Tape Library Concern - Eject & Reinsertion after each backup

Here is what I am currently using.
System overview:
-HP Proliant DL380p Gen 8
-HP D2600 2TB 3G SATA LFF - 24TB Storageworks array
-Quantum Scalar i40
(2) HP LTO-5 tape heads
(25) Licensed slots
 Tape library is configured as one partition
Windows 2012 R2 - fully patched
DPM 2012 R2 Data Center Edition with 7/2014 Update Rollup 3
 I have used DPM for about 6 years since 2007 version but I have always used stand alone LTO-3 & LTO-5 tape drives.  I
have used tape libraries before that time but with a different product.
Here is the scenario I am seeing.  Any tapes jobs that are scheduled at the same time will
pull a tape into each tape drive and backups are performed.  All is working normal from that perspective.  The problem I see is that after each backup is completed the tape is removed from the drive, placed back in the slot, removed again from the
slot and then re-inserted back into the drive to continue with the next backup job that was scheduled at the same time as the previous one.
This seems highly inefficient and time consuming not to mention a lot of extra wear & tear
on the library & tapes.  Is this behavior normal? If so, can it be changed?  or is it is bug?
I would expect the tape to remain in the tape drive until all backups are completed assuming they
had available capacity and were not off-site ready.  It appears if multiple servers are in the same protection group the tape is not removed between these backups.  The issue appears to be when the next separate protection group is backed up.
I’d even be up to manually moving the tape and leaving it in the tape in drive but I don’t see
that kind of library control with DPM.
I saw another thread from August where someone mentioned seeing this behavior when doing verifies
on their backups.
Thoughts?  PSS call?
Thanks!

I'm seeing that if a protection group consisting of hundreds of small SQL databases is configured for short term disk and long term tape, and configured to use 2 drives, that after EACH DATABASE the tape is rewound and re-slotted, only to be re-inserted
into the drive and fast forwarded to the end for the next database to be written.
If you've got hundreds of databases (many small, like msdn, model, etc) this can push the time out to 3 minutes plus per database taped, even for a 5MB database.
My current workaround is to configure the protection group to only allow the use of a single drive.
Doing so seems to reduce the time per database from 5 minutes down to 30 seconds, presumably just REW and FF tape movement.
Even though the time is reduced, I'm still disappointed the progress between databases doesn't continuously stream.  I mean 100 small 5MB databases should only take 7 seconds, if streaming at 70MB/s to tape.  Instead it's 30 seconds per 5MB database. 
:(

Similar Messages

  • How can i open iPhoto Library on Time Machine after full Backup?

    After i had a full backup to iomega external hard drive i wonted to see photos in iPhoto library by using Time Machine. I can see the iPhoto Library icon on
    Time Machine, but when i click on an icon it does not open the folder and i can't see the pictures stored on iomega external hard drive. All other backed up
    documents i can see and restore if i ineed it. Please help. Thank you.

    Thank You for your help. I did what you sugested and it works. Only one more question. Just to make sure.
    When you wrote:  "Control-Click the iPhoto Library icon and choose Show Package Contents there will be a Masters folder with you photos inside."
    Under Master folder did you mean LibraryiPhoto or something else?
    Thank You

  • Is possible control tape library slot 1 - 10 for file system backup

    hi ..
    i am new to osb , i just install and setup osb , i have a question as below , hope expert can help me
    env: testing
    rhel 5.5
    tape library with 20 slot
    file system backup
    1. is possible osb only use slot 1 - 10 for file system backup ? amanda can control slot x - slot y for the configuration .
    2. how do i label the tape for slot 1 - slot 10 by obtool ? how to control osb auto load the tape for next backup ? where to check the log say that next tape is tape-02 ?
    thanks ..

    hi dcooksey
    how do i use list for a tape drive...for example, if you want tape drive A to only use slots 1-10 from obtool or webtool ?
    becoz i new to backup solution & osb ( i always use ghost or acronis to clone the image ) , my thinking as below , pls correct me if i am wrong
    slot 1 - 10 for daily backup
    slot 11-16 for full system backup
    slot 17 - 20 reserve ( this tape only use for full system backup before perform any application upgrade patches , )
    daily backup mon - fri ( 2 week ) ( no backup on saturday and sunday ) , server application offline
    full system backup friday ( 1 , 14 on calendar ) every 2 week perform full system backup after daily backup completed
    for upgrade application ,
    perform full system backup after daily backup , then release the server to application team to perform upgrading .
    so how to set my media family for the above setting ? the slot configuration is control by media family ?
    hope you can help ...

