ITunes Truncate Track Ending, Unsolved in 2+ Years: My Letter to Steve Jobs

I have posted this problem twice in this forum. Twice they were answered with something totally irrelevant, and then marked "Solved" and deleted.
Finally, I am going to mail the CD, and this letter to Steve Jobs, to let him know personally the bug, after so many years of iTunes, and the bullish way his stuff has been treating my questions.
Dear Steve,
My name is Leping, Ph.D. in Physics, working in the San Francisco Bay area as a senior medical imaging scientist. I am a long time and loyal Mac user and promoter -- actually I have not yet really needed to use a PC in my life (except for serious music ripping -- see below), and in the graduate school days our five+ million dollar NMR lab was run from a Mac.
Unfortunately, I am also an avid classical music enthusiasts, and part time musician. Needless to say I am now with my 6th iPod, and I believe I understand all the bells and whistles of iTunes. I am not talking about the higher-level bit-wise accurate CD ripping, that is only available on the PCs, through the EAC software, since also, as a well-regarded and published photographer, I know when is the time to use the pro level applications, such as Adobe Photoshop instead of iPhoto. For my photography works please check out my website at http://www.lepingzha.com -- I will be more than glad if you and/or Apple have use of any of my images.
However, I know a long time iTunes bug, that have never been addressed. Actually I posted it twice to the Apple web discussion forums, but was twice offered irrelevant answers, followed by the subject flagged as "Solved", and subsequently deleted.
Please open the still sealed compact disc in this letter, which I got in a retailer just to show you the problem. The title, Deustsche Grammaphon (DG) B0003902, is "Lang Lang plays Rachmaninov Concerto for Piano and Orchestra No. 2 and Rhapsody on a Theme of Paganini". It happens I am a Chinese American, but I want you to listen a bit into the disc not because I am a fan of Mr. Lang's playing -- as a matter of fact I actually not, but for the much more serious reason.
Please rip the Rhapsody in iTunes, to any format (AAC, Apple Lossless (ALAC), WAV, MP3...) starting from track number 4. A few tracks after that point would be adequate -- these are very short (10-30 seconds) tracks that truly highlight the problem. Listen to the resulting music, and the original CD, you will immediately hear the big problem, start right at the end of track 4 and at the end of every of these short tracks -- fraction of the ending second(s) are harshly chopped off, brutally truncated, and uncover-ably lost.
The same thing happens anywhere I use the Apple codecs, for example, converting the EAC (bit-wise correctly, as confirmed by its check-sum feature against the known sum database) ripped WAV files to ALAC or AAC, for instance, either on a Mac or a PC. The very same thing just happen, while there is no problem to any other non-Apple codecs (mainly to flavours of MP3 -- since Apple has the AAC and ALCA codec nobody bothered to write their own, I guess). So for our serious classical listeners, the iTunes and the Apple codecs are very problematic if not useless in many cases (operas immediately in my mind)!
Please alse not that, over the time the same problem has always been reported here, there, and basically everywhere, but every time there are gurus made comments which does not solve the issue. The followings are some recent examples.
http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?messageID=6246698&#6246698
http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?messageID=6513266&#6513266
I hope you, my much respected and praised Steve, realize, that, how could, and mostly unthinkable, after so many great years, there can be still such very basic and serious issue the iTunes codecs can not handle in the right way? Does the track length information get truncated somewhere (or floored to an integer)? Why it is so difficult to acknowledge such a basic issue, and to have it fixed in the next release?
Thanks for your time and hope you enjoy the music.
Look forward to hearing from you soon.
Best regards,
Leping Zha, Ph.D.
San Mateo, California, U.S.A.

Finally found the reason: in the track's option field for some reason the "stop time" flag is checked and the timing is always about a second earlier than the actual track length.
Searched Doug's scripts and there is nothing to batch reset, or unflag the "stop time" tag. Anyone has a better idea rather than trying to deselect the tag track by track?
Once the "stop time" is unset the converted tracks will play through without truncations at the end.

Similar Messages

  • Downloaded a song from itunes and it ends almost 2 minutes early and skips to next track

    downloaded a song from itunes and it ends almost 2 minutes early and skips to next track. I deleted the song and redownloaded it from the purchased section on the itunes store three times and still have the same problem. What is the solution?

    Clear your web browser's cache, use Edit > Preferences > Advanced and tap the Reset cache button, delete the contents (if any) of ...\iTunes Media\Download, then try again.  If the problem persists contact the iTunes Store support staff through the report a problem links in your account history.
    tt2

  • Ipod stops after each track ends in a playlist?

