Please advise - Garage Band vs Logic Express ???

I am moving from a hard disk recorder to an I Mac. I am purchasing a refurbished 2.4GHz machine from the Apple Store. I have ZERO experience with macs, and ease of use/intuativeness is very important. I will be recording guitars, drums, vocals, one instrument at a time.
What features am I getting with Logic Express that I won't have with Garage Band? Should I consider Logic Studio ?
Any insights on how these software applications compare would be most appreciated.
I can be reached at [email protected] if anyone would like to share their experiences
Thanks
ps - is a refurbished I-Mac just as good as a new one?

skewzme wrote:
Great feedback thus far. I really appreciate it.
What do you mean when you say "better instruments" ??
In other words, I will be recording my guitar, bass, vocals, and drums. To my way of thinking, those are my instruments.
Are you referring to intrument sounds or samples in the software?
TCan someone confirm GB is limited to 8 tracks? That isn't much to work with.
Thanks!!!!
Better software instruments.
GB can record 8 tracks at once, but actual track count is only limited by your system.
"You can record up to eight Real Instruments and one Software Instrument at the same
time. This lets you record voices and instruments together, and simultaneously record a
backing track, for example."-from the GB Manual
Of course you'd need an interface capable of 8 discrete sends.
For what it sounds like you want to do, I'll repeat my original advice-especially since you're learning Mac as well. If anything, knowing GB has sped up my Logic Learning Curve. JMHO.
-d

Similar Messages

  • Sample Rate Problems going from Garage Band to Logic Express

    I've downloaded the Trial Version of Logic Express. When it launched it changes the i/o sample Rate that is required by Garage Band (I'm using a digi002 i/o). The result is that garage band plays back at a fraction of it normal rate (sounds like crap).
    It wasn't a problem until the trial ran out on Logic Express. I could change the sample rate back inside Logic. Hummm ... what to do? I don't see any place to change the rate in the garage band preferences or in the core audio interface. Any suggestions would be appreciated.
    G4 1.25 dual, mirror Mac OS X (10.4.6)
    G4 1.25 dual, mirror Mac OS X (10.3.9)
    G4 1.25 dual, mirror   Mac OS X (10.4.6)  

    I've never had any such problem with Logic Express. GB files just load up, and work fine. Did you change anything in Logic Express? There are setting for that there, but even songs I open after I changed LE to 24 bit, work fine.
    Wait, are you saying LE is changing the sample rate, and then it stays that way when you open GB? Hmmm, What do you have LE set for? I think mine is set at 24/96, but I'd have to look to be sure. But I am not using the same interface as you are. It might be something you just have to live with. Have you tried posting this in the LE7 forum? Maybe one the gurus there knows what you can do.
    Oh, and I am using GB 2, not GB 1, but I am not sure that is relevant.

  • Garage band controller/logic express?

    will the garage band controller made by m-audio work with logic express?

    Yes but you have to do the following for it to work: Control-click on the GarageBand application and select "Show Package Contents". Navigate to the Midi Device Plug-ins folder and do a copy of the iControl.bundle to the desktop. Now, go to the same place in Logic Express and put the file you copied to the desktop in there.

  • How can I get instructions for old versions of Garage Band please, eg Garage Band 3 and Garage Band 6?

    How can I get instructions for old versions of Garage Band please, eg Garage Band 3 and Garage Band 6? thanks

    meredithfromkybybolite wrote:
    How can I get instructions for old versions of Garage Band please, eg Garage Band 3
    http://manuals.info.apple.com/en/GarageBand_3_getting_Started.pdf
    meredithfromkybybolite wrote:
    and Garage Band 6?
    GB6 is the latest version, so all current docs should directly refer to that.

  • Jam Band for logic express? Drum Fills

    Hello, I am working with a Logic 8 instructional video, Jam Band is being used to set up loops and fills. Does anyone know if that was part of logic
    express, Also are there any Drum Fills ( can't find them) with Garage band loops or Logic Express, Thanks so much,
    Troy

    Battery is not a sequencer. It does not store patterns, you have to do that in your Logic track. There are tons of samples arranged in kits from recorded samples to electronic drum kits and even special effects kits.
    Reading all of your posts, to be honest Ultrabeat sounds to be exactly what you want. To get that you need to upgrade to Logic Pro.
    Do a search Google for "Logic Pro Ultrabeat" you will find info from various sources that will help you decide.
    In Ultrabeat you can load sounds, create sounds by synthesis or samples, create patterns then put the pattern directly into a Logic software instrument region

  • Logic Express takes 4-6 hours to load a Garageband project!??!!

