Ideal Surround Sound Mixing Levels for Music

Hi all,
When using Soundtrack Pro and you mix in Surround sound there are little dots by each speaker and there are more dots for how louder you want the sound to be by that speaker.
My earlier attempts at surround sound have finally worked but the music is so low in the rear speakers that you'd never hear it unless you put your ear to the speaker. Then again I don't want to up it too loud either.
Is there anyone that's familiar with professional audio editing that have any suggestions on typical ideal levels (in dots) by each speaker so that the music really fills the room?

Have you tried posting this question here...
http://discussions.apple.com/forum.jspa?forumID=743
Someone here may have answers, but the STP forum should have some core users with info as well.
K

Similar Messages

  • Surround Sound Mixing

    I am editing a concert and using 4 tracks of audio. 2 tracks come from the live mixing board and 2 come from the mics on the camera. I mixed the 4 audio channels in FCP and it sounds beautiful in stereo. Now I want to make a surround sound mix. I took the mixed audio into Soundtrack Pro and used the surround sound mixer for each channel. Imported back in FCP, burned a DVD, took it home and listened last night and it sounded pretty good but the crowd applause was not loud enough.
    I just need to know what the proper way to surround sound a concert would be. Should I do all my mixing in STP? Any help on this issue would be greatly appreciated. Thanks.

    Unlike film, there aren't too many rules when mixing 5.1 or surround in music. I would suggest you get a few concert DVDs or DVD-A or SAC-D music releases and listen to the many different approaches. Some are mostly stereo with ambience in the rear. Some are more what used to be called Quadraphonic, L,R,Ls,Rs, and some are more 5.1 like film with vocal in the C and selected music in L,R,Ls,Rs.
    Since you only have stereo and ambience you probably gonna have to stick with the stereo front, ambience rear approach unless you use some upmixing technology. You could also use reverb and delays to create more of a rear channel.

  • Surround Sound Mix

    I recently got a new computer, and I ported over my sound card, Audigy LS. I got the drivers "OK" and everything, it works. But I use ventrilo, and when I talk on my mic, it's all weird. B4 with the CD I was able to install something like a "Surround Sound Mixer" that had a bunch of different levels that I could change say the volume, or my input and what not, is there a way to download this by itself? Thx for any and all help!Message Edited by smp on 07-28-2005 09:42 PM

    If you want to treat left and right separately, like the left channel of your first pair is NOT hard left, then you should make dual mono versions, and then you will get a panner for each, one for the left, and one for the right. But if you want them hard left and right, you can either use the surround panner and put the dot center-forward and center-rearward, or you can assign the tracks to go discreet to outs 1-2 for the front, and 3-4 for the rear. But one dot in the center full forward will give you full stereo in the front. I also use the Quadro setting in the panner, as opposed to the 5.1 with a center channel, assuming of course that there isn't a center channel.

  • How to Marry Video to Surround Sound Mix?

    We're getting a surround sound mix from our post house and we have the choice of .AIFF, AC3, OMF, DAT. How can I take that mix and marry it to the video we have in order to make one MPEG 2 program stream file? And is Compressor the right app for it? Or should I use DVD Studio Pro? I'm reluctant to use DVDSP because we don't need .vob files, just a MPEG 2 video stream.

    I have often "married" AIF audio files to MPEG 2 video using only the Quicktime Player App (Pro license needed, though). I take the separate output files from Compressor and open each in Quicktime Player.
    Then Select All of the AIF file, copy, then click on the window for the MPEG 2 file and choose "Add to Selection & Scale" from the edit window, then save the MPEG 2 file. You can look at the movie properties of the MPEG2 file to verify that it now has an audio track. You should probably play it all through as well just to be sure it's not out of sync (I've never found that to be the case, though).
    Ok, so here are the caveats:
    Surround sound typically is an AC3 file and I don't think you can open those in Quicktime.
    Even if you can, I think AC3 has a rule about being evenly divisible (or something like that) so it rounds up or down on the time. That could lead to sync problems. The advantage with AIF in using output from Compressor files is, assuming they were exported to the batch correctly, you know they'll be the same time length and thus syncable.
    Finally, consider how you are distributing the file if not via DVD. Most people don't have MPEG 2 codecs with their Quicktime player. Even if the movie has a standard .mov extension, they will not be able to open MPEG2 movies with or without sound tracks. To make it playable for the masses you'll need to export the new movie using a more ubiquitous codec.
    But, overall, the marriage of MPEG2 and an audio track is easily done as described, above.
    Dual 2GHz PowerPC G5, Dual 500MHz PowerPC G4, G3 iBook   Mac OS X (10.4)  

  • Recording a surround sound cd/dvd for home theater

    I am trying to burn a 5.1 surround sound cd/dvd with different audio in each channel.  I have created the file without any problems and it will play on my computer in surround sound.  When I burn the cd/dvd (I have tried both) all of the audio plays in all channels. How do I burn the file onto a disc so that it will play correctly as surround sound in my home theater?

