Should I Get an iMac, Macbook Pro, or iPad (3rd Generation))

I'm getting a new "computer" this summer, and I was wondering: Which Apple Device is right for me: iPad 3, iMac, or Macbook Pro? I realize WWDC is this summer (a day after I was planning on getting a Macbook Pro, June 10, which is my birthday) and Apple will be releasing/ unveiling their new products there. I realized that the iMac is more bang for your buck, but people are starting to lean towards portable devices, such as laptops over desktops, and tablets over laptops (mostly). I had planned to get a Macbook Pro (when the 2012 models come out) as of Sunday, April 22. But, as I realized that the prices for each are so different, considering their value, I realized this:
iMac:
"Land" - Locked
More Power for money (student discount)
Will last me longer (at least 2.5 years)
Macbook Pro:
Portable
Costs less (as of student discount)
iPad 3:
Even More Portable
Costs even Less.
Considering these, which do think I should get by the following:
Me:
Go upstate every once a month or so.
Going on vacation in the summer w/ family.
Do light gaming (Sims 3, Civ 5, Spore; not much)
Plan on bragging about being the only one in family w/ Mac (bring to relatives' houses to prove a point to my cousin that he's not the one w/ the coolest computer)
Lots of Word Processing (can use pages on iPad)
w/ iPad, I'll have more money to use on accessories (Step dad giving me $500 towards computer, I'll have $350 by June 10)
Mostly do web browsing.
Want to use in school (high school)
If I get an iPad, I can afford to upgrade it every year, but not the Macs
Will be reading lots of books next year (will be taking AP English)
Lots of notes next year (Doing Government in Social Studies next year)
Will use iTunes U if needed
Need something to fit in backpack if using in school.
Not sure if teacher will allow laptops/ tablets.
Mostly do my computing at home
So what do you think? Should I get an iMac, Macbook Pro, or an iPad 3? Thanks! Best answer gets 5 ***** for the long reading!

Wow, using computers in school. I remember when I went, teachers flipped out if you had as much as a cell phone
A couple things I would like to point out:
1.) WWDC /=/ product releases. While it is likely, no one knows for a fact what will happen at WWDC other than usual events. I would expect it, but don't jump the gun and say "a new Mac will be launched at WWDC", because they have been released before WWDC.
2.) The iPad is in a different tier than Mac, IMO. I believe iPads should be supplements to PC's, since if troubleshooting need occur, you must still have a PC to restore. (Mac is PC). So say if you suddenly go into Recovery mode, you will be stuck until you find a PC to restore to. One downfall of iOS devices, so for that reason, I will not recommend the iPad alone.
If you plan to do most of your computing at home, I would get the iMac. I am a college student, and plan on replacing my Macbook Pro (selling it) with an iMac if I can afford it. I agree with you on the "bang for your buck", but even then, iMac is still pricey. With $850, you're still shy $300 of the $1149 price w/education discount. If you want to upgrade your processor (which I would), that's even more $. Plus, software if you need it.
What exactly are you going to do with a Mac that you cannot do with a Windows PC (outside of just using the Mac OS)? The playing field is leveling out quite a bit. But, if you plan on developing of any sort, get a Mac.

Similar Messages

  • What kind of external drive should I get for my macbook pro for backups etc

    what kind of external drive should I get for my macbook pro for backups and storage

    Hi, i have a Mercury Elite-AL Pro from OWC, www.otherworldcomputung.com
    this is the one;
    http://eshop.macsales.com/item/Other%20World%20Computing/MEAQ7S1TB32M/
    have had this for over two years, moved around a lot with the drive, ( to date ) no problems, they have good after sales support; give them a call if you need info.
    There are a lot of drives out there as others here will let you know, there are good NAME drives but they also fail, POPULAR drives also fail, select the one you are happy with for your system and how you plan to use.
    i suggest if $ is not a problem get a big drive you will find someting to put on it and is better.
    hope this helps.

  • Which model of memory upgrade should I get for my MacBook Pro early 2011 model? I now have 2 - 2GB modules.

    Which model of memory upgrade should I get for my MacBook Pro early 2011 model? I now have 2 - 2GB modules.

