Samsung hard drive problems with mid 2009 Macbook Pro

Arghh, this is driving me mad. 
I'd like to know if anyone has installed a Samsung HM641JI SATA II hard drive into a mid 2009 Macbook Pro (mine is a 2.8Ghz) and, if so, how they managed it. The drive is 640GB. These are the steps I've taken:
1. Swap out the stock drive for the Samsung
2. Boot from a USB drive which contains a mirror of my system
3. When the system identified the new disk, I formatted it with 2 partitions (GUID table, HFS journaled)
4. Reboot
5. System is very slow. Boots from USB but can't use keyboard to login
6. Switch off and try again
7. Remove Samsung drive
8. Reboot from USB (works perfectly)
9. Downgrade firmware to 1.6
10. Replace samsung drive and try again
11. System boots from USB
12. Verify that drive is running at 1.5Ghz
13. Disk utility and system profiler both crash
14. Disk unmounts by itself and other random weirdness
15. Remove Samsung drive
I've read endless reports about the firmware in this model of Macbook Pro and its issues with SATA II but struggling to find anything current and specific. Two questions:
a. Is there anythign I can do to get this drive to play nicely?
b. What drive should I get if the answer to a is no?
As a bit of background.. my system began playing up last week with lots of spinning beach balls resulting in forced switch offs. Booting from a mirror on a USB drive works perfectly so I concluded that the drive was on its way out. A drive test utility confirmed this. I'm now wondering if it really was the drive or the cable or the logic board.
Any advice appreciated.
Cheers
//A

I'm coming around to the idea that this might be a problem with the SATA cable rather than the drive.
I currently have the stock drive (Hitachi) back in the macbook. It mounted for a while and was then ejected when I tried writing data to it. System profiler reports that "There was an error while scanning for Serial-ATA devices."
I was able to mount the same drive in a USB enclosure this afternoon without any problems. Right now, I seem to be having issues with both the Samsung drive and the Hitachi drive - I wasn't suspicious of thr latter because I thought it was failing.
I found one or two accounts of other people having similar problems that were resolved with a new sata cable.
How does a cable fail? Could this be my problem?
Cheers
//A

Similar Messages

  • Problem with mid-2009 MacBook Pro 13" hard drives

    In May of this year I upgraded my stock hard drive to a 500GB Hitachi from the stock 160. About 5 days ago the computer froze and hung gor several minutes. Mouse still moved but no response from the OS. Forced a restart after several minutes. The computer rebooted, but showed no hard drive. Install DVD (Snow Leopard) doesn't detect hard drive, neither does disk utility. I put the old hard drive back in, everything is fine. The OS finds updates available, updates to 10.6.4. Tonight, the same precise thing happens on the old drive. No disk showing in the installer or disk utility.
    Any suggestions?

    Run the Apple Hardware Test you'll find on one of the DVDs that came with your computer. Swap the drives again and repeat the test, so you'll have results from each drive. Note the exact text of the error message each time, then make a Genius Bar appointment at your nearest Apple Store, or take the machine to an authorized service provider for diagnosis, being sure to take along copies of the error messages.

  • Is there a hard drive limit to mid-2009 MacBook Pro?

    I currently have a 160GB HDD. I know the white MacBooks don't.

    The limit is what you can buy. Right now that's 1 TB for a notebook SATA drive that will fit into your computer model.

  • I am having a problem with my 2009 Macbook Pro

    Hello Everyone,
    I am having a problem with my 2009 Macbook Pro .  A few weeks ago I plugged it into the charger after running it down to reserve battery power. It appeared to be charging, but then all of a sudden my clock and calender reset to year 2000 and then my computer blacked out and went dead. I tried to boot it up but nothing happened (literally nothing).   I have tried 3 different chargers on it, but all I get is a faint green light and even after hours it still won't boot up.   I have tried replacing the battery, but still nothing happens.
    Any Ideas?  I am pretty desperate to get my computer back up and running before school finals.

