Pro platforms & software? Mac or PC? Final Cut, Avid, Premiere, etc.?

I've a 14-year-old niece who, with iMovie, Garageband and iDVD has, in the past year overtaken her Dad's digital video camera and has produced two films (that she's finished - she has others in the works) that would be remarkable for a 40-year-old and are almost unimaginably good for a 14 (soon to be 15) year old.
Her parents and I are considering getting her the Final Cut Studio package with a Mac and enough storage space so that she can get a head start on doing what she wants to do with her life - make movies. She was able to use an older copy of Final Cut Express on a friend's father's Mac and fell in love with it - she actually understands all this stuff after just playing around with it.
Another friend's father, however, is a educated amateur and he uses Adobe products - Premier, primarily, I believe, and my niece keeps us with what's going on in Hollywood and has heard good things about products from a company called Avid and although I think that she would rather stay on a Mac platform, for certain, and she's quick to let her parents know what Hollywood films were edited, etc., on Macs ("Brokeback Mountain"? Is that true) and I think that she'd be delighted with a wicked fast Mac and the Final Cut Pro Studio package, we would like to get her a system with which she can - hopefully - be ahead of the game when it's time for her to go off to film school (if she hasn't had a major studio pick up an indie film of hers by the time she's 18!).
I know that there are companies like Sweetwater who put together and/or recommend system packages but I'm also wondering if there are video specialists that do the same? I'm also wondering if the Final Cut Studio package is actually robust enough to mix and edit a finessed final product (was "Brokeback Mountain" really edited on a Mac?) or if the Adobe products on a PC platform are more of an accepted professional 'norm'?
She already knows the camera that she wants (she shoots everything with a single camera) and the microphones, etc., that she wants for enhancing sound... BUT, although I truly believe se wants to stay on a Mac and use her iMovie, GarageBand, and iDVD skills in a more professional environment, she is being swayed a bit by her friend's evil PC-loving father.
So I need some help.
1. Is there a video resource similar too what Sweetwater is to audio?
2. Is the Mac or PC more prevalent amongst pros (or indie/beginning pros, at least)?
3. Are the Apple products superior to the Adobe and Avid products or - if they are fairly equal - is the Studio package integrated as the iLife products?
And last, I suppose, is the fact that we're thinking that Apple will be introducing the 'wicked fast' Intel desktops before Christmas so that will likely be our last purchase after we've perused the 'packaged' products (which I just assume MUST be out there!) and so while I'm glad that Apple has upgraded the Studio package to Universal binary, the choice of machines is made even more difficult by the fact that what we likely want to get or her hasn't been introduced yet.
Any answers to the three questions - or any other suggestions - will be much appreciated. It's a long time before Christmas but this is going to be an expensive venture that could well determine just how well my beloved niece will be able to fulfill her dreams.
Life was so much simpler when girls her age just wanted ponies..

i've been perusing Promax and have definitely settled on FCP as the software o choice and, s the camera is a 'done deal' (she knows hat she wants there!) it will ultimately come down to, I think, the CPU 'box' itself. I always think of computers as having a three-year 'window', after which time something new and exciting is blazing trails and (usually) costs have dropped (not as significantly as in the 1980's-1990's, but in terms of real dollars todays G5 Quad is a sizzling bargain compared with what I paid for my MDD Wind Tunnel G4 in 2002.
So although I would expect some of the equipment (and software - with upgrades) to remain useable for 3 years (at which time my niece will be a freshman in college) my thought at the moment is to wait until, say, October, too see if Apple is going to have blazing fast Intel machines ("MacPro" is my current guess for the name of the Intel desktops!) to go along with the Universal FCP apps. My guess is an August announcement with late September, early October shipping.
I my prognostication is wrong, however, she'll be able to 'make do' just fine with PM G5, I think. When I know a bit more about what I'm talking about (I've ordered a couple of books from Amazon to at least learn some lingo... i watched the MacBreak 1080p and compression podcasts and understood about half - when it comes to setting up a home theater, I know what to do, what i need, what to wait for, etc. But the 'broadcasting' bit is over my head (and although she may wind up in TV and need to know all that stuff, it's movies she's aiming for - yet she's realistic and says that even if she finally gets to direct a local used car commercial in her career she wants to make sure that it's the best ever!
All of this info has been tremendous - and kind of given me the impetus to begin a project started long ago (first on 8mm then 16mm... and ending just this year with miniDV!). I have a lot of iMovie footage and have burn some iDVDs but I just don't have the creative juices of my niece!

Similar Messages

  • What's the best Mac for running Final Cut Pro X?

    Title says it all. What's the best Mac for running Final Cut Pro X? I'm not looking to make a feature length hollywood film. But I'd like to be able to edit video without lag.

