Premiere CS3 vs After Effect CS3 !

Ok friends hopping someone gives a detailed or a brief  feedback on this !
I used to use Sony Vegas, but later on i discovered that Adobe Premiere CS3 was much better software, so i started to use Premiere CS3 few month ago and so far have been very very happy with the Chroma , garbage remover and few more ...
i also installed Adobe After Effect CS3, but my question for you is how do you compare AE with Premiere ! I noticed plug in manufactures mostly make plug ins for AE, at the same time there are many plug ins for Premiere as well , but not as many as i can find for AE.
for example RedGiant makes plug ins for AE and they also have 60% for Premiere ..
please give me your brief or detailed idea about why would you use AE or why would you use Premiere !
So far i have using Premiere for evertyhing (Adding fx and etc)

As Shooterz says, "Have a play" - meaning, you are going to have to use each program to see for yourself how they differ.
So, for example, do this tutorial for premiere (or any other):
http://www.adobe.com/designcenter/premiere/articles/preppictinpict.html
And do this for After Effects.
http://www.toolfarm.com/tutorials/gleam1.html
I've picked one for each that shows its most relevant strengths - video for Premiere and motion graphics for AE.

Similar Messages

  • Premiere HDV Workflow (After Effects CS3 too)

    I'm working with a Sony HDR-FX1 and Premiere Pro CS3 to capture my HDV clips - in mpeg format.
    1. I'm looking for the best way to edit these HDV clips in Premiere. I have heard of CineForm's Neo Scene and I was wondering if I NEED this to edit the HDV clips in Premiere or not. If I don't need CineForm, are there any alternatives to editing the footage in Premiere or tips on speeding up the process?
    2. Please note that I will be working between Premiere Pro & After Effects (both CS3) and back to Premiere so I'm also wondering what type of file I can export from After Effects to get back to Premiere. Will I need the CineForm codec for this step as well? I'd like to export to a file where I won't lose any quality or compress my video when bringing it back into Premiere for editing.
    3. I noticed after importing one of my HDV clips into After Effects it's separated by Upper field first. Will I need to export with Upper field no matter what format I use when rendering from After Effects?
    Any tips, links or tutorials on the subject would be greatly appreciated.
    Foochuck

    Although not absolutely necessary
    Cineform prospect HD & adobe cs3 ( premiere & after effects) works very well together. The CFHD format gives You a fluent workflow and is cleraly recommended.
    ( and this codec should have been implemented as part of "the adobe package" - just like native drivers for P2 and EX1 - but thats another discussion)
    ( btw : anything less than 2.1 - 2.4 core_2_duo will be a pain without CF as I see it)

  • Premiere Pro CS3 then After Effects CS3 for Color Correction?

    Hello All,
    I'm at a bit of a loss here, it seems like it's a no brainer to be able to do this. I'm trying to edit my film in Premiere and then use After Effects to do color correction using Color Finesse 2. But there doesn't seem to be ANY way to keep a project so you can continue to edit in premiere while you also keep all your color correction??
    You can do color correction in AE and export a premiere project but premiere won't recognize the Color Finesse Filter so you lose all you color correction!
    Or I can edit the whole project in premiere and open it in after effects to do color correction, but then if there is a single edit change that needs to be done in premiere again i've once again lost my Color Correction to bring it back.
    Is this really the case that I can't use these expensive packages together this way? It seems like there has to be a solution! If Adobe just made it so Premiere kept the "links" to your filters in the project, instead of killing an unrecognizable one. Then when you opened it back in after effects after your edit your Color Correction would still be there.
    Any one have any advice?
    Thanks,
    -Ethan

    Thanks for all the suggestions guys, all good ideas.
    Aanarav, Your idea to just get Color Finesse for premiere I suppose I could do. It's $545 which isn't exactly pocket change, but it would probably be worth it, if there is another way other than breaking the bank book for software I already own i'd like to try to get away with it.
    Steven Gotz
    Dynamic link is unfortunately a feature only of the production studio package which is like $1100 upgrade from what I have...so that's kinda out of the question for me.
    Jon Sands
    Great idea here. I really thought it might work since premiere seems to use what are called after effects plugin files too. But after copying and pasting for a while it doesn't look like it actually sees it as a plugin anywhere I paste it. :( If anyone knows of a way to get that to work I would be seriously grateful!
    I guess it sounds like the only way out is to spend cash, sigh such is so often the case is seems.
    -Ethan