  • Backup Oracle VMs using a direct attached tape library

    Hello all,
    I'm in the process of getting a specification for a new Oracle VM host server which will run OEL VMs and host Oracle databases (10g and others), currently we're looking at getting an HP DL580 and a MSL6000 tape library using SAS connectors.
    Regarding backups, I understand that Oracle VM Server doesn't have a built in mechanism for backups so would need to use a backup method from within the virtual machines.
    Is it possible, and advisable, to use a tape library directly attached to the host server and use an OEL VM running Symantec Netbackup which will then backup the other VMs, if so, are there any issues or gotchas I should be aware of?
    If it is possible to do this, do I connect the tape library to the VM by editing the VM config file and add the tape library devices as 'phy:/dev/xxx'
    Thanks in advance,
    Martin.
    Edited by: user5385211 on 09-Oct-2009 03:39

    NDMP is for backing up NAS platforms.
    Does your backup software support "LAN-Free" backup ? Typically enterprise backup software like Netbackup, TSM, Networker require a special license/agent that gets loaded on server where you are going to implement LAN-Free backups. Without that software/license servers will be fighting for tape resources and it will be a mess (if it works at all). Also you want to use dedicated HBA or port on dual HBA for tape traffic, do not mix tape and disk traffic on the same HBA/port. In big shops people configure dedicated "tape" VSANs but that would be an overkill for your current environment.
    @dynamoxxx

  • How to control the backup tape can't reject after success backup

    Hi, Expert,
         The backup tape will unload the backup tape automatic after successful backup via tcode(DB13) backup job.
    We want to control the backup tape don't unload automatic after successful backup. Could you tell me how to confige the setting? Thanks.
    best regards
    Park Han

    ellabs wrote:
    please can someone help me to restore my backups on time capsule after reinstalled the new system.
    What "new system" did you reinstall? 
    Are you upgrading from Leopard to Snow Leopard?
    Or did you reinstall Leopard?  If so, why and how (that may provide a clue)?
    How is your Mac connected to the Time Capsule (use Ethernet for best results)? 
    You may need to repair the backups, per #A5 in Time Machine - Troubleshooting. 

  • How to setup and Configure the SCDPM 2012 R2 on Hyper- v VM to take the Backup in Tape Library

    Hi
    I have to configured a SCDPM 202 R2 on one Hyper-V VM to take the Backup in Tape.
    Can any one suggest that we can take the Backup through SCDPM  hosted on VM in to tape Library..?
    Shailendra Dev

    Hi,
    Currently, Windows Hyper-v does not support tape libraries on the Vfc - this is covered in the following TechNet article.
    Hyper-V Virtual Fibre Channel Overview
    Tape library support
    Tape libraries are not supported on virtual machines configured with a Virtual Fibre Channel adapter.
    Consequently, DPM cannot support something that Windows does not support, so we have documented that Fvc tape is not supported in a VM
    Preparing for installation in a virtual environment
    So your current options are to use Iscsi attached tape library, or use a Physical DPM Server.
    Good news is both the Windows and DPM teams are working with tape library vendors to get their tape libraries certified to work in a Hyper-V VM using Vfc - expect more news about that in a future release of DPM.
    Please remember to click “Mark as Answer” on the post that helps you, and to click “Unmark as Answer” if a marked post does not actually answer your question. This can be beneficial to other community members reading the thread. Regards, Mike J. [MSFT]
    This posting is provided "AS IS" with no warranties, and confers no rights.

  • Eject usb disk after Timemachine backup done! But SpotLight prevent!

    Hi, all
    OS: 10.8.2
    How can I disable Spotlight indexing the Timemachine volume ?
    After I backup with TimeMachine, I can't eject the usb disk because the SpotLight(mds daemon) is indexing on the usb disk, How Can I disable this. I don't want to plug in my usb disk all the way I am using the macbook pro. And I don't want to completely disable spotlight.
    I have try mdutil -i off -d /Volumes/TimeMachineV1
    but it failed, says can't disabled on the tm volume, ***?!

