How Camera Raw and Various Profiles Handle Transition Into Overexposure

With all the attention I've been paying to profiles lately, I have been opening a lot of images with bright blue colors (hence my recent post on trying to get better blue sky color). 
One of the things I've noticed is that the transition into overexposure appears to be handled VERY differently depending on the profile chosen.
Of particular interest is an image I shot recently toward a stage where some bright blue lights were shining on the crowd and into my Canon EOS-40D's lens.  I was surprised at how differently the transition into overexposure is made depending on the profile chosen.
Notably not one of the Adobe-supplied profiles handles this transition smoothly at all, showing some sharp transitions - which helps explain why I had been having such trouble with sky color.
Some examples follow (these have all been converted to sRGB for display via browser).  Specifically note the area around the bright blue light in the upper-right.
Adobe Standard profile, as supplied with Camera Raw by Adobe:
Camera Standard profile, as supplied with Camera Raw by Adobe:
Camera Landscape profile, as supplied with Camera Raw by Adobe:
The very good 40D "DPP Standard sRGB" profile Vit Novak provided me a couple of days ago, based on his measurements of how Canon DPP handles color:
The in-camera JPEG:
-Noel

That's awesome!
For "normal" exposure levels it exactly matches the other images converted with the profile you developed before, but the hard edge (e.g., seen when the edges of the image are lightened by Vignetting Correction) is gone.  Well done!
I tried it on a number of other images and found that the transition from blue sky to whited-out overexposure was indeed noticeably better, with the sky going to cyan slightly less quicky.  For example, I have an evening time exposure with the sky transitioning to overexposure.  I converted the image once with Adobe Standard and each of your profiles, and put an extreme Curves adjustment layer over the top to more easily see the transition.  Note the color, in particular, of the sky transition into overexposure with the three different conversions, your most recent on the bottom.
You really have gotten your head around how these profiles work with Camera raw, and you do damned good work with that knowledge, Vit!
Let's review the features of this profile:
1.  It matches the camera color virtually perfectly, which I for one find an excellent starting point for further Camera Raw adjustments.
2.  It handles transition into overexposure IMO as well or better than the camera manufacturer's software and hardware.
3.  Since you developed it to match the camera manufacturer's sRGB conversions, and THEY don't think channel clipping is acceptable if the user has chosen to convert to sRGB, it has solved the problem with channel clipping that I had seen with all the Adobe profiles when converting directly to sRGB, and has thus made the action I had been using to do a "bend the edges" conversion unnecessary.
There is nothing not to love here!
Vit, I don't know how much work is involved with making such a profile - clearly you've put some serious time into getting where you are, but would you be interested in partnering with me and selling sets of profiles with characteristics like this one to others who would like to get the best possible Camera Raw or Lightroom conversions?  If so, let's talk off the forum via eMail.
-Noel

Similar Messages

  • How do I install the RC updates to my PS CC, camera raw and Lightroom?

    How do I install the RC updates to my PS CC, camera raw and Lightroom? I have downloaded the correct versions from the Lab site but I still can't open my Nikon D-610 RAW files. The site says follow on screen instructions but I have not found any. Help please.

    Please ensure that for CC you have downloaded ACR 8.3 - CC:
    http://labs.adobe.com/downloads/cameraraw8-3-cc.html
    Please extract the downloaded .zip file to Desktop and then run .exe file.
    After successful installation try opening D610 files, This should work.
    Regards,
    Ashutosh

  • I'm trying to do a batch crop in camera raw and there is no dropdown option in the crop tool to select inches or pixels. How can I fix this?

    I'm trying to do a batch crop in camera raw and there is no dropdown option in the crop tool to select inches or pixels. How can I fix this?

    Create an action to do the crop and user the image processor to batch process your RAW files and have it use your cropping action in the process.

  • Adobe Camera Raw and Adobe Lightroom color profiles ....

