Should Apple punt with RAW and/or DNG support ?

It seems that Apple is taking a very detailed approach to profiling cameras before adding support to Aperture. Consequently Aperture may always be later than others apps to add new camera support. Also there will always be legacy or specialty cameras deemed not worth the trouble that don't get added too. I wonder if rather than asking Apple to support every camera made past and present it wouldn't be better to punt and ask for feature changes that make it easier to integrate other RAW developers into an Aperture workflow.
Further for a few of my most valuable images, maybe 1 out of 1000, no matter how good Aperture's RAW conversion I will always want to try other RAW developers to see if they might do slightly better on a top select image. An professional app that wants to host my entire photo archive must logically offer a workflow that supports any camera past or future that I may use even once.
The tools already exist to export a master and develop it with other RAW converters also to manage different master files of the same image using stacks. All that Apple would need to do to make the unsupported camera workflow in Aperture a useable alternative is make a few minor changes to already existing features:
1. In the RAW + JPEG workflow the JPEG is the second class member. You can expose it and have it stacked with the RAW master but you have to manually make it the stack pick. Otherwise when you close the stack you see only the unsupported master file which means nothing. It's not a problem restacking one image and not thinkable with thousands of images. I haven't found a way to get around this with Automator/Applescript. MAYBE: If the JPEG were the first image in the stack then I could still use Aperture for sorting, DAM, keywords, rating, etc. and just process my unsupported images with an external application.
2. I can use Export Master to save out a master file but the process of doing that then reimporting the master file and stacking it with the original is a tedious manual effort. Again Automator/Applescript can help here but more would be needed. MAYBE: If I could duplicate a master file inside a project or stack and if Aperture had an 'Open Master file with external editor" command then it would be easy to have a duplicate master file stored by Aperture that might be used with any other RAW processing application.
3. When I use 'Export Master' now to process some images with ACR or Nikon Capture then I can reimport the TIFF file or JPEG that I create but I can't easily associate them as versions or as externally edited files with their proper masters. MAYBE: There should be a way to link master files with the rendered versions of those files created by external RAW processors.
4. I started my photographic life with film. Most current 'pros' did the same. If I want to have one home for all my photo archive then it has to support film scans of larger sizes and export them to an external editor in something other than Adobe RGB. Automator and Applescript are will make this work in v1.5 but just barely. MAYBE: Give me a way to have my hi-res film scans stored in Aperture and send them to Photoshop without compressing them to Adobe RGB or downsampling to fit Aperture's current filesize (aprox. 250MB) limitation.
I can't imagine having many different databases and apps for unsupported images from a camera I may only use once. If Apple would just streamline and tweak a few features that exist in v1.5 then Aperture could be the home to all my digital images even if some of them had to be developed by another program.
I can't imagine a better workflow than using Aperture with any of it's supported cameras. That shouldn't stop Apple from opening the door for making use of Aperture's great database and DAM features with unsupported cameras too.
Pro Mac 2.66Ghz/8GB/250GB + 1TB RAID 0 wi SoftRAID in bays 2,3/X1900   Mac OS X (10.4.8)   MacBookPro 2.16Ghz/2GB/100GB 7200rpm

Eric: Great, Aperture 3 might be out by spring 2010? That's only 6 months or so from now. [/sarcasm]
I appreciate the pointer to the AI article, but personally I'm more interested in whether Apple is working on adding additional RAW support for Aperture/Mac OS X any time soon, and certainly before Aperture 3 is out. Both Aperture 2 and Lightroom 2.5 are more than capable for my workflow and editing needs.
This week only added to my dismay re: Aperture v. Lightroom update likelihood and frequency; still radio silence from Apple, and Adobe releases a public beta of Lightroom 3, even as Lightroom 2 was released subsequent to Aperture 2 and has had more updates since its initial release than Aperture 2.
Brian, can you elaborate on the DNG conversion process that worked for you? Having tried every possible profile (I believe) in the latest release of the DNG Converter app, I have to say I'm skeptical that there's a setting that works with the GF1. But I'm ready to be pleasantly surprised!

Similar Messages

  • My Apple Earphones with Remote and Mic White For iPhone says: made ​​in vietnam. i want to know if they are OEM?

    My Apple Earphones with Remote and Mic White For iPhone says: made ​​in vietnam right in the cord. i want to know if they are OEM? here my email: [email protected], thanks.

    Accidental damage is not covered under the warranty but if possible to reset the screen without causing additional damage, the Apple Store should do this without charging for it.

  • I partitioned my apple macbook with windows and mistakenly deleted the apple partition, now i want to restore my system fully to apple. please how can i do that

    i partitioned my apple macbook with windows and mistakenly deleted the apple partition, now i want to restore my system fully to apple. please how can i do that

    If your MacBook shipped with an install disc you'll have to use that. If it didn't you should be able to use Internet Recovery OS X: About OS X Recovery
    EXactly which macbook do you have?

  • How do i set up my apple id with itunes and the appstore?

