Photo loosing sharpness when passing it to Photoshop and viewing it in LR again

Hi
I passed a JPG from LR to Photoshop CC, did a little change and saved it. Then I realized, that the PSD file has lost some sharpness compared to the original JPG.
It doesn't matter if I pass it with the option "with lightroom changes" or not. It happens in both cases that use a copy.
That's really weird and frustrating.
But, I found out that this only the case if I view the photo in LR   (In Phothoshop and Irfanview all version of the photo looks the same regarding the sharpness)
A very ugly bug in LR 5.7?
edit:
The difference get smaller after viewing both photos in 1:1. But still, there is a difference viewable when switching between exactly the same images (just passed it for test purpose to Photoshop as copy, and saved it as JPG, no editing in PS).
Regards

First of all I should say that I was able to download the file, but initially I got an error that said it was not found.  It was probably just an incompatibility of the dropfiles site and my default browser download plug-in and it finally worked just using the standard browser download function.  Looking at the contents of the photo, itself, there are no LR adjustments that have been saved to the JPG, only a few metadata changes such as adding the photo location as being in Hawaii.
Anyway, there are several issues that are being mixed together:
1)  When a JPG is opened and resaved it will be slightly different due to JPG compression being a lossy format and that the color workspace in PS is slightly different than in LR so when PS converts the colors from its 16-bit workspace to 8-bits the output pixels won't be exactly the same as the input pixels even if there were no substantive changes in PS, just an open and resave.
In this 4:1 screenshot the PS photo does have more variation in colors between adjacent rows of pixels than the original in LR:
2)  This variation in colors can lead to an apparent difference in sharpness in LR when a resampled-smaller zoom level is used--in this case Fill with a small LR window size:
3a)  The PS resampling for display and the LR resampling for display use different algorithms due to LR having to be as quick as possible, so what you see at those zoom levels doesn't accurately reflect the actual image sharpness, only resampling algorithm accuracy and differences.
3b)  In LR there is a warning badge in the Detail panel when using zoom less than 100%.  Unfortunately the warning disappears when I press a key to do a screen capture of it:
So to summarize, pixels don't remain unchanged across an Open/Save cycle when you're using the lossy JPG format -- a reason to use TIFs, and less than 100%/1:1 zoom levels don't show sharpening accurately in any program and differences between resampling algorithms in different programs result in differences in the inaccuracy of the resampled result.  In other words, with less than 100%/1:1 zoom PS's inaccuracy is different than LR's inaccuracy so neither should be used to judge sharpness, and you should use 100%/1:1 zoom or higher.

Similar Messages

  • JPGS are set to open in Photoshop Elements, but they open in Windows Photo Viewer instead, even when I specifically select Photoshop (and it's the default app)

    JPGS are set to open in Photoshop Elements, but they open in Windows Photo Viewer instead, even when I specifically select Photoshop (and it's the default app)

    Hi,
    It seems this is a Microsoft related. You are referring on how to set JPG Image in Photoshop Elements by default. You may try visiting Microsoft's Support page http://support.microsoft.com/ for you to get the correct information/help you need.
    Thank you.

  • Many of my recently uploaded photos are horizontal when they should be vertical, and vice versa.  I've corrected all these on my laptop but in my iPad and i Phone photo streams they are still mixed.  How can I fix this?  Thanks.

    Many of my recently uploaded photos are horizontal when they should be vertical, and vice versa.  I've corrected all these on my laptop but in my iPad and i Phone photo streams they are still mixed.  How can I fix this?  Thanks.

    Add the corrected ones to your PS - PS contains only what was added to it - changes made are not applied to the PS - you have to re add the updated photos
    LN

  • After iPhoto update some photos go black when trying to edit them and am unable to edit those photos

    After iPhoto update some photos go black when trying to edit them and am unable to edit those photos. How do I fix this as this is the latest update?

    If I hold down the Option key while launching iPhoto, I get the option to start a new library. Do I have to import all my thousands of photos into the new library?
    In his original post the poster referenced the following. As to the new Library, see the end.
    There are several possible causes for the Black Screen issue
    1. *Permissions in the Library* : Back Up and try rebuild the library: hold down the command and option (or alt) keys while launching iPhoto. Use the resulting dialogue to rebuild. Include the option to check and repair permissions.
    2. *Minor Database corruption*: Back Up and try rebuild the library: hold down the command and option (or alt) keys while launching iPhoto. Use the resulting dialogue to rebuild.
    3. *A Damaged Photo*: Select one of the affected photos in the iPhoto Window and right click on it. From the resulting menu select 'Show File (or 'Show Original File' if that's available). Will the file open in Preview? If not then the file is damaged. Time to restore from your back up.
    4. *A corrupted iPhoto Cache*: Trash the com.apple.iPhoto folder from HD/Users/Your Name/Library/ Caches...
    5. *A corrupted preference file*: Trash the com.apple.iPhoto.plist file from the HD/Users/ Your Name / library / preferences folder. (Remember you'll need to reset your User options afterwards. These include minor settings like the window colour and so on. Note: If you've moved your library you'll need to point iPhoto at it again.)
    *If none of these help*:
    As a Test:
    Hold down the option (or alt) key key and launch iPhoto. From the resulting menu select 'Create Library'
    Import a few pics into this new, blank library. Is the Problem repeated there?
    Regards
    TD

