Motion import to FCP looks awful

I have a Motion2 project I created that looks perfect in Motion. When I import into FCP 5, first I have to render it (is this normal?), and it looks awful afterward - the text looks very jagged and aliased, and the layered "background" animation is completely lost, leaving only black (see below).
The project settings on both are NTSC/DV at 720x480 and 29.97.
I'm using the animated curves layers from one of the templates in Motion2 as my background layer, but I wanted them darker, so I doubled them up and played with the blend modes. This is the animated "background" that's not showing up in FCP.
Man, I was riding high after creating a lower third for the same project in Motion that turned out beautiful (thanks to some helpful advice on this forum . When I did the import for the lower third piece into the very same FCP project it looks excellent! The only difference I can think of is that it had the video clip brought in from FCP that I animated over, whereas this project is a bumper that is all created in Motion.
Help - any thoughts???
All the best,
~Chris

OK, I'm closer to figuring it out and just hoping someone can help me take it to the finish line
The only difference between the two Motion files is the lower third was created over video sent from FCP. Since this Motion project (the one I'm having a problem with) is a bumper on its own in the FCP Timeline, I thought maybe there's a problem with the "black" FCP creates in any spaces in the timeline, and this is perhaps adding black to the background of the Motion file import...
Sure enough, I built an NTSC black b.g. still in Photoshop and imported it into Motion. Putting this black NTSC b.g. on the bottom layer recreated the EXACT problem I'm having in FCP! On this NTSC b.g. layer, I can take down the opacity all the way, or choose "stencil alpha" from the blend modes to get the right look, but either way, when I import it back into FCP I still get the same problem.
So, I tried importing the black NTSC still into FCP, sending it to Motion, adding the Motion file to the top, and still get the same problem upon reimporting...I'm out of ideas at the moment...
Can anyone think of a workaround? Patrick?
Regards,
~Chris

Similar Messages

Motion project imported into FCP looks different...

I have a Motion project that moves 17 magazine covers across a background. When I preview it in Motion it looks great, but when I import it into FCP the mags overlap and run into each other. What could be happening during import and is there a fix??

I'm posting in response to my own question because this may actually be a bug. When I import the Motion project into FCP with the Motion layers locked, the animation is altered. When I go back into Motion and unlock all the layers and import into FCP, the animation is perfect. No kidding, locked tracks and the animation is funky, unlocked and it's fine. Anyone ever stumble on this??

Blurring of text once motion file is imported to FCP

I've been experiencing this problem for a while now. I guess this could have been posted in the motion forum as well. When I create a simple text screen (black solid background) in Motion it looks as it should, but when I import that same file into FCP the text seems to lose a lot of quality and becomes blurred. Sometimes the quality is so bad that the crosses on T's and the dots on I's are not visible!
Both motion & fcp projects are set to 25fps. When I open Motion to start a new project I normally leave it to default (pal dv i think)
I'm sure this can easily be corrected so if anyone can point me in the right direction it would be appreciated.
Alex

Still receiving a number of Motion to FCP problems.
Not only is the text blurring when imported into FCP but motion files with for instance a particle emitter/behaviour (such as stars moving towards frame) is taking nearly 2 hours to render & even then when i go to play the file in fcp the timeline freezes with a 'dropped frames' pop up appearing.
Help?!

Motion Project does not look good in FCP

I am using FCP 5.0 and Motion2. I made a lower third title graphic in Motion. When I embed the clips back into FCP they look pixalated. They do not look as good as they did originally. Does anyone have a solution?

Hey,
Here's the result from last night. The quicktime file is good. It seems that Motion projects in FCP, even from rendered QT files, don't display their true image.
My output this morning for my project is flawless. Even though the timeline looks horrible.
The reason this seems to come up in this forum again and again, is probably that Boris 3D, FCP's titles, even LiveType, all display their true clean rendered image in FCP. Motion, however, doesn't seem to do that.
My guess is that it hangs on to a thumbnail representation for FCP of the rough draught render that motion must create so you can place your motion project in your FCP timeline live. (you know, you can switch back and forth and update a motion project and it updates it in FCP. )
It just doesn't say that anywhere that I was looking.
So, if anyone else is creating Motion projects and importing them into Final Cut, be aware that what you see in Final Cut is not what is going to render in your output. It will be full resolution and without the alising that appears in FCP's timeline.
Whew!
Gord
G5 Dual 2.3Ghz Power PC 3GB RAM, 2x120HDD, & 15" Powerbook Mac OS X (10.4.6)

Importing a matted Motion project into FCP

I did a bunch of work on a shot in motion, maskes, etc.
The shot was greenscreened so I use Primatte to Key in motion.
When I try to import this motion file in FCP for coloring it does not display correctly. I'm sure it has to do with the Key. I regularly move projects back and forth with no issues.
Is there some different I need to do to deal with the Alpha channel, or is it not possible?
Thanks
steve

I think I am viewing only the alpha channel when imported to FCP. It has a light blue hue - as if I was was looking at a channel view in Photoshop.
Also, I created multiple layers in Motion as I did masks. I believe only the top mask is translating. Very weird.
Must be a setting somewhere.
Thanks