    Yes. Begin with the fastest processor / graphics card / and as much RAM as you can afford. (As all three will become obsolete over time.)
    I started from scratch. I have a 27-inch iMac with a 3.4 G Intel Core i7. (currently the fastest processor for an iMac) I also ordered the best graphics card--AMD Ratheon HD. I ordered 16G of RAM, but recently added more RAM to equal 24G. (OWC makes good after-market RAM for iMACs.)
    Last, I ordered a flash drive / SATA hard drive combo.  (250G on flash / ITB on SATA). The OS and all of my applications run off the flash drive. (for fast start up!)
    I put all of my media and FCP projects onto the SATA hard drive.
    Now, I had the option to order a 2TB SATA. But, I realized I can always buy more external storage as I edit more and more projects. ALSO! FCPX is GREAT when it comes to editing projects on external drives! I can segregate an entire project and its media files onto a removeable drive. I simply launch FCPX, plug in the drive and--poof!--I'm ready to edit. It sees the project and the media right away. When I'm done editing, I can then send this drive to another editor (also using FCPX) or attach it to my MacBook if I want to edit the same project in the field.
    This has worked for me. I wish you luck.

  • I want to purchase a powerbook that will run a music program like MOTU or Pro Tools as well as run Final Cut Pro without being sluggish...any help?

    I want to purchase a powerbook that will run a music program like MOTU or Pro Tools as well as run Final Cut Pro without being sluggish...any help?

    The only way that would work out is if you ran exactly the versions that were made for old PowerBooks. Anything newer may require Intel and not run, or will strain the poor old G4 CPU.
    Your needs have to be modest, too, because the problem with older music and video software is that they are not current as far as formats and codecs for the Web. If you want to output H.264, the current standard for YouTube/Flash video, older software may not support it, and in addition, H.264 is processor-intensive and is tailor-made for today's multi-core, 2+ GHz processors. It will overwhelm a G4. A PowerBook G4 can barely play YouTube videos.
    More perspective: The PowerBooks worked great for miniDV format editing. In other words, 480i SD/standard definition video in use from the late 1990s to the late 2000s. If that is all you want to do, edit tape from an old miniDV camera to SD output, then OK.
    But if you want to edit today's HD video, whether 720p from a snapshot camera/iPhone 4 or 1080p from a DSLR, the PowerBook and the software for it will either not recognize AVCHD/H.264, or it will slow the PowerBook to a dead crawl.
    I'm in agreement with the above: Intel Macs have been out for so many years that getting a used one is a much better deal than a dead-end PowerBook. And I loved (still love) my PowerBooks.

  • I am traveling with my macbook pro and I forgot to install final cut express and quicktime pro before I left. How can I in a way download them for free on my laptop from where I am

    I am traveling with my macbook pro and I forgot to install final cut express and quicktime pro before I left. How can I in a way download them for free on my laptop from where I am? I need them and don't want naturally to buy them again!!!
    Thank you    

    Assuming you purchased QT Pro, you can always download it again at no extra charge by logging in to your Apple account.
    Regarding FCE, there is no way to download & install the product.  You need an original FCE install disk and your FCE serial number.
    Final Cut Pro X (aka FCPX) can be purchased & downloaded from the App Store.

  • Anyone study Apple Pro Training Series SP 2 without Final Cut Pro app?

    Hi Guys,
    I have Soundtrack Pro 2. It came with the Logic Pro Studio bundle. I want to get the certification for SP 2. I just opened the SP 2 Apple Pro Training Series book and the first directions are to open +Final Cut Pro+ to convert the .fcp file in the lesson folder to a .stmp file to use in SP 2.
    I don't have Final Cut Pro. Am I dead in the water? How does someone who got SP 2 via purchasing Logic Pro Studio follow this book, since Final Cut Pro doesn't come with the Logic bundle?
    Thanks to anyone who can shed some light!

    I'm checking back in here and bumping this thread up hoping someone from Apple might throw in a reply here. I've spent the last few days on the net seeking out anyone else who ran into this problem and I've discovered there are quite a few others running into this issue. How is someone who purchased STP with Logic Studio supposed to get certified? Why doesn't Apple let people know about this before they purchase the product? If they weren't aware of it before (I've been told Apple has now been notified of the issue), why isn't Apple addressing this and providing a workaround?
    Anyone from Apple out there?

  • I updated to yosemite os and was in the middle of a project with final cut pro 10.  Now it says final cut pro is incompatible.  How can I access my project and/or update final cut?

    I updated to yosemite os and was in the middle of a project with final cut pro 10.  Now it says final cut pro is incompatible.  How can I access my project and/or update final cut?