    You may have to see if an authorized Apple service specialist can check over
    the charging system (magsafe dc-in board, power adapter, and MacBook/Pro)
    and test or run a diagnostic on it, to be sure there is no damage or failed parts.
    When you attached the adapter to charge the computer, after it said it was going
    to reserve power, did you shut down open applications and stop using the MB/Pro?
    That would've been the thing to do, since the margin of run-time near the bottom
    of the power cycle can be wrong by the gauge estimate, it can just quit.
    While I have not researched your year/model/series in detail, I do know some
    models of Apple portable computers have a small battery or capacitor on the
    logic board, separate from the main power battery; it may need replacement.
    A service provider w/ Apple training & parts would be a likely resource to fix it.
    Good luck & happy computing!

  • Mini Displayport to DVI Adapter Problem on Mid-2009 Macbook Pro

    I have a new mid-2009 Macbook Pro hooked up to a 20" Samsung 2033sw LCD with a native 1600x900 resolution using a mini Displayport to DVI adapter that I bought off of EBay. No matter what I've tried I can't get anything to display on the external Samsung LCD higher than 1024x768. I tried switching between GPU's and that made no difference. Any ideas.?

    Michael, thanks for the reply;
    When you open System Preferences/Displays does a second preference panel open up OK on the Samsung ?
    Yes, but I can't see it unless I select 'gather displays'. Then it appears on the MBP LCD, and showing the correct resolution - 1600x900.
    Is there an Options Tab visible under which you can check 'Overscan' ?
    None that I can find. Only display and color tabs.
    Is the Refresh Rate set to 60.0 Hertz
    Yes, that is what it shows in Refresh Rate.
    I also pulled out an older LG LCD that is fairly generic, .e.g. it has DVI in at 1280x1024. Same problem on that LCD ... nothing higher than 1024x768, but this time at 1280x1024 I get major noise and screen distortion. The displayed image is jumping all over the place, but at least there is something displayed.

  • Lion login screen problems on Mid 2009 MacBook Pro

    After upgrading my wife's Mid 2009 MacBook Pro from Snow Leopard to Lion we are seeing weird behavior on the login screen after the computer wakes from sleep mode.
    The screen is only partially drawn (usually the top left 1/4 of the screen), and the grey background is shown instead of her desktop background picture. When you move the mouse around on the screen, it repaints blocks on the screen where the pointer has been.
    This only seems to happen when the machine sleeps for a long period of time, e.g., overnight. When it just sleeps for a little while we don't see the issue.
    When searching the forums for anyone else with the problem, several folks said that there was an issue with the video drivers for the 9400M card and recommended switching to the 9600M GT, but her machine only has the 9400M in it.
    All other aspects of the system work fine.
    Anyone else seeing this? Any clues?

    Surprised there hasn't been anyone else experiencing this issue.
    I have seen this on 2 new MBP 2.3mhz i5's with the Intel HD 3000 384mb graphics, Lion 10.7.3 & 10.7.4.
    Also with the latest Lion firmware for the late 2011 MBP's that addresses compatibility and stability issues.
    Hopefully there is a fix soon because the painting on my locked screen to login is getting annoying

  • Are any of these internal hard drives compatible with 13-inch Macbook Pro (Mid - 2012) model?

    1. http://www.flipkart.com/wd-scorpio-blue-500-gb-laptop-internal-hard-drive/p/itmd nymt3kzmzqxg?pid=IHDD5KD6KAV9WDSE&otracker=from-search&srno=t_16&query=Internal+ Hard+drive+mac&ref=101f421a-b4c1-42fe-a16d-b8d767bcba76
    or
    2. http://www.flipkart.com/toshiba-500-gb-desktop-internal-hard-drive-dt01aca050/p/ itmdcvv2csptdmbs?pid=IHDDCVQGQYZGZ6XK&otracker=from-search&srno=t_6&query=intern al+hard+drive+sata&ref=be9ff117-1adc-4026-8326-0f2da6304157
    Please check and tell me if the specifications of the above two internal hardrives suit for my Macbook Pro 13 inch Mid - 2012 model..
    This is the first time my internal hard drive needs replacement. I'm new to this! So please choose between these two! Thanks for your help :-)

    The scond one is a desktop drive. It will not fit, physically.
    Check this article, It has links to drives that will work in the MBP.
    http://www.macinstruct.com/node/130

  • Can I replace the hard drive on a mid 2012 MacBook Pro?

