Time to buy FCP X?

I'm hoping the community can help me with a decision.
I am not a professional editor.  I consider myself a serious hobbyist, creating multi-cam “event videography” or documentary videography (as opposed to fictional narrative/story-telling type of movie making).
I was very excited when I watched the NAB video demonstrating FCP X, and was anxious to purchase it when it was released, hoping I would get affordable access to simplified color correction and the ability to view multi-camera shots (I assumed, since it had been a part of FCS).
I have read many postings about FCP X, many of which focused on complaints about this new version. Two things that sent up red flags for me:
FCP X does not allow the user to     set the scratch disc. Does this limitation have something to do with     how the program utilizes the 64-bit/multi-core features of the newer     Macs?And
There is no multi-cam view     editing (at least nothing that I can't do now with FCE).
Several posts have suggested  that Apple has assured users that the multi-cam editing feature will be included in future upgrades/versions, although I've personally been unable to find anything about this provided directly from the Apple web site.
I'm very familiar, (although by no means an expert) with FCE.  I am not at all familiar with iMovie.
In your opinion, should I purchase FCPX and start learning it, with whatever shortcomings exist (and with crossed fingers that multi-cam will be added in the future)
OR
start using iMovie to help familiarize myself with that software's “architecture”--if that's the correct use of the term—in anticipation of the “new and improved FCP X” due sometime in the future (and in the meantime, spend my money on a Blu-ray burner or another external hard drive)?
Thanks for your time and input.
Gary

I'm not sure this will help you.
I have never used fce, I have never used iMovie. I opened iMovie for the first time ever about 6 months ago - too weird and closed it after about 15 mins.
I have used fcp since 1.5 and am familiar/comfortble/profficient with it. I used to be full-time in video editing/camera/production but not all that busy in that area for a couple of years.
I am not going to install fcpx 'til it's fixed or at least until there's a clear sign that Apple are going to reinstate the missing features from Fcp 7. Heck why bother to learn it if they don't reinstate them - it'll become some ******* child of the editing world. No use in a production environment.
AAPL look like they're trying to reinvent the wheel with this release - and reposition the product altogether.
I'll wait until it becomes clear - because I can. Other users will not want to wait and have to move to whatever tool works for them in their workflow.
It may be perfect for you.

Similar Messages

  • Is now the time to buy FCP?

    I own the original Final Cut Studio. I just bought a new Mac Pro eight core. I'm considering the latest version but don't know if the timing is right. When was the last time FCP was updated? Buy now or wait? The upgrade from FCP Studio is $499 from Apple.

    Absolutely not.
    NAB2009 is a couple of weeks away.
    The last major upgrade was two years ago.
    History shows a two year upgrade cycle with release or announcement associated with NAB.
    No assurances, but I'd wait until then.

  • Is there a discount to buy FCP X if you already own FCP7?

    Is there a discount to buy FCP X if you already own FCP7? I just purchased a copy not to long ago...

    Apple has changed their pricing models with the App Store. 
    Basically there is no longer such a thing as an "upgrade" price.  There's just a "full" price.  Every time you get a major new edition you pay the "full" price again (but software updates within that major version are free). 
    While this sounds bad... they've offset that by just lowering the price of new software in general. 
    If you total up what you'd spend for your initial "full" price for software plus the price of each incremental "upgrade" edition of the software (times however many upgrade versions you buy) and then compare it to that same number of "full" prices versions purchased at the App Store, you'll find that you're still saving money at the App Store.  So while there is no "upgrade" price anymore... you're still coming out ahead.
    My issue with the new Final Cut Pro X is that I think it's such a disappointment that it's not even worth the reduced $300 price.  I basically view this software as an advanced edition of iMovie and I think it should have been priced as such.

  • HT1911 Why does Itunes have me logging in multiple times to buy a song? Somehow, my account got disabled now. It also shows that I am logged in....?

