If people are shouting that FCPX isn't 'pro'. Can an update fix it?

Oke, I've read through a great deal of feedback on these forums now.
I see some comments:
1) Lack of import options
2) MPG2 support
3) Plugin support
4) Whatever more
Now my question is: CAN AN UPDATE FIX THIS?
Say that Apple can fix most complaints in an update, would you be happy then?
YES: Then the foundation for FCPX is good enough and I'll wait for an update
NO: Then it really is unfixable and 'as you call it', an iMovie+, beyond resque. In that case i'll look further

MPEG2 is terrible to edit with, but native support for it could be helpful in some situations (say you need to quickly pull footage off of a DVD without major hassle), but I see that as more of a luxury—it wasn't supported natively in FCP7, and I never really missed it.
The real question is how long it takes Apple to reinstate the functionality that was lost in the switch from 7 to X—and more importantly IF they decide to reinstate the functionality that we need. I think probably XML interchange (or something like it) will be coming soon, and multicam shortly thereafter. Third parties will start writing plugins for the new architecture, so my guess is that legacy FXPlug plugins will never be supported. Still, there's a huge laundry list of things that FCPX can't do right now, and it seems generous to think that all that functionality could be added back even within 18 months' time—and by then, FCP7 will be nearly four years old and crawling around on its hands and knees.
Other things, I'm not sure I can imagine them being fixed. The new interface seems to discourage organizing audio into tracks (as in, Dialogue 1, Music, SFX, etc.), so my guess is that OMF support will always be sketchy at best, and probably only offered as a paid third-party option. The interface seems to defy customizability, and I can't see Apple devoting the resources that would be required to fix that. External monitoring is a bit of a wildcard. It's such a glaring omission that Apple may have to include it, but it's also possible that they'll leave it up to third parties to develop ways to monitor out (for an additional cost, of course).
There's also the question of whether these will be free updates, or whether additional functionality from Apple will be priced a-la-carte, driving the cost of a working NLE back up to $800-1200, where it used to be. I'm willing to pay more than $300 for a good 64-bit version of FCP, but I've already sunk thousands into FCP, and the lack of a direct upgrade path really irks me.
Again, this is all provided that Apple decides to give us the features we need.
What it boils down to for me is the attitude with which Apple has treated this release—with an utter lack of disrespect for the people that depend on FCP for serious—and COLLABORATIVE—work, handing off timelines to Da Vinci colorists and Flame artists, shooting EDLs off to negative cutters, that sort of thing. Apple's response to our concerns so far has been worse than dismissive, and that alone is enough to make me want to switch to Premiere.

Similar Messages

  • Hi, i am using iphone 4. People are complaining that they can't hear my voice while talking to them? Pls help

    hi, i am using iphone 4. People are complaining that they can't hear my voice while talking to them? Pls help

    My son had the same problem with his 4 after updateing to 5.1.1. Apple would not replace it and he ended up getting a re-furb for £119.00.
    He was 100% sure it was the upgrade that caused it but apple said it was the motherboard.

  • I need internet explorer 5.5 or greater in order to use an online course. I can see that there isn't a mac explorer update but is there another way? I tried the wine bottler app and it didn't work for me.

    I need internet explorer 5.5 or greater in order to use an online course. I can see that there isn't a mac explorer update but is there another way? I tried the wine bottler app and it didn't work for me.

    Buy and install Windows.
    Then you have IE
    Of course you can always do as I do when some idiot, usually with the government, tell me I need to IE. I say no. After saying no enough times they mail me a form.
    I don't believe in Microsoft.
    Allan

  • HT1688 ok i have a iphone 3 and there are some things that is wrong with it can it be fixed and if so where or who do i talk to

    i have a iphone 3 and there is things wrong with it can it be fixed and who do i talk to to get it fixed

    Apple does not repair iPhones, but will replace the entire iPhone for a flat fee; see the Service Pricing section here:
    http://www.apple.com/support/iphone/service/faq/
    There are independent iPhone repair services that may be able to do a repair for less, though of course it depends on what's wrong with it. Do a web search for "iPhone repair". Note, though, that if you elect to have the iPhone serviced by an unauthorized shop, all further support from Apple will be voided.
    The iPhone 3G is pretty old now by smartphone standards, though, so you might want to consider putting your money toward a new, or at least newer, iPhone rather than spending to repair your current unit.
    Regards.

