Problems with pulldown In Cinema Tools

I am attempting a pulldown on some footage shot at 24pA on the Sony V1U (which I was told on this forum was not real 24p and therefore did not require a pulldown but found out from Sony that it is) and captured at 29.97. Looking at the Quicktime file before the pulldown, every 3 frames are clear followed by 2 blurry ones (which I understand to be blurry due to being interlaced.) After the pulldown in Cinema Tools, 1 frame is clear and 3 are blurry. This gives the footage a "stuttered" or "jittery" look when viewed on an NTSC monitor. If I am editing this video with 29.97 video and my final export is NTSC, what is the best gameplan for dealing with the pulldown issue? To pulldown or not to pulldown? That is the question.

If you're not getting a clean pulldown removal, I wouldn't bother. The only reason to edit at 24 in standard def is if you're trying to author a 24fps DVD (which allows you to get better quality at a lower bitrate).
I don't have any experience with removing pulldown from material shot with this camera. I have removed pulldown from a film to tape transfer. I simply kept trying the different options available in cinema tools til I got a clean 24fps (actually 23.986) quicktime.
Message was edited by: Michael Grenadier

Similar Messages

  • Problem with Refine Mask (Edge) Tool (+Refine Radius Brush)

    Hey all,
    I'm a teacher at Vancouver Film School in Canada.
    Having some major problems with the Refine Mask tool in Photoshop CS5 (+5.1)
    Especially when using the Decontaminate colours check box.
    it eliminates smart objects
    it leaves artifacting (especially in areas where I use the Refine Radius tool.) see posted image
    these are consistent problems.When I uncheck decontaminate colours, the artifacting doesn't happen and smart objects stay in tact.
    Is anyone else having problems with this?
    Also having this problem
    sometimes the radius will only increase INSIDE the selection  and not in the center like it should. This is the most frustrating  because it's not consistent but happened on 4 systems yesterday while teaching a class.

    Hi Notsosimpleton,
    You most likely already know this stuff.
    I have been experimenting with two images with Photoshop.  I agree that masking is a non destructive method of editing your image, but when you choose to use the decontaminate color option the refine edge feature automatically changes from new mask to new layer with mask indicating that the decontamination is destructive.
    Smart objects by there nature prevent pixel level modification. From my (general) understanding of the decontaminate color feature, Photoshop is attempting to replace edges which contain colors from the non selected area with colors from the selected area, in turn your smart object needs to be rasterized to allow this process to take place.  This then creates artificating because Photoshop is painting on to edges with color, leaving undesired rubbish around your selection. The majority of this is hidden by the mask.
    Changing your selection method or using clone stamp with the blend mode set to color and replace edges using selections from inside the selection area.  Affectively doing what Photoshop would do, but manually.
    I am not sure this really helps?, but I always try using other masking methods to achieve the result i.e. channels, paths.  I would be happy to experiment and share the results.

  • Problem with align and Selection Tool.

    This is a weird problem which I cannot explain at all.
    I am using AI CS3 with Windows XP.
    I am having this completely random problem with the selection tool and align pallette I cannot explain.
    I have a group of objects and groups of objects I am trying to use the align pallette on.
    Sometimes when I select all of the items I want to align, either by shift-clicking each one, or by drag-selecting them I am getting a random behavior where sometimes the align button will move all of the objects COMPLETELY off of the artboard, all the way to the edge of the working area and beyond into the grey area you cannot see.
    Normally, this would be caused by a stray point somewhere way off-screen or some other cleanup oriented thing on my part. However in this case, the behavior is random and does not happen every time I hit the align button.
    Sometimes it takes items within my grouped objects (lines of text) and moves THEM completely off the work area, leaving the other items in the groups in place. Sometimes the bounding box when I drag-select the items will stretch extremely far off of the work area.
    I have even dragged the extra large bounding box, bringing the edge that was once way off screen onto the work area, in outline view, in hopes of finding the stray point or object that could be causing this. However NOTHING appears that can be causing the align to throw all of my objects off-screen.
    The random nature of this behavior and the way it sometimes affects my text objects inside of groups leads me to believe it is a program bug and nothing I am doing.
    The behavior takes place regardless if I select by dragging or by shift-clicking, and is happening in more than one file, also randomly.
    Also, choosing "align to art board" vs. "align to crop area" does nothing to change this behavior.
    It is quite irritating. I've been using illustrator since v.88 so I have enough experience to know this is not normal.
    Any help with this one would be greatly appreciated.

