Is the woofer in my MBP 17" broken? Help me test it !

I have an early 2009 Macbook Pro 17". I had so far been using just the internal speakers for sound. Recently I plugged in a pair of $20 earbud phones and discovered how much I've been missing from the music! Using the earbuds, I can hear bass elements in music that I thought didn't exist. The MBP's internal speakers hadn't been giving them to me!
Obviously I'm no audiophile... I still don't have a good pair of external speakers. But I'm wondering if the woofer in my MBP is broken? (I understand that the MBP does have a woofer.)
I'd like to know if others who own 17" MBPs also feel that their internal speakers are disappointments. Or are you satisfied with their sound in the bass range?
To see whether my MBP's woofer is broken, I'd like to compare it side by side with another MBP playing the same music. But since I can't do that, _I'd like to ask the readers to run the following test on their MBPs, then reply to this post._
Download "AudioTest" from here: http://www.katsurashareware.com/pgs/audiotest.html .
It's a 485 KB nag-ware. It generates tones at frequencies you specify.
Please run AudioTest to play tones of decreasing frequencies. For example start with a tone at 200Hz. Then a tone at 180, 160, etc. _Please take note of the frequency of the tone that you cannot hear through the internal speakers, then please tell me what that frequency was._
When I used AudioTest, I set my MBP's volume control to less than maximum - i.e. 4 bars below maximum (I was afraid of possibly damaging the speakers.) Within AudioTest, I set its output level to -3dBFS. I used the Sine Wave Type.
With my MBP's internal speakers, I can hear tones (hums) at frequencies as low as 120Hz, 110Hz, then nothing. I cannot discern anything at 100Hz. This is very subjective, but discernability appears to drop suddenly starting at 120Hz.
Through my earbuds, I can hear/feel tones as low as 10Hz!

French Roast: The speakers in notebook computers — ALL notebook computers — are necessarily tiny, and are therefore severely compromised in their ability to reproduce sound faithfully, especially low-frequency sound. They are, to be blunt, not suitable for listening to music. They're fine for Skype calls, listening to recorded books or podcasts, etc., but if you want to listen to music, you need speakers or headphones.
If it were possible to get good sound out of speakers as small as the ones in a notebook computer, the subwoofer in a home-theater audio system would be no larger than a Pink Pearl pencil eraser, and each other speaker in such a system would be the size of two stacked nickels. That's not the case, and it's because speakers that small can't reproduce full-spectrum sound. So don't expect good sound from notebook computer speakers, and you won't be disappointed.

Similar Messages

  • I was told of an application that will allow the use of a second screen to view my data and files, but I forgot its name. I'd like to make the connection because my LCD is broken.

    I was told of an application that will allow the use of a second screen to view my data and files, but I forgot its name. I'd like to make the connection because my LCD is broken.

    You don't need an application, just plug a compaitble monitor into the display port of your MacBook Pro, set the screen up in System Preferences>Displays

  • How do I configure the settings on my MBP and Apple TV so it will stream my Netflix movies from my MBP to the TV Screen?]

    I bought a new Apple TV 3rd Gen.(which is currently updated) so I could stream the Netflix movies on my MacBook Pro Computer running Yosemite, onto my TV Screen. However, if I configure the settings on my Computer and Apple TV so that everything on my Desktop is displayed on the TV Screen, then Netflix can't even get the movie on my MBP open. It just keeps spinning until I get an error message about not being able to use Mirroring or Air Play if I want to stream my movie to the TV. So, when I switched the settings so that all mirroring and Air Play options were unchecked and selected all the streaming options using the internet. Then the Netflix movie would open up quick and easy, but there was nothing on the TV Screen.
    I also was never able to Pair my Apple TV with my Bluetooth.(If they;re even supposed to be Paired, but something I read implied they should be Paired.f)  My MBP Bluetooth discovered the Apple TV immediately and issued a Pairing Number to enter in the Bluethooth's setting for the Apple TV, but the Apple TV Bluetooth just kept spinning. I don't know if that is part of the problem or not, since it wasn't mentioned in any documentation I read.
    Also, when I was digging for information on the browser, going to Netflix Website and Apple TV's information at apple.com, I did come across a few links while searching the browser for any answers to my questions, that said I needed to Activate my Netflix Account for streaming by finding my Apple TVs activation code and then enter it on Netflix's site in my Netflix account.  And other's mentioned a registration code from my Apple TV needed to be entered to activate the "streaming" of Netflix movie content. And again, I've searched for hours and hours trying to find out where or how I could find the two codes, but never had any success. So, I have exhausted all avenues I can think of and with no luck, and I'm hoping my wonderful Apple Community can help me out or get me heading in the right direction.  Thanks, RVAF

    There is a native Netflix app on Apple TV. If you are attempting to use a VPN via MBP then that is not supported.

  • The screen of my iphone is broken and doesn't work anymore. Is there a way to type in my passcode on the computer/itunes?

