Mac Mini HDMI Output Problem w/ LG L246WP

NOTE: This appears to be unrelated to the "screen flickering" that has been noted previously.
I'm using a fresh new Mac Mini 2012 with an LG L246WP LCD monitor. The monitor has HDMI, VGA and Component video inputs.
When I attach the monitor to the Mini DisplayPort output, using a Mini DisplayPort to DVI adapter connected to a DVI to HDMI cable, the display functions properly at all resolutions - including the native 1920 x 1200 resolution that I use it at normally. All resolutions are clearly displayed in the "Displays" System Preferences pane. The display looks perfect, functions properly.
When I attach the monitor to the HDMI port using an HDMI cable, the display does not fucntion properly. The display is shifted about 80-100 pixels to the left and about 20 pixels up, creating black bars on the bottom and right sides. Because of this, a large portion of the display is not visible including the menu bar and most of the left side. Additionally, the settings are reduced to "Best for Display" or "Scaled", with resolution options under "Scaled".
This is not acceptable. I had planned on simply using the Mini DisplayPort output as a workaround, since I already have the DVI adapter from an old setup, but I need to use Thunderbolt to access external hard drives for rapid data transfer. One of my Thunderbolt accessories does not have two ports, so I can't simply add the Mini DisplayPort adapter to a chain. The HDMI port needs to function properly with my monitor.
It's important to note that this monitor has functioned properly with many other comptuers running OS X, Windows and various Linux flavors and it hasn't ever done this before. I've tried several different HDMI cables, ruling that out as a problem. I've tried the HDMI to DVI adapter that ships with the Mac Mini 2012 along with two different DVI to HDMI adapters, ruling that out as a problem. I tried attaching several HDMI devices (game consoles, DVD players, etc) and they all function properly, ruling out an HDMI issue as a problem. The monitor functions properly when attached through the Mini DisplayPort to DVI adapter, so it's not a problem with the monitor. I've reset the PRAM already and the installation of OS X 10.8.1 is stock with no modifications or migrated data. I've tried the suggestions on the HDMI FAQ (although there's no "underscan" option available in Displays)
I tried to call AppleCare and after describing the problem I got disconnected with no callback. I started another ticket, described the problem, discussed the previous disconnection, was assured that I'd be called back if disconnected, and haven't heard back in two hours. So I started to dig into the problem in earnest.
This gets pretty technical.
After substantial research, it appears that this issue is related to the EDID that the monitor sends to the computer and, crucially, the way that the driver responds to it. For some reason, the HDMI port is recognizing the monitor as a CEA device instead of a monitor. As a result, it's restricting the monitor's available resolution to the native resolution  that the CEA 681 Series Extension describes ("Best for Display") and all other resolutions (including 1920 x 1200) are only available as "scaled". For some reason that I can't discern, all resolutions (even the 1080i and 1080p options) have similar deformities.
I've attempted to fix this by placing an appropriate override file in /System/Library/Displays/Overrides with an edied EDID removing the CEA-enable flag from byte 127 but, even after a reboot, the OS still insists that it's a CEA device and it won't allow me to force it to recognize the monitor as a 1920 x 1200 LCD Monitor.
How did I come to this conclusion and develop the fix? A nearly identical problem description showed up on the following website, with details on how this user fixed the issue:
http://byuu.org/articles/computing/edid
They used a convoluted process that involved dismantling the monitor and flashing the EDID on the monitor itself. It fixed their problem. I'd prefer not to go through that process just because one computer has a problem with it. Frankly, I'd prefer if the new Mac Mini performed properly in the first place.
TL;DR: The Mac Mini 2012 doesn't work right with the LG L246WP through the HDMI output. Everything else works fine with it. This is very uncool. It's most likely to be an issue with the driver for the Intel HD Graphics 4000 GPU that are bundled with OS X 10.8.1. The Mac Mini 2012 won't update to 10.8.2 (yet), so I can't test it.
Anyone have any other ideas? Anyone else using a Mac Mini 2012 (or 2011) with an LG L246WP monitor? Anything simple I've missed?

