MacBook Pro monitor turns on... when lid lifted

OK, first and foremost before some snarky reply comes - I am posting in Lion, because this problem is unique to Lion - I never had it prior to yesterday.
I start-up or wake my MacBook Pro and the lid is down so the monitor is off - I'm using an external monitor.  However, once the laptop wakes or fully starts-up - if I lift the lid, the built in monitor comes on (it would stay off, pre-Lion).  I like to open my lid for better sound and I think for better ventilation.
Can someone tell my why this is happening, and is there a way to go back to the previous behavior where it would stay powered off?

This is already being debated here: https://discussions.apple.com/message/15662934#15662934
So far it would seem it is a bug and so far other than using 'SwitchResX' there is no way to circumnavigate the issue.
Submit a bug report and hopefully apple will listen.

Similar Messages

  • Macbook pro 17 turns off when switching to high performance mode

    Hi guys!
    My 2009 Macbook pro 17 turns off and goes dead when switching to "high performance" graphics in the energy saver controll panel.
    This happens also when the battery is 100% charged. i must reconnect powersupply to reboot.
    The battery is new, from june this year.

    Aardal87 wrote:
    I have just re installed the system. and the problem continues.
    I guess ur solution isnt worth trying on a fresh system install?
    It will not do any harm trying it but you are probably correct in these circumstances. 
    If the symptoms are consistent, then a savvy technician at an Apple store genius bar should be able to define the problem.
    Ciao.

  • My MacBook Pro screen turns off when I open the lid!

    This has been driving me nuts, and also apparently Apple as well.
    When my MacBook Pro is connected to a power adapter, if I close the lid it sleeps like a good little Mac. When I open the lid, the display comes on instantly. Then after about a second, it goes black. The LED backlight turns off. I can get it to come on using either of two ways: 1) touch either of the brightness buttons, or 2) remove and replace the power connector.
    Now, here is the weird part: it only seems to do it when I am logged in as me. If I login as guest, it doesn't happen. That would seem to imply it is something about my profile that causes it to happen. So I whacked ~/Library/Preferences and it still happened. So where is this particular bit of nastiness hiding?

    OK, so I think I solved my issue.  It was caused by the system not going to sleep (The screensaver thing was a dead end).
    When I ran the console app pmset, I got something like this:
    ➜  ~  pmset -g assertions
    12-06-29 9:11:06 AM EDT 
    Assertion status system-wide:
       PreventUserIdleDisplaySleep             0
       CPUBoundAssertion                       0
       DisableInflow                           0
       ChargeInhibit                           0
       PreventSystemSleep                      1
       PreventUserIdleSystemSleep              0
       ExternalMedia                           0
       DisableLowPowerBatteryWarnings          0
       EnableIdleSleep                         1
       NoRealPowerSources_debug                0
       UserIsActive                            0
       ApplePushServiceTask                    0
    The process that was causing PreventSystemSleep to be 1 was "org.cups.cupsd" which is the print service.  So I checked all my printers, one of them was "In Use".  When I opened it, there weren't any jobs listed.  I went through the options and selected Jobs > Show Everyone's Jobs and sure enough there was a job there.  I deleted it and everything seems to work now.
    The odd thing is that print job was probably from my other account which didn't seem to have this screen problem.  Anyway, I hope this helps anyone out there....

  • MacBook Pro does not sleep when lid closed

    Hi there. I recently upgraded my MacBook Pro from Snow Leopard to Mountain Lion. Before the upgrade my mac would sleep automatically when the lid closed. However, ever since I've upgraded, when I close the lid, my mac doesn't go to sleep. However, if my mac isn't plugged in (running off the built in battery) it goes to sleep. I looked through system preferences and I can't seem to find any settings relating to this, does anyone have any suggestion on what's happening and how I can fix it? Many thanks in advanced.

    Test after each of the following steps that you haven’t already tried: Step 1 Apple menu > System Preferences > Print & Scan > Open Print QueueCheck all printers for unfinished jobs. Deal with any you find. Step 2 Apple menu > System Preferences > Energy Saver > Power Adapter > Wake for network access: uncheck. You may need to unlock the preference pane by clicking the lock icon in the lower left corner and entering your administrator password. Step 3 Apple menu > System Preferences > Energy Saver > Schedule > Start up or wake: uncheck.    Step 4   Apple menu > System Preferences > Sharing: uncheck all boxes. Step 5 Disconnect all wired peripherals except keyboard, mouse or trackball, and monitor, if applicable. Step 6 Launch the Activity Monitor application. Select All Processes from the menu in the toolbar of the Activity Monitor window, if not already selected. Enter “powerd” (without the quotes) in the "Filter" text field. Select the powerd process and click the Quit Process button in the toobar (stop-sign icon.) In the sheet that opens, click Force Quit. You’ll be prompted for your administrator password. The process will be relaunched immediately. Step 7 Reset the SMC. Step 8 Boot in safe mode and log in. The instructions provided by Apple are as follows: 
    Shut down your computer, wait 30 seconds, and then hold down the shift key while pressing the power button.
    When you see the gray Apple logo, release the shift key.
    If you are prompted to log in, type your password, and then hold down the shift key again as you clickLog in.
     The login screen appears even if you usually log in automatically. You must know your login password in order to log in. If you’ve forgotten the password, you will need to reset it before you begin. Note: If FileVault is enabled under OS X 10.7 or later, or if a firmware password is set, or if the boot volume is a software RAID, you can’t boot in safe mode. Safe mode is much slower to boot and run than normal. Don’t launch any applicationsat first. If sleep still doesn’t work properly, back up all data and reinstall the OS. After that, if you still have the issue, make a “Genius” appointment at an Apple Store to have the machine tested. If sleep now works as expected, go on to the next step. Step 9 Still in safe mode, launch the usual set of applications that are running when you have the problem, including your login items, one at a time, testing after each one. Some applications may not work; skip them. You might be able to identify the cause of the problem this way. Step 10 If sleep is still working after you’ve launched all the usual applications, reboot as usual (not in safe mode) and test again. If sleep still works, you’re done, at least for the moment. If you still have the sleep issue after booting out of safe mode, post again.

