IMac which one with FCP 5.1.4 ?

Hello, I have been using a Powerboog G4 with my FCP no problem so anything would be better!!
Now that I have FCP Studio with Motion and would like to to upgrade. Can't afford a tower... So I'm getting an iMac but I'm stock with which modeel and graphics card is best.
The 20" it comes with 2 400firewires, the 24" with one 400 and one 800 firewire. Save the money or spent an extra $500??
I edit DV from a Panasonic DVX100. Except for Motion I have no other need for a super duper video.
Three options ( withstudent discount)
$1,900:
iMac-20", 2.33GHz, 2GB SDRAM, ATI Radeom x1600/256MB-VRAM
$2,336:
iMac-24", 2.33GHz, 2GB SDRAM, NAVIDIA GeForce7300 GTO/128MB-SDRAM
$2,449:
same as aboe 24" but w/NVIDIA GeForce 7600 GT 256MB SDRAM
To the above I have to add Apple care plan. If I get the more affordable option I can also buy an exteranl drive. with the other option, I'll wait.
Thank you in advance for your feedback.
iMac Mac OS X (10.4.8)

It's always advisable to get the best that you can afford, but if you're going for the imac, you need an external drive so I'd recommend going for the middle option with a decent external HD.
Have you absolutely checked that you can't source maybe one of the earlier Mac Pro models via an authorized reseller or maybe the apple refurb store (the refurb store currently has one at $2199, I'm sure you could find one cheaper).
The imac is compromised in terms of expandability - do a search on this forum for more details.
Having said that, I coped for a couple of years with FCP 4.5 and a G4 imac and an external HD with no probs, so if you can cope without the expandability and you'll be sticking with SD you'll be OK - don't forget FCP 6 is just around the corner and you'll have to check the system requirements carefully to see if it'll run on an imac should you decide to take this route.

Similar Messages

  • Please could somebody help me I have an iMac which came with Tiger 10.4.10 installed I have lost my disks and I need to re-install after a hard drive failure. Where can I find this? I will upgrade to Snow Leopard after but I cannot go straight to SL

    Please could somebody help me I have an iMac which came with Tiger 10.4.10 installed I have lost my disks and I need to re-install after a hard drive failure. Where can I find this? I will upgrade to Snow Leopard after but I cannot go straight to SL

    You can go strait to SL, all you need is a retail SL DVD available from Apple for $20. The US online store has them at:
    http://store.apple.com/us/product/MC573Z/A/mac-os-x-106-snow-leopard

  • How do you format/reinstall Lion on an iMac which came with no disc?

    Hi,
    How do  you format and reinstall Lion on a iMac which came with no disc? It was purchased new from an Apple store but came with no disc.

    https://discussions.apple.com/thread/4177979 - Reinstalling Lion on a computer that originally came with Lion installed.
    How to deal with future problems without a Lion Install Disk - https://discussions.apple.com/thread/3552183
    How to reinstall Lion on a new drive? - https://discussions.apple.com/thread/3570140

  • Need to get an external DVD player for Imac, which one?

    Hey (again),
    I've had a terrible time getting my imac up and running properly since I got it back from its HD replacement yesterday.
    It's gotten to the point where I'm going to wipe the system and then do a time machine reinstall.
    My problem is that my imacs dvd player doesn't play DVD's anymore, it just spits out the install DVD. Could I use any cheap external DVD (usb) drive and wipe and install my OS from there or does it need to be in the internal one? I found a couple of really cheap ones that I'm wondering would do the trick or does it need to be a specific brand?
    Or do I need to have my imac which is out of warranty serviced and have the original dvd player replaced?
    Any input on this is greatly appreciated.

    In my experience just about any external DVD drive works. I've found them way cheaper at a big technology store like "Fry's".

  • Imac or powerbook with FCP?

    Hello neighbors, I am looking forward to buy a new MAC for editing in FCP, I have a budget for about 2,500. I was thinking an imac 20" with a 250GB drive or a Powerbook 15" with a 100GB drive. I also heard that imac frezees to much in pro applications because of all the integrated components on the same monitor. Is this true? I own a Powermac G5 sp/1.8 therefor I want something different. Any opinions? Thanks

    Neither is advised by me.
    Seriously, the iMac has a single firewire bus and no means to add a second one.
    That means your firewire drive, and camera/deck share a single firewire bus, which has presented issues with users.
    The PB is a slightly better choice because it is a 15-inch which means it has PC Card slot to add a Cardbus firewire card to create a second firewire bus.
    If these are the only alternatives get the 15-inch PB with a cardbus firewire card, and 7200 rpm hitachi in a firewire enclosure.
    Never heard anything about freezes as you stated

  • NVIDIA GeForce GTX 775M or 780M iMac, which one to choose for PS CS6?