    I would just let the indexing complete - it will stop indexing with the drive disconnected and begin indexing again when the drive is connected. It may take a couple of hours or more to fully index the drive the first time but it should be easy going after the drive is first indexed.
    I'd just wait it out - it shouldn't take too long.
    Clinton

  • Command to see backup item of OSB  tape library disk

    Dear Friends ,
    Using OSB enterprise manager , I take oracle dump backup into tape library . Now it is very difficult for me to see the backup contents of the library using OEM .
    I want to know , is there any command available on OSB (like ls ..)  to see the list of backup item from the tape library disk .

    Hi shipon_97
    This link show information that I think can be very useful:
    https://docs.oracle.com/cd/E26569_01/doc.104/e21480/obtool_commands.htm#OBREF151
    Here, you can view the commands for the tool obtool.
    I hope this can you help.
    Regards,

  • I have music loaded from cd's. They were intact after each sync. After a iTune upgrade, I lost all the music at sync. Can I restore them from old backup in iCloud ?

    I have music loaded from cd's. They were intact after each sync. After a iTune upgrade, I lost all the music at sync. Can I restore them from old backup in iCloud ?

    Unless you'd signed up to iTunes Match then they won't be in the Cloud, only music purchased from iTunes (if you are in a country where music can be re-downloaded) will be there. Have you not still got it on your computer and/or on a backup which you can use to sync it back to the iPad ?

  • STK L 700 tape library robot holding the media.

    Hello All,
    I have an STK L700 tape library, which has 4 HP LTO3 FC tape drives and 2 IBM LTO4 FC tape drives, the robot is FC connected.
    I have an issue,The hand assembly picks the media from tape drives after backup and then goes to a slot and holds the media for a long time, then after we eject the media. then i can see a message, initialization failed.
    This issue is intermitent.
    I checked the FSC logs and I could find 3 FSC logs with reach alert.
    &&309D
    &&3087
    &&3087
    I have checked the physical library status, it is working normally, after we take out the media and re initialize it.
    I dont think this could be due to hardware failure, anyone could you kindly help me out to isolate the issue?

    Cross-posted to the Storage forum:
    [t-5381933]

  • Lost disk space after each reinstall.

    I've had to reinstall leopard on my macbook three times in the last week for different reasons. After each reinstall(erase and install) it appeared that I lost a little more GB to the HDD. I have a 250GB HDD, and I know it actualls reads as 232.87, but without uploading any media and only using the reinstall disks that came with the box, I have only 218 or so GB. Is this normal? I can't find the numbers anywhere; they just don't add up.

    Anthony Turtzo wrote:
    I can't find the numbers anywhere; they just don't add up.
    My guess is that you have added up the sizes of the folders visible in Finder at the root level of the drive (Applications, Library, System, & Users) & compared that total to the total space used on the drive. The two numbers will not match because there are also hidden files & folders at the root level of the drive that Finder does not normally show. The hidden items are necessary for the proper operation of the Mac & in normal use are managed by the system. Since users should not tamper with them directly without good reason & it requires expert knowledge to do so without breaking anything, they have been made invisible in the Finder view.
    It is normal for the drive space used by these items to fluctuate, & for the total to grow somewhat after first installing the OS. Some of the items contain temporary files that are created & destroyed as needed. Some contain usage, crash, & other informational logs that are managed by routines that the system automatically runs periodically to keep their total from becoming too large. Others contain initialization data gathered over time that the system uses to start up or to run processes efficiently.
    Thus, there is no fixed correct number for their total size since that depends on the history & current state of the machine. On my iMac G5, one large hidden folder ("var") currently uses about 1.05 GB of drive space, but consider that only a ballpark number since it may be considerably different on different Macs at different times.
    If you are still concerned about the health of the drive, especially that something is eating up disk space unnecessarily, then run Disk Utility to check it. In the "First Aid" tab select your drive & click the "Verify Disk" button. If this reports no problems then you can be pretty sure there is nothing to worry about.

