Jagged Text from Motion to FCP5

Hi.. still having trouble with jagged text from Motion 2.1.2 to FCP 5.1.2 (OSX 10.4.8), PAL DV 720 x 576. Would very much appreciate some insight. I have done a butterfly animation with some lense flares and text. Concept is butterflies come in from off screen and land on attractor to reveal text message with lense flare behind. Views great in Motion on fit to screen, resolution fine. But import as .mtn to FCP and text very disappointing, very noticeably having trouble with resolution, even noticeable on Viewer and Canvas, but really awful in full screen Digital Cinema Desktop Review because the text is so obviously not 576 lines. Something is happening in the import to destroy it despite trying everything I could see in this forum. I can actually count the lines on full screen, enough to estimate I am only getting approx 230 vertical lines instead of 576.
In both Preferences/Presets and Project Properties PAL I have set Broadcast SD 720 x 576, Pixel Aspect Ratio PAL D1/DV 1.07 , Lower (Even), 25 fps. Under Project Properties I have additionally tried 16 bit, and under Render, set anti-aliasing to Best, and tried switching on and off Dithering, and also increased motion blur to 50. I have also switched off interlacing (to None) in both Motion and FCP as one forum comment suggested. In FCP I import the clip as a .mtn file, and change properties to Premultiplied Black and Lower/Even line order prior to dragging into Viewer and then Canvas. But the Motion text already looks jagged in both these screens before I even render in the timeline. I learned a while back under Avid XPress Pro to give text gentle movement diagonally in order to create the illusion of higher resolution than if motionless. But once in FCP, it "wobbles" very noticeably as the application attempts to blur the distinction between the 230 vertical lines on the screen. As I mentioned above, it plays perfectly in Motion on a full screen, with no obvious degradation in vertical resolution, but it's very disappointing once in FCP.
In FCP I have tried just about every setting, but nothing so far addresses this problem. The main settings are 720 x 576 CCIR 601/DV PAL (5:4) Pixel Aspect Ratio CCIR 601 (720 x 576). I've been careful to also check Sequence Settings in addition to User Prefs, Audio & Video Settings and also System Settings. Under Sequence Settings/Video Processing I have tried RGB, YUV 8 Bit and high precision YUV in case that made a difference. I also did several exports to Quicktime .mov, including trying Lossless + Alpha, but no difference, and in any case that work around loses ability to update on the fly if something is chnaged in Motion.
Perhaps I have missed something obvious. I would very mcuh appreciate any assistgance before I go back and delete the text from Motion and do it in FCP instead. I really hope tht others have found solution which works within Motion. I have enjoyed crteating the animations and it will be a great product if I can do the text within Motion and export without loss to FCP.
Thanks heaps...

Thank you so much for all your replies and interest in my problem - very helpful. I have just come up for air (after several long nights of editing) and the project went out on time, RUN LIVE FROM MY MBP. Your replies saved me a lot of time, pointing out that the resolution was actually ok (for SD), but I just wasn't seeing it on FCP because it was only showing one field, and scaled at that. I firstly tried playing back with the Canvas settings suggested by Mark and it appeared as smooth as it did within Motion. Then I tried viewing on an external monitor via Firewire - all resolution great (at least for SD).
Typically I publish on DVD, but the above tests gave me enough confidence to print to DV tape as a backup (and I loved the user interface - so easy to add bars and tone etc). But I took the risk of running my MBP live at the event, complete with my SATA RAID ) drives and the M-Audio 1418, which I found worked really nicely daisy chained off my DSR-11 deck. This produced far better sound for the live event and gave me enough comfort that I could always run directly off the DSR11 if any of my computer gear failed. The second advantage was that it allowed me to cue precisely synchronised with the live drama, from which the butterflies flew onto the screen - exactly on time as the talent opened the gift box on stage. If you've tried to cue from dvd or dv deck you'll know what I mean. Some consumer dvd players go to sleep if the standby period is too long, and the DSR11 creeps along frame by frame to save tape wear, which can really get in the way of live events. Also, I foudn that the DSR11 needs to be cued at time code prior to the intended start point in order to allow adequate sound buffering.
But with my MBP set up - it was the easiest incorporation of video in to a live event that I had ever done. It worked flawlessly - all I had to do was hit the MBP space bar as the talent guestured with her hand out of the gift box onto the screen - butterflies flying out exactly on time.
Thanks again everybody.

