Is FCE or FCP the one for me?

Hi,
I'm new to the video editing world, and my main reason for getting into it at all is to prepare DVD demo reels of my film score work. All of my source material is QT movies.
I recently assembled just such a reel using iMovie. Got quite the education in basic techniques of assembling footage, adding titles, transitions, etc. But I also quickly realized that I'm going to need a more "pro" program to do this kind of work more quickly and efficiently (also, once in iMovie, the picture quality went into the toilet for some reason). So I'm considering some version or other of FC.
I'm a music composer first and foremost, and aside from the need to generate promotional materials like my demo reel, I can't make it my life's work to learn a whole new skill. But I do know I need a better tool to dot he job. So I'm looking for advice on what the best program would be for me: FCE or FCP.
I'm going to assume (hopefully correctly) that anything I can do in iMovie can be done in some version of FC. So here's a list of what I'd be looking to achieve from FC. Which is best for me, and, are these things possible?
1. when clips are imported that the picture quality remains identical to the source
2. ability to mix QT clips at different frame rates (24 fps and 29.97)
3. have multiple tracks of video and audio
4. ability to add video clips and lock them to the timeline so that their placement is more or less permanent (unless I decide later to "unlock" them) and, that their position won't be moved or "rippled" when I edit other clips
5. ability to maintain permanent lock between video and audio extracted from the video file (iMovie isn't predictable in this aspect)
6. ability to edit audio with a high degree of precision (see proper waveform displays, maybe even a tempo grid?)
Thanks to anyone who can share their thoughts.
-=iS=-

Hi Ian,
That link was very helpful. Just one more question... from my original post, "when clips are imported [into the program] that the picture quality remains identical to the source", what feature of FC would indicate that characteristic?
(To be more specific, all of my various footage is the output of various well-known animation houses, and is all top notch in appearance even in QT format. But when those QT's are imported into iMovie the appearance becomes grainy, backgrounds become splotchy and pixelated, and edges become aliased...)
Cheers!
-=iS=-

Similar Messages

  • HT204053 i have an apple id on my ipod & another for my macbook & iphone.  how do i change the id for my ipod to match the one for my macbook & iphone?

    i have an apple id on my ipod & another for my macbook & iphone.  how do i change the id for my ipod to match the one for my macbook & iphone?

    To change the ID:
    For iMessage, go to Settings>Messages>Send & Receive (Receive At in iOS 5), tap the ID sign out, sign back in using the other ID.
    For FaceTime, do the same thing in Settings>Facetime.
    For Purchasing, do this in Settings>iTunes & App Stores (Settings>Store in iOS 5).
    For iCloud, you'll have to delete the account, create a new account with the other ID, and migrate your data to the new account.  Before deleting the account, if you have any photos in photo stream that are not in your camera roll or backed up somewhere else save these to your camera roll or you will lose them.  To do this, open the photo stream album in the thumbnail view, tap Edit, tap all the photos you want to save, tap Share, then tap Save to Camera Roll.  Once this is done, go to Settings>iCloud, scroll to the bottom and tap Delete Account. When prompted about what to do with the iCloud data, be sure to select Keep On iPod.  Next, set up a new iCloud account using a different Apple ID (if you don't have one, tap Get a Free Apple ID at the bottom).  Then turn iCloud data syncing for contacts, etc. back to On, and when prompted about merging with iCloud, choose Merge.  This will upload the data to the new account.

  • The file to download the app for Android is not working from my phone--it says that the file isn't there. However it does see the one for the Iphone (even though it can't use it). I'm very computer literate and am pretty sure the problem is on your end.

    The file to download the app for Android is not working from my phone--it says that the file isn't there. However it does see the one for the Iphone (even though it can't use it). I've tried it multiple times and continue to get the same message: "NOT FOUND The requested item could not be found". I also tried through the Market application on the phone but ended-up with the same result.
    I'm very computer literate and am pretty sure the problem is on your end. If this is the case then no one can download the app. I considered that perhaps because it's still in Beta that it was removed due to some other type of software issue. I would really like to use Firefox on my new Droid (2.0); when with this be available?

    Firefox will not appear in the Market for most phones with incompatible hardware. You can check if your phone is supported here:
    https://wiki.mozilla.org/Mobile/Platforms/Android
    Even on some supported devices, a bug in the Market software prevents Firefox from showing up. This may be related to the fairly recent Android Market app update. If you go to Settings/Applications/Market and choose "Uninstall" you can uninstall the update, and then search for and install Firefox from the marketplace.
    Or, if you have a supported phone, you can download the app directly by typing this address into your phone's browser: http://bit.ly/fxbeta3
    (Note: To download the app directly for an AT&T phone, you will have to search for instructions on "sideloading" the APK file, since AT&T disables the option to install from non-Market sources.)