    The screen of my iphone is broken and doesn't work anymore. Is there a way to type in my passcode on the computer/itunes?

    No, get the screen fixed.

  • I like and use Top Sites but it has become unsuable with this constant blacking out and reloading the thumbnails.  My MBP has not seen a problem at all.   I have been searching every other day for over a month trying to find a fix in Windows Safari with n

    I like and use Top Sites but it has become unsuable with this constant blacking out and reloading the thumbnails.  My MBP has not seen a problem at all.
    I have been searching every other day for over a month trying to find a fix in Windows Safari with no joy.  I want to resolve, not switch browsers. Please offer up a solution that only refreshes the Top Site thumbnails once a day or as some controlable interval.  Started about two versions ago, now on ver 5.1.5. Windows 7 64bit.
    Safari 5.1.5 for Win64 bit, Windows 7!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    I think I solved the wifi connection problem, just by switching off completely the router! sounds trivial, but in this case it worked!!!
    the funny behaviour of the trackpad/cursor still persists. any suggestion???
    thanks again

  • My iPod Touvh 4th Generation won't turn on. It will not charge even after I used a few chargers and will not connect to a computer. The Home button is broken and I don't know if the Lock/Sleep button is now broken or stuck as well. What should I do?

    My iPod Touvh 4th Generation won't turn on. It will not charge even after I used a few chargers and will not connect to a computer. The Home button is broken and I don't know if the Lock/Sleep button is now broken or stuck as well. I believe there may be a problem with the battery or the backlight. I've had my screen replaced once by some stooges. What should I do?

    Try:
    - iOS: Not responding or does not turn on
    When it  says place the iPod in recoverymode use one of these programs.
    For PC
    RecBoot: Easy Way to Put iPhone into Recovery Mode
    If necessary:
    Download QTMLClient.dll & iTunesMobileDevice.dll for RecBoot
    and                                  
    RecBoot tip
    For MAC or PC       
    The Firmware Umbrella - TinyUmbrella
    - If not successful and you can't fully turn the iOS device fully off, let the battery fully drain. After charging for an least an hour try the above again.
    - Try on another computer                            
    - If still not successful that usually indicates a hardware problem and an appointment at the Genius Bar of an Apple store is in order.
    Apple Retail Store - Genius Bar                                     

  • I had my iphone 5 replaced at the apple store as of a broken sleep button and i was wondering if they would replace again as i think it may of happend again as it works most of the time but theres an odd click where it wont work.

    I had my iphone 5 replaced at the apple store as of a broken sleep button and i was wondering if they would replace again as i think it may of happend again as it works most of the time but theres an odd click where it wont work.

    Yes.

  • I need to authorize my computer but i am unable to do so as i am authorized to many times but i can't authorize the other computers because they are broken, what should i do?

    i need to authorize my computer but i am unable to do so as i am authorized to many times but i can't authorize the other computers because they are broken, what should i do?

    About Authorization and Deauthorization.
    Follow the instructions in the above link to deauthorize all and then authorize only the computers that you physically have access to and need authorized.

  • HT204291 I have a MBP 13-inch, Mid 2010 and have just upgraded to mountain lion and am trying to connect it to my apple tv however i dont get the air play icon on my mac i have followed all the advise on support anyone able to help??

    I have a MBP 13-inch, Mid 2010 and have just upgraded to mountain lion and am trying to connect it to my apple tv however i dont get the air play icon on my mac i have followed all the advise on support anyone able to help??

    stevie, a third party app called airparrot will give you the pretty much the same as mirroring and forks on Macs too old to mirror.

  • Can I use the 85 watt charger on the 13" unibody aluminum MBP?

    Can I use the 85 watt charger on the 13" unibody aluminum MBP instead of the 60 watt that came with it??
    Is it safe to use any of the 3rd party chargers instead of the $79 Apple model?? Some of these are 1/2 the price or less

    "Some of these are 1/2 the price or less..."
    How much is your computer worth: $40, $50? The counterfeit power adapters that I've seen are improperly grounded - is that OK for your computer or you personally? The real power adapters meet are necessary international safety and agency compliance standards - do the counterfeit products meet the same threshold. The real power adapters have over-current, over-voltage, and over-temperature protection...do the counterfeit products have these features.
    Is your personal safety and your computer worth more than $40 or $50?

  • The command line 'route' command is broken - what alternatives are there?

    The 'route' command appears to be broken in Mavericks ( now also in 10.9.4 ). It does update that tables, so netstat -r makes it seem that it has worked. However, browsers, pings and trace routes all give errors such as 'out of memory'.
    So, what can I do to set up working alternatives to the standard routing?
    There certainly is some routing capability, and the ability to change it - if you use the OS/X server and set up a VPN, you can set up routing there. So it should be possible to access it through the command line somehow.
    Any suggestions gratefully received.
    I really thought that this would be easy, but it's turned into quite a headache.