Similar Messages

  • Jagged text from DVD studio pro

    Hi,
    I have created a number of sequences in Final Cut Pro and in the beginning of each sequence I have added a text (chapter name) with the font Zapfino.
    When exporting to quicktime in 720 x 1280 the type looks beautiful when I play back the .mov file.
    I am importing my sequences to DVD studio pro for playback on television .
    The type from Final Cut looks pixelated, jagged and terrible after the encoding. I added text in DVD pro to the menu page. That text looks fine.
    I can not find a setting in DVD pro that looks like it will render the text better.
    I have heard that the interlacing can damage text.
    Can anyone help?
    I created my menu page in Photoshop with a image that is 720 x 1080 pixels in 72 dpi.
    The first time around I created a title in Photoshop. That one looked terrible as well.
    Secondly I created the title in DVD pro and as mentioned that looks good.
    Do you recommend higher resolution than 72 dpi for a menu page?
    Thank you on beforehand.
    ggaarde

    Sorry I meant to say that my PS image was 720 x 1280 (not 720 x 1080)
    It shouldn't be that size if you are making a SD DVD Menu. If you have later versions of Photoshop start a new blank project with pixel aspect ratio on for what you are doing (NTSC 4:3, NTSC 16 x 9 ) etc.
    Other take a look at the guidelines in the manual for creating menus (For NTSC 4:3 720 x 534 and rescale to 720 x 480 without constraining proportions.) You are best off rescaling outside DVD SP and not letting DVD SP scale.
    Also look at this [link|http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?messageID=10682141&#10682141]

  • Scrolling text from motion too fast in fcp

    Help!
    I tried using motion 4 for scrolling text but it scrolls too fast... it scrolls perfect speed in motion  but when I open it up in fcp 7.0 it goes faster.
    my sequence settings match for fcp and motion 4.
    I have tried auto, custom and fixed .
    I have played with scroll rate mulitplier
    I have shortened and lengthened the timeline
    I have gone to some video's on setting this up i.e. vtc.com/products/AppleMotion4/Text/90443 and other videos... nothing I do seems to slow it down,.
    Thank you for your assistance
    kfcman

    Hey Michael,
    Yes frame rates are the same.

  • Bad looking text going from Motion to Flash

    I'm creating a project in Motion which the client wants to play in Flash.
    My work flow is 1) Export from Motion (uncompressed+animation codec) 2) Open in Quicktime 3) Export to .FLV using the Flash encoder (highest Quality)
    Everything looks fine but I have red text on a white background and it is dithering horribly.
    Any suggestions are appreciated--
    Thanks

    hi,
    two things really, flash can look really horrible depending on the data rate you've used to create it. So you could try upping that until things look crisper. Obviously then you get bigger files.
    Also red text on a white background is notorious in video for looking crap. Personally I would try any one or all of the following:
    change the colour of the font/ and or the background.
    change the font, and its size.
    change everything.
    or and another thing, why export out to to a quicktime from motion. Why not use compressor from motion to create the .flv. I assume you have flash and all the codecs since you are making the .flvs already.
    ( on a related note - recently I have had a problem where files created from motion via compressor change fonts - however if i drag the motion file into fcp and export via compressor there its all fine - weird)
    hth
    adam

  • FCP not reading templates correctly from Motion (Urgent)