  • Hi everybody,please someone help me,i had a 3gs last year and i bought a 4,but itunes doesn't synch videos from photos file and it crashes,every time i try to synch photos it stacks when videos try to synch and crashes,what to do please?

    hi everybody,please someone help me,i had a 3gs last year and i bought a 4,but itunes doesn't synch videos from photos file and it crashes,every time i try to synch photos it stacks when videos try to synch and crashes,what to do please?

    hi i had the same problem today when i updated my itunes to latest version. however, i have just found my songs in the 'itunes media' folder. this was accessed through 'my music'  then keep clicking through until you find itunes media and all my library songs were in there and i then just added these files to my library and all were restored however, i have lost all my playlists but at least my 700 songs are back. very dissapointed with apple that they have let this happen with their latest update, the previous version was miles better than this one . hope you find them. stevo

  • When i scan in PDF and view it on the screen it has a blue effect

    When i scan into PDF and view it on the screen it has a blue effect

    What scan software do you use? Adobe Reader can't create PDF files.

  • My problem is after updating to Yosemite does my mail client any longer. I can not even open the mail, and when I "forced closes" mail and try to open it again to go in the entered settings running the colored wheels around and allows me only to forc

    My problem is after updating to Yosemite does my mail client any longer. I can not even open the mail, and when I "forced closes" mail and try to open it again to go in the entered settings running the colored wheels around and allows me only to forcing close again? does anyone have a solution to the above problem?

    You mean the default OS X mail app? Try reinstalling OS X Yosemite if that's the case.
    If you are referring to 3rd party mail applications, that's a compatibility issue. Some apps don't work in the new operating system. You have to wait until the developer updates the app, or you have to revert back to Mavericks to continue using it.

  • When I go to youtube and view a video clip it usually asks if i want to save the video I'm watching. Now all of a sudden it no longer asks the question. How do I get it back?

    when I go to youtube and view a video clip it usually asks if i want to save the video I'm watching. Now all of a sudden it no longer asks the question. How do I get it back?

    I believe that might be related to this:
    See: http://real.custhelp.com/app/answers/detail/a_id/7303/p/3/c/2222/r_id/119487
    Real is always, it seems, late in releasing updates for new browser updates. They are given the same opportunity during the Firefox pre-release testing as other developers to be sure that their products will work with new Firefox releases.
    But, alas, always the same problem!

  • HELP, why does saved image look too sharp when re-opened in Photoshop but normal in Windows viewer?

    Been using Photoshop Elements 7 for several years and this has never happened before!  I applied sharpening to an image and saved two copies: PSD and JPEG.  When I re-opened the PSD file it looked WAY over-sharpened.  In Photoshop Editor I then opened the JPEG and it too looked way over-sharpened.  But the strange thing is that when I view the JPEG in the Windows Photo Viewer it looks normal!  Just as it did when I originally saved it.   I decided to try an experiment.  I opened the PSD file that now appears overly sharpened and saved a new JPEG.  I then opened the new JPEG in Windows Photo Viewer -- and it looks normal, even though it was saved from the PSD file that looks over-sharp!  I then opened the same, newly saved JPEG in Photoshop -- and it now looks oversharp and distorted, just like the PSD file.  Can anyone tell me what is going on here?  I'm completely confused!  Hope someone can help me figure this out.  Thanks!

    The over sharpening may have caused a color shift.
    You might have better luck using the adjust sharpness command. Enhance<Adjust Sharpness.
    Skip down to "Precisely sharpen an image" on the help page listed below for info on adjust sharpness command.
    http://help.adobe.com/en_US/PhotoshopElements/7.0_Win/WSAC75B090-7431-4b74-B4DC-C5B02EBC4C BF.html
    Here are a handful of links which might be of use about USM.
    http://photocritic.org/unsharp-mask-sharpening-photos-photoshop/
    Note: You will not be able to do the manual USM segment in the above article as Photoshop Elements does not include the Apply Image Command. It does give some start settings to try out.
    http://www.photokaboom.com/photography/learn/Photoshop_Elements/sharpening/USM_2_amount_ra dius_threshold.htm
    http://www.naturescapes.net/122004/tg1204.htm
    http://www.earthboundlight.com/phototips/unsharp-mask.html
    USM for haze removal added as it can be a useful thing to know:
    http://www.lonestardigital.com/photoshop_quicktips.htm
    Several sharpening methods discussed including highpass sharpening.
    http://www.photokaboom.com/photography/learn/Photoshop_Elements/sharpening/1_sharpening_in troduction.htm
    Highpass sharpening:
    http://www.essential-photoshop-elements.com/high-pass-sharpening.html
    http://nyfalls.com/article-photoshop-high-pass-sharpening.html

  • Why do I loose sharpness when I export out of Aperture?

