Problem syncing video capture with audio sountrack

Hi,
I'm a drummer.  I'm trying to use iMovie to record a video of me drumming to a pre-recorded song.  I want the final video to be me drumming with mixed audio of both my drumming and the original soundtrack.  (Here's an example of someone else doing this on youtube: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cgqYkBFSva4)
I'm recording the video using iMovie's import from FaceTime (ie. straight from my MacBook Air) and then adding the song that I played along with as an additinal audio track from iTunes, and syncing.
This is where I hit a problem, and it's driving me nuts.  When I sync the iTunes song into my iMovie project I use waveform view to line it up so start of the song is perfectly in sync with the start of the video of my drumming.  That works fine.  But then gradually over the course of the video the song track goes out of sync with the video/audio of me playing, and by the end of a 6 minute song there's a very noticable gap, which both looks and sounds terrible.
This is very strange since it's the same audio track I was playing along to!  In real-time when recording I was obviously in sync with the music, but then when adding it back to the recording it somehow no longer lines up.
Does anybody know why this is happening and how I can resolve it?  Is this a frame-rate issue?
It seems to me this shouldn't be so hard to do what I'm trying to do ...
Thanks!
Ari

Hey Ari,
I was having a similar problem perhaps and this is what I did to fix it.
timothymckean
Re: iMovie '11 audio sync issues since 9.01 patch 
Jan 24, 2012 12:11 AM (in response to Urban Shocker)
Hi All,
I've been dealing with this sync problem tonight as well and here's what I found that worked.
I noticed that the audio sync was fine when I viewed in Quicktime 7, but not in iMovie.  I also noticed there was a small indicator on the clips in iMovie notating that the source clips were in 17 fps, not 30 fps.   This is odd because I recorded the clips using the FaceTime HD camera right into iMovie and it never gave me the option for framerate on the recording.  Viewing the source video in Finder I also realized that the codec for the source was Photo Jpeg... yuck.  Who's choice was that.
Using MPEG Streamclip (free video converter) I converted the source video clip to a Quicktime .mov at 30 fps and using the Apple Intermediate Codec and all the audio sync issues were fixed.  Didn't have to optimize, detach, or - most importantly - re-edit anything.    Apple's editing systems love Apple Intermediate Codec (AIC), I don't know why they don't import in this codec by default.
** Download MPEG Streamclip from http://www.squared5.com/

Similar Messages

  • After recent upgrade to Yosemite on Macbook air bluetooth audio cuts out and associated video stops with audio. Likewise with airplay and Apple TV. I have deleted all my saved wifi connections and restarted numerous times. I do not expect a resolutio

    After recent upgrade to Yosemite on Macbook air bluetooth audio cuts out and associated video stops with audio. Likewise with airplay and Apple TV. I have deleted all my saved wifi connections and restarted numerous times. I do not expect a resolution from the community, but hope to get the attention of Apple engineers. If you are having same problems or have a miracle cure I am all ears.

    May start my own thread, but I'm having similar issues.
    I've been using an old iMac (running 10.7.5) and Apple TV for years with no issues. Last week I bought a new Macbook Pro running Yosemite and have had audio issues multiple times. The weird thing is that sometimes it works flawlessly, other times (like now) I spend half an hour just trying to get a song to play.
    My issues are: When I got to "computers" in Apple TV to stream my music, my music is sometimes chopper or intermittent, and I seen to know when it's going to happen based on the status wheel just before it plays. When I choose a song, the status wheel will spin for an unusually long time, usually an indicator that the audio is either not going to work, or stutter.
    When it does finally pull up a song, the playhead sits at the beginning of the song for a good 3-5 seconds before actually playing. Then, when it starts playing, it's all downhill. It will play a few seconds, drop out, play a few more seconds, drop out, and then ultimately the playhead will keep moving across the song as if it's playing, but there's no audio.
    Again, this is a new phenomenon never experienced by me. I've tried everything I could think of, some of them all at once:
    • restart Apple TV
    • restart Macbook Pro
    • quite iTunes/open
    • turn off Home Sharing on iTunes then reconnect it
    • unplugging and cycling both my modem and router
    None of these have alleviated the problem.
    The odd thing is, like this morning, the audio started up perfectly and never gave me any issues. It wasn't until later in the day that it started. Perhaps after the macbook pro had been put to sleep? Not sure.
    Regardless, this is an annoying trait, one that's new to me and my system (as stated, worked flawlessly until my new purchase), and is 100% limited to either a) the macbook pro b) Yosemite or c) both of them.

  • Had to remove itunes from my computer to reset the computer. Now I'm having problems syncing my iphone with the computer. Computer is saying it wants to download updates to the phone but that will delete things I downloaded straight from the phone. Help!

