Is It Safe to use an old Disk Utility on a new OS HD?

Hi - Maybe I'm too concerned about this but I need to calm the obsessive-compulsive within.
I'm in the habit of verifying permissions on my 10.4.9 system (G5) via Disk Utility (version 10.5.6) before and after every install or update. On occasion I've also hit "Repair Permissions" but I know that the only way to really do an effective job of "repairing" is by running Disk Ut from a drive or disc separate from the drive being repaired.
Now...
I have an external HD with Panther on it...and it has Panther's version of DU on it (10.4.2). I want to use the Panther version of Disk Utility to Repair Permissions on a drive with Tiger (10.4.9) on it. Is this safe? I don't want ANYTHING to be harmed. Is it safe?
Expert input appreciated.
D2

I know that the only way to really do an effective job of "repairing" is by running Disk Ut from a drive or disc separate from the drive being repaired
You can repair permissions from the same hard disk, but you can't repair the hard disk except from Disk Utility in your install disk.
Two different repairs!
So therefore no need to use the Panther version of Disk Utility to Repair Permissions on a drive with Tiger (10.4.9), BUT
Panther's version of DU on it (10.4.2) - 10.4.2 is Tiger. Panther was 10.3.x.
Put it this way: you can safely repair the hard disk of your Mac with the Disk Utility of the install disk that came with your Mac, but not from any other.
If that wasn't clear, post back!

Similar Messages

  • Can't use my old HDD after upgrading with new one,old is GPT protected

    Hi everyone! First of all I would like to thank you in advance!
    Recently I upgraded my old HDD on my MacBookPro. I made a clone of the old disk, installed the new one in the MBP and putted the old one in external enclosure. Now I'm trying to use the old disk with the enclosure, but it doesn't appear in Finder, it appears in Disk Tools, but I can not perform any actions on it. I tried to erase it, but with no success! The old disk is GPT protected and I don't know what to do. Tried to erase it with Windows and Linux with no success neither. I know the enclosure works because it recognize every other disk, but my old one is untouchable to my Mac OS! I'm looking for possible ideas on how to make my old HDD usable with the enclosure?

    Can't really help with your Internet issues, but I can put you on the path to leaning more about Macs.
    If you're a former Windows user, there many resources on Apple's web site to get yourself familiar with how Macs and OS X work.
    Here ard a few areas to spend time with
    http://www.apple.com/support/macbasics/
    http://www.apple.com/support/imac/intel/
    http://support.apple.com/videos/
    http://www.apple.com/support/lion/
    http://www.apple.com/support/osx/
    For the video tutorials, in the video search box, just type in OS X. You'll get a list of OS X video tutorials to watch  as you learn to use your iMac.
    Start with the Anatomy of a Mac video first, Then the Finder Basics video second. After you have watched and put to use these two videos, you can watch any other OS X video you want in any order.
    Here is a free eBook download of David Pogue's OS X Snow Leopard The Missing Manual here. While OS X 10.7 LIon and OS X 10.8 Mountain Lion work a bit differently than OS X 10.6 Snow Leopard, there are many things that still apply.
    http://it-ebooks.info/book/337/
    Good Luck!

  • Can I use my old apple speakers with my new I mac

    Can I use my old apple speakers with my new I mac

    If they are the old clear globe speakers that worked with old G4 models, then no.

  • Can I use my old apple monitor with a new mac mini?

    Can I use my old apple monitor with a new mac mini?

    Probably.  Any information about the monitor?

  • IPhone 4S fell on some water, was working but now won't work. I got a replacement coming. Can I use the old Sim card in the new phone if it wasn't damaged? Will I get my pictures and contacts and messages back if it wasn't damaged?

