To get best MPEG2 compression?

I've got to master out a 90 minute film tonight. It was produced in DV NTSC Anamorphic. Does anyone know if I can get a better MPEG2 compression (with Compressor) going from the DV NTSC Anamorphic timeline - or from an 8 bit 'uncompressed' timeline? Would the end result look any different?
I recently mastered a show from an HDV timeline out to MPEG2 (Compressor) and got not so happy results. I seem to remember getting better results from this combo with earlier versions of Compressor.
Any suggestions would be most appreciated,
Ben

RESULTS:
Put the DV NTSC anamorphic onto an 8 bit uncompressed timeline (all I changed was the compression format in the sequences settings box).
Output through Compressor to best 90 min, tweaking the bit rate up: average 6.6, maximum 7.8.
The results were mind-boggling. This DV NTSC looked as good as the Hollywood rental DVD's ... given the whole show was built using graphics and stills, not live-action.
I played the mv2 (MPEG2) with the MPEG Streamclip player ... which may have made a bit of a difference.
I was 100% thrilled. I'm going back to last week's HDV project, and re-author the DVD, trying this technique with HDV.

Similar Messages

  • New to 16x9 format, how get best quality when using standard dv footage?

    If I am capturing standard NTSC dv footage, and adding standard dimension digital photos, what capture and sequence settings should I use to get best looking 16x9 output? I know I can export as 16x9 and burn a 16x9 DVD in DVDSP, but I was thinking I should capture and edit that way as well to get best quality.
    Thus far, I've been editing everything as 4x3 and assuming the tv's these will be shown on will compensate, which is generally true. I would like, however, to give my clients the option of which output option is best for them.

    So, a client would have to give me 16x9 raw footage for me to produce a true 16x9 DVD?
    Yes.
    I know I can't produce HD DVDs, at least not cost effectively, and most people don't have players anyway.
    Right. None of us can. The movies from the store or Netflix aren't HD. HD has no current relevance in DVD production (other than as acquisition formats).
    I do want their footage to look as good as
    possible on those large screen tvs.
    If you produce a good DVD it will look good. All the other DVDs that are 4:3 are just that - 4:3. Same with 4:3 television. If they were produced well they should look great on any screen.
    1. I'm starting with DV NTSC raw footage, a low-res
    codec.
    OK.
    2. I'm compressing to MPEG-2 to be playable on an
    SD-DVD player, a further low res codec.
    OK. But you really mean "to be playable on a DVD player".
    3. Regardless of what I do, it's going to be
    low-res.
    Regardless of what you do, the resolution is limited by current DVD technology. That is, in the NTSC world, 720x480 whether it's 4:3 or 16:9.
    Does MPEG-2 always look crappy on an HDTV? On a 72dpi SDTV, it looks acceptable. Is there a workaround for HDTV?
    Whether or not it looks crappy is subjective. If Hollywood-produced DVDs and SD television look great on it, then it's possible to make it look great.
    Your real limitations - the ones you have control over, are:
    - quality of camera, glass, and related equipment
    - quality of lighting, audio, camerawork, production in general
    - recording format (DV ain't the greatest).
    - editing format (hint: you don't have to edit in DV)
    - quality of editing / editor
    - quality of MPEG2 encoding
    In your case I think the last one is the most relevant. If you aren't getting acceptable results you may need to learn more about MPEG2 and Compressor.
    BTW 72dpi is a print term, it has absolutely no meaning in video.
    Further question, if I'm doing a photo slideshow, not DV footage, can I leave it uncompressed or will it convert to MPEG-2 and stink regardless?
    To make a DVD movie it needs to be MPEG-2. That's the technology we have. But it doesn't have to stink. The MPEG-2 you use is the same MPEG2 the studios use with movie releases. The technology is the same, the difference is that they have people who really really know how to use it well.
    There is a way to make actual slideshows from JPEGs which play from a DVD or CD. I know little about this, but I suspect that the resolution is still limited to 720x480. Someone will correct me if that's wrong. But you don't have to put them through MPEG2 compression.
    You may benefit from finding out what 16:9 really means. All it means is that the display is wider. That's all. There is no implication of a quality increase, in fact from DVD playback the 16:9 picture will always appear a little softer than SD if viewed on a widescreen device. That's just the way it is.

  • Best mp4 compression possible for 50" TV

    Hi,
    I need to compressed my project (24fps, 1080p from FCP) to mp4 which will be run on a 50' TV via a computer (not sure what software but I was told it needs to be in mp4 format). If size isn't a factor, what's the best possible compression to get a very good quality on mp4 format?  Should I take the mpeg-4 setting and modify the bit rate to HIGH VBR? 
    Any help appreciated.

