Seagate or Toshiba external harddrive?

I have a macbook pro that runs on mac os x 10.7.5. I recently bought a Seagate back up plus external harddrive thinking that it was a portable one as oppossed to the Toshiba Canvio Desktop. However, I just took it out of the box and turns out it also needs a AC power cord. My question now is if I should return it and buy the Toshiba one (considering that it has the same 2TB memory and is 20-30 dollars cheaper). Price wise, I should return it, but my plan is to use the drive as a back up for capture scratches and render files for Final Cut, so I was wondering which one would perform better in an editing situation? Or if should forget those brands and get the Western Digital Elements External Harddrive.
These are the products, specificaly:
http://www.staples.com/Western-Digital-Elements-2TB-External-Hard-Drive/product_ 884865#pr-header-884865
http://www.bestbuy.com/site/Seagate---Backup-Plus-2TB-External-USB-3.0-Hard-Driv e/5597304.p;tab=reviews?id=1218670777856&skuId=5597304#tab=reviews
http://www.staples.com/Toshiba-Canvio-Desktop-2TB-Desktop-USB-30-External-Hard-D rive-Black/product_982534#revs_content

All things considered, I like Seagate drives better than Toshiba and MUCH BETTER than Western Digital.
I've four Seagate drives in my LaCie 2big Thunderbolt drive caddies and haven't had a problem with them. In the past I've had nothing but trouble from Western Digital drives. My favorite drives are Hitachi but I only buy bare drives and I've no idea what they have in the way of externals (altough I do know that they are used in G-Technolgy drives).
I would stay with the Seagate were it me...
Clinton

Similar Messages

  • Maverick does not see External Harddrive

    I had a Seagate external usb3 harddrive connected.  I was working on a video file when suddenly I got a message in the upper right hand corner saying that the external harddrive was incorrectly disconnected or dismounted.  OK.  So, I unplug and then plug the ext. HD back into the usb3 port.  To make the story short, the hd light comes on, I can hear the disk spinning.  But it does not appear in the Finder or desktop.   The only sign on the Mac is by going to the "About This Mac" and to the System Report which lists hardware and software.  Clicking on the USB line, it shows the external HD plugged into one of the usb 3 ports.  The disk info indicates its ID and other data and how much energy it is consuming (it appears it is only using 96 mA from an available 500 mA).  So, it appears that the Mac sees it and can read it and has power enough to run it.
    I then removed the first ext. HD and inserted another Seagate external usb3 harddrive - the Mac doesn't see it either except in the System report.  The external HDs  do not show up in the Disk Utility app.  The only conclusion is that the harddrives are probably OK but the Mac won't mount them anymore.  Most people with unmountable ext. HDs usually see them in the disk utility (greyed out).
    Any ideas.

    Update - I have three Seagate FreeAgent GoFlex external harddrives.  The two that I have connected to my Macbook Pro no longer can be read.  I took the two and connected to another MacBook Pro but it would not read the drivers either.  I took my third drive which I have not connected to my Macbook Pro for several weeks and connected to the other Macbook Pro and it reads it fine.
    I downloaded drivers from Seagate but it didn't help.  I started my computer in safe mode, HD didn't work.  I have another drive containing a duplicate of my internal HD (using Superduper) and booted with the backup drive.  It would not open the two drives.   I'm taking the HD to a friend who has a G5 using an early Mac OS, 6.0.  These two drives contain my video files and I need to retrieve the files.
    Conclusion:  The Maverick on my computer has corrupted the first two Seagate drives.

  • Problem accessing Seagate External Harddrive from iMac and Mac Book Air

    I have a brand new Seagate 2TB external harddrive which I have just used to backup my entire iMac files (photos, videos, etc) via the Time Capsule programme. However I now can't access the files which apparently have been copied onto the Segate. I have now connected the Seagate to my Mac Book Air and it is not even being recognised as an external storage device.
    Is someone able to tell me how I can access the files on the external drive?

    do you mean "time machine" as opposed to "time capsule" the latter is a back up drive in itself.
    before you did your backup was your seagate drive formatted or did you just connect and instruct the mac to back up to the drive.
    if the drive was not formatted then you will need to format the drive using disc utility.