    Hi,
    I'm planning to buy a new iMac 27", 16MB, 3 TB fusion drive. But for the graphics I don't know (and cannot find) what is best (would be sufficient) for Photoshop CS6 (and Lightroom-5). Would the standard GeForce GTX 775M 2GB be enough for my use or will the GeForce GTX 780M 4GB give a really better performance? It’s not the budget that’s holding me, but sometimes you get too much unused power in your Mac. I use Photoshop and Lightroom for (sometimes extensive) photo editing and not for video or 3D.
    Murk

    Musch Imac,
    Did you ever post your findings?
    I'm in a similar situation.  I want to get a new Imac in the very near future (few weeks max).
    The areas i'm not sure about getting as options are:
    1) I5 vs. I7 -> tho leaning towards I7
    2) Nvidia GPU 775m 2gb vs. 780m 4gb  -> tho leaning towards 775m
    From my research if I go with the I7 then I could probably skimp on the GPU and get the 2GB 775M
    Currently I do not nor do I plan on any gaming.   Photo and video editing is at a bare minimum - HOWEVER, photo and video editing is something I'm interested in and would like to pursue.  With the Imac, once you buy it, you can NOT change or upgrade.  So i'm thinking better to be safe than sorry.
    Having said that, do my poins 1 and 2 above make better sense?
    Thanks,

  • Updates for Final Cut Studio, Quicktime, and OS X on new iMac?  Which ones?

    Hello All,
    Okay, so I have been searching through the forums about updates for all the software updates, and which ones work and which ones don't. The Tiger vs. Leopard battle. The ones that have had no problems doing all the updates and the ones who are suffering terribly. But it is really hard to pinpoint everything since it is all spread out over so many different pages. So I am hoping that this question will be of benefit to others in my situation.
    So I have a new iMac Alu 24" 2.4 ghz, and 4 gig of RAM. I did software update for everything except the OS and not for Quicktime. So I am running OS X 10.4.10 and Quicktime 7.2
    I installed FCP Studio 2 without a hangup. I did not even bother to install Color because I knew that it would be more then this GPU could handle. I didn't bother with Live Type either. Don't use it at work and don't think it will be any different at home. So I intalled FCP 6, Compressor 3, Motion 3, Soundtrack 2, and DVD Studio 4. I have done no updates to any of the Studio programs. So I am looking for some opinions (more then one would be appreciated). What updates should I do and which ones should I avoid for my particular setup? I want to do this as right as I can the first time around.
    Again sorry, if this seems redundant, but I want to get everything together in one place to make sure that I don't miss something from split up forums. And hopefully this will help others. Sorry about the length.
    My Current Situation:
    Alu iMac 24" 2.4ghz, 4 gig of RAM
    OS X 10.4.10
    Quicktime 7.2
    Final Cut Pro 6.0
    Motion 3.0
    Compressor 3.0
    DVD Studio Pro 4.0
    Soundtrack Pro 2.0
    Which updates? If the almighty Shane Ross would like to step in, please feel free to. Thanks folks for any and all help.

    UPDATE: Okay, so I gave my Final Cut a really simple run through last night. Just shot some footage on the HV20 and imported it and did the Apple recommend workflow for the reverse telecine. (I know, I know, doing the full out reverse telecine to get it to 24p is unnecessary if I am just going back to video, but I just wanted to give it whirl) Anyways it worked, and it came out great. So I dropped into a 24p timeline and through it together, and no software malfunctions. No complaints. During log and capture, there was a lag between my player and the computer, but the footage after capture was right on targert (I am referring to audio sync).
    So as long as it works, I am happy. Besides, I don't plan on using on board audio too much since there are no XLR inputs unless I get a Beachtek. Different story, sorry.
    So currently, with absolutely no Studio updates, OS X 10.4.10, and QT 7.2, on a brand new iMac, 2.4ghz, 24", everything is as it should be. I'll keep checking back in to see if anyone recommends an update for me or if I encounter problems and what caused them.
    -Albert
    Message was edited by: JayEnder

  • What is the best way to manage multiple devices with one iMac - different users with seperate itunes accounts or one mac user with different itune logons and libraries?

