Lightroom not a one-stop shop for Pro Photographers

The claim to fame purports to make this a one-stop processing shop for Photographers.
Most photographers prefer to send their post-processed files to the lab. And if they really know their stuff, they are probably profiling their images to the lab printers. This is where LR fails miserably.
To make my point, I will start off by explaining how RawShooter worked (RawShooter was purchased by Adobe and after major surgical procedure sold as Lightroom):
For Rawshooter:
1. Open the RAW file.
2. Choose the profile of the printer I wish to use for the final output. This results in a significant color shift to the image as seen on the screen. After all, the benefit of the profile is to ensure that What You See Is What You Get (WYSIWYG).
3. Make changes to the image so that the final output is to your liking. (remember, the RAW files themselves are never modified. All you do is create offset points and save that data seperately)
4. Export to JPG
5. Send image to the lab with an assurance that WYSIWYG.
With Lightroom:
1. Open the RAW file
2. No ability to choose a printer profile.
3. Make changes to the image with no idea how the final output is going to look. (remember, the RAW files themselves are never modified. All you do is create offset points and save that data seperately)
4. Export to JPG
5. Send image to lab with the hope you like what you get (HYLWYG)
So, LR cannot be a one-stop shop for processing and printing RAW files. Any one who understands the importance of printer profiles would demand a WYSIWYG image to which one can apply the changes.
Rawshooter was much better at this.

My chip was largely from the way the Pixmantec acquisition was handled. I think everyone felt that was a real issue. George and Tom (and probably others) started the turnaround with the announcement of the freebie for RSP users.
The other issue was that there really wasn't much for Windows users at the time (which was every RSP user). B3 came out and was pretty, umm..., in need of help. Then B4 came out and we started to see how fast the team was working. B4 was impressive from that standpoint, but a disaster in another way - it would only run for 5-10 minutes at a time before crashing for me. That was frustrating because I could see the improvements, but not use the tool. But the fact that we had started to see movement in a positive direction (instability not withstanding) started to turn attitudes around, at least for me.
Since I've been a tester I've seen more first hand how dedicated and hard working the team actually is. 1.0 was far from perfect, either from a QE standpoint or from a feature standpoint. But it's more movement. When you see two positive changes in a short time, you start to see a pattern.
I still see both detail and fundamental problems with LR. But now I'm just trying like crazy to help the team move forward, one little bit at a time, in what little way I can. Given the team's dedication, I have no doubt that we'll get "there" (wherever that is) as long as they get continued support from Adobe management.
I still think you jump on people too quickly, Jeff. I think you should give people one strike (like you did with me) instead of calling them out after the first one. Answer an overly-aggressive post with kindness. If you get more flames back, then that's different. But sometimes you get useful information instead. You never get that when you respond with flames! You're too darned useful for us little guys not to be getting the full benefit of your experience.

Similar Messages

  • How does one stop Safari for Windows from auto resetting itself?

    Safari for Windows running on XP Pro SP2 on a Dell Latitude D520
    gets its settings reset automatically somehow. Also, the saved
    userids/passwords randomly get "lost". These behaviors occur whether the
    system is left running (with Safari terminated) then Safari is
    started or when the the system is put in sleep mode (with Safari
    terminated) and Safari is started after waking the system or when
    the system is put into hibernate state (with Safari terminated) and then
    Safari is started when the system is woken from hibernation. The
    resetting and lost UIDs/PWDs is a random occurrence; it may, or may
    not, occur after any one of the three use cases described above.
    This behavior is becoming very annoying and will cause me to dump
    Safari for Windows as my patience wears thin.
    Any known solutions or suggestions will be greatly, and gratefully, appreciated.

    [[How to fix preferences that won't save]] may help

  • Can not generate one xsd file  for message type in xi

    Dear Experts.
    I am not able to generate  one XSD file from  message type from XI 3.0, When i select message type and go to XSD tab  then click on export xsd to file, it is generating two xsd files MainSchema.xsd,  Schema1.xsd  into one zip file, but i need only one xsd file to import it into MDM.
    Could you please help
    Thanks and Regards.
    Sravya.
    The following are the two files. MainSchema.xsd,  Schema1.xsd .