  • Tape Library - Extend Expired Tapes

    Hi,
    I have several questions regarding the Tape Library behavior.
    I have DPM 2012 R2 UR3 with VTL library. I have several PG that is using Long-Term-backup to the VTL. I have several protection Groups that is having long term backup. Each PG have its own Library with several tapes presented. The schema is 1 month
    kept for 12 months and 1 year kept in 5 years. my questions are:-
    1. Is it possible to extend tapes expiration date? For example changing the 1 month to be kept for 10 years?
    i read this thread
    https://social.technet.microsoft.com/Forums/en-US/bf5115d4-a050-4aca-9759-8180c415d415/how-can-i-change-tape-expiry?forum=dpmtapebackuprecovery and Mike wrote
    •Expiry dates for valid datasets that are already written to tape are changed when the retention range is changed during a protection group modification.
    To change the behavior create the IsDatasetExpiryDateChangeInModifyPgAllowed DWORD value under the following registry key, and then set its value data to 0:
       HKLM\Software\Microsoft\Microsoft Data Protection Manager\Configuration\MediaManager
    Does that means if i add "IsDatasetExpiryDateChangeInModifyPgAllowed " and change the Protection Group retention range will that change the expire date for all tapes in the library?
    2. If i present a new Library to each Long-term PG and kept the old library presented in DPM Library. Will the tapes still be usable even if they will expire? the idea behind that is keeping each library and its containing tapes untouchable for like 10 years
    and when the tape expires i will mark them as free (contain data) and recategorize the tape. in that way i can still use the tapes for a specific amount of time.
    thanks in advance,
    Laith
    Please remember to click “Mark as Answer” on the post that helps you. This posting is provided "AS IS" with no warranties. knowledge is valid only if it is shared by All.

    Hi,
    Without the IsDatasetExpiryDateChangeInModifyPgAllowed registry value, when you change the goals for LT tape, DPM will change the expiry dates on existing media.  Some weird behavior can occur if you have three goals configured then go down to two or
    one goal, so the registry value is meant to maintain the original goals.
    Expired tapes are always usable / readable by DPM - the only restriction is you only get the option to restore to a network location and not back to original location.  DPM 2012 R2 UR3 did change behavior so the tapes show up on the normal calendar
    and not under external dpm tapes tree, so you may want test that and see if there are other recover options for restoring from once expired tapes.
    Please remember to click “Mark as Answer” on the post that helps you, and to click “Unmark as Answer” if a marked post does not actually answer your question. This can be beneficial to other community members reading the thread. Regards, Mike J. [MSFT]
    This posting is provided "AS IS" with no warranties, and confers no rights.

  • Integration of RMAN with virtual tape library

    OS: Oracle Linux 5.5 UEK (Virtualbox)
    Oracle: 11gR2 11.2.0.1 Enterprise + ASM (Virtualbox)
    Hello,
    I would like to test something about RMAN and writing directly to tape. For this I installed mhvtl, a virtual tape library. The installation was pretty easy. http://sites.google.com/site/linuxvtl2/
    RMAN does not recognize any tape in the system.
    ORA-19554: error allocating device, device type: SBT_TAPE, device name:
    ORA-27211: Failed to load Media Management Library
    What I found out is that in order to make backups to a media manager, RMAN must communicate with a media management library, which is a 3rd party library that is not supplied by Oracle. So I guess unless there is a Oracle MML library available for mtx I' out of luck here.
    Any ideas? Thanks!
    rpm -ivh mhvtl-0.18-13.x86_64.rpm
    rpm -ivh mhvtl-0.18-13.src.rpm
    cd /usr/src/redhat/SOURCES/
    tar zxvf ../SOURCES/mhvtl-2011-01-11.tgz
    cd mhvtl-0.18/kernel
    make
    make install
    /etc/init.d/mhvtl start
    yum install mtx
    The tape library and using it for backup from system seems to work fine:
    # mtx status
    Storage Changer /dev/changer:4 Drives, 43 Slots ( 4 Import/Export )
    Data Transfer Element 0:Full (Storage Element 1 Loaded):VolumeTag = E03001L4
    etc.
    # mtx load 1
    Drive 0 Full (Storage Element 1 loaded)
    # tar cf /dev/ntape ./
    # tar tvf /dev/ntape
    Edited by: Dude on Jan 20, 2011 5:22 PM

