Tweaking compression for YouTube
I am trying to make the best possible files for uploading to YouTube. I am working with HDV Quicktimes exported from FCP and compressing using the AIC codec and a frame size of 640x360, as YouTube requires for 16:9. The longest file is 10:30 and comes in at 1.14 gig, just over the YouTube limit. I can't find a way to change the codec to reduce the file size. Is there any way to adjust quality with this codec?
Changing the frame size from 1440x1080 to 640x360 would have largely done the trick, I would have thought. But it doesn't seem to make much difference. In fact, I exported 2 versions out of FCP, one at the original frame size and one at 640x360 and both files are the same size! Can't for the life of me figure out why that is.
If anyone has any tips about compressing for YouTube channels, please let me know. Ideally we would upload files just under a gig so that YouTube's compression doesn't completely kill the quality.
Thanks.
I followed everything kenstone said. Still having problems. Here's the new link...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4cBrDO9wqY4
The video is playing choppily, and now I'm even losing synch. What's going on?
Similar Messages
-
What is the best compression for youtube videos ?
I know I can go in export movie, then chosse medium for youtube, but is there a better compression because when I upload it on youtube, the quality is much lower. Should i export with QuickTime or i dunno ?
Thnx for aswering !!What is your source material? If it is DV, then sending to YouTube in the Medium Preset is fine.
If your source is AVCHD, you could import at 1920x1080. Then after editing, share using QuickTime at 1280x720 in h.264. Then upload to YouTube through the website. -
Hello All, Does it matter which format and Codec I choose for sending a video to YouTube since most people will be watching it from there, or should I take into consideration people who may want to download. I recently sent a video to YouTube and some people are experiencing the video stopping during playback, so i need to figure out what I can do to make it play back smoothly and continuously.
Thank You
CrisChris:
An H264 file at standard defintion sizes and a bitrate of about 3 Mbps should work very, very well as a source for YouTube.
Yes, you could produce the largest file they let you upload, but it's also true that pristine quality is really not their main concern for encoding, so you could spend your life uploading gigantic files and get modest improvements in quality.
If quality is your main concern, I'd take a look at Vimeo.
Since YouTube is so popular, you may prefer the trade-off. In any case, uploading an H264 file with specs similar to those I described above should work fine. Using 2 pass VBR encoding in AME standalone can help in getting the most out of the bitrate. -
Compressing for YouTube or MySpace online video
i'm wondering what is smoothest compressor and settings for put up a 1 minute and 3 minute film clip are,
coming out of Final Cut Pro 4.
i'm putting these clips up on YouTube and MySpace.
thanks,
kyle
ibook 1 gig Mac OS X (10.3.7)I think there's been a lot of discussion on this so you should do a search as there might be better methods. <
Lord, yes, even on the sites themselves! Imagine that! Look for "Guidelines for creating and uploading your won stuff."
Uploading depends on your connection speed so file size is crucial. The compression is extremem so there's no real need to waste time uploading DV. You can go to MP4 or another decent encode and save yourself lots of time going up the pipe, plus a lower rez file takes much less time to process at the other end.
bogiesan -
Compression for YouTube, to less than 100MB
Hello - I followed YouTube's instructions, and have been compressing from FCP, to MPEG-4. All's good - it looks great, client's happy. I now have quite a larger file, that another client would like to upload to YouTube, but it's well over 100MB, in the 145MB area, and about 9 1/2 min. How can I compress, so I can keep that nice quality, but put it under 100MB? Thanks so much!
YouTube has a *2 gigabyte* upload limit. But you still have to come in at under 10 minutes.
The last piece that I put up was a 900MB DV PAL file. Took a while but it looks fantastic. -
24P Compression for YouTube?
I shot this video on a DVX100B in both 24P and 60i. I exported from FCE using H264 as a quicktime with an automatic data rate, Best Quality preset, current frame rate, 768x576 dimensions (native is listed as 557x417), and key frames every 24 frames. Here's the video:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=br3-Z-t9vHU
As you can see, there are horizontal lines on the video during quick motion in all scenes shot in 24p. This artifacting doesn't occur in the source footage or in the Quicktime export or after the video has been encoded as an FLV for Brightcove. It only occurs on YouTube, in both normal and high quality.
Has anyone else addressed this problem? I've troubleshooted for weeks, trying different combinations of MOV and MP4, changing the data rate, and key frames. Anyone have any suggestions? I'd appreciate any insight.