  • Adobe After Effects CS3 crashes with Codecs such as Motion JPEG and Avid DnxHD

    Hey guys, I'm new here
    I'm having a problem with After Effects CS3 crashing with .mov files (exported from Adobe Premiere) with codecs such as Motion Jpeg A and Avid's DnxHD. Its driving me crazy.
    If I import a Motion Jpeg A file, AE crashes immediately. If I import a DnxHD file that works fine with Premiere, it seems to import ok. However, when I try to play it in AE it comes up as a plain white... thing. If I move the slider across it previews one or two frames before AE crashes. Its driving me crazy.
    AE works ok with H.164 and animation files.
    I'm reinstalled quicktime and Avids codecs, uninstalled ffdshow, disabled Open GL and multiprocessing, changed between 10bit and 8bit (whatever that is all about) with the dnxhd and I'm really stumped. If I can get Dnxhd working I'm fine with that. I thought I'd mention the Motion Jpeg A codec to see if they're a result of the same problem.
    I've also tried Avid's RGB packed Codec with the same results.
    I'm running Windows Xp 32 bit with 3gbs of ram, a GeForce 8600 gt with a Intel Pentium Duo Core Processor 2.00 GHZ.
    Can anyone help me please?

    I'm mistaken, Animation files don't work either!
    I tried that with no luck. I even tried a few more Quicktime codecs with the same results.
    Only H.164 and some png compressed .mov files seem to work. Very frustrating.
    I'm surprised thats the case - I am defintley due for an upgrade. Even though this system seems to work ok, struggling a little bit with HD .mov files but yeah, I've been planning a new system for a while.

  • How to batch convert with After Effects CS3

    I sure hope this isn't a super silly question!
    I have never used After Effects as it came with my Adobe Master Suite and it's quite duanting to learn all of those programs at once. I'm trying to figure out how to convert several MPEG files to AVI using a batch convert process. It would seem to me that would be a pretty simple process and I've read in several locations that it can't be done with Premiere Pro any more. They also say it can be done in After Effects but they don't explain how.
    I'm pretty new to video editing so layman's terms would be much appreciated. I'm running After Effects CS3 on Windows XP.

    It can be done, but After Effects is far from being a specialized encoding application. A bit like using a ten ton truck to commute
    In CS4, threre is such an specialized app. It's called Adobe Media Encoder, and it can be used in standalone mode or invoked from within Premiere Pro or AE.
    Remember, After Effects is a content creation tool that offers multiple ways to render the content you create. But it's not an utility to convert or encode video formats.
    If you really want to do this in AE, this could be a way:
    Import all your MPEG files in the Project Panel.
    Select them all (drag with your mouse or make Project panel active, then Control+A on Win or Command+A on Mac).
    Drag them all to the New Comp button at the bottom of the project panel.
    You will get a dialog which offers to place all these files in a single After Effects Composition, or create a separate Composition for each. Select the latter.
    In the Project panel, select the resulting compositions and go to Composition > Add to Render Queue. Set each item to AVI format with your codec of choice.
    Of course, there are a million variables that couldn't be discussed in a single post or thread.
    As you can see, you are performing a lot of steps because After Effects is designed to render video once you have created content in the form of After Effects Compositions. In that context, these steps would not be "a lot" - you arrive there quite naturally.
    I suggest you take a look at the After Effects Help chapter on Rendering and exporting

  • I am trying to open a .mxf files from 2 different Panasonic cameras in After effects CS3

    I am trying to open .mxf files from 2 different Panasonic cameras (the HVX 200A and the HPX 170) in Adobe After Effects CS3.  I have down loaded all of the Adobe CS3 upgrades and I have also installed the P2 card reader for Tiger which is the operating system on my mac.  I have not been able to open these files.  Can anyone help pls?

    >  I have not been able to open these files.
    Please tell us exactly what you're trying to do and exactly what happens. Make sure that you're following the instructions here.

