Redundancy with dual WLC

Hi, I will implement a WLAN network with AP1130AG and WLC 2125. If I understand right the whole traffic to/from the APs (data + management) will be first encapsulated in a LWAPP tunnel to/from the WLC ? Then, the WLC will forward the different traffic VLANs via a 802.1Q trunk to the network. Is it correct ? If so, the WLC is a true single point of failure ! What will happen if the WLC get out-of-service ? What is the impact on existing client sessions and new ones ? How will a redundant WLC 2125 work with the primary (active/standby with HSRP, load balancing)? What are the best practices in such a network ?
Thanks

Hi Jean-Pascal,
In the WLC world this is how an AP is covered in case one WLC fails. It is not without some "downtime" in case of failure but both Controllers are active. You have to keep in mind that an AP can only be registered to one WLC at a time so this is the best that you can do :) When one WLC fails the AP then has to re-register with the backup, this is not a completly seemless process.
This has some really good info;
WLAN Controller Failover for Lightweight Access Points Configuration Example
http://www.cisco.com/en/US/tech/tk722/tk809/technologies_configuration_example09186a008064a294.shtml#c4
Hope this helps!
Rob

Similar Messages

  • Redundancy with dual nic servers

    Hi I have 2 11500's configured with box-to-box redundancy. I have a number of app servers each with dual nic's (which are Teamed) and which are connected directly to the CSS's. Nic 1 in each goes to the master CSS1 and is therefore live. Nic2 goes to standby CSS2.The CSS's are connected two 4500 switches to the public.I am monitoring the links to the 4500's,if i switch off the master CCS1,we fail over and the servers all connect via nic2 to the new master CCS2. But when the link to the 4500 from the CSS1 Master goes down the CSS'S failover but the nic2's do not connect to the CCS2 because Nic 1 in each server has not failed ie they still see CSS1 as up. Is there a workaround to this problem ?
    Thanks
    J

    I know of no way to link CSS interfaces so that if the uplink goes down, the the other ports are shutdown. There may be another way to configure the adapter teaming or failover on the server side. I know some OS's send out test frames from one adapter to the other to verify network integrity.
    What I'd recommend is that you setup a VLAN on your 4500's for the server's physical connections, and uplink that to a "backend" interface on the CSS. This can be done with the CSS in either a router or bridge configuration, but I'd recommend router mode.

  • N+1 redundancy with 2504-HA

    Hello,
    I have question regarding N+1 redundancy with 2504-HA WLC.
    Can I use 2504-HA unit for H+1 redundancy? SSO is not needed
    I have two wireless network:
    1.      With WLC 5508 with about 40 AP(1262), all them are A regulatory domain
    2.      With WLC 2504, with about 30 Mesh AP(1552), all of them are E regulatory domain
    I plan to use two 2504-HA units for backups, one for network with WLC5508 and second for network with WLC2504.
    In case N+1 redundancy is management with Prime mandatory ?

    Hi,
    Better to use same model and same software.
    Case1: You have 5508WLC
    Solution from my side: You must buy a another WLC with HA SKU license(Zero AP license). This wlc can work as N+1 and AP SSO as well as Client SSO but with higher version of code(7.5 or higher).
    Case2: You have 2504 WLC
    Solution: You must buy a another 2504 HA WLC: AIR-CT2504-HA-K9, that only supports N+1(No AP SSO and NO Client SSO)
    http://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/td/docs/wireless/technology/hi_avail/N1_High_Availability_Deployment_Guide/N1_HA_Overview.html
    More info:
    http://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/products/collateral/wireless/aironet-1130-ag-series/qa_c67-714540.pdf
    Regards
    Dont forget to rate helpful posts

