Suggestion to overhaul the photo/syncing/organizing system on the iPhone

I am currently going through and organizing my camera roll's photos into different photo albums, and I realized that the way photo organization is currently implemented is simply NOT up to Apple's standard of usability (****, it's not even up to Microsoft's....)
Not only can I not directly transfer images from the Camera Roll to an album of my choice directly on the iPhone, I can't even do that from within iTunes nor can I create albums directly on the iPhone (why not!????). The only way I can do that on Windows 7 is by manually creating folders outside of iTunes, and then syncing them.
But that got me thinking that not even the album approach to organizing photos is good. Say for instance I want to organize my photos by both people AND places. For instance I go on a trip and have a photo of a friend. In order to place that photo in an album for that trip, as well as place that photo of my friend in an album for that friend, I need to have TWO instances of the same photo, which takes up twice the space on my phone. Furthermore, I have to clone it manually via Windows etc.
What the iPhone needs is a simple, tried and true image tagging system, whereby the photo albums are not physical albums, they're simply based off of tags. This means the same photo can appear in multiple albums without requiring multiple instances of it on the phone.
Further, photos then become search-able via the phone's search spotlight. Currently the albums are not even search-able, let alone specific images. But if image tagging were to be implemented, it would allow particular "albums" to show up in the search results.
So rather than adding the ability to create albums via the phone and to move images from the Camera Roll to a particular album, you simply allow the user to create a bunch of pre-defined tags which can show up in a list when you go to tag each photo.
If Apple's feeling really ambitious, it could use the multi-select approach the camera role uses for sharing/deleting. Select a bunch of images, and apply the same tag(s) to all of them.
Meanwhile the current list of "albums" would appear exactly as it does now, except those albums would simply be based off the tags.
Anyway, there's no real point to this post other than to rant about how utterly poor the usability of the photo organization system is on an otherwise well thought-out device, and to offer a solution to fix it.

The sync process for photos is for the most part is centered around using iPhoto on a Mac, or with using a supported 3rd party photo management app on a PC.
Photos in the iPhone's Camera Roll are designed to be imported by your computer as with any other digital camera. iPhoto supports importing photos from any digital camera including from the iPhone's Camera Roll. iPhoto includes a places and faces feature. In order for a photo to be available in an available iPhoto album, event, places, and faces, the photo must be in the main iPhoto library. A photo in an iPhoto album, event, places, and faces is not duplicated and can be in all 4 categories. A photo in an album event, places, and faces includes a pointer to the original photo stored in the iPhoto library. The same with iTunes playlists. You can't have a song in an iTunes playlist unless the song is in the main iTunes library, and a song can be in multiple playlists without being duplicated. A song in an iTunes playlist is not duplicated.
What the iPhone needs is a simple, tried and true image tagging system, whereby the photo albums are not physical albums, they're simply based off of tags. This means the same photo can appear in multiple albums without requiring multiple instances of it on the phone.
Already done this way with iPhoto on a Mac, and should be the same when using a 3rd party photo management application on a PC.

Similar Messages

  • HT1414 My iPhone4 (iOS 6) does not sync with iTunes. The message displayed suggests to return the iPhone to factory settings (which I cannot do). This happened after the iPhone was upgraded to iOS6 and performed one sync. Any ideas?

    My iPhone4 (iOS 6) does not sync with iTunes. The message displayed suggests to return the iPhone to factory settings (which I cannot do). This happened after the iPhone was upgraded to iOS6 and performed one sync. Any ideas?

    Lilasil wrote:
    The message displayed suggests to return the iPhone to factory settings (which I cannot do).
    Why not?

  • I currently have the 1st generation iphone. I am looking into upgrade, which iphone do you suggest 3GS or the iphone 4?

    I currently have the 1st generation iphone. I am looking to upgrade, which iphone would you suggest?  iphone 3GS or the iphone 4?  other?  

    Yes!! I have been told by many to buy the 3GS iphone. They love it and tell me I would, too.  But thanks to you, Dad and Michele, for your information that you have provided; I will purchase the iphone 4. With the great Facetime feature, I will be able to use it with my daughter who is stationed in Japan with her husband. By the way, I keep hearing that Apple will be making iphone in white. When will that happen?  Thanks again! 