    I have a problem: Suddenly, my ipod stops after each track ends in a playlist.  This happens with every playlist and every track, all of which worked fine until this week.  All tracks' settings are "yes" on 1) part of a compilation; 2) remember playback position and; 3) skip when shuffling.  I have not updated any software or added any new content to my ipod.  I imagine that some setting has been switched on or off, but I am unable to identify which one.  Please help as these are my audio books!  Thanks!
    nano 6th gen

    Yilofall wrote:
    I have an iPod Classic (I am fairly new to the medium) and when playing music the Pod goes smoothly from one song to the next but, when listening to a book (brought in from a CD copied into iTunes) it plays one track and stops.
    See below for a link on how to copy a CD into iTunes if you want an Audibook.
    I have tried checking the gap less album box (what is that for by the way) but it makes no difference.
    If you've heard of Dark Side of The Moon by Pink Floyd then it's used there when you want no break between tracks. Or any DJ mixed continuos play CD. Or some classical music. Take your pick
    Third question, can I make a book copied into iTunes an Audiobook? How?
    [How to Import Audio CD audiobooks into iTunes|http://aldoblog.com/audiobooks/itunes/importing-audio-cds>
    Thank you!
    No problem, hang around and read a few posts, there's always plenty to learn in here.
    Regards,
    Colin R.

  • ITune Plus tracks not showing up

    It seems to me that in the past, if I logged into my account settings in the iTunes store, there was an area where I could select "always show iTunes Plus" or something like that. I no longer see that as an option.
    This concerns me, because, for example, if I do a normal iTunes store search for "Cannanes", I see a number of tracks available for purchase, but none are available as iTunes Plus...however, if I do a "Power Search" from Quick links in the iTunes Store menus, and make sure I select "Search iTunes Plus", I see that there are 13 tracks available in this format that were previously not shown!
    What gives? Has the preference for this option changed? Is there a bug in iTunes or the iTunes store? Or is it that Apple would really prefer to not sell the iTunes Plus format, given the higher bandwidth cost and the fact that these tracks now cost the same as DRM'd songs?

    It's no longer an option since iTunes Plus tracks are the same price as the other tracks, so there's no need to turn iTunes Plus on and off. There are indeed anomalies in the display of Plus tracks, so assuming you're using the latest version of iTunes, it's probably an ongoing glitch in the iTunes Store and not anything on your end.

  • I shared my itunes account with my daughter for many years while she had only an ipod. She now has her own iphone with her own itunes account. Is it possible to transfer the purchases she made on my account over to her new itunes account?

    I shared my itunes account with my daughter for many years while she had only an ipod. She now has her own iphone with her own itunes account. Is it possible to transfer the purchases she made on my account over to her new itunes account?

    No. Purchase always remain with the account they were purchased with.

  • How to calculate first date and end date of this year in Query

    Hi Expert
    I want to calculate following dates with inputted date in query.
    I have no knowledge on ABAP and I just can create a query with simple logic.
    Could you teach me how to calculate following date?
    (If inputted date is April 12 2009)
    - First date of this year (Ex January 1 2009)
    - End date  of this year (Ex December 31 2009)
    - First date of last year (Ex January 1 2008)
    - End date of last year  (Ex December 31 2008)
    - First date of this month (Ex April 1 2009)
    Thank you!
    Take

    HR_JP_MONTH_BEGIN_END_DATE   use this FM to get the begin and end date of the Date you are passing. eg when u give input as 04/12/2009, it will return
    04/01/2009 as begin date
    04/30/2009 as end date
    pass the Year in this FM HR_E_GET_FISC_YEAR_DATES, you will get the Fiscal year Begin and End Dates
    Abh

  • When ever itunes updates, it ends up coming up with error message please re-install itunes, nothing i do seems to work, help please

    When ever iTunes updates, it ends up coming up with error message, iTunes did not install properly, please re-install iTunes, this is about the fourth time this has happened, end up having to take it to computer tech at a cost of $180, please help

    For general advice see Troubleshooting issues with iTunes for Windows updates.
    The steps in the second box are a guide to removing everything related to iTunes and then rebuilding it which is often a good starting point unless the symptoms indicate a more specific approach. Review the other boxes and the list of support documents further down the page in case one of them applies.
    Your library should be unaffected by these steps but there is backup and recovery advice elsewhere in the user tip.
    tt2

  • HT4236 Hello, does anyone have any advice on how to sort photos in an albumn on an Iphone by date of photo? I've ordered them all in my Pictures but then when I sync them across through Itunes, they all end up in a jumble on my phone. Thanks!

    Hello, does anyone have any advice on how to sort photos in an albumn on an Iphone by date of photo? I've ordered them all in my Pictures but then when I sync them across through Itunes, they all end up in a jumble on my phone. Thanks!

    When viewing an album on the iPhone you can tap "Photos" at the bottom and that will show all photos by date. Unfortunately though it is all photos, not just the album you are currently viewing.
    What I have done is the following. On the computer I have a main folder (e.g. iPhone photos) and then make sub-folders within that. Placing photos that will be synched to the iPhone into various subfolders gives quite a bit of organizational capablility. In iTunes when you select the main folder to sync, the sub-folders will show on the iPhone as separate albums. Beyond that, in one case where I really wanted a specific sort within an album I renamed the photos on the computer (something like A-picxxx, B-picxxx) so they sorted on the computer alphabetically in the order I want on the phone. That sort order was maintained after the sync.
    Note that each time you sync using iTunes, the non-Camera Roll pictures on the phone will be set to match the current iTunes settings/photos -- so you can experiment.

