Signatures in Mail 6 - OS X Mountain Lion.

Question

Hi everyone.
As you may know, Mail 6 gives you the choice to place your signature above or below the "quoted text".
Ok.
Now (with the option above siabled, as in the picture) when I directly mail a link by pressing cmd-shift-i there's the place where I'll write the text of the e-mail, the link and the signature.
The problem is that when I reply to an e-mail conversation, my signature goes all the way down to the end of the entire conversation. With Lion (and older OS X versions) every one of my replies used to have its own signature.
By enabling the optoin above and pressing cmd-shift-i in Safari to directly send a link via e-mail, the overall look of the message get even worse: it makes no sense at all to have the link below my signature. See the picture below.
Any solution to have Mail behave as it used to (i.e.: every message with its own signature in the right place)?
Thanks in advance.
Andrea

Answer 1

I had exactly this problem.  In an old post from 2008 there was this advice:
"Go to Mail > Composing and uncheck "Use the same message format as the original message" checkbox (under the Responding title)"
My "Use the same message format as the original message" checkbox was unchecked, so I checked it to see what would happen and Hurrah!, it works!  I've been annoyed by this problem for ages.