MSI K8N Neo Platinum Edition vs. ASUS K8N-E Deluxe

I'm beginning to get nervous. Since almost everyone has had problems with the MSI board, I'm beginning to doubt it's a good choice...
I've been looking some at the ASUS K8N-E Deluxe. Is this board a better choice?

Quote
Originally posted by beheader
Quote
Originally posted by Richdog
Quote
Originally posted by beheader
Quote
Originally posted by Richdog
It could be an amazing board if it didn't behave like the DFI Ultra B did... with it's cold-boot problems when OC'd, need of using a BETA BIOS for good overclocking results, losing the PS/2 mouse on boot-up.  A couple of my friends can't break 230Mhz HTT no matter what BIOS they use, and their components are all good for it.  I can safely say that this is my first and last MSI product.  When I also compare the MSI support forums to those of ABIT etc I also find them sorely lacking.  It's not the most constructive or knowldgeable place in the world.  I'll be getting the DFI NF3 when it's released I think, even if it does have the cold-boot problems it can't be worse than the MSI, and will likely at least come with an active chipset cooler.  As for reliability, two of my friends build computers for a living and swear by ASUS and ABIT, they would never build MSI into their systems.  MSI is very much a mid-rank manufacturer, not top-flight.
*dons flame-suit*.  
I don't think anyone is going to flame you... but I will point this out:
You are over clocking. ? You'll get varied results from any brand.
Like there's some inherent warranty behind overclockability. Give me a break.
I had an ASUS board where a diode EXPLODED and took out a Thunderbird. I handled it with support... like I should have.
God I hate whiners.
Listen bud, I ain't a whiner, but I say things how I see them and I don't needlessly mince my words, in my job it desn't pay to.  I don't pussy-foot around anyone.  Also, i've been overclocking a long while now, likely far longer then your wee self, and i've used a wide range of motherboards on both the AMD and Intel platforms.
Also, God knows what you're talking about with the "inherent warranty behind overclockability" part as that's not even in context, I made no reference to the warranty, merely on the board's performance and my opinions on MSI.  They weren't offensive, merely informed opinions.
If you're going to attempt a put-down, please try and make it vaguely relevant and remotely intelligent.  Otherwise...
Just for the record, my first overclocked machine was an 80286
lol same here tiresmoke, touche sir.
And SAB I hear you mate, i'm sure you love MSI motherboards, but review after review has shown they are not the best, in terms of stability or overclocking, especially overclocking in fact.  Ask 9/10 reviewers and they would rate ABIT, DFI or ASUS over MSI every time.  But the very fact that I bought an MSI motherboard shows I am willing to give them a chance, and I will wait until the next BIOS update for the NEO Platinum before I make my final judgement on my first ever MSI product.  If the BIOS turns out to be a dud and doesn't solve the many issues with this board, i'll say bye bye forever, as many others no doubt will who have bought the MSI Neo Platinum as their first MSI motherboard, mainly because it was the first Norce3 250GB to be released.  

Similar Messages

  • MSI K8N NEO Platinum Edition memory question

    Hi there,
    I've currently got a MSI K8N NEO Platinum Edition (Nforce 3) motherboard and 2X 512 MB Corsair Value Select memory modules (both double sided) running at DDR 400 - this runs completely stable and has done for a number of months. I would like to increase my memory to 1.5 Gig but there seems to be a lot of issues?
    I originally planned to buy an additional 512 Meg Corsair value select chip and place it in Bank 3 - is this acceptable?
    I assue that i would have to drop the speed down to DDR 333 from 400, could anyone tell me how much of a difference this actually makes (when playing FPS games Doom3 etc..) ?
    Any help would be greatly appreciated as i've been looking through both this forum and the Corsair one and i cant seem to find the answer.
    thanks in advance !

    Just note that there are combinations of two sticks that will also make the board run in DDR333 mode (see page 2-8 of the manual). For example, using two double-sided sticks in DIMM2 and DIMM3. I've actually managed to get it to work at DDR400 in those two slots, but it's not perfectly stable and overclocking diminishes drastically. Bottom line is the system will work fine when forced to DDR333...as long as you don't expect to overclock the RAM to any significant degree.