  • How do I get itunes music track back into album it originated from

    i have found several albums  in my itunes  having tracks that belong there  now separated  and i am unable to get them back to the album where they belong by draging them back in itunes 11 thanks fro any help I am trying to clean up my itunes library  these are ablums i have purchased and own and where imput via cd but I really don't want to go dig the cd out of storage ( pia)  why can't you just drag and drop  like I could before in previous itunes library?

    thanks i'll try to check that. I have just moved my itunes to new imac and saw that things were not very tidy

  • I've had itunes on my laptop for over a year; it seems to arbitrarily duplicate songs and now, instead of 800 songs, I have 3,500 with 2,700 being dupes.  How do I get rid of the dupes?

    I've had itunes on my laptop for over a year; it seems to arbitrarily duplicate songs and now, instead of 800 songs, I have 3,500 with 2,700 being dupes.  How do I get rid of the dupes?

    How to find and remove duplicate items in your iTunes library

  • Getting Start and End Date of Current Year?

    Hi Folks,
    How do I get the start of the year and end of the year in Java ?
    If I say :
    Calendar cal = Calendar.getInstance();
    int day = cal.get(Calendar.DATE);
    int month = cal.get(Calendar.MONTH);
    int year = cal.get(Calendar.YEAR);
    System.out.println("Day: " + day);
    System.out.println("Month: " + month);
    System.out.println("Year: " + year);
    I get the current day and time.What I need is the start of the current Year (Jan 2010) and the End of the Current Year (Dec 2010).
    How can get the above 2 dates if I the current date is March 24th 2010 ?
    Thanks

    sabre150 wrote:
    What am I missing? The start date of 2010 is 1/1/2010 and the end data is 31/12/2010 . So, as I see it, at any time the only information you need is the current year which you currently get from int year = cal.get(Calendar.YEAR);
    Well, with the GregorianCalendar, anyway. ;-)

  • Does track end jump trump chapter or story end jump?

    I have a DVD with 1 menu & 3 tracks. Tracks 1 & 2 each contain l short video (different audio or video formats) and track 3 contains 3 short videos which I have broken into 1 story w/3 chapters. On track 1, there is 1 chapter marker and I have set its end jump back to the menu. The end jump for the track itself is set to Track 2. Button 1 connection is set to the chapter marker. Ditto for track 2 except its end jump is set to track 3 while its one chapter marker end jump is set to menu 1. Button 2 is targeted to track 2, chapter 1. Track 3 has 3 chapters. It's end jump is set to menu 1. The chapters within the story are also set to menu 1 and it works the way I want it to. Button 6 is a PLAY ALL button targeted to track 1. When I select button 1, the video ends and continues on to track 2 instead of going back to menu 1;. When I select button 2, it also contiunues on (to track 3) instead of jumping back to menu 1. My goal was to be able to access each individual video and then jump back to the main menu. I tried adding stories to each of Track 1 & 2 and making the story end jump go back to he main menu but it seems the track end jump trumps both chapter & story end jumps. Anybody have any solutions to my problem? thanks.
    Steve

    Hi:
    You can do it using a script. Take the DVDSP User Manual and look for the topic Jumping to a Menu's Loop Point (Chapter 14 - Creating Scripts) and you'll find a detailed description of how to do it.
    DVDSP User Manual download page
    Hope it helps!
    (1191)
      Alberto

  • Itunes truncates my wma songs

    I imported some songs in wma format to iTunes and iTunes truncated them.
    For example for one songs Musicmatch plays (and shows) the full 3:32 wheras iTunes only plays (and shows) 3:17.
    When the song is played on my iPod or burned to a CD it remains truncated.
    Is this a bug in iTunes' wma conversion or do you know another reason for this strange behaviour?
    Windows XP Pro Itunes 6.0.4.2

    It's 'cause .wma ***** =p
    I recommend using Blaze Media Pro (www.blazemp.com) to convert the files to mp3, see if that works.
    Everything can be on default settings, but I'd recommend using 192 bitrate. 128 to 192 is safe but if it's music where it gets loud or you'll be playing it on a high quality stereo you'll notice the difference between 128 and 192.
    Post back with your results =)

  • How transfor the year ending balances to next year

    hi,
    Now i am  learn in SAP FICO.
    i want how transfor the year ending balance to next year
    i am waiting for answar
    thanks

    Hi,
    Up to 4.7 use T.code for Transfer GL Balances F.16,
    ECC use T.Code: FAGLGVTR
    Customer & Vendor Balances: F.07
    Asset A/C:
    Close Fiscal Year: AJAB
    Open New Year: AJRW
    Regards,
    Viswa

  • Function module to find start date and end date of fiscal year for company

    Hi,
    Is there any function module exist which will provide me start date and end date of fiscal year for company code and fiscal year provided?
    Thanks & Regards,
    Parag

    Hi,
    please check this link
    it would be very useful
    http://www.sapdevelopment.co.uk/fmodules/fms_fiscalyr.htm
    Thanks and regards
    durga.K

Maybe you are looking for