Quality difference between S-video and RCA

Can someone tell me what's the difference (in quality) between S-video out and RCA out?
I'm using RCA out because with s-video, the image shows up in black and white on my TV.
It would help to know I'm not loosing too much quality this way...
Regards everyone.

pauliewog is speechless  
But what Robi says is true!
The various forms of (analogue) signal transfer are, in descending order of quality:
RGB - The Red, Green and Blue signals are generated by the PC (say), and connected by separate wires to ultimately control the Red, Green and Blue electron guns of the display monitor/TV set. The standard 15-pin "VGA" connector is RGB (plus H and V synchronising pulses).
YUV - Also called Component, and YCrCb, as found on DVD players. The Y is the luminance, or Black-and-White component, while the Cr and Cb are the Differences between the Y and the Red and Blue signals respectively. Usually, the Y signal has higher bandwidth than the Cr and Cb signals (twice as many Y samples as Cr and Cb samples on the DVD). Still needs wires, but the Sync is added to the Y signal.
Y/C - aka S-Video. The Y is as above, but the Cr and Cb signals are used to modulate a subcarrier (3.579545MHz for NTSC, 4.43361875MHz for PAL), with one of the signals effectively at 90 degrees to the other - the C signal. The bandwidths of the colour difference signals need to be bandwidth limited to about 1/3 of the subcarrier frequency (about 1.7MHz for PAL from memory), compared to the Y bandwidth of 5MHz for broadcast television. In PAL, the phase of one of the signals is inverted every other line (PAL = Phase Alternating Line, aka Peace At Last). Transmission errors which result in green faces and purple trees in NTSC (National Television Standards Commitee, aka Never Twice the Same Colour) tend to desaturate the colours instead.
CVBS, aka Composite Video (also RCA, named after the company that developed the type of connector used, which is typically yellow for video). The Y and C (and sync) signals are combined one one wire. The TV has a harder job of separating them back to RGB  :(
RF (Radio Frequency). The CVBS signal is modulated onto an RF carrier, which could be anywhere between about 45MHz and about 1000MHz (not counting satellite distribution), so that it looks the same as a broadcast TV station to a TV set, and connects via a single cable to the antenna socket of a TV set. So first the TV has to demodulate the signal back to CVBS, before separating the Y and C, then separating the C into Cr and Cb and putting into a matrix with the Y to get RGB back. Nevertheless, this is a useful technique for distributing a signal to a lot of TV sets over a reasonably large area. It is also the only method that works with old TVs without A/V inputs - which is why game consoles used to come with an RF Modulator (aka RF Converter) as standard.
The above methods are also in descending order of signal bandwidth, which restricts the available resolution, or the finest horizontal detail (especially colour detail). Generally, 800x600 is about as good a resolution as you can expect to get on a TV display without resorting to special enhancing techniques.
The above is probably a lot more detail than you need, but is still a fairly superficial explanation. But study it up, the test is next Monday at 9am  :D
Cheers

Similar Messages

  • Difference between ipod video and a ipod v2

    can anyone tell me the difference between ipod video and a ipod v2 video?

    Brighter Screen
    Longer Battery Life
    New Search Feature
    "Largest" model is available with an 80GB capacity instead of a 60GB capacity.

  • Dw cs5 FLV video quality difference between web play and local play w/same flv file

    When I play a flv locally on my pc with adobe media player.. it looks great.
    i build a page, insert it in the page (dw cs5) use auto size detect. upload all..
    then go to test it out using FF and the video is not a sharp ( the text titles are especially ratty looking  http://www.centroidcnc.com/cncvideo/centroid_digitizing_cs5.html ).
    how can this be? its the same file.  what am i doing wrong? thanks in advance for any tips.
    here is a screen capture of the 480 wide flv playing in adobe media player... reasonable text clarity
    and the same file playing in firefox.. with rattly looking text.
    is the browser trying to scale it up or something?

