How far does iPhoto preserve the RAW file when editing?

I'm trying to get a better understanding of how iPhoto handles RAW photos and hope you'll answer a humble, possibly misguided question:
How far through the editing process does iPhoto preserve RAW data?
Here's what I mean by this: I understand that iPhoto cannot "edit" a RAW file, but there are a couple of ways it look like it was. Let's take a WB adjustment as an example.
Option 1: "Convert on import." iPhoto converts the RAW to a JPG when I import the file (or begin to edit it). Then adjusting the WB will be a filter applied to a JPG file (meaning there wasn't much advantage to shooting RAWs in the first place)!
Option 2: "Fully RAW." iPhoto imports the RAW file and then "processes" it whenever you display or print it. When you edit it (e.g., adjusting the white balance), it keeps track of the new parameters (e.g., WB, or contrast, or cropping, etc.) and then uses these parameters the next time it processes the RAW for display. This would mean, for example, that there would be no difference in quality between
A. Taking a freshly-imported RAW and setting the white balance to X, and
B. Taking a freshly-imported RAW, setting the white balance to Y, closing iPhoto, re-opening iPhoto then editing the picture again and changing the WB to X.
Option 3: "Somewhere in-between." Files are imported as RAW, but then converted to JPG at the end of the first editing. Subsequent edits are treated as JPG edits (including the resulting loss in image quality with each edit).
Can anyone clarify this? How does the answer differ for different types of edits (e.g., WB vs. image rotation vs., expanding the highlights, etc.)? Is the answer different for Aperture vs. iPhoto?
Thanks!
-Mike

How about the 4 th option... None of the above.
Option 3 is closest. As the Help says:
When you edit a RAW-format photo and click Done, iPhoto applies your changes to the RAW image data and stores the data as a JPEG file (the original RAW file remains unchanged).
It can also be saved as tiff is you prefer.
Here's where it's different from your option 3:
Subsequent edits are treated as JPG edits (including the resulting loss in image quality with each edit)
There is no loss of image quality with each edit because of iPhoto's _[Non-Destructive Editing Feature|http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?path=iPhoto/7.0/en/11464.html]_ .
You can, of course, re-process the RAWs if you choose. This will bring you right back to the Original file.
Aperture is quite different. It's at your option 2
Regards
TD

Similar Messages

  • How fast does Apple produce new RAW files for new cameras? I want to buy a D7100 wich is not supported in the present version?

    How fast does Apple produce new RAW files for new cameras? I want to buy a D7100 wich is not supported in the present version?

    Jeannot7 wrote:
    I'm interested in seeing who gets the D7100 support first? Apple or Adobe!! I will go with the one that gets it out first.
    FWIW,
    Adobe keeps a quarterly release schedule for RAW updates. The current Lightroom 4.4 RC expires on 5/31/2013 which typically is an indication that the official release will be close to that date. According to the current list of new supported cameras, the Nikon D7100 is not slated to be supported (but that could change on release).
    http://labs.adobe.com/technologies/lightroom4-4/?tabID=details#tabTop
    The most likely time frame for Adobe support of the D7100 will be sometime in August or September 2013 (although there will probably be a Lightroom 4.5 RC available prior to that for testing purposes).

  • Adobe Lightroom, Photoshop and Bridge does not recognize the raw files from my Canon Mark III 5D Camera.

    Adobe Lightroom, Photoshop and Bridge does not recognize the raw files from my new Canon Mark III 5D Camera.  How can I get my files open to view and edit?  I am using LR3, Photoshop CS3 and Bridge CS3.  Do I need to upgrade these programs or is there another way to get these programs to recognize my files?
    When I try opening the raw images in Lightroom, the thumbnails say "Preview unavailable for this file"  ... when I click "import" an error message pops up that says "The files are from a camera which is not recognized by the raw format support in Lightroom."
    When I try opening the raw images in Photoshop, an error message pops up saying "could not complete your request because photoshop does not recognize this type of file."
    When I try opening the raw images in Bridge, it just shows an icon with the file name and CR2.
    Please help!!!

    Unless I missed an announcement, today, LR6 isn't available, yet, right?  Only Adobe employees and beta testers would know what LR6 does differently at this point and they're all sworn to secrecy.
    LR5 is available as a standalone version.
    PS-CS6 is available as a serial-number-licensed version.
    PS-CC + LR5 are also available as a Photography Plan subscription for $10/month with a minimum OS versions of OSX 10.7 (and probably 10.8, soon) and Windows 7.
    Bridge is part of PS, not a separate program.
    LR5 standalone and LR+PS-CC plan are both available on this page:  http://www.adobe.com/products/catalog/software.html
    PS-CS6 can be found on this page:  Creative Suite 6 which can be found by searching www.adobe.com for Photoshop CS6 and clicking the Buy link in the on-the-fly search results.
    As with any new Adobe software, it might be wise to run it in trial mode for a few days/weeks to see if it works well with your computer, before purchasing and finding out you might need a new computer, first.