  • HT3131 Macbook pro + external display sleeps when lid closed and 'clicking' noise

    Hi all, new mid-2012 macbook pro non-retina user, I have an PC external display with Microsoft USB wired keyboard and mouse pair (the keyboard and mouse are wireless but connected via a USB desktop receiver) but even when all connected up, shutting the mac lid always turns off external display too and no amount of pressing keys or mouse clicking wakes up the display again. External display only wakes up when I open the lid again. There's also a clicking noise from the mac every time I close the lid with external display connected. Any ideas? I've tried a number of things, wondering possibly if my cheapo (non-Apple) VGA external display to Minidisplayport adaptor is the culprit? Also, everytime I connect the display I have to go to display settings to get it to recognise the external display. I haven't installed any software for the USB mouse and keyboard , the macbook recognises it ok.

    Hi Itsfixed,
    It sounds like you are having issues running your MacBook Pro in closed clamshell mode (computer closed but awake, connected to an external display). If possible, you may want to see if it behaves as expected when connected to a wired USB keyboard and mouse as outlined in the first section of the article; wireless USB (non-Bluetooth) keyboards may not be recognized by the system the same way for the purposes of running with the display closed.
    Regards,
    - Brenden

  • MacBook Pro won't sleep when lid is closed and battery lights won't work?

    I have a 2010 MacBook Pro 15" and ever since I got it, the battery indicator lights wouldn't light up (not that big of a deal) and the computer wouldn't sleep when I closed the lid.
    I've reset the NVRAM/PRAM, the SMC and verified/repaired my hard disk as needed.  But the computer still won't sleep when I close the lid (regardless if the machine is plugged into a charger or not).  Is there a known fix for this problem?  I've been searching through the forums and troubleshooting from advice that other people have suggested, but nothing seems to be working.  Any help is greatly appreciated!

    This exact thing happened to me. Resetting the SMC solved all my problems. Here's a link to how to do it: Intel-based Macs: Resetting the System Management Controller (SMC) Hope it works!

  • Macbook Pro won't sleep when lid shuts or hit sleep

    Hey Everyone,
    So after the latest update my Macbook pro no longer immediately sleeps after shutting the lid. It also won't sleep when 'sleep' is hit in the apple menu. It's actually really annoying as I need it for security.
    Does anyone know how to fix this problem?

    Try Reset SMC.  http://support.apple.com/kb/HT3964
    Choose the method for:
    "Resetting SMC on portables with a battery you should not remove on your own".

  • Macbook Pro won't sleep when lid open

    My 2011 Macbook Pro won't go to sleep if I leave the lid open. I have checked System Preferences>Energy Saver and the display/computer sleep is set to 10 min for both Battery and Power Adapter settings. Even if I close all the applications down, my computer will still not go to sleep. The battery just gets completely drained if I forget to close the lid. Help?

    1/31/13 9:44:10 PM PST  
    Assertion status system-wide:
       PreventUserIdleDisplaySleep             0
       CPUBoundAssertion                       0
       DisableInflow                           0
       ChargeInhibit                           0
       PreventSystemSleep                      0
       PreventUserIdleSystemSleep              0
       ExternalMedia                           0
       DisableLowPowerBatteryWarnings          0
       EnableIdleSleep                         1
       NoRealPowerSources_debug                0
       UserIsActive                            0
       ApplePushServiceTask                    0
    Kernel Assertions: None

  • My macbook pro doesnt turn on when i push the power button

    I was working on my mac the other day and as usual shut it down when i was done. A couple hours later i wanted to turn it on again to check my emails and it didnt start up when i pushed the power buttin. i light on the lid lock bottun lights up but it does nothing else. Battery is fully charged so i don't understand why it refuses to turn on... HELP please?

    Portables that will not Power on.
    http://support.apple.com/kb/TS1365
    Go step by step.
    Note: Steps 5 and 6
    Step5
    Reset SMC.     http://support.apple.com/kb/HT3964
    Choose the method for:
    "Resetting SMC on portables with a battery you should not remove on your own".
    Reset SMC, hold the keys down for 20 seconds or more.
    Keep it charging for 2 hours or more.
    Best.