  • My Mac wants to 'initialise' my Seagate external harddrive but it already has saved data on it?

    My Mac wants to 'initialise' my seagate external harddrive but it already has data on it that I want to keep. What can I do to protect existing data?

    The message actually says it can't read it and it provides an opportunity to initialise it.

  • Problems with my Seagate external harddrive

    My Seagate external harddrive is read-only for my new Macbook Air, yet worked fine with my old Macbook Pro. Any suggestions?
    I want to copy some photos onto it, but when I open properties it says I only have permission to read. Do I need to format it, would that work?
    Many regards
    Hanne

    Awhile ago I read about a way to force external drives to use a designated drive letter. Something about a file on the drive that gets read when drive is plugged in?
    Also, check drive letter after plugging in drive but before starting itunes, fix as necessary. I have to do similar due to using my network drive for iTunes. Must always check drive before starting iTunes. It is always same letter but if connection is not established before starting iTunes I get library problem. Simply close iTunes, get connection, restart iTunes has always worked for me.

  • How to connect an external harddrive with firewire 800 to a macbook with firewire 400?

    Hello,
    I just got the external harddrive "Seagate FreeAgent GoFlex USB 3.0 1TB" with a Seagate FreeAgent GoFlex Upgrade Kabel FireWire 800. I have neither a USB 3.0, nor a Firewire 800 on my white macbook (2008). I already know, that it's possible to use USB 3.0 with an USB 2.0 port, but I would like to use it with the firewire to spare the USB port for other devices. My question: Is there an adapter or cable to use the Seagate Firewire 800 with my Firewire 400 port? I don't know, where and what to look for.
    I'm glad for any advice.

    There are many adaptors, try here

  • Moving photos and videos from iPhone, to iPhoto, to external harddrive. Videos come out to be less than 0 seconds. HELP, PLEASE!

    Hi guys! This is my first discussion and I'm not exactly sure what kind of details to put, so I'll just be as detailed as possible. I hope I don't confuse anyone. I really REALLY need help!
    I've got a 16 GB iPhone 4S and always find myself filling up my phone with photos and videos, so I upload both onto my MacBook Pro 2011. Now that my laptop's getting full... I'm uploading all of those backed up photos and videos onto a 500 GB Seagate external harddrive.
    All of my photos open just fine. It's the videos that I'm worried about. All of the videos that I've loaded from last year (2013) are playing well. Anything before 2013 aren't opening properly. I'm opening the video files directly from my external harddrive. It goes:
         1) Opens up QuickTime Player
         2) Shows that it's converting
         3) Shows a frame from the video, but the time says 0:00-0:00.
    I had a LOT of videos from before 2013 and would like to retrieve them if possible. They're no longer on my laptop though. All of the video files are 20 KB - 980 KB and has to convert on quicktime player for me to watch them. Some of the video files I've tried out were from 2013 and 24 KB and opened just fine. I've opened both ~20KB - ~900 KB video files before 2013 and they're all 0:00-0:00 time length. Anyone else having this problem? Thanks!

    I have the same issue.  We've lost all of our older videos including videos of our children and since passed family dog.  I have no idea why this has happened.  I have backed up religiously, but now even the archived photos are 0 seconds.  So frustrated with iPhoto.  This is the second time this awful software mysteriously lost pictures or videos.  Last time it was the birth pictures of my second daughter.  And now this.  Horrible horrible product. 
    Older videos are all now just 0:00:00 in length.  We did not alter these at all!!
    HELP!!

  • What format for my external harddrive?

    Hello,
    I have a 1,5 TB Seagate external harddrive.
    What format and partitiontype shall it be to be used on both Mac and Windows?
    Because right now it only works on my mac and the rest of my family uses Windows so i would like to share my ext. hdd with them aswell..
    Right now it's Mac os Extended Journaled and Apple-partitiontype..
    Help Please :-)

    Not quite sure I understand but here is what Disk Utility Help says about partitioning a disk:
    Partition a Disk
    1. If you’re partitioning an external disk, make sure it’s connected to your computer.
    2. Open Disk Utility.
    3. Select the disk that you want to partition and click Partition.
    4. Choose the number of partitions from the Volume Scheme pop-up menu.
    If you can’t choose the number of partitions, follow the steps for partitioning a startup disk.
    5. Click each partition and type a name for it, choose a format, and type a size.
    You can also drag the divider between the partitions to change their sizes. If a partition’s name has an asterisk beside it, it’s shown larger than its actual size in order to display its name clearly.
    6. Click Options and choose one of the following:
    If you’ll be using the disk on a Windows computer, choose the Master Boot Record partition scheme (also known as “fdisk”).
    If you’ll be using the disk only with Mac computers, choose GUID Partition Table.
    7. Click Apply.

