Need help on network design

Hi guys.
Looking for some advice on a network design.
Please tell me what you think may or may not be wrong or missing.
Here are the details:
The user count is approximately 600 (desktops, laptops and Cisco IP phones) with two locations (office and data center) connected via 100Mbps guaranteed MAN line with site-to-site VPN as backup.
Servers will all be in the Data Center.
Edge routers to be used as site-to-site VPN connection point between office and data center.
Edge router at data center also to be used to connect to 4 other remote sites.
Edge networks (router and ASA) will be used to provide internet access to equipment at their respective locations. (No routing across MAN for internet access)
Cisco 4510 to be used as user switches.
Supervisor engines will be connected via 10G fiber to core switches.
There will be 2x 10G connection for each supervisor module.
Core switches are 4500x to be stacked via VSS using 10G Twinax cables.
Core switch will also have 1G copper sfp to connect to MAN line hand-off.
There will also be a physically (for the most part) segregated network using 3750x 
switches that connect back to the core. We will use 1G Fiber connections.
Here is the current kit list:
Office Network Edge
1x Cisco 3925 Router to connect to internet and vpn tunnel endpoint (CISCO3925-HSEC+/K9)
1x 2GB RAM upgrade for Cisco Router (MEM-3900-1GU2GB)
1x 1GB Compact Flash for Cisco Router (MEM-CF-256U1GB)
1x ASA Firewall w/ IPS  (ASA5525-IPS-K9)
Office Network Core
2x 4500X 32 Port Switches (WS-C4500X-32SFP+) w/ IP Enterprise License
2x 1GB Fiber SFP module per 4500X switch to connect to 3750x  (GLC-SX-MMD)
2x 10GB TwinAX cables to stack 4500x switches together (SFP-H10GB-CU1M)
8x 10GB Fiber SFP+ module to connect to 4510 Sup Engines (SFP-10G-SR))
1x 1GB Copper SFP to connect to MAN circuit hand-off (GLC-T)
1x 1GB Copper SFP to connect to ASA firewal (GLC-T)
Distribution
4x Catalyst 4510R+E Switches (WS-C4510R+E) w/ IP Base License
2x Supervisor 8-E per 4510 switch (WS-X45-SUP8-E)
8x 48-port PoE module per 4510 switch (WS-X4748-UPOE+E)
4x 10G Fiber SFP+ module per 4510 switch (SFP-10G-SR)
1x 2GB SD Memory card per Supervisor Engine (SD-X45-2GB-E)
Office Network Segregated
4x 3750X 48-port PoE Switches (WS-C3750X-48P-L) LAN Base License
1x 1G Fiber SFP module per 3750x switch (GLC-SX-MMD)
1x Slot module per 3750x to connect 1GB SFP modules (C3KX-NM-1G)
Data Center Edge
1x Cisco 3925 Router to connect to internet and vpn tunnel endpoint (CISCO3925-HSEC+/K9)
1x 2GB RAM upgrade for Cisco Router (MEM-3900-1GU2GB)
1x 1GB Compact Flash for Cisco Router (MEM-CF-256U1GB)
1x ASA Firewall w/ IPS  (ASA5525-IPS-K9)
Data Center Core
2x 4500X 32 Port Switches (WS-C4500X-32SFP+) w/ IP Enterprise License
2x 10GB TwinAX cables to stack 4500x switches together (SFP-H10GB-CU1M)
3x 10GB Fiber SFP+ modules per 4500X switch to connect to 3850 switches (SFP-10G-SR)
1x 1GB Copper SFP to connect to MAN circuit hand-off (GLC-T)
1x 1GB Copper SFP to connect to ASA firewall (GLC-T)
1x 1GB Copper SFP to connect to segregated ASA (GLC-T)
Data Center Distribution
6x 3850 24-port PoE Switches (WS-C3850-24T-S) IP Base License
1x Slot module per 3850 switch to connect 10GB SFP+ modules (C3850-NM-2-10G)
1x 10G Fiber SFP+ module per 3850 switch (SFP-10G-SR)
Data Center Segregated
1x Cisco 2951 Router to connect to internet and vpn tunnel endpoint (CISCO2951/K9)
1x ASA 5512-X (ASA5515-K9)
Attached diagram is just a draft.