    There is this offer of a trial version FC Pro X with 30 day runtime:
    http://www.apple.com/final-cut-pro/trial/
    Too bad you didn't have a complete backup that could run the previous OS X
    and then you could resume using an earlier Final Cut Pro (10) or (7) since a
    clone would have been a means toward that position.
    http://www.apple.com/support/finalcutpro/
    http://www.apple.com/support/pro-apps/
    This appears to be another good reason to check out all the reasons why one
    would want or need to upgrade a working OS X version, since these kinds of
    events are known to happen as a direct result.
    Sorry to not have an answer to this, other than try & use the Trial version...
    Or see if someone at Apple sales/support can field your issue w/ an answer.
    Good luck & happy computing!

  • Final Cut Pro Studio 5.1.1 and Final Cut Express HD 3.5

    Hi,
    I have a client with both of these installed on the same machine (running 10.4.6).
    When they try and launch either application, the splash screen comes up, loading various filters, etc. then they get an error message:
    "File Error: A file of this name already exists" "OK"
    Clicking "OK" closes the app.
    Any idea:
    1. What the file in question is?
    2. Can it be deleted to let the app run?
    3. Can Final Cut Pro Studio 5.1.1 and Final Cut Express HD 3.5 be used on the same machine?
    I'll post this on the Final Cut Express HD 3.5 thread too (but with the order reversed).

    What you did was not enough to delete the preferences properly.
    This article tells you how. It is for FCE2 but works the same for FCE3 so I assume it is also OK for FCE 3.5:-
    http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=93690
    It's simple to do so try it before reinstalling etc. - You should completely uninstall before reinstalling:-
    http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=301182
    Ian.

  • I have a newer MacBook Pro and I am trying to download my Final Cut Pro 7 Studio 2 on it. Is that possible or does the new MacBook Pro not support anything other than Final Cut Pro X?

    I have a newer MacBook Pro and I am trying to download my Final Cut Pro 7 Studio 2 on it. Is that possible or does the new MacBook Pro not support anything other than Final Cut Pro X?

    As Tom said the FCS forum is the better place to post the question.
    Here is Apple's best practices doc for installing both on the same system.
    BTW, FCP7 is part of the FCS 3 suite of apps.
    Russ

  • Soundtrack Pro and Audio already altered in Final Cut

    I'm just getting my feet wet with Soundtrack Pro. I have a project that was edited in Final Cut Pro, including keyframes to adjust audio levels in specific places in the audio tracks. When the project is sent to Soundtrack Pro, the changes that were made in Final Cut Pro seem to be ignored. Is there something I'm doing wrong here, or are audio alterations made in Final Cut Pro not passed on to Soundtrack Pro? I'm using Soundtrack Pro version 2.0.2 and Final Cut Pro version 6.0.5.
    Larry

    Hi Lorenzo,
    I haven't encountered this problem, however it sounds to me as though the waveform editor is sensing that the incoming signal is too hot & is automatically pulling down the gain to compensate and overcompensating to the point where the audio is barely intelligible.
    What I would suggest you try is:
    Select All Command (Apple) A then
    Shift Command L. This gives you a window that allows you to boost the level. As the signal is so low, try 100%. If the signal is still too low do the same again. The Adjust Amplitude Filters will appear in the Actions List to the left of the Waveform. This is a nondestructive process & each Adjust Amplitude can be toggled on/off by unchecking it so that you can do a before & after comparison.
    All the best
    Dave

  • Can I share files from other programs or just Adobe apps files. I work with Final Cut and Premiere X

    Can I share files from other programs or just Adobe apps files. I work with Final Cut and Premiere X.? Need to share files up to 6GB.
    I need to know if the 20 gb limit is about all that I share, or if it's just about whatis in the clouds. If I take, recover my limit?
    The speed of upload e download is good?

    The Creative Cloud file storage could be used for video assets but speed and performance might vary based on location. I would suggest you testing it out yourself using your Adobe ID before subscribing. Performance would not change after you joined.
    -Dave

  • Is my mac compatible for Final Cut Pro?

    Hi,
    I was wondering if my Mac OS X is compatible for any of the final cut pro studios? It's about 5 or 6 years old. Or, does the software only work on imac computers? Is there any way I can bring my computer in and get better RAM or something to hopefully make the software work?
    If not, if you could list any other really good film editing software I could use, please list it below. Thank you!!
    Here are the details on my Mac computer.

    There's nothing wrong with your RAM except you need more:
    Maximum Memory
    3.0 GB (4.0 GB can be installed, only 3.0 GB will be addressed)
    Memory Slots
    2 - 200-pin PC2-5300 (667MHz) DDR2 SO-DIMM
    You can install up to 4 GBs - two 2 GB modules. You will find suitable modules at OWC, DataMem, or Crucial.com.
    Your computer can run some version of Final Cut. Your computer is capable of running upgrades to Snow Leopard and Lion.
    You can run Final Cut Pro X with Snow Leopard 10.6.8 or Lion.

  • Mac mini for Final Cut Pro X?