    Had to remove itunes from my computer to reset the computer. Now I'm having problems syncing my iphone with the computer. Computer is saying it wants to download updates to the phone but that will delete things I downloaded straight from the phone. Help!

    iTunes thinks you have a new computer because you restored the OS. Open iTunes and authorize it to the same account you have on the iPhone. Did you restore your iTunes content from a backup after resetting your computer? Have you been syncing regularly with the computer, and does the iTunes library on the computer contain your apps, music and videos? If so just sync and your content will be removed then restored.
    If you have not hopefully you have now learned something. You can recover apps and purchased songs by connecting the phone, without syncing, and choose "Transfer purchases..." from the File menu.

  • I'm having problems uploading video taken with my iPhone 4 to Photobucket.  FB will not accept the file extension which is ex. IMG_423.  They will play on my computer and will upload to Facebook.  Why is the phone taking video with this file instead of so

    I'm having problems uploading video taken with my iPhone 4 to Photobucket.  FB will not accept the file extension which is ex. IMG_423.  They will play on my computer and will upload to Facebook.  Why is the phone taking video with this file instead of something like .mov or mp4.  How can I change the extension after the fact and avoid it in the future?

    You said, "the 4 also has signal and wifi whereas the 5 has only wifi". By "signal", I'm assuing that you mean cellular signal. If so, that means your iPhone 4 is still active on your cellular number and your iPhone 5 is not. Contact your carrier to sort out which phone is active on your account.

  • I am having problems syncing my ipad2 with my outlook 2010. Any suggestions

    I am having problems syncing my ipad2 with my outlook 2010. I went to ATT& T store and they recommended airplane mode when syncing.  It did not sync Outlook to my ipad 2. Any suggestions?

    You haven't purchased apps with multiple Apple ID's have you? If you have, you can only sync with one Apple ID in the iTunes library at a time. Whichever ID you are signed into on the computer and the iPad would determine which apps would sync.
    Have all of your apps been transferred into iTunes for your iPad?
    iTunes Store: Transferring purchases from your ... - Support - Apple

  • I am attempting to convert 8mm video cassettes to dvd using a video cassette player, elgato video capture with rca/usb connections to the mac, editing in imovie and burning on idvd. The picture quality is awful. What can I do?????

    I am attempting to convert 8mm video cassettes to dvd using a video cassette player, elgato video capture with rca/usb connections to the mac then editing in imovie and burning dvd-r using idvd. The picture quality is awful. What can I do??????

    At what point is the video quality bad?  Is it bad on capture?  I would recommend using an s-video 1394 firewire converter instead.  They capture the video at a higher bit rate.  If you have a lot of 8mm tapes to capture, invest in a stand alone DVD recorder.  They capture and compress in one shot.  If you need to rip it back from the DVD into iMovie again, I would recommend using DVDxDV.

  • HT4972 I am having problem sync my Iphone with pc running window7 after rebuilding pc due virus. Can someone help. Thanks

    Hi Guys
    I am having problem sync my Iphone with pc running window7 after rebuilding pc due virus. Can someone help. Thanks
    Regards
    Harwin Marr
    <Personal Information Edited By Host>

    Try restarting the AMDS >  iPhone, iPad, iPod touch: How to restart the Apple Mobile Device Service (AMDS) on Windows

  • Can I use Elgato VHS Video Capture with my Macbook pro?

    Can I use Elgato VHS Video Capture with my Macbook Pro? It comes with a CD on which is the software. My Macbook pro does not have a CD drive. how do i get the software?

    Elgato provides a download link to their latest Video Capture software v1.1.5. Supposedly runs on Snow Leopard and later. They recommend Yosemite.

  • Insert a video clip with audio in a sequence

    I've created a sequence out of three subclips and renamed and saved it.  When I try to add another video clip with audio to the end of the last subclip in the sequence it only adds the video, not the audio.
    Please advise

    Edit the video with sound to your timeline, when you are ready to replace the video with pictures, lock the audio tracks by clicking on the locks at the left side of the timeline:
    Clicking on the locks will lock the tracks and will protect them from being affected when you replace the video with pictures.
    Remember to unlock them when you want to edit or add more audio to the sequence.
    MTD

  • Video Capture with FX 5900 XT VTD

    Hope this is not redundant.  I sent a message to GlennVideo but I don't think it went through.  Trying to find my way around the forum and to post this message. So here goes.
        I recently purchased the FX 5900 XT VTD 128 card and installed it on my new computer (Pentium4 2.8).  The video display on my monitor is exceptional but there is no video capture.  I have read through the basics, installed the capture drivers from the CD that came in the package (nv4_disp version 6.14.10.5303) but after connecting the RCA banana video and audio plugs to the 4 in 1 connector that came with the unit and turning the VCR on nothing happens.  I did complete a "customer problem description form" from the MSI web site and sent it along but there has been no response thus far. I did not receive an automated response indicating the message had been received by them.  So I will resend and turn to the forum as well for help.  I have 512 of 2700 memory on this computer plus an MSI motherboard, 865PE New2-P.  Appreciate any suggestions.  Thanks.
       LJ Brown