    Installing RAM in a 2011-2012 MacBook Pro
    There is really only one way to install RAM into a 2011-2012 MacBook Pro and while there are hundreds of DIY videos online, I just like this one, found on YouTube, by “macmixing”.
    Note that there is a difference in the RAM that should be used in 2011 and 2012 models.
    2011 models must use:
    •204-pin PC-10600 (1333 MHz) DDR3 SO-DIMM
    And 2012 models must use:
    •204-pin PC3-12800 (1600 MHz) DDR3 SO-DIMM
    So here's the video:
    Remember that the 13", 15" and 17" 2011 models (early or late) and the 13" and 15" mid-2012 non-Retina models can handle 4GB, 8GB or (unofficially, but, believe me, it works) 16GB of RAM. There are, in my opinion, only two 100% Mac-compatible vendors out there: Crucial and OWC. I really can't recommend any other brands, even though it may work, as these are the only brands that I've personally used in quite a while. Also remember to stay away from any RAM that is a “value” brand - Macs are picky about RAM and often these value RAM modules just don’t work very well.
    Good luck,
    Clinton

  • The text on my iMac, MacBook Pro and iPad are light grey and difficult to read

    I have the latest upgrades of OS X Yosemite 10.10.3 on my iMac, MacBook Pro and iPad Air 2. To my dismay, the text on all three computers is light grey and difficult to read. I tried to increase the contrast and also reduce the transparency, but to no avail. It is still difficult to read the text. What do I do?

    Send feedback to Apple about their poor design choices. That's all I can think of, since this is the new, modern, minimalist, gray, and drab crapola Apple's foisting on computer users.
    27" i7 iMac (Mid 2011) refurb, OS X Yo (10.10.3), Mavs, ML & SL, G4 450 MP w/10.5 & 9.2.2

  • What Configuration should i get on the MACBOOK PRO???

    my mom's birthday is coming soon and im throwing a surprise party for her. let me start off by saying im 16 years old but i am well aquainted with Mac and PC. I have been around computers since i was about 4. I LOVE THEM.
    my mom is starting loans and she needs a laptop for her job. she has never used mac before as she has been around pc all her life.
    one of the biggest reasons why i am getting her a macbook pro is because of BOOT CAMP. but at the same time i will do my best to introduce her to OSX. I feel she will pick it up fast.
    I wanted some help on deciding how to build her computer.
    i have come up with this:
    1.83 ghz config w/ 512 ram on 1 slot
    on the other slot i will add a 1 gb stick to total 1.5 gb.
    (ive found better deals on ebay for memory than apple)
    so it comes down to:
    1.83GHz Intel Core Duo
    1.5 gb RAM
    80GB Serial ATA drive @ 5400 rpm
    SuperDrive (DVD±RW/CD-RW)
    AirPort Extreme Card & Bluetooth
    Backlit Keyboard/Mac OS - U.S. English
    15.4-inch TFT Display
    please let me know what you think?
    please let me know if i should also consider the 2.0 ghz also? is there a significant difference?
    thanks a lot guys
    iMac Intel 20 Inch   Mac OS X (10.4.6)  

    If a whine and heat issues are the 'issues' that you're refering to, then I think that there are some more serious issues that could happen than this, and I haven't heard of them. Not everyone has these issues, and if they want to go ahead with a MBP, I say go for it! If their MBP has one or both of the issues, they know well enough to take it to an Apple Store (or wherever) and get it repaired/exchanghed/refunded. I think that the chances that they get a 'bad' MBP are rather slim. It's possible, but not certain. Those who post on these message boards have problems because, well, that's what these message boards are for. Again, I say go for it!

  • Should I get a 2008 MacBook Pro 2.4ghz with 4gb of ram or macbook aluminum 2008 2.4ghz 4gb of ram? And which is thinner?

    Hello everyone I would like to know if I should get the 2008 MacBook Pro non unibody 2.4ghz 4gb of ram or should I get a macbook aluminum unibody with the same specs? And does anyone know which is thinner?

    Go with the aluminum, which is also thinner. The Late-2008 aluminum model is the oldest model MacBook capable of running the latest version of OS X (Mountain Lion).

  • What display should I get for my macbook pro?

    Hey Guys. I think this is in the correct section.
    So I have a Macbook Pro (specs at the bottom) and I am looking to add an external monitor to use as a second monitor and at other times a screen for my playstation. I have never had a monitor before so not sure how big? What resolution? What ppi? HD, UHD, 4K? Someone said something about refresh rate. I have no idea what that is. None of this stuff I know.
    Obviously I want the best screen I can have and I would connect my Macbook to it by HDMI using a Thunderbolt to HDMI converter and connect my ps3 to it by HDMI.
    What is the highest resolution a HDMI/Thunderbolt can handle?
    What screen should I get?
    Also I connected it up to my TV once and if I put my mouse at the bottom of the screen and then moved it onto my macbook screen it disapeared and didn't appear again until I moved it up and I don't want this problem
    How can i solve this?
    All help is very much appreciated.
    Thanks.      Miles.
    Specs:
    Macbook Pro - 13 inch - Mid 2012
    13.3 inch (1280 x 800)
    OSX Yosemite - Version 10.10.1
    Intel HD Graphics 4000 1024MB
    [email protected]

    The apple thunderbolt display is £900 which to me seems an extremely large amount of money to spend on a display ?