    How do i set up my apple id with itunes and the appstore?

    iTunes 10 for Mac: Set up an Apple ID account for use in the iTunes Store
    http://support.apple.com/kb/PH1726

  • Does the ipod nano come with Apple Earphones with Remote and Mic

    does the ipod nano come with Apple Earphones with Remote and Mic

    Click on the Ipod gray tab at the top of this site.  There you will find all the information you need about the model iPod you wish to purchase. 

  • Using Apple Earphones with Mic and Remote with Ipod Nano (3rd generation)

    Hi, I'm just wondering if there is any way i can make the Ipod Nano(3rd generation) compatible with the Apple Earphones with Mic and Remote. I know on the box it says the earphones are only compatible with a few ipods, like the 4th generation ipod nano. But Is there any program i can download or use to allow the ipod to recognize the earphone remote and mic?
    Thanks a lot.

    I'm quite convinced the answer is no for that Apple mic.
    I do believe recording is possible on the Nano 3G with the right attachment. But I don't think the sound comes through the headphone jack the way they do on the nano 4G and iPhone 3G/touch.
    This review http://www.macworld.com/article/60004/2007/09/3gipodnano.html says it's possible, but when I look at "Belkin, Griffin Technology, and XtremeMac" I don't find much... doesn't sound like they worked very well ... the iKaraoke is compatible

  • Using Apple Earphones with Remote and Mic on my Macbook

    Is it possible to use the remote to control volume on my macbook? I know the mic works but I can't get the remote to. Is it even possible to use the remote?

    I have a unibody Macbook with OSX 10.6.1 and it works with my Apple Earphones with Remote and Mic. However, whenever I plug them in to the Macbook it takes up to 10 seconds for the volume and tracking controls to start working on the earphone remote. Also, if there is music playing in iTunes, the audio drops out for about the same amount of time. The hardware buttons on the Macbook also stop functioning during this time. The same behavior occurs when unplugging the earphones.
    Basically, it seems like the Macbook is extremely slow when adding / removing the earphones as an audio control device.
    Has anyone else noticed anything like this? Thanks!

  • Is anybody using the Canon 1D mark III with RAW and Aperture?

    Hello,
    Is anybody using the Canon 1D mark III with RAW and Aperture?
    JO

    I'm using a 5D with a G5 and having nothing but problems. I have aperture installed on my Powerbook and don't have any problems. Upload fine and everything. But as soon as i try and upload photos on my G5 it's terrible. They preview fine before import.
    but afterwards they're corrupt.
    any help....
    Message was edited by: Kris Shacochis

  • Hello!  I need Apple (!!!) headphones for Ipod Shuffle 3! (only apple earphones with remote and mic!!!) Tell me, what distinguishes the model are presented in black and white boxes? They may differ in features? Can one model is more modern than the other?

    Hello!
    I need Apple (!!!) headphones for Ipod Shuffle 3! (only apple earphones with remote and mic!!!)
    Tell me, what distinguishes the model are presented in black and white boxes? They may differ in features? Can one model is more modern than the other?
    Thanks in advance!

    Hi Fencer1986,
    I apologize, I'm a bit unclear on your request. If you have questions about headphone compatibility for your iPod shuffle 3rd Gen, you may find the following article helpful:
    iPod shuffle (3rd generation): About headphone compatibility
    http://support.apple.com/kb/ht3472
    Regards,
    - Brenden

  • Any solution for Panasonic Raw files and/or DNG support?

    Hi folks - in addition to my Nikon cameras I shoot with a Panasonic LX3 and soon a GF-1 - and so far I haven't had any luck getting any sort of raw files from the panasonics to be read by Aperture. I had thought that with Apple's DNG support that there would be a way to convert the files to DNG and then import, but so far I have had no luck.
    I realize that the GF1 is brand new, but the LX3 is over a year old and supported by all of Apple's competitors. I really don't want to switch to lightroom, but it is getting harder and harder to stick with Aperture.

    Eric: Great, Aperture 3 might be out by spring 2010? That's only 6 months or so from now. [/sarcasm]
    I appreciate the pointer to the AI article, but personally I'm more interested in whether Apple is working on adding additional RAW support for Aperture/Mac OS X any time soon, and certainly before Aperture 3 is out. Both Aperture 2 and Lightroom 2.5 are more than capable for my workflow and editing needs.
    This week only added to my dismay re: Aperture v. Lightroom update likelihood and frequency; still radio silence from Apple, and Adobe releases a public beta of Lightroom 3, even as Lightroom 2 was released subsequent to Aperture 2 and has had more updates since its initial release than Aperture 2.
    Brian, can you elaborate on the DNG conversion process that worked for you? Having tried every possible profile (I believe) in the latest release of the DNG Converter app, I have to say I'm skeptical that there's a setting that works with the GF1. But I'm ready to be pleasantly surprised!