    Thanks for the tip!
    I installed Oracle Secure Backup Express and spend all afternoon with this strange product, mainly to troubleshoot the installation and setup. I'm not really sure everything works - it's quite a piece of software, as usual.
    I ran into a couple of issues that were not mentioned in the installation documentation:
    - install sg3_utils
    - use obtool to register the server as mediaserver
    # sg_map -i -x
    /dev/sg9 3 0 1 0 1 /dev/nst0 IBM ULT3580-TD5 550V
    /dev/sg10 3 0 2 0 1 /dev/nst1 IBM ULT3580-TD5 550V
    /dev/sg11 3 0 3 0 1 /dev/nst2 IBM ULT3580-TD4 550V
    /dev/sg12 3 0 4 0 1 /dev/nst3 IBM ULT3580-TD4 550V
    /dev/sg13 3 0 9 0 1 /dev/nst4 IBM ULT3580-TD4 550V
    /dev/sg14 3 0 10 0 1 /dev/nst5 IBM ULT3580-TD4 550V
    /dev/sg15 3 0 11 0 1 /dev/nst6 IBM ULT3580-TD4 550V
    /dev/sg16 3 0 12 0 1 /dev/nst7 IBM ULT3580-TD4 550V
    /dev/sg17 3 0 0 0 8 STK L700 550V
    /dev/sg18 3 0 8 0 8 SPECTRA PYTHON 550V
    # obtool
    ob> chhost --addrole mediaserver ol55
    ob> mkdev -t library -o -a ol55:/dev/sg18 library1
    ob> mkdev -t tape -o -a ol55:/dev/sg9 -l library1 -d 1 tape1
    RMAN was not happy with it:
    ORA-19554: error allocating device, device type: SBT_TAPE, device name:
    ORA-27023: skgfqsbi: media manager protocol error
    ORA-19511: Error received from media manager layer, error text:
    sbt__rpc_connect: Internal error - could not connect to obproxyd (Oracle Secure Backup error: 'bad port name specified (OB SBT proxy manager)').
    # cat /usr/tmp/obproxyd.log
    2011/01/23.02:11:10 [5431] can't set root privileges; continuing anyway - program isn't stamped setuid-root (OB utilities)
    2011/01/23.02:11:10 [5431] can't listen for connections - Operation not permitted
    Document ID 396046.1 solution outlines to correct the hostname or mediaserver name. However, this was not the problem. I finally figured that /etc/obproxyd is a symlink to a .wrapper script which points to the actual proxy application. The fix was:
    #chmod +s /usr/local/oracle/backup/.etc.linux86_64obproxyd
    After this the error changed:
    RMAN-03009: failure of backup command on ORA_SBT_TAPE_1 channel at 01/23/2011 02:43:36
    ORA-19506: failed to create sequential file, name="3cm2q2an_1_1", parms=""
    ORA-27028: skgfqcre: sbtbackup returned error
    ORA-19511: Error received from media manager layer, error text:
    sbt__rpc_cat_query: Query for piece 3cm2q2an_1_1 failed.
    (Oracle Secure Backup error: 'no preauth config found for OS user (OB tools) oracle').
    The fix for this error:
    https://10.0.0.6, login as 'admin'
    Configure->Users->Select Admin->Edit->Preauthorized Access->Add user 'Oracle' (select host and rman)
    RMAN> backup database;
    Starting backup at 23-JAN-11
    using channel ORA_SBT_TAPE_1
    channel ORA_SBT_TAPE_1: starting full datafile backup set
    channel ORA_SBT_TAPE_1: specifying datafile(s) in backup set
    input datafile file number=00001 name=/scratch/oradata/test/system01.dbf
    input datafile file number=00002 name=/scratch/oradata/test/sysaux01.dbf
    input datafile file number=00003 name=/scratch/oradata/test/undotbs01.dbf
    input datafile file number=00005 name=/scratch/oradata/test/users02.dbf
    input datafile file number=00004 name=/scratch/oradata/test/users01.dbf
    channel ORA_SBT_TAPE_1: starting piece 1 at 23-JAN-11
    Now it just sits there forever and the log just keeps adding the following lines:
    # cat obproxyd.log
    2011/01/23.03:00:31 [5662] handle_qsp_msg: received get job state request
    2011/01/23.03:00:31 [5662] job id 'admin/5.1'
    Strange, backup to tape with 'mtx' and 'tar' works, so the problem might be OSB.
    Edited by: Dude on Jan 22, 2011 8:32 PM
    I finally got it running. I deleted the current library and drive configuration and used the webtool to configure the other library at /dev/sg17. it was also necessary to use the webtool to load a volume into the drive. Unfortunately I did not note down the steps in details. Maybe next time.
    channel ORA_SBT_TAPE_1: starting piece 1 at 23-JAN-11
    channel ORA_SBT_TAPE_1: finished piece 1 at 23-JAN-11
    piece handle=3im2qc42_1_1 tag=TAG20110123T053042 comment=API Version 2.0,MMS Version 10.2.0.3
    channel ORA_SBT_TAPE_1: backup set complete, elapsed time: 00:03:26
    Finished backup at 23-JAN-11
    Starting Control File and SPFILE Autobackup at 23-JAN-11
    piece handle=c-2036659790-20110123-00 comment=API Version 2.0,MMS Version 10.2.0.3
    Finished Control File and SPFILE Autobackup at 23-JAN-11

