Newer MBA or Older MBP for light - moderate music, video, and graphic editing

Essentially I would be using it for the following:
Word Processing (ms office suite)
Video editing (primarily YT videos) via FCP X
Music editing / production via Garageband, Logic Pro, and Melodyne
Adobe Photoshop CS6 (nothing to heavy like I said willing to live without retina)
Probably light gaming
Coding ( I don't think this should be an issue, but want the ability to write apps for iOS)
Web surfing obviously
Building itunes library
It seems like a bit now that I look at it, but I don't think I would have more than two of these programs running at the same time (my guess is the worst would be fcpx, garageband, and cs6 all open at the same time). I have a 500GB western digital external HD that is practically empty minus a recent backup of all my files on my current computer.
Which do you think would fit my needs more? Portability is a factor for me but I think the mba is like 1/2 a pound lighter or something which I'm not sure makes a huge difference to me since I'm currently lugging around a 15" pc that is around 7-8lbs.
So I've kind of figured that 256 gb ssd is probably going to be the most I can afford with a budget of $1190 and under ( could I get away with 128gb with my 500gb external hd?).
I know I can get the ssd and ram (at least 8GB unless 4GB would suffice) I need with a MBA but I do not know if the processor will be good enough for everything i'm planning to do. I've seen older MBP (circa 2011-2012) that has adequate ram (8-16gb) minus a ssd but regular hd with 500-700gb in some cases 1 TB. I've seen these for less than 1000 on ebay.
So which is a better choice? I don't want a system that is too old. I currently have a working cd/dvdr drive on my pc so I could live without having a cd/dvd drive in my mac or superdrive or whatever.
I'm interested in brand new or refurbished (either by apple or seller). Nothing used. An SD slot would also be nice to have but I'm unsure as to which models have them.

From what I see on Twitter and blogs, a lot of photography pros are picking up the new MacBook Airs as their road machines because with the new Core iX processors they are quite acceptable for performance. I've mostly read about them using Lightroom, though, and not as a primary machine, so you should take some of your raw photos to an Apple store and run some Aperture tests to see how it feels. Do you think there is enough room to see everything, or does it feel cramped?
The main problem with the MacBook Air is not being able to put more than 4GB RAM in it, but with the SSD you might not notice the lag as much. For most people the Air is a fantastic computer. I use the 15" MacBook Pro, because I use other graphics apps where I need room to display documents, filmstrips, palettes, etc. so I need mor pixels, and also because I need to be able to have more RAM.
I would guess that GarageBand wouldn't be a problem on any new Mac, assuming you're not piling on heaps of effects.

Similar Messages

  • 13" MBA or 15" MBP for a musician, amateur photographer, and college student?

    Now, if I had it my way I'd wait for the next MBP release, but alas my mother says I must buy a laptop now.
    I've heard that the MBA is great for just about every average user's needs, but I do use my computer for more than the average user does.
    Right now I'm using an HP desktop which I'll be bringing with me to college: 6 GB RAM,  an i5 2.67GHz processor, and a 512 GB HDD at 7200 rpm.
    It has a sucky monitor, but I'm going to replace it very soon.
    I'm excited to get my Mac and use Aperture with it, because I tried Lightroom and found that it is not good enough in terms of workflow, so I did not purchase it (pricey) and am just using the Nikon software included with my camera.
    I work with RAW files and often import 8 GB of them at a time and edit them, convert them to jpegs. The processes are all just a little slow, with the conversion to jpegs being the worst by far. That could be because I'm using the Nikon software, though. I recall that Lightroom was lightyears faster at that.
    My point it, I WANT to use the Macbook I get as my primary photo editing machine. Is this realistic? Can either of the machines I'm looking at really handle that?
    The 13" MBA would be too small, wouldn't it?
    If I got the 15" MBP, I'd get the hi-res screen as well.
    But the MBA is just so beautiful and portable. I'm worried that the MBP will feel like a burden. Then again, 6 pounds isn't that heavy still. And I know that if I buy the MBP, they will release a new one and I will feel remorseful, but, hey, a new model will always be around the corner.
    And I couldn't afford a SSD if I got the MBP. :/
    If I get the MBA, it will be maxed out.
    I will also probably be purchasing an external hard drive for photos in the next 6 months, so I'm not concerned about 256 GB on the MBA being too little.
    As far as other uses of the computer, I do some audio recording and editing. How good are the two machines at Garageband?
    I'll do a lot of word processing for school. I like to stream video, listen to music.
    Also, I love the HD cam on the MBP and hate the one of the MBA. I will be Skyping a lot this year.
    Oh my GOSH. Sorry for writing so much and being disorganized. Thanks for reading! Haha.