Disclaimer
The Author of this posting offers the information contained within this posting without consideration and with the reader's understanding that there's no implied or expressed suitability or fitness for any purpose. Information provided is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as rendering professional advice of any kind. Usage of this posting's information is solely at reader's own risk.
Liability Disclaimer
In no event shall Author be liable for any damages whatsoever (including, without limitation, damages for loss of use, data or profit) arising out of the use or inability to use the posting's information even if Author has been advised of the possibility of such damage.
Posting
A 39xx is underpowered if you want to support gig VPN tunnel.
If your MAN is 100 Mbps (possibly "light" for 600 users), I would suggest running your port at 100 Mbps, not gig.  (This because LAN switches don't shape, and may not be able to "see" congestion or drops within the MAN.)
You user edge (the 4500s) will be L2 or L3.  If the latter, I would recommend not using a VSS core.
I would recommend not using the same Internet connection for both general Internet access and VPN.

Similar Messages

  • Need Help for Page Design Technique: Level 0 Record and Level 1 Record

    Folks,
    Hello. I am developing HR system for a client. I design a page for "Position Information" as follows:
    Level 0 record fields:
    Position Number: 01
    Status: Open
    Because many people are in this position, level 1 record is a scroll area containing many rows belong to this Position Number as follows:
    Level 1 record fields:
    Profile ID: 001 effective date: xx/xx/xxxx
    Profile ID: 002 effective date: xx/xx/xxxx
    After save the page into Database, the data in Level 1 record table doesn't match the data in Level 0 record table.
    No way to identify the rows of data in Level 1 record table belong to a specific row of data in Level 0 record table.
    I need help to design the Database, that is 2 tables: many rows in second table belong to one row in first table.
    Can any folks give some idea to design such a Database so that save the Page correctly ?

    Table 2 should have all the key fields from Table 1, followed by atleast one more key of its own.
    Subhash

  • Need help with networking external hard drive

    Hi,
    I am working on a corporate network and I have a Western Digital My Book Studio Edition external hard drive attached to a Mac OSX 10.4. i have other Macs connecting through the network to this Mac and accessing the external hard drive and it works just fine for that.
    What I need help with is the fact that I also have several PCs on the same network (all XP), that need to connect to the hard drive and access the files. I've been able to connect to the Mac using the XP by accessing the IP address. I also set the Mac up with password credentials so that I had to log in to the Mac to access the files. But when I try to access the Mac, it only shows the main computer drive as the only available share and no external drive.
    Does anyone know how to access a Western Digital external drive on a Mac from a PC through a network?

    For an external hard disk drive or other (different) system shared
    storage devices to work, they probably should be formatted in a
    format seen by both operating systems.
    If the WD unit is not seen by Windows computers on your network,
    the WD may have been formatted in HFS+ for the Macintosh. That
    is OK unless you need a Windows computer to access the same.
    The Macintosh can see and use a standard Windows disc format;
    so the external drive may need to be reformatted away from HFS+
    if that is really what is going on (and archive any data on the suspect
    drive elsewhere, since it will be lost to reformatting overwrites)
    and then both Mac OS X and Windows should see the files on there.
    And Macs set up to run Windows may also see the non-Mac format;
    without having to re-boot via BootCamp, if that option is in use.
    As to the other question(s) I really have no idea at this point in time.
    And since that may be the rub, hopefully someone will follow up here.
    Good luck & happy computing!