Cheers,
Rakesh
Apple iMac
2.4 GHz
2 GB 667 MHz DDR2 SDRAMI followed this recommendations and they worked for me
http://www.google.com/support/youtube/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answer=132460
My footage was original recorded on 1080p60, here is the video
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dnWTVppVt74 -
Exporting/Compressing for YouTube
I exported a video I want to post on YouTube. The DV video is under ten minutes, but it's over 2GB.
I don't understand this. YouTube says "your videos can be up to 1GB in size and 10 minutes long."
But no matter how I export using QuickTime Conversion the video is over 2GB. Is there a way to compress the video so it's less than 1GB?http://www.kenstone.net/fcphomepage/youtube_compressorgary.html
http://www.kenstone.net/fcphomepage/you_tube_reduxgary.html
http://www.kenstone.net/fcphomepage/you_tube_hdgary.html
-DH -
Best Compression for Youtube for long video
I have a 45 minute film I would like to upload to Youtube. I have outputted a file from FCP7 using settings as they are, ProRes422 and it is 1920 x 1080 and 40.4GB. I then used the Youtube presets in Compressor and now have a .mov file 1280 x 720 and 2.83GB. This upload from where I am in Australia will take approx 7 hours.
Can anyone please recommend a better setting that gives me good quality and a size that wont give me a long upload time? The film was shot on a Canon XA10, frame rate 25.
Thank you.Three ways to make a smaller file (with the assumption you are using H.264 as the codec)
1. Lower the bit rate (image may degrade as there are less bits to carry the subtle image information - do a test to see what's acceptable)
2. reduce the image size (smaller images need less bits to carry the same color subtlety - you will also need to reduce bit rate as well - no use shrinking the image and keeping the same high bit rate - you may see marginal file size reduction)
3. reduce length (less to encode...)
Alternatively, start the upload just before you go to bed. Get a good night's sleep and the file should be at it's destination by the time you wake up.
x -
HELP...DVD image file compression settings for youtube.
HELP...I am mounting a DVD Image from a file on the HD. I would like to compress to use on Youtube.
What are the best settings? I have a account with YT which allows for more than the 15minute standard. I will be uploading 2hrs worth at times
Can I batch compress several mounted images?
I'm using Compressor bu if it is easier I have Handbrake and Mpeg SteamClip.
Thanks
Bill
[email protected]Compressor has a preset for youTube videos... Pick the one that closely matches your video:
Compressor YouTube settings has Frame Reorder set to on by default. YouTube doesn't like Frame Reorder, set it to off. Here are YouTube guidelines for Video set to them:
http://support.google.com/youtube/bin/static.py?hl=en&topic=1728570&guide=172858 5&page=guide.cs
Click the links to the left for more info about encoding videos. -
I am trying to compress an 18GB quicktime movie for youtube/vimeo sharing but Compressor keeps telling me it's failed. Any ideas?
make sure you have sufficient drive space on your target drive. Make sure you have a minimum of 15% free space on your startup drive. What format is the original quicktime movie?
-
How to compress a quicktime movie for youtube
how do you compress a quicktime movie for youtube?
dimensions: 1920 x 1080
codecs: apple prores 422, linear pcm
Color profiles: hd (1-1-1)
duration: 4:05
total bit rate: 98,422
i tried just directly uploading and it said upload time was 680 minutes....
..also when i play it on quicktime it is choppy. why is that?Setting from the horses mouth (so to speak)
File format and editing tips for Apple users -
Hello,
I am wondering if anyone has any experience with compressing original 1080i HDV video for youtube. What compression gives the best results?
Thank you,
CheersThis may help: http://www.kenstone.net/fcphomepage/you_tube_reduxgary.html
-DH -
I need help with exporting 720p video for youtube.
Hi everyone, I have been using Adobe premeir for almost a year now and I love it, as its very professional and powerful. I used to edit Standard with no problem, then export the full unconverted file (wmv) and run it though Windows Movie Maker to compress it (haha yeah I know its crazy.) Now that I got a camera capable of shooting HDV I want to use it. Im just wondering the following:
1.What format should I export with in Adobe Media Encoder? (Original Raw footage files from Camera are MOV formatted)
2.What should I set the Bitrate to?
3.How do I export to flash without it being to large of a file (Under 200mb's for a 5 minute video) and have it not choppy or pixelated?
4.How do I speed up exporting, how many passes should I do?
5.What overall is the best setup for youtube?
I also noticed a small glitch, and its when I export normally (full size, no compression) and run it though a compressor it cuts out all of the titles, and just flashes them for a milisecond. Its really odd. It only happens when I export in a certain format in which I cannot quite remember. Anyways.. thanks in advance for helping me. Its very appreciated.
