Smart Collection features I don't see in LR4 beta and wonder why not

I've been playing with the new LR4 beta for all of 10 minutes now, and am disappointed to see that Smart Collections haven't moved forward at all.
Things I'd hoped to see:
In the Edit Smart Collection window, why when you add a new rule does it always default to "Rating"? How is that the most likely thing I want? Sure, make it the default for the first rule, but thereafter, I think it would be a lot more useful if it added another rule of the type on the line you pressed '+' on. That is, if I have a "Keywords...Doesn't Contain" rule and press the '+' button on that line, there's a better chance that I want another such rule than that I want yet another "Rating" rule.
Continuing the previous, I think the second rule added should follow slightly different logic. If the default Rating rule wasn't changed to a different type, the default for the second rule shouldn't be "Rating" again to clone the first rule, but rather pick the second most likely rule type. Does Adobe have usage statistics for people's Smart Collections to draw on?
For Keywords rules, there aren't negative operators to match all of the positive operators. So we have Contains, and Doesn't Contain, but we have Contains All and lack Doesn't Contain Any, and we have Contains Words but not Doesn't Contain Words. You can get the desired effect by nesting the positive version in a "None of the following are true" sub-rule, but this feels clumsy. Either give us a symmetric set of logical operators, or take away the negatives and give a clean way to negate arbitrary rules without nesting rules when not needed.
Nested rule sets aren't discoverable. I stumbled across this feature by accident, and only then because I knew how to do the same in iTunes. I'd rather see a third button to the right of each rule line that gave a way to create a nesting than the current magic Option trick. One of the great things about Lightroom is how discoverable most things are; you scarcely need the manual. This is a sharp corner than needs to be knocked off.
There's still no way to refer to one Smart Collection from another! iTunes has had this since approximately forever. It is very useful to be able to extract common rule sets from multiple Smart Collections and simply refer to it from others. We call this the DRY Principle in programming, and it's a Good Thing.
No new Smart Collection rule types. At minimum, I'd hoped to see rules for megapixels and pixel dimensions. I'd like to be able to find all the pics with a long edge 640 pixels or less, for example. Megapixels is actually less useful, because it can be fooled by high aspect ratio images. A banner 4000 px wide and 100 px tall is "only" 0.4 Mpx, but it probably doesn't need to be any bigger. (Yes, I'm aware of Jeffrey Friedl's plugin. He wants this built into LR4, too. )
We don't even get one new rule having to do with geoencoding. Just off the top of my head, I'd kind of like to have a Smart Collection that found photos taken within 100 feet of my home's lat/long and didn't contain the keyword "home". I have many such Smart Collections in a Collection Set called "Warnings", each of which automatically checks my photos for something that I often forget.
You can't reorder rules or move them into or out of groups. I have Smart Collections with a dozen or so rules, and some with logic nested three levels. When assembling such complex little beasts, it isn't always clear while building it what logic order will give the desired result. You have to iterate, and that often means taking a perfectly good rule and moving it somewhere else. Lacking the ability to reorganize the existing rules, that means creating a new "Rating" rule, changing its type to match, cut-and-pasting the match criteria [if text] and deleting the old rule. Pfagh.
That's enough for now.

Ooops, found one new Smart Collection rule: "Metadata Status". One. Want more.

Similar Messages

  • I bought a brand new mac and follow through setting up process with my apple id but when I open App Store I don't see lion into the purchases list. why?

    I bought a brand new mac and follow through setting up process with my apple id but when I open App Store I don't see lion into the purchases list. why?

    Updates come through Software Update not the App Store. If you have to reinstall Lion that is done via Internet Recovery.
    OS X Lion- About Lion Recovery
    OS X Lion- Run Software Update to use Lion Internet Recovery
    Lion maintenance and recovery operate via the Recovery HD. It's possible to create a separate recovery disk on a flash drive using OS X Lion: About Lion Recovery Disk Assistant.
    To boot into the Recovery HD:
    Boot to the Recovery HD:
    Restart the computer and after the chime press and hold down the COMMAND and R keys until the menu screen appears. Alternatively, restart the computer and after the chime press and hold down the OPTION key until the boot manager screen appears. Select the Recovery HD and click on the downward pointing arrow button.

  • HT201272 From Latvia iTunes store i don't see my previously purchased movies. Why is that?

    From Latvia iTunes store i don't see my previously purchased movies. Why is that?

    Not other than parental oversight. On the computer you can implement Parental Controls on a separate user account that they would use. You can then block certain websites. But you cannot do that on the iPad.
    You could change your iTunes account such that they cannot access it in order to buy or download apps.

  • I'm trying to install an update to itunes that downloaded but can't complete installation as its trying to install onto D: drive. I don't have a D drive and i'm not given option of selecting the drive to install on. How can i select the drive that i want

    I'm trying to install itunes but can't complete installation as its trying to install onto F: drive. I don't have a F drive and I'm not given option of selecting the drive to install on. How can I select the drive that i want to install on?

