How much it makes sense AIA FP without AIA Error Handlers?

Question

If we decide not to use AIA Error Handling, how much do you rate AIA FP out of 5?
How much it makes sense AIA FP without AIA Err Handler?
And should we go ahead without AIA Error Handling?
Our requirement is litle tricky (can be achieved with some word arounds) to be achieved using AIA EH so we decided to use our own Email handler BPEL to send Error Mails. what challenged we may face going ahead and what things we should keep in mind designing the custom BPEL. Also If we use AIA EH
Please suggest me the best way you think...
We are using SOA Suite 11g
Edited by: panks on Jul 12, 2011 6:18 PM

Answer 1

I even feel the same AIA EH is significant part of AIA.
Here we faced some issues which obviously can be overcame by some changes in prebuilt solution..
1. AIA EH sents Text mail no HTML template I was able to find
2. Role is not role in 11g. it is user :( This is very dis appointing if we want to assign multiple people to a same role. I will have to put them into a dist Mail List. Migration from one instance of Web logic to another for UI messaging(notification channel) is also a challenge. In 10g It was more easy by putting all these in Jazn. I have no Idea same can be achived here in 11g.
3. Error code/Err Msg/Corrective Action: we want customized Error codes and Error messages even when we trigger the CompositeJavaAction from Fault Policy. It was Over riding the values of Fault notification in Composite Java action and Mail is sent. We have no control of customising the Error codes/ Error Message if triggered from Java Action. I will have to write again our own Java Action for this.
I got some where in Doc that some codes and custom texts can be stored in a Resource Class. but again this is overhead to decompile the class file update it and again compile it :) . I have no Idea what led them to put these Texts in a Class :) they have DVM, AIA Config Xref still they used Class for storing hardcoded values which they say are configurable (but how? decompile -> change ->compile??)..