    I have a MacBook and it's served me in good stead since November of 2006. It runs Final Cut Express 4.0.1 happily, and helped me get through college. However, it is a bit too weak to run Final Cut Pro X. (Quite an understatement!) I know I've got to upgrade. It's a very compelling piece of software. There is a link to the iMac on the FCPX page, so I guess it's safe to say iMac will run it. But I am also in the running to upgrade my failing CRT TV. So basically the most compelling upgrade path is a Mac mini, if I can get away with it. It will be able to use an HDTV as a monitor through the HDMI port, and I'll be able to use an existing LCD monitor as a second display for my timeline.
    Help a broke wannabe recent graduate out!!! PLEASE!!! We jam econo on this ship, sailor, so I need to go with the least expensive option to move up to FCPX.

    OK...here's an interesting tidbit...320M is supported by OpenCL according to The Oracle, aka Wikipedia
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenCL
    However, a look at the official Apple Snow Leopard docs suggests that they withdrew support for 320M.
    http://support.apple.com/kb/SP575
    Sometimes The Oracle is wrong.
    Message was edited by: S. Michelle Klein-Hass to note differences between what is up on Wikipedia and the most recent version of the Apple Knowledge Base article.

  • Anyone use a 2012 mac mini for final cut pro x?

    I am considering buying a 2012 quad core mini to use for Final Cut pro X.  I've looked everywhere on the web, and can't really find an answer as to whether or not this is a good idea.  The main reason I'd do this over a 2011 refurbished iMac is for the USB 3.0 ports.  I'm currently using a 2010 mid-level iMac, and find that I need to use proxies if I do anything multi-cam.  I do know that buying the mini, thunderbolt display, and mouse/keyboard costs about as much as buying a new 27" iMac.  Would the ivy bridge mini be faster than the 2011 refurbished quad core iMac for rendering and exporting, or slower because of the intel 4000 graphic chip?
    Thanks

    OK...here's an interesting tidbit...320M is supported by OpenCL according to The Oracle, aka Wikipedia
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenCL
    However, a look at the official Apple Snow Leopard docs suggests that they withdrew support for 320M.
    http://support.apple.com/kb/SP575
    Sometimes The Oracle is wrong.
    Message was edited by: S. Michelle Klein-Hass to note differences between what is up on Wikipedia and the most recent version of the Apple Knowledge Base article.

  • My files from final cut pro trial aren't transferring to final cut pro x - how do I fix this?

    I had been making a video in the final cut pro trial and didn't realize my trial was going to run out as soon as it did that day. I downloaded final cut pro x and was planning on finishing up editing tonight, but none of my files from final cut pro trial transferred over to final cut pro x. Everywhere I have read online said they should transfer automatically, but that's not happening. Is there a fix?

    you're tried using the 'Open Library' command?
    http://help.apple.com/finalcutpro/mac/10.1/?lang=en#ver217d6e77d
    Where are your Projects & Events located?

  • New MacBook Pro 7.1 doesn't install final cut pro studio

    I bought a new macbook pro 13' last week. When I tried to install the final cut pro studio, an alert window popped up saying that my mackbook doesn't have the required hardware to support the final cut pro. Can any one please help me on that?

    FCP 5.0.4 is not compatible with Intel Macs.
    If you have that version, then you need to upgrade to FC Studio 3, which is compatible with Intel Macs.
    FCP 5.1.4 is compatible, but you'll need at least FCP 6.0.x to run with Snow Leopard.
    Expect to pay about $250.00 for the upgrade if you shop.

Maybe you are looking for

  • Problems installing Adobe Reader

    Hi, I need some help installing Adobe Reader. First a little history. I run Windows 7 and Internet Explorer. I had Adobe Reader installed on my system and it was working fine. Several days ago I had problems opening any Windows Office program after v

  • How to Include Java sourcecode into ER File in Web Dynpro

    Hi Everyone, There should be a setting in the developer studio , where in which we can include the source code into a ER File after we build the source code. I am unable to get this settings. Please help me out Regards, Raj

  • @mac vs @me causing problems.

    I have been using a @mac address for my apple ID for about 9 years or so, when mobile me came into existance i got @me address as well. Both adresses are the same (or supposed to be) but its has caused a few problems. Is there anyway to delete my @ma

  • Error -10006 can't set object or data to object or data

    Hi Tripped up again by a silly error, I am trying to update an item in a record list but keep getting error -10006 Code below simplified but still produces the error, all help gratefully received. set filePath to "/Users/Ours/Documents/Text File.txt"

  • Role is not showing up in SUIM transaction

    All Z_PT_TRANS_ALL role was created for all Display access. When I go to SUIM Roles -> By Transaction Assignment. and search for roles this role is not showing up. However, role does have the transaction in S_TCODE. Please advise. From, PT.