    Hi all,
    I am trying to work in FCP (6.06) with templates created in Motion 3.0.2 But FCP seems to be seeing video drop zones as text layers!?
    If I use a pre-existing template (or one I have created), when I bring it in to FCP I get the correct amount of input dialogue boxes for the amount of layers in the template, but regardless of whether they are drop zones or text layers the control dialogue box in FCP looks the same and I am unable to actually get anything to appear correctly on the timeline. It's driving me nuts!!
    Also: when I have a template on my FCP timeline I am unable to save the project! I delete the template from the timeline and am able to save the project again...
    Even weirder: I'm getting the same result on two machines!!
    Any Ideas what could be causing this!? (i've tried software update and re-start)
    Best
    GK

    Thank you to those who replied. By further process of elimination I have discovered that Motion does not recognize the ProRes 4444 Alpha Channel. When using a clip with the Animation Codec, it reads the alpha channel perfectly. The ProRes 4444 Clips I exported from Motion with Alpha work perfectly in After Effects ... so clearly Apple has a bug to fix

  • Best way to edit text in Motion 5?

    I am using Motion 5 and a Template (from Motion VFX), and had trouble editing the text in this one text field. I couldn't just click in the Canvas and edit the text; it would just create another text box.
    I am trying to get out of the habit of just clicking on the canvas, and I want new ways to edit text.
    I searched and I found one way. I would use the "Find and Replace" tool (Command and F), and then search for the text string, and have it edit it. Is this the best way in everyone's opinion? Are there other ways I can edit text fields? Any tips?
    Thanks,
    Craig G from DC

    Select the Text "layer" in the layers column; select the Text tab in the inspector; select the Format button at the top and change the Text in the Text field at the bottom.
    BTW, that text field is publishable for FCPX from the disclosure triangle that appears when you mouse over that space with the "Text" header.

  • Export/Import From Motion to FCP

    Hello
    I'm new to this forum and have just recently begun working in the film and video industry. I am also new to the Apple community. So please excuse any misuse of terms as am not fully integrated into the business yet. I have created a background that has a lot of motion as well as an emitter in it and duplicating the sequence didn't seem to be the way to go. So I looped the sequence to run for 90 minutes. I am trying to decide if there is a need to export the file from motion as a quicktime file or should I just import the motion document into FCP and overlay my text elements (also created in motion) on V2. Any help would be greatly appreciated.
    By the way thanks to Patrick for all you great "fun with" projects they have been a great help in learning Motion.

    Thanks for your input. What I'm building is a sponsor loop for a banquet. I needed a 90 minute graphics bed over which to apply my text and logo elements. I ended up modify and existing 15 sec clip from the motion library tossing in an emitter and looping it for 90 minutes.
    The problem was the sheer size of the file and the time it took to render if FCP. I ended up exporting the file as an 8 bit uncompressed QT movie so I wouldn't have to rerender it in FCP. It took about 2 1/2 hours but in the end it worked out.
    Here is a follow up question. I have finished the text and logo element that goes over the bed but when the time comes to import the Motion file into FCP I have to render every time I put it into the timeline. I realize that the first time it appears it's necessary but is there a way to get around that having to let the thing render over night as this clip will be copied 44 times and each copy takes about 6 minutes to render.
    I was thinking about exporting it as a QT file from motion just like the background but then I can't get the title sequence to appear over the backgound the way I would like as a QT element compared to Motion element. Tranparency issues.
    Any and all suggestions will be greatly appreciated.

  • How to get printed manuals with upgrade to FCP from Motion?