  • Switched from NAS to external harddrive but Itunes is still looking for NAS

    I used to have a NAS (Net attached storage) and i switched to a Seagate 1TB external harddrive, I copied the whole Itunes library, program etc...and it runs but it is 7.6 version so it would not identify my ipod until i updated the software, so i go to update, download the update and go to do the update and I get a error message that it cant locate //nas/disk1 the old destination...I went so far as to delete itunes and Quicktime and redownload itunes 8.1 so i go to install it and it is still looking for //nas/disk1 now i have a folder with 375gb of music and movies and no program to run it.... I try to go into control panel add/delete programs and itunes is still in there so i go to delete and I get a error message that it cant delete it because it cant find //nas/disk1...*** I need help Please someone tell me what i have to do to I was able to delete quicktime but it still shows itunes and it will not let me install itunes...i did a search through the computer and ther are no files for itunes so i do not know why it is still trying to locate it from there....HELP

    Hi,
    The reason that you are getting the ! is because iTunes is still looking for the music on your external hard drive.
    You need to create a new library iTunes: How to open an alternate iTunes Library file or create a new one
    Now turn on iTunes Match and select add this computer. You will now see all your music in the cloud. When you want to add new music, revert to the original library on your external hard drive.
    Jim

  • External Harddrive

    Hi,
    I've got a toshiba external hard drive (USB 3) and i've transferred data from my old laptop and macbook to it and everything was fine. It also works when i plug it into my Samsung TV.
    I bought a brand new macbook pro and when i plug the external hard drive in nothing pops up on my macbook pro, but the light on the hard drive comes on and you can here the hard drive working. I've tried it in my old macbook and that machine still recognises it so i think that rules out the lead connecting the hard drive.
    Would appreciate any help i can get, i've read a few other topics about this subject but i can't find any answers.
    Thanks guys
    Rick

    *by "able", I think Clinton meant "cable," above.
    I've got the right cable. It came with the Seagate drive, and it's marked "SS" on it, for Super Speed.
    I'm a little worried my current 5-hour Time Machine backup is going to corrupt some of the files if there are serious USB3 problems here...
    This is the System Information report on the drive, as listed under USB 3.0 SuperSpeed:
    GoFlex Desk:
      Capacity:          2 TB (2,000,398,933,504 bytes)
      Removable Media:          Yes
      Detachable Drive:          Yes
      BSD Name:          disk2
      Product ID:          0x50a5
      Vendor ID:          0x0bc2  (Seagate LLC)
      Version:           1.00
      Serial Number:          NA0LPEBH
      Speed:          Up to 5 Gb/sec
      Manufacturer:          Seagate
      Location ID:          0x14900000 / 20
      Current Available (mA):          900
      Current Required (mA):          0
      Partition Map Type:          GPT (GUID Partition Table)
      S.M.A.R.T. status:          Not Supported
    I have a call scheduled with Apple tech support tomorrow—I will direct them to this thread.

  • I need an external harddrive for my ipad

    My ipad is running out of harddrive space for my music. I need an compatible external harddrive to store my music. I want to have my music stored on an external harddrive and be able to play it wirelessly on my ipad as needed. I was looking at Seagate Blutooth harddrive, however, I an not sure it will work.