    Why does itunes have me logging in multiple times to buy a song? I can access everything else fine, but now my account is disabled for some reason although my password was entered correctly... help

    I've seen a couple of other threads over the last 10 minutes posting similar problems, so it appears to have affected other people as well - the poster on the first thread has now posted again saying that it's now working for him, so you could give it another try.
    Edit : your reply appeared as I was attempting to post this

  • The Time To Buy iPad, Or Not?

    Hey everyone,
    I have been thinking about buying the iPad ever since it came out and to this date have not been able to. I have the money, but is now the time to spend it on that 9.7" beauty? I would like to use it for web surfing, email, apps(of course), and I would also like to pick up on the reading for the rest of high school. This is the time for me, I need to decide in the very, very near future. I need two burning questions answered though, is it the right time to buy? Also, Which one to get? As far as which one to get, I plan to use this mostly around home and of course whenever I travel. I think that as far as videos go, I would be putting a few on when I take some trips then take them off if I find myself not viewing them often. I would always have my computer relatively close though, so I would be able to get content on and off quick.
    Merging into the next question, I would only get the 32GB if I would have it for a while. If the next one would have killer features then maybe I should wait off for the next generation. The feature that I think is guaranteed is a front facing video camera, I don't think that I have a huge need with that. I have my MacBook Pro for most of the stuff like that. I don't know how much I would desperately need the speed bump that could also surface next spring, because, like I said I have a laptop that I do a good amount on. Or do I not need one at this time? I am a big fanboy so this product is in my mind a great buy.
    I need some help here, just tell me what you think. Anyone who has been in the same situation or is in it themselves, feel free to chime in.
    Thanks for any help.
    SIDE NOTE!!!!!: If anyone has some thoughts about refurb iPads coming up, tell me as well. I don't think they are coming since it has been a while.

    I just got my 32gb 3G iPad about a week ago for my bday and I'm absolutely loving it. I was planning on buying one myself but was saving up for it. Anyway since it had been a few months since it came out I thought to myself that if I waited this long couldn't I just wait till the 2nd gen but I decided that I still wanted it. Also I figured if the 2nd gen came out and if it had some feature that I just couldn't live without that I could probably sell my 1st gen iPad for a good amount. I've owned every version of the iPhone (except the 3Gs) and I've always been able to resell them for a good price.
    The reason I wanted the 3G was in case I wanted to use my iPad somewhere wifi wasn't available. But so far I haven't had to activate the 3G service.
    The other thing I love about my iPad is that it really is useful. I've only used my laptop to add movies to my iPad Undoubtedly when school begins I'll need to laptop for writing papers and such. But otherwise my iPad is perfect for carrying around and using everywhere. Until the iPad I was considering buying a new MacBook Pro 13" because my 15" (almost 3yrs old) was just to heavy and cumbersome and I didn't like carting it around, even in the house (4 floors).
    Anyways the point of this rambling is if you want an iPad go ahead and get it now.

  • Opinion - MacBook Pro  -is now the time to buy?

    I am looking to replace a 2006 MacBook Core Duo 2 Ghz wi 2 GB RAM and a 500 GB drive with either a 15 or 17 MB Pro with Matte screen (4 GB and 500 GB drive). They have the high end 15 and 17 in stock with matte screens at my local Apple Store.
    Is now the time to buy?
    Three things give me pause so I am looking for some advice.
    1. Hard drive related beach balls - especially on 7200 rpm drives.
    2. Is the 15 or 17 any more or less prone to these troubles? Is the 5400 rpm 500 GB drive a surer bet?
    3. Potential speed bumps to coincide with new cheaper MacBook releases.
    Those who have bought recently - is the hard drive beach ball, 30 - 40 second hang issue resolved?
    Just generally, would you wait to see if there are any changes to the MacBook Pro specs (a la speed bump) with the impending Mini, iMac, MacBook announcements?
    Message was edited by: Joseph Nowak
    Message was edited by: Joseph Nowak