  • I lost my iphone in the water I bought a new one 4S now I have 2 back ups in Icloud, the one for the new Iphne and the old Iphone where I have the most info I need. How I can download my old backup?

    I lost my iphone in the water I bought a new one 4S now I have 2 back ups in Icloud, the one for the new Iphne and the old Iphone where I have the most info I need. How I can download my old backup?

    Welcome to the Apple community.
    You cannot download a backup from iCloud, the only way to access it is to restore to the backup with your new phone, which you should have done when you first connected it. If you restore now, you will lose all the new information you have added to your new phone.

  • Im an 8th year old and i am looking for a mac. I do alot of presentations and i like to have a lot of music and images. You think the macbook air is the one for me?

    Macbook air or pro? I am in 8th grade and like to hear alot of music and save alot of images which one is the one for me?

    "alot" can vary greatly depending on ones perception of the word.  However, I would recommend a non-retna model MacBook Pro so you can have the option to install a higher capacity hard drive and more ram if necessary over the years.  You can not install more ram in a MacBook Air after purchase and installing a new drive in a MacBook Air while it is under warranty would void said warranty.

  • I'm getting a notice on my iPad saying...Provisioning Expiration "Lynx Enterprise Release" expires in 3 days...show or remind. Option are verify or remove...which I am hesitant to do because the icon it shows next to it is the one for "settings".

    I'm getting a notice on my iPad saying...Provisioning Expiration "Lynx Enterprise Release" expires in 3 days...show or remind. Option are verify or remove...which I am hesitant to do because the icon it shows next to it is the one for "settings".

    Why is that making you hesitate?  You can't accidentally remove any of the built-in apps, that I'm aware of.

  • SSIS Connection Manager: MSOLAP100 where is the one for SSAS 2012 ?

    I have an SSIS project under SSDT, that should process a SSAS 2012 Cube, when I setup the connection, the SSIS Connection Manager gives me only MSOLAP100 as a possible connection manager type. From my understanding this is the one for SQL 2008 R2. Where
    is the one for SSAS 2012 and how can I enable it ?
    I feel this is a bug in SSDT:
    I used another UI dialog and could create a new connection like this:
    Still it says ConnectionManagerType MSOLAP100, however in the connection string I now have Provider=MSOLAP.5, this seems to be another SSDT bug.

    If this issue can be reproduced in multiple machines, then you can you can submit a feedback at
    http://connect.microsoft.com/SQLServer/Feedback and hope it is released in the next release of service pack or product.

  • [svn:fx-trunk] 11548: MXFTEText. css now has a type selector for FTEDataGridItemRenderer that matches the one for DataGridItemRenderer in the MX default .css file.

    Revision: 11548
    Author:   [email protected]
    Date:     2009-11-06 16:35:27 -0800 (Fri, 06 Nov 2009)
    Log Message:
    MXFTEText.css now has a type selector for FTEDataGridItemRenderer that matches the one for DataGridItemRenderer in the MX default.css file. Both set paddingLeft to 5.
    QE notes: None
    Doc notes: None
    Bugs: SDK_22741
    Reviewer: Alex
    Tests run: ant checkintests
    Is noteworthy for integration: No
    Modified Paths:
        flex/sdk/trunk/frameworks/projects/spark/MXFTEText.css
        flex/sdk/trunk/frameworks/spark-manifest.xml

    AN UPDATE ON MY ISSUE:
    It appears to be limited to Dreamweaver. When I upload the files to my server and use BrowserLab or Microsoft SuperPreview the pages are rendering properly in all versions of IE. It's only broken when viewing in Design view within Dreamweaver or when using BrowserLab from within Dreamweaver. So at least I know my website works, which is a huge relief, but does anyone have any idea why Design view would complete ignore my styles? It's very annoying.

  • ICloud symbol in settings does not appear, instead there is the one for MobileMe, what do I have to do or didn't do well?

    iCloud symbol in settings does not appear, instead there is the one for MobileMe, what do I have to do or didn't do well?
    Thanks in advance

    If your Mac is one year old it did not come with Lion, so you must have purchased and installed it yourself, or it is not installed.
    Do this
    Go to Apple Menu>About This Mac:
    It should look like this:
    If your version is anything other than 10.7.xx you do not have Lion (10.6 is Snow Leopard)

  • I bought Adobe Photoshop Elements 13 They sent me the one for Windows and I need the one for Macbook Pro!!!