    When I open projects I have made with Garage Band in Logic Express, it takes 4-6 hours to load the song. Thats obviously not the way it is supposed to be.
    On another machine I have Logic Pro. There opening a Garageband project is fast -30 sec or so.
    Maybe I am crying for help? Or maybe there is something wrong with the software?
    I have all my Garageband instruments on the startup volume, while I have most of my loops on another volume. That works just fine with Garageband. It also works fine with Logic Pro under 10.3.9.
    The Garageband loops are on an external USB disk, and this hard disk is spinning constantly during those hours. Logic Express puts up messages like "Loading Audio Files for "Cellos.exs"" during this time. Incidentally Logic Express is not responding during this time, The above dialog say one can press command period to cancel the operation, but that does not work. All that is working is killing the application process.
    The above behaviour occurs wether I have any loops in the project or not.
    Is there a solution to this? Having all loops on the startup volume is not possible.

    Thank you very much 'Windham Hillbilly'.
    Yes, saving the song as an archive from GarageBand gives fast loading in Logic Express, fully comparable to my Logic Pro loading of non archive songs.
    So, this takes care of the issue for me.
    Now, if there really should be a 4-6 hour load time in the first place is a different matter.

  • Can logic express slow down or change the key from playbacks like the program "Amazing slowdowner"?r

    Hello,
    I'm a new member and I'm actually trying to work with garage band to record voice and playback. Can "logic express" Vs. 8.0 slow down or change the key from playbacks like the program "Amazing slowdowner"? This is a programm wich costs 50 US Dollar and I want to decide if i buy it or not.
    What is the hgreatest different between "garage band" and logic express 8.0? Who can hepl me, which is the right thing for me. I find it difficult to find out which effects are the best only to record my voice with playback.
    Thanks for your advices.

    If you want to slow down the audio why not download a program from ABRSM called Speedshifter- its free and is very good.  you could export the audio from Logic and open the MP3 file with speed shifter. I think speedshifter  may also  have the ability to alter the pitch as well. I use it for Flute practice- its very useful !

  • Logic Express with MBox

    Can someone please help.Can I use Logic Express with an MBox and if so how.

    Hey Roma,
    welcome to the forum!
    Assumming you had the drivers installed, (in Logic) go to the audio menu>audio hardware & drivers>Driver (change from built in audio to Digidesign HW (MBox), Relaunch, that's it.
    ((Click on (say) audio 1 (to select track) Press R to arm it and you shoud now have sound level on metters. Don't forget the I/O in logic is audio 1 = input 1, audio 2 = input 2, audio 3 = input 1, audio 4 = input 2 and so on (by default))
    Kiddly regards,
    Jorge

  • Opening Garage Band files in Logic Express

    I'm a school music teacher and have just started using Logic Express 7 to open kids' Garage Band files for tidying up and polishing.(Still a beginner with logic I'm afraid!) Have just purchased Logic Express 8 update, but haven't installed it because I heard that it won't open Garage Band 3 files. Is this true? If so, is it possible to have both 7 and 8 running independently on the computer? Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated.

    The original release of LE8 had a bug which required a workaround to open GB files. The subsequent 8.0.1 update fixed that. After you install LE8, go to Software Update and install the 8.0.1 update and you will be fine.

  • I downloaded Garage Band 2x and the same note appears: there is no General Audio 10. Please advise. Thank you.

    I have downloaded Garage Band 2x (10.0.3) and both times a window appears that says, "Could not find General Audio 10." I have OS X Yosemite 10.10, Mac 3.2 GHZ processor, Intel Core i3  4GB 1333 MHz  DDR3. Any direction is appreciated as to what "General Audio 10" is and where I could possibly find it.
    Thanks,
    CAScott

    Any direction is appreciated as to what "General Audio 10" is and where I could possibly find it.
    There is a support file "General Audio 10.layout "for Smart Controls installed in the folder /Library/Application Support/Logic/Smart Controls/General Audio 10.layout  and also a preference file "SC_layout General Audio 10.plist" in /Library/Application Support/Logic/Smart Map/SC_layout General Audio 10.plist.  My guess i they are related to the musical score layout setup.
    So these files are not original GarageBand files but shared with Logic or MainStage3 and have probably been installed by the additional content.

