Leave the extra graphics card in or out?

I just bought a new Mac Pro and added the 4870 card. I use a 2 display setup, so I was wondering whether I should leave the nvidia card installed, add my HD 3870, or leave just the 4870 card in? I want max performance, but I am concerned that adding an additional card will not add performance, only more communication tasks for the system.
Does anyone know what the pros and cons are?
Many thanks.
Message was edited by: Nicholas Dawes

I'm running the stock GT120 as well as the Quadro FX 4800. I also have an eSATA controller installed in one of the PCIe slots and have one free slot for future expansion. The Quadro card requires a double slot so I have it installed at the bottom.
FYI - I'm also running three displays. If you don't require three, you'd probably be better off with the single card.
As for driver issues, I have none as both are nVidia cards.

Similar Messages

I am trying to find out the proper graphic card for mac.

I am trying to find out the proper graphic card for imac. The graphic card which is mentioned in the web sit, that Graphic Card is not available in the open market. In open market NVIDIA GeForce GT 750M and NVIDIA GeForce GT 755M is available and this card is not mentioned in web site. So please help to select a proper suitable GPU.

Are they supportable for After Effects ray-traced 3d renderer.
I am confused because adobe recommended on the following graphic card.
Mac OS
GeForce GTX 285
GeForce GTX 675MX
GeForce GTX 680
GeForce GTX 680MX
GeForce GT 650M
Quadro CX
Quadro FX 4800
Quadro 4000
Quadro K5000

HT4664 What is the best graphics card for FCPX?

In the nonstop anti-FCPX propaganda is an article of interest — posted 7/9/12 — comparing the benchmarks of FCPX and PP6.
http://www.streamingmedia.com/Producer/Articles/ReadArticle.aspx?ArticleID=83582 &PageNum=1
The system used was a 2 x 2.93 GHz Quad-Core Mac Pro from early 2009 running MacOS X version 10.7.4 with 12 GB of RAM and an NVIDIA Quadro FX 4800 graphics card with 1.5 GB of onboard RAM.
In most cases PP6 outperformed FCPX with this configuration. However, in the comments Ben Balser pointed out that FCP X's A/VFoundation engine wasn't ideal on the NVIDA card:
"Quadro is actually not the best card for FCP X's A/VFoundation engine, but great for CS6's Mercury engine, so the test is amazingly flawed right there. Try both on a 5780 card and watch things drastically change. I've done that test myself. Exporting to Compressor uses a MUCH more sophisticated encoding engine meant for higher level, professional transcoding, not simple outputs, which are faster using Export Media…"
Apple lists this card on its support page: http://support.apple.com/kb/HT4664
So,
What is the best graphics card for FCPX?

Ben,
Thanks for chiming in on that article. It would be good to have a benchmark comparison with the two systems each with a preferred card.
I'm hoping to see some other comparisons on this thread. Also, some links to other articles about best practices and configurations.

What is the best Graphic Card Option for me?

I have a first generation Quad Core Mac Pro with a Radeon X1900XT with dual DVI Connections for my two older Apple 24" LCD Displays. I want the best card to run Adobe CS5 and support dual DVI for my 2 monitors. I was told maybe the ATI 4870 or 5770. What would be the best card for CS5 and Final Cut Studio?

300 dollars.. 250 for the backplane board(661-5706), and for the single processor tray(661-5707) - your price may vary.. I got mine for 50 dollars.
so, for 300 dollars.. you can make your 2009 mac pro into a 2010.. and yes, you can use the same existing processors.. the good news is that 1333 mhz memory works with the following processors in the new board: W3570, W3580(High end 3.33 2009 mac pro quad which was 1400.00 extra as a configure to order on apple's store from a 2.66 quad-core at 2499.99), and finally the W3680.
I am running still my w3580 with now 8GB of DDR3 1333 mhz memory.. it was 1066, but i got 1333 for a great price..
If you want to know more information about this, please send me a private email.
I can help you if you want..
Please note: if you have the 4870 HD Apple version, and not pc flashed, the sensor reading is too high for the 2010's firmware... you will need the GT120 or the 5770 graphics card.. 5870 is not going to be available for sometime and there is rumor from AMD themselves stating the card might be EOL..

Off-the-shelf graphics cards... any luck with Lion?