    Hi Harsha,
    Thanks lot for the immediate response. Appreciate it.
    Now I am able to generate the one xsd with your inputs , but i am not able to load it into mdm with out any changes in the generated XSD from Message Type. the below is only the original root tag, where modification required.
    Original  Element : MDM_CUST_MASTER_FILE_REQUEST_MT
    ==============
    <xsd:schema xmlns:xsd="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema" xmlns="urn:abc.com:MDM_Customer_Master_ECC" targetNamespace="urn:abc.com:MDM_Customer_Master_ECC">
    <xsd:element name="MDM_CUST_MASTER_FILE_REQUEST_MT" type="MDM_CUST_MASTER_FILE_REQUEST_DT" />
    etc.
    Case :.When i modify the above element as below  with out xmlns, targetNamespace
    <xsd:schema xmlns:xsd="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema">
    <xsd:element name="MDM_CUST_MASTER_FILE_REQUEST_MT" type="MDM_CUST_MASTER_FILE_REQUEST_DT" />
    I can import xsd into mdm with the above modification.
    The generated XML out put File from mdm is having message type tag like below
    ?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
    <MDM_CUST_MASTER_FILE_REQUEST_MT> 
    <CUSTOMER> </customer> ...
    note: no namespace for message type
    Result:
    1.When i send this xml file into XI it is failing in message mapping  because it doesn't have namespace attached to it and failing in message mapping.
    Finally i need your help to generate the xsd or data file like below to avoid mapping problem in xi.
    <?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8" ?>
    - <ns0:MDM_CUST_MASTER_FILE_REQUEST_MT xmlns:ns0=urn:abc.com:MDM_Customer_Master_ECC>
    Appreciate your help.
    Thanks and Regards.
    Sravya.

  • Lightroom not showing all photos avail for import

    About a week ago, I tried to import some new photos into LR 3 (3.4.1 to be exact), and the import dialogue does not show all the photos that should be available for import.
    The files are on my hard drive and there are approximately 200 photos in the file folder. When I open LR's import dialogue to import the photos (after navigating to the proper location to import from of course), it shows me 17 of the photos in the file folder! I selected "all" instead of "new" to see if that would make a difference and it did not. I made sure I did not have "do not import suspected duplicates" checked, even closed LR and rebooted my computer.... that didn't work.
    I tried creating a new catalog to see if that would fix the issue, and it did not.
    I'm not sure what else to try, or if there is a known fix out there (having a heck of a time finding one in my internet search!)
    Any ideas/suggestions?
    Thanks!
    -KBP

    Okay, so for giggles I tried checking in the Bridge to see if that changed anything... and it only showed the few files too. So I decided to "select all" and noticed at the bottom left that it listed the balance of my photos as "hidden." I have no idea how my files got hidden, or why it was only some and not others... but at least it's all fixed now and I can get back to what I need to do in LR!

  • Skype Call not attanded one Windows 8.1 PRo

    Hi Every one Last some day ago i am faceing problem to attanded skype audio and video  call when my friend call me than i click so many time on the answare option but not answared successfully , it take many time to attanded call .
     Bro this time i am using latest version ,if you have solution then share with me

    Really, no one can please help me with this? Three days later.. still screwed. sitting here like a duck on Christmas even and can't even talk to my own Mother.. Wow, I can't believe no one is willing to help here...

  • How to visit full versions of sites (not mobile ones) on firefox for android on the tablet pc?

    for example I want to go on the full version of the twitter.com but I can't, it redirects me on the mobile version.

    Install https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/mobile/addon/phony/ and select desktop Firefox from the User Agent section of the preferences.

  • Exchange Friend Links with ShenTop - One-Stop Chinese goods Procurement Service

    Exchange Friend Links with ShenTop - One-Stop Chinese goods Procurement Service
    Home page: The applicant must meet the requirements below:
    1. PR value of 3 or more;
    2. Alexa ranking within 100,000;
    3. More than 1,000 collected by Google;
    Our Link Address:
    [url]http://www.shentop.net[/url]
    1. PR value of 3 or more;
    2. More than 30,000 collected by Google;
    3. Text Link: Hotel Supplies;
    Contact: Aries Liu
    Skype:Md.shentop
    Email:[email protected]
    Welcome [url]http://shentop.net[/url] -  One-Stop Chinese goods Procurement Service ;  Your satisfaction is our utmost priority. By offering you China's largest one stop shopping platform for commercial equipment, we hope we can satisfy all your needs, such as corporate culture exchange, entrepenuerial experiences and insights, hotel merchandise, lobby equipment commercial electronics, wine cellar inquiries, lamp, light, ceram, Please feel free to google Shentop.net
    If you want to be the next entrepreneurs,make you business more stronger in future,lower cost is necessary ,google shentop.net,you will find it.
    [URL="http://shentop.net"][img]http://www.shentop.net/uploadfile/content/201110/20111010120946_26529.gif[/img][/URL][/COLOR]