  • Hellp on Nokia E61i associating with Cisco WLC 4402

    I met some problem with associate Nokia's dual mode mobile phone E61i with Cisco WLC 4402, hope someone can help me on it:
    I setup a VOICE WLAN in 4402(v5.0.148), Layer2 security is WPA1+WPA2, Key management using 802.1x, WPA1 policy enable both TKIP and AES, Radius server using ACS engine(v4.1.1.23)(enable PEAP-MSCHAPv2);
    I can use my laptop to join this WLAN(my laptop configure with PEAP/MSCHAPv2, WPA-TKIP, not validate server certificate), but can't let E61i join it, each time it will remind me “unable to connect, WPA authenticate failed).
    In E61i, I select WPA/WPA2 as WLAN security mode, enable EAP-PEAP, under EAP-PEAP, I enable EAP-MSCHAPv2; however under Cipher, there's a lot of options such as “RSA,3EDS,SHA”, “RSA,AES,SHA”, but there's no TKIP, I have tried to enable all of them and tried only enable those items which include AES, but I failed each time with the same reminder “unable to connect, WPA authenticate failed”. I checked ACS's failed log, there's no record; In 4402, there also have no record.
    If I change the security to open or static WEP for VOICE WLAN, then the E61i can connect to the WLAN.
    I think the problem maybe relate to encryption or certificate, right now I just do the test in lab, not in customer's real environment, so I use ACS to generate a self signed certificate and installed it in ACS.
    Pls. help to point me what I need to adjust to make it work. Thanks!

    Hello,
    CCKM Key Management mode on Nokia E61i phone can be used
    against Cisco LWAPP AP's with TKIP encryption
    Nokia E61i (and other E-series WLAN enabled phones) are supporting CCKM key management method with both dynamic WEP and TKIP ciphers.
    On the phone configuration, 802.1X security mode needs to be in use in order to enable CCKM support. WPA/WPA2 security mode on the phone is dedicated to standards based WPA and WPA2 methods and it does not allow usage of proprietary CCKM key management method.
    Phone's 802.1X security mode does not mean that phone would only support dynamic WEP encryption method in this mode although in contexts term "802.1X" may be attached to pure dynamic WEP (legacy / pre WPA era)security methods.
     802.1X security mode can be seen on Nokia Eseries phones as sort of an "everything with EAP based authentication is allowed" mode, meaning that following key management and cipher configurations are supported:
    - WPA-Enterprise  = WPA Key Management (EAP based authentication) with TKIP encryption
    - WPA2-Enterprise = WPA2 Key Management (EAP based authentication) with AES encryption
    - Mixed WPA/WPA2-Enterprise = I.e. WPA/WPA2 Mode Migration WPA2 Key Management (EAP based authentication) with AES (for unicast data) and TKIP (for multicast data) ciphers
    - 802.1X dynamic WEP = legacy (pre-WPA era) 802.1X based dynamic WEP (EAP based authentication with dynamic WEP encryption)
    Supported:
    - CCKM with WEP = CCKM Key Management (EAP based authentication) with dynamic WEP encryption
    - CCKM with TKIP = CCKM Key Management (EAP based authentication) with TKIP encryption
    Not supported:
    - CCKM with AES = CCKM Key Management (EAP based authentication) with AES encryption
    Please note that CCKM-AES mode (CCKM Key Management with AES cipher) is not working properly due to some incompatibilities between Cisco and Nokia implementations thus it must not be listed as a supported combination on the current Nokia E-series devices. We are also seeing CCKM-Fast
    Re-authentication failures with Cisco autonomous AP's when AES encryption is used although initial authentication to autonomous AP's is successful. Nokia is currently working with Cisco to get CCKM-AES based authentications and roaming working properly with both LWAPP and autonomous Cisco AP's.
     Also note that Nokia E-Series does not support Cisco proprietary CKIP/CMIC encryption/data integrity methods. CKIP/CMIC is supported at least by Cisco autonomous AP's and it seems to be available also
    at least on LWAPP AP version 4.1.171.0.
     CCKM on E-Series devices has been tested against Cisco LWAPP (ver. 4.1.171.0) and it works when TKIP encryption is in use (WPA Policy + TKIP encryption in Cisco LWAPP configuration terms).
    In practice this means Cisco LWAPP is configured in a following manner: WLAN -> Edit -> Security-> 
    Layer 2 Security = WPA+WPA2
    WPA+WPA2 Parameters:
    -WPA Policy = enabled
    -WPA Encryption = TKIP enabled, AES disabled
    -WPA2 policy = disabled
    -Auth.Key Mgmt = CCKM
    Br,
    -Pasi-

  • Trouble with Neo4 Platnum and AMD X2 with dual channel memory

    I just installed an X2 3800+ in my Neo4 Platnum board.  The board had a 3500 in it and ran fine.  When I installed the X2, the machine will no longer POST if the memory is in the dual channel mode.  I flashed to the latest BIOS (1.8) and it still does not work.  I am using 2 Corsair XMS 2-2-2-5 Dimms each at 512MB.  The PC POSTs fine if I place both modules in the Green slots.  It does not work with 1 in green and 1 in purple (with either Dimms1-2 or 3-4).  Has anyone else seen this?