  • Two DPM 2012 R2 Servers - one tape library split logically

    Hi
    We’re looking to purchase a new tape library with two LTO6 drives. 
    We wanted to share the library between the two DPM servers using the tape library sharing option, but to do this we’d need to attach the library via ISCSI as we don’t have a fibre channel SAN. Unfortunately the one I could find only has a 1 GB ISCSI
    Bridge which really isn’t enough to drive the two LTO6 drives that are inside it. 
    So, I’m looking into the idea of SAS attaching the library directly to both DPM servers then partitioning the library into two logical libraries so that each DPM server see’s the library independently. 
    Although the library supports this option, is this supported by DPM and has anyone got their library configured this way? 
    We’re looking at the HP MSL4048 range.
    Many thanks.

    Hi,
    Yes, I can confirm that DPM can work with hardware partitioned libraries. The only problem I see is that each library will only have a single drive, so that means you can only have a single long term recovery goal.
    DPM does tape copies of daily tapes to make the weekly tape, and copies of the weekly tape to make the monthly tapes etc.  You should see a warning when you go throught the PG Wizard if you only have a single tape drive.
    When you go throught the PG Wizard for a PG that has two or more long-term recovery goals specified, and you only have a single tape drive, on the "Specifylibrary and tape details" page, you should see a yellow ! with "Please ensure that there are a minimum
    of two tape drives or two tape libraries for copy backups to succeed.
    Please remember to click “Mark as Answer” on the post that helps you, and to click “Unmark as Answer” if a marked post does not actually answer your question. This can be beneficial to other community members reading the thread. Regards, Mike J. [MSFT]
    This posting is provided "AS IS" with no warranties, and confers no rights.

  • Can restore backupset files from tape library to disk?

    Hi,
    I need to explain my scenario/position:
    We backup our database every night to disk this command:
    configure channel device type disk format "/backup/%d_%T_%s.%U";
    backup filesperset 4 database;
    After backup job is done create a lot of backupset files in /backup directory. And after we backup this backupset files to tape library, this command:
    CONFIGURE CHANNEL DEVICE TYPE 'SBT_TAPE' PARMS 'ENV=(NSR_SERVER=legato, NSR_CLIENT=dbserver)';
    backup device type 'SBT_TAPE' backupset completed after "sysdate-1" format '%d_%T_%s.%U';
    we backed up all backupset files to tape library (SBT_TAPE). And delete backupset files on disk.
    Here my questions:
    How can i restore these backupset files to disk? I dont mean, restore database,datafiles, tablespace etc. I mean restore original backupset files to disks?
    Database version:9.2.0.6 and we use rman catalog database.
    Thanks..

    I'm not sure why manual managment is risky. If you no longer have the music in iTunes (or any other back-up), what difference does manual versus automatic management make? I for one will certainly be the last to argue against backing up files. But I don't see where this is related to how a person chooses to manage their iPod, either manual or auto.
    Scenario 1: Restore iPod, now iPod files are gone, iTunes is empty for whatever reason. Manual versus auto: irrelevant. There's nothing there to manage until iTunes is replenished anyway.
    Scenario 2: Restore iPod, iPod files gone, iTunes still loaded. Manual versus auto: matter of personal preference.
    Scenario 3: iPod is OK, but iTunes is empty for whatever reason. Manual versus auto: ON AUTO, PLUG IN YOUR IPOD AND LOSE EVERYTHING ON IT. On manual, everything on iPod is still safe. Right?
    Sceanrio 4: iPod is OK, iTunes is OK, business as usual. Keep adding songs in iTunes. Manual versus auto: matter of personal preference.
    Scenario 3 is enough to keep me away from auto. I bow to the opinions of all you experienced folks out there, but I've read so many posts from the iPod veterans suggesting to the newbies that they use auto management and back-up their files. I agree with the back-up suggestion, but I whole heartedly disagree that auto management is better and manual management is risky. I don't understand why manual would be more risky than auto. In fact, it seems to me that auto would be more risky.
    I like manual: things aren't happening out of my control. I control what's on iPod, I control what's in iTunes. If I want to add to or delete from one or the other but not both, I have that freedom. I see no risk.
    Can someone explain to me if I'm misunderstanding or missing something?

Maybe you are looking for