    Test page looks pretty good but you still have dimension problems.... notice the black bars on the side of the video. Black bars on the sides mean the height is not great enough. Because that version of the player has the controls below the video, you have to ADD that number of pixels to the height.
    height: 360, width: 480
    so width needs to be video height (360) PLUS height of controls ...15 or 20 or so... may need the trial and error thing again.
    The JW Player will play mp4s on the iPhone.
    I'd suggest using QuickTime Pro to convert. QT Pro has an excellent "Export for Web" option that exports beautiful video (m4v).
    QT will open many file types but if you only have the .flv version, you can use Handbrake to convert to .mov or .mp4:
    http://handbrake.fr/
    It's free and does a pretty good job. But I still do the final convertion with QT because the finish video comes out so nice.
    For example:
    http://exploreolympics.com/reports/?p=3499
    videos play in iPhone as well as PCs (JW Player with controls over video)
    Check for other/newer version of player with controls over video.
    Of course JW Player is just one of many media players available. FlowPlayer is another:
    http://flowplayer.org/
    or get a Flash developer to create one for you... as on the Home page here:
    http://www.exploreolympics.com/index.html
    This page uses our custom Flash player with fallback to the JW PLayer (using swfobject).
    So there are many solutions to your problem, but the reason the text is fuzzy is that the video dimensions are not correct.
    Best wishes,
    Adninjastrator

  • Is there quality difference between iMovie project and QT shared file?

    I have several scenes that I want to piece together. Each scene was edited and saved as a separate iMovie project. I also "shared" each of the edited scenes to create full quality QuickTime files. I now want to compile the scenes to create a short film (actually an actor's demo reel). My reason for importing the QT files would be to have simpler uncut scenes as opposed to importing each of the iMovie projects, which would result in hundreds of tiny clips. It just seems like the fewer scenes/clips the easier it will be to make transitions, etc. But, will I lose quality (video or audio) by using the QuickTime files instead of the iMovie projects? Thanks.

    it just looked lower quality in the QuickTime Player.
    probably just my mind. thanks for the assurance.
    Don't worry; your mind (and your eyes) are okay. What you see is normal.
    By default, a Full Quality movie does not look beautiful. Playback quality is reduced, making it easier for your Mac to play the movie. But if you have QuickTime Pro you can adjust the movie's playback settings to see all the quality that's there. Even then it will appear to be "stretched". That's normal too.
    Full Quality means it contains all the data of the source material with no loss of quality, not that it delivers great playback quality. A Full Quality movie is not intended for playing movies, and it's too large to share. Its sole purpose is to preserve the quality of the video/audio, letting you copy it from place to place with no loss of quality.
    Actually, when you use QT Pro to adjust the playback settings of a Full Quality movie, it actually looks BETTER than iMovie's own display. iMovie never shows you all the quality that's there. (One of the benefits of having QuickTime Pro.)
    Karl

  • One pixel difference between rendered video and composition

    I have a non-standard dimensions (767 x 454) in my composition, but the finished render becomes (766 x 454). Does video generated need to have even-numbered dimensions? If not, how can I get it use to 767?
    Thanks,

    Depends on the CoDec. Most compression methods involving visual compression (MPEG etc.) are indeed based on multiples of 2, 4, 8, 16 and so on, so this is normal. Only algorithms that only use compression on the binary level do not suffer this limitation (QT Animation, PNG etc.) but even then you can find many who are locked into specific resolutions and field settings because they provide optimized routines for standard broadcast resolutions such as e.g. the Avid CoDecs do.
    Mylenium

  • HT2729 what exactly is the difference between regular video and video playback?

    i am wanting to purchase a black video playback ipod with 30 gb, the fifth generation and before i get it i would like to know all the details about video playback

    i am wanting to purchase a black video playback ipod with 30 gb, the fifth generation and before i get it i would like to know all the details about video playback
    http://support.apple.com/kb/SP41

  • Quality difference between Imovie 05 and 08.

    Ihave a ordinary Sony handycam DV camera(DCR-HC39E).I have made some films with Imovie 05 and they were ok, but not as good as plugging directly from the camcorder in to the mac or a TV. Why so, isn´t digital digital. I bought the Ilife 08 hoping that the quality was better, but when i made the same film with 08 it was much more "blurry" than 05. I was realy dissapointed. Do I do something wrong or should I downgrade ?