    I have a friend that told me he is using a Seagate external drive and it is working. I did not see any that stating it's compatible with the ipad. My friend he is using Seagate 1TB Backup Plus Slim

  • "A USB device is drawing too much power..." External Harddrive

    My 15" Macbook Pro, OS X, 10.6.8, 2GHz Intel Core i7, 4GB memory keeps booting my 1 TB Seagate external harddrive off because it is drawing too much energy.  It's done this repeatedly for about two weeks, and now it won't appear on the desktop (while it still whirs when I attach it and the LED comes on).  I checked how much energy it's drawing in the System Profiler.  500, then very little after I restarted both machines, and then too much again.  I tried connecting it with an identical harddrive's cable (my housemate has the same model), and it wouldn't register then, either.
    ...I suspect it's the harddrive as opposed to my MBP!  Or I hope it is, and not a problem with my USB ports or anything like that.  I'm surprised because the Seagate is connected to the mains...  But if it is the Mac, how would I go about checking to know if it is?  (My Wacom Bamboo is working fine.)
    Anyone with any ideas, suggestions?  Anything else I need to inform you guys of?

    :-) use your room mate's and do it!
    pretty old drive, is it makeing clicking noises? try re repairting it before you go erasing but I think yoru system is giving you some sound advice. but I would go further in saying it's either too full or too old and is on it's last legs.
    If you are afraid you're going to be loosing some important data that you haven't backed up get DiskWarrior as this has saved me from loosing my hair a few years back when my HDD crashed.
    http://www.alsoft.com/diskwarrior/
    if you do get this, be sure to be picky on the things you keep as it will not always work and it sounds like your hard drive is on it's last legs. Imagine a door slowly closing everytime it spins up.

  • WD External HardDrive Compatibil​ity Question

    Alright, So I bought a 1TB Western Digital External HardDrive Passport. I re-formated it for mac, so it works with my 15" macbook pro. Everything works fine. I'm using the hard drive as a music storage device, since I am a DJ and have a lot of music. I don't want to bog down my computer with it.
    A friend, who has the exact same device, uses it for his windows. When he plugs it in the computer will ask him what he wants to do with the device, and to play his music with his specific program is one of his options. i.e. open to view in folder, run with windows media player etc etc etc
    That is also something that happens with Mac depending on the device you plug in. A window will pop up and ask, what do you want to do. Open with itunes, open with finder, etc etc. 
    What I want to do is use this external hard drive either with itunes or DJAY. By just plugging it into my laptop, and having that box come up and ask if i want to play the music with DJAY or itunes. When I open DJAY and itunes currently it doesnt show my external harddrive as a device. I can certainly drag music from the device to either program, but then that puts it on the computer, and defeats the purpose of having this 100$ harddrive. If someone can help me figure out how to get my macbook pro to view the harddrive as a device, and play the music on it with itunes or DJAY I would GREATLY appreciate it. Thanks!

    The iPad does not support a USB host port, so no external hard drive will be recognized.  Seagate has a new wireless portable hard drive that creates a hotspot for up to 3 devices and is fully compatible with the iPad as external storeage:
    Video of drive in actions:  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DRaVAeYhONc
    Review: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-05-18/portable-​wi-fi-drive-turns-ipad-into-cineplex-rich-jaroslov​...
    Not sure when these will be available in Best Buy.
    If you find my post useful or informative, please click the icon below with the plus sign and star to give kudos. Thank you!

  • Partition External Harddrive and part format Extended Journaled part fat32?

    Hello
    I bought a Toshiba NTFS formatted External Harddrive for the safe keep of my files.
    I want it to make partition into 2, and one part to format Mac Extended (Jounaled), one part to FAT32.
    Is this possible?
    Many thanks.

    Thank you very much.
    Can I have related question?
    Is it possible to make 3 partitions on a harddisk?
    If it is,
    Can I retain NTFS on a partitioned part?
    Or does it have to be entirely formated to Mac readable/wrtitable fotmat?
    I mean if I partision in 3 parts can I format
    part 1 Mac JOurnal
    part 2 FAT32
    part3 to retain NTFS?
    Many many thanks

  • Can anyone recommend a good external harddrive for iTunes backup?

    I would like to backup my files externally. I really dont know too much about this stuff. Can anyone make a suggestion for an external harddrive? Thanks!

    I have an AcomData 120GB, a Western Digital 200GB and a Fantom 250GB external HD. All are working well. LaCie is another fine brand. I usually buy the major brands by price. Expect to pay $0.50 or less per GB (my last ExHD was $90 for 250GB).
    If you are very concerned about longevity, then look at the Seagates as they carry a 5-year warranty (at least on the internal laptop drive that I have purchased).
    See This Link

Maybe you are looking for