Error message when importing motion files into FCP

In FCP.
I choose a clip/clips in my sequence. Then choose send to motion project and follow the directions from the training dvd.
By unchecking (embed "motion" content) then save the file with a different name. Then continue with making my graphics over the video clip/clips.
When I am done I then shut off the video layer of the clip in the motion timeline. Then I save the project. Then close Motion and try to import the motion project in FCP.
When I try to import, I get an error message stating "File Error: 1 files(s) recognized, 0 access denied, 1 unknown."
I go back to the training file to try the same procedure and it works fine.
Go back to my own project and it doesn't work.
Any ideas? Anyone?
I have a Mac Pro 2.66GHz / 5 gigs of ram / 512 vram ATI graphics card
Also working with universal software for FCP studio.
Intel 2.66GHz Mac OS X (10.4.9)
Intel 2.66GHz Mac OS X (10.4.9)

OK???
Don't know what the deal is. But I made a new sequence in my project and copied my other sequence with in the new one and then tried to do the whole clip step for step process of send to motion and importing back in and it worked!!!!
I check all the listed settings of my sequence in my browser window and both the old sequence and new sequence are the same.
I am happy that I can move on with my work, yet I am frustrated with the fact that I am not sure exactly what the problem is.
Thank You Again!

Can't open quicktime movie that I exported from Motion 5 and can't import to FCP

Can't open quicktime movie that I exported from Motion 5 and can't import to FCP 7.
I exported (with current settings) from Motion 5 now i can't view my movie with QT Player an FCP
won't recognize it.
That's the message I get ?
I'm running Mac OSX but still on FCP 7 (upgrading to FCP X is NOT an option)
Thanks a lot for any sugestions
luxbud

Thanks TOny
i think it was just a problem during the export. i tried a second time and it just worked fine

Importing Motion Files to FCP

I've searched for this problem and have yet to find a thread with a conclusion - please point me in the right direction if I've missed it.
I'm running Motion 3.0.2 and FC Pro 6.0.6 along with OS 10.4.11. I'm due to upgrade all these asap - but as I'm in the middle of a long project I'm holding back. I've never been able to import Motion files into FCP either by using Import or dragging into the browser - I get a "File Error: Unknown File" message. Instead I make a QT file and work on that. Usually I don't have many files in a sequence so that's never really ben a problem.
However, I've now putting together some much longer sequences and it's a pain when shots need tweaking to have to re-make QTs each time.
I've trashed both Motion and FCP preferences without luck. I have Snow Leopard sitting waiting to be installed. Could that fix the problem? Does anyone have any suggestions?
Thanks in advance.
Andy

hi,
seem to remember someone else having this problem, have you repair permissions etc on your system. Can you double click a motion file for it to open from the Finder. Does the Finder know they are Motion files and should be opened by Motion? er can't think of anything else
adam

Motion animation when imported into FCP comes out as 4:3 instead of 16:9

Hi,
I'm trying to create a bumper animation for my feature film. I started in Motion 3 created a simple animation and imported into FCP and flagged it for 16:9 but still comes ot as 4:3 when exported to Quicktime. Any ideas as to why?
Chris

Set the anamorphic flag. Click on you clip in the FCP timeline or browser and type ⌘9. Check the Anamorphic flag.
Patrick

Color profile off when importing motion proj into FCP

Color profile off when importing motion proj into FCP. Is there a way to set the profile?
I deleted preferences in FCP.

No, profile do many things. It is a color space. It allows different apps and systems to view colors the same. Also fcp typically works in a tub color space not rgb.

Poor rendering quality of Motion import

I have some simple Motion moves - pans scans and zooms across hi-res (3600x2400px) still images. When these are taken into FCP (v5.0.4), either as an import or as an export from Motion (v2.0.1), I encounter a problem with image quality. This is most apparent when I have zoomed into the original image, even when taking the precaution of not zooming in as far as tv resolution. All diagonal lines become stepped, as if the FCP image is displaying at around 240 lines rather than 480 (NTSC) This has a particularly nasty appearance with horizontal, vertical or diagonal lines in the image during movement. The original Motion file plays back beautifully, with no artifacts. I imagine this to be a problem within FCP to do with rendering. Can anyone tell me what am I doing wrong?
John

I'm viewing this on both the computer and an external TV monitor. The tv monitor exhibits the problem - that's why I am concerned - and so does the computer, where I'm viewing the clip at 100% resolution. This project is shot and cut in NTSC DV. I have imported the motion files into FCP and rendered them there, then rendered out the sequence to a self-contained file. (I have also tried rendering the clip from Motion and placing that clip into FCP. There is no apparent difference in quality.) Since my original posting I have tried this routine on someone else's computer and the end result was good, without any of the line flicker that is distressing on the problem version. I went back to my computer and re-did it and still got the poor end result. It would seem to me that there are some render settings somewhere that I need to change, but I don't know where else to look. Both computers used in this process are G4 Powerbooks.