    Hi
    iMovie'08 is something else than iMovie 1 to 6 and should have been named properly.
    If You got iLife'08 then You are entitled to download iMovie HD 6 (6.0.4) which
    is Great.
    http://www.apple.com/support/downloads/imovieHD6.html
    If You copy/export Your movie back to Camera and a new miniDV tape You'll get
    a quality which I can't differ from original.
    DVDs - are hard compacted eg 25Gb down to 4.2Gb => There is a loss and depending
    on how this encoding is done this quality vary from worse to better.
    I use Verbatim DVDs
    I use DVD-R disks
    I burn at x1 speed (can be set in iDVD08)
    I use Pro-encoding in iDVD08
    I sequre at least 25Gb free space on internal hard disk (important)
    This gives me a result I can stand for.
    Yours Bengt W

  • Print quality difference between iphoto and aperture...?

    when ordering books, is there a print quality difference between using iPhoto and Aperture? or are they sent to the same lab?
    it's possible i may have some setting wrong, but when i order a book using iphoto, i never really feel the quality is that great. it's good, i just feel it could be a lot better. the print quality sort of reminds me of newsprint, albeit high quality newsprint. similar sized prints made at home on my basic 3-in-1 printer look better.
    thanks...

    Previews are what you view on your display. When you import a photo into Aperture (and I'm pretty sure iPhoto as well), your computer automatically generates a preview for quick viewing. The original images are stored in your library, but it is the preview that you see.
    In Aperture, you are able to set the size and quality of these previews. When sharing photos between Aperture and iPhoto, the process is as follows:
    Let's say that your images are stored in Aperture, but you also want to be able to view them in iPhoto without taking up too much room on your hard drive. Essentially, if you were to import the originals into iPhoto as well, you would be storing two exact, yet separate copies of the same image on your hard drive. As you are aware, with large images (whether JPEG's, and especially RAW) this would put quite a tax on your storage capacity after not too long.
    So, you have your images in one or the other (in this case Aperture), but you want to play around with them in iPhoto. What you can do, is open iPhoto, go to the File menu and then select, Show Aperture Library. This will open a window with all of the contents of your Aperture Library. You can then drag any images you want into iPhoto . The only thing is, you are not dragging the original JPEG's, but rather, the previews of those images. If you have those previews set to a lower quality (again for capacity concerns), you will only have lower quality and lower detailed images in iPhoto. These images might not be ideal, or even suitable for printing high quality prints. The previews that you generate in Aperture though can be adjusted to be extremely high quality with no size limits.
    My thinking was that since you mentioned Aperture, it sounded like you had experience with working with it and with ordering a photo book through Aperture. I guess you were saying that you ordered via iPhoto, weren't happy with the quality and were wondering if Aperture created books were better.
    Anyway, if this is the case, I cannot answer that for you. I have never ordered a book through Aperture. If the quality of your images is good, you should be able to get a decent product no matter where you order it from. There is not doubt that the materials used and the print shop that does the work makes a difference, but if your images are good, you should still get a decent product through iPhoto. Perhaps iPhoto isn't the way to go though if you have had poor experiences with them.
    If you haven't used Aperture yet, I would highly recommend it though aside from the photo book aspect of this thread. It is a stellar product.
    I hope this helps.
    Message was edited by: macorin

  • I do video productions for a small local TV station. I use Final Cut Express to edit. I need a new video camera but am at a loss as to what to buy. I know I will get a digital camera but do not know the difference between just digital and digital HD.

    I do video productions for a small local TV station. I use Final Cut Express to edit. I need a new video camera but am at a loss as to what to buy. I know I will get a digital camera but do not know the difference between just digital and digital HD. Also, I can not afford an expensive camera and need some advice on which of the available cameras would be best and also work well with a Mac. One last issue, I currently use a Panasonic #CCD camera that takes a tape. When I load video to Final Cut the audio and video are out of sinc. Go figure. Can anyone help with these questions. Karen

    Hello Karen,
    If you are using Final Cut Express, then look for camcorders that are AVCHD camcorders.  Look especially for the AVCHD logo and specific mention of AVCHD in the specs.  Most of the major manufacturers produce good quality camdcorders - Canon, Sony, etc.
    Also, be aware that there are a lot of "not quite AVCHD" camcorders on the market (sometimes they say they record video as MPEG4-H.264/AVC) - buyer beware!
    Most everything you are going to find on the market today is HD, which stands for "high-def".
    Regarding your question about the Panasonic camcorder, it's best if you post that as a separate question, and please identify the specific model camcorder and the Easy Setup you are using in FCE.