    From what I see on Twitter and blogs, a lot of photography pros are picking up the new MacBook Airs as their road machines because with the new Core iX processors they are quite acceptable for performance. I've mostly read about them using Lightroom, though, and not as a primary machine, so you should take some of your raw photos to an Apple store and run some Aperture tests to see how it feels. Do you think there is enough room to see everything, or does it feel cramped?
    The main problem with the MacBook Air is not being able to put more than 4GB RAM in it, but with the SSD you might not notice the lag as much. For most people the Air is a fantastic computer. I use the 15" MacBook Pro, because I use other graphics apps where I need room to display documents, filmstrips, palettes, etc. so I need mor pixels, and also because I need to be able to have more RAM.
    I would guess that GarageBand wouldn't be a problem on any new Mac, assuming you're not piling on heaps of effects.

  • Any new firmeware in year 2009 for nokia n73 music...

    any new firmeware in year 2009 for nokia n73 music edition ?
    product code : 0539295

    Hi man2007
    As firmware support for a device is about 18 months from release, it is most unlikely unfortunately. 
    Happy to have helped forum in a small way with a Support Ratio = 37.0

  • After change HDD for my MAC, How to transfer music, video and app from my IPAD to new iTunes

    after change Hard disk for my MAC, How to transfer music, video and app from my IPAD to new iTunes,

    you can only transfer music and video you bought on the ipad
    this is don by choosing it in the menu called transfer purchases to itunes or something like that
    apps can only be bought once you in itunes you can always choose purchases and show apps not on this ipad and get it back that way

  • I downloaded the updated Firefox, but the ad-on for converting YouTube music videos to mps files is now unavailable. How do I get it back? Why was this feature disabled?

    I downloaded the updated Firefox, but the ad-on for converting YouTube music videos to mps files is now unavailable. How do I get it back? Why was this feature disabled?
    In the former Firefox version there was a box to click for converting YouTube music videos into HQ mp3 files. That box is no longer apparent in the new Firefox version. I went back to Ad-On s and re-downloaded the program YouTube to MP3 1.2. It says it's not compatible with Firefox 6.0. Can I reinstall the older version of Firefox?

    When I clicked on the second site mentioned, I got such EXPLICIT, step-by-step directions!!! Thank you so much. I'd been wondering what that window was that kept popping up with the Firefox icon and that other funny thing. The word *install* was never mentioned. Pictographs were never my thing.
    When I looked under the initial system requirements, it said that OS X 10.4.5 and higher were good for 5.0. I didn't check further. Under your advice, I'll go with the older version. Thank you for taking the time to help me.

  • Which is faster for video and photo editing

    I am using a black macbook (2.2 GHz C2D, 4 GB RAM), my wife is using a macbook pro (2.16 C2D, 3 GB RAM). I found my macbook to be slow in video and photo editing. Do you think I'll get a boost in processing if I exchange my macbook with my wife's older macbook pro? If it is not worth it, I do want to go through the hassle of transferring data and re-installing apps. Thanks in advance for the advice.
    Schizont

    Try editing a decent picture on her MBP and see if you're satisfied.

