MacBook (6-bit) display OK for Photoshop?

I currently have a 1.67GHz PowerBook G4, but will most likely get myself a MacBook within a year to replace it, running Photoshop CS3 (or more likely CS4 when it arrives) as a student of photography.
A few weeks ago I came across some disturbing reading on the web: while Apple says that their laptops can all display "millions" (24 bits) of colors it has been revealed that this is not so and they can in reality only display 262 144 colors (18 bits) because their displays are of the cheap 6-bit type instead of 8-bit. Here's a site that describes the problem in more detail: http://peewaiweb.free.fr/
This might not pose a problem for most people, but how does it affect professional use, such as with Photoshop?
I've always had desktop computers in the past, but bought my first laptop 3 years ago and haven't looked back since. But paying a premium price for an Apple laptop which has a "cheap" display which isn't capable of delivering the goods seems pretty unfair to me.
The big question is: is it good *enough*? Good enough for photography use with Photoshop that is.
PS: as far as I know, MacBooks and MacBook Pro computers are fully able to display images with 16.7 million colors at once, but the built-in display isn't. If you attach an external display I believe you get a true 24-bit image, but then you're no longer looking at a "portable system", and you've forked out so much money already that you could just as well have bought a desktop computer to begin with!

I've never considered buying a MacBook. It's the MacBook Pro I've been looking at to replace my PowerBook G4 (just like I never considered buying an iBook but opted to a PowerBook).
Allen: you say that the MacBook display is better than 90% of displays in other branded laptops. How does the MacBook Pro display compare to other laptops?
PShock: It seems that there is no way past getting a separate display connected to a MacBook Pro, or buy a desktop Mac if I want really accurate color.
Actually my Powerbook is used mostly at home, with the AC adapter plugged in, but then there are those times I need to use it somewhere else and I've found a laptop to be invaluable! I don't think I could ever go back to a desktop computer again. I hate all those bulky boxes, wires, mouse, external keyboard etc.
Who knows what the future might bring, but for the next couple of years I'll be studying to become a photographer, so I won't be at the pro level just yet. But then again I like to invest in stuff I can really use well for a long time to come.
Would a 15" MacBook Pro along with an external high-quality monitor be a good choice if I want to get serious about photography?
I probably don't have to worry about that stuff just yet though, and according to the school it seems that a MacBook Pro and a Canon or Nikon SLR is what they recommend when studying there.
I mentioned having a Canon EOS-350D and someone there said it's OK to start out with, but I'll probably have to trade it in for something more professional soon.
Some additional concerns I have about trading in my Powerbook G4 for a top of the line MacBook Pro:
1) While my 15" display is set for 1440x960 pixels, the 15" MacBook Pro has 60 less vertical pixels (1440x900). Anyone know why this is, and if this makes much of a difference?
2) Unlike the PowerBook G4, the MacBook Pro doesn't have a built-in modem. I must admit that I haven't used it that much, but it has been critical for a few instances where I needed to fax something. Mind you, I know that a USB modem is available but one of the reasons I got rid of my desktop computer to go the laptop route was because I hated all those things dangling off the machine.
What are all of your experiences with the missing modem?
3) You can't run "Classic" on Intel based Macs as far as I know. Being able to run Classic applications was a big deal for me before getting my PowerBook because I wanted to run all the stuff I had used on my desktop Mac. But when I eventually got the Powerbook I used OSX software anyway, except a small handfull of apps. Truth be told I don't think I've used "Classic" for several months, so I can probably live without it.
4) The Powerbook has an S-video connector which the MacBook Pro is (as far as I know) missing. I don't know if this is a big issue or not, but I can think of a few instances where S-video might be useful. Perhaps there are adapters available to convert the video connector to S-video?
Other than that it looks like the MacBook Pro can replace all that I've grown accustomed to with my 15" Powerbook G4 (Firewire 800, PCMCIA card slot, USB, audio in/out, ethernet and wireless Internet :-)

Similar Messages

  • 1366 x 768 Display enough for photoshop?

    I'm looking to get a hp envy 14 laptop soon for doing my graphics work at school... When at home I can plug in to my 23-inch monitor but while at school will 1366x768px be too small to practically use for photoshop/illustrator?