    The High VBR should do a decent job. Whether it's the best you can do will require some testing on your end.
    There was a recent thread on working from the H.264 presets and simply changing the extension to MP4 after encoding the file. I'm not sure whether that would work or not, but you could try. It certainly would give you comprehensive control over your quality.
    Alternatively, you could use MPEG Streamclip, which offers pretty good control but will definitely put your file in an MP4 wrapper.
    Russ

  • Burning iTunes Plus and other 256 bit rate material to get best quality?

    I understand that iTunes Plus and most songs on Amazon are provided at a higher bit rate than non-Plus iTunes songs in order to provide higher audio quality on playback. But, does this quality differential come through when burning a song to disc from within iTunes?
    I ask because of an experiment I just conducted. I downloaded the same song from iTunes (not a Plus version) and from Amazon. The Amazon version takes up twice as much file space as the iTunes version. (The ACC file at 128kbps was 5MB while the MPEG file at 256 kbps was 11.6MB.) However, when I burned both songs to a CD, those files where identical in size. Further, when played on a near-audiophile stereo system, I could hear no discernible difference between the two.
    So the question: Does whatever extra information and hence sound quality contained in the Plus or other 256 kbps material get lost in the conversion to audio CD format? Are there settings in iTunes I'm missing? Are there alternative software or file formats available that would burn audio CDs without this loss?
    (I realize that whatever difference there is in sound quality would not be detectable on most equipment. What I'm looking for is to preserve quality differences that can be heard on high-end equipment. As it is, I'm able to tell the difference between well-recorded and produced commercial CDs and the same material bought through iTunes.)

    The quality of compressed audio is not always linked to file size. I believe it is possible for a 128 kbps AAC file to sound as good as a 256 kbps MP3 file. MP3 is not the best audio compression format but it is by far the most commonplace. A 128 kbps AAC file isn't as good as a 192 kbps AAC file, however.
    When your audio files were uncompressed for burning to audio CD they naturally became the same size because there no longer was any compression.
    If your objective is to have audio CDs that sound best on high-end equipment then you should continue buying audio CDs rather than purchasing on-line music. That way there is no loss in audio quality from compression. I'm not aware of a source that is selling lossless on-line music downloads.

  • How can i get best practice for SD and MM

    Please, can any body tell me how can i get best practices for SD and MM for functional approach?
    Thanks
    Utpal

    Hello Utpal,
    I am really surprised, in just 10 minutes you searched that site and found it not useful. <b>Check out my previous reply "you will not find screen shot in this but you can add it in this"</b>
    You will not find readymade document, you need to add this as per your requirement.
    btw, the following link gives you some more link for new SAP guys, this will be helpful. <b>Check out HOW to BASIC transaction</b>
    New to Materials Management / Warehouse Management?
    Hope this helps.
    Regards
    Arif Mansuri

  • What settings do I need to get best quality Word (mac office 2011) to Acrobat 9?

    What settings do I need to get best quality Word (mac office 2011) to Acrobat 9?And what is best method, save as from Word, or create from Acrobat?

    Thank you Steve! For the benefit of anyone following this thread, if Acrobat tab does not show in Word
    This add-in may be disabled in Word. We can try to re-enable it:
    =============
    1. Open Word program.
    2. Click the Office button. Then click the Word Options button.
    3. Click Add-Ins.
    4. From the Manage dropdown list select Disabled Items and click Go.
    5. Check the list for PDFMakerOfficeAddin:
    1)      If it is listed, then select it and click Enable. Close all dialog boxes and restart the Word program.
    2)      If it is not listed, then make sure that PDFMOfficeAddin.dll is located in the ‘…/Program Files/Adobe/Acrobat 8.0/PDFMaker/Office’ folder. If the file is missing, then reinstall Acrobat.
    For the detailed troubleshoot steps, you can refer to the link below:
    http://acrobat.timhuff.net/?p=29

  • Working with HD m2ts files to get best video out burned on disk.

    Working with m2ts video files, how to get best video output.  I have Pinnacle 12U and the video picture that is produced on a burned disk is much better then what is produced in Adobe Premieme PRO CS4.  I would like to continue to use Premieme Pro, but unless I can archive at least the same quality of video it would be hard to make the switch.  I must be missing something???  HELP!!

    More input,  the media file output is VTS.VOB format from Adobe and from Pinnacle it is m2ts.  When you stop the playback m2ts is real sharp and the the VOB is not as clear.  During the playback the m2ts disk is so much better than the Adobe VOB format.
    Does anyone know if this is the best format that Adobe can produce?   It's a shame that with the great High Definition picture that you can now get out of a personal movie camera, that Adobe cannot produce the same quality picture out on disk!!