  • Can't sync Apple Mail with Gmail and Yahoo

    Hi all, I really hope you can help. I have e-mail accounts with Gmail and Yahoo, and I'd really like to set either or both of these up in Apple Mail, primarily so that it will be really quick and easy to send people photos from my iPhoto library.
    I've put in the correct info and I've enabled POP and IMAP in my Gmail settings, but when I try and set up it just says "checking connection to server [email protected]" for ages and doesn't acheive anything. When I did somehow manage to set it up briefly, I tried sending a message and it just dissapeared when I pressed send, didn't appear in my sent mail either in Gmail or in Apple Mail, and was not delivered.
    Any ideas would be appreciated. I'm really frustrated that something that should be so simple could be such a pain - setting up e-mail on my iPhone took seconds and works perfectly! Thanks,
    Malinna

    Hi Malinna,
    Did you follow Google's instruction on how to setup Mail.app and GMail?
    http://mail.google.com/support/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answer=81379

  • I have an apple id with verizon and @me and i can't set up family sharing

    i need help setting up family sharing because i have two apple id's  one with verizon and one @me.com  so i already purchased more storage on the cloud with verizon and when i signed in on the desktop to upload my library and set up homesharing i had to do another 9.99/mo plan because that computer only allows me to sign in with @me.com.  I've read that I can't combine them??  So how can I fix this?  Any easy solution?

    Howdy Denise,
    It is not possible to combine Apple IDs. See this article -
    Frequently asked questions about Apple ID - Apple Support
    You can set up Family Sharing using one of your Apple IDs by following the directions in this article -
    iCloud: Family Sharing
    Note in particular that in order to set up Family Sharing you need a Mac computer running Mac OS X 10.10 (Yosemite).
    This article provides a good overview of Family Sharing and what you can do with it -
    Family Sharing - Apple Support
    Thanks for using Apple Support Communities.
    Best,
    Brett L 

  • Apple care with MBP and iphone

    Hi I already have apple care with my mac book pro and wondering if i can add my iphone to it, or do i have to buy more apple care just for the phone ?

    No you cannot add a product to an existing Applecare.
    Applecare covers the product that you purchased.
    You would have to buy Applecare for the iphone

  • How does Apple EarPods with Remote and Mic(MD827ZM/A) work with iPod 3rd Generation

    I have recently bought EarPods With remote and mic (MD827ZM/A) for my old iPod shuffle (3rd generation) Software V 1.1,  capacity 2GB
    but these EarPods doesn't seems like working with my iPod, any possible solution ?

    You can also get an "adapter," that has compatible remote control buttons.  There are several such products, for example
    http://www.amazon.com/iLuv-iEA15wht-Adapter-Earbuds-Headphones/dp/B002RL9WE0
    You can then connect the any standard headphones to the adapter, including Apple EarPods.

  • I just got an eMac G4-1Ghz/256/80/SuperDrive/56k/220v the problem is, it's stuck on theLoading Screen everytime i turn it on it wont go any further it's stuck on the Gray Apple logo with whiteBG and the loading icon that keeps circling any ideas?

    i got this emac from my uncles friend, and they said it's still working so i was likeok lemme see. and when i turned it on i was like "nice it really is working" but right after it went to the loading screen (Gray apple logo with a whiteBG and the loading icon that keeps circling) it wont go any further.. it just stays like that forever.. OMG any ideas???? thanks

    Hello, do you have the Install Discs for it?
    "Try Disk Utility
    1. Insert the Mac OS X Install disc, then restart the computer while holding the C key.
    2. When your computer finishes starting up from the disc, choose Disk Utility from the Installer menu at top of the screen. (In Mac OS X 10.4 or later, you must select your language first.)
    *Important: Do not click Continue in the first screen of the Installer. If you do, you must restart from the disc again to access Disk Utility.*
    3. Click the First Aid tab.
    4. Select your Mac OS X volume.
    5. Click Repair Disk, (not Repair Permissions). Disk Utility checks and repairs the disk."
    http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=106214
    Then try a Safe Boot, (holding Shift key down at bootup), run Disk Utility in Applications>Utilities, then highlight your drive, click on Repair Permissions, reboot when it completes.
    (Safe boot may stay on the gray radian for a long time, let it go, it's trying to repair the Hard Drive.)
    If perchance you can't find your install Disc, at least try it from the Safe Boot part onward.

Maybe you are looking for

  • Reformatting computer- what will happen to iTunes?

    So I have to reformat my hard drive, so I bought an external hard drive and I think I transferred my music to it. I just went through my iTunes and copied and pasted the songs that I don't have on CD onto my external hard drive...will that work? I co

  • Error In Displaying Message When There Is An Attachment

    I am trying to display an error message in SharePoint 2013. I added the following code inside my ItemAdding() event receiver to force it to have error: properties.Status = SPEventReceiverStatus.CancelWithError; properties.ErrorMessage = "test"; It wo

  • Making buttons stay "selected"

    Hi, I can't figure out how to make a movie clip button appear to stay selected. Right now, I have a duplicate button off the stage, and was thinking when one of my nav buttons was clicked, I could make this duplicate button move over the actual butto

  • Help about error 12 in iTunes, Help about error 12 in iTunes

    Hi I'm stuck in recovery mode iPhone 5 when Restore after Error 12 is 70% then the Kindle when it does connect to iTunes again gives error 12 ... Please

  • Website movie won't play

    I have exported a movie for web using Quicktime Player I chose the smallest version (425k .mov) and it plays fine I added the movie to a photo album page on my site in iWeb Selected movie - opened the Quicktime inspector and ticked Autoplay and saved