    I know this question was asked ages ago, but I'm sure others are probably looking for an answer too (as I was over a year ago, when I started working with Audition 3).
    In my experience, there is no way to directly export a functional 5.1 file from Audition.  You can surround mix a file using the surround panner, but you can't export in the file format used by most home theater systems (.ac3 - Dolby Surround Sound).  My solution was to track down a standalone encoder, although there may be pugins available to allow Audition to do this.  After surround mixing, I export to 5 mono wav files and then drop them into this absolutely ancient program called Soft Encode, which creates a single, interleaved .ac3 file out of my source files.  Then, I take the .ac3 file, create a blank video the same length, and use my video editor to burn them to a DVD.
    From what my research turned up, the reason Audition does not have the capability to export in .ac3 is because of the expense of licensing with Dolby.  I would love to see a more sophisticated surround panner in AA4, as well as the ability to natively export .ac3 files, but by the same token, I don't want to see a skyrocketing price, so I'm waiting to see what happens!

  • Surround sound headphone solution for iMac in Bootcamp/Windows 7

    Hi all
    I have a 27" iMac which, unfortunately, in Windows, outputs only in stereo (I have NO idea why).  It has no PCI option that I aware of.
    I like to game in Windows 7 (dual booted) and have in my possession:
    Creative X-Fi USB 5.1 soundcard (http://us.store.creative.com/Sound-Blaster-XFi-Surround-5.1/M/B0017QQQAE.htm);
    Turtle Beach Earforce DSS;
    AKG K271 Studio headphones.
    I am using the CMSS-3D software with the X-Fi and getting okay results.  I have also tried plugging in the Earforce DSS via the optical out on the X-Fi (with CMSS-3D off) and have two different results:
    Movies/DVDs, etc. the Earforce clicks into Dolby Digital mode;
    Games (Dead Space, Metro 2033, etc.), I get only the Pro Logic light coming on.
    I can't tell much difference between CMSS-3D and the Pro Logic on the Earforce so am debating getting rid of them both (not the headphones, I use them for music) and going for another solution, as I don't think I can really get a very good performance from these.  I previously owned Astro Mixamp and A40 headset and thought they sounded fantastic on 360, really helped on Battlefield Bad Company 2, etc.  What I am using now just doesn't seem to measure up.
    So, any thoughts?  Logitech G35?  One of the Sennheiser ones?
    Cheers!
    Steve

    I have a G35 and the surround works great in Windows 7 under Boot Camp.  The headphones will also work in a basic way with OS X, but you'll only get stereo since there is no Mac version of the software

  • How do I turn on surround sound (5.1) for all my iTunes items?

    In iTunes, while a video is playing, I can go to Controls/Audio and Subtitles and select English (Surround Audio). This allows the sound to work with my 5.1 Dolby Digital audio setup.
    It looks, though, like the only way to turn this on is to actually be playing the video. I have gone into iTunes and selected a whole set of videos, then selected the surround sound - but that didn't work. As soon as I played a video I hadn't played before, it was back to stereo, and I had to manually make the selection again. (Now, once I make the selection it sticks; I don't have to do it again. But, I still have to do it for each individual video.)
    How can I "turn on" surround sound for all items that have it?

    1. Double-click the Home button and swipe Task Bar to the right
    2. Check the volume and mute settings
    http://i1224.photobucket.com/albums/ee374/Diavonex/6d3191ba.jpg

  • Surround sound mix, have I got this right (CS6).

    OK, done some reading and this is what I think I need to do with my 6 WAV files.
    Channel 1 Left - Drag dot in surround pannier to top left.
    Channel 2 Right - Drag dot in surround pannier to top right.
    Channel 3 Centre - Drag dot in surround pannier to top left (and pan Centre percentage to 100%).
    Channel 4 Left Surround - Drag dot in surround pannier to bottom left.
    Channel 5 Right Surround - Drag dot in surround pannier to bottom right.
    Channel 6 LFE - Drag dot in surround pannier centre (and pan LFE to 0gb).
    Unless specified LFE and centre percent infinity db and 0%
    Does this sound correct?