NineLivesProductionsperform a search using the term export for web and it should throw up some ideas.
here's one for starters:
http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?messageID=2309121�
If you're using flip4mac to convert to wmv, the trial stops at 30 seconds - you need at least wmvstudio to export to wmv:
http://www.flip4mac.com/wmv.htm -
Best setting for Canon VIXIA HF R21 for YouTube
I am looking for the best or most optimal setting for shooting video with my Canon VIXIA HF R21 camera.
I am using a MacBook Pro laptop and Adobe Premiere Elements 10.
My goal is to produce the best quality videos for a "YouTube" channel. The videos will be for a teenage car show shot outdoors and narrated.
The current DEFAULT settings are:
Recording Mode = SP, 1440x1080
Bitrate = 7Mbps
Codec = MPEG4-AVC/H.264
Frame Rate = 60i
Digital Image stabilization = standard
Here are possible "alternative selections" - please let me know if any of these settings are better than the Default settings for YouTube.
Change Recording Mode to
1. MXP = 1920x1080 @ 24Mbps
2. FXP = 1920x1080 @ 17Mbps
3. XP+ = 1440x1080 @ 12 Mbps
Change Frame Rate to
1. PF30
Digital image stabilization
1. Dynamic
2. Standard
3. Off
I will use Adobe Premiere Elemebnts 10 to upload the final edited video - what setting are the best upload compression settings if I want to upload for the ebst quality?BillFlorida, I'm not sure what you're not getting here. Have you tried any of the things we've suggested?
There are two settings you need to worry about. One is your PROJECT setting. That must match your original footage, as I've indicated. If it doesn't, you're going to get poor performance and video quality.
The second setting is your OUTPUT setting. That's the only setting YouTube is interested in. If you use the output settings I linked you to above -- working from a project that's been set up properly -- you will get excellent YouTube results.
Try it. You'll see.
You'll also see, if you experiment a bit, that there's virtually no difference in the quality of FXP and MXP -- especially if you're going to display your video online. The important thing is that your PROJECT settings match that 1920x1080 AVCHD footage and that you use the YouTube output settings recommended in the FAQs.
Try it. You will see. -
Creating the Best Video Quality for YouTube Using FCE
Hey guys, have a quick question. I'm making drum covers for YouTube, and I want the best possible quality for my viewers. I use Final Cut Express 4.0.1 on my MacBook Pro, and Log and Transfer the video footage from a HDR-CX160 Sony AVCHD Handycam. What are my best options?
Thank you!
JustinIn every aspect of life there is no such thing as one best option as it all depends on your particular circumstances.
Here is a good starting point for you to decide what suits you best.
When you have edited your project in FCE try these settings:-
Select File>Export>Using QT Conversion.
Click the "Options" button and when the the Options window opens you will see "Size", "Settings" and "Sound" buttons.
Click the Size button and set 1920 x 1080
Click the Settings button and select:-
Compression Type . . . . H.264
Frame Rate . . . . . . . . . Current
Key Frames . . . . . . . . . Automatic
Compressor Quality . . . High
Encoding . . . . . . . . . . "Faster" encode will give almost the same quality as "Best" but is twice as fast - your decision!
Data Rate . . . . . . . . . . Restrict to 10,000kbps (Don't use a comma when you enter the number)
Then click the "Audio" button and make sure that AAC has been selected.
These settings should give very good quality results fairly quickly, which should play well. Your file size will be around 5GB per hour.
Some people prefer to use the smaller 1280 x 720, in which case the Data Rate should be 5,000kbps.
I suggest you do a quick test with a film under one minute long to see how it looks as there is nothing worse than spending hours encoding a long project only to find that the settings were unsuitable.
Maybe you are looking for
-
The focusOut event for textinputs fires after focus is lost. Is there an event that will fire before focus is lost?
-
Not able to create request for multiple user in oim 11gr2
Hi, I am trying to assign a resource to multiple user using oim identity console as System Administrator. But when i am assigning the resource to multiple user its taking the same value for both the users. Please let me know how to add the different
-
BPE doesn't activate XML Objects and Workflows
Hi all. I have created some BPE Processes. The all are active and with status 0 in transaction SXI_CACHE. The odd thing is, when I trigger messenges the BPE_ADAPTER error 'No object type found for this message; check the activation of the correspondi
-
Hi everyone, I hope someone can help with a little problem I have. I have been creating a multi page folio and on some of teh pages I created and animation using edge animate. The animation is trigered by a button created in edge animate. I have expo
-
ATV will play movie extras and all other content. Put will not play the movie it self! iTunes is currently unavailable. Try again later. Shows up every time!