  • Difference between workflow engine and quality assurance system

    Hi,
    please let me know the difference between workflow engine and quality assurance system.

    Hi,
         please let me know the difference between workflow engine and quality assurance system in TMS.

  • Difference between signal strenght and quality?

    Hi all,
    As per Cisco documentation
    Low RF signal strength does not mean poor communication.
    Low signal quality does mean poor communications.
    If someone can explain me difference  between signal strength and signal quality?
    As per my home AP  i can see that signal strengh is measured in numbers like 50 %  or 100%.
    But what is signal quality and how me measure it ?
    thanks
    mahesh

    Great question ....
    First, lets look at the concept of signal quality and strength ... Suppose for a minute you are front row at a rock concert right next to the speakers. The sounds is so loud you cant hear anything but screaming. This is an exmaple of a loud signal but poor quality.
    As for measuring the signal and noise or should we say quality of signal. Vendors sometimes give you a % or dB scale when grading the signal.You really cant make headers or tails from the % scale becuase each vendor has different % measurements. But check your ap, becuase you may have the option to change it to dB.
    Lets look at dBm. Right now my client is showing:
    Signal -59 dBm
    Noise -98 dBm
    The dB scale is simple. The lower the dB the LOUDER the signal. You will see -59 of signal is good, in fact I am about 50 feet from the AP. If you are right under the ap you will get like a -30ish. Noise, we dont want to be loud, so we want to see noise at -100. The lower the noise dB the louder the noise is.
    So back to out example above. Next to the speaker, you are showing say -30dBm but your noise may be like -70dBm...
    Does this make sense?
    You normally like to see your signal no higher than -67 for voice or -76 for data. And your noise should be higher than -90.

  • The difference between chapter markers and dvd studio pro markers

    Does anyone know what is the difference between chapter markers and dvd studio pro markers? I can not find anywhere on Google. Also in the tutorials I have seen, suggesting DVD Studio Pro markers, but it did not mention the chapter markers.
    Thanks,

    "Adding Chapter and Compression Markers to Your Sequence
    Once you have your edited sequence or program finished, you can add markers to the sequence for use on DVD. Markers are reference points you can place within clips or sequences that identify specific frames. There are two kinds of markers you can add that directly relate to authoring a DVD—chapter markers and compression markers.
    • Chapter markers allow DVD authoring applications to create a navigable chapter list for your exported QuickTime movie. Chapter markers force MPEG keyframes (known as I-frames) at their location, since the DVD specification requires an I-frame at each chapter point.
    • Compression markers identify areas of abrupt change and include two types: those that are automatically inserted by Final Cut Pro at all edit points, and those you manually place in the clip or sequence. Like chapter markers, compression markers force I-frames at their location, although in this case it is for better quality encoding, and they are not used to create a chapter list.
    Note: When you export a QuickTime movie, you have an option to export various kinds of markers, including compression, chapter, or DVD Studio Pro markers. *When you choose to export DVD Studio Pro markers, Final Cut Pro actually exports chapter markers and all compression markers.* This includes compression markers you set manually, as well as ones created automatically by Final Cut Pro at edit and transition points."
    From the Final Cut Pro User Manual.
    So, JS was right the first time

  • What is difference between SAP R3 And SAP IS Mills Product

    HI Friends
    What is difference between SAP R3 And SAP IS Mills Product
    What are the futures are availables in IS MIlls
    Regards