    My iPhone 4S accidentally fell into a very shallow bit of water. The phone was wet, but worked afterwards for a short bit. Now it's not working, so I called and got a replacement phone coming. Same exact phone. Can I use the old Sim card in the new phone without harming anything? I don't know if the sim card got messed up or not, but I had a lot of pictures and messages and my contacts on my phone, and I assume these were on the sim card or am I wrong? I just wan to know if I can use the old sim card if it's still working in the new phone that is coming, as long as there was no damage to it? Thanks

    I think I had it on the iCloud, I just changed computers and had part of my old computer backed up, where are the default iTunes info saved like the pictures and I know my contacts were backed up cuz I kept getting updated stuff that I wasn't sure about, but it was contacts where some belonged to my wife's contacts....but anyway, if the cloud backed up contacts, it should have grabbed pictures too? Like I asked before, if they were backed up to the computer, is there a default iTunes folder they are saved to? I had a crap load of pictures on there that I usually could really access if I was connected to wi-fi. I turned off my data stuff as I only have 4GB and between me and my 2 kids, we seemed to use up a lot of it. My son would play music from Pandora during work, and use up all our data til I limited him to only 3GB, my daughter and I barely used 1GB. Anyway, thanks to everybody that is answering. I thought I might have done good finding the dang sim card, but pointless I guess.
    Ralph - F.Y.I. I would be happy to back up the iPhone if I could turn it on LOL......I am pretty positive I did, but what about Text messages? ANY of those saved too or not? Sorry guys, I don't know a **** of a lot about cell phones, but I do know about memory cards, but not sim cards that act like memory cards or look like them anyway. What is the purpose of a sim card if I may ask a stupid question since they don't hold any data from my phone stuff. I just hope my stuff comes back on the new replacement phone once I get it up and running. Again, thanks to everybody for the edumucation.

  • Using Automator with Disk Utility

    I'm new to using Automator. I want to create a work flow with Disk Utility but is doesnt appear in the applications list. How do I make Disk Utility work with Automator?

    If a program doesn't appear in the list, that means that Apple hasn't written actions for it yet.
    You can still use Automator with Disk Utillity, but you will need to use Applescript and the 'Run Applesript' action to operate Disk Utillity.
    Unfortuately the 'how' is beyond my knowledge, and the scope of this post.

  • Can I use the old power supply with the new unit?

    I have a second generation Apple TV. When I install the new unit next week can I use the old power supply with the new one and the new power supply with the old one? This would save some messing with cords behind the units.

    Hello:
    I would definitely not try that.....  The power supplies may be compatible - or may not be compatible.  I think messing with cables is a small price to pay for not potentially frying a new device.
    Barry

  • I have recently started using an old Nano and purchased some new songs. When I go to sync it wants to erase other songs to download new. Is there a way to just sync new songs to ipod without erasing existing music on devise?

    I have recently started using an old Nano and purchased some new songs. When I go to sync it wants to erase other songs to download new. Is there a way to just sync new songs to ipod without erasing existing music on devise?

    Syncing shouldn't trouch you photos unless you have photos in a Photo Library album.  These would be photos that were synced to your phone from your computer.  If you do have any, you'll need to use an app like PhotoSync to transfer them to your computer prior to syncing.
    If you prefer to backup your camera roll photos prior to syncing, open iTunes and go to Preferences>Devices and check "Prevent...from syncing automatically".  Then connect your phone to your computer and import them as explained here: http://support.apple.com/kb/HT4083.
    Then, to minimize data loss, follow the steps in this user tip: https://discussions.apple.com/docs/DOC-3141.  To follow the steps, first open iTunes and go to View>Show Sidebar.  Also, Transfer Purchases is now located in File>Devices.

  • Can i use my old IPOD dock with the new G5 IPOD?

    Can i use my old IPOD dock with the new G5 IPOD?

    That's really good to know. I thought because it was a different thickness you wouldn't be able to, and the dock adaptor that comes with the new iPods doesn't fit into the old Photo dock.
    Do you know if you can use the charger that came with the old Photo iPods? You can plug straight into the power socket, but the cable that goes into the charger from the iPod is the firewire cable, so I was thinking maybe it wouldn't work, and I don't want to try it in case I short out my iPod or something!

  • Can Disk Utility make a "New Image" from a desktop copy of a DVD?