    This isn't a great fix but it's helped us out. We created an autoit script to edit the firefox.js file found in program files\mozilla firefox\default\pref. It searches for the line "pref("app.update.auto", true);" and changes it to "pref("app.update.auto", false);". It's a pain but it's the best we could come up with.
    Note: We updated to 3.6.14 and even with the setting above FF still did an auto update to 3.6.15.

  • I am trying to decrease the size of my aperature library on my MB Pro HD.  I used  file\ relocate master to move files to my External HD(EHD) and this worked.  However, the size of my MBP library has not decreased.

    I am trying to decrease the size of my aperature library on my MB Pro HD.  I used  file\ relocate master to move files to my External HD(EHD) and this worked.  However, the size of my MBP library has not decreased.  I do not want to delete the files on my MB Pro until I am confident Aperature can see the files on the EHD.  It looks like the relocate master fxn just copies the masters and data to another location. 

    Relocate master (or original in newer versions) does move and not copy the master file. Jut to make sure I just ram a test and moved some images out of the library to an external drive and they were definitely gone from the Aperture library.
    If you look at the images in the library that you moved do they have the referenced file badge? If you run a filter on your library looking for referenced files do the images you relocated show up? If you select one of the images and do a Show in Finder what does it show? Finally if you select the images and do Locate Referenced files do they appear listed as being on the volume you put them on?
    You could go into the library and look for the masters you moved to see if they are still there but if all the above show you they were relocated then I don;t think you will find them.
    How are you checking the library size? Have you quit Aperture and restarted it (better would be to log out and log back in) and then checked the size? It is possible that some of that data is cached and won't get updated till you restart.
    Finally you could do a library repair in case something got 'stuck'.

  • Windows can't wake up after closing the lid of a MBP?

    My Windows XP can't wake up after I close the lid of my MBP. When I open the lid, the screen is black and the latch light is out.

    I cannot solve your problem but I did have the same problem which has now evolved into my computer NEVER going to sleep and my bluetooth does not work I have tried all the advice I can find and nothing works. Of course my waranty expired four months ago so now I will have to come up with the money to fix it if I want this resovled. If your warenty is still good I suggest having someone look at it before it evloves into a bigger problem.

  • HP 6310 all in one, the Print Cartridge Door Hinges are broken.

    I have 2 printers HP 6310 all in one with the same problem, the Print Cartridge Door Hinges are broken.
    Were can I buy the parts? is it too difficult to change them?
    Is it a HP repair services in my area?
    Is it any "recall" for this problem? I know same peobles with the same trouble
    I thank you for your help
    geny

    Hi geny,
    I understand the cartridge door latch has broken.
    I will be happy to help you.
    This is a older model so you might not be able to get that part replaced.
    I have provided the HP Parts Surfer. It doesn't look like a replaceable part.
    If you can get it to connect and tape the door shut so the printer recognizes the door is closed, you might still be able to still use the printer.
    Hope this helps.
    Thank you for posting on the HP Forums.
    Have a wonderful day!
    Please click “Accept as Solution ” if you feel my post solved your issue, it will help others find the solution.
    Click the “Kudos Thumbs Up" on the right to say “Thanks” for helping!
    Gemini02
    I work on behalf of HP

  • HT3226 My iphone 4s fell down on the floor and a very very small bit on the edge of my iphone were broken. Can I insert a new iphone body panel with replace the old one

    My iphone 4s fell down on the floor and a very very small bit on the edge of my iphone were broken. Can I insert a new iphone body panel with replace the old one.. ???

    I think I had it on the iCloud, I just changed computers and had part of my old computer backed up, where are the default iTunes info saved like the pictures and I know my contacts were backed up cuz I kept getting updated stuff that I wasn't sure about, but it was contacts where some belonged to my wife's contacts....but anyway, if the cloud backed up contacts, it should have grabbed pictures too? Like I asked before, if they were backed up to the computer, is there a default iTunes folder they are saved to? I had a crap load of pictures on there that I usually could really access if I was connected to wi-fi. I turned off my data stuff as I only have 4GB and between me and my 2 kids, we seemed to use up a lot of it. My son would play music from Pandora during work, and use up all our data til I limited him to only 3GB, my daughter and I barely used 1GB. Anyway, thanks to everybody that is answering. I thought I might have done good finding the dang sim card, but pointless I guess.
    Ralph - F.Y.I. I would be happy to back up the iPhone if I could turn it on LOL......I am pretty positive I did, but what about Text messages? ANY of those saved too or not? Sorry guys, I don't know a **** of a lot about cell phones, but I do know about memory cards, but not sim cards that act like memory cards or look like them anyway. What is the purpose of a sim card if I may ask a stupid question since they don't hold any data from my phone stuff. I just hope my stuff comes back on the new replacement phone once I get it up and running. Again, thanks to everybody for the edumucation.

Maybe you are looking for