  • HT2623 people are reporting that my mobile me email address is bouncing back emails.  please help!

    I am not recieving some important emails from multiple sources, some are being bounced back and others appear to be going through but i'm noit recieving them.  What can I do to fix this issue?
    thanks

    Did you migrate your MobileMe account to iCloud in August last year? Or did you open an iCloud account when it was first available? 
    Do you have a functioning @icloud.com version of the @me.com address? - please send yourself a message to that and see what happens.
    Can you log in with this address at http://icloud.com ?

  • I have 2 laptops, 2 desktops and an I Phone all are supposed to be authorized but it tells me that one isn't and can't because I am used all 5 of my authorizations.  I have a theory of what is going wrong but I am unsure how to fixe it.

    I need to free up an authorization for one of my current computers; I am using 4 but it tells me I am using 5.

    Use the Deauthorize All command documented in this article. If that's not an option, use the 'contact iTunes Store support' link at the bottom of it.
    (109077)

  • HT1657 I've rented Argo on my mac pro and it keeps saying that the file is corrupted, now I canot see my movie or download/watch in any other Mac that I have. How can I either fix it or watch it in another device?

    I've rented Argo movie and my mac pro keeps saying that it is corrupted. Now I cannot watch or download it in any other device and I'm stucked with this file in my mac pro. How can i start it over or just get my money back and dowload it again using my Apple TV or any other device?

    If the download is corrupt then you will need to contact iTunes support - rentals are currently a one-time only download, so you will need to contact support to refund/credit or grant you a re-download.
    Try the 'report a problem' link from your purchase history : log into your account on your computer's iTunes via Store > View My Account (Store > View My Apple ID on iTunes 11) and you should then see a Purchase History section with a 'see all' link to the right of it ; click on that and you should see a list of your purchases ; find that rental and use the 'Report a Problem' link and fill in details about the problem (iTunes support should reply within, I think, about 24 hours).
    If that process doesn't work (it's been taking people to this site on a browser instead of showing a form in iTunes), then you can try contacting iTunes support via this page instead : http://www.apple.com/support/itunes/contact/- click on Contact iTunes Store Support on the right-hand side of the page.

  • When opening Photoshop CS2, the Toolbar & Palettes are small and hard to read. Can this be fixed?

    When I open Photoshop CS2, the Toolbar and Palettes are quite small and hard to read. Can I correct this and if yes, how?

    You can also change the UI Font size in photoshop cs2 under Edit>Preferences>General, but that
    just makes some of text bigger and not any of the icons.

  • Someone is trying to sell me a iphone 4s from a carrier that I am not on, Can it be fixed to work on my network

    I am with AT&T, but this person is on West Central Wireless in Texas. Is it possible to change this iphone 4s to work with all features, including data?

    The process is contact the current network supplier .
    Ask IF they offer unlocking.
    IF yes request the unlock and pay any fees requested.
    Your network supplier then contacts Apple to request the White listing (Unlocking) of your phone on the iTunes servers.
    Apple do this -It takes anything from 3 days to several weeks to complete.
    On completion Apple confirms this back to your Network supplier (NOT YOU)
    Your network supplier contacts you via email or SMS inviting you to connect your iPhone with your computer via the supplied USB cable and launch iTunes and follow on screen prompts through to the "Congratulations your iPhone is now unlocked" screen.
    All these steps need to be carried out with the ORIGINAL SIM and by REGISTERED account holder used when setting up the phone.
    Once the Congats...... screen has been reached you can swap out the REGISTERED SIM and replace with a compatable SIM on another network.
    CAVEATS
    Only the original SIM and Account holder can initiate an unlock- If you bought the phone used/second hand you CAN NOT UNLOCK through official routes
    Once unlocked use of a Mobile Virtual Network SIM may result in difficulties sending SMS messages.
    You may have to go into Setting /Network/Cellular/Cellular Data Network and enter the correct settings manually.
    Further caveat Cellular Data Network menu is SIM card dependant if its not supported you CAN NOT change the settings manually then you may need to contact the SIM card company - They can send a setup SMS if they support this process.
    PRESEE -
    ONLY REGISTERED ACCOUNT HOLDER AND SIM CARD CAN BE USED TO UNLOCK THROUGH OFFICAL ROUTES
    ANYONE SELLING THEIR IPHONE SHOULD UNLOCK THE DEVICE BEFORE SELLING ON