    Hi,
    How do you connect the printer to the XP machine ? If USB, you need to make that machine as a Print server. Please try this:
       http://techtips.salon.com/make-windows-computer-pr​int-server-11914.html
    Regards.
    BH
    **Click the KUDOS thumb up on the left to say 'Thanks'**
    Make it easier for other people to find solutions by marking a Reply 'Accept as Solution' if it solves your problem.

  • I don't remember my security questions and I'm not in America now. I want to reset resurce email address but I can't have a phone call. Please send information from email, thank you.

    I don't remember my security questions and I'm not in America now. I want to reset resurce email address but I can't have a phone call. Please send information from email, thank you.
    <Email Edited by Host>

    The Three Best Alternatives for Security Questions and Rescue Mail
         1.  Send Apple an email request at: Apple - Support - iTunes Store - Contact Us.
         2.  Call Apple Support in your country: Customer Service: Contact Apple support.
         3.  Rescue email address and how to reset Apple ID security questions.
    A substitute for using the security questions is to use 2-step verification:
    Two-step verification FAQ Get answers to frequently asked questions about two-step verification for Apple ID.
    These are user forums. You are not speaking to Apple here. You should not put a valid email address in a forum message.

  • I don't remember my security answer and it's not my 1st time for using this device,i using this before..but the last time I try to buy some games using iTunes card its saying this is your 1st time using this device so I need to answer the security questio

    i don't remember my security answer and it's not my 1st time for using this device,i using this before..but the last time I try to buy some games using iTunes card its saying this is your 1st time using this device so I need to answer the security questio

    https://expresslane.apple.com/

  • I don't have imessage on my iPad. Why not?

    I noticed that my mother's iPad has the "imessage" application, but I don't have it. Does anyone know why not?

    You Have to update your iPad to ios 5!!!!

  • TS1702 I downloaded a free Merriam-Webster dictionary app for use on my iphone 5.  I thought I executed the steps to download it properly...I do see it in my App Store 'purchased' list, but I don't see it actually activated and ready for use anywhere...he

    I downloaded a free Merriam-Webster Dictionary app for use on my iphone 5.  I thought I followed the download process properly, but cannot see that the app is launched on my phone.  I have checked my phone for 'updates' and the app is listed among the ones I have purchased.  I clicked on it and it began installing, however, it still has not launched.  I get a message screen to sign in with my Apple ID, which I tried, and I get the message that I have purchased this app and it will download.  When I try to sign in, I get the message that it can't connect to the itunes store and to retry.  I've done that several times without any luck...not sure where else to look for the 'working' app.  I did try re-booting the phone...even did a 'hard reset' to no avail...help?

    Anything* >.<

  • I can't see pictures when on EBAY. I can see them in Chrome and Explorer, but not Firefox

    This just started happening in the past few days. I can't see EBAY pictures (there are some other sites as well where I now don't see pictures). I see the pictures fine using other browsers.

    Do you have AdBlock Plus or any of the ad-blocking add-ons? If so, that may be what is causing the problem.
    There's just something about eBay that makes these add-ons think the entire website is an advertisement and so they're just trying to do their job and block everything "ad-related".
    If you disable your AdBlock Plus or whatever it is just for ebay, you should see it go back to normal.

  • Not able to see Beat Audio software and mute light not glowing on fresh windows 8

    Hi, 
    I am using Laptop : HP ENVY 4 1046tx. I have installed fresh windows 8 on it. After that I have downloaded audio software from HP software site but that driver is not accepting. 
    1. I am not able to see Beat Audio software and equalizer setting in control pannel.
    2. When I am pressing mute button mute light (red light) is not glowing on button
    Thanks,
    Prabhat
    This question was solved.
    View Solution.

    Try the IDT Audio driver here:
    http://ftp.hp.com/pub/softpaq/sp58501-59000/sp5863​5.exe
    ******Clicking the Thumbs-Up button is a way to say -Thanks!.******
    **Click Accept as Solution on a Reply that solves your issue to help others**

  • Apparently when I send to a Group of Contacts they can all see every email address and this is not acceptable how do I avoid that

    I need to send to a group of about 50 parents. Their addresses are held in a Group of Contacts. I highlight the group name to distribute a message to all of them and what I am being told is that they can then all see every email address. This is not acceptable as many do not want their email address being made public in this way. Surely this should not happen or at least there should be a way to avoid it.