    I have not been able to get Disk Utility to make "new images" of a couple of DVDs. For one of the DVDs, it may have something to do with a hyphen in the title. I haven't a clue why I'm failing with the second of the two DVDs. (Previously, I've had no trouble with about a dozen DVDs so far.)
    Several members of this discussion group recommended me to copy&paste or drag&drop the files from a DVD to a new folder (say on the desktop), and then to drag the resulting new folder into the box in Disk Utility, and then to make a disk image using Disk Utility.
    (Note: While I believe the original DVDs are not encrypted, I ran an experiment to make double sure, by using MacTheRipper first to produce folders containing clean files.)
    However, when I drag the new folder into the box in Disk Utility, and let go of the mouse button, then the folder does not stay in Disk Utility window, but instead springs back to the desktop.
    How can I get Disk Utility to make new images from the new desktop folders?
    Note:
    As a partially successsful work around:
    For one of the two original DVDs - which has only about 3.7GB on it - I can sometimes (only sometimes) succeed in doing without Disk Utility simply by dragging the audio and video files from the new desktop folder onto a blank DVD, and then burning that DVD. However, in an average of about two out of every three attempts so far, my Mac rejects the new disk as unusable during the burn process.
    For the other original DVD - which has about 4.36GB on it - the contents of the new desktop folder won't fit onto a blank DVD. It then gets messy - shrinking the files - so I'd like to avoid all of that by getting DIsk Utility to work properly.

    For the answer, see the following excerpt from my own posting dated 2 May 2006, i.e.:
    "I finally found out for myself (from Disk Utility Help) that to make a new image from a file/folder, rather than dragging the folder to the Disk Utility pane, in the top menu bar in Disk Utility you select Images/New/Image from Folder."

  • I want to use my old iTunes acct  with my new iPhone. It is coming up with a different iTunes acct  how can I get the correct account.?

    How do I get my old iTunes acct. on my new iPhone 5?  I am getting someone else's account coming up associated with my new iCloud account.  It is because I temporarily used a friend's old iPhone while waiting for my new phone to arrive.  What do I do to fix this?

    Here is a link to email them.
    http://www.apple.com/support/itunes/contact.html?form=authorization&topic=Author ization&subtopic=Authorize%20or%20deauthorize%20your%20computer

  • Using disk utility to burn new image dvd's

    Ok I just learned to burn DVD'd using Disk Utility and New image.
    But I have come to halt in my burning with a new issue.
    My issue is that I have a file that is 4.63GB. When I make a new image so that I can burn it, it increases the size of the file(Video TS) to 5.13GB. Making it to big for a 4.7GB DVD.
    My question is is this normal for the new image file to increase in size, and is there a way for me to stop this from happening. Or can anyone give me any other suggestions. Please help.

    Ok I have never tried that, as this is the first time it is suggested to me.
    The reason i have been doing it via DU, is because this has been to only way to get it to play on
    home DVD player and burn with the UDF setting. I was told to do it this way when I was trying to burn
    copies of my nieces fifteens that was prof. done on a DVD.
    I am trying to burn a copy of a movie so that it can be played on home dvd players. Yes I have done this before and the copies I burned via DU/new image, worked perfectly. And the ones I burned by just choosing file and burning it did not work.
    So any help would be great.

  • I changed my main email on my apple ID and now it doesn't work and still uses my old one and with my new and old email my password doesn't work

    I changed my main email on my apple ID now when I try sign in with the new email it doesn't work and neither does my old one so I don't know what happened, any help?... I made a new apple ID and on my iPod it tries to use my old one and I can't change it to my new apple ID I've gone on to settings and iTunes and App Store and changed it to my new apple Id yet when I buy apps or try update them it uses my old apple ID I don't know what to do any help??

    - Apps are locked to the account that purchased them.
    - To update apps you have to sign into the account that purchased the apps. If you have apps that need updating purchased from more than one account you have to update them one at a time until the remaining apps were purchased from one account.
    If you can't log into Settings>iTunes and App stores with your new ID them mean there is a problem. Try restting the password and try to sign in again.
    iTunes Store: Retrieving and changing passwords (Apple ID)
    Can you sign in with the new ID on your computer?
    Last, contact iTunes.
    Apple - Support - iTunes - Contact Us