    Hi,
    SAP R/3 is the central enterprise version. It is not specifically designed for any inducstry sectors and it can cater many of the industry types.
    Is is developed for specific industries an for SMB's (small and medium business). It will have components specifically for the industry.
    The SAP Mill Products component adds sector-specific functionality to an ERP system to satisfy the complex requirements of mill industries (e.g. metal, wood, paper, textiles, construction materials, and cable sectors).
    These industry segments differ from others primarily in that the materials used have a large number of characteristics and variants. The materials in the segments listed above are also predominantly area-based (e.g. paper, textiles, plastic film) or length-based (e.g. cables, piping). Account must be taken of these material characteristics throughout the entire supply chain.
    To cater for the particularities of these industry segments, SAP Mill Products features processes and functions that cover the entire supply-chain cycle – from product design and configuration, through planning, order processing, capacity planning and production, to final delivery. Additional functions are available in costing and inventory management. SAP Mill Products are also integrated into Quality Management, Financial Accounting, and Controlling.
    Prase

  • What is difference between adobe photoshop  and photoshop extended cs5

    what is difference between adobe photoshop  and photoshop extended cs5

    Hi,
    The biggest difference is the 3D feature set is only available in Ps Extended CS5. Exclusive to Extended CS5 also are timeline for video editing, Dicom format support, Stack mode blending, analysis measurement tools, and some 32-bit painting capabilities.
    Some things have changed for the Photoshop Extended CS6 version, mainly enabling more of the video editing features for both products.
    regards,
    steve

  • What is the difference between Category Mgmt and Spend Analysis?

    Hi Friends
    What is the difference between Category Mgmt and Spend Analysis?
    Regards
    Chinna Krishna

    Hi Chinna
    Here are my two cents on this questions
    1. Catagory Management : It pertains to all sourcing activities that a purchasing group does for a specific catagory of items ( say tyres, bearings, etc. in automobile industry scenario OR steel sheets, electric motor, etc. in consumer durables industry scenario) in order to meet companies strategic goals like cost, quality, delivery and new product introduction. It also involves the strategic sourcing piece for that category. Typically it can include following activities for a category which is being managed
    - Identifying current and future business & technical requirements
    - Constant vigilence and analysis of supply market for that category ( and also identifying new sources)
    - Lauching various projects within category focussed on cost reduction, quality improvement, delivery improvement. This may include some of activities like supplier analysis. RFx, Reverse auctions, contract negotiation, etc.
    - Monitoring the category specific supplier performance
    Category Management team typically consists of cross functional team and it is iterative process (continuous improvement).
    Category Management in covered to some extent in E-Sourcing application and its analysis is covered in Spend Analytics application. Fully blown category management is on road map of SAP but none of the current functionalities addresses it fully.
    2. Spend Analysis: This involves analysis of the spend at highest level of organization. To improve the data quality, it typically involves spend data standardization & enrichment, supplier normalization and spend categorization. Once you have clean data, one can slice and dice the data to gain insight into the spend and identify opportunities for launching the various initiatives focussed on cost, quality and delivery.
    SAP Spend Analytics application covers this spend analysis capability.
    Its a long answer and hope it helps you.
    Bhushan

Maybe you are looking for

  • Error while installing SAP Gateway

    Hi, I am getting the following error while installing SAP Gateway. INFO 2009-09-24 06:11:18.815 Execute step stopInstance of component |NW_Gateway|ind|ind|ind|ind|0|0|NW_GW_Instance|ind|ind|ind|ind|7|0|NW_Instance|ind|ind|ind|ind|0|0 INFO 2009-09-24

  • 12GB already used on out-of-the-box refurb MBP?

    Hi- Just a quick question-- My refurbished 15-inch MBP (2.2 Ghz, 120 GB hard disk) just arrived. I took it out of the box, started up and registered, and was planning to shift things from my old Powerbook G4 in Target disk mode, etc, but haven't done

  • I use iphone 3GS, after upgared to ios5, my phone restart when i took picture with   button and while playing music .. what happened?

    I use iphone 3GS, after upgraded to ios5, my phone restart when i took picture with   button and while playing music .. what happened?

  • Curve keeps turning of

    Need some help, I have a curve 8520 and it just keeps resting its self all the time, I went to vodaphone and they said it just needs to be updated so I done that, and it still keeps resting its self when it wants to, its freezes then cuts of then sum

  • Transport Projects

    hello, I have SolMan 3.20 and want to transport my project into new Solution Manager.I create a transport request, using Progect-->Transport and moove it into new SolMan. The structure of the project appeared but there are no project documentation in