    For average digicam photo editing tasks like color adjustments and simple cutouts it will be enough, but of course you will be hard pressed to do extensive retouche jobs on high res imagery or even precision jobs. The constant zooming will not make this a pleasant experience. Using the tab key to toggle palette visibility as Marian suggested will help a little, but not in all situations. Sometimes you will simpyl have to have many palettes open to do a specific task and then your image will almost disappear...
    Mylenium

  • Windows 8.1 (64 bit) display driver for Satellite L630-12C SYSTEM UNIT

    Hi I am looking for the Windows 8.1 (64 bit) driver for the display adapter on my Satellite L630-12C SYSTEM UNIT. The part number of the laptop is PSK04E-01W00FIT. The display adapter is ATI Mobility Radeon HD 5145 made by AMD. I have searched for the driver both the Toshiba and the AMD website but couldn't find anything that worked. Does a driver exists for this adapter for Windows 8.1 (64 bit) or do I have to roll back to Windows 7? I would greatly appreciate your help in this mattter. Thanks Hussain

    AMD Catalyst Driver for Windows 8.1 64bit - Has support for the Radeon HD 5xxx Series http://www2.ati.com/drivers/amd-catalyst-omega-14.12-with-dotnet45-win8.1-64bit.exe  

  • I have Adobe Photoshop and Adobe Lightroom on my MacBook Pro laptop. I bought an iMac and I'd like to move my installations to the larger display desktop for editing purposes. How can I go about transferring them?

    I have Adobe Photoshop and Adobe Lightroom on my MacBook Pro laptop. I bought an iMac and I'd like to move my installations to the larger display desktop for editing purposes. How can I go about transferring them?

    I have the same question. It seems that Adobe is almost impossible to contact (I ended up here at the forums to ask the same question).
    I will never buy another Adobe product again if I can get another program to replace it. If this is customer service then it is NON EXISTENT!
    I notice that your question has not been answered and why should you have to get the information from a forum? I know of no other company that makes you do this for simple product information.
    NOT HAPPY with this version of arrogant customer service (nor am I happy about renting Photoshop products into the future - it is just a money grab in my opinion). I will be voting with my feet and going elsewhere in future.

  • Year-old MacBook adequate for PhotoShop?

    My friend is a bit of a computer klutz and has a MacBook bought over a year ago. He was ready to buy an expensive Mac Pro desktop machine today for Photoshop work but I told him his MacBook would probably be powerful enough, and if not, an iMac would be good. BTW his MacBook is the higher-end black version with 1 GB ram, 120 GB HD, and a single processor chip (2 Ghz?) - the faster Core 2 Duo version came out about a month after he bought.
    He has a couple of nice Canon digital SLR cameras and shoots lots of images on vacations and wants to do minor PhotoShop touchups from RAW files and print them. He also has Aperture, a 22" Samsung widescreen LCD monitor, a 1 TB USB/Firewire external hard drive, an expensive new large-format Epson printer, and a USB stylus pad.
    So what version of Photoshop would be good, and is this MacBook capable? Or would iPhoto be sufficient for this? I think all he might need is a USB hub to increase USB port capacity for the extra devices, but actually the 2 ports on the MacBook might be enough. We have tested the Samsung monitor (226BW) and it works fine with the MacBook on the DVI cable. I think he would be able to use the external HD for archival storage of his images, and take the MacBook with him on vacations for dumping the RAW images from the camera.
    Also, what is a good book or online site to get him up to speed on Mac? He knows how to do a few basic Mac things. This is unfortunately a common problem I think - lots of people who were into film photography are having a hard time making the transition to digital cameras, computers, and software.
    I don't have a Mac (will get one soon), so I can't properly advise him yet.
    Message was edited by: adams7

    BTW his MacBook is the higher-end black version with 1 GB ram, 120 GB HD, and a single processor chip (2 Ghz?) - the faster Core 2 Duo version came out about a month after he bought.
    The "Core Duo" model MacBook still has two processors inside, that's the "duo" part of the name. If it only had one, it would be a "Core Solo". (There were never any "Core Solo" MacBooks, but there were some Mac minis.) The "2" in the "Core 2 Duo" just means it's the second version of the "Core Duo" processor.
    So what version of Photoshop would be good, and is this MacBook capable? Or would iPhoto be sufficient for this?
    iPhoto is NOT an image editing application. Although it does have a very limited set of adjustments you can make, it's not a replacement for PhotoShop. In fact, if your friend does have Aperture, he doesn't need iPhoto. Aperture is the "pro" replacement for iPhoto.
    I would strongly suggest upgrading to 2GB of RAM and using PhotoShop CS3. It should run fine, that's what I have on mine. I use it, mostly, to touch-up pictures from my iPhoto, so I'm no PhotoShop power user. But, I do open it almost every day.
    -Doug