I've been hearing online ramblings about Lion being compatible with some off-the-shelf graphics cards and Wikipedia says the Radeon 6XXX HD cards are compatible, but has anybody tried any cards that aren't clearly labeled as Mac compatible? I know, I know, only the "Made for Mac" cards are supposed to work but I'm hearing too much online to be satisfied with that response at this point.
The GT 120 is just tired and I want the power of the 5870, but $400+ feels unfair. I know it's only been out for a day, but I'm already itching to hear if anybody has tried anything new with Lion.

Tried a XFX HD 4670 Radeon. Once booted everything works fine. Here are my findings:
No boot up screen (therefore ability to change start up drive) expected based on other discussions
The card seems to think that I have a second monitor connected - and I was not able to find a way to make it think otherwise.
Overall the card was speedy and boosted my xbench and geekbench scores - but for now I am back to my GT120..
MacPro 2009 4,1 8 GB RAM OSX 10.7

What's the best graphic card i can update my 1.8Ghz G5 to?

Any advice on the best graphic card i could update too (AGP x8 slot i think)? I've had a hard time finding out my available wattage on my power supply (not listed in About This Mac menu). The ATI Radeon X1900 looks good but i can't find any compatability sites for my Mac. I'm thinking around the $200-300 dollar range. I need something to help me get by while i save up for a new mac next year...I need to be able to run all the latest Final Cut & Motion apps. Any help would be appreciated!
Thanks.

Best graphic card for your model is the nVidia Geforce 6800 Ultra DDL which is plenty fast for Aperture and Motion and can support two 30" displays.
Second best option is the ATI X800 XT for Power Mac G5 and the 6800 Ultra GT model - both of these can drive only one 30" display.
Forget about the ATI 9600 XT and 9800 XT. I've upgraded from the ATI 9600 to the Geforce 6800 Ultra and I'm glad to have even found one on the market. My scrolling and viewing thru large photos don't lag and I don't have to wait for things to be rendered.
With the price point you are budgeting, I doubt you will find one on the market. I ordered from We Love Macs an ATI X800 two weeks ago and they led me to believe they had one in stock when I spoke to a person. Then when my order went thru I was told they only have it on order and cannot tell me exactly when. In fact I also have on order until now from JR.com another X800 for months already and all they do is just say my order is delayed.
I gave up and bought from eBay instead. The way these cards are even available for our extinct model, I doubt they will produce more.
The cards above are getting rare and unless they find a boatload hiding somewhere all along they will never go down in price. So if you keep holding off like I did, all I saw was prices going up.
eBay has one on sale right now for the Geforce 6800 Ultra DDL for USD400. With only one on sale, I don't think it will last long at that price. When that's gone, you can go the WeLoveMacs route for the same card which they are selling for USD799.95.

How do I use the secondary graphics card on a mac book pro with retina display?

I know that this is kind of a stupid question but I am new to dual graphics cards and this is the first mac that I have ever had, so I don't understand how you use the 2nd graphics card. When I click on the apple logo and go to about it shows the Intel Graphics HD 4000, but I know that they put an Nvida in here to so how do I access that? Because it has a lot more graphic power than the intel does.

Try opening iPhoto and then consulting the More Info... item. That app will cause an autoswitch to the big GPU.
Same will happen with any other app that requires that kind of display driving power.

Efilogin-helper requires for the discrete graphic card

After updating to the latest version of osx on my 2014 macbook pro 15.
There is a process named efilogin-helper always requesting for the discrete graphic card and taking the energy and CPU..
Is there any solution to fix this problem??

I have to use a software to change the graphic card to integrated one only..

How much better is the new Graphic Card?

How much better is the new graphic card compared to the X1600 256mb in the older 2.33 Core 2 duo's? Im a gamer and was wondering if there is gonna be a big difference or just a small difference?

Hi,
according to this there seems to be a big advantage: http://www.apple.com/macbookpro/graphics.html
(Scroll down to the bottom).
Regards
Stefan

How can I get the extra graphics under artwork in Photoshop elements?

I got an old laptop running and have PSE installed. I used to use it a lot for the graphics, backgrounds and frames. A bunch of them have a blue ribbon across the upper right corner and when I try to use them it ask to me to sign it to photoshop.com. I am aware that Photoshop.com has been depreciated. Is there anyway to get access to the extra graphics, frames, backgrounds, etc...?

Thanks for the reply Barbara B. I am sure someone has a copy. Hint, hint adobe. I see when you right click one of these you have an option to make available offline. Does anyone have these offline. I found the default ones in the C:\Documents and Settings\All Users\Application Data\Adobe\Photoshop Elements\**.0\Photo Creations\graphics.