  • Elegant technique for cutting a music video

    Hi,
    I am editing a music video and need to make color and contrast adjustments to the clips. The video was shot in a few locations and each location requires different color correction, etc. For example, there are clips from an office under fluorescent lighting, and other clips shot in backlit sunset. The clips alternate between the different locations/lighting setups and I think that once I decide on something that works, I could apply the same adjustments to all of the other clips from each setup.
    I've been thinking about the best way to apply my adjustments to each clip. I can only think to copy and paste the video effects and manually copy/paste into each clip. But I thought I would reach out and see if anyone here could advise me on a better, more elegant way to do this.
    Thank you!
    -John

    Ah, great and simple tip. Thank you.
    I was imagining there might be a tricky way to use an adjustment layer so that I could avoid having to copy and paste multiple adjustments to multiple clips.

  • How do i download the new version of itunes without deleting my current music library and apps?

    I have downloaded to new version of itunes in the past and lost all of my music. How do I successfully complete the download of teh new version of itunes, without deleting my current music library and apps?

    Open itunes, click Itunes>Check for updates.
    I nor anyone I know have ever lost anything on update.

  • I have an iphone 5s and when I make a playlist on itunes for music videos and sync my iphone the playlist does not show up. What can I do to fix the problem?

    I have an iphone 5s and when I make a playlist on itunes for music videos and sync my iphone the playlist does not show up. What can I do to fix the problem?

    Version 11.1.5.5 of iTunes was just released today. If you update to that, does that help with the recognition troubles?
    http://www.apple.com/itunes/download/

  • Submitting academic proof for Adobe Creative Cloud Student and Teacher Edition

    I was contacted to validate my academic status for a Creative Cloud Student and Teacher Edition I purchased via adobe.com on May 14, 2014. The Education FAQ page (http://helpx.adobe.com/x-productkb/policy-pricing /education-faq.html) states:
    "Submit your proof of eligibility when you place your order. If you have a pending order, go to My Orders in your Adobe account, and click Submit Proof."
    However, when I go to My Orders page, there is no link saying "Submit Proof". I do have my proof readily available, but I am not sure how else I can submit it.
    I was told my subscription would be canceled in if I could not prove my academic status within 14 days (it was sent on July 2nd), and am still awaiting a response from Adobe Customer Support. So any help would be greatly appreciated.

    Thank you! This page helped.
    I also read through another thread (Where to submit proof? No submit proof button) that provided a link where I could send proof.

  • How do i search for a specific music video instead of browsing through thousands

    how do i search for a specific music video instead of browsing through thousands?

    Type a keyword or two in the search area - shown in the upper right here (the oval area):

  • Then new version of IMovie imported nearly all of my video and then suddenly closed.  Now it won't recognize the video that it stil hasn't imported?  I took the sd card out of the canon camcorder but still won't recognize or import it.  Is there a cache t

    Then new version of IMovie imported nearly all of my video and then  suddenly closed.  Now it won't recognize the video that it stil hasn't  imported?  I took the sd card out of the canon camcorder but still won't  recognize or import it.  Is there a cache that needs cleared?

    Did you get any joy with answering this?
    My first thought was that maybe when you imported you chose to leave the files  in place rather than copy then to the iMovie library..but I can't see where that option is now.
    I too have created a short movie from load f clips..but can't export or share either..the 'Share 'menu is empty..you go to it and no sub menu appears.

  • Same volume for music videos and music?

    Is there a way to have all my music videos and music to have the same volume on playback rather than me having to adjust my receiver up and down all the time?
    Thanks

    recall itunes having an option to lvl out vol for all music in the lib
    it takes awhile
    not sure about videos

  • Good afternoon, my name is mike Perreault, on 9-28-13 I was looking for a free music app and I must have touch an ad about iTunes Radio because I was charged 20.20 on my acc", could please tell why and credit back on my acc.