    When this behaviour occurs, are perhaps guides included in your selection?

  • Problems with the elliptical marquee tool in CS6/Mac

    I have CS6 and did the newest update yesterday. I'm working on Mac OS X 10.6.8. The problem is following:
    The elliptical tool doesn't function anymore correctly. If I want to make an ellipse or circle first it looks normal put if I let go the mouse, it changes the shape in another form like square. Who knows whats wrong or how I can handle this?
    Thanks in advance. Foto Pitt

    How/where do I have to save that?
    If you are quite new you may not have customized any Actions, Brushes etc.
    But if you have you should regularly save those from the Panels’ fly-out menus or Edit > Presets > Preset Manager.
    3rd party plug-ins deactivation -> How/where can I deactivate the plug-ins?
    Do you have any plug-ins installed that were not part of the original program installation?
    Boilerplate-text:
    As with all unexplainable Photoshop-problems you might try trashing the prefs (after making sure all customized presets like Actions, Patterns, Brushes etc. have been saved and making a note of the Preferences you’ve changed) by keeping command-alt-shift pressed on starting the program or starting from a new user-account.
    System Maintenance (repairing permissions, purging PRAM, running cron-scripts, cleaning caches, etc.) might also be beneficial, Onyx has been recommended for such tasks.
    http://www.apple.com/downloads/macosx/system_disk_utilities/onyx.html
    Weeding out bad fonts never seems to be a bad idea, either. (Validate your fonts in Font Book and remove the bad ones.)
    http://helpx.adobe.com/photoshop/kb/troubleshoot-fonts-photoshop-cs5.html

  • Problem with Oracle Security Developer Tools creating signed SAML Assertion

    Hi,
    I'm trying to use OSDT to create a signed SAML assertion.
    Basically, what I've done is to use the ST_Test.java sample and the SignXMLEnveloped.java sample together.
    This is just a proof-of-concept, so what I did was use the code from ST_Test.java to create the unsigned assertion, take the byte array that results, and use it in a ByteArrayInputStream feeding into slightly modified SignXMLEnveloped.java code.
    I was actually able to created a signed assertion, but the signature on the signed assertion does not validate.
    I think that the reason it doesn't validate is because the original code in SignXMLEnveloped.java sets the URI in the reference to "", whereas the reference should be to something like "XXXXXX", which is the "AssertionID" attribute on the Assertion element.
    However, if I modify the SignedXMLEnveloped code to do a setUri to "#XXXXXX", I get the following error:
    Exception in thread "main" oracle.security.xmlsec.dsig.SigningException: Cannot find node with @Id="theassertion"
         at oracle.security.xmlsec.dsig.XSSignature.sign(Unknown Source)
         at SignXMLEnveloped.main(SignXMLEnveloped.java:116)
    Caused by: oracle.security.xmlsec.dsig.ReferenceException: Cannot find node with @Id="theassertion"
         at oracle.security.xmlsec.dsig.ObjectReference.dereference(Unknown Source)
         at oracle.security.xmlsec.dsig.XSReference.getTBDData(Unknown Source)
         at oracle.security.xmlsec.dsig.XSReference.computeDigest(Unknown Source)About to sign the Assertion...
         at oracle.security.xmlsec.dsig.XSReference.computeDigest(Unknown Source)
         at oracle.security.xmlsec.dsig.ReferenceList.computeRefDigests(Unknown Source)
         ... 2 more
    I think I know what the problem may be, but I'm not sure how to workaround it. I have written some apps to do digital signature verification before, and I know that there is a problem with SAML 1.1 called the "idness" problem, where the "AssertionID" attribute is not an "id" type attribute in the schema. I have a feeling that I'm running into the same problem here, with OSDT.
    Has anyone been successful at doing something like this with OSDT? If so, how?
    Thanks,
    Jim