  • Brand new to video editing and thus brand new to Final Cut...How can I best get started.  We created a video to put on our website.  I want to be able to edit to get best clips/thoughts.  Thank you!

    We are brand new to Final Cut.  We have video we would like to edit to get best clips.  Can someone provide best tips for getting started?

    Or better yet get a good book or online training like this
    http://www.fcpxbook.com
    I stand to profit from this message.

  • M-Audio Fast Track, how to get best results?

    Hey guys.
    I just got my M-Audio Fast Track. It seems quite cool. Not really to sure what to do with it though!
    I'm using it to record guitars and vocals into GB.
    So how can i set it up to get best results?
    Right now I have my Audio System Preferences set to Built in Audio for In and Out, but in GB preferences I have Input set to FastTrack and Out set to Built-In...
    It seems to be quite quiet, quieter than if i plug my guitar directly into the iMacs line in...?
    Cheers
    jim
    P.S. Please don't bother writing about how I should have bought a Firewire device or anything else, I'm a cheap *** student, I bought what I could!

    Jim
    I have just bought one and the sound is good. I monitor sound thru my HI_FI system. The settings I have are:
    1. Leave sound settings alone in system preferences.
    2. In GB2 I have set input and output devices to fast track. (By the way there are no drivers available for this device - it is natively supported by OS X)
    To adjust volume I have to adjust the right hand output volume knob on the front of the Fast track. My G5 system volume control has no effect on the fast track.
    Andrew

  • How to get best material for Oracle 10G PL/SQL

    Please help me out to get best material for Oracle 10G PL/SQL form oracle site.
    Thanks in Advance

    There's no special book or material related Oracle 10g PL/SQL. Can you explain what you want ?
    Please refer to this page for more information:
    http://www.oracle.com/technology/tech/pl_sql/index.html
    Edited by: Kamran Agayev A. on Aug 14, 2009 11:41 AM

  • Now how to create a tsql to get best result.

    Hi all
    I have a table that called   voucheritem
    This table has 6 fields
    And my standard value is:
    Rows
    Rules
    Subsidiary
    1ad
    2ad
    3ad
    4ad
    5ad
    1
    Rule 1
    2050  
    103
    207
    396
    452
    509
    2
    Rule 2
    2050
    107
    210
    354
    431
    580
    Row 1 : I want to compare rule1 and the table values (voucheritem), when the values are opposite of each other then show the values
    Row2 : I want to compare rule2 and the table values (voucheritem), when the values are opposite of each other then show the values
    I run this code:
    Select * from
    voucheritem
    Result is
    Rows
    Subsidiary
    1ad
    2ad
    3ad
    4ad
    5ad
    1
    2050  
    103
    208
    396
    452
    509
    2
    2050
    107
    210
    354
    435
    580
    3
    2050
    110
    210
    300
    430
    590
    4
    2050
    100
    207
    396
    452
    510
    5
    2050
    107
    210
    360
    431
    580
    6
    2050
    103
    207
    396
    452
    509
    7
    2050
    107
    210
    354
    431
    580
    see row 1 :
    2ad has 208 value its not equal by rule 1
    row 2: 4ad has  435 value . its not equal by rule 2
     Now how to create a tsql to  get best result.
    Name of Allah, Most Gracious, Most Merciful and He created the human

    Does this do what you were looking for?
    DECLARE @rules TABLE (ruleID INT, subsidiary INT, ad1 INT, ad2 INT, ad3 INT, ad4 INT, ad5 INT)
    INSERT INTO @rules (ruleID, subsidiary, ad1, ad2, ad3, ad4, ad5)
    values
    (1,2050,103,207,396,452,509),
    (2,2050,107,210,354,431,580)
    DECLARE @voucheritem TABLE (voucherID INT, subsidiary INT, ad1 INT, ad2 INT, ad3 INT, ad4 INT, ad5 INT)
    INSERT INTO @voucheritem (voucherID, subsidiary, ad1, ad2, ad3, ad4, ad5)
    values
    (1, 2050, 103, 208, 396, 452, 509),
    (2, 2050, 107, 210, 354, 435, 580),
    (3, 2050, 110, 210, 300, 430, 590),
    (4, 2050, 100, 207, 396, 452, 510),
    (5, 2050, 107, 210, 360, 431, 580),
    (6, 2050, 103, 207, 396, 452, 509),
    (7, 2050, 107, 210, 354, 431, 580)
    SELECT v.*,
    CASE WHEN v.ad1 NOT IN (SELECT ad1 FROM @rules) THEN 'E' ELSE NULL END AS ad1Error,
    CASE WHEN v.ad2 NOT IN (SELECT ad2 FROM @rules) THEN 'E' ELSE NULL END AS ad2Error,
    CASE WHEN v.ad3 NOT IN (SELECT ad3 FROM @rules) THEN 'E' ELSE NULL END AS ad3Error,
    CASE WHEN v.ad4 NOT IN (SELECT ad4 FROM @rules) THEN 'E' ELSE NULL END AS ad4Error,
    CASE WHEN v.ad5 NOT IN (SELECT ad5 FROM @rules) THEN 'E' ELSE NULL END AS ad5Error
    FROM @voucheritem v
    LEFT OUTER JOIN @rules r
    ON v.ad1 = r.ad1
    AND v.ad2 = r.ad2
    AND v.ad3 = r.ad3
    AND v.ad4 = r.ad4
    AND v.ad5 = r.ad5
    WHERE r.ruleID IS null

