IBook (Late 2004)- Thought it was a disk problem but now out of my depth?

Hi all,
This a really strange one.
I'll give you as much to go on as poss... Long post alert!!
(I'm wondering if I perhaps have more than one problem..?)
I have an iBook G4 (Late 2004) here, 1.2 Ghz, with an 80GB factory installed HD. RAM maxed out, but unaltered for 4 years. No new software or other recent changes.
It started acting wonky, freezing, crashing etc, so ran Disk Utility to repair permissions. Closed itself down halfway through, then wouldn't boot at all, just showed flashing question mark.
In Target Disk Mode, Disk Utility showed "*Underlying task reported failure*" and Disk Warrior couldn't replace directory "*due to Mac OS X services failure*".
(Did show me red than I've ever seen on using DW before though!)
Tried to boot from install CD but wouldn't start up. The only CD it will boot from is Apple Hardware Test, which showed "*Error Detected*" for Mass Storage.
OK, I thought, the disk is 4 years old, time to get the screwdrivers out.
Using the ifixit instructions and Spudnuty's helpful suggestions (+BTW, thanks!+), successfully changed it for a WD 250GB Scorpio disk (£90, MicroAnvika), and then using Target Disk mode again, initialized it and used Carbon Copy Cloner to restore my last full clone (6 months old though... I know, I know!).
Restarted in 'standalone mode', repaired disk permissions (SMART showing Verified), all seemed to be functioning OK, then tried to start up from Disk Warrior to double check.
Now all attempts to start up from DW or Install CDs result in Kernel Panics or blank grey screens, although Apple Hardware Test still runs and shows
*ERROR CODE: 2STF/8/3: ATA-100 ata-6-Master ERROR CODE*
In Target Disk Mode, both Disk Utility and Disk Warrior are making the same reports as before the Hard Disk exchange.
So I pulled the 1GB of RAM (Crucial) which has been in there for 4 years, and also took off the battery, and hey it started up ok!!
Ran Disk utility- SMART status Verified, but repair permission "*lost its connection with Macintosh HD*" halfway through. At second attempt, it repaired ok.
Tried to start from CD again, several attempts result only in booting to-
" *Invalid Memory Access at %SRR0: 72b82dc0 %SRR1:40003030*
*Apple PowerBook 6,5 4.8.7f1 Boot ROM Built on 09/23/04* " etc etc
*Welcome to Open Firmware*" etc etc, where entering "shut-down" hangs and "mac-boot" flips me the Flashing Question Mark again.
I've tried resetting PRAM (several tries no changes), tried starting up in Single User mode, Safe Mode etc etc... makes no difference.
So here's the question-
Is it possible that the ATA bus is to blame? (What's the fix?) Or suddenly bad RAM?
What else can I do before I concur with the service manual that the logic board needs replacing?
I'm loath to give up on it, it's been a good friend for years! (On the other hand, I can't justify spending too much on it either...)
Any ideas? (and sorry, brevity apparently not my forte!)
Andy.
Message was edited by: AndyL

The point is up to your needs. They are nice machines, and if you can have it repaired, there is no harm in trying to be environmentally friendly by making it useful again. Updating to new software may be more trouble than it is worth depending on how old the software you currently have installed, and your finances for new software. Or getting a working used or refurbished Mac might be another option. See my FAQ*:
http://www.macmaps.com/usedrefurbished.html
And check these sites as to what they might cost to repair your machine:
http://www.dttservice.com/
http://www.powerbookresq.com/
http://www.microdocusa.com/
http://www.macspecialist.com/
http://www.techrestore.com/
- * Links to my pages may give me compensation.

Similar Messages

  • Thought it was Prox Sensor issue, but now I dont think it is

    I thought I was having intermittant issues with the proximity sensor...every now and then I would mute someone or start dialing random numbers while on a call. Today while I was on a call it happend again, but I now am pretty sure I know what trigers it...at least for me. While on the call I got the chime that I had a new e-mail and then I started dialing random numbers and muted the call...I havent had a chance to experiment any more today, but does a new email or text notification "wake-up" the screen while in a call? If thats the case..hey apple..disable that!

    I'm pretty sure that's not the case.