  • Can you download a 32 bit installer for photoshop elements 12 to install on a 64 bit system (windows 7)

    can you download a 32 bit installer for Photoshop elements 12 to install on a 64 bit system (windows 7). Thanks in advance

    yes, if you follow all 7 steps you can directly download a trial here:  Adobe Photoshop Elements 12 Direct Download Links, Premiere too | ProDesignTools
    and activate with your serial number.
    if you have a problem starting the download, you didn't follow all 7 steps, or your browser does not accept cookies. 
    the most common problem is caused by failing to meticulously follow steps 1,2 and/or 3 (which adds a cookie to your system enabling you to download the correct version from adobe.com). 
    failure to obtain that cookie results in an error page being displayed after clicking a link on prodesigntools.com or initiates the download of an incorrect (eg, current) version.

  • Photoshop CS5.1 Pixelated on Macbook Pro Retina Display

    Hello!
    I am a photography student who just bought a new macbook pro retina display. I use Photoshop a lot for my course so need help with this as quick as possible.
    Everything on Photoshop seems to be pixelated which is not ideal right now. I also have an iMac which runs the same version of Photoshop and that is absolutely fine, never had a problem. My friend suggested downloading a trial version of the CC as this automatically sorted hers out but did not mine. Any suggestions at all will be SO helpful as I've researched into this problem and are yet to find an answer!

    Very simple. The hiDPI Macintoshes and MacOS support for same were released after CS6 was released. Some of the CS6 applications got upgrades to support these hiDPI displays; others including InDesign did not get such upgrades until the CC 2013 version.
    Sorry, but there is not anything you can do about this with CS5-vintage software.
              - Dov

  • After updating my Macbook Pro retina display to os x yosemite 10.10.2, the mause and track pad locks, and do not respond especially when using the Mac for a long period, please help, how can I solve this, I do not like feel like in windows, so I paid

    after updating my Macbook Pro retina display to os x yosemite 10.10.2, the mause and track pad locks, and do not respond especially when using the Mac for a long period, please help, how can I solve this, I do not like feel like in windows, so I paid good money for this mack, I feel calm

    Hi Buterem,
    I'm sorry to hear you are having issues with your MacBook Pro since your recent Yosemite update. I also apologize, I'm a bit unclear on the exact nature of the issue you are describing. If you are having intermittent but persistent responsiveness issues with your mouse or trackpad, you may want to try using Activity Monitor to see if these incidents correspond to occupied system resources, especially system memory or CPU. You may find the following article helpful:
    How to use Activity Monitor - Apple Support
    If the entire system hangs or locks up (for example, if the system clock freezes and stops counting up), you may also be experiencing some variety of Kernel Panic. If that is the case, you may also find this article useful:
    OS X: When your computer spontaneously restarts or displays "Your computer restarted because of a problem." - Apple Support
    Regards,
    - Brenden

  • Solution for photoshop on my retina display

    Hi, I am trying to work with Photoshop on my macbook pro retina display. Only i'm keep getting blurry pictures for the web. Please give me some tips to work better with sizes and saving photoshop files.

    I have exactly the same problem and have been searching online for somene like me!  My MBPR 15 started showing tiny white "pits" in the screen that has been getting progressively worse.  I can see now that they are in a line that matches up with the bottom row of the keyboard along the space bar.  I did use a thin microfiber keyboard cloth to protect the screen when the lid was closed, but this didn't seem to make any difference. 
    I bought it through the Apple store in singapore (I live in Thailand) and will be travelling to Geneva, Switzerland next month so I'll be dropping into the store there to see what happens....

  • How do I use my Macbook pro retina display as a monitor for a PC?

    How do I use my Macbook pro retina display as a monitor for a PC?

    MacQueries wrote:
    How do I use my Macbook pro retina display as a monitor for a PC?
    Unfortunately, that is not possible. The computer only can "output" your display image, it cannot "input" an image from an external computer and display it on your MacBook's retina display.

  • Will an Infra-Red Adapter work with a macbook pro retina display so I can use the apple TV remote for presentations?