  • Macbook Pro suddenly turned off when fully charged and won't restart. Charger not working either coincidently

    My 2 year old 13" MacbookPro suddenly turned off, presumably when the screen automatically dimmed (or went to sleep?) and now it won't turn back on. It was at 96% charge and now when I use the battery checker on the side, nothing shows up. No lights or anything. The charger doesn't seem to work either even after trying it on different outlets. This has never happened before but it has been harder to wake it from sleep in the last 6 months or so. I would have to push the On/Off button for a sec and the screen would turn back on. Also when I turn it on, the password screen is sometimes off-centered..weird.
    I'm using Yosemite, the latest version..not sure what it is and can't check right now...I had to go use a PC to ask this question >_<

    Try a SMC reset:
    http://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201295
    If no success, make an appointment at an Apple store genius bar for a FREE evaluation.
    Ciao

  • Macbook pro mid2012 turns on when magsafe get unplugged. anyone else with same issue?

    as stated above, when I unplug the magsafe, macbook wakes up from sleep. Anyone having that issue as well?

    I have confirmed that this is definitely related to the Firmware Update 2.0.
    I performed an erase and install of Mountain Lion 10.8.2 then applied all updates EXCEPT the firmware update 2.0.
    I then restored all of my content and tested.
    My MBP no longer wakes from sleep when the AC adaptor is disconnected or connected. I'll be logging it with Apple support shortly.

  • MacBook pro doesnt start. When I start my lap top, it shows the apple and the line uploading but it only goes like to 1/3 and then it goes blank for some seconds, then it turns off by itself and turn on again and happen the same, apple logo, etc

    MacBook Pro doesnt start. When I start my lap top, it shows the apple and the line uploading but it only goes like to 1/3 and then it goes blank for some seconds, then it turns off by itself and turn on again and happen the same, apple logo, line .. the noise like-fan going on, then turn off and turn on again. Tried starting holding option command P and R key and didnt work either. Starting to think I have lost all my data inside

    Try a SMC reset.
    http://support.apple.com/kb/ht3964
    It might be helpful if you indicated the exact model/year of your MBP.  Are you running Lion OSX?
    Ciao.

  • I bought my macbook pro this morning. When I turned it on it led me through set up with voice over. I finally quit VO but my pointer is not working. It moves but does not open anything. Can anyone help?

    I bought my macbook pro this morning. When I turned it on it led me through set up with voice over. I finally quit VO but my pointer is not working. It moves but does not open anything. Can anyone help?

    ladislavfromcygnet wrote:
    Thank you Shootist007. I cannot do even Update now. I probably should have spent the same amount of money on a new IMac!
    No not really. If this is a brand new Macbook Pro take it back for a refund. Apple has a 14 day No Questions Asked return policy for Full refund.
    Take it back, get the Full Refund (DO NOT LET THEM TRY TO FIX IT. YOU BOUGHT A NEW COMPUTER NOT ONE THAT HAS BEEN WORKED ON OR NEEDS TO BE FIXED) and then decide whether to buy another Macbook Pro or the iMac. Or you could return it, get the Full refund and buy some other brand computer.

  • I have a CC subscription and had it loaded on my Mac and my old MacBook pro.  I bought a new macbook pro and turned off CC on my old laptop but when I try to load it on the new one it keeps saying I already have it activated on two devices. Help!

    I have a CC subscription and had it loaded on my Mac and my old MacBook pro. I bought a new macbook pro and turned off CC on my old laptop but when I try to load it on the new one it keeps saying I already have it activated on two devices. Help!

    Contact support by web chat or phone to reset activations.
    Mylenium

  • How can I make my macbook pro go to sleep when I close the lid? Currently it doesn't sleep when on battery.

    How do I make my macbook pro go to sleep when I close the lid?

    For this and other power related issues the best first step to try is resetting the System Management Controller.
    Best of luck.

Maybe you are looking for

  • Is there a way to get rid of iOS 5.0.1 on the iphone 4s

    I just got my phone and the first day my battery ran awesome then i did the update and now its draining my battery. Is there a way to just get rid of the update? Like should i do a restore on my phone and just not use icloud and start off brand new,

  • Purchasing a Ringtone in Itunes

    I just purchased a song in Itunes with the intent of using it as a ringtone. After I bought and Paid for the song and tried to apply it I received a message that "this song is no longer available as a ringtone", My question is this: Is there a way to

  • Two problems : navigating the timeline and know where your shot matching originates

    Hello, - I wonder how you can navigate the timeline freely (I'm on PC in direct link mode) to be able to use, for example, the C shortcut easily when you edit a one hour film. In a word, I can't find how I can zoom on the secondary playhead instead o

  • Export score as music XML file is grey in logic x

    when I want to export a song as XML file to communicate with sibelius the option export score as xml file is grey Why is that and can I change it Thanks

  • Applications crash when opening files on network drive

    The problem occurres when I try to open the tree-list on the "Open-File" dialog panel when on a network drive. Also... the folder presented to me in this dialog is one branch short of the current folder the program is working in. The crash does not o