  • Best File Compression Software

    What is the best file compression software on Mac OSX in terms of both user-friendliness and performance?

    Stuffit Deluxe's native .sitx archives make the smallest files. You can even set the compression rate. Smaller will take more time, but of course, saves more space. It's all I and my client's use. It even compresses .jpg images quite a bit, whereas .zip does almost nothing to them.
    There are drawbacks to all formats, though. Zip and Stuffit both do a lousy job on video files. RAR will usually cut the size down by at least half. But the only way to create RAR files on the Mac is through the Terminal. It astounds me that no one has come up with an OS X native application for this. Or that Stuffit hasn't added it to their choices. Stuffit can open RAR files, so they obviously know how the compression scheme works. Why not add the option to create them?
    As far as someone opening the Stuffit files you create? All a person needs to do is download the free Expander if they don't own Stuffit Deluxe or Standard.

  • How to get Best practices solution

    Hi,
           We want to apply Best practices in our server.
           Please inform how to get best practices by solution manager or SAP servive merket place.
    Best regards,
       Gaito

    Use your Secure user id to login to hxxp://service.sap.com . Click on "Quick Links" on top right corner of market place. Under "Software downloads", navigate to "Installations and Upgrades" link.
    You can search for "Best Practices" from here.

  • Best file compression utility?

    What is the best file compression utility for the mac, and i mean the one that will compress the file the most.
    I want to compress a disk image to make it smaller. I remember downloading a file one time that compressed a dmg even further, but can't remember it.

    yeah i do realize a disk image (dmg) is already compressed, but i swore i found a dmg that was zipped into another format one time that compressed it even further.
    Do you know if the new Stuffit 12 STANDARD does the same compression as DELUXE? i really don't need all the extras deluxe offers for $80....

  • Hey All, what is the best file compression app to compress large video file on my Mac Book Pro?

    Hey All, do you recommend compressor 4 or what is the best file compression app to compress large video file on my Mac Book Pro?

    X,
    Thanks for checking in.  The anwser to your questions are below.
    Where is the material coming from?
    These are MP4 files from my Canon vixia HFR40
    What software are you using to edit the material?
    I am using iMOVIE 9.0.9
    What do you want to do with the files after compression? I want to email I need to have the file be smaller than 100MB to send.
    I am an actor and I video tape my auditions and send them to my agent so I need Highest Quality HD files that have small file sizes, no more than 100MB.  The scenes are like 1-5 Mins long in most cases. Thanks for your help.

Maybe you are looking for

  • I can't believe I fixed my Shuffle!

    After suffering all the problems with the latest version of the firmware/drivers and iTunes updates, I had a shuffle that couldn't be synced, couldn't be recognized, and couldn't play. Guess what? I fixed it and it now works better than ever, with va

  • Programmatic launch of reader 11.0.3 won't open file with spaces in the path?

    The application I work on uses a PDF file for online help.  We programmatically launch the help file into the user's PDF viewer.  The path to the help file may have spaces in the directory names or filename.  With previous versions of Adobe Reader, i

  • IPhone will not power on after update

    Dear Apple, I currently have your iPhone 3GS which I received approximately 18 months ago. However, after updating the OS Software the device has decided to not power on. After speaking to your Apple Support Centre, they booked me an appointment at A

  • Post Goods Receipt for Inbound Delivery using WHSCON IDoc

    Dear All Currently I am working on a big project dealing with EDI connections to our logistics partner for the Export business. The entire message flow between Lindt and our partner should be via EDI. Our SAP release is (still) 4.6c. We will create t

  • Manual infiniband installation -  ib_sdp not found

    I've asked oracle support for a guide on how to do this but they aren't being helpful. Before upgrading to 2.6.32-300.7.1.el5uek I had to remove all the infiniband drivers now I'm trying to get it working again. Everything worked previously. Installi