USB3 ONLY external drive ejecting during backup

This has been discussed and posted in various ways here, but I haven't seen/found a solid solution yet which might be out there.
Has anyone figured out the solution to a USB3 drive ejecting on it's own?
My staff's OWC USB3 external portrable hard drive keeps ejecting during any operation: time machine, Carbon Copy, Lightroom, importing, moving files, etc. 
Attached is a screen shot of the warning box that comes up when the drive ejects itself.
COMPUTER:
The machine is a 2012 NON-Retina MBP.
OSX 10.8.2
EXTERNAL DRIVE:
The drive is an OWC Mercury Elite On the Go drive: USB3 only
http://eshop.macsales.com/item/Other%20World%20Computing/MSU37750GB16/
We have used the drive, and cable on my 2011 MBP, OSX 10.7.5 with only USB2 on my machine, and it runs perfectly fine under all conditions.
ATTEMPTED FIXES:
Repaired disk permissions
Disk Warrior
Defrag
All Updates for OSX
Re-install OSX
All updates for 2012 MBP
Taken to Apple "Genius" bar twice.  They confirm the failures.  Initially blamed the drive/enclousure/cable.  Then blamed that there were firmware and other updates that would fix it....which they did not. 
YET TO ATTEMPT :
Creating a 10.7.5 boot partition on the 2012 MBP and test that.
Trying a powered external drive on the 2012 MPB
Trying a FW800 drive
Any thing else I am missing?  Trying to avoid having to send it into Apple Care and be without a needed machine for week+, and concerned that like others, it won't be fixed anyway.
Appreciate your thoughts.

I have something similar on a brand new iMac 27" i7 top of the line model.  I bought a USB 3 enclosure from OCW for a 120 gig SSD. I was using it as the cache drive for Photoshop CS6.  It began to display the same issues you are describing. I brushed it off and blamed the cheap enclosure I purchased.  This all occurred 1 week ago on 1-22-2013.
On Saturday 1-26-2013 I was backing up a sweet sixteen shoot via time machine connected to the USB3 port and the drive ejected mid way of a 70 gig back up. I found that strange because I've never had a problem with that drive or the enclosure it's in. (By the way this is a USB2 enclosure)  I tried it 3 more times and the same issue occurred.  I figured it was the cable and switched it with another USB cable and this time it worked.
Not thinking much about I assumed the problem was the cable.  The next morning I realized I still had one 8 gig compact flash card in my camera and I needed to back that one up.  This time I used my USB 3 RAW STEEL UDMA card reader to ingest the work. There were only 20 images on the card. During import the compact flash drive froze on the third image. I had to force quit and redo the import again.  It took 3 times before I had no issues importing the images.  I could not figure out what the **** was going on until it hit me. 
During my trouble shooting I realized the 3 drives were, when they ejected themsleves, connected to the same port in the back of my iMac.  The second one closest to the SD card reader port in the back.  That was the free port I kept switching to use these different peripherals.
I need to do a little more testing but I'm almost certain something is wrong the the USB3 ports in the back of the new computers. Never had these issues with my late 2009 iMac. 
The last thing I want to is haul this machine into Apple after it took me 4 days to get it set up the way I use it for my Photography business.
Disappointed big time!

Similar Messages

  • External drive ejected during "consolidate library" attempt

    I have a recent mac mini running mountain lion with a 1 tb g drive connected via firewire 800 and a 2 tb seagate connected via usb.  The original itunes files are on the gdrive.  I want to consolidate and back up the music files to the Seagate but in the middle of the consolidation, the g drive spontaneously ejects and I get an error message saying i have ejected it improperly.  I had settings on so computer would not go to sleep so its not that.  I have run disk utility on both external drives, no errors.  I had this happen twice while trying to consolidate library and twice while trying a simple drag and drop of the itunes folder.  What's the deal?  Can anyone help?  Has anyone had this problem?
    rabbit

