So Apple blew it with Final Cut Pro X?

OK...was just getting ready to upgrade from FCP to FCP X, but...reading the reviews, I'm EXTREMELY hesitant...
Did Apple blow it with this? The last thing i need is "iMovie" on steroids. I need a streamlined, PROFESSIONAL grade application for editing video and video soundtracks, NOT a "pretty face"...
You guys please lmk if it's worth the money as it stands RIGHT NOW. I'm not interested in paying for this THEN waiting for update after update when we should be beta testing for free, NOT with money out of our pockets.
Also, is it REALLY not backwards compatible with other FCP projects? If not, why not? And if not, how do you convert them and can you still work with them via some mechanism? If so, how hard is this to do and what do we compromise...?
OK...discuss...ty.

392Firepower wrote:
OK...was just getting ready to upgrade from FCP to FCP X, but...reading the reviews, I'm EXTREMELY hesitant...
Did Apple blow it with this? The last thing i need is "iMovie" on steroids. I need a streamlined, PROFESSIONAL grade application for editing video and video soundtracks, NOT a "pretty face"...
If you are not willing to gamble $300, wait a few days (or heck, even a week) for more detailed reviews. Then you can make up your mind if FCP X is useful for you.
392Firepower wrote:
Also, is it REALLY not backwards compatible with other FCP projects? If not, why not?
This may come as shock to some, but not everyone has a huge back-catalog of previous FCP projects. Yes, I do think that Apple should call out that right now FCP X can't open previous FCP projects. So if you need that, than FCP X isn't a solution for you now. Stick with FCP 7. Nothing has changed.
But in the meantime, for those who it's not a big issue (like me) can start using FCP X today.
This is what is so boggling to me - how is it a negative that because Apple shipped it early for those for who the current feature set is appealing a negative? If Apple had waited until the "pro" features were done and incorporated it would still be the same amount of time for those people. But now all the users who don't rely or need on those higher-end "pro" features wouldn't have the software in the meantime.
You seem to be one of the smarter people on these forums - you actually waited to read a review before rushing out to spend $300 on a new piece of software. Congratulations! If it's not a fit for you, you can wait until it is (or until there is a more compelling solution for you if Apple takes too long or never delivers).
The amount of hysteria for what is basically poor impulse control and a lack of due-dillagance on the part of people who are supposedly "Pros" is simply breathtaking...

Similar Messages

TS1846 I have some troubles recently with Final Cut Pro 7 and would like to remove my preferences. I can't find any "com.apple.finalcutpro.plist" file from the Preferences folder but I do have some preferences. So, where could be the file ?

I have some troubles recently with Final Cut Pro 7 and would like to remove my preferences. I can't find any "com.apple.finalcutpro.plist" file from the Preferences folder but I do have some preferences. So, where could be the file ?

Digital Rebellion has you covered: http://www.digitalrebellion.com/prefman/

Is the Canon Legria HF M56 compatible with Final Cut Pro X

I am new to Mac and new to Final Cut Pro X. I am looking to buy a new HD Video Camcorder to use with my new computer/software and wondered whether or not the Canon Legria HF M56 is compatible with Final Cut Pro X.
If it is, do you have to import the footage directly from the Camcorder, or can you first save the files to the Mac and import them that way?
I currently use a Sony HandyCam HDR-SR10 which produces AVCHD .mts files. I have these saved on my Mac after transferring them over from my PC but Final Cut Pro X cannot import them. Very frustrating for a professional app to be unable to import these files. Even Cyberlink Power Director can use these files.
Thanks for your help
ConvertedAppleFan

It's not on the tested list but it may well work.
http://help.apple.com/finalcutpro/cameras/en/index.html
Why don't you download the trial and try it?

Your experince with final cut pro vs adobe premiere?

I am just wondering about your experience with final cut pro and adobe premiere and which you like better and why. Thank you.

dorian86 wrote:
I am just wondering about your experience with final cut pro and adobe premiere and which you like better and why.
I've posted this in other threads here: I've tried the Final Cut Pro X 30 day trial on my old Mac Pro 5,1 (heavily modified) and my new Mac Pro 6,1 (8-core, D700s). I have a specific benchmark that I run on an NLE when I'm testing it: how long does it take to export one of my movies to a 720p h.264 MP4?
If we assume the length of the movie is represented by 't' (for time) -
The old Mac Pro and Final Cut Pro X 10.0: 2t
The new Mac Pro and new Final Cut Pro X 10.1: 1/2t + epsilon
The old Mac Pro and Premiere Pro CC: 1/2t + epsilon
The new Mac Pro and Premiere Pro CC: 1/2t - epsilon
The newer version of Final Cut Pro X is substantially faster at exporting my movie than the older version. But Premiere is still faster than it is. Also, Apple still can't get the whole "edit the source footage raw" bit right; my source footage is all spanned-clip AVCHD, with files that are over 4G a piece. FCPX can't just open those raw, it insists on putting a MOV wrapper around the footage. There's no transcoding happening, but the file I/O for those massive files slows the whole process down significantly.
Because I don't have years of experience editing with NLEs, I'm not married to any particular UI. FCPX's UI is ... strange, but I didn't find it too difficult to become used to it. If it were faster and more efficient for what I do, I'd reconsider it. But for now, it's all Premiere.