  • Adobe After effects cs3 deployment

    Hi
    I am hoping someone here can help me. I have to deploy Adobe after effects CS3 to about 30 pc's.
    I have done the following command
    setup--record=1 which generated a install.xml file and an uninstall.xml file
    I am still struggling to understand what the install.override.xml does?,
    Lastly is there any way to include the updates needed for after effects cs3 during the deployment?
    Any help or advice would greatly be appreciated

    I am still struggling to understand what the install.override.xml does?
    It overrides dependencies for local installs like language selection and serialization or otehrwise some packages would not install.
    Lastly is there any way to include the updates needed for after effects cs3 during the deployment?
    Not that I know of, but you could just create a custom MSI script/package that installs them immediately after the original software.
    Mylenium

  • Adobe After Effects CS3 does not work on my new iMac

    Hello everyone,
    I recently bought myself a new iMac and Adobe After Effects CS3, and guess what, the stuff does not work. I've tried almost everything, been on a lot of forums but can't seem to find any solution. One thing that keeps coming back is that it has to do with the Geforce 8800 GT in my iMac, some kind of compatibility problem between both.
    The problem is this, whenever I start AE CS3, a window pops up, stating "Out of Memory ( 23 :: 40 )".
    And then something about licensing, but I guess I can skip that window, since that clearly has nothing to do with the problem.
    Are there some beta drivers or something for my videocard that I can download somewhere to maybe get rid of this problem?
    Thanks in advance,
    Maxim

    Maybe an answer at http://www.adobeforums.com/webx/.59b665be/1

  • Adobe After Effects CS3 horrible export quality

    I made an intro for my Youtube channel using Adobe After Effects CS3, in the preview and whilst I was rendering the video quality was remarkable, no flaw in it. But after it rendered and I exported it as a .flv file the quality was horrible and grainy. Since I'm starting a serious channel my videos have to be high quality, including the intro. Is there any way to make it better quality, perhaps a free program that converts it into a better quality extension, or anything. I appreciate any feedback since I really need this intro in high quality.
    Here's the video link as you can see it's grainy as hell, even when put at 720p(HD):
    As I mentioned before in the preview and whilst rendering the quality was one of the best I've ever seen, no grain or anything, it was flawless, but when I exported, the quality turned to s***. Please help.

    Well, straight to the point: Read YouTube's requirements! FLV? They don't even recomemnd it themselves and in the last 3 years nobody serious has used it. There are enough free H.264 encoders based on ffmpeg. Download one and render an uncompressed movie from AE to be used for final output.
    Mylenium

  • Adobe After Effects CS3 Crash help on Vista

    I've installed and re installed After Effects about 5 times now and it keeps crashing when the splash screen pops up. The message "Adobe After Effects CS3 has stopped working." I found that the message comes up when its initializing Media Core. Here is the report from vista about the App Crash.
    Please help!
    Product
    Adobe After Effects CS3
    Problem
    Stopped working
    Date
    9/17/2008 1:39 AM
    Status
    Not Reported
    Problem signature
    Problem Event Name: APPCRASH
    Application Name: AfterFX.exe
    Application Version: 8.0.0.298
    Application Timestamp: 465d3a47
    Fault Module Name: StackHash_acaf
    Fault Module Version: 0.0.0.0
    Fault Module Timestamp: 00000000
    Exception Code: c0000096
    Exception Offset: 0ff62a3b
    OS Version: 6.0.6001.2.1.0.256.1
    Locale ID: 1033
    Additional Information 1: acaf
    Additional Information 2: b76b3522689a083200114e083ecf3e98
    Additional Information 3: 0c56
    Additional Information 4: 4d8a5cc0ffe3e3a2cf058732c3c78aad
    Thanks!

    I used CS3 Clean script and followed all the instructions for "Bigger problem-solving tools" and "Other Tips & Tricks" on http://generalspecialist.com/2007/02/troubleshooting-after-effects-7.asp.
    I'm still having the same problem but only StackHash_d742 is the problem none of the other extensions are showing up, after I attempt to run the program multiple times.
    Is there a way to track this file down?
    Here is the new problem report:
    Problem signature
    Problem Event Name: APPCRASH
    Application Name: AfterFX.exe
    Application Version: 8.0.0.298
    Application Timestamp: 465d3a47
    Fault Module Name: StackHash_d742
    Fault Module Version: 0.0.0.0
    Fault Module Timestamp: 00000000
    Exception Code: c0000096
    Exception Offset: 0ccb2a3b
    OS Version: 6.0.6001.2.1.0.256.1
    Locale ID: 1033
    Additional Information 1: d742
    Additional Information 2: 8c0b39e9167d2af32cd5918c4e47ad30
    Additional Information 3: 0bc6
    Additional Information 4: b9a642c2fb7d280dedb83638cddb3589
    Extra information about the problem
    Bucket ID: 933737916
    -Logan

