAM incompatibility issue is happening all over again, only with hard drives now! I have not ever known another computer in all my work as a tech support provider that is only compatible with specific makes/models of SATA II drives.
    I am very disappointed, and honestly baffled. Once I make enough money to pay the restocking fee on all these WDs, I might try another brand. Someone else has to be having this issue?

  • Unable to capture video off of Hitachi DVD+HDD combined hybrid to iMovie

    I have video captured on a hard drive in my Hitachi consumer grade camera. I am trying to capture that media into iMovie. iMovie is not recognizing the files on the camera and I am unable to select the media to transfer. I am connecting to my Macbook using a 6pin to USB cord. The camera ONLY has a 6 pin and A/V outlet. I have been unsuccessful capturing any media. If anyone has any insight, please let me know. I am using iMovie 6.0.3
    I have heard that I should use firewire, however I can not find a 6 pin to firwire cord. If you know a way to work around having a firewire cord or where I can fine the necessary wire, I would appreciate it.
    Thank you.

    iMovie HD 6 won't accept mpg-2 compressed files
    With luck, you might be able to use them in iMovie '08 (but your camera isn't on the supported list).

Maybe you are looking for