Do I need the discrete graphics card?

I'm buying a 15" macbook pro in the next couple of weeks. I do lots of work on Adobe Lightroom and Photoshop. Do I need to get the top model with the discrete graphics card or is it not worth the money?

No, it's certainly not geared for gaming! If you do a lot of Photoshop work with 3D renderings, actions, etc., a discrete GPU can be great - particularly one with 2GB of Video RAM. If I were in the market for a new machine, I would certainly purchase the unit that has the discrete GPU.
Clinton

What's the best graphics card without upgrading PSU?

I know the K430 JU has a wimpy 280 watt power supply. I don't want to go through hassle of replacing the PSU, due to I won't be able to have the front lights or the top speed shifter working.
However, I might be interested in getting a better graphics card. Considering the power supply, what's the best graphics card I could use that wouldn't make the system overheat?

Go here and enter your system details, followed by adding in a graphics card in the range you might like.
If the wattage is too high, keep decreasing the card specs until you get something that falls in the range of 200-240W.
After this, you must check the requirements of the card. Make sure that the +12V rail has enough amperage for your card. My 280W PSU has 18A on +12V.
It would be better if you upgrade the PSU to a good branded one, as it would be more hassle with a new video card that refused to run because of an inadequate power supply.Replacing the PSU is quite straightforward, and will save you a lot of problems in the long run.
The P9 connector is responsible for supplying power to the speedshifter. You could maybe find an adapter, but I'm not sure. By default, turbo is set to AUTO so you shouldn't notice any differences playing in game.

What's the better graphics card?

The Radeon HD 6750M (1GB) from the 2011 macbook pros or the nVidia Geforce GT 650m (1GB) in the current refresh?

Depends what you're going to use it for.
The Nvidia Geforce GT650M will be a faster graphic card.
But the Radeon will have a better video quality.
The way graphic cards are built now however, it's hard to find the difference in video quality since they're all pretty fast.

Error: The installed graphics card does not meet the minimum requirements for Aperture.

I have been using Aperture for nearly 5 years on my MAC Book Pro. I suddenly am getting this message and Aperture will not launch. Any ideas?
This is my graphics
NVIDIA GeForce 9400M:
Chipset Model:    NVIDIA GeForce 9400M
Type:    GPU
Bus:    PCI
VRAM (Total):    256 MB
Vendor:    NVIDIA (0x10de)
Device ID:    0x0863
Revision ID:    0x00b1
ROM Revision:    3427
Displays:
Color LCD:
Resolution:    1280 x 800
Pixel Depth:    32-Bit Color (ARGB8888)
Main Display:    Yes
Mirror:    Off
Online:    Yes
Built-In:    Yes
Display Connector:
Status:    No Display Connected

There are actually two graphic cards in the system, the one you show in your post and one part of the motherboard.
This is done on laptops to help save battery, when the system does need need high performance graphics, when it is doing text it uses the integrated graphics card, when it needs to do high performance graphics like when running Aperture it switches to the other card.
It is possible something is wrong with your system preventing it from switching. What OS version are you running, is it really 10.6.4?
See MacBook Pro: How to determine which graphics processor is in use to determine which GPU is in use. But if it is not switching you most likely have a hardware problem.

Error: The installed graphics card does not meet the minimum system requirements by Aperture

I have a Mac Pro 3.1 10.5.8 and Aperture 2.1.4. My NVida 8800gt with 512 mb was over heating so I brought and install the ATI radeon hd 5770 to replace it. Now when I try to start Aperture I get this message "Error: The installed graphics card does not meet the minimum system requirements by Aperture". All other software works fine, ie photoshop elements and Safari. When I install my old card aperture will open with no problem, but of course the card will overheat within 10 mins and I will have no video. I have search on google with no luck. Will upgrading to Aperture 3 fix this problem?

5770 requires 10.6.5.
The 8800GT - there is the 350* bake in over 10 minutes - 50% or better chance
you can find 8800GT on http://myworld.ebay.com/macvidcards/
http://www.macupdate.com/info.php/id/23049/smcfancontrol
http://www.bresink.com/osx/HardwareMonitor.html
Fan control helps with FBDIMMs which need to be kept under 70C too.

Leave the extra graphics card in or out?

Similar Messages

Maybe you are looking for