  • After effects CS3 crashes when importing file

    system specs are as follows
    Operating System: Windows XP Professional (5.1, Build 2600) Service Pack 2 (2600.xpsp_sp2_qfe.061219-0311)
    Language: English (Regional Setting: English)
    System Manufacturer: Dell Inc.
    System Model: Dell DM051
    BIOS: Phoenix ROM BIOS PLUS Version 1.10 A05
    Processor: Intel(R) Pentium(R) D CPU 3.20GHz (2 CPUs)
    Memory: 2046MB RAM
    Display Devices
    Card name: RADEON X600 Series
    Manufacturer: ATI Technologies Inc.
    Chip type: RADEON X600 (0x5B62)
    DAC type: Internal DAC(400MHz)
    Device Key: Enum\PCI\VEN_1002&DEV_5B62&SUBSYS_06021002&REV_00
    Display Memory: 256.0 MB
    Current Mode: 1280 x 960 (32 bit) (60Hz)
    Monitor: Hitachi CM812
    Monitor Max Res: 1600,1280
    Driver Name: ati2dvag.dll
    Driver Version: 6.14.0010.6677 (English)
    Sound
    SigmaTel Audio
    Alright, now that's out of the way, heres the error i get.
    Adobe After Effects CS3 has encountered a problem and needs to close. We are sorry for the inconvenience.
    Error signature
    EventType : BEX P1 : AfterFX.exe P2 : 8.0.0.298 P3 : 465d3a47
    P4 : AfterFX.dll P5 : 0.0.0.0 P6 : 46348371 P7 : 00111a69
    P8 : c0000409 P9 : 00000000
    This happens every time i try to import any kind of file. And I'm running the trial version of AE btw.
    Now heres the things i have already tried.
    1)Reinstalling After Effects repeatedly.
    2)updating quick time
    3)Deleting the pref file
    4)removed any and all plug-ins
    5)Deleted the OpenGL file
    6)changed by screen resolution.
    7)closed down anti-virus programs
    8)Tried various ways of importing files, like drag and drop
    9)tried importing different files.
    10)Restarting my computer after attempting the all above^
    I have also been to the general specialist website already thank you very much.
    Edit: Now i have also tried uninstalling quick time and all of the video codec packs on my computer, this also didn't help (i did remember to restart afterwards)
    Edit: Also, i started a new thread because nothing in any of the other threads on this same or similar errors was at all helpful to me.
    edit3: i might also add that i have after effects 6.5 and it works just fine, though its much older.

    You can contact Adobe Technical Support for help with issues like this. You are entitled to a certain number of free calls for "installation issues, basic usage questions, and troubleshooting unexpected behavior for documented features".
    For information on what free technical support you're entitled to, see this page:
    http://www.adobe.com/support/programs/customer/gss.html

  • How do I Import footage from Premier Pro CS3 to After Effects?

    Hi
    As the subject says, how do I import footage from premier pro cs3 into after effects. I'm getting rather frustrated trying to figure this out.
    Via copy & paste I can copy into after effects but this copys the whole of the track on the timeline, where as I just want 10 seconds copied. The 10 seconds I want to copy is a segment & was highlighted when I clicked copy.
    Also when the full track gets copied, all my edits aren't copied & I get the raw track copied???
    I've googled this, tried the "Add Dynamic Link" but all I want is to copy 10 seconds of footage from premier into after effects, add my effect & then copy it back, and I can't figure out how to do this simple thing
    Any help
    Thanks.

    I am still not getting this.
    I highlight the selection I want to copy into after effects. I copy & paste it & it pastes my entire footage without any off the edits I have made.
    Having searched loads for this I can find no other answer than copy & paste.
    Please please could you guy be more specific with your answers as I just can't figure this one?

  • Export to After Effects CS3 in FCE 4 workflow.