    Todd,
    Your last post help me understand your situation a bit better.  Here are some questions for you:
    1- On your old system did these memory sticks work fine has a dual channel pair? Were these 2 memory sticks bought has a dual channel rated matched pair?
    2- In your own words give me your definition of POST?
    3- In your own words give me your exact detailed rendition of what happens when you try to post with dual setup. (How far do you get? Where does it hang up?)
    4- Can you access your BIOS if booting with only one memory stick? If so, this is only for testing purposes, set your memory as 2.5,3,3,8, and 2T and add 0.05 volts to both your CPU and memory recommended voltages. Save, exit, and then shut down your system. Re-install the second stick of RAM in a proper dual channel slot. Re-boot and see what happens. If successful posting and booting in dual channel with this BIOS config go back to your BIOS and tighten your board and memory timings one at a time until you ID the perfect BIOS config for your CPU and RAM. Do the same with your CPU & RAM voltages.
    AMD CPUs encompass their own memory control devices. There might just be enough variance between your older & newer AMD chips to reject dual configuration. If this is the case you may be able to correct it by using step for above. If this does not work, you sould borrow some suitable and proven dual channel memory sticks from a friend to see if the will work in your rig as dual channel?
    Just keep on trucking & you'll solve it

  • Is it possible to connect my mid 2010 Macbook Pro with my 21.5" iMac 11,2 so that I can work with dual screens?

    Is it possible to connect my mid 2010 Macbook Pro with my 21.5" iMac 11,2 so that I can work with dual screens?

    try xxx - may work
    _may_ work.

  • Dual-DMVPN Design with Dual Hubs on a single router ??

    Hi All,
    In DMVPN, in Dual-DMVPN Design with Dual Hubs , can a single router perform the role of dual hubs.
    The router has two different internet links. It is intended that when one link goes down, spokes shud connect to the same router onto the other active internet connection. Is this possible ?

    Since no one has answered yet, I'll give you the practical answer.
    You'll have issues with IPSec and static routing. "DMVPN" itself probably wouldn't have an issue, but it would depend on IPSec and routing to work.
    It is easier, by far, to put in a second router. And when you factor in your time to try to make it work (and it may not work), the second router is less expensive.
    Rob

  • Use of business partner functionality in combination with dual control

    Is there a generally agreed upon procedure to use the business partner functionality in combination with dual control? The problem is that when you block a business partner, the customer/ vendor master data aren't blocked automatically. You can then still use them in transactions, which leads to problems.
    So is there a way to make this work or a procedure to do this?
    Niels Vanwingh

    Thanks Masa,
    I did notice the 'Add external supplier from' in create supplier or bidder option. However there is a small catch and your experience may help.
    Let me explain the requirement and scenario here in SRM 7.
    We are implementing the Registration of Supplier scenario; both ROS and SRM are in same client. When a potential supplier registers themselves in the registration system, a BP number is created (an Internal number range is defined for this). After accepting the potential supplier in pre-select screen the purchaser has two options to transfer the potential supplier from the ROS system to SRM
    Option 1: He can select the accepted potential supplier from the supplier directory option and transfer the business partner to SRM. In this case the business partner number of the potential supplier is retained in SRM and a business partner with supplier and bidder tag is created. However the purchaser does not have any option to select which type of business partner he would like to create like supplier or bidder.
    Option 2: Purchase can go to create supplier or bidder option and choose the u2018Add external supplier formu2019 from the ROS system and create the business partner. The ROS business partner details are copied to the create supplier screen, but the purchaser have to provide an external business partner number for the supplier. This is because we have defined external number range for business partner for the vendors that are replicated from ERP to SRM.
    Objective is the ROS business partner should be retained in SRM with option to create as supplier and bidder and then manually create ERP supplier with same SRM BP number and map against SRM supplier.
    Is there any way we can achieve this?
    In SRM 5.5 with Manage business partner functionality we could achieve as system give us the option which business partner type we would like to create as well as retains the ROS BP number in SRM.
    Regards
    Sandeep

  • New IMac 27"with dual internal hard drives

    How do I manage Data on my new IMac 27"with dual internal hard drives?  I have just migrated my data to my new computer.  Since I've done it from a TM backup, it all went to the Analog HD. Ressearching online I've figured I could re-run Migrating assistant and replace different data between the SSD and the Analog.  My problem now is: I want to keep my Music Library (iTunes), my Aperture Library and my documents on the analog, and use the SSD for System, Users and Apps.  Aperture, is easy, because both Aperture and iPhoto can find their way, bt iTunes and My documents are a issue.  Can Anyone help me?