    Hello
    I have just purchased an imac which I am very happy with.  In our household we also have two iphones (one mine and one husbands) and one ipod (my sons). We all have individual itunes accounts set up on our previous computer (not a mac). We have sepereate apps and music, although there may be the odd occasion where we would like to share a song (if this is possible) across devices.
    I am just wondering the best way to manage these devices using the new imac.  Should I create individual accounts to logon to the imac, then from within these launch our own itunes accounts and sync our devices with these.  Or should I be using one version of itunes, logging on to this with our different itunes usernames and storing things in libraries.
    Any help would be greatly appreciated. 
    Thanks

    I am presuming that we cannot share downloaded apps and music between accounts because of the copyright issue,
    Though I'm no copyright lawyer, as long as it's within a household, you can share content among users. Such sharing is, absent specific language preventing it not present in the iTunes Store terms of use, generally considered to be "personal use". So you can share apps and music amongst your users on your computer and with their devices. You just can't give any of that content to friends or relatives who don't live with you.
    What I am not clear on, it making sure that this appears in each itunes account - is it easy to find the file storage folders that match the itunes accounts and what would these be?
    The iTunes library and files are by default in a user's Home/Music folder. But you don't have to find the folder; in fact putting a file into the folder yourself won't add the file to iTunes. Just drag the file into the iTunes window. iTunes will copy it to the correct location.
    Regards.

  • How to set up 2 iMacs, one with a non-functioning graphics card.

    Looking for suggestions.
    I have a 2009 27" iMac that has a broken graphics card. At least that's what I think is wrong with it cause when I turn it on I see white screens with vertical pink bars from top to bottom. I bought a new iMac 5K and I wanted to see if I could connect the old iMac as a second screen. Would that still need a functioning graphics card for the old or will the new iMac which will be the main computer be able to run both screens with it's own graphics card. I don't have a mini Display port cable yet as I wanted to see what people think first before I go get one. The old iMac has no thunderbolt port and has a mini display port, Ethernet and Firewire only. I'd appreciate any input on this learning process.

    Hello vman1027,
    As long as the 27" iMac is a Late 2009 model, you should be able to utilize its display as a Target Display for your 5k iMac.
    Target Display Mode: Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
    http://support.apple.com/en-us/HT3924
    Cheers,
    Allen

  • I have a iMac and want to know if I can add an additional hynix memory to it? It currently has one with an open slot next two it.

    I have a iMac and want to know if I can add an additional hynix memory to it? It currently has one with an open slot next two it.

    You can install up to 6 GBs of RAM. You have two RAM slots so you could max out the machine by installing one 2 GB module and one 4 GB module. The largest supported module is 4 GBs, but you could use only one. Best memory performance would be attained by installing two 2 GB modules to provide 4 GBs of RAM. Installing two matching modules implements dual-channel memory that will provide a small increase in memory speed.
    Sorry for my memory: Good places for RAM are OWC and DataMem. You do not have to use Hynix RAM. Any RAM will be fine as long as it meets the computer's requirements which are outlined in the section of your use manual for adding memory.

  • Want to buy new IMac  but which one?

    Hi guys,
    Firstly I want to say that I do not own a Mac yet but am looking to buy one, I have very limited experience with them and am not sure where to start I also only use computers for general stuff like internet browsing watching a movie or 2 and sometimes editing videos, I don't play any games either. I am also not really up with the ins and outs of computers so bear with me.
    I'm looking at getting an IMac 2.66 or 2.8GHz but I have a few questions.
    Would you suggest that I buy the 2.66 as it looks like the same unit except for the processor speed and save some money for some more memory? Just on that I would probably buy the memory seperate and not get it upgraded when buying the IMac right? Because of the cost I could get it much cheaper elsewhere yes?!
    A question about internet & Broadband use, I live in Darwin Australia and am using Bigpond Broadband ADSL 20000/512kbps I am not sure what I need to do to hook up an IMac, do I just use a ethernet cable as per PC do I need any other hardware for either model 2.66 or 2.8GHz?
    I guess that's it for now, I hope you can help me, I'm sure you can.
    Anything else you can tell me will be helpful as I'm keen to get one and get started.
    Thanks
    Message was edited by: BB4L
    Message was edited by: BB4L

    Hi BB4L -
    I'm from the UK so not sure if I can help re the broadband question but I'll try my best. I use the 20inch 2.66GHz iMac at work and whilst the screen isn't amazing, it's a great, fast machine and would suit your needs perfectly.
    You're right, you'd notice hardly any benefit between the 2.66 and 2.8 machines. They have the same HD, RAM and graphics card. You'd be better off spending the extra cash on maxing out your RAM to 4GB - this will give you a more significant speed increase. And don't use Apple to upgrade your RAM, buy it from somewhere cheaper and install it yourself - it's extremely simple. The instructions are [here|http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1760]. A good choice of RAM is [here|http://www.crucial.com> although I'm not sure whether there's an Australian outlet. I just found [this|http://www.buymac.com.au/store/computer-addons/mac-memory-upgrades/imac/i mac-intel-core2duo-penryn] site but obviously have never used them so couldn't say if they're good or not.
    In terms of broadband, if you already have a modem/router box which came with your broadband then you can hook it up with an ethernet cable or connect wirelessly if the box is a wireless modem/router.
    Hope this helps.

  • DVD Training for FCP 5.0, which one???