  • HT201368 I got an error message when trying to import a Garage Band song into Logic Express 9.

    Logic Express 9.1.8 (which I have) claims to be the most recent update.

    YOu have not provided any system info, not told us what version of AE you use, your audio setting, what specifics in the audio file and a million other things. See how it may not be possible for anyone to tell you anything beyond "Your computter sucks!" ???
    Mylenium

  • Can't open a garage band song in logic express trial

    I've been thinking about getting logic express, but I wanted to try the trail version first. When I try to open any of my garageband songs in logic it says, "Damaged Song or not a logic express song! Damaged songs might create problems and crashes!" After that box it says, "Rad Error! This is not a Logic Express song!" I would appreciate any advice on how I might fix this problem.

    I'm not using a different user account than previously, and haven't moved anything. That said, I was able to solve the problem. Here's what I did:
    1. Right-click and select GET INFO
    2. In the INFO window, open the SHARING & PERMISSIONS panel at the bottom
    3. In the lower right corner, click the LOCK to change it to UNLOCKED
    4. In the pop-up PASSWORD window, enter your MAC password. The LOCK changes to UNLOCKED.
    5. Click the PLUS SIGN lower left, choose the appropriate Person or User/Group (me) and click SELECT
    6. The name gets added to the bottom of the GET INFO window, but with “Read only” permission
    7. Click the “Read Only” selection and change to “Read & Write”
    PARTIAL SUCCESS:  The PROHIBIT badge is gone from the file, and instead of showing ZERO bytes, it now shows XXMB — for example, 32MB.
    HOWEVER, when I tried to open the file, I got the message, “Your file has no content”.
    TOTAL SUCCESS:  I discovered that I had to go back a level, click on the FOLDER that contained my prohibited songs, and follow the same instructions 1-7 above. Now, at last, I can access my files in the new GarageBand!
    Thanks to Hang Time and Leonie for responding so quickly to my plea for help! 

  • Please help with Logic Express 8 language support - requires little effort

    Dear fellow musicians, I plan to buy Logic Express, but as I live in a country you probably have never heard of (Moldova) I only have the chance to buy it while traveling.
    So, I am going to Paris soon and this is a perfect occasion to purchase the software - the only thing I am concerned is whether the french version of Logic express also supports the English language just like garage band and other apple apps.
    So, could you please check what languages are supported by Logic Express?
    It is simple to do - just go to the applications folder, Ctrl click on the Logic Express 8 application and unfold the languages triangle (if there's any).
    I'd be more than lucky if someone owning a french version does that to confirm whether there's English among the supported languages.
    Thanks!

    checked in my application folder but I don't see the languages option. However my English version provides French support, and my pretty clued up about apple things guess (but it is a guess) is that it's the same package and the installer just picks up the default language of the machine you're installing it on. And if you've got experience of other French versions of apple software being OK then it's a pretty safe bet that Logic will too. Can you not order an English version over the internet if you're really concerned ?
    By the way, I know where Moldova is! Even been thinking about traveling there sometime soon

  • How do you add non-Garage band instruments into a Logic project so that you can hear them on playback?