    Install OS X on the SSD:
    Install or Reinstall Lion/Mountain Lion from Scratch
    Be sure you backup your files to an external drive or second internal drive because the following procedure will remove everything from the hard drive.
    Boot to the Recovery HD:
    Restart the computer and after the chime press and hold down the COMMAND and R keys until the menu screen appears. Alternatively, restart the computer and after the chime press and hold down the OPTION key until the boot manager screen appears. Select the Recovery HD and click on the downward pointing arrow button.
    Erase the hard drive:
      1. Select Disk Utility from the main menu and click on the Continue button.
      2. After DU loads select your SSD volume (usually Macintosh HD) from the left side list. Click on
          the Erase tab in the DU main window.
      3. Set the format type to Mac OS Extended (Journaled.) Optionally, click on the Security button and set the Zero
            Data option to one-pass. Click on the Erase button and wait until the process has completed.
      4. Quit DU and return to the main menu.
    Reinstall Lion: Select Reinstall Lion/Mountain Lion and click on the Install button. Be sure to change the target disk to your SSD.
    Note: You will need an active Internet connection. I suggest using Ethernet if possible because it is three times faster than wireless.
    After you boot from the SSD open Users & Groups preferences. Click on the lock and authenticate. CTRL- or RIGHT-click on the user account and select Advanced Options. You will see a Home Dir: field with a Browse button on the right. Click on the button. Navigate to the HDD's Users folder. Select your account folder then click on the Open/Choose button. You must restart immediately.
    Upon the restart your SSD system will now be using your actual Home folder located on the HDD. You can then go about installing your applications or copying them from the HDD to the Applications folder on the SSD (and also from the Utilities folder on the HDD to the one on the SSD.) You will likely need to do some transfers of the Applications Support and Preferences folders found in the main Library folder.

  • Can't get windows 8.1 with dual boot for fedora (linux) . system is UEFI .

    Can't get  windows 8.1 with  dual boot for fedora (linux) . system is UEFI .

    Hi,
    Any update here?
    We may seek help at Fedora forum as Milos suggested, if convenient we could share the related thread link here for reference.
    In addition, please also check the information in the similar thread:
    Dual Boot Windows 8 and Linux?
    Best regards
    Michael Shao
    TechNet Community Support

  • Receiving multiple files with dual extension using file adapter

    Hi,
    The scenario where I am implementing requires multiple files of different names to be picked(ABC.txt) and dropped at destination(ABC.txt.pgp) up by my File Sender and Receiver adapters.  Any idea on about how the configuration for receiving multiple files with dual extension for receiver adapter is to be done?
    Note:- currently, The scenario is working fine without dual extension. i.e Its picking all files which starts with ABC and creating at destination as it is. even I configured as ABC.txt.pgp, but its not creating the second extension.
    Thanks in Advance
    Manmadha

    Hi,
    Try to concatenate '.pgp ' to the source file name to create the target file name for the receiver file adapter, by accessing the Adapter Specific Attributes using Java user defined function. This might work.
    Reference links:
    <a href="http://help.sap.com/saphelp_nw04/helpdata/en/43/03612cdecc6e76e10000000a422035/frameset.htm">SAP Help - Accessing Adapter Specific Attributes</a>
    <a href="/people/michal.krawczyk2/blog/2005/11/10/xi-the-same-filename-from-a-sender-to-a-receiver-file-adapter--sp14 - XI: The same filename from a sender to a receiver file adapter - SP14</a>
    Regards,
    S.Santhosh Kumar

  • Is it possible to config H-REAP/REAP and CAPWAP in Autonomous mode with a WLC?