  • I have a mac mini that has os 5.8, can i update to snow lepord?

    I have an old mac mini with on OS 5.8, c I update to snow lepord?  Bought a new printer and it needs 6.0 as a minimum.

    Choose About this Mac from the Apple menu and check the processor.
    If it's a PowerPC Mac, it's already running the newest OS it can.
    If it's an Intel Mac, click here, buy the DVD, back up your system, install it, and run Software Update.
    (102940)

  • Using Verizon Messaging and people are not receiving my texts NOR am I receiving texts that were sent to me!  Went to old iphone and disabled imessaging but still not working. I'm a big texter for personal and business and am ready to go back to iPhone. 

    Just got the Samsung Galaxy s5 and am very frustrated that I am not receiving text messages that were supposedly sent to me.  Also, it says 'sent' but it is never delivered.  Or it might get delivered but mine still just shows being sent.  I re-started that phone and disabled my texting on my old iphone as some have suggested.  I'm ready to go back to the iphone just because of this issue.  Please fix this Verizon!

    I'll tell you it is some marketing coup that a problem Apple has created and has control over is being passed off on Verizon.
    This problem is the result of you migrating from iMessage, a messaging platform controlled completely by Apple, back to a more mainstream messaging system of SMS/MMS. Verizon has no control over other iPhones "thinking" you are still using iMessage. NOTHING Verizon can do will fix this problem.
    Try texting the word "stop" to 48369. Others have reported this has worked. Doing this should de-register your number with the iMessage system. You should receive a confirmation reply. It may take a day or 2 for other iPhones to completely register that your number is no longer associated with iMessage. You can also try calling Apple support and let them know you are not receiving messages from iPhone users after switching to an android phone from an iPhone.

  • For the People Who Say That Creative Is Taking Their Money and That Apple Is Better.

    I was just browsing the Apple site (gotta' keep up with the competition) and found this page. Pay close attention to the overview of the ratings and how people are complaining that Apple is gouging at their wallets.

    Well, I understand the reason Creative took the charger out of the Micro box was that Apple didn't have one and they could reduce the cost by taking it out.
    There's one advantage the Micro has over the iPod in the charger game: Since there are cell-phone or similar chargers that use mini-B ports like the Micro (RAZR, BlackBerry, Audiovox SMT5600, and others), it's easier to find cheap third-party chargers for the Micro than for the iPod. (Most third-party iPod chargers are part of more complex accessories that cost even more.)

  • HT4191 Notes are being stored as messages in Outlook.  Can this be fixed?

    Notes are being stored as messages in Outlook -- can this be fixed so they stay as notes rather than being converted to HTML message items stored in the Outlook Notes folder?
    I've got an iPad that syncs its notes up to the IMAP Notes folder on Exchange server (Outlook) as HTML messages and an Android "phablet" that syncs Notes between the device and Exchange server as true Exchange/Outlook Notes items.  Due to the conversion of these iPad notes to Exchange/Outlook formatted-as-HTML-messages-notes they are not detected as real Outlook Notes and don't get synched to my Android.  So the Android synchs notes fine back and forth to Exchange/Outlook and they resulting Notes are Note-type items in Exchange.
    The problem is that the iPad is converting these notes to message-type items and thus making notes unsynchable between the Android and the iPad.
    Any ideas how to make the IMAP-based synching of notes back to Exchange not corrupt the note format would be appreciated.
    thx, t.