    Hi,
    I was able to past my original problem, and can now sign the assertion which has the AssertionID attribute. I had to set the SAML version to 1.1 using initialize().
    Unfortunately, when I run the resulting signed assertion through a signature validation, it is failing to verify.
    I'm not sure why, but it is failing when it tries to verify the hash/digest on the reference.
    I am using a separate application that I wrote that uses Java6 and the security API that Java6 has, and with debugging enabled, I can see the dereferenced data that is being fed into the digester, and that looks correct, but the calculated digest doesn't match what my OSDT-based application generated.
    Anyone have any idea about what the problem might be?
    Thanks,
    Jim

  • Newbie problem with new objects and tools.

    in chapter 4 of the after effects essential training series from Lynda.com in the section about controlling animation with the pick whip. when he applies the null object the red bar immediately populates (correct usage?) the timeline to the right. when i apply the null object it's hidden to the left, under all the layer info, and i need to drag it out into view.
    ive found that whenever i have a problem, e.g., im using a tool and nothing is happening, it always comes down to this same thing: the layer is not with everything else and i need to drag it out into view.
    not only am i new to mac, but im only marginally literate and a total newb to anything more advanced than iphoto, any advice would be appreciated.

    Rick Gerard wrote:
    I'm not understanding what you are asking.
    If you have a layer in the timeline, a null, and the parenting column is visible you simply click on the pickwhip next to the layer and drag it to the name of the null layer. The Parenting box now says that Layer 1 is connected to Null 1.
    Now, when you move the null, the layer will move.
    i understand what they do and how to set them up.
    my question is more specific, but also applies more generally to other tools and layers. when Ian creates his null layer in the video (as well as other layers ive seen him create) the red bar that represents his null layer immediately appears in the timeline with the begining of the red bar at the left end of the work area. it is fully visible. when i create one the file shows up in the list of layers on the panel to the left of the time line, but it is not visible in the comp window and the red bar is hidden to the left side of the visible timeline to where you have to click its right end and drag it out from behind the panel on the left.
    this has happened with other layers ive created using other tools and before i figured out what to look for it was very frustrating. now, whenever i can't find something, or a tool that im using isnt doing anyhting (besides creating more and more layers) ive learned to look and see if theyre just hidden. it seems like it's probably a setting. but clearly, something is different: he creates a null layer and it appears in the timeline, and mine appear slid to the left.

  • Problem with Sun ONE Assembly Tools

    I try to start "Sun ONE Assembly Tools" but it gives me the error as the following:
    "Another copy of AssemblyTool maybe running with the same userdir.
    Please exit from previous session or remove the lock file."
    I used to run this tool before and it worked without any problem. But now it cannot run properly and there isn't have any running session.
    Please give me the suggestion of how to solve this problem and I'd like to know where is the lock file of this tool.
    Thanks very much...
    Worawisut

    I cannot wait for reply any more :-)
    I try to de compile "com.sun.enterprise.tools.deployment.main.DeployTool.class" in "appserv-assemblytool.jar"
    and see that when Assembly Tool start ,it will create filename "lock" in the folder "C:\Documents and Settings\<User>\.assemblytool".
    This file is used to lock the tool's session.
    I delete it and then run the tool again.
    Fortunately,it works fine.
    Thanks.

  • Problems with the apache ij tool, encoding error?

    Hello
    I try running a method in the ij.class from within my application. I always receive an error, which I believe is to do with encoding.
    int i = org.apache.derby.tools.ij.runScript(getDatabase("test").getConnection(),
             in,"ASCII", System.out, "UTF8");gives me:
    Exception in thread "AWT-EventQueue-0" java.lang.NoSuchMethodError: org.apache.derby.iapi.tools.i18n.LocalizedResource.getNewEncodedOutput(Ljava/io/OutputStream;Ljava/lang/String;)Lorg/apache/derby/iapi/tools/i18n/LocalizedOutput;
    at org.apache.derby.tools.ij.runScript(Unknown Source)
    The method getNewEncodedOutput() is not in the class specified, as indicated by the exception. However, I was hoping the problem was me not using the encoding correct. I have tried different comb. of "ASCII" and "UTF8".
    Regard
    Fluid