  • MSI K8N NEO Platinum Edition PROBLEM

    Hi (my english is not good sorry for that)
    I just got my new computer:
    MSI K8N NEO Platinum Edition
    AMD Athlon64 3200+
    Western Digital Caviar 160Gb
    PNY Verto GeForce 6800Ultra 256Mb
    1GB Value Select pc3200
    Levicom 500W
    The Problem is that when i start the computer, it boot and die directly no bootscreen what so ever, it boot and die.  i dont know what to do plz help me

    Make sure you have Both the ATX Wires on.. theres the Big one! (21Pins i think).. and the Small 4Pin Connector both need to be connected.. if you havent done so yet.. Another thing you could do is Take everything out and place it on a cardboard or something appropriate for the mobo.... I think your motherboard is shorting?.. if it's touching your case.. I had somewhat the same issue long time ago.. give it a try..if you want hope it helps..

  • MSI K8N NEO Platinum Edition Low Benchmark scores

    Hi, can someone please help?
    I have these details of my friends new PC :
    MSI K8N NEO Platinum Edition
    AMD Athlon 64 3200+ 2.2 GHz Socket 754, 512 KB cache
    Corsair Value S. PC3200 DDR-DIMM 512MB
    I have run a sandra memory bandwidth test on it and I think he gets really low scores for his spec.
    int buff'd 2657
    float buff'd 2656
    This is the scores he gets un tweaked and not overclocked. Do these sound like reasonable out of the box scores??
    Any information would be appreciated

    Quote
    Originally posted by tritium4ever
    Who cares, Sandra is a completely synthetic benchmark with absolutely no relevance to real world performance. Don't believe me? Put a 3.0C up against a 3000+ S754 with the memory bandwidth benchmark. The 3.0C will own, but the 3000+ will perform better in most real world apps. Bottom line: don't sweat the Sandra results.
    not 100% true either beacuse if you then run encoding apps etc which are mem bandwidth dependant the 3C would own. it is not true to say they are not real world results, just games and most apps dont bottleneck on the mem bandwidth.....now that is will be different on 64-bit coding but of course the A64 would still own the 3C on them.
    just for the record i would never buy an intel.

  • MSI K8N Neo Platinum Edition review

    MSI K8N Neo Platinum Edition
    http://www.tbreak.com/reviews/article.php?id=290

    Is it worth the money I wonder?  There aren't that many programs written wich can run in 64 bit mode! This is truly the main reason for getting this board unless all you guys have a load of money and want to be at the cutting edge.
    I think I'll wait till its get worth the money...  or am I completely wrong here?
    E-Dog

  • MSI K8N NEO Platinum Edition Memory plz help!

    Hi
    http://www.datorbutiken.com/se/defa...2X512DDRCA400PR
    Is this memory ok with MSI K8N NEO Platinum Edition ?
    If it is, do you know how well its oc:s?

    He would be talking about this:
    http://www.newegg.com/app/viewProductDesc.asp?description=20-145-466&depa=0
    But I wouldn't reccomend that memory mainly because I have heard mixed reviews about it. You can get the same (if not better) memory at either of these links, the only difference between the two links is the color of the heatspreader (as far as i can tell). This is the memory I have and it works very well, plus its much cheaper:
    http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc.asp?description=20-145-449&depa=0
    http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc.asp?description=20-145-450&depa=0

  • Any MSI K8N NEO Platinum Edition S754 nForce3 users?? Need advice..

    Hi, thinking of building a budget system around a S739 Clawhammer 3700 with an
    MSI K8N NEO Platinum Edition S754 nForce3 board. But have a few concerns..
    - Will this board run on this chip or will it need updated BIOS to do so?
    - Will it work with crucial 3200DDR memory.CL=3 • UNBUFFERED • NON-ECC • DDR400 • 2.6V • 64Meg x 64 ?
    - Can it take an extra (3rd) 512 stick of this ram?
    Thanks.

    I have ran the Neo s754 model with 2 * crucial CT6464Z40B 512MB cas 3 modules and never had one single problem with the combination
    of A64 GC version , mobo and RAM .
    Three modules is tough on the single channel memory controller though , as it would have to deal with 6 banks
    and you probably see the ram max speed as DDR333 and 2T commandrate is what it can cope with.

  • K8N Neo platinum edition, only beeps

    I have had my K8N Neo (7030)for about 1,5 years and its been working good. Today however, when I restarted my computer it only started to make beeps, about 1 sec long and maybe 4 seconds in between, all of the same length(they never stop). I have tried to move the memory dims ( have two 512 MB), in different positions and only using one (tried both), but nothing seems to be working.
    The last thing I did before the restart was in the BIOS, and I chose "optimized" at an item in the "overclocking menu". This was not an item with a warning.
    can anyone help?? any ideas? I have none at the moment or links to other with similar problems.