Importing issues with Final Cut Pro X. Green flash and twitches while play back

Hello, I'm having some importing issues with Final Cut Pro X and I can't find any solution whatsoever. Perhaps my importing settings are wrong?
Anyways, I've done a lot of recordings on eye TV and HD PVR with some videos that are about 3 hours long. I exported them into H.264 files, which turns them into mpeg-4 files with AAC audio. Then I import them into final cut pro X and I notice it takes a long time for them to render the videos and I notice that there are some green screens and twitches while I play through the video.
Here is a screenshot of the green screen that I'm talking about:
[URL=http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/688/screenshot20130409at338.png/][IMG]http://img688.imageshack.us/img688/4537/screenshot20130409at338.png[/IMG][/URL]
Could it be my 2 video graphics card that is causing this kind of issues? Or is there any solution to fix this?
In the past, I've used iMovie 09 and it worked out perfectly. However, the new iMovie 11 is terrible because it automatically optimzie my 3 hour long videos into making the importing process to (144 hours long to import). Is there any way to get iMovie 09 back or am I stuck on dealing with this Final Cut Pro X issues?
More information:
My Hauppauge HD PVR settings are set to custom. Video Constant Bit Rate, the average bit rate: 13.5 Mbps. The audio is AAC.
My project settings for video properties is set to custom, 720P HD Format, 1280 x 720 Resolution and 30P Rate. The audio and render properties is set to custom, audio channels is stereo, audio sample rate is 48kHz and the Render Format is Apple ProRes 422.
I export the video as a quicktime movie. The export setting is H.262.
The summary of the export is:
File type: Quicktime movie
Estimated size: 397GB
H.264, Width and height: 1280 x 720. Framte rate: 30 fps

My Hauppauge HD PVR settings are set to custom. Video Constant Bit Rate, the average bit rate: 13.5 Mbps. The audio is AAC.
My project settings for video properties is set to custom, 720P HD Format, 1280 x 720 Resolution and 30P Rate. The audio and render properties is set to custom, audio channels is stereo, audio sample rate is 48kHz and the Render Format is Apple ProRes 422.
I export the video as a quicktime movie. The export setting is H.262.
The summary of the export is:
File type: Quicktime movie
Estimated size: 397GB
H.264, Width and height: 1280 x 720. Framte rate: 30 fps

Is my 2007 MacBook compatible with Final Cut Pro X?

Is my 2007 MacBook compatible with Final Cut Pro X?

Probably not the specs call for at least 256mb of VRAM. Depending on the model your MacBook is either 144mb or 64mb of VRAM
http://www.apple.com/finalcutpro/specs/

Apple Audio Filters in Final Cut Pro

I'm posting this question here because I didn't receive any responses in the Final Cut Pro message area, and I thought given the nature of the questions, audiofiles that read this area might have an answer.
In Final Cut Pro there are two folders of audio filters, one called APPLE and the other FINAL CUT PRO.
I fully realize none of these filters have the power of programs like SOUNDTRACK PRO.
However, I'm in a situation where I need to document what the filters do. I've already found all the material I need for the FINAL CUT PRO filters. However, I can't find any information anywhere on the APPLE category of filters.
My questions:
#1 - Does anybody know why the APPLE audio filters are seperated out from the Final Cut Pro filters? How are they different generally?
#2 - Does anybody know where I can find documentation on what each of the APPLE category of audio filters do? I can't find it in the Final Cut Pro Manuals or Diane Weyland books. I found some Ken Stone tutorials on line, but they don't address the APPLE filters.
#3 - And many of the APPLE audio filters seem to be near duplicates in the Final Cut Pro audio filters, so what's the point in having two versions?
Any info at all or a direction to look would be appreciated.
Thanks so much.
Message was edited by: brvideo

As of Leopard I was surprised to find that the Apple system plug-ins, and those that are supplied with the FCP suite are not AU plug-ins in the old sense of what a plug-in used to be. They no longer exist as a file anywhere in the system as they used to. Audio Unit plug ins formerly used to exist in Library/Audio/Plug ins/Components - now they are build into the Leopard operating system.
Any third party plug-in you purchase will still be installed in the "old" way.
Sorry, I can't remember where that documentation exists. Probably in the developer docs somewhere.

I updated to yosemite os and was in the middle of a project with final cut pro 10. Now it says final cut pro is incompatible. How can I access my project and/or update final cut?