  • Need help in voip design

    hi,
    our customer having nearly 30 branches. 20 are connected to central office via leased lines.
    And 10 branches are connected by internet.
    Now customer willing to use voip on all these branches.
    That is From central office to leased line offices and internet offices vice versa..
    And there are analog phones with PBXs.
    present along with them soft and hard IP phones are required with redundancy.
    so anybody can help me in designing this voip setup? (designing means what are the required equipments and protocols for this setup)
    Regards
    skrao
    Regards
    skrao

    Skrao,
    Several ways to go here I don't really recommend the VOIP over the internet but your going to have to do a user count and peak call utilzation survey for each site.
    Your probably going to go with one of the ASxxxx models for the central site and 2800 or 1800 for the remote sites. As for the VPN offices you might try CME Call Manager Express for them or keep there existing PBX's kinda depends on what there Goals are.
    I can't give you specific parts because there is such a huge combination of different ways to go but your gist is you'll probably have a couple of Access-Servers to handle your primary site PSTN connections and then put something that can handle SRST Survivable Remote Site Telephony at each branch office. For your VPN sites your going to want to use Call Manager Express.
    Patrick

  • Need help - setup network in solaris

    Hello! Today I install Solaris 10 for learning in my laptop and have some trouble. Please help me
    1. Set up network interface for wi-fi card iwi0
    (a. ifconfig iwi0 plumb
    b. wificonfig iwi0 connect airJet
    c. ifconfig iwi0 dhcp)
    2. Set up default route (route add default 192.168.100.2 (its my access point with dhcp server))
    Ping -s 192.168.100.2 -> done
    But when I trying in Firefox open any url - recieve error "host not found"
    okay. in terminal i put
    ping google.com
    and recieve answer
    host not found
    What is my problem?
    Thanks for u answers.

    Try changing hosts line in /etc/nsswitch.conf to:
    hosts dns files
    so that hostnames will be resolved via your dns servers. You also need to enter dns server info in /etc/resolv.conf.
    Here's a tutorial: [Configuring Networking|http://solaris-x86.org/documents/tutorials/network.mhtml  ] (kind of dated, but most of the info is still relevant)
    john

  • Need help with network

    hi, i am trying to leave ubuntu, so i installed Arch Linux. it seems everything went allright on the CD installation, but i am having trouble with the network. i have a dell XPS M1330 with the intel 4965 card, and i believe that the card is recognized by the system.
    i can scan for networks, and i can even connect to my network, and when i run "iwconfig" i can see all my network details, including the password, and th signal strenth, noise, etc.
    so, everything indicates that i am succesfully connected to my network. but everytime i try a ping it fails misserably, with a host unknown. i've tried google, yahoo, msn... but it doesnt matter. they always fail.
    can anybody help me?
    btw, i've checked that hostname is the same on rc.conf and hosts

    EDIT AFTER LAST TRY!!!!!
    first of all, i have to say that even though the module is listed on rc.conf, everytime i start the computer i need to do a modprove iwl4965 for the network card to start working, then i have to do "ifconfig wlan0 up" and then is allright.
    ok, tonight is the night!!!! lets get going
    sputter wrote:But as a thought just to try and get your juices working, what happens if you enable the gateway in your rc.conf?
    how do i do that? right now my rc.conf looks like this
    gateway="default gw 192.168.0.1"
    ROUTES=(!gateway)
    sputter wrote:with wired connections at times you need to specify a broadcast address, what would happen if you ran
    "ifconfig wlan0 192.168.0.221 netmask 255.255.255.0 broadcast 192.168.0.255"
    i'll try on a few minutes,
    EDIT: nothing special, same result as before
    sputter wrote:Is your wireless module being loaded by the MODULES=() line in your rc.conf?
    yes it is, iwl4965 is listed there
    MODULES=(tg3 iwl4965 snd-mixer-oss snd-pcm-oss snd-hwdep snd-page-alloc snd-pcm snd-timer snd snd-hda-intel soundcore)
    megagram wrote:
    After doing the manual addressing using ifconfig or the manual configuration in rc.conf, can you show us the output of "route"? Just type "route" and hit enter.
    The broadcast flag is likely unneeded as a 255.255.255.0 netmask implies a 192.168.0.255 broadcast address. However, it's definitely worth a shot! I just wonder if, for some really really strange reason your router isn't using a 255.255.255.0 netmask. Can you try giving yourself a lower IP address? Try 192.168.0.2 this will guarantee that you are in the same subnet as your router.
    Try this!
    according to my wife's computer and my mint install, our netmask is really 255.255.255.0
    i will try those suggestions tonight and post the outcome here, but to begin, this is "route" on my mint install
    Tabla de rutas IP del núcleo
    Destino         Pasarela        Genmask         Indic Métric Ref    Uso Interfaz
    192.168.0.0     *               255.255.255.0   U     0      0        0 wlan0
    link-local      *               255.255.0.0     U     1000   0        0 wlan0
    default         192.168.0.1     0.0.0.0         UG    0      0        0 wlan0
    be right back
    this is the outcome on arch before doing dhcpcd
    Kernel IP Routing Table
    Destination       Gateway        Genmask         Flags Metric Ref    Use  Iface
    192.168.0.0     *               255.255.255.0   U     0      0        0 wlan0
    and this is after doing "dhcpcd wlan0" and getting again the error i posted on my last message
    Kernel IP Routing Table
    Destination       Gateway        Genmask         Flags Metric Ref    Use  Iface
    169.254.0.0     *               255.255.0.0   U     0      0        0 wlan0
    this time i was unable to get a working Access Point although i could connect to my network
    Last edited by apertotes (2008-08-06 19:10:24)