    You can do a check for corrupted fonts and other font issues:
    * http://www.thexlab.com/faqs/multipleappsquit.html - Font Book 2.0 Help: Checking for damaged fonts
    * http://www.creativetechs.com/iq/garbled_fonts_troubleshooting_guide.html

  • TS3824 My 2006 iMac has vertical lines that wont disappear - can this be fixed?

    My 2006 model iMac has vertical lines on the monitor that won't go away and are growing more all the time. Can this be fixed? I was told about the iMac Graphics Firmware Update but it doesn't work on my model - seems to be from 2011 models. Any suggestions?

    Hello,
    Have you blown the dust out lately?
    Get Temperature Monitor to see if it's heat related...
    http://www.macupdate.com/info.php/id/12381/temperature-monitor
    Take a screen shot & view that in Preview, move the Preview window around, if you see double lines it's a Video card/VRAM problem, if the lines do not move moving the pic around then it's the LCD or cable.

  • HT6030 Help!  I upgraded to Maverick and my emails are now really messed up.  It flagged over 5,000 messages when I haven't flagged anything.  Now, the email message that people are sending me is actually an email message from years ago.  Any explanations

    Help!  I upgraded to Maverick and now my emails are really messed up.  It flagged over 5,000 emails that I have never flagged.  Now, it shows a message from someone this morning, but the content is an email that I received years ago.  My Iphone and Ipad are fine.  Any ideas?  I can't read mail off of my macbook because the email isn't what these people are sending!  Help!

    Thanks one again. I know you helped me the last to. I do have the Deja Vu font set in my folder. I downloaded and the last time. So I don't know if there is supposed to be more or not, but those were installed with Windows-XP after my reformat.
    This is really driving me nuts. as I've done several re-formats on my computer and several friends computers and even upgraded hardware so I am not necessarily a software or programming expert, I am somewhat advanced when it comes to computers in general and can usually diagnose the problem but these font's are the problem and they never were before.
    I did see in another forum that if you had a Dell Computer and did the Microsoft update for the onboard video card driver that it could be the culprit, but I have that disabled being I have a much better graphics card so the updates from Microsoft for the onboard video weren't installed.
    It' a Dell Dimension 3000 with an Intel(R) 82865G Graphics Controller so I don't believe it is the culprit being it is disabled. The actual video card that I am using is a PCI Nvidia GeForce 9400 GT with 1 GB Memory. And I didn't have any problem before.
    I appreciate the help. But still can't get things to work. Live Help Chat doesn't open for another two hours so maybe they can do "Remote Access" or something and can check setting and help me. But if you come up with other suggestions, they would be greatly appreciated.
    Thanks again.
    Susan

Maybe you are looking for

  • My apple menu has disappeared

    This is incredibly frustrating. I am absolutely not in full screen mode, my problem is not related to any applications, or Safari, or any of that nonsense. When I logged in to my account it seemed as if everything was zoomed in, my Macintosh HD icon

  • TextEdit - "lower-case" an upper-case string?

    I'm using TextEdit to draft postings for my favourite blogs. And I'm forever accidentally pushing the caps-lock down on my PB, resulting in a long upper case string. I used to use BBEdit on Classic for my text drafting purposes. It had a very handy '

  • OrionRemoteException: Error (de-)serializing object

    Hi all, I am using Oracle Application Server 10g Release 1 and I am trying to deploy My Application on Oracle As. In My Application One EJB calling Another EJB. while calling time i am getting this exception. com.evermind.server.rmi.OrionRemoteExcept

  • Any scanning software suggestions?

    Have HP G4010 Scanner and would like to try software other than IMage Capture or the preferences option. Do you have any suggestions. The old HP sw was quite nice but stopped operating several operating systems ago and HP is no help.

  • Z1 Unable to fast forward/rewind music

    I wondered if anyone could help me with this. Within the Sony Walkman app the function 'Press and hold' to fast forward or rewind doesnt work. When you use this feature on my phone it just skips tracks on release of the button regardless of the lengt