    How do you add non-Garage band instruments (orchestral instruments) into a Logic Pro (8) project so that you can hear those insrtruments' sounds on playback?  I've tried to understand and follow the Logic Pro 8 User Manual, but the process comes off as so complex and the writing so technical that it does not help but only confuses.
    To be precise - I want to add instruments (orchestral) that are not offered in the current Garage band menu which is offered in the Mixer's channel strip menus for Logic Pro 8.  To be clear, the instruments that are offered are Bass / Drum Kits / Guitars / Mallets / Organs / Pianos and Keyboards / Synth Basics / Synth Leads / Synth Pads.  Most of these that I've tried seem to work and give their characteristic sound when placed in a particular channel and playback is clicked. 
    However - there is one orchestra instrument offered in the standard Logic Pro 8 Mixer channel menu and it's the item labelled "Performance - 000 flute 1 or 001 flute 1."  And it is this instrument that presents a problem. When I click on it and choose it from the menu and enter it as the instrument of choice for a specfic channel / track in my Logic Pro project arrangement, when playing back the music for the overall piece this particular track, the flute, does not playback and produce the notes (Midi events) in the track in the sound of the flute.  Instead, nothing comes out at all.  I can't imagine why this does not work.  Any ideas, anyone? Again, when choosing this instrument for a track and clicking the playback no flute sound is forthcoming.  Why not? I have not tried them all, but when most of the other various types of keyboards, such as an electric piano or an organ, are chosen for a track the playback successfully renders the sound of these instruments.  Why then does playback not produce the sound of the flute when it has clearly been chosen to play and sound the Midi events given it?
    Anyway, the overall, larger issue for me is the inability I have to choose and get non-Garageband instruments (largely orchestral) to play the Midi events given on various tracks. If my guess is correct then technically, orchestral instruments not offered in the standard Logic Pro 8 Garageband Mixer channel menu are referred to as external Midi sampled instruments - still, IMHO the process is not clearly spelled out in the User Manual.  The simple step by step process whereby a non-Garage band instrument, say an orchestral instrument, is placed in a channel replete with Midi event (notes) waiting to be played should be easy, logical and given in a simple to follow format, but is not.
    What with all the talk of routes, busses, auxillary channels, GM devices, GM mixers, audio bins, libraries and audio files this Logic Pro User is confused to the max.  Can someone please help me and, in simple English, describe the step by step process whereby presumably external sampled orchestral instruments can be successfully employed, in any given Logic Pro arrangement project, to render their characteristic sounds upon playback?
    On my two Macs, one a laptop and one a much larger Mac, I have any number of the GSO (Garritan Symphony Orceshtra) and Vienna Symphony Orchestra instrument library samples - and yet - I've yet to figure out how to actually get them INTO a Logic Pro project of any kind!  To put this as a question, even as a humble request, how can I make good use of these orchestral sample libraries in a Logic Pro project?  Can someone steer my to a clear resolution of this issue.  I'd sincerely appreciate it!  Thanks all! 
    DavidBacon

    DavidBacon wrote:
    Anyway, the overall, larger issue for me is the inability I have to choose and get non-Garageband instruments (largely orchestral) to play the Midi events given on various tracks. If my guess is correct then technically, orchestral instruments not offered in the standard Logic Pro 8 Garageband Mixer channel menu are referred to as external Midi sampled instruments - still, IMHO the process is not clearly spelled out in the User Manual.  The simple step by step process whereby a non-Garage band instrument, say an orchestral instrument, is placed in a channel replete with Midi event (notes) waiting to be played should be easy, logical and given in a simple to follow format, but is not.
    What with all the talk of routes, busses, auxillary channels, GM devices, GM mixers, audio bins, libraries and audio files this Logic Pro User is confused to the max.
    David,  you understand that this is professional software and is not necessarily meant to be easy but is in fact designed to give the professional user as many choices as possible, that's why it's in the Pro Apps section. You WILL need to learn about buses, GM Devices, Audio Bins, Libraries...etc..etc if you intend to use Logic.
    That said, you are looking in the wrong place in the channel strip.
      May I offer you advice?
    Go here:
    http://documentation.apple.com/en/logicpro/
    Open "Exploring Logic Pro"  (a short PDF Document). Pay special attention to chapter 3. Also pay special attention to the included graphics of the channel strips.
    I encourage you to read the whole document as it will clear up many things... even though it's a Logic 9 document.
    Post back

  • Logic Express - I bought and installed Logic Express 7.2.3 way back when... Now I would like to move ti to my new MacBook Pro - how do I do it please?

    Please can someone advise how I reload an old version of Logic Express on a new Mac? Many thanks

    Hello KarmicCC,
    If you still have access to the old Mac, you might try using Migration Assistant to transfer applications to the new Mac.
    How to use Migration Assistant to transfer files from another Mac
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT4889
    However, Logic Express 8 and earlier are PowerPC applications which are no longer supported (in 10.7 and 10.8).
    Cheers,
    Allen

Maybe you are looking for