  • Should I get a new Macbook pro?

    Hey there,
    I have had my white Macbook for over three years now. First of all, it runs really sluggish most times now. I mean, I'm still able to use it, however, it is significantly slower than when I first got it. The disc drive no longer works, and hasn't worked for about a year now. Instead of spending 200ish dollars to get it fixed, I just bought an external one. The Macbook pro now is really new and having been recently approved for the barclaycard, I would be able to finance it over the next twelve months. I have heard people say that right now is the perfect time to buy a Macbook pro and that it should last me at least the next six years. Should I just tough it out and wait until my current Macbook really is driven into the ground, or should I take advantage of my current student discount and the prime time to buy a Macbook pro?
    I am really leaning towards getting it, but still debating.
    Thanks!

    That is a really good question. The difference in performance will be huge for you, but on the other hand the new Pro's are buggy right now (heat, 10.6.7 update glitches, freezes,). Of course common sense tells us that new iteration bugs happen to the minority - most people will be happy with their new machines. Read the posts here about new machine issues and see if you are up to the challenge. I'm seeing a lot of people solving their problems, but as a rule: if you wait a while after a major upgrade you can avoid issues completely.
    Finally - consider the Apple Refurbished page. Good deals right now.
    http://store.apple.com/us/browse/home/specialdeals/mac?mco=OTY2ODY3Nw

  • What upgrades should I get for my MacBook pro for video editing?, What upgrades should I get for my MacBook pro for video editing?

    Hi,
    i am a student and I will use my MacBook pro to edit my movies, I will go to a film school and I think the preview of my previous works has to be professionally done. But I don't know what upgrades should I get to make the editing smooth, and have enough storage.

    as an hobbyist on a shoestring budget, but with the head in the sky, based on my own experience:
    8GB Ram is ok, 16GB is nice
    most important, aside 'skills': …
    <voice of Steve Balmer> ext HDD, ext HDD, ext HDD, ext HDD!!!
    I'm handling here 4k material on a MacMini, which doesn't even have a dedicated GPU. In Multicam.
    Distribute your materials on several hard drives, make a plan first, before editing, what & where, you get instantly messy and lost without a plan.
    What mentioned before: back ups! I'm not shy using a 99€ Raid0 (=two 2.5" drives + Disk Utility's feature, to create 'software raids' ) - Raid0 are NoGo for pros, 'cause it doubles the chance to 'crash' - no prob for me, having my backups - inconvenient to reload everything - but I'm no News Room
    For professional 'look' care for the other stuff :
    tripod with 'fluid head', lights, more lights, ND filters set, ext. microphone(s) at last a shotgun and a lav, ext audio recorder (I'm abusing my ol' iPhone4 and a tiny box called iRig, which offer XLR connector), did I mention lights? , a good bag and a waterproof, lockable aluminium box, soft boxes for light, maybe a shoulder rig (starting at 80€), 200sq ft of some green cloth for green screening (if your school doesn't offer a 'studio') FCPX does marvel with even really bad lighted green screens, those handy foldable 'brighteners'/reflectors, to bounce light ('Rembrandt lightning') … finally tons of odds and ends, starting with gaffer tape, ending with SDcards ...
    And DO things, try things, play with your stuff, make experiments just for the trash bin!
    Enjoy your film school (I'm envy… )

  • What monitor should I get for my Macbook Pro?

    I have a 2012 Macbook Pro
    I want to get an external monitor
    What spec monitor should I get?
    The only thing I'm worried about is getting the correct connection
    I'm assuming I want a monitor that will take DVI connection
    ALSO: would I need to buy a DVI connector - would the monitor come with this?
    Aside... are there any specific (non Apple) monitors that are widely used by everyone?
    I read another thread and there where a few names pop up like a Dell model
    Thanks
    Omar

    thanks for the reply
    i was looking at this model: http://benq.co.uk/product/monitor/gl2450hm
    i choose this one because it had a response time of 2ms
    other monitors have a response time of 5ms
    i assumed this would mean fast action graphics would display better?
    any thoughts?
    (+ this is £120 on amazon - others are roughly £140 starting price)
    ALSO... does it matter what i connect to - DVI or HDMI?
    is one better than the other?
    i already have a hdmi connector... so am assuming i will be ok with this and not bother with dvi?
    thanks

  • Which cooling pad should I get for my MacBook Pro?

    I have the mid 2012 Mac Pro (the $1500 one) and now it is going to get hot in my country.Like around 110F and it is 92 and my Mac is starting to get really hot.So I was thinking of which cooling pad I should get.