  • Closing Apps on the iPhone 4 in OS 7.02

    Does anyone know how to close the apps on the iPhone 4 in OS 7.02? In the previous OS, when you double clicked the iPhone, the apps that were used would show up at the bottom of the screen, when you placed your finger on each icon, they would start to shake, a little red dot would appear at the top left corner of each app used, then when you tapped that red button on each app, they would close one by one. By following this same procedure in OS 7.02, you're able to see the apps you used at the bottom of the screen; but there doesn't seem to be any way to close them. Any suggestions?
    Also in OS 7.02, there doesn't seem to be a way to edit or delete an individual text message within each contact, only the contact itself can be deleted.
    Is this another feature lost with this new system?

    Double-click the Home button to bring up the app screen, then swipe upwards on the app.
    http://howto.cnet.com/8301-11310_39-57602601-285/how-to-force-close-apps-on-ios- 7/
    Not using text messages I can't address your second question. Someone else here probably can, though.
    If you have further questions about your iPhone, I'd suggest asking in the iPhone forum. You'll be more likely to get quick and applicable help there than you will here in the iTunes for Mac forum.
    Regards.

  • My iphone's memory is near capacity from photo albums sync'ed with my mac and I haven't found out how to delete select albums without wiping the iphone.  Any suggestions??

    my iphone's memory is near capacity from photo albums sync'ed with my mac and I haven't found out how to delete select albums to free up memory without wiping the iphone.  Any suggestions??

    You do the opposite of how you got them on your phone, you unsync the pics using iTunes.

  • My laptop was stolen and I need to be able to connect my iPhone4 to the new laptop and transfer content (photos, mp3's, apps etc.) to the new laptop.  I'm afraid to try a sync in case it deletes all the content off the iPhone.  Any suggestions?

    My laptop was stolen and I need to be able to connect my iPhone4 to the new laptop and transfer content (photos, mp3's, apps etc.) to the new laptop.  I'm afraid to try a sync in case it deletes all the content off the iPhone.  Any suggestions?

    You should be importing all pics taken with the iphone to your computer regularly as you would with any digital camera.
    iOS: Importing personal photos and videos from iOS devices to your computer

  • What does this mean? iTunes cannot sync photos to the iPhone because you do not have write access to the folder "iChat Icons"

    Can anyone help me please? My iphone originally was linked to my PC. I downloaded over 3,000 pictures from my PC to my iphone. Since then my PC broke and now I have a macbook pro and the macbook doesn't recognize all the pictures from my pc. I get the following message.
    -iTunes cannot sync photos to the iPhone "Daniel's iPhone" because you do not have write access to the folder "iChat Icons".

    Hi,
    I picked up on this Post as I was searching for "iChat" in non iChat places.
    A Mac will contain a Folder for "iChat Icons"
    It is kept in Hard Drive/System/Library/Application Support/iChat icons
    There are about 9 sub folders here including Planets, Guitars, Feng Shui and so on.
    They are normally accessed in iChat to be your Own Buddy pic.
    They way you have phrased your posts suggests you have a folder on your phone called "iChat icons" which may have been created by the PC.
    For people who know more about iTunes than I do to help will need to know where this Folder is exactly.
    10:43 PM      Saturday; June 30, 2012
    Please, if posting Logs, do not post any Log info after the line "Binary Images for iChat"
      iMac 2.5Ghz 5i 2011 (Lion 10.7.2)
     G4/1GhzDual MDD (Leopard 10.5.8)
     MacBookPro 2Gb (Snow Leopard 10.6.8)
     Mac OS X (10.6.8),
    "Limit the Logs to the Bits above Binary Images."  No, Seriously

  • System freeze iTunes photo sync

    Hello,
    Recently I've encountered an error that I was able to replicate a second time: My system crashes when I quit the automatic Photo sync (a subwindow of iTunes) with my iPhone 5s. It isn't a spinning beach ball, the whole system simply stops responding to anything.
    What could be the cause? Both devices are this month's acquisitions and should be in top form.

    While I haven't heard a solution to posts I've made to both Adobe and iTunes sites, I have found a manual workaround.
    The catalog files that iTunes uses are of the format "catalog.pseXdb". 
    In my case, the new catalog is "catalog.pse13db" and the old is "catalog.pse9db". These files are found in catalog folders like: C:\ProgramData\Adobe\Elements Organizer\Catalogs\Elements 9 Catalog
    With iTunes and PSE closed,
    1) copy the catalog.pse13db file to the "Elements 9 Catalog folder. 
    2) rename the old catalog.pse9db file to keep it and deactivate it
    3) rename catalog.pse13db to catalog.pse9db
    iTunes will continue to use the older catalog file, but it now has new catalog contents.  The manual part is that this will need to be done prior to each time you want to sync new catalog content to your devices.
    Somewhere around PSE version 7, the catalog file format changed, so this technique may not work for upgrades from about v7 upward.