    Hello
    I try running a method in the ij.class from within my
    application. I always receive an error, which I
    believe is to do with encoding.
    int i =
    org.apache.derby.tools.ij.runScript(getDatabase("test"
    ).getConnection(),
    in,"ASCII", System.out, "UTF8");
    gives me:
    Exception in thread "AWT-EventQueue-0"
    java.lang.NoSuchMethodError:
    org.apache.derby.iapi.tools.i18n.LocalizedResource.get
    NewEncodedOutput(Ljava/io/OutputStream;Ljava/lang/Stri
    ng;)Lorg/apache/derby/iapi/tools/i18n/LocalizedOutput;
    at
    org.apache.derby.tools.ij.runScript(Unknown Source) The method getNewEncodedOutput() is not in the class
    specified, as indicated by the exception. However, I
    was hoping the problem was me not using the encoding
    correct. I have tried different comb. of "ASCII" and
    "UTF8". Yeah, mismatch.
    Alternatively, you could do away with ij if you are simply running a script. For example, if you had a script that looked like this:
    CREATE TABLE HOCKEY_TEAMS(
      TEAM_NAME  VARCHAR(30)  NOT NULL,
      CITY                 VARCHAR(50)
    )You could simply read this file, build a query and perform a statement.executeQuery(String query);good luck.

  • Problem with FX5200 Personal Cinema and DirectX 9 - serial reboots

    I'm hoping someone here can help, because I'm pretty much at the end of my rope here.  Here are my system specs:
    HARDWARE
    ========
    Motherboard: MSI KT6V-LSR
    RAM: 2x 512MB Infineon PC3200 DDR
    CPU: Athlon XP2500+
    Video: MSI FX5200 Personal Cinema 128MB
    HDD: Maxtor 160GB
    CDROM: MSI DVD/CDRW Combo
    SOFTWARE
    ========
    Windows XP Home SP1
    All available Windows Updates
    Norton SystemWorks 2003
    MSI bundled drivers and software
      MSIDVD
      MSI Personal Cinema
      MSI Live Update 3
    The problem is, I get serial reboots (computer boots to desktop, then reboots within a few seconds) unless I start in safe mode, or use MSConfig to disable all startup items.  Enabling even a single startup item, no matter what it is (NVCPL, any of the Norton tasks, etc) results in serial reboots.
    Troubleshooting steps taken so far:
    =======================
    Replace RAM - (single 512 or 2x512) no effect
    Replace motherboard (same model) - no effect
    Replace video card (same model) - no effect
    Replace CPU (same model) - no effect
    Replace power supply (w/ 450W) - no effect
    Update all drivers, MBD BIOS, VGA BIOS, DVD/CDRW BIOS w/ Live Update 3 - no effect
    Install Windows XP but don't install any Windows Updates - computer functions normally
    Install DirectX 9.0b - serial reboots
    Roll back to DirectX 8.1 - computer functions normally
    Install DirectX 9.0a - serial reboots
    Replace video card (GeForce MX440) - computer functions normally
    Throughout this whole process, Windows XP was reinstalled clean about five times - just to be sure the issue wasn't caused by file corruption in the install.
    Anyone have any suggestions?  Do I have to go with a different video card?  Or is there something obvious I've missed?
    -Cameron

    Try to put another video card on the computer.
    Try the video card on another machine.
    Try the lastest driver (there will be a new driver from http://www.nvidia.com tomorrow or may be a few days later).
    Try the lastest motherboard bios.
    Install the monitor driver.
    Install WinXP SP1

  • Problem with weblogic deployment descriptor tool (DDInit)

    Hi,
    I'm just playing with weblogic ... following their tutorual but I can't seem to run their deployment descriptor tool:
    java weblogic.ant.taskdefs.war.DDinit <folderName> gives me a NoClassDefFoundError.
    I have weblogic6.0sp1 installed with an evaluation license which has not yet expired. I have d:\bea\wlserver6.0sp1\lib in mt classpath so weblogic.jar is n there.
    When I check out the contents of the weblogic.jar file .. I can't seem to find this tool.
    Can anyone give me a clue as to what I am doing wrong?