I updated to yosemite os and was in the middle of a project with final cut pro 10. Now it says final cut pro is incompatible. How can I access my project and/or update final cut?

There is this offer of a trial version FC Pro X with 30 day runtime:
http://www.apple.com/final-cut-pro/trial/
Too bad you didn't have a complete backup that could run the previous OS X
and then you could resume using an earlier Final Cut Pro (10) or (7) since a
clone would have been a means toward that position.
http://www.apple.com/support/finalcutpro/
http://www.apple.com/support/pro-apps/
This appears to be another good reason to check out all the reasons why one
would want or need to upgrade a working OS X version, since these kinds of
events are known to happen as a direct result.
Sorry to not have an answer to this, other than try & use the Trial version...
Or see if someone at Apple sales/support can field your issue w/ an answer.
Good luck & happy computing!

Are microsoft movie maker files compatible with final cut pro files?

I would like to know if microsoft movie maker files are compatible with Final Cut Pro?
Thanks,
elemir

depends on how you're outputting. .wmv I don't think so.That's pretty much a dead end format. mp4 might be, but i'm not sure if movie maker outputs them. .avi might be, depends on the codec used.
Avoid .wmv, apple products don't play well with that format (never have) and aim for some other output type. Then on your mac, if you don't already have it, if you don't already have it, get the free converter mpegstreamclip and see if it can convert your movie maker output into something final cut will input. DV files are good, as are .mov files.

When I try sharing to my apple devices from my final cut pro x, I keep getting a "Quicktime Error:-50". How can I fix this?, When I try sharing to my apple devices from my final cut pro x, I keep getting a "Quicktime Error:-50". How can I fix this?

When I try sharing to my apple devices from my final cut pro x, I keep getting a "Quicktime Error:-50". How can I fix this?

You can search the entire internet by putting that error message into google, see what other discussions appear.
With only the little information you've provided, I'd trash Compressor and download it again from the App Store.
You could share the timeline out to MPEG2 and then import that into iDVD, if you have it, or Toast.
Given an hour or three, someone with better suggestions will soon chime in.

Buying a mac book pro to use with final cut pro

does anyone have know what specifications I should be sure of before purchasing a laptop? I will be using it extensively with Final Cut Pro HD as well as many other programs
thank you all as always...

In addition to what Jerry and David said, if you have Final Cut Pro HD (4.5), you'll need to crossgrade to get the full benefits of your macbook pro.
http://www.apple.com/universal/crossgrade/

What is the best dvd burning program with a nice menu like idvd that works with Final cut pro

What is the best dvd burning program with a nice menu like idvd that works with Final cut pro, I am wanting to burn mainly wedding dvds but also sports and other things we used to use idvd but then upgraded our computers and now we dont have it. idvd was the only thing i could find that worked.
Thanks

There is no real substitute for iDVD.
Why is there no iDVD on my new Mac? How do I get it and how do I install it?
https://discussions.apple.com/docs/DOC-3673
To burn a DVD with iDVD from the latest version of iMovie, you have to export the movie using the Export button and select 480p as the size. Open iDVD and start a new project, then drag that exported movie file into the iDVD menu window, avoiding any drop zones you see.

Can I use Final Cut Express 4 with Final Cut Pro 10

Can I use Final Cut Express 4 with Final Cut Pro 10 on the same computer?
Thank you,

Yes, you can install both of them, but you can only have one open at a time.
You can check this for yourself by downloading the free 30 day trial from
http://www.apple.com/finalcutpro/trial/

I get this message often with final cut pro 7 "Autosave: File Error: Unknown file?

I get this message often with final cut pro 7 "Autosave: File Error: Unknown file?

Is you're autosave folder on a drive that's not formatted macosextended? You set the location for the autosave folder in system settings which can be found in the FinalCutPro Menu. Also, the best way to trash fcp preferences is using Digital Rebellion's Preference Manager
https://discussions.apple.com/docs/DOC-2491

Editing HDCAM with final cut pro 6?

Hi all,
We have been offered some post work on a music video shot in HDCAM, we use Final cut pro 6 and have a HDCAM capture deck (Sony J-H3 (JH3) HDCAM Compact Player), I am in the process of researching this work flow.
Would any one be able to shed some light on editing HDCAM in final cut Pro 6, the settings, things to look out for, and the overall work flow,
i very much appreciate your help
The mac to be used is a Mac Pro, mac os x 10.5.6 with final cut pro 6, duel core intel 2.66 Ghz, 8 GB memory, 2 NVIDIA GeFource 8800GT, with a 3 TB of internal HD Space

we don't take in HDcam, but we do use it for output archive and transmition.
the workflow we use is, Shoot in AVCintra 50 onto P2 cards transfer into FCP 6
edit in Apple Pro Res 1080i50 and output to HDcam via an AJA Kona card sending out as HD-SDI
ian

So Apple blew it with Final Cut Pro X?

Similar Messages

Maybe you are looking for