    Hello everyone,
    Could someone give me some suggestions about training in DVD format for FCP 5.0? I am a beginner to FCP and I would like to know how basic stuff works... At the moment, I have 3 choices from DigitalMediaTraining (DMTS), RippleTraining and Total Training (www.totaltraining.com) but I am confused since their offers may be too high (or too low ;)) to me...So please, give me some hints for this. Which one you like to best?
    Thank you very much for your time and effort.
    Kind regards,
    James

    Run the tutorials and be prepared to be frustrated and confused. it's a big application.
    Play with a few simple projects.
    Then you MUST do the tutorials again. They will make much more sense the second time because you now know where the menus are and understand of the basic interface language.
    Look at your budget. Decide what you want to spend and what you want to learn. The APTS books are great and come with several interesting and challenging editing tasks. The second volume for FCP5, "Advanced Editing Techniques", just hit the shelves. It's fabulous but it's all about the craft of editing. It's not about how to run the application. So if you're making films and never went to school, that's the book you want.
    If you want to learn the application, Brian Maffit's Total Training series is, without any doubt, the best way to do the job. I have all of the available training resources for FCP3 through 5. None are as well done nor as innovative and exploratory as Brian's set of disks.
    bogiesan

  • Watch HULU on HDTV - iMac or MacBook Pro? Which one should I use?

    I have this dilemma which computer would perform better on streaming video from the net. I wanna drop the cable company so I have been looking to buy a converter to HDMI with AUDIO included like this: http://www.brilliantstore.com/hdmicables_dekcell_cpa1454.html
    or like this:
    http://www.kanexlive.com/products/item.aspx?id=3495
    but can't make up my mind if I should use the iMac or BMP and they have different video output (Mini-DVI/Mini Display Port). So I could use some feedback on which one you think would handle the project better (speed, resolution... etc.) or if it's make any difference at all, for specs please look below.
    Thank you!

    The Imac and you don't need any converter.

  • I have an ipad with 8.1.1 software. I lost my thumbnails on my movies after one of the system updates but not sure which one since I don 't look at the movies that often.

    I have an ipad running 8.1.1. I lost all of my movie thumbnails after one of the system updates, but I'm not sure which one since I don't look at the movies that ofter.How do I restore my thumbnails. They are fine in itunes on my imac that I sync with.

    onix_76 wrote:
    how come? Documents also have on hand to buy as photo and check the box
    So what?  The second-hand shop you bought it from didn't follow the right procedures.  You also didn't follow the right procedures to make sure that iPhone was not in Activation Lock.  It's like buying a car for cash but not getting the title signed over to you.  It's not your car if you don' have the title.  And that's not legally your iPhone if the previous owner's Apple ID is still registered to the device for Find My iPhone/Activation Lock.
    Only a proof of purchase from the ORIGINAL retail store would do any good at all.  Return the device to where you bought it and demand your money back.  If they refuse, either get a lawyer and/or turn in the device to local police.  If you're in possession of stolen property, then the cops won't care about where you got it from.

  • I did an auto software update on my iMac, which included a restart. When the machine restarted it's stuck with an Apple logo and spinning wheel. I've tried all of the key strokes that are supposed to work, but nothing has. Any suggestions? Thanks!

    I did an auto software update on my iMac, which included a restart. When the machine restarted it's stuck with an Apple logo and spinning wheel. I've tried all of the key strokes that are supposed to work, but nothing has. Any suggestions?

    Gray screen could be any number of things, bad third party at boot kext file, a bad Apple one, a bad install/upgrade of OS X, drive corruption etc.
    Run through this list of fixes
    Step by Step to fix your Mac

Maybe you are looking for

  • Check HDD Part Number in Solaris 10 during System Running

    Dear all, Please help me, I want to check the part number of HDD of Sun Fire V890 Server during system is running by the Solaris OS command. Can we check that part number of HDD by solaris OS command? Or have other ways, except shutdown the system an

  • Local_sync_key merep_111

    Could anybody tell me, why i have two entries on table MEREP_111 with the same local_sync_key for the same id_mobile???

  • How do I synchronise from iCloud onto new phone

    Got a new iPhone 4S today I'd downloaded every thing to I cloud but now can't get it all on to my new phone. Can't get onto my emails and all photos lost help

  • Backup ibook to macbook pro

    i am needing to do a total reformat and reinstall of os x on my wifes ibook. she is the only user account on her puter, so, if i boot her ibook in target disk mode and connect it to my macbook pro, dragging and droping her user folder should get ever

  • YTD, QTD and Year grain metrics = ORA-00942: table or view does not exist

    Hi everyone, I'm having a weird issue. I've got some GL data that I want to report on in three different grains: Quarter To Date, Year To Date and Entire Year. For the first two measures, I've setup a time dimension and I'm using the ToDate function.