    Good afternoon,  my name is mike Perreault , on 9-28-13 I looked for a free music app., I don't know what happen but my credit card was charged $20.20, please tell me why and credit my acc. Because I didn't purchase anything from iTunes .
    Sincerely ,
    Mike

    Please be aware that you are not communicating with Apple when you post in these forums. Most of the people who will reply to your posts are, like me, your fellow users.
    As to your issue, first, make sure that you did not inadvertently make an in-app purchase. Many apps, particularly games, are free for the base game but charge for additional features such as levels, "coins" and other such add-ons. Check your Purchase History to see if that reminds you as to what you might have purchased:
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT2727
    If you find that this was an in-app purchase, to prevent this from happening again, turn off "In App purchases" in the Restrictions settings on your device. For more information, see:
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT4213
    As to a refund, that's not automatic since the terms of sale for the iTunes Store state that all sales are final. You can contact the iTunes Store, explain the reason for your request, and ask, though:
    http://www.apple.com/support/itunes/contact.html
    They're usually pretty lenient in the case of inadvertent purchases, but there are no guarantees.
    If the charge was not an in-app purchase that you made and forgot but the charges do appear in your Purchase History, contact the iTunes Store and let them know. You should also immediately change your password for your Apple ID. If the charges don't appear in your Purchase History, they were probably fake charges made directly to your credit card, and your card issuer will need to handle those.
    Regards.

  • HT1420 My old computer crashed so I bought this new one. I can't get my prevouis purchases and my new purchases will not let me add to my IPODs. I deauthorized all computers and just authourzed ths one. my new one. How do I get my music back and how do I

    My old computer crashed andI bought a new one. When I went to Itunes I deauthorized all computers and then authorized my new one but I can not get my prevous purchases and I can not add my new purchases to my IPods with out it deleting all the music. How can I transfer everything that was on the old computer to this new one?

    Whether you can redownload previous purchases depends upon the type of item (audiobooks and ringtones are one-time only downloads), what country that you are in (music, films, TV shows can't be redownloaded in all countries), and whether the item is still in your country's store (content providers occasionally remove their items) - what you can redownload will show under the Purchased link under Quicklinks on the right-hand side of the iTunes store homepage
    Or you should be able to copy purchases back from your iPod via the File > Devices > Transfer Purchases menu option (if the drop-down menus aren't showing then control-B should get them to show).
    If you have music from other sources on your iPod (e.g. copied from CDs) then there are some programs listed half-way down this page which should be able to copy them back : https://discussions.apple.com/docs/DOC-3991
    Or do you have a copy of them anywhere else e.g. on your backup of your downloads/library that you can copy them onto your new computer from ?

Maybe you are looking for

  • ICloud: reminders in iCal all over the place, unable to sort

    Since I have switched my .me account to iCloud I have been unable to auto sort reminders in iCal on my Mac by date as I used to be able to before the switch. Before I had the option to sort by date when I clicked on the small triangle on the right si

  • ORDER BY timestamp column as a string

    Does any one have any tips/tricks for using an ORDER BY clause for a timestamp column that is a string? I am developing a UNION query that combines data from a table and an audit history table to show current data plus historical data. I had to conve

  • Double-loading pages in Firefox

    Hoping someone else has seen this and has a quick answer. When I publish my project (RH6) and open it in Firefox 2, clicking on links frequently flashes the page loaded by the link, but then reloads the page from which the link was originally clicked

  • WebApp Custom Fields with Liquid

    With the liquid rendering engine tags in webapps have changed. For instance in the list layout I could display the name of the webapp item by using the following tag: {tag_name_nolink. With liquid I can use: {{name}} But for custom webapp fields what

  • I added an app that said FREE then it is giving to me for 14 days,,,I want to delete it and do not know how..

    I added an app that said FREE then after installing it said I had a 14 day trial..I want to delete this and do not know how