    I just bought a new MacBook Pro. I had a 2010 MBP and kept the hard drive (Hitachi 500gb 7200 rpm) from that computer. It ws running 10.7 and worked fine. It still boots up perfectly on my MacPro so I know it works.
    I tried to boot the new MacBook Pro using the old drive but I get a circle with a line through it. I have tried to boot using Firewire and even installed it into the new MacBook Pro. I then tried to re-install OS 10.7. I just downloaded it from the App Store for my MacPro so I tried to use it to re-install. It will not work on this new Macbook Pro. I had to download a version specific to this computer (using the "recover" disk). I takes 1.5 hours to download and then it still didn't work. When the computer reboots after the download and restarts I get the same **** circle with a line through it. The new "manual" is a joke. There is no reference to upgrading drives or memory. Did Apple decide to make their new laptops inaccessible to the owner? I can't find any info online and at the Apple store today they told me they knew of no reason that the drive wouldn't work.
    Anyone else have any thoughts?

    Have you considered Migration Assistant?
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT4889
    From Mac HELP:
    Transferring information using Migration Assistant
    You can use Migration Assistant to transfer important information, such as user accounts, applications, network and computer settings, and files, from one Mac computer to another. You can also transfer information to a Mac from an external disk. Your information can be transferred using a FireWire cable or over a wired or wireless network.
    NOTE:If you’re transferring information over a wired or wireless network, make sure your computers are connected to the same network.
    To transfer information from a Mac:
    Open Migration Assistant (located in the Utilities folder in the Applications folder), and then follow the onscreen instructions.
    When you’re asked how you want to transfer your information, select the “From another Mac” button, and then select the method by which you want to transfer.
    To transfer files using a FireWire cable connected to your computers, click Use FireWire. Then, follow the onscreen instructions to restart your other Mac while holding down the T key.
    To transfer files using a network, click Use Network. Then, follow the onscreen instructions to open Migration Assistant on your other computer. When you’re asked how you want to transfer your information, select the “To another Mac” button.
    To transfer information to a Mac:
    Open Migration Assistant (located in the Utilities folder in the Applications folder), and then follow the onscreen instructions.
    When you’re asked how you want to transfer your information, select the “To another Mac” button.
    On the other computer, open Migration Assistant, and then follow the onscreen instructions. When you’re asked how you want to transfer your information, select the “From another Mac” button.
    Ciao.

  • Why does the hard drive keep crashing on 2009 MacBook Pro?

    We are now on the third hard drive, the second in 5 months.  The problem started after I dropped book on it, but no repairmen have suggested that has anything to do with it.

    drop your books on it and you can crash your armature heads in the HD, ....HD are fragile.
    I assume the first one died of age.....second from the book drop.......and the third? 
    endlightend 
    Hard drives don't fail often, but they do occasionally
    They fail, and often, and new ones fail a LOT more than older ones (sounds silly, but logical)
    Hard Drive Warning (all makes and models)
    Ironically but logical, new hard drives are far more fragile than one that has been working for several months or a couple years. So beware in your thinking that a new hard drive translates into “extremely reliable”!
    Hard drives suffer from high rates of what has been termed "infant mortality". Essentially this means new drives are highly prone to failing in the first few months of usage. This is because of very minor manufacturing defects or HD platter balancing, or head and armature geometry being less than perfect; and this is not immediately obvious and can quickly manifest itself once the drive is put to work.
    Hard drives that survive the first few months of use without failing are likely to remain healthy for a number of years.
    Generally HD are highly prone to death or corruption for a few months, then work fine for a few years, then spike in mortality starting at 3-4 years and certainly should be considered end-of-life at 5-7+ years.
    The implication of this is that you should not trust a new hard drive completely (really never completely!) until it has been working perfectly for several months.
    Given the second law of thermodynamics, any and all current mfg. HD will, under perfect storage conditions tend themselves to depolarization and a point will be reached, even if the HD mechanism is perfect, that the ferromagnetic read/write surface of the platter inside the HD will entropy to the point of no return for data extraction. HD life varies, but barring mechanical failure, 3-8 years typically.