    @ adobe-admin (J.C.?):
    Thanks for fixing the "backslash" error. Accuracy is important, and doubly so when presented as an F.A.Q.
    The sad thing is how prevalent the usage of "backslash" is when a plain old slash is meant (generally, the "forward" attribute is assumed and unneeded), and by people who should know better. It's a direct result of people knowing just barely enough about the Windows file path naming protocols, and then applying the only terminology they're familiar with incorrectly to URLs.
    I went about 10 rounds—TWICE!—with a labyrinthian succession of people at the Discovery & History cable TV networks because they were saying "backslash" in voice overs whenever their commercials promoted their websites. It took some doing, but I finally got in touch with somebody who was savvy enough to recognize that it was a rookie mistake made by a clueless marketing copywriter. The voice over person just read the copy they were given, oblivious to the difference. It amazes me that it wasn't caught by somebody early in the recording/production process and rectified.
    They then had it correct for about a year, until new commercials started popping up with the same error. Unfortunately, the person I had talked to previously no longer worked for the History channel and I had to go through the process of finding someone who understood all over again.
    Yeah, you can call me a nitpicker with nothing better to do.
    But I've earned that dang badge, and I wear it proudly!

  • After moving my music library from my old mb to the new one, my new mb pro does not play the files evenly. It takes a break for two sec's and starts playback where it stopped. Ideas anyone?

    After moving my music library from my old mb to the new one, my new mb pro does not play the files evenly. It takes a break for two sec's and starts playback where it stopped. Ideas anyone?

    I may have found an answer here:
    http://www.ilounge.com/index.php/articles/comments/moving-your-itunes-library-to -a-new-hard-drive
    They only thing I can assume is that my external hard drive was slow to start and iTunes defaulted to its old directory (see the last paragraph at the link above). However, once my external was recognized shouldn't everything have fixed itself?
    Message was edited by: williamson42
    Message was edited by: williamson42

  • How do I change the start/stop time for multiple songs not just one song at a time?

    How do I chnage the start/stop time for multiple songs not just one song at a time?

    I don't think you can in iTunes.
    Multiple editing in Get Info does not offer an option to change start/stop times.

  • HT3702 I have paid once for one month subscription for al jazeera sport live app. I just released after few months that they are automatically charging me on monthly bases. How i can stop them charging me for something i did not use and i did not authoriz

    I have paid once for one month subscription for al jazeera sport live app. I just released after few months that they are automatically charging me on monthly bases. How i can stop them charging me for something i did not use and i did not authorize?

    You possibly set up an auto-renewing subscription with the app - there are instructions on this page on how to manage them, including how to stop them : http://support.apple.com/kb/HT4098

  • I just purchased a Canon 7D Mark II, new DellXPS and the Lightroom 5.2.  The Lighthouse is not openinging the 7DMark II but does open the older 7D that I imported.  I checked the Abode update page and do not see one for the 7D Mark II.  Please say it is t

    I just purchased a Canon 7D Mark II, new DellXPS and the Lightroom 5.2.  The Lighthouse is not openinging the 7DMark II but does open the older 7D that I imported.  I checked the Abode update page and do not see one for the 7D Mark II.  Please say it is there - if not when.  I am "on hold till its done.  Thanks.

    Update to the current release, which is Lightroom 5.7.1. You can do this from the Lightroom help menu and choosing updates.

  • I have a new PC and I am getting the message "The iTunes Library File cannot be saved.  You do not have enough access privileges for this operation."  I am the only one using this PC and I have Windows 7 Pro and have an administrator account.  Help

    Can anyone help me with this problem.  ITunes message," The iTunes library file cannot be saved.  You do not have enough access privileges for this operation."   I have administrator account and transferred files from old PC.  I downloaded new iTunes program on new PC.  I synced my iPhone to new PC, no problem.  I deleted old account after indicating shared files to new admin account.  Can anyone help?

    A belated reply, as the problems itunes has have discouraged me from using it much. If you uncheck the "read only" box, it doesn't stay that way! Next time you use it, the box comes up checked.
    I'm still having that problem, even when I open iTunes as administrator.
    I've yet to see the answer to this problem. I use itunes mostly to download audiobooks, and I'm ready to download more, and want to save them!

  • I'm shopping for the Apple Mac Pro

    I'm shopping for the Apple Mac Pro Desktop 2.66GHz Intel Core 2 Quad, 3GB RAM
    Mfr. Part # MB871LL/A
    When I put that in the Apple website, (just MB871LL/A ) or Google on the Web, it shows results)
    which on the Web is :
    2300$ at PC connection, J&R and Amazon
    While looking for a better price I found one
    for much much cheaper (+/- $500 less)
    Desktop Computers » APMP266QC3 » Apple Mac Pro Desktop Computer Workstation (Early 2009)
    (I don't know why they call it a workstation ?)
    They say all our products are new, not refurbished
    It's the same as the one seen on J&R, Amazon, etc. but what bothers me is that the Mfr# is different. [APMP266QC3] when everywhere else, including Apple store, it is MB871LL/A
    I'm wondering if there's something fishy here ?