  • Does iPhoto 11 support RAW files from Nikon D800?

    Does iPhoto 11 support Raw files from a Nikon D800 or do I need to upgrade to Apeture? I am running 10.7.4. and currently use iPhoto '09

    Aperature and iPhoto use the same RAW support - you probably need to upgrade to iPhoto '11  - purchase from the App store, backup your iPhoto library and upgrade - the RAW support list is here
    LN

  • IPhoto does not recognise the raw files(.NRW) from my new Nikon camera model P7100,any advice please as running latest version of iPhoto(9.2.1)

    Since changing my little everyday camera to a new Nikon Coolpix P7100 iPhoto cannot import any of the raw files(.NRW),says it does not recognise them.
    I have updated iPhoto to the latest version(9.2.1) but still cannot open them.
    Any ideas please

    The raw from the P7100 is not supported at this time.
    The Raw from every model of camera is different. Note: that's every model not every brand. So, the NEF produced by a Nikon D40 is not the same as the NEF produced by a D60, the CR2 produced by a Canon 350 is not the same as the CR2 produced by a Canon 400.
    Therefore the Raw for every camera model needs to be added individually. If yours is not supported then let them know you want it:
    iPhoto menu -> Provide iPhoto Feedback

  • Does iPhoto change a RAW file upon import or export?

    Hi! New Mac user here. Trying to get my workflows and backups going.
    I created an iPhoto library from multiple sources: migration from PC, folders from backup HD, new photos from iPhone and camera memory card.
    So I have one consolidated library that is almost 300Gb but I want to go through and remove and archive many of these, leaving only a much smaller working library with the archive copies of some originals stored somewhere else.  These archive copies will not be referenced files, my plan is to export them from iPhoto, back them up to an external HD, and then delete them from the iPhoto library. If I ever decided to look at them again, I would import them from the archive HD.
    Ideally, I should have imported all the files to my iMac desktop and then imported only what I wanted into iPhoto, but because everything is now consolidated (and the photos from the iPhone and camera memory card are erased), I don't want to wipe out my iPhoto library and start over. So I'm starting with this huge managed library and want to export a good part of it to what I will call "the archive" to cull it down.
    My questions: Upon import, did iPhoto change the RAW master files, or will those be the same when I export them (assuming I made no edits)? Did iPhoto change the JPEGs or will those also be the same when I export them?
    How do I export the files I want to save to the archive before deleting them from the iPhoto library?
    Alternatively, I think I will use Aperture going forward for editing.  Should I use that instead for trying to export these files?
    Thank you for any assistance you can provide.
    LCA
    iMac 4 GB, 2.7 GHz, Intel Core i5
    OS X 10.7.4
    iPhoto 9.3.1
    Aperture 3.3.1

    File -> Export and in the resulting dialogue set the Kind to Original
    That will export a byte by byte copy of the file you imported, unchanged in any way.
    Can I suggest another way of working. Why not have two Libraries? An archive and a working one?
    The principle advantage is that you won't have to import pics to review them again later, just open the other library.
    Make sure the drive is formatted Mac OS Extended (Journaled)
    1. Quit iPhoto
    2. Copy the iPhoto Library from your Pictures Folder to the External Disk.
    Now you have two full versions of the Library.
    3. On the Internal library, trash the Events you don't want there
    Now you have a full copy of the Library on the External and a smaller subset on the Internal
    Some Notes:
    As a general rule: when deleting photos do them in batches of about 100 at a time. iPhoto can baulk at trashing large numbers at one go.
    You can choose which Library to open: Hold down the option (or alt) key key and launch iPhoto. From the resulting menu select 'Choose Library'
    You can keep the Library on the external updated with new imports using iPhoto Library Manager

  • OM-D: how to view entire 4:3 RAW file when aspect ratio set in-camera to 3:2?