    Not so fast...
    I thought it was working ok since I got all the way to the BIOS.. But it kept on crashing, just freezing within 2 minutes from when I started it, no inputs worked, not mouse or keyboard.
    Now, after I tried to start it several times, it just turns itself off again without any sound at all. Tried to reset the CMOS once more, but to no help. Any ideas?

  • Corsair Value Select on MSI K8N NEO Platinum Edition

    Does anyone have this combo? (A64 CG) and can tell me some clock result and bios etc how high fsb and so on
    THX
    /Stiga

    value ram usually will not clock high, higher end ram like corsairs xms is better suited for ocing

  • K8n neo platinum edition problem

    hey not 2 long ago i accidently shocked my comp . now i want start. i tried a whole bunch of stuff but it wont start. im really pissed. wut do i do man

    There is no telling what was toasted, if anything.  I'd unplug from the ac, push the power button to discharge any caps, clear the cmos, remove the cmos battery, and wait about ten minutes to re-assemble.   Remove your memory and reseat, same with any other cards you have plugged into the board.
    Visually inspect the board to see if you popped any resistors or blew any caps.  If you see nothing physically wrong, then plug it back in, (making sure you already moved the cmos jumper to the keep data position) and see if it'll fire up.
    Check to see if any of the fans try to start when you push the power button.  If you get nada (nothing), I would first try a different powersupply (could have toasted a component inside).  But that would just about be your limit of checking without volt meters, ossiliscopes, etc...

  • "error loading operating system MSI K8n Neo platinum

    OK,
    System will post, according to MSI Website I have the latest Bios version.
    I can boot from CD.
    The only odd item is that I am using the HD that I took out of my old computer with windows already on it.  
    Tried re-installing windows XP.  It went through the loading process and then rebooted.  Same error message appears.
    Also, is 48 degrees normal for idle temp on CPU AMD 64 3400? 36 degrees NB temp ok?
    Oh, yeah, I have a floppy installed, CD-ROM, CD RW, all non SATA. Using IDE cables.
    Video is Asus V9980 ultra GeForce FX 5950.
    MSI K8N Neo Platinum
    AMD 64 3400
    Hercules 600 W PSU
    WD 80gb HD
    Generic CD-Rom
    Sony Cd-RW
    2 x 512 crucial 400 ddram  slosts 1 and 2
    Asus V9980 ultra GeForce FX 5950 256 TVD
    Do I need to clear bios and re-start?
    HD is on it's own cable in IDE 1
    Cds on IDE 2 shared.
    let me know what you think.
    The other related posts I read, people were using raid or multiple OS.  I'm not.

    I had the same issues as you sometimes Windows would install and sometimes it wouldn't the problem was related to ram. I had my ram in slots one and two like you did and I moved the ram to slots 1 and 3 and now the machine is rock solid stable.
    I think most of the problems people are having are actually more ram related than anything else.
    So try moving the stick of ram you have in slot 2 to slot 3 and see if this solves your problem. This solution is on forums somewhere I am just not sure where.
    Take care,
    Bob

  • Help with MSI K8N Neo Platinum

    HELP please- motherboard MSI K8N Neo PLATINUM: I tried to take away the backplate for the heatsink (on the back side of MB) in order to install the zalman HS beafore i read the forum (use a fan...) and the worst of all happend:
    I scratched the back surface!! the scratches are minor, that is 4 scratches half a milimeter long each and not deep but i can see the copper of some lines leading from the memory slots to the processr. My question is : can I try and build the computer on that motherboard anyway or better buy a new one? is there a risk of dammaging other components? oh god what a mistake!

    Make sure the new backplate is non-conductive. The backplate for the Hyper 6 has a non-conductive sticker on it. Make sure to keep it on if youve got one... If the lines are exposed even with the back-plate on perhaps you should cover them with some non-conductive (100% non conductive!) tape or something.
    Then it doesnt matter if they are exposed, as long as they are ok.
    A good tip, which got when i was removing my backplate, is to use a blow dryer to heat it up and the remove it with your fingers. That way youll also notice if it gets to hot
    The glue gets sticky at blow drier temps. And pls, dont singe the MB with your blow dryer, you only have to make it hot, and if you cant touch it, how can you remove it with your fingers?
    I guess theres no way of telling if you have a serious prob and no way to tell if your cpu will be ok. I guess you could (?) try and start it wíthout anything (cpu, mems) but a PSU, and then, if it (and maybe the PSU) goes "!Pfsssssss!"  or "bang!", youll now you will have to replace it.
    I put a screwdriver through an asus board once, and it still worked...  