  • Will a Seragate 500 GB SATA 7200RPM Hard Drive work in my 2009 Macbook Pro?

    ?

    Yes, get a Toshiba (made by Hitachi) or Hitachi 1TB HD,    a 1TB drive is only about $70 now even in retail. you CANNOT INSTALL a 1.5 TB drive, because thickness is 12.5mm thick
    A macbook CANNOT accept anything thicker than a 9.5mm HD. (=1TB max)
    7mm = 500GB max
    9.5mm  = 500GB or 1TB
    12.5mm  = 1.5TB
    15.2mm  = 2TB

  • My friends hard drive failed on his 2009 macbook pro and he bought a new hard drive. we installed the hard drive and now all we get is white screen.

    the macbook will not boot to the boot disc, or into startup disk control menu. is there anything else possible that we can do? we are slightly experiencvecd when it comes to these types of repairs. but this is baffling us.

    We have tried this and it still goes to the white screen. One time when we were trying to boot from the disc (by holding "c" directly after the boot sound) we got a folder icon with a question mark in it. But it will not boot from the boot disk or go to the boot menu when you hold the option key upon boot.

  • Having hard drive problems with 2011 macbook pro

    Hey all,
    I am having some hard drive issues with a 2011 Macbook Pro running OS X Mavericks.
    How it happened: I was browsing the web when suddenly I got the spinny-wheel-of-death.  The spinny wheel of death stuck around for much longer than usual, and eventually my computer wouldn't even respond to mouse input (the mouse wouldn't move).  Nothing worked, so I did a hard reset of my computer.  When I rebooted the machine, it took me into "Recovery Disk Mode".
    Here are the diagnostics that I've done: In "Recovery Disk Mode", I have the option to use the Disk Utility, which I have done.  My main volume, called "Macintosh HD" is grayed out - and not mountable.  When I run "first aid" on it, it is not able to verify the disk because of an "Invalid B-tree node size".  It then tells me to repair the disk.  I have tried repairing the disk, but it fails - and that is not entirely unexpected because all of the forum posts that I have read up until now say that Disk Utility cannot repair this specific type of error.
    3rd party software I have tried: Based on the forum posts that I have read, Disk Warrior is especially capable at fixing this kind of error, so I went to my local computer shop, purchased the software, and booted into it.  Disk Warrior did not recognize my drive, and did not even show it in the list of available options.
    Other things I have tried: I purchased a Seagate external drive, and I tried to use Disk Utility to copy the contents from my MBP's hard drive over to the external drive, but when I do so, "Disk Utility" tells me that "Recovery partition restores can only be done on GPT partition maps."  I have also had it give me another error message where it says it "cannot verify source - error 254". 
    Additionally, I have seen around the internet that many people try using "fsck" to fix this issue, but I haven't been able to find a good explanation of the proper steps when using "fsck", nor how to specify to the "fsck" program that I want it to fix my "Macintosh HD" volume.  I've opened up the terminal, and gone into the "/dev/" folder, but I don't know which item in that folder, or any other folder, would properly lead down the path to my "Macintosh HD" volume.  Also, the man pages seem to be of little help here.
    One option I would like to try, but I have not been able to, is to try putting my MBP into Target Disk Mode, and see if my desktop machine (a Dell) can see it.  The problem here is that my Dell only has USB ports - no Firewire, and obviously no Thunderbolt ports.  I would need to find a way to plug my MBP into my Dell while it is in Target Disk Mode, but from what I can tell, that's impossible if I don't have a Firewire or Thunderbolt port on my Dell.
    So, now having explained everything I have tried, can y'all give me any advice on how I can recover my drive without completely repartitioning it?  Although most of my important data and files are located on cloud services, there are definitely some files on the drive that I don't have backed up, and I would like to recover the drive without losing those files.  What suggestions can you give me?  Thanks!