  • Need Help Please  - Data Design

    Hi,
    I have flow from Data Source to DSO and to cube.
    The cube has 3 master data  fields. 0employee, 0orgunit and 0gender. ( 0employee is having attributes 0orgunit and 0person ) 
    0person is time dependent and 0gender is attribute of 0person.
    I cant use any of 3 fields in DSO or datasource and until DSO nothing should be changed.
    Now 0employee is mapped with a field from DSO. I have to get data for 0orgunit and 0gender.
    Clients says to use infosource between DSO and Cube to read meta data for 0person and then use 0orgunit and 0gender as navigational attributes in cube.
    I dont understand what they mean by this. At the end we need data for 0orgunit and 0gender in cube.
    Also client say " 0PERSON is a time depended and you've to put the due date. For Data from actual year it would be current day, and for the "historical" ones use field_x an auxillary field in the InfoSource might help there " What do to for this?
    Please help
    Regards
    Zabi
    Edited by: Syed786 on Sep 12, 2011 11:52 AM
    Edited by: Syed786 on Sep 12, 2011 12:14 PM
    Edited by: Syed786 on Sep 12, 2011 6:08 PM

    Hi Frank,
    I'm creating some SEM Management Cockpit, the problem I faced is not the BEx Query itself, but the pie chart design and display. I have processed my data in advance, so there a only 5 values in my query at a time, and these area values are not constant values. If I don't mark a selection criteria, it will display a full pie in Management Cockpit.
    And if I browse the query in IE directory, I can get a desired pie chart by "Swap Axes", so I think maybe there is a same choose in Management Cockpit.
    Thank you and Best Regards,
    Rocket

  • Need help - The network adapter could not establish connection

    hi, I installed sql developer on my standalone PC. I am unable to create a connection. The following error is shown when try connecting:
    IO Exception: The network adapter could not establish connection.
    Should i set some Environment variable? Is there anything else i need to download/install?
    Please help...! I am new to this...

    user11937618 wrote:
    hi, I installed sql developer on my standalone PC. I am unable to create a connection. The following error is shown when try connecting:
    IO Exception: The network adapter could not establish connection.This means that the software being used, was unable to use your PC's networking to establish communication with the database server.
    You need to ask your network admin folk to check your PC and ensure that it is correctly configured for IP networking for your network - valid IP address, valid IP subnet mask, etc.
    You can look at your existing IP configuration in Windows by opening a command console and typing the command "+ipconfig+".
    Once that is done, you need to test connectivity between your PC and the database server. You need the IP address of the server for that and use the "+ping+" command to see if you get a ping echo response from the server.
    If you configure your Oracle client software (e.g. +%ORACLE_HOME%\network\admin\tnsnames.ora+ ) to use a hostname and not IP address, you need to make sure that your PC's IP stack can resolve that hostname into an IP address. Once again the "+ping+" command can be used, but this time using the hostname instead. The output will show the IP address the hostname resolved to.
    All these are basic networking issues - and have nothing really to do with Oracle itself. You first need to get the networking to work on your PC, before attempting to use Oracle client-server.