    Adobe Camera Raw and Adobe Lightroom color profiles .... for sony cameras

    Adobe Camera Raw and Adobe Lightroom color profiles .... for sony cameras

  • Why do my raws look different when I view them in Adobe Bridge/Adobe Camera Raw and Canons Digital P

    Hello all,
    I am sorta new to taking Raw photographs and I have been been using Adobe Bridge/Camera Raw to edit. When I take my photos (I am using a Canon t2i) I have it set to save a raw and a jpg. When I view these images in Adobe Bridge/Camera Raw I notice a clear difference in the jpg and raw (I understand the whole concept behind raw vs. jpg. so im not questioning why one looks different) It is obvious all the adjustments that were applied to my jpg. vs the natural raw.  My question is: When I view the same two images in the software that came with my camera, canon digital photo professionals, the canon and raw look almost identical.... My assumption is that canon is applying the same "adjustments" to my raw as it did to the jpgs?  Has anyone used these two programs and noticed this?
    Thank you in advance for your assistance.
    Michelle

    Can't say I'm an expert on DPP myself either.  I've only run it a few times myself.
    If you're seeing Photoshop freeze just by looking at the File Info tab, that's certainly not expected and you should start a tread specifically to discuss that.  The forum may be able to help you get that working.
    I happen to like the color my camera delivers in its embedded JPEGs (which I use to quickly review shots via IrfanView).  Starting with that color in Camera Raw by default just feels very natural and integrated.
    Without a specific custom profile to help you with the task, here's my suggestions for the next best thing:
    1.  Take an image with a range of different colors in it.
    2.  Open the embedded JPEG also using whatever means you have to do so.
    3.  Open it also in Camera Raw and make sure you're using the Camera Raw default parameters.
    4.  Go into the Camera Calibration tab (little camera icon), and choose the Camera Standard profile as provided by Adobe.
    5.  Tweak the various sliders so as to match the color between what you're seeing in the JPEG and Camera Raw.
    6.  Save new Camera Raw defaults.
    Some notes:
    Make sure you leave the White Balance on As Shot, since storing a specific white balance is probably not going to be helpful.
    Test your settings and repeat the above to tweak them as needed using other images.
    Keep in mind that not every application does proper color-management.  IrfanView can be set up to do so, and I don't recall whether you have to tweak a default setting to make it do that or not (it's been a while).
    Hope this helps!
    -Noel

  • Why the colors look so different betweet my Camera Raw and Bridge?

    We know that after editing images in Camera Raw, thumbnails in Bridge will updated according to the new xmp files.
    However, for some of my Raw files, the colors look very different in Bridge after makeing adjustments in Camera Raw, I can see more red in those phoots. But when I reopen the file in Camera Raw, all the colors are just correct.
    For those photos without applying xmp files the colors looks exactly the same in Camera Raw and Bridge.
    Does this means that my Camera Raw and Bridge use different color space? How can I fix this problem? Thank you

    If you want help, you need to specify your platform (Mac or Windows), the exact versions of your Operating System, Photoshop, ACR plug-in and Bridge.
    Also look at your Bridge preferences and tell us what you have your Thumbnail preferences set to.
    Re-setting your preferences and purging the cache would also help.  It could be something as simple as a corrupt cache.
    Bridge is Color Managed, but it does not use a color space of its own.  It applies the color space with which each image is tagged, it assigns sRGB to untagged files.
    When was the last time you calibrated and profiled your monitor?
    Details would help.
    Wo Tai Lao Le
    我太老了

  • Camera Raw Preferences- Tiff / JPEG Handling -CS 3

    In the Camera Raw Preferences > JPEG + Tiff Handling Section I have " Always open TIFF/JPEG Files with Settings Using Camera Raw" UNCHECKED. Yet, when I double-click on an image in Bridge to open it, it opens the Raw window. I want the image to open directly in Photoshop. What do I need to do?

    There are other preferences to be UNchecked. Carefully examine Camera Raw prefs, Bridge prefs and Photoshop prefs.
    Then relaunch Bridge and Photoshop.