  • Firefox sometimes does not allow me to complete an online purchase. I thought it was a website issue, but now wonder if relates to Firefox or Add-ons.

    <blockquote>Locking duplicate thread.<br>
    Please continue here: [[/questions/926176]]</blockquote>
    Yesterday I tried ordering from walmart.com and selected and edited my order with ease. When I clicked on "Check out now and Place Order" I was re=cycled back to the same order page and could not finish my order. I then tried with Safari and completed my order with no problems. This has happened on other websites occasionally, and I need to know if it is something in Firefox or my Add-ons that I need to adjust to keep this from happening. Thank you for any assistance, I am an old grandpa with much appreciation for, but with little savvy of, the computer world.

    sir,
    i feel very much proud to get ur post
    r u upgrade the firefox 11 to 12?
    it seems that upgrading to
    firefox 12 has many problem.
    Most of the people have problem
    after upgrading firefox 12. Most
    of the time the upgrade from
    firefox 11 to 12 not successful.so
    the problem has occure. I
    recommend u to download
    Firefox 12 from mozilla.org and
    install it. It is the easiest way to
    solve ur problem. There are many
    other ways to solve the
    problem.but the easiest way is
    this.
    First,uninstall ur firefox.
    Then download the latest version of firefox from mozilla.org.install it and browse.
    If not solve,just leave a reply.
    Thanks a lot.

  • I keep crashing. thought it was a add on but now it isnt. I got these two crash reports. bp-b58733f9-1bd5-4dcf-b103-2095621205125/12/201210:27 AMbp-6d911984-eb7

    firefox keeps crashing. I uninstalled and reinstalled and took off add ons which I thought were the problem. It is still crashing.

    Perform the suggestions mentioned below:
    1) Restart your Windows in Safe Mode as described in the following article:
    * http://www.microsoft.com/resources/documentation/windows/xp/all/proddocs/en-us/boot_failsafe.mspx?mfr=true
    2) Uninstall Firefox as described in this article -> [[Uninstalling Firefox]]
    * Restart your system
    3) Download latest Firefox version from the following link using some other Web Browser:
    * http://www.mozilla.com/en-US/firefox/new/
    4) Install Firefox 12 as described in this article -> [[Installing Firefox on Windows]]
    * DON'T START FIREFOX YET
    5) Create a New Firefox Profile as described in the following article:
    * [[Basic Troubleshooting#w_8-make-a-new-profile|Basic Troubleshooting - Make a New Profile]]
    * Now start Firefox using this newly created profile.
    Check and tell if its working.
    -> IF that New Profile works then you can recover your History, Bookmarks and Passwords from the Old Profile.
    * [[Recovering important data from an old profile]]

  • I can't be the only person who has this problem - when a month ends on a Saturday I can't drag events into the next month and instead have to cut and paste - a real pain in the butt. I thought there was something called "scroll" but I can't find that

    I can't be the only person who has this problem with iCal- when a month ends on a Saturday I can't drag events into the next month and instead have to cut and paste - a real pain in the butt. I thought there was something called "scroll" but I can't find that.

    Yeah that works, but, it involves a click on the event, a click on edit, a click on the date, keystrokes, plus, since you can't see the next month you have to have a calendar in front of you so as to put it to the right date. It's easier just to cut it and advance the month and paste it, once you are in the right month you can move it around helter skelter willy nilly no problems. Although now that you mention it I will try it, maybe it is easier than cut and paste as I don't really care about the date, as long as it gets moved into the right month I can drag it around all I want.

  • Good evening, my name is Ludmila I have a problem. im buy second hand iphone 5 but I can not use the screen shows asking me apple id but I do not know this is my first iphone I do not know what the police thought it was stolen or lost but I you can help m

    Good evening, my name is Ludmila I have a problem. im buy second hand iphone 5 but I can not use the screen shows asking me apple id but I do not know this is my first iphone I do not know what the police thought it was stolen or lost but I you can help me. Someone told me we should stop function Find my iphone but how?? email does not even know the first lord. It cost me 400 euros but may not use iphone. someone laugh at me because I deceived. Please help me tell me his email talk to you should stop off iCloud or ID

    Scuzati de engleza google translate

  • I thought I was installing an update and now iTunes will not open? HELP!!!!!, I thought I was installing an update and now iTunes will not open? HELP!!!!!