    Yes, BUT...
    ... there are many problems that are really easy to eliminate by replacing the Hard drive, including ones that have nothing to do with actual Drive Hardware failure. These include corrupted install of Mac OS X, its EFI partition, clobbered partition tables, or the appearance of Bad Blocks in a critical area.
    Any of these problems can sometimes be eliminated by re-initializing the entire drive and writing Zeroes, and re-installing from scratch. The trouble is, this process takes hours to complete, and is not guaranteed to be successful -- you may still need a new drive after all that effort.
    I learned from my Plumber that consumers have no appetite for solutions that might work, and detest return visits for any related problems whatsoever. You or your friend may have had your drive replaced, not because it actually failed, but because the situation was troublesome, and the provider thought you would not tolerate anything less than a crisp, complete fix on the first attempt. And based on the cost of technician time, it may have even been cheaper that way.

  • New problem with display on Macbook Pro retina (Samsung panel)

    Hello All,
    I am a very new people on your forum but a few weeks ago i bought a new macbook pro retina with samsung panel.
    I haven't ghosting effect on my macbook but i have a new and really bad problem.
    I try to found a some information on Russians forums but nobody can help me with it.
    I can see an artifacts in the form of flashing pixels on all display.
    It occurs in 20-30 minutes after the start of work.
    Today i try to test it on game Dirt 2 and i can see defects after 2 minutes after start. So i think it can be reason with Geforce 650 but when i back to desktop and use HD 4000 i still see a problem.
    This is best seen on a black screen with high backlight.
    When i try to connect TV via HDMI i can't see any problem in my TV.
    So i really don't know what could be the reason.
    I attached the video with issue to video hosting
    http://vimple.ru/579f880e8b7045e09f8fc5bc097c5e2b
    Also i have a many software problem like Crashing safari and iTunes. It can be a few times per day.
    I really disappointed with my new Macbook.
    I haven't any problem with old 2009 Macbook pro with Snow Leopard but Mountain Lion is not working well.

    Option 1
    Back Up and try rebuild the library: hold down the command and option (or alt) keys while launching iPhoto. Use the resulting dialogue to rebuild. Choose to Rebuild iPhoto Library Database from automatic backup.
    If that fails:
    Option 2
    Download iPhoto Library Manager and use its rebuild function. This will create a new library based on data in the albumdata.xml file. Not everything will be brought over - no slideshows, books or calendars, for instance - but it should get all your albums and keywords back.
    Because this process creates an entirely new library and leaves your old one untouched, it is non-destructive, and if you're not happy with the results you can simply return to your old one. .
    Regards
    TD

  • My mid-2009 MacBook Pro's hard drive is near death. I want to install a new SSD and work from scratch. Please help.

    Recently, my mid-2009 MacBook Pro has been crashing when I close the screen ("it's having a problem recognizing when the screen is closed/open and deciding what to do, error overload etc.").  It wasn't an SMC issue so I took it to an Apple Store, ran some tests, and decided my hard-drive is failing.
    Not wanting to spend an insane amount of money on some "official apple hard-drive," I want to install a new 256GB SSD instead.  Hoping to squeeze as much life out of this computer as possible (in January I upgraded from 4 GB RAM to 8 GB), I would like to try and start from scratch, i.e. back-up important folders, music, photos etc. and only take that to the new hard-drive.  If someone could explain all the steps I need to take to safely complete this task (or point me in the direction of a guide) I'd appreciate it.
    Potentially Important info:
         Model:                mid-2009 13'' MacBook Pro
         Processor:          2.53 GHz Intel Core 2 Duo
         Memory:             4 GB 1067 MHz DDR3
         Software:            OS X 10.8.4
    Some additional questions I have...
         Should I be concerned with making a fully bootable back-up (not sure what that is called) as well?  If so, what program should I use to create it?
         How much more life should I try and push out of this computer?  I'm an engineering student and really only use it for web-surfing, music, and
              word-processing.  The batter was replaced in March, the RAM was upgraded to 8 GB in January.  When the battery was swapped, the trackpad went           nuts so that's new too.  Only other issues are a slightly loose audio jack and the left side of the screen being slightly wobbly (hinge is worn I'm told).

