Proper "Formatting" of second internal drive with Disc Utility??

Question

Using a second internal HD for data storage, was formated 4 months ago with default settings from Disc Utility. When I called the drive manufacturer today about corrupted Photoshop files (10 in 4 months) occuring on this drive, they recommended that I backup, Erase and Format as MAC OS Extended "NOT" Journaled.
Before I start - any comments, recommendations??
Would "Journaled" or "Not Journaled" actually cause corruption in 150mb Photoshop files??

Answer 1

I'd run Disk Utility and have a look at the disks; I'd look to verify the volume structures.
Journaled HFS+ is the default for installations, too.
Formatting usually doesn't help with disk hardware that is going wonky. Bad blocks are bad blocks, and failing disks tend to have increasing numbers of bad blocks. Reformatting a failing disk "papers over" the bad blocks, at least until the next crop of bad blocks arises and corrupts something else.
Formatting does help if there's a corruption in the volume structure.
Would also look to off-load everything and either replace the disk with a new one (wonky disks aren't worth bothering with), and/or run a write-comparison test and pound on the drive some.
Journaling can be shut off on the fly; see the diskutil man page for details on the disableJournal knob.
I'd also try to determine if this is something specific to Photoshop, or if this is a more generic problem. Look also for patches for Photoshop, and do look to update whatever version of Mac OS X or Mac OS X Server is in use here.
There's no obvious mention of HFS+ and Journaling and Photoshop over at Adobe, either.