  • Need help with network adapters for presario sr2163wm

    i cant get my network adapter to work on my presario sr2163wm,can someone help find them

    Hi:
    Below is the link to the network drivers you need for your PC.
    Download the driver file for the operating system you have installed on your PC.
    http://www.realtek.com.tw/downloads/downloadsView.aspx?Langid=1&PNid=14&PFid=6&Level=5&Conn=4&DownTy...
    Paul

  • I need help retrieveing cs3 design standard product key

    I purchased 2 adobe cs3 design standard in 2008. The purchase was made from new egg. I have a copy of the invoice. Need to get the product key. Can you help?

    We can't help you. This is a user forum and we can't help with product key/ registration numbers/ etc.
    You need to use Adobe Chat to talk to an Adobe rep:
    Contact Customer Care

  • Need help re: authentication design

    Hi all.
    I'm designing an app from the ground up on 9i+HTMLDB (yay!), but am still climbing the learning curve WRT all the authentication issues, especially where database links are involved.
    I've tried to piece together an understanding from posts here, from asktom, from docs, etc... but am still a bit fuzzy.
    We're not committed to any particular authentication mechanism yet, but I'd like to take advantage of VPD/FGAC, auditing, and all the other stuff that having "real" database users gives you.
    (If it helps to know: as far as I know OID authentication IS an option in our environment.)
    HTMLDB will reside on one machine (A), fetching data from another machine via database links (B). I believe the HTTP server will be on yet another machine (C). I don't really have control over this.
    I need a "best practice" here for having VPD work in this scenario.
    My thoughts so far:
    1. Set up the HTMLDB DAD with no default username/password, which would prompt the user to login via basic authentication. I'd also set up my dblink without a default username/password, so that authentication from the HTMLDB login will get passed to the linked db. Is that right?
    2. Create views in A to wrap access to tables in B, e.g. "create view t as select * from t@B" (Certainly makes HTMLDB's wizard-driven development easier.)
    3. Apply policies to base tables on B.
    I'm unclear about where to set sys_context, and what object permissions I'll need to set on the views in A.
    Help! Many thanks.
    -John
    PS: sorry for the repost. I sent this last night, and for some reason it got posted with an Aug 2001 timestamp. weird.

    John,
    We should have a VPD how-to published on OTN any day now. Send us your email address (to [email protected]) and we'll send you a draft.
    To address some of your questions lightly:
    - You don't need any database accounts for your users. Setting the sys_context with the name of the authenticated user is the key.
    - You'll use the same DAD you use now, which connects as a generic public user.
    - I strongly recommend that you create views, dblinks, policies, etc., using SQL*Plus and try out a few scenarios with your schema. Then you'll learn what privileges you need on base tables vs. views, etc. Once you get the components working, using them from within an HTML DB application is simple.
    - Search this forum for VPD for related discussions.
    Scott

  • Need help with class design

    I want to design and use one or more classes for a particular project I am working on.
    I need some advice hopefully from someone who has experience in this area. Basically,
    for this particular problem I have two database tables. I want the first class to
    represent the first database table and the second class to represent the second
    database table. An object of the first class will be created first, and then if certain
    criteria are met then an object of the second class will be created.
    Question:
    Should I use classical inheritance and let the first class inherit from the second class?
    Or should I use the containment delegation model and embed an object of the second
    class in the first class?
    ----Tables------
    For example, my first table ET_UserData looks something like this:
    ET_UserData
    (PK)UserName
    Password
    FirstName
    LastName
    My second table ET_DetailedUserData looks like this
    ET_DetailedUserData
    (FK)UserName
    WorkAddress
    WorkPhoneNumber
    CityWhereEmployed
    SocialSecurityNumber
    City
    State
    StreetAdress
    PrimaryTelephoneNumber
    AlternatePhoneNumber
    HasRegistered
    RegistrationDate
    RegistrationTime
    CreditCardNumber
    NameOfPrimaryContact
    DateOfBirth
    Weight
    EyeColor
    Height
    Member
    Here is are some pseudo classes for the two classes.
    Class UserData
    string UserName
    string FirstName
    string LastName
    Class DetailedUserData /* For a classical approach, sub class off of class UserData */
    /* UserData ThisUser --> Containment delegation model */
    string (FK)UserName
    string WorkAddress
    string WorkPhoneNumber
    string CityWhereEmployed
    string SocialSecurityNumber
    string City
    string State
    string StreetAdress
    Int PrimaryTelephoneNumber
    Int AlternatePhoneNumber
    Bool HasRegistered
    Int RegistrationDate
    Int RegistrationTime
    Int CreditCardNumber
    String NameOfPrimaryContact
    Int DateOfBirth
    Int Weight
    Int EyeColor
    Int Height
    bool Member
    }