    For the 15" the time to buy, for me, was before they jettisoned the express card slot My ideal would be a 13" with an express card and the dual graphics chips - oh well I'm not holding my breath for that one. I'm glad I got my 15" while they were still offering express card although I might have been willing to trade that for the smaller footprint of the 13" if it would have been available at the time. I love my 15", but it is big (esp. coming from a 12" PB G4).
    As for beach ball speed issues - I think all the shipping MacBook Pro's (at least the 15" and 17") can take 8 gigs of RAM - I would get the base memory from Apple and then upgrade after the fact. I bumped my late 2008 MBP (typing on it now) to it's max of six Gigs RAM and it made a noticeable difference.
    And as far as performance, even 7200 rpm notebook drives are slugs compared to their desktop cousins; and compared to the speed increases in every other component in personal computers, mechanical hard drives are glacially slow slugs.
    If you really want maximum performance, you need to do what I am getting ready to. Skip the 7200 RPM drive and replace your primary drive with a solid state drive (but do your research - not all SSD's are created equal and some may be slower then a traditional hard drive!). Since I'm not about to pay more for an SSD then the purchase price of my computer, I'm going to get a smaller one (corsair makes a 160GB that looks nice), and remove my optical drive (hardly every use it anyway). In the optical drives place I will put a 500GB drive with one of several kits out there that provide a mounting bracket for the second drive. Best of all worlds - OS and applications on the ultra fast SSD, bulk of my data on the more spacious traditional drive.
    CPU and Video are pretty darn fast across the board, even with the base configurations. These days the hard drive is THE speed bottle neck in computers...
    Message was edited by: Eric Eskam

  • Is now the time to buy? (The CREATIVE ZEN 8

    I want to know if now is the time to buy, people on these forums don't seem happy although I have read reviews on amazon/play etc. and they are good on the whole
    In a slightly off-topic way: I hear that video playback is limited in resolution. I have x-vid videos with width 624 and height 352 pixels. Normally I convert them to MP4 with PSP Video 9. Will the x-vids work on the Zen or will even the converted .mp4 work
    Many thankz for help.

    everything is great on the zen. Appearance, video converter is great and even crops widecreen videos to 4:3 without stretching, sound quality is great and has a bass boost which is a v nice extra . The only thing which lets it down is the battery life, can perform well straight after a charge ( ran a whole 2h30mins film losing under half life) but tends to drain when not being used a fair bit. Having said that it is however a lithium ion battery (like in a laptop) so cant be overcharged unless u leave it long enough to overheat and damage, and also can be topped up all the time.
    Neway i say get it it's the best media player out atm i reakon

  • Time to buy?

    OK, I've been waiting since June for Apple to iron out any problems with the MacBooks before I replace my 12" PowerBook G4. Are the newer models better? Is now a good time to buy?
    Looking to buy from John Lewis (UK) who offer a 2 year warrantee as standard. Thought this might be best on a portable.
    Any happy customers out there?
    Dual 2Gh G5   Mac OS X (10.4.6)  

    Yes, I would say now is a great time to buy. I just got my Macbook about a week ago and it has been flawless. And with Core 2 Duo the speed is amazing.

  • HT5188 Nearly every time I buy a VPP app and download the spreadsheet there are multiple redemption codes that say that they are invalid!  HOW can a code I am getting directly from apple be invalid!!!!!!!!  Seems like your system has A LOT of flaws.

    Nearly every time I buy a VPP app and download the spreadsheet there are multiple redemption codes that say that they are invalid!  HOW can a code I am getting directly from apple be invalid!!!!!!!!  Seems like your system has A LOT of flaws.

    I have taken it back to the Apple store genius bar, but they say they don't see anything wrong. Well unless you use it all day and experience the problems when they happen, you wont see anything wrong. But there are lots wrong with it. But this would be the same store as I purchased the phone. And they backed up my old Iphone 4, but were not able to get anything to load back onto my new phone. So, I lost pretty much everything. But over time, some of my contacts have started showing up, although i am still missing over 800 of them.

  • HT1491 I want my ipad to ask for my password every time I buy something, is that possible?

    I want my ipad to ask for my password every time I buy something, can anyone help?