    cwgonzalez1192
         Should I be concerned with making a fully bootable back-up (not sure what that is called) as well?  If so, what program should I use to create it?
         How much more life should I try and push out of this computer?  I'm an engineering student and really only use it for web-surfing, music, and
              word-processing.
    Well there is no "official Apple HD / SSD" in any regard, no worries there.
    If as you say youre only using same for surfing and word processing, why the need for a SSD? You would not notice any speed diff. in use on either of those,....in boot times yes, but in word or surfing, not.
    You can push it likely a few more years, for mere surfing and word processing,...many many years.   Up TO the point that any major fixes become unrealistic relative to getting a new(ER) machine.
    Concerned with a boot clone?  yes and no.  Its an ideal immediate recovery, since you cannot boot from Time Machine, ....in case of HD crash, recovery takes seconds from boot, or 20 mins or so from removing old and installing a clone. All the prosumers and pros have at least one updated clone of their prime machines.
    You can do a "fresh install" if you choose, however if your current drive is FINE, why not merely clone it and save yourself some headache?...., but that is your prerogative of course.    Ideally 2 drives, one to backup your data (you need that regardless of installing a new drive for sake of a backup/archive,...ideally 2 actually, not merely one).
    You could clone internal to NEW SSD/HD , ...then offload unnecessary files to an external to free up space and clutter and run off the clone, and this would only take a couple hours......the clone itself takes approx. 40+ mins.
    CLONE Apps :
    Superduper does not clone the recovery partition, but that is NOT necessary if you keep the original HD as a “backup clone”. Most don’t bother with the recovery partition in a clone, however that is your prerogative.
    http://www.shirt-pocket.com/SuperDuper/SuperDuperDescription.html
    (Free superduper APP above)
    CCC App
    http://www.bombich.com/

  • Only Apple Branded Hard Drives Work in My Mid-2009 MacBook Pro

    My Mid-2009 MacBook Pro (actually, my wife's) experienced a hard-drive failure about a year ago.  This was a 500GB 7200RPM drive that came BTO from Apple.
    It's easy enough to replace HD's, so, I did it myself with a Seagate 7200RPM 500GB drive, the same model as the one from Apple, but I got this one from Seagate, not from Apple, so it didn't have the Apple logo (and firmware?) on it.  The drive did not work.  I was able to format the drive using Disk Utility, but when I tried to install Snow Leopard on it, it would fail.  I placed the new drive in my other MBP (early 2008), and installed SL, no problems.  Booted to it just fine.
    I put it back in the 2009 MBP, and it would not boot - it would show the flashing folder with a question mark.  I put the drive in a usb enclosure and the MBP booted from it just fine (well, a little slower because the usb speed, I presume).
    I bought another Seagate and experienced the same problem.  I bought a Hitachi and experienced the same problem.  I took it to an authorized Apple repair facility who told me that the HD was bad (which was obviously false, since all 3 HD's I tried worked just fine in my other computer).
    So, I took it into Apple and gave them the whole story and they ran overnight hardware diagnostics and were unable to find (or fix) a problem.
    So, I played stupid and brought it back again, saying "uh, my hard drive broke, can you fix it?" hoping that they would try to replace the HD and fix the problem or at least diagnose it.
    Well, they put an Apple branded HD back in, and it works just fine.
    Seemingly, that would be problem solved, and life has been fine for the last year.  But, now we bought an OptiBay to ditch the DVD drive and place a 750GB (non-apple) drive in the optical bay.  To my surprise, the non-apple drive works, but, it is pretty slow (we put our iPhoto library on there, and it chokes very badly when you ask it to do anything, such as zoom on a picture, play a video, go to full screen, etc.  It takes about 30 to 45 seconds of SBOD to perform those tasks. 
    I am wondering if there was any way we could have damaged the SATA connector or driver?  Why would only Apple branded drives work in the main HD bay? I don't know if an Apple branded drive would preform better in the optical bay or not.

    I recently saw a similar situation described in another forum and someone directed the OP to look for a jumper on the drive. I raised my eyebrows--that sounded like old PATA technology--but, sure enough, the OP found a jumper, changed it and everything worked. This apparently changed the timing on the drive to match Apple products. I'm leaving town and won't have much time to search myself, but try a forum search for "SATA jumper" and see if something rings a bell.

Maybe you are looking for