Intermittent Garbage Behind Text Imported to FCP

Hi - I'm animating some text with the wave behavior in Motion, adding a drop shadow and importing the Motion file into FCP. I'm getting some black areas behind the text that are not getting masked out in FCP.
After searching the subject I changed the alpha in FCP from straight to black and it has not solved the problem.
The text looks great for a majority of the time but every so often a few frames have a garbled black rectangle behind them.
Any ideas?
Thank you,
Craig

First, make sure that all render types under the Sequence->Render menus have a check mark beside them - and then render the Sequence. Next, make sure the images aren't too large for your Sequence. If you plan to push (zoom) in to the images, they probably shouldn't be more than twice the pixel dimensions of the Sequence you're working in. If the images are too large, you'll see 'mosquito' noise or other artifacts in the image on a TV monitor. Resize them in Photoshop or Preview before importing them into your FCP project.
Also note that 300 pixels per inch isn't the an accurate measurement term - I think you mean dots per inch (DPI) which has absolutely no bearing on image quality in video/television. It is a measurement used in the print world. A 1200 x 800 pixel image at 1200 DPI will look exactly the same as that same 1200 x 800 image at 72 DPI on a television monitor.
-DH

Text looks awful?

Hi all,
Using FCP 10.0.6 and when importing a video that has text on it, it looks awful. The text 'shakes' and doesn't look right at all. I use avidemux to change the look of a video, and FCP to put it in HD and sharpen it. However, whenever I put the video into FCP it always has problems with the video imported that aren't on the actual file. An example of what this looks like would be:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LHJeWBmVR90&list=UUkxHI9k2Ir3epaJLdcttlbg&index=5
Can be seen at 1:45 in the video. Any way to remove this, or stop it from happening? My avidemux output settings are:
MPEG-4 AVC
Single Pass 10000kbit/s
MP3 (lame)
.MP4
Any help greatly appreciated,
Damien.

dam2040 wrote:
… when importing a video … The text 'shakes' . I use avidemux to change the look of a video, and FCP to put it in HD and sharpen it. …
wotwotwot?
you have a low-quality, highly compressed source file and scales it to 'HDef'?
that just blows-up pixel-mud, doesn't 'create quality'.
by contrary: so-called scaling-effects could degrade quality, in your example, the font creates 'sub pixel'.
probably, you're using the wrong codecs to swap btw. the two tools.
use FCPX only to add your titles and 'changing the look'.
... and be nice to ©opyrights …

Motion projects in FCP

OK, so I've been importing motion projects into FCP (for a while now) and rendering them each time they're changed...and finally wondered: why? If I click "open in editor", change something and go back to FCP, I should only have to re-connect it, right? That's what I do in DVDSP if I need to change something on a menu I did with After Effects...export it from AE with same file name, then the file in DVDSP automatically updates (sometimes I gotta re-connect the file...).
I busted open the FCP manual and it only said that LiveType and Motion clips must be rendered (red render bar)...but not why. Is it because they are inherently motion effects/graphics intensive? I know the answer is probably just that simple, I'm just looking for some re-assurance that I'm understanding this correctly...
I'm not a noob...just trying to understand the tech side of things. That way I can be happier with my software.
Thanks
Jonathan

OK, so I've been importing motion projects into FCP (for a while now) and rendering them each time they're changed...and finally wondered: why? If I click "open in editor", change something and go back to FCP, I should only have to re-connect it, right?
Unfortunately for us, whenever the source media - a video clip, still image, Motion or LiveType project file - changes, FCP trashes the associated render files. As far as I am aware, it's a hardwired 'housekeeping' thing within FCP.
The usual advice is to render only as a last resort, but I take it your workflow doesn't allow for that?
I busted open the FCP manual and it only said that LiveType and Motion clips must be rendered (red render bar)...but not why. Is it because they are inherently motion effects/graphics intensive?
It's because Motion or LiveType files typically do not match the codec - what FCP terms 'Compressor' in your Sequence Settings - that you're working in. Sure, the files may match the frame size and rate - for instance, 720x480 at 29.97 fps - but Motion and LiveType files are 'interpreted' as Animation codec files. If you're working in DV, for instance, you'll have to render files that are not DV. Another issue is that no machine/setup I've ever worked on can do Animation files - at Full Quality - without rendering (they are simply too data intensive). However, beefier machines can get some amount of RT playback, depending on the settings and number of tracks being composited.
Or did I misread your questions?

PSD Logo stretches when imported into FCP

I began work on a project awhile back and I am finally returning to it. In a previous thread I was explained how PSD and EPS files work and don't work in FCP. It was very helpful. (http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?messageID=4144809&#4144809)
However, I've just noticed that all my PSD logos have stretched out horizontally and they have that lovely fat (incorrect) look to it. The original PSD files in PS looked fine after some tweaking, but as I said, the stretching only appeared once imported into FCP.
Any thoughts? Many thanks.

Hi:
Check the Distort settings in the Motion tab.
Alberto

Motion import to FCP looks awful

Similar Messages

Maybe you are looking for