Problem Resolved. But it was complicated. And a huge pain in the rear.
TL;DR: I flashed the EDID as described here. This is not recommended for the weary. Ideally, Apple should release an update OS X that will include the updated Intel HD Graphics 4000 drivers that utilize the CEA flag properly.
Here's the detailed version. As mentioned above, this isn't recommended for the weary. An improper (or interrupted) EDID flash can have seriously unpredictable effects on a monitor's performance.
Step 1: Get a Windows PC set up with a floppy drive and find a floppy disk. Use this system to format the floppy as a MS-DOS Boot Disk and copy over the "ddcw" program described at the aformentioned link.
This took awhile, but I was able to cobble together a temporary frankensystem with parts I had laying around. In installed XP and formatted the disk with XP's format tool.
Step 2: Grab EDID data from the monitor, modify it to disable CEA mode at bit 127 and make sure bit 128, the checksum, is appropriate.
This also took awhile. Several graphics cards I tried could not read or write EDID data. I ended up swapping AGP cards in my frankenstein box until I found one that worked - a generic GeForce4 4200.
Once the EDID data was written to the floppy, I edited the text file containing the EDID data to change the last two hex octets from "01 33" to "00 34" (00, to disable bit 127, and 34 is 33 + 1, which satisfies the checksum) and formatted the text file to match the sample included in the EDID_Write.zip file. Your mileage may vary - make sure the checks.
Step 3: Write EDID data to the monitor.
The link above mentioned three options: Easy (monitor's EDID is unprotected - write away!), Hard (monitor's EDID is protected - use service mode to attempt a fix), and Very Hard (monitor's EDID is protected, hardware modification is required).
Luckily my LG246WP simply needed to be put into service mode as described at the link above (menu + power) and once started up in service mode, I simply enabled "Aging Mode" (whatever that means) and attempted a DDCW write of the updated data.
Step 4: Profit!
After doing this, I powered off the monitor and powered it back on with the Mac Mini attached. The display functions PERFECTLY with HDMI out, just as it does using the Mini DisplayPort to DVI adapter.

Similar Messages

  • Mac mini audio output problems

    This is similar to a problem that appeared before, but with a different twist.
    On 4 July all was well. On 5 July I switched on and there was no "chord" from the Mac. When I collected my mail - no sound from my speakers (which are part of my screen). Logged on to a couple of sites - no sound.
    The System Profiler, under the "Audio (Built In)" category, says: "No Built-in Audio." I know that's wrong because it's always worked before and when I plug my headset in it works fine.
    When I go to the Sound preferences panel in System Preferences, it finds the headset but if I unplug that it finds nothing.
    I tried running the hardware test (by putting in the OS X install disc and holding D during startup.) It couldn't find a problem.
    So, as far as I can see, audio output is fine for the USB headset output but not for the others. Is there a simple fix? The nearest Apple store is about 200 miles away and I don't fancy the idea of posting the Mac off.
    (And I think it's still under warranty for a couple more weeks.)
    Mac mini   Mac OS X (10.4.10)  

    hello mini users with the "no audio output" problem
    it seems that there are faulty output jacks in the macbook and the mac mini
    there are two things you can try:
    i tried everything and began thinking about what new software i had installed. it was "macam" which enables you to use older webcams on OSX. i needed that to use my webcam on skype.
    macam installs a file called "macam.component"
    if you have the same, do this - take that file out of:
    (your hard drive)/library/quicktime - macam.component
    and just put it on your desktop
    restart, then in your sound pref's choose your audio output (if doesn't work restart again)
    the first time i took it out, i had my sound back instantly, another time i had to choose audio output in sound prefs. you kind of have to try different things. after you get your sound back, you can put back "macam.component" to use your webcam.
    it seems macam causes the problem, the two can not work at the same time.
    the second thing: if you dont have "maccam" try plugging and unplugging output jack a few times and restarting until you have sound.
    the problem still could be with the OSX 10.4.10 update / quicktime...or maybe even a hardware problem like others with macbooks were saying (with the red light), not sure.
    people with macbooks and who have the red light on, say to use a paperclip to turn off the switch inside.
    my mini does not have a red light on. i tried using a paperclip but it doesnt work.
    hope this helps, beleive me i feel your pain!!!!
    what good is a computer without sound?
    extremely annoying problem that i hope apple looks into and fixes
    -andrew