    Well that's the rub, a manual did not come with my package.  I downloaded the manual from the web site and the package contents shown their does include a manual.  The only written material was a small brochure on installing hardware and software.  And the online manual is essentially the same; no help in how to use the capture program.  Yes 5 discs came in the box but seemed to be games, "Morrowind, Duke Nukem, Ghost Recon",etc.  And in that group is the WinDVD Creator; but I didn't appreciate what it was because of being grouped with the games until you responded to my note on the forum site.  Anyway I installed the program.  It doesn't seem to recognize my VCR connection.  When I activate the capture button the a picture of a TV screen comes up with the words "nVidia WDM Video Capture (...." next to it.  And when my VCR that is properly connected is turned on nothing happens.  If I hit the burn button a timer is started but I see nothing.  I was anticipating that if the program was recording from th VCR I should be able to monitor what is coming across on the large black TV monitor on the left half of the screen?  No substantive advice in the help section either.  So I'm still struggling and hopeful you or someone on the forum can guide me further.  Essentially all of the descriptions in the creator help section address digital material but always indicating that VCR material (analog) can be captured as well.  
        L J Brown

  • Flash videos playing with audio echo on initial load.

    I have been having issues playing Flash videos in the current version of Firefox (10.0) as well as the previous version (unknown) over the past few months.
    When I open a page with a video it will begin playing with an echo as if two videos are playing at the same time with a slight delay on the second video causing an audio echo effect. So basically one video with echoing audio. The websites that I experience this the most are yahoo sports (happens practically every time) and gamespot (happens occasionally). If I refresh the page the echoing effect goes away.
    I am running Windows 7 64-bit.
    I have updated video drivers on my ATI Radeon HD 5800 series.
    My flash player / shockwave is 11,1,102,55 (updated) but I know I have experienced the same problem with previous versions.
    I have the following plug-ins enabled:
    1. Adobe Acrobat 10.1.2.45
    2. Current version of Ad-Block
    3. Divx Plus Web Player 2.2.0.52
    4. Divx VOD Helper Plug-In 1.1.0.6
    5. Microsoft Windows Media Player Firefox Plug-In 1.0.0.8
    6. Quicktime Plug-In 7.7.1 / 7.7.1.0
    7. Real Player 32 Bit Plug-Ins (4 total plug ins) 15.0.0.198
    8. Veetle Plug-Ins (3 total plug ins) 0.9.17.0
    I have some others as well but I thought these were the only relevant ones.
    Can anyone help me with my problem?

    Start Firefox in <u>[[Safe Mode]]</u> to check if one of the extensions or if hardware acceleration is causing the problem (switch to the DEFAULT theme: Firefox (Tools) > Add-ons > Appearance/Themes).
    *Don't make any changes on the Safe mode start window.
    *https://support.mozilla.org/kb/Safe+Mode
    *https://support.mozilla.org/kb/Troubleshooting+extensions+and+themes

  • Video Capture with GF4 TI4200

    I seem to be haveing a few problems with video capture on my PC.
    I am using my TI4200 TV-in function from my VCR/CC to capture footage. I am also using the latest WDM drivers from the nvidia site.
    However everyso often i will get an annoying white block straight accross the screen and i try to recapture but it will happen, maybe somewhere else! what can i do?
    I have used ULEAD and WIN MM and IV WinPro to try this!  :(

    Installing the OLDER video capture drivers seems to have corrected my problem with the white bar.
    http://download.nvidia.com/Windows/23.11/WDM_1.08.exe
    When I tried the NEW video capture listed on the MSI pages for the 8X agp the HUE on the capture was WAY OFF. No Blues were present AND I still had the WHITE BAR syndrome.
    Why does the OLDER capture driver work and not the NEW ones. Seems like I am taking steps backwards to get a NEW video card to function properly. I am running Win2K with an AMD 2400, Gigabyte mb, 1gig ram, 1st hd 80 gig, 2nd hd, 120 gig, yamaha cdrw, 4x dvd burner.

  • Anyone using Elgato Video Capture with good results?