    re: and I quote "they can then all see every email address. This is not acceptable "
    I showed you the basic method of sending a group as Bcc - which is what you initially asked for.
    As you now specify that not only do you want to know how to use Bcc but every email needs to be personalised - not just distributing a message to all of them, then I would agree with Matt and advise you use Mail Merge. This creates separate emails - not a bulk email to several recipients, so using a TO field will only send to that person - other people will not see other email addresses.
    Matt has offered the link.
    Here is some more info regarding Mail Merge.
    '''How to install Add-ons:'''
    download the .xpi file to your computer eg: desktop or downloads folder.
    In Thunderbird
    'Tools' > 'Add-ons' OR 'Menu Icon' > 'Add-ons'
    click on the gear wheel icon and select 'Install addon from file'
    see first image below as aid.
    locate the file you downloaded and click on 'Open'
    You may need to restart Thunderbird.
    Mail Merge will appear in the list.
    see second image below.
    '''How to set up a Template emails for Mail Merge:'''
    Create a Template email, which contains the 'personalised' sections.
    see example - third image below.
    I set the Subject as 'Mail Merge' so it is easily identifiable.
    Save it as a Template email.
    It will get stored in the 'Templates' folder. If you do not see a Templates folder, this is auto created when you create the first email and store as template.
    '''When you want to use Mail Merge.'''
    Select the Template folder.
    Select the 'Mail Merge' template
    either double click on the email in the list or right click on email and select 'Edit as new message'
    you can then change the Subject and compose or edit the message - but do not change the sections in the curly brackets - the point of saving this as a template saves you from typing it each time.
    'File ' > 'Mail Merge' (see third image)
    This will open a new small window
    see the fourth image below.
    I would suggest you use 'Send Later' option . this will put all the emails in your Outbox, but it does allow you to check the email is correct - or do spot checks. Then you can choose to send them all in one go.
    Right click on 'Outbox' folder and select 'Send unsent messages'.
    Hope this info helps you.
    As you are new to Thunderbird, you may or maynot have managed to locate all your toolbars.
    The fifth image shows you how to enable all toolbars to make life much easier.
    In addition some very useful info on maintaining a healthy Thunderbird and all about compacting- what it does and why it is important.
    * http://kb.mozillazine.org/Keep_it_working_-_Thunderbird
    * http://kb.mozillazine.org/Compacting_folders

  • I installed a blank cd to burn which I have done before but nothing is happening and I can not eject the cd

    I installed a blank cd to burn a playlist which I have done many times but nothing is happening and I can not eject the cd and when I try to close ITunes I get a message saying a cd is burning but nothing is happening and I can not do anything in ITunes

    I have this tip in my notes to eject a stuck disc, but not even sure if I have used it before -
    Restart computer while holding "option" key, when hard drive icon appears, release "option" and hold "eject" key.
    Hope it works!

  • HT1495 I use method 3 to sync my iPad to my desktop which is used to sync my iPod nano. After I done all the steps,how will I sync the separate library to my iPad? I don't see any sync option and don't even see my iPad on the device.

    My iPad is registered in a different account.im having difficulty installing iTunes on my laptop so when I read that multiple iPod,iPad etc can be sync in one computer,I tried making a separate library on my desktop which have an iTunes already.i used my desktop for my iPod nano. After following the instructions, I don't know how to sync it with my iPad now connected on my desktop.i can't see a button or option to sync. And I don't even see my iPad recognize on the device.pls tell me what am I missing. I already sign in so my desktop will be authorize.

    All devices only sync what you select to sync.
    If you do not want all of the music, then simply do not select all of the music to sync.

  • MY IMAC don't see the main server and all the network! I didn't nothing on his system, but since some days it is out of network on my company. And what is curious is that others computers can see mine. Some one can help me??

    My IMAC lost the network, it can be seen but cannot see! What I have to do?

    You're welcome.
    Voicemail is left at your carrier's server. That will continue to work unless you report your iPhone as lost or stolen with your carrier.
    You may never find it again and you can't if the iPhone remains offline or out of service which means the iPhone is powered off or doesn't have cellular reception.

  • Apple  tv keep saying Widescreen when buying and renting I don't see widescreen when buying and renting I only see widescreen on 1 movie I have to use the other romote and make the screen bigger can anybody help me?

    Apple Tv keep saying widescreen I rented and brought the movies I don't get widescreen I have to open up the screen with another remote there was only one movie that was widescreen? Can you fix this?  Do you have any advice?

    Virtually all iTunes movies are widescreen, so it is difficult to understand what you are referring to, could you explain a little better please.

Maybe you are looking for

  • Why are bookmarks pinned from Firefox android less attractive than ones pinned from stock browser

    I want to pin the BBC weather mobile site to my home screen for quick access. http://m.bbc.co.uk/weather/2643743 If I do this from within Firefox then I get an unattractive, generic bookmark symbol on the home screen. It works but doesn't look nice.

  • Using built-in Strings

    InDesign stores many strings. I want to use some of them in my UI (to avoid the need to translate) In Scripting you can use "ID/....", If I just put in the string I find that its translated but I get an assert in debug build that string is not transl

  • Load balancing and session sharing

    Hi, in my company we have the following situation: We have 2 instances of the same web application on differend servers. An external load balancer (Alteon) routes the requests to these instances. The problem: If one instance is shutting down, all the

  • Best way to acquire data from both serial port and D/A board in real time?

    In my experiment, I have 2 kinds of data: analog and digital. Now, I have to write a programme to acquire both data not only in real time but also in sychronicity. My colleague tried to write a program for this purpose. However, the digital part was

  • How to get resultset from viewobject

    is there a way to java.sql.ResultSet from ViewObject , i am using Jdev 10.1.3.4 with ADFBC Thanks