    Try the MacBook forums
    MacBook Pro
    https://discussions.apple.com/community/notebooks/macbook_pro 
    https://discussions.apple.com/community/mac_os?view=discussions
    http://www.apple.com/support/macbookpro

  • Should i get the current MacBook Pro or the new design MacBook pro 2012?

    Dear all,
    GImme some opinions which to choose? Should i wait for the supposedly new design MacBook Pro? or get the current models that hae pretty good specs? I'm doing college at the moment and my current laptop is 4yrs old in need of a new one and hopefully get the 17" MBP coz the specs seem amazing. I'm doing graphics and multimedia so i would need a laptop that can handle all those stuff and be fast. So gimme some ideas what you think abt the current MBP and the soon to come new models? which is something pretty doubtful.

    Hold off the buying. The current unibody macs are the last of the generation. A geenration that's in it's 4th year.
    You might want to consider upgrading your current hard drive only to an SSD if your mac supports it. You can then move this over to your new mac. That's what I have done, and the speed difference of an SSD makes it feel like a new machine.
    I would also suggest you buy a 15" and not a 17" save your money. The 17 is loking carrying a surfboard around.
    <Edited by Host>

  • Should I get the 2013 MacBook Pro with Retina or wait for new one?

    Okay so they announced the new MacBook Pro with Retina in February of 2013, but that doesn't have the haswell CPU that recently came out. I am for sure going to buy a MacBook Pro Retina for college this upcoming fall, but I don't know I should wait and see if they announce once with the haswell chip in it or just go ahead and buy it..? Can anyone suggest what I should do? Thanks.

    My gut reaction to this is to say buy. After all, what else do you want from a mac, the pro with Retina is a very capable machine, and for most functions, any CPU difference would be hardly noticeable.
    I do like to wait too, hopeful to get the latest kit, but when the spec is as good as it is, the updates probably arnt worth the wait.
    Thats my advice, its your call of course but I would go for a Pro with Retina any day.
    Good luck with your hunting!

  • What kind of monitor should I get for my Macbook Pro Retina?

    I bought a Macbook Pro Retina to replace my old 2007 Macbook. When I hook my Retina up to my Acer 1080p LED Monitor, it does not display in full quality. I assume this is due to the size of the graphics card inside the laptop. My old macbook displayed a perfect picture on this same monitor.
    I want to buy a new monitor that can display my Retina in full quality, but I don't want to break the bank to get a Thunderbolt Display. Any suggestions on a monitor I can get?

    Try adjusting manually the resolution on the external monitor. You may have to degrade slightly the resolution on the built in monitor when you do this. I have been told that the Mac automatically tries to optimize the picture quality on the retina display at the expense of the resolution on the external monitor. You may have to "redistribute" manually the available resolution to favor more the external display.

  • What specs/ upgrades should I get for a Macbook pro that I'm buying?

    I don't want to spend a ton of money but enough that the macbok pro will be really fast.
    I browse the web a lot
    I watch youtube and netflix on it
    I will need it to do college assignments
    I will need to do basic video and picture editing

    I think either of the 13" MacBook Pro models would do, with RAM upgraded to 8Gb. That would put you at $1399 for the 2.4GHz, $1699 for the 2.8GHz.
    You could save some money by getting a stock MacBook and upgrading the memory via the various third-party RAM vendors. They'll charge a lot less - OWC has an 8Gb upgrade kit for less than $50, vs Apple's $200, and you might even get a rebate for sending your old RAM to them.
    Other people may have different opinions, but that's mine. Good luck with your new Mac.
    Message was edited by: Dick Young

Maybe you are looking for

  • How can you edit a finalcut archive

    I have been attempting to figure out if it is possible to edit my archives - delete files. The files in the archive are just one large file when I archive AVCHD files. I have several duplicate files I would like to delete the duplicates to conserve d

  • STO - Unpack HU assigned to an outbound delivery

    Hi SAP experts, I'm trying to unpack a HU assigned to an outbound delivery created for a STO. The material packed is WM managed. I would like to know what are the steps to perform ? - I've created and confirmed a TO from 916 to 923 with LT09 transact

  • Can't open a tab in the same window

    Hello, tell me, please, why can't I open a new tab in the same window. maybe I did something wrong done in the settings?

  • Cannot open multiple images in Photoshop

    I recently purchased a new laptop (OS: Windows 7 Enterprise, 32 GB RAM) and installed CS5 on it.  All of the applications work well except for Photoshop. At first Photoshop would load correctly but crash when I tried to Save As.  I deleted the prefer

  • Poor jpg quality in video files

    Hi, My apologizes if my questions are common knowledge. In general, why does still photos look blurry and IMO crappy in video files (made in Premiere)? For example, why doesn't a 900 x 600 px. jpg in a 900 x 600 px. flv video look exactly like in Pho