    I've got some VHS tapes that I want to edit in iMovie '11 (and/or FCE).
    Viewed on a TV monitor, the image quality of the tapes varies from acceptable to very good - but I am very disappointed with the quality of the video once imported, using Elgato Video Capture, to my MBP. It is very indistinct and washed out. Only the audio remains as clear as the original.
    Anyone had any success with using Video Capture to convert old tapes?
    Any advice and/or feedback would be much appreciated!

    conran wrote:
    Thanks Coolmax - I tried that, but no discernible improvement unfortunately.
    These are the tech specs from the Elgato site:
    Video resolution: 640×480 (4:3) or 640×360 (16:9)
    Video format: H.264 at 1.4 MBit/sec or MPEG-4 at 2.4 MBit/sec
    Audio: AAC, 48kHZ, 128 kBit/sec
    I've tried both H.264 and MPEG-4 without much success. The resulting footage is always extremely grainy and 'muddy'. Any other ideas?
    If I understand this correctly, Elgato can save your footage either in H.264 or MPEG-4 and you tried both. If the original file plays with ok quality and the resulting footage after being finalized by iMovie 11 look worse, I think we need to determine what are you finalizing to?
    In "Export to Quicktime", you can choose the compressor to "none". Do this with a short clip as the resulting file will be big. Play back this video.
    If there is a degradation in video, then you know it is iMovie 11 process that is causing it. From here on, you can further compress the video using Handbrake and adjust the settings to give best quality vs size.
    There are software available on the PC side that can enhance and resize an already weak VHS captured footage and make it look better before you import it into iMovie 11. But this require quite a bit of computer horsepower to complete it in any acceptable time frame.

  • Video Capture with WinProducer

    Hello,
    I just bought a Ti4200-VTD8X and I'm trying to capture DV type 2 avi using WinProducer. The hard drive that I am capturing it to has 50gb free but yet I am getting an error after 30-40 min that my hard drive is low on disk space. The resulting AVI file is a little over 9gb in size so there is still plenty of space left. I have captured DV type 2 avi using Studio 8 and Edition 5 with no problem. Does anyone know a fix to this problem?
    WinProducer 2.0
    WDM driver 1.08 (driver without Macrovision)
    Detonator driver 45.23
    Windows XP SP1
    Thank You,
    -pjman

    I have found WinProducer 2 to be feeble at doing anything other than the most simplest of editing. I did try analogue capture using the DV codec and had simular experiences. It may be memory/harddrive space but I am very sceptical though as using a decent (Media Studio Pro)video editor/capture program it does not exhibit these problems.
    Also do not get confused between firewire transfer and analogue capture they are 2 total different operations. If when you used Studio8 etc you used Firewire transfer you are only transfering a file from camera to the harddrive so very little CPU time and memory is used. Where as Analogue capture using what ever codec requires lots of processing time, memory and hardrive space to process and convert/compress the video stream. Analogue video will benefit from having a dedicated harddrive just for video purposes. It may also help to kill all background tasks prior to any analogue captures, i.e. just the neccesary system programs (no virus checker etc.) and the video capture program running in memory.

  • Ge4Ti4200 VTD8X 128 -video capture..audio pickup?

    I am setting up my Ge4Ti4200 card for video capture using my VCR as the video input. I want to put VCR video onto CDs. I need to know how to set it up so that the audio is captured along with the video. There is  nothing in the manual or that I can find in the forums about this. Does the card capture both sound and picture?

    Get an RCA to Mini plug adaptor and plug audio into your microphone jack.  

Maybe you are looking for

  • !!NOKIA MAKE A NEW FIRMWARE FOR N82!! 35.0.002 is ...

    I BUYED THIS PHONE(N82) TO USED...NOT TO WATCH AT HIM....TO MAKE A PICTURE DOESNT WORK...VIDEO NO.....MUSYC PLAYER IS BLOCKING...A NEW BUG AT BAR CODES READER!!!!i am tired to ask for help on this forum.........nothing solved......i dont know what to

  • How do I publish to a pre-existing site?

    I'm a self-taught web designer who started doing our church website years ago because no one else would do it, so there are gaps in my understanding of how certain things work.  I have used a web design program for several years and use Smart ftp to

  • Randomly shutting off

    Hello, My Toshiba laptop (windows 7) turns off randomly after about 15mins of running, It isn't due to dust nor over heating for I used a dust cleaner and I currently have a cooling mat for my laptop. I am unsure about the problem. But before this ev

  • Mousepad won't scroll in Firefox

    I know this question has been asked before by others, but none of the threads had a working answer and are unlikely to invite new ones as they are slightly old now. My Vaio touchpad/mousepad won't scroll in Firefox. It works in every other program (p

  • DB Link , ORA - 02083: illegal database name character '-'

    Hi, I work for an integration company and right now we are putting together an application that is moving a small subset of data from one db to another. I have created a db link to move the data. However, when I try to compile the procedure, that mov