    I thought I was installing an update and now iTunes will not open on my computer... HELP!!!!

    Others are more likely to help if you stop needlessly repeating yourself and provide some details.
    What operating system? Windows (XP, Vista, 7) Mac
    Any errors?
    Also, try doing a search either here or via Google, you are more likely to get a faster resolution as there is no need to wait on others to respond.    

  • I accidentally erased my keychain passwords, how can I replace it?  I thought I was deleting one account but it deleted everything.  I now keep getting pop-ups asking me for a keychain password...which I don't remember ever creating.

    I accidentally erased my keychain passwords, how can I replace it?  ( I was in the keychains folder on the password link when i pressed delete). I thought I was deleting one account but it deleted everything.  I now keep getting pop-ups asking me for a keychain password...which I don't remember ever creating.

    Try running Keychain Access/First Aid and resetting the original keychain.
    Keychain Reset
    Keychain Issues - Resolve  see post by Kappy

  • I added a custom ringtone . Then later I tried to add another three set  but now after sync . Am not able to get rid of the first one... It's still there as my custom ringtone. But my iPhone in iTunes shows all four... But the phone shows only one...?

    I added a custom ringtone . Then later I tried to add another three set  but now after sync . Am not able to get rid of the first one... It's still there as my custom ringtone. But my iPhone in iTunes shows all four... But the phone shows only one...?

    Paul--you are a life-saver!! Worked great. I did have to look around to make sure I was getting 4.9 instead of 4.7 (even when the file was named 4.9 at techspot.com), but I finally got the right file, did the install as you suggested, and everything is now fine. One note, though, that I haven't seen mentioned in any of this thread: when I first tried to open up iTunes after getting back to 4.9, the following message appeared: "The file iTunes Library.itl cannot be read because it was created by a newer version of iTunes." I merely went to the old .itl file that was created when I did the update to iTunes 5, renamed it, moved it over to my now new 4.9, and iTunes opened fine. My library was a few days out of date, because of the few days' lag from the time I did the iTunes update, but that was easily taken care of, and everything's now working fine. Thanks again!!!

  • I created a slide show in imovie for my daughters 21st with voice overs from friends and family which was all working fine but now the voice recordings are not playing at all.  Obviously some setting has changed but I can't find which one.

    I created a slide show in imovie for my daughters 21st with voice overs from friends and family which was all working fine but now the voice recordings are not playing at all.  Obviously some setting has changed but I can't find which one.

    I created a slide show in imovie for my daughters 21st with voice overs from friends and family which was all working fine but now the voice recordings are not playing at all.  Obviously some setting has changed but I can't find which one.

  • The synchronisation of my iphone on my mac is during so long, why? before it was not so long but now the 3rd step is very long (it's synchronisation of buys)

    he synchronisation of my iphone on my mac is during so long, why? before it was not so long but now the 3rd step is very long (it's synchronisation of buys).
    thank you

    Contact the carrier... ability to receive government alerts is controlled by the carrier settings.
    Does TMO even officially support the iPhone 4?

  • How do u get help from apple support with iChat? I was able to chat with support last week to solve my problem but now the same issue is back and I don't see the option to chat now?

    qHow do u get help from apple support with iChat? I was able to chat with support last week to solve my problem but now the same issue is back and I don't see the option to chat now?

    For what it is worth I have noticed a similar issue from the iPad3 while at work and home. At work we have two Apple TV 3rd Generation installed and tied to our A/V system. I believe the issue has to do with a timeout on the broadcast saying "here I am" and allowing devices to connect.
    For example:
    At work we have several Wi-Fi SSID being broadcast from Cisco APs. The only one we can use with the Apple TV is the one that uses a WEP since the others are either setup to be hidden, require web page authentication, or have a login requirement from employees. Essentially, what I believe the issue is that the Apple TV periodically broadcasts a message to other iOS devices that support Mirroring. When the Apple TV does not get a response from a device it goes into a dormant mode and requires either a command from the remote control or a reboot. This has been tested with both the power management enabled and not enabled with the same results.
    As for when I come home, the Apple TV3 has not seen the device in some time and therefore is not broadcasting it's location information. A simple click of the circle or menu keys on the remote will give it the command to start broadcasting again and allow the iPad3 to see the Apple TV. When trying to Home Share the computer can not play (iTunes 11, Win8RTM) until the Apple TV is awoken then it will show up for mirroing.
    This may or may not assist you but, it hopefully explains how the issue may be happening.