  • 2Can't burn a DVD using IDVD nor Disk Utility first time user-what is wrong

    T he recording device reported the media error: Power calibration area error. (0x73, 0x03.)
    IDVD Version 6.0.3
    Emac- OS 10.3.9--- in the owner's manual it DOES state my emac can burn DVDs. Is this correct?
    I am using FujiFilm DVD-R . Never used the DVD apps or burner before. I PRAM'ed 3 times. Also did 6 CD audio burns to check the drive. Is it the media-- Fuji does not work? I used Office Depot generic for audio CD-Rs.
    I keep getting this error message after about 20 minutes of programming the DVD-- then it ejects with this message:
    "The recording device reported the media error: Power calibration area error. (0x73, 0x03.)"
    When using the IDVD application to burn my slideshow onto a DVD; Then I contacted Apple Care and I was told to use Disk Utility to burn my DVD in lieu of IDVD not working.
    I converted my slideshow into a .dmg format; all was verified successfully. Then I receive this error message when attempting to BURN DVD:
    "STOP The device drained its buffer without burn under run protection"
    I made a WONDERFUl slideshow-- of only 17 slides-- confirmed I have plenty of room on hard drive and et al on the "disk information". I have attempted since May 7th to get this DVD to burn my slideshow. PLEASE HELP ME!!! I have deadlines-- now it is for Tuesday May 15th. Please alert me to an alternative until I can get my Emac working properly on what I can do to make copies of my slideshow ASAP. Thank you.
    Now I looked thru your ERROR message archives and found NONE to match mine. What do these error messages mean-- is my Emac not working? This is first time ever I tried to use IDVD and IMovie and Disk Utility--- so the first impression is VERY VERY VERY bad for Apple's "easy to use for first time customers"....
    Oh to add information-- I DO have an external DVD recorder-- have yet to even see how to hook it up to my Emac-- if this is an alternative to meet my Tuesday deadline-- PLEASE let me know-- how do I burn a copy of my slideshow into an external DVD recorder?
    My emac model: 1.25 GHz Power PC G4
    Memory 256 MB DDR SDRAM
    Machine Model: eMac
    CPU Type: PowerPC G4 (1.1)
    Number Of CPUs: 1
    CPU Speed: 1.25 GHz
    L2 Cache (per CPU): 512 KB
    Memory: 256 MB
    Bus Speed: 167 MHz
    Boot ROM Version: 4.8.2f1
    Serial Number: G84181KDQQJ

    Also did 6 CD audio burns to check the drive. Is it the media-- Fuji does not work?
    Your drive is actually TWO devices - one set of optics and laser burns/reads CDs, another set of optics/laser reads/wtites DVDs. The fact that your drive can burn CDs doesn't mean it is working for DVDs.
    I keep getting this error message after about 20 minutes of programming the DVD-- then it ejects with this message:
    "The recording device reported the media error: Power calibration area error. (0x73, 0x03.)"
    When using the IDVD application to burn my slideshow onto a DVD; Then I contacted Apple Care and I was told to use Disk Utility to burn my DVD in lieu of IDVD not working.
    You might want to get back to Applecare and expalin again the error messages you are seeing. They really don't involve iDVD.
    I converted my slideshow into a .dmg format; all was verified successfully. Then I receive this error message when attempting to BURN DVD:
    "STOP The device drained its buffer without burn under run protection"
    You either have a media problem or you have a DVD burner problem.
    F Shippey

  • Can't burn a DVD using IDVD nor Disk Utility- first time user-what is wrong

    The recording device reported the media error: Power calibration area error. (0x73, 0x03.)
    May 13, 2007 8:05pm PDT
    IDVD Version 6.0.3
    Emac- OS 10.3.9--- in the owner's manual it DOES state my emac can burn DVDs. Is this correct?
    I keep getting this error message after about 20 minutes of programming the DVD-- then it ejects with this message:
    "The recording device reported the media error: Power calibration area error. (0x73, 0x03.)"
    When using the IDVD application to burn my slideshow onto a DVD; Then I contacted Apple Care and I was told to use Disk Utility to burn my DVD in lieu of IDVD not working.
    I converted my slideshow into a .dmg format; all was verified successfully. Then I receive this error message when attempting to BURN DVD:
    "STOP The device drained its buffer without burn under run protection"
    I made a WONDERFUl slideshow-- of only 17 slides-- confirmed I have plenty of room on hard drive and et al on the "disk information". I have attempted since May 7th to get this DVD to burn my slideshow. PLEASE HELP ME!!! I have deadlines-- now it is for Tuesday May 15th. Please alert me to an alternative until I can get my Emac working properly on what I can do to make copies of my slideshow ASAP. Thank you.
    Now I looked thru your ERROR message archives and found NONE to match mine. What do these error messages mean-- is my Emac not working? This is first time ever I tried to use IDVD and IMovie and Disk Utility--- so the first impression is VERY VERY VERY bad for Apple's "easy to use for first time customers"....