    Thank you for your help. If you can continue to help me I would appreciate it.
    I and another developer did the database design. Pretty solid design. Plus we have all of the requirements
    which are very good too.
    Originally I wanted just one table to contain all of the data associated with a user. Instead of ET_UserData and ET_Detailed user data I wanted just one table. But I decided to break this table up into the two tables for the following reason.
    1.) This is a web application where each user logs into a web form. At a minimum, in order to use the website the session associated with each user needs the UserName, Password, First and last name.
    This is the data in the first table.
    If they choose to do more specialized functions on this website, then they will need all of the information (Attributes) that are located in the second table. In general 40% of the time all users will need information located in the second table.
    My reasoning for breaking the table into two seperate tables is that I wanted to minimize the amount of data involved in a result set, created from the sql query. The math tells me that 60% of the time most of the data in the result set will not be used.
    2.) If I create one class to represent all of the data/attributes in both tables, then my reasoning is that their will be alot of overhead in the single class because 60% of the time, a majority of the attributes are not needed and used.
    I would deeply appreciate your help with this. You seem to have great insight and advice. Please help me as I increase the duke dollars Sir.

  • Need help in Architecture Design

    Hi All,
    Currently we are facing an issue in design of SAP Landscape which has CRM, EP, BW. We need to generate and display reports on B2B screen by accessing BW. Can some one help me out in providing some docs or  links that give an insight in desinging the landscape with various approaches.
    All Helpful answers will be rewarded.
    Regards,
    Udaya

    Hi Udaya,
    See if any of the following links prove to be of any help:
    EP 6.0 integration with BW, R/3, and ORACLE
    <a href="/people/kamaljeet.kharbanda/blog/2005/09/14/sap-netweavercomplete-information-integration-platform:///people/kamaljeet.kharbanda/blog/2005/09/14/sap-netweavercomplete-information-integration-platform
    Bye
    Ankur

  • Need Help With Spreadsheet Design

    Hi,
    I write about diabetes on various Internet Forums and am currently involved in testing various blood glucose meters to determine the accuracy of the different makes/models. I am trying to design a spreadsheet in Appleworks to help me evaluate the meters but have very little experience with spreadsheets so am finding it tough going.
    In comparing the various blood glucose values delivered by the meters I am trying to come up with a way to automatically compare 2 readings and then display how much a particular reading is above or below another percentage wise. The difficulty is that a particular meter might sometimes display a value higher than another one time, and lower than another the next time so I'm not sure how to design the speadsheet to automatically calculate the percentages.
    For instance in sample one Meter A reads 115mg/dl and Meter B reads 87 mg/dl so by dividing the 115 into 87 I can determine that Meter A is reading 24% higher than Meter B. But then in sample two Meter A reads 89 mg/dl while Meter B reads 121 mg/dl so in this case Meter B is reading 26% higher than Meter A.
    Is there a way to structure the spreadsheet so that it can compare the two readings and then based upon which one is higher divide the result into the lower one can come up with a percentage?
    Thanks!
    Winston