    My images look almost blurred once exported out of Aperture 3.0.  !  I am finding in my reading that others have been having this problem for years!  Has Apple not fixed this yet?  I may have to go to Photoshop, but really don't want to!!!

    That doesn't sound right at all. My exports looks fine. I wonder if it could be some kind of glitch or something...
    Just out of curiosity, what do your export preferences look like? What quality setting do you have for jpegs, and what dpi for external editor file format? How about the dpi in your export presets you've been using? How about your RAW Fine Tuning sharpness sliders? (although that would affect how your images appear in Aperture, although it is subtle)
    Aperture has limited (but effective) sharpening options, and by default rendering the images are softer than what you might be used to if you used to process your RAW images with ACR (Photoshop, Lightroom). But I was able to match the default ACR rendering (in terms of sharpness, I mean) with Aperture by maxing out the sharpness sliders in RAW Fine Tuning and applying a Sharpen Edges adjustment with only mildly aggressive sharpening.
    Oh, that reminds me, which sharpness adjustment are you using? Sharpen is from the previous versions of Aperture, and is included for legacy/compatibility purposes with images that were processed in Aperture 1 & 2. Sharpen Edges is much more advanced and is generally recommended over the other.
    Doug

  • My Content/text/code is being deleted when selected in Dreamweaver, Photoshop and Illustrator

    FOr the past week when I select text in photoshop and illustrator, or code in dreamweaver, it is deleted.  I've updated all apps and uninstalled and reinstalled dreamweaver but nothing seems to work.  Is this an app issue or a mac issue?  Its only happening with adobe products.

    Have you asked in the specific forums for those programs?
    If you start at the Forums Index http://forums.adobe.com/index.jspa
    You will be able to select a forum for the specific Adobe product(s) you use
    Click the "down arrow" symbol on the right to open the drop down list and scroll

  • Photos loose sequence when moved to photo stream

    Seems to me I've seen this one before, but can't find it. I finally got my photo sequence correct and modified version name to reflect the sequence. Now when I create a shared photo stream, the photos seem to loose that sequence. Did I miss something?

    Did I miss something?
    The Shared Photo Stream is supposed to show  the photos in the order that you add them to the stream - the newesst photos at the end of the stream. But that will not work, if you add all photos at once. I find, I get he best results by adding the photos one by one, and letting each photo upload, before I add the next one.

  • I loose my files after editing with photoshop and saving.

    I can "see" the file title listed in the photoshop save dialogue box but can find no way to access them again. They do not appear in aperature and fail to be found using any search string from finder.

    Before you sent the image to Photoshop as the External Editor, did you see new version (either .psd or .tif) that Aperture created for the purpose?  If so, then is that version still in the strip of images, or in the Browser?
    Ernie

  • Why the iPad became blank black when I syn with itunes and it did not work again?

    Why the ipad became blank black when I syn it with itunes of the desk top.  It did not work since then.

    Have you tried a reset ? Press and hold both the sleep and home buttons for about 10 to 15 seconds, after which the Apple logo should appear - you won't lose any content, it's the iPad equivalent of a reboot.

  • I am facing a problem in downloading the free apps as it says verification required. when i press to continue and puts my password, it again ask foraccount details.where i am opting payment type none and then updating other requirment...and it is then ask

    please help in downloading the free apps from apple store as i could not find the postcode of Dubai as it is a nessary step to complete the account.

    You still have to have a payment method registered even to download free apps.

Maybe you are looking for

  • How do I back my iphone  music up to a new computer

    I previously had the music on my iPhone 5 backed up to my old computer, this computer has now crashed and I can't access anything off it. Is there a way I can get this music from my library?

  • Is there a way to create a new section under "Library"?

    iTunes lists several sections/divisions under the heading "Library" (Music, Movies, Books, Apps, etc), but I have a lot of audio (and a few video) recordings of speeches that I would like to put in a division of their own, preferably called "Talks".

  • ORA-01031: insufficient privileges when creating a table in other schema

    Dear all, I appreciate your help please in this issue : when i try to issue the below statement to create a table in an another schema than the user i am connected in CREATE TABLE SCHEMA_NAME_B.HST_ARCH nologging AS SELECT * FROM HST WHERE 1 = 0; I a

  • Motion 5 crashes on opening compositions

    When trying to manually add a key frame to text in the properties tab (if I remember correctly) the user interface lost part of its visibility (buttons, the timeline and other GUI parts disappeared) and the program became unresponsive. After restarti

  • Server name not showing up in Chooser

    mac OS 10.1.3 server. The server name is not showing up in the Chooser,. I can get to it by typing in the IP address, but this is a pain for my teachers. It showed up for a long time, but now it will not show up. Any ideas?