    I upgraded my standalone version of Motion to FCP 5.1 Universal through the mail and wondering how I can get the printed manuals. I realize it's not practical for Apple to mail 40 pounds of books and that the same text is probably on one of the DVDs but reading a physical book makes learning easier than reading on screen.
    Has anyone been able to upgrade from Motion to FCP and get the printed books?
    Thanks,
    DAN
    PowerBook G4   Mac OS X (10.4.4)  

    David,
    Apple provides manuals with most of it's software. I KNOW THIS OCCURS FOR A FACT! Thanks for posting your doubts and other notes but I don't think they are really being crafted towards helping at this point.
    I was actually hoping others might have found solutions rather than looking for salt to rub into the wound. But to help you and the others you have spoken with to understand possible solutions I'm hoping might remedy the problem here are a few that suggestions:
    - Call Apple Customer Support and get them to exchange the misrepresented product through the mail for what was represented.
    - Walking into the Apple store and confronting the sales people with the issue and getting them to exchange the product.
    - Working through Consumer Affairs and getting them to eiother refund or exchange the product.
    - Calling a local TV station to report the fact that Apple shows one product on their web site and in their stores while selling something different with a the same name that is incomplete.
    - Working through the Better Business Bureau to file a complaint against Apple for the misrepresentation and getting them to replace the product for the abused customers.
    - Emailing the support folks at Apple and getting a emailed voucher in return which will allow users to exchange the product int stores.
    I can think of dozens of ways Apple or other organizations could help resolve the situation.
    Printing a color manual at Kinko's seems like a ridiculous expense to me. I cannot afford it and I appreciate you not consistently saying it's a viable solution. I'm actually a bit surprised that you keep responding with no help, confusing unrelated comments, and insist on further irritating the situation.
    I hope my multiple attempts to help you understand what my issue is and possible solutions that people might offer has helped clarified things for you. If you have any further comments though please reserve them so others who may have had actual experiences similar to mine with possible solutions might be able to read this thread without having to see me explaining things over and over.
    Thanks,
    DAN

  • Importing Media from Motion 5

    Why all of a sudden do all of my imports from Motion 5 have a black background?
    They won't properly super as before.  I have everything in Motion set as transparent too!
    What am I doing wrong here?  I just want text over my subject (shot on green) keyed over white to show words.
    Help!

    No 422 as always.
    I'm now trying the Final Cut Title set up in Motion.  I've done one and it still doesn't show as transparent over they layers beneath it in FCPX.  Still see black file that won't reveal the layers below it.

  • Sending text to Motion does nothing but open a new file

    I'm editing in FCP and created a text object, carefully placing it in exactly the right position. I right click on the text in the timeline and choose "Send to Motion" but all it does is open a new file. Seems to me it should have actually "sent the text" to Motion as it implies. Did they really not include this feature? Otherwise, its pretty darn meaningless.
    Now it seems like I have to re-typeset the text, and go back and forth until I get the placement right again. So much for simplified workflows!

    Your fundamental approach to this is wrong.
    Tom has already pointed out that Motion is a graphics and text animation tool (amongst other things).
    If your point of reference for positioning text is based on the content of the video track below it -send the video clip to Motion and apply the text there, where you can also apply any number of effects to it. Motion has access to exactly the same typefaces that FCP has and a few more in the form of "LiveFonts".
    If you wish to have the animated text as a separate element, you can simply delete the video from the background layer in Motion once the positioning and timing has been established. If it needs to be tweaked or changed completely, simply right click it on the FCP Timeline and choose Open in Editor. This will launch Motion with the text project loaded automatically.
    So consider it a suggestion for future versions of FCS. (If these posts filter up to the right people!)
    They don't. Apple Discussions participants are all users, just like you.

  • Dunning Proposal - Accounting Text from vendor Master

    Hi,
    In F150, if you click on the change button, it will take you to Dunning proposal and on the selection screen, you have a check point Check Account long text and Check Document Long Text..
    1. What is the difference between the two?
    2. When you execute this Dunning Proposal, again you get a button for Change Texts, from where the texts can be maintained for each Vendor.. The requirement is to have the text displayed in the output report of Dunning Proposal against each vendor.. How is that possible? I changed Variant to bring in the field Text but it shows blank.
    Regards,
    SAPFICO
    Edited by: SAPFICO on Apr 4, 2011 12:18 PM

    Hi All,
    Any Pointers???
    Regards,
    SAPFICO
    Edited by: SAPFICO on Apr 8, 2011 7:22 AM

  • I made my own apple id because my family was getting my texts from other people. I want to add my device to my dads find my iphone app on his icloud but can't figure out how, without having to log in to his apple id on my phone. how do i add my device?