  • Mac Mini, HDMI option problem

    On my Mac Mini,In sound output options I cant select HDMI for my TV since upgrading to Mountain Lion

    I was able to get sound form my VIZIO GL47L after a reboot when using it as the only display. However, audio does not work for me when running dual displays.
    I am thinking I will most likely break down & buy an AppleTV and Airplay mirror it.

  • Mac Mini HDMI output gives bad resolution on external 1920x1200 external monitor

    A brand new Mac Mini gives blurry picture with HDMI  HDMI connection to an external 1920x1200 HDMI monitor.
    very bad start

    Hi tlaci60.
    I'm experiencing the very same issue you had with your monitor. Mine is a different brand (Westinghouse24" L2410NM), but the issue is the same. Not surprisingly, the resolution of this monitor is exactly the same as yours:1920x1200. Interesting…
    Basically,I connect my brand new Mac Mini to my 24" monitor, and it results in a fuzzy and grainy image, with washed-out colors, and text so blurry it's difficult
    to read. I'm sure you are familiar with what I describe.
    Anyway: I’m kind of desperate, because nothing seems to work .I have tried your suggestion, but it doesn't work for me. I tried other suggestions from other threads and forums... and nothing works either. I just get the same awful look,even though the Mac recognizes the monitor and applies the correct resolution(1920x1200). Nevertheless, it looks just horrible.
    Any suggestions?  Any ideas?  I'm just losing my mind with this, and I already bought every adapter and cable combination I could think of.
    Thank you

  • Mac mini video output problems

    My mini is one bunch of problems, here is what im dealing with,
    On my screen i have 2 systems connected, when i switched bac from my windows pc to my mini, my screen says no signal. I can press the keyboard etc, nothing happens. Same as when the mini goes into sleep mode. It wont wake up . Si i have to reset the mini all the time. What is causing this and how could i solve it. The mini is connected with hdmi.

    Hi, JO5B.
    I have Dell Monitor that has 3 computers plugged into different inputs.
    When switching between different machines I have to select the new input from the monitor's on screen menu. The Dell doesn't auto detect the new input and switch itself over.
    Try a manual selection from the OSD, that might solve your problem.
    Regards,
    Scorpii

  • Mac mini hdmi video output blurry

    I have an Aug 2011 mac mini plugged into an AV receiver en route to a sony bravia 32" and the resolution is pretty bad, especially text and photos.  PS3 and HD cable box output look great.  I've tried working with the picture resolution on the tv but that does little to help the fuzzy mac mini video output.  I have an earlier vintage mac mini that used a monitor cable to the tv and the resolution was fine -- do I have to go back to that?  It seems from the message boards that windows 7 on mac mini works fine and looks great but that OSX is failing to deliver a sharp image.  Suggestions?  Or is there some software fix available?

    I just bought a mac mini(2010) and had the same issue as coaster - mini to samsung P2270HD via HDMI gives a very bad picture quality. Took the mini back to the store and they reproduced the problem on the same monitor. Then the guy took a dvi cable and via HDMI-DVI adaptor connected it to the same monitor but on DVI input. Picture quality was fantastic.
    Now why did that happen? Same HDMI port but different input to Monitor

  • Problem switcing Mac Mini HDMI via an Onkyo 606 Receiver

    I'm having problems when attempting to switch my Mac Mini HDMI via my Onkyo Receiver. Connecting via a DVI to HDMI converter. Works fine when connected directly to the TV.
    When connected via the Onkyo, I get the Apple logo at the begining of the boot-up process, but when the screen would ordinarily switch to my desktop background, the screen goes blank.
    Any suggestions?
    John.