  • Scale difference between Camera Raw and Lens Correction Filter in CS6

    I have the latest Camera Raw plugin (8.6.0.254). When I open an NEF file from a D800, the resulting image is 4912x7360 pixels, whether I apply distortion correction or not.
    If I load the NEF file, do not apply distortion correction in Camera Raw, but then apply it via the Lens Correction Filter, the image must be rescaled to approximately 4840x7252 (some 98.53%) so that it matches the results of the Camera Raw plugin (minus the missing pixels around all four sides, of course).
    Anyone else notice this (particularly in newer versions of Photoshop)? Is there a way to prevent this cropping? The amount of distortion on the lens (35mm) is minimal and, regardless of that, I would have expected Camera Raw and the Lens Correction filter to output identical images after distortion correction, since the lens profile is the same.

    To see if that can be replicated, we'd need to now the exact version of CS6 you're running (e.g. on Mac you should be on Photoshop CS6 13.0.6) and the exact version of your OS.

  • Camera Raw and Photoshop fluctuations

    When I open a JPG from Camera Raw and view it in Photoshop I'm noticing that the Photoshop version, viewed at 100%, is slightly darker, viewed side-by-side, than the preview in Camera Raw, also at 100%. Both in the same color space (sRGB).
    Interestingly, when I changed the color settings in Photoshop to Adobe RGB and then reprocessed the photo in Camera Raw as an Adobe RGB file and then opened it in Photoshop, the side-by-side comparison shows the Photoshop version as slightly lighter, not darker, than the version shown in the preview window in Camera Raw. Both also at 100%.
    Any thoughts on the subject would be very much appreciated. Thank you. Tom
    Photoshop CS3
    Camera Raw 4.3.1
    aluminum imac 17" display, 2.4 GHz Intel Core 2 Duo
    2 GB 667 MHx DDR2 SDRAM
    Mac OSX 10.4.11

    >
    Both Camera Raw and Photoshop are using your display profile to make the image preview. If the two don't match (everything matches on my displays) I suspect your display profile is less than optimal.

  • I'm in Camera Raw and for no reason my adjustment brush will not work. Any suggestions

    I'm in Camera Raw and for no reason my adjustment brush will not work. Any suggestions

    BOILERPLATE TEXT:
    Note that this is boilerplate text.
    If you give complete and detailed information about your setup and the issue at hand,
    such as your platform (Mac or Win),
    exact versions of your OS, of Photoshop (not just "CS6", but something like CS6v.13.0.6) and of Bridge,
    your settings in Photoshop > Preference > Performance
    the type of file you were working on,
    machine specs, such as total installed RAM, scratch file HDs, total available HD space, video card specs, including total VRAM installed,
    what troubleshooting steps you have taken so far,
    what error message(s) you receive,
    if having issues opening raw files also the exact camera make and model that generated them,
    if you're having printing issues, indicate the exact make and model of your printer, paper size, image dimensions in pixels (so many pixels wide by so many pixels high). if going through a RIP, specify that too.
    A screen shot of your settings or of the image could be very helpful too,
    etc.,
    someone may be able to help you (not necessarily this poster, who is not a Windows user).
    Please read this FAQ for advice on how to ask your questions correctly for quicker and better answers:
    http://forums.adobe.com/thread/419981?tstart=0
    Thanks!

  • New to camera raw and have a basic question

    Hello,
    I have just started playing with camera raw and when I make changes, and say done, I am able to open that image up and continue with the corrections, which is great.
    but.....
    If I open up an image that has been edited in camera raw, and I want to get back to the original and start again, how would I do that?
    thanks
    'babs

    I don't know if you made a small typo, but you don't want to "Reset Camera Raw Defaults" - that affects all future file opens (assuming you have saved custom defaults for your camera in the past).
    You just want to check the entry Camera Raw Defaults up near the top to affect the selected image(s) alone.
    -Noel

  • Camera RAW and Yosemite?

    I just updated Aperture 3.6 and Camera Raw 6.01. According to all the info it should read files from my new Canon 7D Mark II.
    http://support.apple.com/en-us/HT203996
    Well it doesn't!
    Adobe Camera Raw also doesn't work with the files from this camera in Photoshop/Lightroom.
    Very frustrating as I like to shoot everything in RAW.
    Anyone have suggestions on why Aperture with latest Camera Raw and Yosemite don't play well together? Or even better how to make Aperture work with these files...  Thanks - Roger

    I was able to figure it out. I downloaded Camera RAW 6.01 from this address
    http://support.apple.com/kb/DL1777?viewlocale=en_US&locale=en_US
    and manually installed it. Apparently the App Store update didn't take. After this install all is working as it should.