  • MSI K8N-NEO-PLATINUM nForce3 250 + Corsair vs.

    Hi, I'm thinking of buying a new computer with a MSI motherboard and now thinking if these will correct and have no direct problems, MSI K8N-NEO-PLATINUM nForce3 250GB + Corsair VS512MB400 Value Select 512Mb DDR PC3200 400MHz 184pin Unbuffered CL2.5. I'm not the guy who is intresserd in overclocking and such things.
    Will that motherboard and memory correct good with each other ?
    Sorry for my bad english. :D
    //Johan
    EDIT: I think I made this topic in the wrong forum. Mods move it to AMD64 nVidia Based board  ?

    MakubeX,
    I have the Antec True Power 480. Unfortunately it only has 22 or 23 amps (the specs and the label on the psu have different ratings  ) on the +12V rail. Most of the folks here recommend a power supply with at least 24 amps.
    The good news is that the system in my sig is working flawlessly so the extra 1 or 2 amps don't seem to make a big difference, at least in my case. I will say, however, that according to Core Center my +12V rail runs around 11.5 volts, which is low and nearly out of ATX sepc. The low voltage will result in higher amperage draw...but again, the system is stable.
    I wish you good luck

  • Msi k8n neo platinum ps2 keyboard problem

    Hi. I'm having issues with my msi k8n neo platinum motherboard. I've read about 50 posts on these forums regarding the supposed ps2 keyboard issues with recent msi boards. However none of them seems to address my current situation.
    Like many  others, when I power up my system the cpu fan spins for like 3 seconds then everything comes to a halt.
    I tried many things to get my system to boot and the only thing that works is plugging my ps2 keyboard into the ps2 mouse port and moving the ps2 mouse into a usb port with an adapter.
    It seems there's no hope for fixing the problem other than RMA'ing, but I thought I would add to the pile of complaints stacking up against the MSI boards.

    if u had read the threads a little more u might have found a solution that seems to have worked 4 many - a usb keyboard usb Keyboard if u go this route dont forget to enable usb kb in bios
    Edit: This Thread Summarises the situation PS2 keyboard/mouse causes random shutdowns or doesnt work      

  • MSI K8N Neo Platinum Nforce3 250GB - PSU?

    My sister in law have this board, MSI K8N Neo Platinum nforce3 250gb chipset, recently the power supply sounds noisy and a high frequency sound from the Antec Truepower 380W SP. Had maked an RMA to Antec and they had agreed to replace the 380W psu with SmartPower2.0 450W. But they asked me one question, that im not sure about:
    "Make sure that your motherboard does not need the -5V. If you want more information on the power supply you can look at this link: http://www.antec.com/us/productDetails.php?ProdID=26450 "
    So, do Antecs SmartPower 2.0 450W suits this board and what really is -5V for? As I read the manual, it said ATX 20 pin power connector: JWR1 and at pin 18: -5V
    So does it mean this board need a psu that gives -5V on ATX 20 pin power connector and thos board can't use with Antecs SP 2.0 450W?

    Quote from: syar2003 on 22-February-06, 05:10:37
    Hi!
    The K8N Neo Platinum (MS-7030) doesn't use -5v to anything.
    So the -5v from the old atx spesification is not needed in your case.
    WoW, thanks for fast reply!
    So, it won't be any problem to use Antecs SmartPower 2.0 450W with this board then? Want to make sure about it, before accept Antecs offer for replacement and had spent over 4 days to find the problem with his computer. Really don't want to do it again. 
    This is his riggs:
    Antec Sonata
    AMD 64 3000+ S754
    Corsair Value S. PC3200 DDR 512MB
    Maxtor Diamondmax 9 250GB SATA
    Maxtor Diamondmax 9 IDE 160GB
    Sapphire Radeon 9550 Atlantis 128MB DDR
    and
    Accton ethernet card on PCI slot
    MSI D-Bracket2
    so
    With the "new" Antec SmartPower 2.0 450W
    Any problem with this rigg and PSU?
    edit:
    Dound this post that it said the board do need -5V and now Im confused? 
    http://www.archivaty.net/forums/about12964-30.html

Maybe you are looking for