    First a clarification: After reading the May 2009 issue of MacWorld (pg 50) I decided to buy the Apple Mac Pro Desktop 2.66GHz Intel Core 2 Quad, 3GB
    I find out that this model is known as Mfr. Part # MB871LL/A
    So if I see a Mfr#Z0G8-0002 (see below) I'm wondering what it is.
    The store that I'm talking is not B&H, it's on the other side of the country. They sell a 3GB and a 6 GB.
    they sell a 3GB computer with # [APMP266QC3] which seems now to be a B&H stock # (No information on Mfr#)
    They have also a 6GB and it has the APMP266QC6GB and
    Mfr#Z0G8-0002 also with $500 less than anywhere else.
    Both these number can be seen in B&H
    And that's my question: Mfr#Z0G8-0002 ? (not sure what is 0002)
    A completely different number just because 6GB instead of 3GB and everything else is the same ? That would be stupid. Usually it would just have one digit different at the end.
    When I put that number in the Apple page it said no result found. (but that could be because they stop selling it ?) If you google it will show results.
    I google both ZOG8-3GB and Z0G8-6GB
    http://www.google.com/search?client=safari&rls=en&q=Z0G8-6GB)&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8
    http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&client=safari&rls=en&q=Z0G8-3GB%29&btnG=Searc h
    or
    http://www.epinions.com/MacDesktops--price_range_20006000
    The first one compare to the 4th one. Ignore the stores. I'm not buying from them. I just want to show both computer on the same page.
    Again, they have a different manuf. number. Is it just because it's 6GB instead of 3GB ?
    So a store in the West, with no affiliation that I know with B&H in New York, sells a computer with a BH stock number ?
    I know the saying of "if it's too good.."
    I checked with the BBB there's no complaints about this company.

  • I am using Chrome as a browser. When I shop, for example, on Amazon, items I'm looking for then appear in ads on other web sites. How can I stop that?

    I am using Chrome as a browser. When I shop on Amazon, for example, items that I'm shopping for then appear in ads on other sites that I am browsing later. How can I stop that from happening?

    You probably picked up some adware from a "shady" download site. Please see this:
    Adware Removal Guide
    If that does not help you find the adware, please download and install this free utility:
    http://www.etresoft.com/etrecheck
    It is secure and written by one of our most valued members to allow users to show details of their computer's configuration in Apple Support Communities without revealing any sensitive personal data.
    Run the program and click the "Copy report to clipboard" button when it displays the results. Then return here and paste the report into a response to your initial post. It can often show if any harmful files/programs are dragging down your performance or casuign browser issues.

  • Migration Assistant on MB Pro never stops looking for the PB G4 with Panthe

    Hi,
    I bought a Macbook Pro 13 inch to add to my PB G4 12 inch running OS X 10.3.9. When I selected migrate data from another Mac and tried to follow the instructions for migrating over airport it doesn't work.
    I installed the update for airport sharing from the MBP's dvd and the old PB connects to the MBP but the MBP never stops "looking for computers".
    I've also tried connecting through my router's network and with an ethernet cable.
    I don't yet have a cable that can do Firewire 800 to Firewire 400. (I never realized the ports were different )
    I tried turning off the firewall on the PB G4, turning on Appletalk on both Macs. Some articles talk about turning on Bonjour (can't find that on the new Mac and on the old one I think it's called rendezvous for iChat.)
    I found this article http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1554?viewlocale=en_US#faq13
    and this http://support.apple.com/kb/HT3253
    and this http://support.apple.com/kb/HT3322
    But I'm lost for trying to make this work before my new Firewire cable is delivered.
    Does anyone have any suggestions?
    Thanks!

    Marlinespike:
    I think you may have missed the ads see this page http://store.apple.com/us/browse/home/shopmac/family/macbookpro?mco=NzUyMzg0
    I make a habit of missing ads by not watching TV, not readng the newspaper, listening to NPR and using AdBlocker in Firefox. However, thanks for updating my information. I use Mactracker for info, but apparently they have not yet updated their data.
    at this point I can't get either computer to even recognize the other one even when both are connected to each other by airport computer to computer network or through the router. I don't know if they're seeing each other when directly connected by ethernet.
    Are you using FileSharing in System Preferences? I don't do much networking so I may not be up on the technology, but when I have used it I set up FileSharing on both computers.
    I loathe having to reset all my internet connections and I was hoping to avoid having to do the manual drag and copy
    I was advised, when I was in your situation, that Migration Assistant is not the most effective way to update the new computer. Take a look at the advice I got in this thread.
    Sorry about the firewire cable. I have several laying around here, wish I could link on to this post
    cornelius

Maybe you are looking for