    I have something similar on a brand new iMac 27" i7 top of the line model.  I bought a USB 3 enclosure from OCW for a 120 gig SSD. I was using it as the cache drive for Photoshop CS6.  It began to display the same issues you are describing. I brushed it off and blamed the cheap enclosure I purchased.  This all occurred 1 week ago on 1-22-2013.
    On Saturday 1-26-2013 I was backing up a sweet sixteen shoot via time machine connected to the USB3 port and the drive ejected mid way of a 70 gig back up. I found that strange because I've never had a problem with that drive or the enclosure it's in. (By the way this is a USB2 enclosure)  I tried it 3 more times and the same issue occurred.  I figured it was the cable and switched it with another USB cable and this time it worked.
    Not thinking much about I assumed the problem was the cable.  The next morning I realized I still had one 8 gig compact flash card in my camera and I needed to back that one up.  This time I used my USB 3 RAW STEEL UDMA card reader to ingest the work. There were only 20 images on the card. During import the compact flash drive froze on the third image. I had to force quit and redo the import again.  It took 3 times before I had no issues importing the images.  I could not figure out what the **** was going on until it hit me. 
    During my trouble shooting I realized the 3 drives were, when they ejected themsleves, connected to the same port in the back of my iMac.  The second one closest to the SD card reader port in the back.  That was the free port I kept switching to use these different peripherals.
    I need to do a little more testing but I'm almost certain something is wrong the the USB3 ports in the back of the new computers. Never had these issues with my late 2009 iMac. 
    The last thing I want to is haul this machine into Apple after it took me 4 days to get it set up the way I use it for my Photography business.
    Disappointed big time!

  • Is there a solution to external HDD ejecting during backups?

    I've used Super Duper. I've used Time Machine. I've tried copying tons of files from one external HDD to another. Every time, the backup crashes and delivers the message that said HDD was not properly ejected. This did not happen with Tiger, but started happening with the upgrade to SL. From everything I've read, it points to a bug in Snow Leopard. If so, has it been fixed?

    FWIW, when I said earlier in this thread that I back up every day I'll add here that one of the drives I backup is my boot SSD with no problems.
    Here's something I just thought of -- by any chance do these externals have firmware that needs updating for snow leopard (and lion)?  For example, you said it worked on tiger (10.4.x) but you started having problems when you tried snow leopard.  Since you mentioned the model of the WD external I did a little searching and found a WD Software Update page for firmware for WD products.  Perhaps you need that.  I didn't check the LaCie since you didn't specify the exact product and LaCie makes lots of stuff.
    Just something I thought I'd mention.

  • External Drive as a Backup

    Hello all,
    I have been scanning the threads on this issue and from what I can see most posts on this subject refer to either moving the itunes library or temporarily moving it. I want to use an external drive as a backup only with the ability to be able to use it on another computer should anything happen to my pc and it takes itunes down with it. All I can find in the itunes help is backing up to cd/dvd.
    So using my very limited computer knowledge, can I simply copy and paste the library folder into the external drive? Or is that a stupid question?

    To use that iTunes folder, hold Shift and launch iTunes.
    Select *Choose existing library* and select the *iTunes library.itl* file in the iTunes folder on the external.

  • Is there a way of knowing which external drive ejects?

    Is there a way of knowing which external drive ejects?
    I have several external drives and when one ejects on it's own it usually immediately restarts again and does not give me time to find which one was the problem drive.
    Is there a way of figuring this out?
    Thank you!