    I made my own Apple ID because when I was logged into my dad's my family was receiving my texts from other people. I want to add my device to my dad's "find my iphone" app but without signing into his Apple ID on my phone because that was causing them to get my texts. I was told by Apple I could add my device to his by signing into icloud.com but there is no option that I can find to add my device. And I don't want to log back in to his.. Any ideas???

    Also when I apply the safety copy it only imports the app the phones have had in common, so none of the apps that only the iPhone 4 had doesn't come in, only the ones I and the iPhone 4 has had in common. So you say the only way I can use the Apple ID to download on the old iPhone 4 is if I delete the apps that are in the phone and then download them again? How will that change the ID to download/update from. Won't it still have mine to update/download from?

  • My phone has been smashed I need to get records of all my iMessages and texts from the last month. How do I get these?

    My phone has been smashed I need to get records of all my iMessages and texts from the last month. How do I get these?

    Do you have a backup of your iPhone which contains these messages?
    If so, you can restore a new iPhone from that backup during setup.
    If not, the messages are gone.

  • When I attempt to send a text from the new iPad, a dialog box appears with the option to either sign in with Apple ID Password or Create New Account. I try signing in using my Apple ID password but IMessage informs me that email address cannot be verified

    When I attempt to send a text from the new iPad, a dialog box appears with the option to either sign in with Apple ID Password or Create New Account. I try signing in using my Apple ID password but IMessage informs me that email address cannot be verified because it is already in use ??? What am I doing wrong?

    settings -> iTunes & App Store
    click on apple ID listed there
    select Sign Out
    sign in with the proper account
    from then on, when the store ask for your password it should be with the correct ID

  • I switched from an iPhone to a Droid and can't receive texts from iPhones now, help?

    I switched from my iPhone 4s to a Droid and I do not have that phone anymore. I can not recieve texts from anyone with an iPhone and can not get in contact with my girlfriend or siblings now. I think their phones are trying to send their texts as iMessages to my phone that does not recieve iMessages. How can I just delete my Apple account and recieve texts again?

    Sounds like you didn't turn of iMessage on your iPhone before making the switch.  If you registered your iPhone with Apple using a support profile, try going to https://supportprofile.apple.com/MySupportProfile.do and unregistering it.  Also, try changing the password associated with the Apple ID that you were using for iMessage.

Maybe you are looking for

  • Error while updating the status record of IDOC in SAP

    Hi All, I am facing this problem. I have done outbound processing and IDOC was sent successfully from SAP to EDI system and it was processed in EDI and now EDI system wants to send the status back to SAP with a status message and the status number th

  • Suddenly can't open .eps files in FW8

    Hi all- I suddenly can't open .eps files in FW8.  Starts to open and then says "Internal error occurred"  Text tool is also acting up.   I think it may be related to one of the extensions I downloaded  from the Adobe Exchange.  Or, maybe it was somet

  • Fixed length file to xml file

    Hi, Fixed length file to xml files. i have to generate 2 xml files based on a field in the incoming file. structures of both xml files are same. I want to know how many target data type ,target msg interfaces have to be created? Thanks.

  • Slow broadband from the 07/06/10 and still got to ...

    well it looks like i am not the only one have been told 27 times that i should be getting 11.8meg in but only get 2.2meg down by 2meg before up grade plus hub lights are like a dicso just flash most of the time on second new hub and that don't work s

  • How to get good picture quality on a burned DVD slideshow using IDVD?

    After producing a slideshow on IDVD from either jpg or psd photos, it looked great when I played the project. Picture quality was excellent. When I burned a DVD to share the slideshow with a friend and when I played this on the same computer, it had