    I have always used the apple TV remote for my presentations.  I bought a retina display last year for the betterment of my presentations and now I have to stand near my computer and hit a button to change my slides where as before I used my remote.  Will a infra-red adapter work with the apple TV remote in the macbook pro retina display?  Love my computer, but very disappointed not to have a remote for presentations that does not need the internet.  Does anyone have any ideas?

    Yes, I used that and it works great if you have wireless connection.  Im looking for  a remote that worked like the apple TV remote.  My questions is, "Is there a USB infra-red remote that works with mac.  I have found this one: Keyspan EZ1 easy presenter.  It claims with works with PC and Mac and the reviews are good.  Does anyone know anything about it or if it works with retina display macs?

  • I am trying to install an update for my macbook pro retina display and my mac wont restart because it says my mail is still open but when i try and open my mail, it wont let me. I think it crashed. Help?

    I am trying to install an update for my macbook pro retina display and my mac wont restart because it says my mail is still open but when i try and open my mail, it wont let me. I think it crashed. Help?

    Go to: Apple > Force Quit
    and select Mail > Force Ouit.

  • I have a MS Office for Mac CD, how do I install the software onto my MacBook Pro (Retina Display)?

    I have a MS Office for Mac CD, how do I install the software onto my MacBook Pro (Retina Display)? It does not have a CD drive.

    If all else fails, try this.  i used to do it all the time before. might or might not work with the new office.
    if you have access to another computer with a cd/dvd rom, copy the entire contents of the cd on a thumb drive.
    insert the thumb drive in your MB and do the install from there.
    However, if you have the newer version of MS Office, Bandit's suggestion is much better.

  • Just bought new PC running Windows 8.1. I have Install discs for Photoshop 4 and an upgrade to Photoshop 7. Unfortunately the Photoshop 4 Install disc won't run as it's incompatible with 64 bit. How do I install Photoshop 7 on my new PC? Is there a place

    Just bought new PC running Windows 8.1. I have Install discs for Photoshop 4 and an upgrade to Photoshop 7. Unfortunately the Photoshop 4 Install disc won't run as it's incompatible with 64 bit. How do I install Photoshop 7 on my new PC? Is there a place I can download the Install files from?

    Pagemaker is ancient, obsolete and unsupported. It was discontinued over 10 years ago. (Though why it is still sold is a mystery.)
    If you want to run PageMaker, your best bet is to use a Win2K or WinXP PC.
    Otherwise move to Indesign or look at Serif's PagePlus or Scribus.

  • Photoshop elements 10 will not migrate to my new macbook pro/retina display.  There is no CD/DVD player on this machine.  Any suggestions on how to get Elements onto my machine?  Yes, I have the disk(s).

    Photoshop elements 10 will not migrate to my new macbook pro/retina display.  There is no CD/DVD player on this machine.  Any suggestions on how to get Elements onto my machine?  Yes, I have the disk(s).  Am I going to have to buy an external CD/DVD player to load this one program:(

    I have ordered a USB3 BluRay/DVD/CD player/burner and will use that both with my iMac ( in which the Superdrive seems to be failing ) and the MBPro Retina I just bought .

Maybe you are looking for

  • Delete a range of rows in Oracle Table

    How do i delete a range of values in Oracle Table using SQL Pus. For example i have iwanted to delete rows with user_id from 12344 ~ 12399

  • HP Pavillion dv6647cl - CD/DVD drive not working

    My DVD/CD drive isn't working. I was in the process of reinstalling my OS through the Windows Vista recovery discs(Which I did a few times before) and now all of the sudden, the BIOS isn't recognizing the drive. Because of that I was forced to use a

  • BPM guidelines and conventions

    Hi all, I'm looking for a document that deals with guidelines and conventions regarding BPM. It would be great if it contains common dos and donu2019ts. Maybe some kind of naming convention is included as well. Does anyone of you know of or has writt

  • Help With Flash In Dreamweaver

    Good day all! I've got three flash files on the homepage of> http://winterslippers.com they are in there own layers and they work fine when I goto test the homepage. Yet when put the homepage live on the server, I don't see the flash files. Anyone go

  • EVAL_BODY_AGAIN - Problems compiling

    Hi,           I am having trouble compiling the following - I can see what is causing the           error>           All help is greatly appreciated.           When I try to compile it states:           EVAL_BODY_AGAIN : cannot resolve symble