    I'm going to deploying all new AP as Remote-Edge AP and they will be shipped straight to site.  With a pool of WLCs deployed in central DC locations.  I would like to get local staff to deploy a basic CLI discovery script for the APs.  However, i thought LAPs don't have CLI???
    I'm thinking I must use a Lightweight AP with the WLC to use Remote-Edge AP functionality - However, I'm not sure... the configuration example at the bottom doesn't state whether it an Autonomous AP or a Lightweight one.  
    http://www.cisco.com/en/US/products/ps6087/products_tech_note09186a0080736123.shtml
    H-REAP Controller Discovery using CLI commands
    H REAPs will most commonly discover upstream controllers via DHCP option 43 or DNS resolution. Without either of these methods available, it may be desirable to provide detailed instructions to administrators at remote sites so that each H REAP may be configured with the IP address of the controllers to which they should connect. Optionally, H REAP IP addressing may be set manually as well (if DHCP is either not available or not desired).
    This example details how an H REAP's IP address, hostname, and controller IP address may be set through the console port of the access point.
    AP_CLI#capwap ap hostname ap1130ap1130#capwap ap ip address 10.10.10.51 255.255.255.0ap1130#capwap ap ip default-gateway 10.10.10.1ap1130#capwap ap controller ip address 172.17.2.172
    Could anyone help?
    Cheers
    Adrian.

    Hi Adrian,
    Further down in the doc you linked;
    H-REAP Controller Discovery using CLI commands
    H REAPs will most commonly discover upstream controllers via DHCP       option 43 or DNS resolution. Without either of these methods available, it may       be desirable to provide detailed instructions to administrators at remote sites       so that each H REAP may be configured with the IP address of the controllers to       which they should connect. Optionally, H REAP IP addressing may be set manually       as well (if DHCP is either not available or not desired).
    This example details how an H REAP's IP address, hostname, and       controller IP address may be set through the console port of the access       point.
    AP_CLI#capwap ap hostname ap1130
    ap1130#capwap ap ip address 10.10.10.51 255.255.255.0
    ap1130#capwap ap ip default-gateway 10.10.10.1
    ap1130#capwap ap controller ip address 172.17.2.172
    Note: Access points must run the LWAPP-enabled IOS® Recovery Image Cisco           IOS Software Release 12.3(11)JX1 or later, in order to support these CLI           commands out of the box. Access points with the SKU prefix of LAP (for example,           AIR-LAP-1131AG-A-K9), shipped on or after June 13, 2006 run Cisco IOS Software           Release 12.3(11)JX1 or later. These commands are available to any access point           that ships from the manufacturer running this code level, has the code upgraded           manually to this level, or is upgraded automatically by connecting to a           controller running version 6.0 or later.
    These configuration commands are only accepted when the access point is       in Standalone mode.
    Cheers!
    Rob

  • How to use Real time execution trace toolkit with Dual-core processor??

    hi there
    the situation as follows:
    i have a computer (PC and Laptop) types with Dual-core processors, and am trying to do simulation using Multi-core technology and based on different simulation scenarios...starting from sequantial processing,.......Piple lining processing strategy. so that i can differentiate the time delay between those types of processing based on (Using 1 processor then dual-core processor Computers)
    my question is: As i read through Ni's white papers i saw many notes refer to Real-time execution trace toolkit to investigate the (processing-time , etc) of multi-core processors in processing diffenent algorithms. My algorithms are to be run on 1 computer with dual-core processor BUT, not in real time environments, that is ( No hardware to be connected to my pc) only algorithms running on my pc....
    So, is it possible to use Real time execution trace toolkit  or anyother tools in LabVIEW to show processing-delays and/or anyother timing critical issues without using my application for  real- time hardware.???
    in other words: how to use Real time execution trace toolkit  in non-hardware and/or real-time scenarios???
    please help me in this.
    Any suggestion, comments, feedback.....is absolutely highly appreciated
    thanks a lot in advance
    Labview Lover

    Hey,
    The Realtime Execution Trace Toolkit only works for NI RT Targets.
    But you can use the Desktop Execution Trace Toolkit, just search for it under ni.com.
    Christian