    Settings>General>Restrictions>Require Password>Immediately

  • HT203208 Why do I have to keep putting in my security code every time I buy?

    I have to put in my credit card's security code every time I buy something from iTunes. I seem to be the only person that has to do this because I've asked friends and they don't have to do this. Is there a setting I need to change in my iTunes profile?
    Thanks in advance.

    No Problem Demo.. They said to keep trying they would get back to me later this week, she had to talk to the tech people that has a longer history than what she has availabe.. We also ran the diagnostics on the ipad and all is fine with the firmware and the battery.
    One thing that leads me to believe i am locked out of the servers, when i do a restore through itunes I get that little lock in the window just above where it says the servers are unavailable.
    I have also been intouch with verizon and they said they would run some diagnostics on there end and would get back to me, that was 2 weeks ago.
    Thats what I like about apple they're good on the follow up.

  • Favorite effects gone every time I start FCP

    This is getting frustrating...
    Every time I launch FCP 5, it treats me as a first time user. It looks like my preferences are not saving when I log out and shut down. I have created a new user account and have been using that for a week, but this morning as soon as I launched the editing software it asks to choose a set-up (AV setting) and move my windows to the default location. The favorite effects are gone and all of the user and system preferences are reset to default or day-one configuration. has anyone else experinced this and did you resolve it?
    thanks

    Have you tried trashing prefs and starting them again?
    Sounds like a corruption.
    Tried http://fcprescue.andersholck.com/ ?
    This is a great free program.

  • Do you have to redeem your iTunes gift card every time you buy something? Or does it take money off the card automatically?

    Do you have to redeem your iTunes gift card every time you buy something? Or does it take money off the card automatically?

    As far as I know redeeming a card simply adds the value to your account.
    When I credit a gift card I get a credit appearing in my iTunes account.
    Every time I buy something the cost is deducted from my 'iTunes credit', the card is no lobger needed or usable after redemption.
    AC

  • Length of Burn longer than shown on time line in FCP 4.5 HD

    Have an 8 minute-30 second movie. When I send it to compressor then to DVD Pro 3 it burns at 41 minutes and 15 seconds and takes about 3 and a 1/2 hours
    to burn. The time line in FCP 4.5 HD shows ,as stated 8' 30". When the disc is played back it goes to black after the 8'30" movie but continues to run out to 41'-15". Help is greatly appreciated.

    Check your FCP timeline and that you do not have any stray clips past the 8:30
    Or just mark 8:30 as out point, export as self contained using In/Out points and encode that - but I would bet there is something in the timeline in FCP

  • When is it time to buy a new laptop rather than upgrade existing?

    My daughter has a Macbook with the following config:
    Model Name:                          MacBook
      Model Identifier:                   MacBook4,1
      Processor Name:                   Intel Core 2 Duo
      Processor Speed:                   2.1 GHz
      Number Of Processors:         1
      Total Number Of Cores:        2
      L2 Cache:                              3 MB
      Memory:                               2 GB
      Bus Speed:                            800 MHz
      Boot ROM Version:              MB41.00C1.B00
      SMC Version (system):         1.31f1
    We have upgraded hard drive, etc, but her system is gumming up. When is it time to buy new rather than refresh/upgrade??
    Thanks!!

    You can still upgrade the RAM to 4GB (or even 6GB under some circumstances) http://www.everymac.com/systems/apple/macbook/stats/macbook-core-2-duo-2.4-white -13-early-2008-penryn-specs.html
    But this doesn't help in general with slowness.
    Have a read here http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1342 on how-to use the Activity Monitor to determine whether the MacBook is suffering from too low RAM.
    Especially on the amount of page-outs which are the indication that you are short on RAM.
    Since you already upgraded the harddisk I assume the MacBook don't suffer from too little free diskspace.
    When buying a new macBook I would start with the Refurbished section on Apples Online Store.
    Some great findings/savings there to make.
    My two current Macs (iMac and Mac Pro) are refurbished ones.
    Stefan

Maybe you are looking for