  • I went to sync my iPhone 4 as usual and when it got to the end stage of the sync where it sync the photos from iPhoto, I get a message pop up that says, "The iPhone cannot be synced. The required file cannot be found." What do I do?

    I went to sync my iPhone 4 as usual with my iTunes account on my MacBook Pro and when it got to the end stage of the sync where it syncs with iPhoto, I get a pop up message that says, "The iPhone cannot be synced. The required file cannot be found." What do I do?

    Hi. I am having the same problem.
    I have updated iPhone software and carrier settings, OSX Lion on the comp and in step 4 of 4 during photo sync about half way through, the error message comes up and now my pics are gone from the phone. I did empty the cache and the problem still persisted. I changed cables, I restored the phone and synced from the back up and even restored and created a new phone identity, still no love.
    I am puzzeled, any suggestions?

  • TA22992 Trying to sync new photos from iphoto withou having the old photo synced on ipad2 but when I select sync from iphoto the old photos are already included. How do I stop itunes from preselecting photos? Already try "selected albums, events, etc" no

    Trying to sync new photos from iphoto without having the old photo synced on ipad2 but when I select sync from iphoto the old photos are already included. How do I stop itunes from preselecting photos? Already tried selecting "selected albums, events, and faces, and automatically include" then I enter "no Events" with no success the photos still are being synced along with the new photos. I want to be able to add new photo and remove old photos. Please help this has taken a lot of my time trying to figure it out.

    If I knew the answer I would have given it - but since it is not an iPhoto question I suggested
    You might try the iPad forum - or the iTunes forum - this really is not an iPhoto question
    LN

  • Re: Trying to sync new photos from iphoto withou having the old photo synced on ipad2 but when I select sync from iphoto the old photos are already included. How do I stop itunes from preselecting photos? Already try "selected albums, events, etc" no succ

    Trying to sync new photos from iphoto without having the old photo  synced on ipad2 but when I select sync from iphoto the old photos are  already included. How do I stop itunes from preselecting photos? Already  tried selecting "selected albums, events, and faces, and automatically  include" then I enter "no Events" with no success the photos still are  being synced along with the new photos. I want to be able to add new  photo and remove old photos. Please help this has taken a lot of my time  trying to figure it out.

    If I knew the answer I would have given it - but since it is not an iPhoto question I suggested
    You might try the iPad forum - or the iTunes forum - this really is not an iPhoto question
    LN

  • I need to get the photo's synced via ITunes from my IPhone to my Windows PC

    Due to a hard drive failure I have lost all my data on my Windows Desktop.  I have synced most of the photo's on my IPhone 5S on iOS 8.1.2 via ITunes however it seems I cannot do the reversal to get the photo's from the IPhone to my Windows Laptop.  Has anyone got any suggestions to help??

    The only photos that you can put onto the drive of the computer from the phone are the ones in the Camera Roll. Those are done via the Import utility in Windows. Photos that have been synced to the iPhone via iTunes would have to be taken from the iPhone via a 3rd party utility. You cannot sync photos that have been synced to the phone back to a computer via iTunes. It does not work that way.
    There are a number of 3rd party utilities that you can use, but TouchCopy by Wide Angle Software is a good choice. I have used it before, and there is a free trail or a purchased alternative, depending on how much you need to do. That also will allow you to archive voicemail, SMS, and other data from the phone, if you did not have a backup of your iTunes library on the desktop. Remember the photos that were synced to the iPhone were done so in a reduced resolution, so you would not be getting them back in the same size and resolution as you synced them. Also understand, that if you did not have a backup, you will need to move music as well, or it will delete all of the music on the iPhone.

  • ITunes cannot sync photos to the iPhone because your iPhoto Library is not yet available.

    I've turned my iPhone 4 into a iPod, meaning I only use it to hold music for my workouts. Ever since I've upgraded to Yosmite I can't sync my iPhone 4 to iTunes anymore. I can back it up, but I can't sync. Each time it tells me "iTunes cannot sync photos to the iPhone because your iPhoto Library is not yet available"  I don't want to sync any photos, just music.
    I've tried to repair my iPhoto Library, restarted my Mac, restarted my iPhone 4 but I still get his error message.
    In iTunes when I select my iPhone 4 > Photos, I just get a spinning wheel.
    Any thoughts??