    I set up my FCE 4 prefs to edit video in After Effects CS3. After I rendered the clip in FCE 4, I right clicked to >edit video in editor, After Effects CS3 opened and low and behold sat my clip with the same settings that my FCE 4 project had. After some AE title work, to get it back into FCE 4 I used Render Queue in AE set at the same settings. I then took the .mov and overwrote the clip in FCE 4. The composite looked like the original ( with the new compositing work of course ). The audio even worked perfect.
    I tried to do the same thing in Motion 2 ... um .... no luck. Motion would not open any files... period.
    This may work as a nice round trip compositing workflow that was taken away with the export features that were in FCE 3.5 HD.
    Since Motion is not available as a separate app any longer, this may be a great alternative for FCE 4 users who what to do some compositing in their projects.
    Ed

    Curious, what does Apple want you to do with open video in editor feature in FCE 4?
    I think it works with Livetype 2, but it's not a video editor in my opinion.
    Can't round trip with Motion and FCP with the edit in video option. I think I saw a tutorial once where after you have done an initial round trip, you can use this feature to go back and forth?
    I know that you can open Motion projects in AE by changing the extension. I do not think I would open LiveType in AE, doesn't make sense to me.
    At least us FCE users who want to do some compositing work have some options. I still wish I could round trip with Motion though.
    Ed

  • Adobe After Effects CS3 won't install

    I have windows XP, and I used to have my version of Adobe After Effects CS3 installed. Then I uninstalled it because it kept crashing, but I forgot to deactivate it before I uninstalled it. Now every time I've tried reinstalling it, the installation goes completely fine until the last step, when it says:
    Summary:
    Successfully installed: 3 component(s):
    Adobe After Effects CS3 Template Projects and Footage
    Adobe After Effects CS3 Third Party Content
    Shared Components
    Errors: 2 component(s):
    Adobe After Effects CS3
         Component install failed
    Shared components
         component install failed
    I don't know how to fix this! I've tried multiple times at reinstalling it but each time without success. I've also ran the installation as administrator, and I've restarted my computer. Does anyone know how to fix this? Thanks a lot!

    Did you correctly uninstall the software? Are there other Adobe programs on the system? Sounds like there are other, newer versions that throw off the install. You need to uninstall those and reinstall them after you have installed CS3. Also simply delete the caps.db in C:\Program Files\Common Fiels\Adobe\caps. And for further diagnosis it might help to have a look at the install logs.
    Mylenium

  • ExternalObject undefined in After Effects CS3

    Hi, we have After Effects CS3 and have developed an external library that we would like to use from Extend Script.
    When I launch Extend Script Toolkit and target itself, I can create the ExternalObject.
    However, whenever the script runs targetting After Effects, we get the error message that "ExternalObject is undefined".
    The Javascript CS3 guide clearly says that the ExternalObject javascript object is supported by all CS3 applications.
    Is there some special configuration that needs to be done to enable this in After Effects?
    Thanks,
    Matt

    Here's the response from a bug report I made on the issue. Turns out that it is not supported, and the manual is incorrect. Boo!!
    It appears that AE CS3 does not support ExternalObject. After Effects CS4 supports it and you can create a ExternalObject with any framework, but you can't do anything useful with that object (even version always returns zero).
    Aslo, the syntax should be:
    Exporter.tgaInfoLib = new ExternalObject("lib:TGAInfo");
    Steve
    -the After Effects Team
    On 9/21/09 1:22 AM, "matt connolly"> wrote:
    The following information was submitted on the Software Feature Request and Bug Report Form for After Effects
    Name                       : Matt Connolly
    Email Address              : <deleted>
    Company/Institution        : THQ Studio Australia
    Feature Request/Bug Report : Bug Report
    Product                    : After Effects
    Product Version            : CS3 8.0.2
    Browser                    : Safari
    Web Server                 :
    Application Server         :
    Database                   :
    Operating System           : Windows XP
    OS version                 : SP3
    HTTPREFERRER               : https://www.adobe.com/cfusion/mmform/index.cfm?name=wishform
    Feedback Report            : ******BUG******
    ExternalObjects not available in ExtendScriptToolkit when Adobe After Effects is the exedcution target. ExternalObject objects can be created when the ExtendScript Toolkit application is the execution target.
    Steps to reproduce bug:
      1. run this script with target = ExtendScript Toolkit:
    ExternalObject.searchFolders = g_tgaInfoDLLDir;
       Exporter.tgaInfoLib = new ExternalObject("lib:TGAInfo.dll");
    works.
      2. Change target to Adobe After Effects CS3.
      3. run same script. fails with error: "ExternalObject undefined"
      Results:
    ExternalObject is accessible in ExtendScript Toolkit, but not in Adobe After Effects CS3 (v8.0.2.27)
      Expected results:
    Expected to work in both, as per page 185 of Javascript Tools Guide:
    "All Creative Suite 3 applications support this feature."

Maybe you are looking for