    Well I had to make the copies for my presentation-- so the cheapest I could find in my area was Walgreens-- 39.99 for ONE COPY of a DVD! So I paid $70.00 and the clerk made 4 copies for me;-) So thanks Walgreens!
    Now-- my Mac-- I could not find anything on shelves at Walgreens or Office Depot but the FujiFilm I already have... So I now have time to look elsewhere.
    I did PRAM my Emac 3 times-- I tried these things also:
    1)Saved the IDVD- .dmg format to QuickTime .mov
    I uploaded to google video.com or whatever-- they use their own software-- .gvp file and player. All was successful (even now on YouTube-
    2) I then made another version in PowerPoint and saved it as an MPEG
    Also for below-- I lowered the burn rate upon the 2nd try to 1x-- took one hour or more (I went to get a root canal... then exfoliate... then I came back;-)
    Also tried different .mov from the web-- a great whale shark video that was only 49mb. My presentation is 120 mb. So I was just thinking-- make it smaller; burn slower.
    3)I did try to burn from IDVD, Disk Utility and then the drag and burn/click method on the desktop-- put a blank DVD in-- drag the .mov icon to the blank DVD -- write a title for the blank DVD- formats it / Drag to trash-- Burn icon comes up/ Clicked it-- waited 20 minutes and received:
    "Error: Error occurred while burning the disc. This disc can not be used."
    So I put in another blank Fuji DVD-- just in case. Same error message-- so I am hoping it is the DVD itself and not the SuperDrive.
    4)Also-- I tried to do audio CD burn-- just to make sure about the drive-- all was successful and I did a back up of my Itunes files-- 6 CDs they burned (they meaning "the Gods of Mac OS" ;-0 My audio CDs are Office Depot CD-R 52X700mb/ So the generic is better for CDs on my Emac that I know;-)
    So I will use my weekend to try other DVDs-- and I have the safety net of Apple Care-- but then just realized-- my Extended Care plan is OVER at May 30, 2007!!! I called to ask to EXTEND it further-- I'll pay whatever-- NOPE-- 3 years was max on this contract. So any repairs I have to pay for after May 30th-- ISN'T THAT JUST THE WAY THE WORLD GOES? The DAY after your warranty on AnYTHING-- the thing goes kablooey?
    But I still have days left--- and I know of a good Mac Repair person in area-- but it is just so darn difficult to move my desktop Emac (I got the GLASS monitor to save $300 or something) Weight Lifting is what it is-- weighs about 45lbs or more.
    But it seems it may be the media I am using if the CD burner is working, right?
    I can update-- if you want me to email direct-- just give me a note (my email is listed). Thanks all!!! I just want to impress everyone of how tenacious I am to find that my Emac is FINE-- it is just ME that is warped;-)

Maybe you are looking for

  • Downloaded fonts (MapInfo) are not getting displayed once assigned to drop down in my web application

    I am using mapinfo fonts in my web application and assigning these fonts to the dropdown boxes as below : ddlSymbol.Style.Add("font-family", "MapInfo Arrows"); But it is not showing correct font. Same is working nice with IE or Chrome. Only FIrefox i

  • Red eye problem gone

    Just thought I would point out that the newest iPhoto patch has finally corrected the problem of photos syncing over to the iPhone in the original, uncorrected, red eyed form. Now when you sync from iPhoto, any photo you removed the red eye from will

  • When i click on a link the link doesn't open fully?

    when i am on a web page if i click on a tab it only shows some of the page but the original page operates normal == This happened == Every time Firefox opened == since i downloaded firefox

  • GST allocation to cost centers

    hi all,    in an invoice the GST from all line items will go to a single cost center, but my client wants to automatically distribute it to their respective cost centers entered in the line items with out manual entry ex: Itm PK ACC        Tx  Amt  

  • How can I straighten a movie clip?

    I have some great footage from an interview, unfortunately the windowsill behind the subject is skewed.  Is there a way to straighten it in Imovie or another inexpensive application?