    Do you have a second computer at your disposal? In cases like this, the best debugging method is to use a second computer and create a screen sharing setup under OS X Leopard, or a VNC set up if the second computer is not a Mac running Leopard. That way you will be able to see exactly what the mini is doing, even though the TV is blank.
    Probably, in the end, you are going to need something like Gefen's DVI Detective to get HDMI switching to work the way you want it to.

  • 2014 mac mini dual monitor problem

    I just brought a mac mini (Late 2014) i have two displays monitors connected, one HDMI to DVI. and one thunderbolt to DVI. I can have both thunderbolts connected and the problem its the same, when back from sleep ,one monitor doesn't turn on. i have to disconnect one and then both work, it only happens when the mac goes to sleep. on cold restart or turning the mac on, this problem doesn't occur. any help.

    I have this same problem too. I purchased the Mac Mini with the intention of running dual monitors. I'm using the HDMI and mini-display/Thunderbolt to DVI. I've also tried MiniDisplay/Thunderbolt to HDMI and I'm experiencing the same problem as angelfromfullerton. Whenever it tries to wake from sleep, it can't decide on monitor arrangement and keeps flicking between the two, making the OS unusable and forcing a reboot... EVERY TIME. I've also experienced the issue once or twice on a cold boot. It doesn't matter which Thunderbolt port is used either.
    I'm going to have to return my Mac Mini unless this problem is fixed asap.
    Mac Min, OSX Yosemite (10.10).

  • 2011 Mac Mini HDMI only 2Ch Stereo

    Wow is this frustrating. I've had my Mac Mini for about a week, and for the life of me, cannot get surround sound working via HDMI. I've read so many posts about people with this problem but I can't find a definitive answer for a fix. All I want is for the Mac Mini to passthrough the audio so that my Pioneer Receiver can handle all of the Dolby stuff.
    Setup is simple -
    Mac Mini ------> HDMI -------> Pioneer VSX-1020 Receiver --------> Samsung 55" LED
    Inside of the Midi Audio options, it shows my receiver as the audio device, and I have all of the options for 2ch, 8ch, etc. I also selected Dolby 5.1. I can only get PCM or Stereo to display on my receiver while ticking through these channel options, while I would expect Dolby to display if it is receiving a Dolby signal. Also, when I do the test tones in the Configure Speakers area, I get the correct test tones from all channels. BUT.........
    No matter what I play whether it be iTunes, VLC, etc, I am only getting 2 channel sound and my subwoofer.
    Can anybody help?? This seems like such a simple task yet it has me pulling my hair out.

    ive had my 1021 for about 2 months and i think its great. Do you like yours?
    i have 5.1 using optical cable to one of the optical in ports on the 1021. But you will need an optical-to-miniOptical adapter tip to use in the mini.
    then make sure that any app through which you want 5.1 has that specified in its prefs. (like VLC)
    VLC always has the option ' out through system', and if the system is optical out, then 5.1 will pass.

  • Mac Mini HDMI - Stuck CD

    Hello,
    I have a CD stuck in my new Mac Mini HDMI.
    * It does not appear in the Finder as a CD.
    * Disk Utility shows the CD drive itself, but all options for eject, format, etc are all greyed out.
    * Booting with the mouse button down does not work (I have a bluetooth keyboard; however, I selected to stop using it and connected a wired keyboard)
    * Booting with C down does not work
    * Booting with Option down until getting to the firmware boot disk selection menu, then pressing / holding the eject button does not work
    * I used the Terminal command "drutil eject", the drive makes the eject noise, but nothing comes out
    * Tried System/Library/CoreServices/Menu Extras/ double clicking Eject.menu - the menu only has a greyed out drive listed
    I think that's everything I've tried. Please let me know if there's anything else I can try.
    Thanks for all your help!