  • H67MA-E45 doesn't start with dual memory channel

    I have just bought an H67MA-E45 motherboard and a brand  new intel i5-2300 processor.
    The pc works fine with a DDR3 1333 memory module on slot DIMM1 (as suggested in the manual),
    but does not seem to work with dual memory channel at all.
    When I install two same memory modules on DIMM1 and DIMM3 (dual channel configuration), I get the following problem: When I power on the computer, it turns on and instantly turns off. Then it powers on again on its own, but does nothing else. I get no beep error codes and the display doesn't show anything.
    I use he on-board display adapter and I have only a sata II hard disk connected, nothing else.
    Any suggestion what the problem might be?
    Is there a way to check if there is a problem with the second memory channel?
    PC details
    Intel(R) Core(TM) I5-2300 CPU@280 GHz
    MSI H67MA-E45 (ms-7678, Lga1155),  Click BIOS, E7678IMS V1.2
    KINGSTON KVR1333D3N9K2/4G DDR3 4GB (2X2GB) PC10666 1333MHZ
    Intel HD Graphics (on board display adapter)
    Seagate Baracuda 7200.9 ST3160811AS 160 GB SATA 2.0
    Windows 7 Ultimate 32 bit
    FSP AX500-A Blue Storm, +3.3V~30 A  +5~28A  +12~15A

    My computer is now working only on one channel memory.
    Every time I power the computer on, I get three short beeps, the third one is of slightly different tone. However, the manual does not have the beep codes written down, nor can I find them somewhere for the EFI BIOS (E7678IMS V1.2). Is there any link for the beep codes?
    I tried mounting a single memory slot (KINGSTON KVR1333D3N9K2/2G DDR3 (1X2GB) PC10666 1333MHZ ) on DIMM 3 slot, for the second channel to work on its own. When I powered the computer on, I got the same problem, as if both slots DIMM 1 and DIMM 3 were populated. The mainboard turned on (without any beep code or display on screen) only to instantly turn off. Every while (about every four seconds) it tries to power on again on its own, without any intervention, but instantly turn off again. It may manage to stay turned on at one of the following iterations, without giving any beep code, displaying or loading anything.

  • Looking for dual wireless rechargeable headphone system with dual docks

    I'm looking for a pretty specific product, and was wondering if anyone knows of a product that'll fit the bill.
    I want a wireless dual headphone system with a charging dock for each headset. Transmitter should accept line level signal from dual RCA plugs. I'd prefer a 900mhz transmitter, but IR is acceptable. Either the system should come with two headsets or it should be a system with a transmitter/headset with the option to add a charging dock and an additional heaset.
    My old system was a Sony which is on its last legs, and I found a replacement from another manufacturer with dual headsets but it lacks charging docks - you have to plug the heaset into the transmitter and both heasets can't be charged at once. Also, the manufacturer says not to charge a headset for more than 24 hours or you can damage the battery.
    Anyone know if Sony or someone else makes what I want?
    Solved!
    Go to Solution.

    Hi Verne,
    Sony does not have manufacture dual Wireless Headphones. You can perform an Internet search and check for any third party dual headphones.
    If my post answers your question, please mark it as an "Accepted Solution."

Maybe you are looking for

  • How to avoid server busy dialog in iac

    Hi, I am a beginner in IAC. I am executing a plug-in throung an mfc based IAC dialog box. But when my plug-in takes little longer time to execute a pdf, then I am getting a server busy dialog, asking swith to/retry option. Can you please let me know

  • G/l accounts for pricing conditions in invoice

    Hi, I have 2 conditions, are defined exactly the same in customizing (accruals flag is on). In the invoice, if i select one condition and go into condition details i see a g/l account and a provision acc and Accruals code. If i go to the other condit

  • 'authentication control-direction in' in authentication CLOSED mode

    Switch: 4510R+E, running a DEV version based off 3.6.0 ISE: 1.2.0.899 patch 7 Hi, I have been working on a weird issue where some of my clients would randomly drop their IP address and the only way I could get it back was to move their port to authen

  • Zen Touch problems...HELP, plea

    I got my Zen Touch yesterday and charged it for a couple of hours and then downloaded some songs on it. Then tonight I turned it off and about an hour later went to turn it on and the blue power button turned on, but the screen did not? Does anyone k

  • Front Row movie trailers internet connection

    Hello, I have search everywhere and I haven't found a solution to my problem. When I open Front Row to watch movie trailers online, it tells me I'm not connected to the internet. But, I am connected to the internet ! In many discussions (and it also