    Here's a link describing the process. If this is what you are doing then your problem may be that 6.0 doesn't support this.
    http://edocs.bea.com/wls/docs61/programming/packaging.html#pack004

  • Problem with refresh button in tool bar in ALV

    hello experts,
                              I am displaying a report using OOPS ALV. Here i am deleting one row. After deleting the row, if i clicked on REFRESH button in the tool bar, it should display the table newly with all updations which i made. wat is the code to perform dis.
                                                      thanks in adance,

    in normal ALV we can refresh using     sel-refresh = 'X'.
    in OOPS ALV
    IF wa_toolbar-function = '&REFRESH'.
            wa_toolbar-function = 'REFRESH'.
            wa_toolbar-disabled = gc_x.
            MODIFY e_object->mt_toolbar FROM wa_toolbar
                              TRANSPORTING function disabled.

  • Problems with the digital publishing tools

    I downloaded the digital publishing tools but got an error when trying the preview button. I followed the instructions from adobe on clearing the indesign prefs, turning the extension on and off with the extension manager, an now none of the digital publishing tools operate. any ideas?

    Moving this discussion to the Digital Publishing Suite forum.

  • Problem with the new pattern tool in CS6

    When I make a pattern like the image below, it appears some vertical and horizontal lines where the pattern ends, when you change the zoom of the page, the lines appear and disappear alternatively
    The problem is that these lines also appear when I paste them in photoshop it's really annoying to have a really great tool but which doesn't work.
    ¿Anyone have some idea why thise happens? or how can I solve it?
    Thanks

    Monika, it doesn't really work what you say.
    When I turn off anti-aliasing, in fact the lines disappear, but I have the same problem when I paste it in PS.
    I can rasterize and it seems that disappear aswell, but what I want is to have acces to modify the pattern if I have to, so if I rasterize I can no longer edit the pattern so it's not a really good option for me.
    I want to suppose that this is a bug and they will fix it eventually, I really hope so, because the tool it's really good, but not so good if it's bugged.
    Thanks anyway

  • Problems with InDesign CC 2014 tool palettes on an extended display

    We have a Mac in our group set up with an extended display. With Indesign CC and before, we were able to move our InDesign tool palettes to the extended display, giving us a full view of our work on the main display. Now with the new upgrade to Indesign CC 2014, when using the tool palettes, the commands open on the main workspace display and the palettes will not collapse into each other unless you move them to the main display first. Can anyone offer help?

    Ask in the ID forum and provide proper technical information like what Mac, what OSX, what display.
    Mylenium

  • Problems with CC DPS desktop tools

    When I download CC DPS Desktop tools and I try to install it, the system tells me to update first Indesign CC with the update in indesign CC help menu, but the update voice is not selectable. How can I do?

    I too am lost trying to install the DPS tools for InDesign CC (Windows).  I have seen a downloadable patch that I can't apply, I have seen advice to run the update from the help menu, but there are no updates available, and I have tried downloadable installers that don't seem to do anything.  I still don't have the DPS tools in my extensions!

Maybe you are looking for

  • Can't open mail

    Hi , ineed your help.... I have do a downgrade 10.8 to 10.7 And i cant open more mail ... I try to install again but doesnt work ... I have this message : Process:         Mail [765] Path:            /Applications/Mail.app/Contents/MacOS/Mail Identif

  • Re-establish old itunes library on network drive

    After an extended period of not using itunes, I installed it today on my current desktop (Win7-64). Immediately, I had all my prior purchases available which was nice to see. My old library (about 4gb) is on a secondary drive. What's the best way to

  • Calendar sync issues between iphone and icloud

    My Iphone5 "phone' calendar does not seem to sync with Icloud calendars. Icloud carries home and work calendars which are also on my phone but not my "phone" calendar

  • Insert data base table

    Hi....     Iam having five records in my database tables.... with 5 fields.... now iam added a new field to that table... I want to insert entries into that fielf through program.. Suggest me logic... Thank you, Naveen.I

  • Choppy Play back

    Hello; I have a tiered system with an acquisition cluster, distribution cluster, and then finally an edge system. I am doing a live stream from an On2 Flix live encoder the streams is supposed to be 24x7. My client sees choppy behavior in the video o