    I can't follow the first link since I just get a spinning wheel for photos.
    Launch the Console application in any of the following ways:
    ☞ Enter the first few letters of its name into a Spotlight search. Select it in the results (it should be at the top.)
    ☞ In the Finder, select Go ▹ Utilities from the menu bar, or press the key combination shift-command-U. The application is in the folder that opens.
    ☞ Open LaunchPad and start typing the name.
    The title of the Console window should be All Messages. If it isn't, select
              SYSTEM LOG QUERIES ▹ All Messages
    from the log list on the left. If you don't see that list, select
              View ▹ Show Log List
    from the menu bar at the top of the screen.
    Click the Clear Display icon in the toolbar. Then take an action that isn't working the way you expect. Select any lines that appear in the Console window. Copy them to the Clipboard by pressing the key combination command-C. Paste into a reply to this message by pressing command-V.
    The log contains a vast amount of information, almost all of which is irrelevant to solving any particular problem. When posting a log extract, be selective. A few dozen lines are almost always more than enough.
    Please don't indiscriminately dump thousands of lines from the log into this discussion.
    Please don't post screenshots of log messages—post the text.
    Some private information, such as your name or email address, may appear in the log. Anonymize before posting.
    When you post the log extract, you might see an error message on the web page: "You have included content in your post that is not permitted," or "The message contains invalid characters." That's a bug in the forum software. Please post the text on Pastebin, then post a link here to the page you created.

  • TS3697 I am receiving an error message(iTunes will no longer sync photos to the iPhone "Peter's iPhone". Do you want to keep or remove photos previously synced to your iPhone") I am trying to download pics from my computer to my iPhone. Any ideas? Peter

    When I went to download some pics (originally taken with my iphone 4S) from my computer back to my iPhone I got the following error message: "iTunes will no longer sync photos to the iPhone "Peter's iPhone". Do you want to keep or remove photos previosly synced to your iPhone?"
    Coincidentally, my wife just purchased an iPhone 4S and syncs to iTunes on the same computer.
    Any ideas?
    Peter

    The "best" way to handle it, if you want to keep everything separate, is to create separate user accounts on the computer. make sure you log into your account on the computer before you attempt to sync your phone and log out when you're done using the computer.
    Though it's possible to sync both of them to the same iTunes library, and even share an account for the iTunes store, you're inviting confusion and possible data loss (as you've discovered already). Best to just use separate user accounts on the computer. That also gives you the benefit of not polluting the other persons browser favorites, contacts, etc.

  • How can i delete photos in a folder from my Iphone 4s.  when it was synced, the photos went to two folders and not to the camera roll

    How can I delter photos in a folder from my Iphone 4s?  When I synced the new phone from the Itunes, the photos went to two folders and not the camera roll. 

    thanks, should I delete all the phones on Itunes and re sync the old phone, then resync the new phone to get the pictures?  Will they go to camera roll instead of a folder?

Maybe you are looking for

  • Using Apple remote with macbook display closed

    Hi , I have a macbook connected to LCD TV with HDMI connection . Is there a way to use Apple remote with display closed . examples of using apple remote with display closed would be (1) waking the macbook with apple remote (2) putting the macbook to

  • Storing internal table from XML File into DDIC

    Hi everybody, im trying to store an internal table <b>without</b> knowing the content - means the structure (fields)- into th DDIC, but i failed. The code is: DATA xslt_error TYPE REF TO cx_xslt_exception. TRY . perform load_file  using 'D:/usr/YTGVF

  • New Airport Express: iMac loses printer, apple Tv connectivity

    I just replaced my netgear router with a Apple Airport Extreme Base Station (late 09). My set up is as follows: iMac 24" wireless to AEBS Printer and harddrive connected via USB hub to AEBS Apple TV connected to AEBS (via power extender) Airport Expr

  • Problem with a subfolder

    I have been using iWeb to create and maintain fairly simple web sites.  One of them is http://www.getalifesports.com and up until recently everything has been working fine.  Recently I noticed that if I type the website name into the Safari address b

  • Variable Reference of Instance Name

    While I have had no problems with bracket evaluation of constants and number variables, I don't know the coding convention for brack evaluation of a string. I get an undefined for oBtnName oBtnName = new Object; oBtnName = this["mcWing" + aWingColor[