  • I'm new to boot camp and have always used Parallels which was easier to install but now I can't get my hands on Windows 8 for boot camp?  What do i do?

    I'm new to boot camp and have always used Parallels which was easier to install but now I can't get my hands on Windows 8 for boot camp?  What do i do?

    There is no Windows for Boot Camp. just buy a copy of Windows.

  • I was automating batch images but now when I do it is trying to save each raw photo as a jpeg

    I was automating batch images but now when I do it is trying to save each raw photo as a jpeg, how do I make it stop or is it a bug?
    The destination is marked "none". I've been doing this correctly all day so I don't know why it has started doing this! Help please

    Due to the current unavailability of clairvoyants and mind-readers in the forum, we respectfully request you supply sensible, complete details.
    BOILERPLATE TEXT:
    Note that this is boilerplate text.
    If you give complete and detailed information about your setup and the issue at hand,
    such as your platform (Mac or Win),
    exact versions of your OS, of Photoshop (not just "CS6", but something like CS6v.13.0.6) and of Bridge,
    your settings in Photoshop > Preference > Performance
    the type of file you were working on,
    machine specs, such as total installed RAM, scratch file HDs, total available HD space, video card specs, including total VRAM installed,
    what troubleshooting steps you have taken so far,
    what error message(s) you receive,
    if having issues opening raw files also the exact camera make and model that generated them,
    if you're having printing issues, indicate the exact make and model of your printer, paper size, image dimensions in pixels (so many pixels wide by so many pixels high). if going through a RIP, specify that too.
    A screen shot of your settings or of the image could be very helpful too,
    etc.,
    someone may be able to help you (not necessarily this poster, who is not a Windows user).
    Please read this FAQ for advice on how to ask your questions correctly for quicker and better answers:
    http://forums.adobe.com/thread/419981?tstart=0
    Thanks!

  • My AI program (CS5 Illustrator 15.1.0) will not open some PDFs. It was working just yesterday, but now will only open a PDF if the graphics of the PDF is visible in the box that appears in the lower left corner of the dialog box after you click Open. The

    My AI program (CS5 Illustrator 15.1.0) will not open some PDFs. It was working just yesterday, but now will only open a PDF if the graphics of the PDF is visible in the box that appears in the lower left corner of the dialog box after you click Open. The file size does not seem to matter. Any ideas?

    Hello Kathie,
    Sorry for the inconvenience that has caused to you.
    Please let me know if you have tried converting any other PDF to word with Reader.
    Alos, please sign up at "https://cloud.acrobat.com/" using your Adobe ID credentials. Click on 'ExportPDF' tab and upload the PDF that you want to convert to Word.
    Let me know if this converts fine.
    Hope to hear from you.
    regards,
    Anubha

Maybe you are looking for

  • Why will iTunes/App Store not let me download apps?

    Whenever I go to download any apps or songs whether they are free or not it says that there is a "billing problem with a previous purchase. Please update your payment method" so when I update my payment method to the correct details it says its wrong

  • How do I edit the search engine name in the Search bar?

    I just added the Oxford Dictionary to my list of search engines in the search bar. Only problem is that it doesn't say Oxford Dictionary. It says ONO. How can I edit this list of search engines so I can change the name to something more descriptive?

  • Requisition Release Procedure No longer working

    Hi expert! My client raised an incident regarding the PR release strategy. Their Requisition Release procedure is based on document type.The user that is creating the requisition has the option of choosing document type NB (Non Release Requisition) o

  • How to determine actual device activiation date?

    My Verizon plan has five phone lines.  Often we will grab an available two year renewals from one line and use it for another line.  My son noticed that his line line has a renewal coming up this fall and he wants to get a new phone.  I mentioned to

  • Create DVD backup

    It it possible to create a boot disk on CDROM, but this limits the size to 650 MB (roughly). Is it possible to make a boot disk in DVD format, and if so, can it be done by burning all the relevant files on a Win 2k DVD burner? Our rep is suggesting a