    Hi Winston,
    Leaving aside any discussion of the actual test design, here's a rundown of how to make the spreadsheet do (most of) what you want it to do.
    What I want the spreadsheet to do is to accept the data from meter 1 and meter 2 in side by side columns of cells. I next want the spreadsheet to compare the 2 bG values obtained from the same blood sample with these meters to one another and then divide the smaller value by the larger value to determine the amount in percent that one meter is higher or lower than the other.
    This division (r/R) compares the smaller value (r) to the larger (R) and reports the result as a fraction.
    eg. 75/100 = 0.75 The smaller reading is 75% of the larger reading, or the smaller reading is 25% lower than the higher reading.
    But that does not mean the higher reading is 25% higher than the lower. That percentage is given by comparing the larger reading to the smaller (R/r). For the same pair of readings:
    100/75 = 1.33.. The larger reading is 33% higher than the smaller.
    As the percentages will be listed in columns labeled "Meter x higher", the R/r division is the appropriate one.
    This is comparison is complicated by the fact that meter 1 will sometimes return the higher of the two readings, and at other times meter 2 will be higher. Thus it's not a simple matter of asking the spreadsheet to divide the result of meter 1 by the result of meter 2 each and every time or vice versa.
    Next on the agenda I want the spreadsheet to put the result obtained by the above calculation in one or the other of two additional columns of cells. In other words the spreadsheet will compare the value of meter 1 to meter 2, divide the smaller value by the larger value to determine percentage, and finally place the result obtained in one of two additional columns of cells. One of these additional columns of cells would be labeled Meter 1 Higher and the other would be labeled Meter 2 higher.
    All of the formulas given previously will make a comparison.
    Niel's and Barry's report the percentage by which the higher reading is higher than the lower.
    Brie's and Terry's report the percentage by which the lower reading is lower than the higher.
    All put the results into the same cell (column) without regard to which reading is highest. (Barry's set includes labels to identify the higher meter.)
    Here's mine again, with revisions to place the results into separate columns:
    Labels in Row 2: C2: Meter A, D2: Meter B, E2: A Higher, F2: B Higher
    Tests results in Row 3, Meter A in C3, Meter B in D3
    Comparison results in E3 and F3
    E3: =IF(C3<D3,"",C3/D3-1) Set the Number Format of this cell to percent.
    F3: =IF(D3<C3,"",D3/C3-1) "
    Note: the IF() statement suppresses the result in the column reporting "is higher" results for the meter with the ;ower reading. Written as above, the formulas will report in both columns where both meters show identical readings.
    Note2: As written, the formulas will return a #DIV/0! error if no results have been entered on that line. The version below suppresses any results until readings have been entered in column D.
    E3: =IF(D3,IF(C3<D3,"",C3/D3-1),"") Set the Number Format of this cell to percent.
    F3: =IF(D3,IF(D3<C3,"",D3/C3-1),"") "
    Roughly 1,000 tests will be performed over a several month timespan and all the meter readings referred to above will each be compared by the spreadsheet.
    The default size of an AppleWorks spreadsheet is 40 columns by 500 rows. Go Format > Document... to increase the number of rows to 1050 to allow room for 'roughly 1000 tests.'
    For 1000 tests, fill the formulas above down through rows 3..1002 (aasumed in examples below).
    Next I want the spreadsheet to examine all the cells in which meter 1 returned the higher result and perform the following calculations:
    lowest percentage over meter 2 obtained
    highest percentage " "
    The second is easy: =MAX(E3..E1002)
    Place the formula where you want this result reported.
    The first runs into a problem: empty cells, or those with non numeric data are evaluated numerically as "0" by the MIN() function. There is a workaround.
    Use an empty column to the right of the active part of the spreadsheet. (I've arbitrarily chosen column M)
    M3: =IF(E3>0,E3,1000)
    Fill down M3..M1002
    This copies all greater than zero values into column M, and inserts a value of 1000 wherever the value in column E is 0.
    The minimum value in this column (which is also the non-zero minimum of column E) is given by:
    =MIN(M3..M1002)
    Place the formula where you want this result reported.
    number of identical readings obtained
    I'm assuming you mean 'identical differences' in terms of percent higher.
    There are a couple of difficulties here:
    1. AppleWorks does not include a MODE() function which would extract the number appearing with the greatest frequency.
    2. What constitutes "identical" depends on the (mathematical) precision of the results. AppleWorks can display results to 11 significant places (eg. 12.345678901), and actually does the calculations to a few more places than that. Given that precision, many results that are not significantly different willl not be identified as "identical."
    Probably doable, but more detail needed before jumping in.
    average percentage " "
    average deviation
    Not sure what you're asking with these. Can you elaborate?
    Regards
    Barry

  • Need help creating network of 1 Airport Extreme & 2 Airport Expresses!