    I figured out the 'problem'
    Let me pre-face it by saying, my wife originally emailed me at work talking about this disc she couldn't get out.
    Flash forward to now. I was fishing around with my work badge (thin hard plastic) and I couldn't feel anything that felt like the edge of a disc. So, after getting up the nerve I took a blank DVD, and slowly let the drive catch it and pull it in. Loaded up just fine.
    I guess the "Stuck CD" must have evaporated
    Good new is, I now know every single way to get the disc out should this happen to me for real (short of completely disassembling the Mac Mini). For now, all I can do is laugh (quietly so my wife doesn't hear).
    Thanks for helping out Boece!

  • Mac Mini with Major Problems

    I'll try to make this short, but it is a looonngg problem.
    About one month ago my Mac Mini began having problems when I boot up.  The computer would freeze on the opening page where I put in my password.  My wireless keyboard and trackpad would not work.  This would be interminent at first but progressively got worse.
    I spent hours on phone tech support.  Finally realizing that would not help I drove the 100 mile round trip to the local Apple store for a Genius bar appointment.
    The first appointment (there have been 5 - meaning 500 miles) resulted in them doing a clean install of Lion.  I took the computer back to the office and guess what, the same problem.
    I drove back to the Apple store, the Genius did some more work and proclaimed it fixed.  It was, for about 3 days when everything started again.
    More time now on tech support.  One more trip to the Apple store.
    This time they kept the Mac Mini for about 4 days are replaced the logic/mother board. 
    I got it back to the office on Thursday. Everthing works great.
    Until today.  I boot the computer, it gets to the screen that has the apple on it - then nothing.
    I manually power it down and reboot.  Same thing.
    I've set up ANOTHER appointment at the Genius bar tomorrow. 
    My question: can I demand that they replace this machine.  Between work and home I have 2 Mac Mini's, a Macbook Pro, a Macbook Air and 2 iPhones.  I've never had this type of problem.  I'm really tired of this.
    I purchased this in February so it is in warranty. 
    Thanks

    rwgleaves wrote:
    I took it to the Apple store Genius bar today - my 5th trip - and they did just what I'd hoped.  They replaced the Mac Mini with a brand new machine. 
    This is why I buy Mac/Apple!
    Excellent new, sorry you had so much trouble on the way. And yes, Apple Stores are awesome!

  • 2010 Mac Mini HDMI 1080p output to Samsung B750

    Hi all,
    I just got the new Mac Mini. My primary reason for getting it was because it had an HDMI output. I've now hooked it up to my Samsung LCD via HDMI to HDMI and it automatically detected it as 1080p. The image was pristine!
    However, the issue I am experiencing is quite irksome and basically defeats the purpose of having it as a HTPC. There is a severe delay between the movement of my mouse and the actual display of it on the screen. There is also audio/video syncing problems.
    This problem does not occur when I have it hooked up to my original monitor via miniDP, so I'm assuming it must be a TV or Mac display issue when outputting at 1080p. Is there a specific setting that I must do to either the Mac or the TV?

    I just bought a mac mini(2010) and had the same issue as coaster - mini to samsung P2270HD via HDMI gives a very bad picture quality. Took the mini back to the store and they reproduced the problem on the same monitor. Then the guy took a dvi cable and via HDMI-DVI adaptor connected it to the same monitor but on DVI input. Picture quality was fantastic.
    Now why did that happen? Same HDMI port but different input to Monitor

  • HDMI On Mac Mini Late 2012: Problem with hardware?