    Channel 6 LFE - Drag dot in surround pannier centre (and pan LFE to 0gb).
    If you do this, there will be output on LFE and Front Left/Front Right, but there only should be output in LFE. If you pan Centre to 100% there will be output on LFE and Centre - that's also wrong. I also don't know how to get output ONLY on LFE!
    Besides, this is the right order for your Monos:
    1: Left
    2: Right
    3: Left Surround
    4: Right Surround
    5: Centre
    6. LFE

  • Which sound-mixing program (for multiple sounds)?[SOLVED]

    I'm looking at wiki here but there's tons of different software mixers and I don't know which one to go for. I think I use alsa-drivers for everything regarding sound and I want to play like; mplaye, xine-ui and xmms at the same time. Any suggestions?
    /Richard

    I just changed xmms to use ALSA and it's now mixing fine.
    jaboua wrote:Configure XMMS to use ALSA in that case. However, I thought OSS would work just as fine since the OSS emulation layer is over ALSA with dmix...
    I don't know what OSS emulation layer means but I'll check it up. Sounds useful!
    profoX wrote:Ps: my favourite audio players are
    1. mpd + mpygmy or ncmpc for Speed and Console
    2. amaroK for Looks and Features
    I'll check out mpd/mpygmy. I think I've tried amaroK back in Debian but it (if I rembember it correct) was pretty much overkill. I want like; playlists, shuffle function and a queue fumction. That's why I use xmms (and I'm an old Winamp/Windows user).
    Thanks for the help!
    Regards
    Richard
    [edit]
    082419/home/riwa# ncmpc
    error [15]: problems getting a response from "localhost" on port 6600 : Connection refused
    I also got:
    082149/home/riwa# mpd
    problem opening file "//.mpd/mpd.log" for writing
    [/edit]

  • Is TV2 suposed to recognise iTunes settings(eg. start, end, volume level)  for music videos ??

    I am trying to run music videos from iTunes to AppleTV2. But any of the settings I have made in iTunes agnats the music video (eg. Video start time, stop time, volume level) don't seem to be recognised by TV2. Is this correct ? If so, how do I control varying volumes levels when playing via TV2 ?

    I have this problem on occasion, below the song title and progress bar there are two symbols tap them 1 at a time and restart not sure witch one but one of them does this. I think the other causes the song to loop

  • Surround sound for A305-S6872

    Greetings!
    I want to use my computer to send a 5.1 surround sound signal to my Onkyo receiver. I have a headphone jack-sized SPDIF port, which I think allows for surround output.
    Additionally, when I tested my Realtek digital output device, the green lights go on but I have no sound (which I'm thinkin' may be a result of the wrong cables I'm using, headphone to RCA).
    What do I need and how do I make my computer output surround sound?
    Thanks!

    Surround sound mixing is done in Soundtrack Pro. FCP isn't capable of surround mixing.
    Shane

  • Surround Sound for Film

    I am mixing surround sound (5.1) for an independent feature film.  I will be mixing in Soundtrack Pro 3, then sending the file to the producer who is using Final Cut Studio Pro.  Ultimately the DVD will be burned in DVD Studio Pro.
    1.  I need to know the exact file transfer details.  What files types do I send from Soundtrack Pro to Final Cut, then from Final Cut to DVD Studio?  I want to make sure I'm not "re-enconding" anything, and that I ultimately end up with the correct file type on DVD.
    2.  I plan to do a separate stereo mix.  How do I make sure my DVD is encoded for a 5.1 surround mix, AND a stereo mix?

    I have the Artist Mix, the Artist Control, and the Transport. The transport controls don't work... they jump in approx 1-minute intervals instead of going frame-by-frame. Avid says I need to set up the systems on a static IP address. We'll see if that works. The transport control on the Artist Control surface is pitiful. The pan buttons on the Mix are unusable.

  • Critical Surround Sound bug in Logic 8

    Unlike many of you I purchased Logic 8 to do surround sound mixing. I liked the fact that it included Sound track Pro. I quickly realized after purchasing it that soundtrack pro had its limitations with regard to doing full audio post for film projects that i am accustomed to doing here in Los Angeles. I turned to Logic as an alternative only to find out that the surround panner is inadequate and somewhat limited when trying to automate it. The issue is that when trying to do a 360 degree pan counter clockwise the node reverses itself clockwise once you cross the 180 degree position in the plane or center of the rear speakers and then continues its counter clockwise 360 degree path. This causes a noticeable stutter in the audio as there is a 1 to 2 millisecond delay that occurs. This also occurs when moving the node from left to right across the rear speakers. I have posted this message to bring attention to this issue in hopes of getting this resolved quickly. I have used many surround sound programs and this is the first time that i have ever encountered this type of problem.