  • Camera RAW and DNG version 8.2

    I have a Canon 70D.  How do I find out what version of camera raw and dng  that I have installed?

    Unfortunately, photoshop elements 11 can only use up to camera raw 7.4 for the camera raw plugin.
    (in the photoshop elements 11 editor; Adobe Photoshop Elements Editor>About Plug-In and click on the words Camera Raw to find the version you have)
    (Help>Updates in the pse 11 editor to check for updates)
    You can use the DNG converter 8.6 to convert your canon 70d files to dng copies, which pse 11 should then open.
    If you have mac os x 10.6.8 snow leopard then you would need to use dng converter 8.3
    dng converter 8.6:
    Adobe - Adobe Camera Raw and DNG Converter : For Macintosh : Adobe DNG Converter 8.6
    dng converter 8.3:
    Adobe - Adobe Camera Raw and DNG Converter : For Macintosh : Adobe DNG Converter 8.3
    How to use the dng converter:
    Camera Raw: How to use Adobe DNG Converter - YouTube
    You could also upgrade to photoshop elements 12 or look at adobe lightroom 5.6 to avoid using the dng converter

  • I updated cs6 camera raw and now can't see the camera metadata I used to see and cannot find it in photoshop itself.

    I updated cs6 camera raw and now can't see the camera metadata in raw that I used to and can't see it at all in photoshop.  can this be fixed?

    sgterrill65 wrote:
    I am using windows 7 64 bit not mac
    Next time, please give all pertinent information from the get go.
    Please read this FAQ for advice on how to ask your questions correctly for quicker and better answers: 
    http://forums.adobe.com/thread/419981?tstart=0
    Thanks!

  • Camera raw and bridge: no dialogue in cs3

    After purchasing the Nikon D300 I had to upgrade from CS2 to CS3 as former versions of photoshop are unable to manage the RAW files (NEF) generated by the new camera.
    My problem is that, even having downloaded the 4.3.1 version of Camera Raw and having installed it, there is no dialogue with bridge. I tried to reinstall CS3 as well.
    This means:
    - I miss the Camera Raw preferences setting (under the edit menu in bridge)
    - Always in Bridge I cannot cut and paste (copy and apply) camera raw settings of one photo to others. Neither selecting the edit menu, nor with the mouse's right button.
    The point is not that these and similar selections do not work, the point is that they do not even appear in the menus. The help resources, for instance, tell about a Edit > Develop Settings function that is not present in my menu.
    What is wrong? Is it possible that there is any kind of conflict with Nikon capture NX?
    I'll be grateful to anyone able to help me,
    fm

    Hi All,
    Been reading this thread with interest.
    I am on PC with XP, I have been using CS3 for quite a while now and both my D200 and D300 have all been working perfectly. But over the last few months I have noticed that Bridge was (a) very slow to start and (b) would suddenly come up with the "Bridge has encountered a problem and must close" message. Then it got to the stage were Bridge would not open at all and just the "Problem" message would show and then next PS3 then starting displayed the "There has been a cataclysmic Failure" message.
    So I have used the original CS3 CD and uninstalled and reinstalled and got both programs working but no Camera Raw. If I click on the NEF file it goes to PS and gets the message wrong file type. All the preferences are set ok.
    The other thing that happened was when I downloaded all the updates, Bridge went back to not opening and the "problem" message showing again.
    After reading Xoslic message I will try to take out the registry entries and reinstall again and see if that works.
    For all of you on Nikon, CS3 was working perfectly for me until just recently, so I know that it does work fine.
    Hopefully I will get a soloution and let you know if it works.
    Gerry
    PS. I also had a problem in that Lightroom 1.4 would not work either, opened ok but "lightroom has encountered a problem" message appeared and it closed down. Other people suggested that the problem lay in "Version Cue"

Maybe you are looking for