    When shooting RAW, the OM-D records 4:3 files no matter what the aspect ratio is set to.  If you set it to 3:2 (for example), the camera records some sort of metadata to communicate this information to Lightroom, which honors the setting.  So far, so good.
    My question is, is there any way to override that setting? I have a photo shot at 3:2, but I can see from the in-camera preview that it'd be a better shot with the whole thing. But I can't figure out how to get LR 4.1rc2 to show me the whole thing!
    Thanks,
    Ben

    Unfortunately, there is no way in LR directly. You may be able to restore the settings directly in the raw file using exiftool (tags "aspectratio" and "aspectframe", there are instructions in some forums I think), but it is generally not advisable to manipulate original raws that way (at least, a backup should be made).
    See also:
    http://feedback.photoshop.com/photoshop_family/topics/lightroom_4_1_rc_trouble_with_canon_ 5d_mark_iii_aspect_ratio
    http://feedback.photoshop.com/photoshop_family/topics/importing_orf_files_does_not_import_ all_image_area

  • Is there any benefit to keep the RAW file after editing outside Lightroom creates a TIFF

    When working with RAW files in Lightroom and you choose to edit in Photoshop, the only option is "Edit a copy with Lightroom Adjustments" (Edit Original is grayed out).  This creates a .TIFF so after you come back from Photoshop you now have two copies of the photo--the RAW file and a TIFF version.
    In my normal workflow, I make additional edits to the TIFF file in addition to the changes Photoshop made so I'm left with a "out dated" version of the RAW file.  Is there any benefit to keeping the RAW file at that point?  I'm doubling my disk usage by keeping it.
    Fire away.....

    Answering this question:
    This got me wonderig why LR turns my 25-30mb CR2 RAW files into 80-95 mb TIFF files when it sends them to Photoshop for editing but Photoshop can open the same 25-30 RAW file in DNG format and save it as a 25-30 mb TIFF.  Why are the TIFF's LR creates 3x larger than the ones created by PS?
    Camera RAW file formats are compressed to a small file size using manufacturer proprietary information about the image sensor pixel layout. This provides a more efficient loss-less file compression algorithm than TIFF's LZW or ZIP compression algorithms. LZW or ZIP compression is not used when Lightroom exports and opens an image in Photoshop for editing, but you certainly have that option when saving the file after applying your PS edits. DNG files using loss-less compression can produce a file size slightly smaller than RAW format, but I have no experience with DNG.
    Answering this question:
    CS3 can't read Canon .CR2 RAW files (at least mine can't unless there is a plugin of some kind). 
    Support for newer camera models like your Canon 7D are only added to the then current (and later version) Adobe Camera RAW Converter and Lightroom. Newer Adobe Camera RAW converter versions (6.3) are not supported in older version of Photoshop like CS3. It is the nature of business marketing and also due to the large expense to support older application versions with "new" plug-in features. It would be a support nightmare!
    Hypothetical Example:
    "Why doesn't Adobe Camera RAW 10.3 work properly with my Canon 1600 D MK XV 45 Megapixel camera in Photoshop CS3?"

  • HT201250 what do I do if my passport for mac does not delete the old files when the disc is full

    What do I do  if the time machine does not delete the oldest files on my passport for mac. I get the message backup failed not enough disc space available

    See Pondini's TM FAQs, for starters.

  • How far does iPhoto take you?

    Hello,
    As I get deeper into digital photography, I am wondering how far serious amateurs go with iPhoto. Is there some point where you find that you wish the software could do more than what iPhoto does and then, do you move on? iPhoto is outstanding, and Photoshop is very expensive. And yet, I begin to think that blowing $400 on another lens might be spent better on software.
    So how does it work for you?

    Ratty:
    PSE has about 80% of Photoshops editing capability at
    about 25% of the price. It is far more versitile to
    iPhoto in editing power, allowing the user to create
    layers, etc.. It does have a much stepper learning
    curve however, but you can do so much more with it,
    for example. You can add text to
    images as well. There is one caveat to using PSE
    thru iPhoto and that is if you create an edit that
    requires a layered file and, thus, a change of
    extension, you must save it to the desktop and then
    import as a new file. Future edits on that file can
    proceed as usual.
    The Effects pallet in iPhoto does make it easy to
    make those types of changes and the Effects pallet is
    much more extensive than before. I think there's a
    demo of PSE available that you can try and and use to
    compare edits with those in iPhoto.
    Toad,
    At first, I thought the sample photos you linked to were different photos. I thought, whats the point of using two different photos to show off the software. Only looking more carefully did I realize that each one was the same photo twice! Very good example of Photoshop Elements! Thanks very much. Seems like a good buy at the price.

  • Preview does not support the raw file format of the nikon d300s

    preview does not support the files and snow leopard does not provide icon previews either.
    is there any date when there will be support for these type of files?
    any suggestions on how to open the NEF files with preview in the meantime there is an update?
    regards

    any suggestions on how to open the NEF files with preview in the meantime there is an update?
    Not with Preview, but Nikon Transfer v1.0.1.3005 is so far happy with 10.6.1 and you may see if there is any advantage there. Take the card out of the 300s and use a reader if you have to.
    It usually takes from 3 to 6 months before Apple releases a new/specific Nikon RAW related update, so you are at the beginning of that cycle it would appear...all you can do is wait, sorry.