    DJWillis wrote:
    Since this morphed a little into a Logic vs PT threads as for benefits and drawback, one question always occurs to me when I see any post on surround sound: do you know ANYONE who has a surround sound system in their home who is just a regular consumer, and not a pro audio person testing a mix?
    I don't. Surround sound is only for theatrical releases, and it's just small component of seeing a film. No one goes or doesn't go to a movie because it does or doesn't have dolby blah blah surround up the wazoo! Who cares? No one. They just want to see a good movie.
    I'm always amazed that this marketing gimmick has had any impact. I mix music in stereo. Period. When I edit movies I edit in stereo. Period. No one has ever asked for surround for delivery. But then again, I won't work for the studios.
    Surround sound is like 3-D movies -- pretty silly and extraneous to the entertainment experience. (I just saw "Coraline" last night -- my date and I were underwhelmed. It was nice -- but nothing earth-shattering, and hardly worth the whole 3-D effort.)
    Sorry to rant, but it's all just so silly. Going from mono to stereo was awesome I'm sure in its day. Same for going from black & white to color and silent to sound. And from VHS to DVD.
    But from stereo to surround? Pass. I'm not stringing up a bunch of speakers around the living room because my life is so boring I need to hear sounds behind me when I'm watching a movie!
    Hi DJ,
    My next door neighbor has a 7.1 system, and has a few audio-only titles. He wishes there were more.
    My uncle, a general contractor, also has a 5.1 system in his home, and mostly watches movies with it. He does have an Eagles concert DVD in surround, and likes it a lot.
    When I went to Circuit City, which is going out of business, I asked the pro sound guy what was flying off the shelves, and he stated two things : cameras, and surround theater systems.
    As to your statement in red, you should probably become a member of either the NARAS, or the AES, they have both conducted research, with doctors both of physics and medicine, about what is more important, both consciously, and sub-consciously, to a human observer, when viewing a moving picture, both with and without sound.
    Both guilds agreed that the sound was more important in judging the realism, and therefore what was believed, than any picture without sound, or an picture with poor sound. The determining factor for when an observer was more involved in the experience always ended up being related to the sound, and it's quality, or lack thereof.
    And this research was done a while ago. A nice Canadian fellow has been conducting research on this since 1969 :
    http://www.psych.mcgill.ca/labs/auditory/laboratory.html
    And his book :
    http://www.psych.mcgill.ca/labs/auditory/book.html
    Let me know if it's too deep for ya... I'll try to find something a little less technical.
    Cheers

  • Sound effect licensed for commercial use?

    Are the sound effects licensed for commercial and distribution usage? thanks.
      Mac OS X (10.4.10)  

    Found this eventually.
    http://images.apple.com/finalcutstudio/docs/20070415FinalCut_Studio_2_ProductOverview.pdf
    On page 44 of that apple PDF it states:
    “Soundtrack Pro 2 includes a library of more than 1000 royalty-free surround music beds and sound effects. These professionally produced and recorded elements make it easy
    to get started fast and keep quality high when you create a surround sound mix. The library also includes 5000 royalty-free Foley, sound effect, and music segments for stereo use. Easily add third-party music and effect libraries when you want more options.”

  • Apac an surround sound - easy one, hopefully...

    I'm moments from making my first surround sound mix with Apac, and was wondering in a 5.1 mix which speakers the dialogue tracks should go to? ie just the front Right and Left, or these two plus the center, or all, or what?
    Also, I'm reasoning the way to do it is to export to aif the dialogue and Left speaker mix, then export the dialogue with right speaker mix, etc. OR can I simply export just the dialogue, and in Apac place both the dialogue AND left speaker sound (for example) in the left speaker box? Which is the best way to go about this?
    Any help would be appreciated.
    Thank you!!

    From your description, it sounds like you're not working with discrete stems (which a sound designer would give you so that they include the appropriate dialogue, effects, and music for each channel). Instead, it seems like you're exporting 2 channel audio from FCP. (am I right here?)
    If that is the case, I'd recommend that you simply create a 2.0 mix in A.pack. (the viewer's playback setup [his/her receiver] can then use it's processing to fill the soundscape). In my experience, if you create a 5.1 mix from a 2 channel mix in FCP, all you end up doing is wasting space (and doubling up audio channels).
    Of course, if you do have stems (and all my rambling was based on an incorrect presumption , please detail those a little bit more.

Maybe you are looking for