    The download that adobe sent me is for Windows. I have a Mac and I need the one for Macbook Pro. I have been looking for a contact with customer service and even the chat is not working. Help please! I haven't use the product they sent me

    Please open link
    Contact Customer Care
    Then click on still need help, you will get the chat option

  • HT1277 Automatic set up for mail isnt working, on the "welcome to mail" pop up its not recognising my password and gives me no option to reset, which password should I be entering? Im assuming its the one for my Mac ? also tried my Yahoo one but no joy...

    Automatic set up for mail isnt working, on the "welcome to mail" pop up its not recognising my password and gives me no option to reset, which password should I be entering? Im assuming its the one for my Mac ? also tried my Yahoo one but no joy.....

       start mail then:
      Preferences> Accounts>  click the  [+] icon and  fill in the blanks.
    select  POP account
      Here are the basic server settings for Yahoo! Mail:
    Incoming Mail (POP3) Server: pop.mail.yahoo.com (Use SSL, port: 995)
    Outgoing Mail (SMTP) Server: smtp.mail.yahoo.com (Use SSL, port: 465, use authentication)
    Account Name/Login Name: Your Yahoo! Mail ID (your email address without the "@yahoo.com")
    Email Address: Your Yahoo! Mail address (e.g., [email protected])
    Password: Your Yahoo! Mail password

  • Where can I find more OBE like the one for Database xE and SQL Developer?

    Hi,
    I tried to post on the OBE forum but it is expired.
    I found the downloadable OBE, or tutorial, very good resources for me to learn Oracle, like the one for XE and SQL developer, which you can download, not just read online, and see as many times as you can, with flash stuffs inside,
    Will you make more this kind of OBE?
    Where can I find them?
    Peter

    Hi Hans,
    I know the above address you offered but those are
    not downloadble.So do what I do .... CTRL-S (save page)
    As an Oracle trainer, I consider the OBEs to be very important. I doubt that Oracle will get rid of them.
    However, it takes time to make them. I suspect that they are created when a new feature needs to be demonstrated and the product management has the resources available.
    I just wish they would make the original set from Oracle8i available. They provided some very important basics which have long since hit the archive pile.
    I'm sure that some of the ACEs would be happy to upgrade them to Oracle10g/11g level. I know I would be willing to contribute to that effort.

  • I am looking at an MP3 player with the capability to download audio-books. Is the Nano the one for me?

    I need a new mp3 player & have never had an Apple product. A must have "accessory" is to download e books.
    Is this the product for me?

    Thanks! I did not know that. I have been looking for an mp3 player for a long time & did not realize the one I wanted was right in front of my nose! [ at Walmart]

  • I keep trying to install firefox for mac 10.4 and keep getting msg stating not good for this operating system. i downloaded the one for mac

    I had firefox on my mac for the longest time and woke up one day and it was gone...poof. I am trying to install it again and each time i try to download it and install i get an error message stating it is not the right browser for this operating sysytem....help me please. I did of course download the firefox for mac system

    *Firefox 4 versions and later do not run on a PowerPC Mac.
    *Firefox 4 and later require at least OS X 10.5 and an Intel Mac.
    * http://www.mozilla.com/firefox/5.0/system-requirements/
    For an unofficial Firefox 4 compatible version (TenFourFox) that runs on PowerPC Macs with OS X 10.4.11 or OS X 10.5.8 you can look at:
    * http://www.floodgap.com/software/tenfourfox/
    Firefox 3.6.x (Mac OS X 10.4 and later) can be found here:
    * http://www.mozilla.com/en-US/firefox/all-older.html

  • How do I use a different number for imessages than the one for my phone?

    I use two different phone numbers. My main number is not the one associated with my iphone. I want imessages to be sent from my primary number, not the one assigned by default by my phone. I see in settings where I can add another email address, but not where I can add another phone number. How can I change the default number to the one I actually want people to use?

    You can't add another phone number.

Maybe you are looking for

  • A letter of complain

    Dear Sir/Madam: Re: Web order No: W52825845 On 11th June 2006, I bought a Mac Book Pro (17-inch), model number Z0CP and serial number is W86240BQTJ1 at apple.com. Unfortunately, your product has not performed well because the super drive is not funct

  • Show Purchasing group Field in UI for Create Limit Item

    Hello All,               Do you if there is a way without modifying the templates to show Purchasing Group in UI for Create Limit Items in SRM 4.0 ( Classic Scenario)? -thanks in advance Shilpa

  • Hypertext for Reader in Android

    I was surprised to find that Reader for Android does not support hypertext links - specifically mailto: like the windows version does.  I keep a directory for a group that includes links for email addresses making sending emails from the directory ve

  • Message 615

    Dear Experts I have an error Delivery item is not or only partially packed while doing Inbound delivery. I want to received goods partially when required. Whether it is possible in SAP. But Item categories are picking different 1st  is customizing an

  • Audio conferencing through MSN?

    Is there anyway to do this?