  • TS2518 I have Aperture 3.1.2 running on os 10.6.8. Aperture does not show focus points on my Nikon D7100, nor does it recognize the RAW files. Will upgrading Aperture allow me to see the focus points and RAW files again? Also, do I need to upgrade my os f

    I have aperture 3.1.2 running on os 10.6.8 mac book pro. Lost some features in aperature when I upgraded my camera (no longer shows focus points, does not recognize RAW files) Would like to upgrade to aperture 3.5, but do not want to loose any pictures in my extensive library. Do I have to upgrade one vesion at a time, or can I jump? I believe I also need to upgrade my os, but not sure which to do first?  Any help would be appreciated...

    1. Can I get Icloud without having to upgrade to OS Lion?
    Nope, you need 10.7.
    2. If I upgrade to OS Lion, does this automatically put me onto ICloud
    No, you set that up yourself.
    3. I have three mobile me email addresses. One for myself, one for my wife and one I use for my business. What happens to these.
    You can convert them to be used in iCloud.
    4. My wife and I also use mobile me to sync our calendars across an Ipad (original) and two Iphones (3Gs). Both Iphones and Ipad are still currently using IOS4, and I am reluctant to upgrade this to IOS 5 as I have heard some horror stories. If I fail to upgrade to IOS 5, will this create confusion with my Apple ID's. (There already is a lot of confusion with these- Apple appear to not have down their homework)
    If you don't change the settings you have now, I'm sure it will stay working.  I believe Apple is phasing out MobileMe and you'd be forced to upgrade eventually.
    5. Will Icloud allow me to transfer my Icalendar across seamlessly? This is Ical 4.04 whic came with my Imac. Does this get upgraded if I update to Lion?
    Yes, it will get upgraded.  I have my calendar on Lion and my iPhone 5.0.1 working seamlessly at the moment.  That doesn't mean you won't have problems because with new technology that can be expected.  Make sure you do a back up if you're worried about losing data.

  • Does iPhoto 6 support RAW files?

    Seems that some of my RAW images are not importing into iPhoto 6. They are taken with the Panasonic Lumix L1 SLR. So question is whether or not iPhoto supports RAW files, and is it specific to the camera model which might have its own proprietary RAW format? Am I better off with Aperture?
    Thanks

    whether or not iPhoto supports RAW files<<<</div>
    Yes.
    is it specific to the camera model which might have its own proprietary RAW format<<<</div>
    Yes. Apparently, Panasonic has chosen not to share its RAW format characteristics.
    Am I better off with Aperture?<<<</div>
    No. RAW support (or lack thereof) is system-wide.

  • Where does iphoto store the raw photos?

    Hi - I have imported all my photos into iphoto and am begining to get the hang of using iphoto to create my events/albums etc.  I have been a PC user for over 20 years and all my media/data etc is backed up onto a NAS drive.  For a long time I assumed I could use iphotos in Reference Mode and keep everything on NAS but it is painfully slow, eventhough all my computers communicate wired and I have a decent router.  So I have given up and have imported all of them.
    However, I would like to keep my NAS as a backup for my raw files.  I know I can load my raw data twice by going between the PC and Mac, but would rather not.  I would really appreciate it if anyone can tell me if the following is possible;
    1. Import new photos from my camera into iphoto
    2. Use an app on the iMac to just Copy the new raw photos into my NAS drive, without corrupting iphotos. I can't find where iphotos stores the photos.
    3. Go back to iphoto and organise my photos into events etc
    4. Keep the original files on NAS to import as and when (if I ever need to)
    I am going to get a new external drive, formatted for Mac to back up iphotos BUT in the mean time I'd like to do the above.  I am grateful for any help.
    Regards
    Fataneh

    iPhoto 09 and iPhoto 11 have exactly the same options for accessing the images. Exactly the same supported ones, exactly the same unsupported ones.
    For help accessing your photos in iPhoto see this user tip:
    https://discussions.apple.com/docs/DOC-4491
    This User Tip
    https://discussions.apple.com/docs/DOC-4921
    has details of the options in the Export dialogue.

  • How to unselect iPhoto as the default app. when my camera is connected?

    Hi. I prefer to use "image capture" as the default app. when I 1st connect my camera to the mac . Right now iPhoto appears to be the default app. as it automatically opens when I connect my camera. How do I change the default app. to "image capture"? Thanks.

    Bruce
    That's an option in the Preferences to Image Capture.
    Regards
    TD

Maybe you are looking for