    Please somebody help me! I've literally been trying to get our home network to function for months now. I'm seriously about to cry if i can't make it work.
    Here's the situation:
    Our apartment is long and narrow and probably has lead paint, so our wifi, powered by a brand new Airport Extreme Base Station 802.11n router (named Igor) connected to a comcast modem doesn't reach the whole house. So we got 2 Airport Expresses to place throughout the apartment (named Sven and Svetlana) to help boost the signal.
    First i tried to set up Igor to 'Create a wireless network" with the option 'allow this network to be extended' and the connection sharing set to 'Share a public IP' and i set up Sven and Svetlana to 'extend a wireless network' and the connection sharing was set to 'share a public IP'. Everything else was automatic or default pretty much. I got it to work but the connection was really weak and dropped out a lot.
    Then i tried setting up a WDS network. no luck there either. so i went to the apple store and they told me i had to hard wire them all together using ethernet cables (roaming network i guess) to compensate for the ****** network acoustics in our place.
    So...i ran 1 ethernet cable from Igor down the hall to Svetlana and another from Igor further down the hall to Sven. I set up all 3 to 'create a wireless network' and gave them all the same network name and password. i left the 'allow this network to be extended' option unchecked on all 3 and put them all in bridge mode and automatic settings for the radio mode and channel selection. After about 50 restarts i finally got it to work. Things seemed great for a minute until i realized that my laptop was the only one in the house that could connect to the internet. When i tried to troubleshoot the problem using network diagnostics and restarts, i eventually got my roommate's laptop to work but then mine stopped working.
    i've tried changing Igor's connection setting to share a public IP address and leaving Sven and Svetlana's in bridge mode. I've tried changing the 'configure IPv4' setting from 'using DHCP' to 'manual' and entering in identical info for all 3 in the TCP/IP section.
    no matter what i do i still have no idea how to make this work for multiple devices in our apartment. I really don't understand that much about networking but i am great at following directions. Please please please please help me! I'm desperate.
    thank you in advance for your help!
    ilana

    So...i ran 1 ethernet cable from Igor down the hall to Svetlana and another from Igor further down the hall to Sven. I set up all 3 to 'create a wireless network' and gave them all the same network name and password. i left the 'allow this network to be extended' option unchecked on all 3 and put them all in bridge mode and automatic settings for the radio mode and channel selection.
    In a "roaming" network, the router connected to the Internet modem should NOT be in bridge mode. In this case that would be your 802.11n AirPort Extreme Base Station (AEBSn). That is because you want it to provide both NAT & DHCP services to both AirPort Express Base Stations and the network clients.

Maybe you are looking for

  • In table PAYR field CHECV is not being populated when void check is reissue

    Hello,  we are trying to find a link between original check # that is voided and then new check # is issued when the reopened invoice is repaid.  It is very cumbersome trying to research back to original check # as there is not link in any SAP tables

  • Display does not turn back on after idle

    I have an annoying problem with my MacBookPro that never occurred with my previous MacBook. When I leave it open and idle for awhile and the screen goes dark no trackpad motion or keypress gets the screen to come back on. It just stays black. The onl

  • Imac external display

    I am having trouble getting my imac to act as teh external display for my MBP.  This has worked up until today ... new software update on imac (10.8.5). Anyone else having this issue?

  • Urxvt and äöå

    Hey! I have this really hard-to-solve problem, so I decided to ask for help.. My keymap works just fine in other programs except for urxvt. Even in urxvt, all the other buttons except for ä å and ö work fine. Copy-pasting them doesn't work either, al

  • Problem with SAP logon 720 for printng with Citrix.

    Hi, I have a problem with sap logon 720 when printing for Citrix, one time print and other time don't print.... I try to start SAPLPD for prompt comand... it's start but don't print.... i'm write here for look if other people have this problem... I d