    Just converted from PC to Mac.
    Purchased latest mac mini (Late 2012 version)
    Have tried several monitors through HDMI port and each time the picture quality is poor with very bad text resolution.
    Have tried HDMI to HDMI  and also tried HDMI to DVI adaptor.
    This is with full 1080p 27 inch samsung monitor and HP 2010i monitor.
    Is there a problem with the HDMI port on this new mac mini?
    The monitors I have are fine and are crystal sharp when connected to PC.
    Many thanks if you can answer this

    OK. So I have now tried LG 27 Inch E2742 Monitor as follows:
    1) Mini display to DVI-D : Picture good with decent text resolution
    2) HDMI-HDMI: Picture poor with poor colour and text resolution. This is not a calibration issue.
    The samsung monitor 27 inch series 3 also has poor picture and colour and text resolution with HDMI-HDMI. Again this is not a calibration issue. It does not have a DVI-D input to test the minidisplay port.
    So it seems the HDMI port is not working properly but the minidisplay one is ok as I suspected.
    From reading the other threads it seems this is a common problem including those people that have taken their minis back for an exchange and experienced same problem.
    Is there likely to be a software update to resolve this?

  • OS X 10.8.5 mac mini hdmi audio output issue

    I am running a 2012 Mac Mini with OS X 10.8.5 and my Mac is set for audio and video output via HDMI to my AV receiver / TV. I have recently noticed that HDMI audio output ceases to function once the computer goes to sleep. A full computer restart is required to resolve the issue which is an inconvenience to say the least.
    Or is anyone aware of a simple fix?
    All my software is up to date, the HDMI lead and connection works fine for video and audio works fine after a restart so it must surely be a software error. Worked fine until the latest OS X update...
    Grateful for any help!

    See > TS4113 Mac mini looses audio output...: Apple Support Communities and others like it, just to the right in More Like This

  • Strange problem with mac mini hdmi, denon avr 3310 and itunes

    Hello,
    I just bought the new mac mini with HDMI. It is connected via HDMI to my receiver Denon AVR 3310. The receiver shows that it has "multi channel in" on the display.
    I made all the configurations so that i can watch dvd an the mac mini. When i play a movie with Dolby Digital the receiver does show that on the display and playback is possible without any problems. I hear sound on all my 5.1 speakers.
    The big problem is with iTunes. When I want to watch rented series, for example Dr. House, only 2 speakers of my 5.1 are used. And when I change to surround in iTunes I can only hear static noise.
    What is the problem? Did I make a wrong configuration or is something wrong with iTunes?
    Thanks in advance

    Great news! My Mac mini is sending true 5.1 to my reciever through the HDMI cable! Okay so here's my list of gear.
    MAC MINI 2011 2.5 i5 8gb ram
    Using a quality audioquest hdmi I have connected my Mac mini to my Denon 1712 Reciever. I have connected this hdmi cable into hdmi port entitled game 2. I have connect my reciever to my tv with a monster 1000 hdx thx certified hdmi cable. It has a transmission sped of 17 gb or so...meaning it can handle transmitting 3d...if only I had a 3d tv.
    Okay so that's the gear. Now onto the changes in audio midi. Open audio midi and Simply change it to 48000 hz and to 2 channel 16 bit integer. That's all I did and now it works. Before I had it set to 8 channel 24 bit and when I pulled up my surround sound options I could pretty much only get multi channel stereo. Now I can get several Dolby choices.
    The voices are coming out of the center speaker and all the action is coming out of the other speakers....so in other words 5.1 surround sound has been achieved on my Mac mini 2011 which has Lion on it.
    I have tested this with iTunes and Netflix. Both are in 5.1 and sound great. In iTunes I have tested both music and digital copies of movies. Both worked flawlessly.
    Rejoice Mac mini owners 5.1 surround is now possible over your Mac mini 2011 edition with just an hdmi cable to your reciever. You can throw away that toslink cable becuase now you don't need it!
    I hope this works for you. Remember not all hdmi cables and the same holds true for your reciever. If it does not work consider getting either audioquest or monster....everything else is junk.

Maybe you are looking for