    No unfortunately without restoring the library and running it there is no way to tell if it is good or not.
    regards

  • External Hard Drive ejects during Time Machine Backup

    I've read through all the troubleshooting pages that I thought had anything to do with this problem, but none of my error messages seemed to match. This is my first backup with Time Machine onto my external hard drive, and it never gets past about 60GB before deciding that the drive has improperly ejected itself and aborting the backup. The error message from my Time Machine Buddy is below:
    Starting standard backup
    Backing up to: /Volumes/Untitled/Backups.backupdb
    Ownership is disabled on the backup destination volume.  Enabling.
    Backup content size: 147.2 GB excluded items size: 5.1 GB for volume Macintosh HD
    No pre-backup thinning needed: 170.49 GB requested (including padding), 930.54 GB available
    Waiting for index to be ready (101)
    Copied 56.0 GB of 142.1 GB, 112101 of 886988 items
    Error writing to backup log.  NSFileHandleOperationException:*** -[NSConcreteFileHandle writeData:]: Device not configured
    Error: (-50) SrcErr:NO Copying /System/Library/Frameworks/Ruby.framework/Versions/1.8/usr/lib/ruby/gems/1.8/ge ms/net-ssh-1.1.4/lib/net/ssh/proxy/errors.rb to /Volumes/Untitled/Backups.backupdb/Eugenio Vargas Computer/2011-05-17-161101.inProgress/E6F5C3CB-75B8-41C4-B52E-138235EB4B34/Maci ntosh HD/System/Library/Frameworks/Ruby.framework/Versions/1.8/usr/lib/ruby/gems/1.8/ gems/net-ssh-1.1.4/lib/net/ssh/proxy
    Error writing to backup log.  NSFileHandleOperationException:*** -[NSConcreteFileHandle writeData:]: Device not configured
    Error: (-50) SrcErr:NO Copying /System/Library/Frameworks/Ruby.framework/Versions/1.8/usr/lib/ruby/gems/1.8/ge ms/net-ssh-1.1.4/lib/net/ssh/proxy/http.rb to /Volumes/Untitled/Backups.backupdb/Eugenio Vargas Computer/2011-05-17-161101.inProgress/E6F5C3CB-75B8-41C4-B52E-138235EB4B34/Maci ntosh HD/System/Library/Frameworks/Ruby.framework/Versions/1.8/usr/lib/ruby/gems/1.8/ gems/net-ssh-1.1.4/lib/net/ssh/proxy
    Error writing to backup log.  NSFileHandleOperationException:*** -[NSConcreteFileHandle writeData:]: Device not configured
    Error: (-50) SrcErr:NO Copying /System/Library/Frameworks/Ruby.framework/Versions/1.8/usr/lib/ruby/gems/1.8/ge ms/net-ssh-1.1.4/lib/net/ssh/proxy/socks4.rb to /Volumes/Untitled/Backups.backupdb/Eugenio Vargas Computer/2011-05-17-161101.inProgress/E6F5C3CB-75B8-41C4-B52E-138235EB4B34/Maci ntosh HD/System/Library/Frameworks/Ruby.framework/Versions/1.8/usr/lib/ruby/gems/1.8/ gems/net-ssh-1.1.4/lib/net/ssh/proxy
    Error writing to backup log.  NSFileHandleOperationException:*** -[NSConcreteFileHandle writeData:]: Device not configured
    Error: (-50) SrcErr:NO Copying /System/Library/Frameworks/Ruby.framework/Versions/1.8/usr/lib/ruby/gems/1.8/ge ms/net-ssh-1.1.4/lib/net/ssh/proxy/socks5.rb to /Volumes/Untitled/Backups.backupdb/Eugenio Vargas Computer/2011-05-17-161101.inProgress/E6F5C3CB-75B8-41C4-B52E-138235EB4B34/Maci ntosh HD/System/Library/Frameworks/Ruby.framework/Versions/1.8/usr/lib/ruby/gems/1.8/ gems/net-ssh-1.1.4/lib/net/ssh/proxy
    Indexing a file failed. Returned 200 for: /System/Library/Frameworks/Ruby.framework/Versions/1.8/usr/lib/ruby/gems/1.8/ge ms/net-ssh-1.1.4/lib/net/ssh/proxy, /Volumes/Untitled/Backups.backupdb/Eugenio Vargas Computer/2011-05-17-161101.inProgress/E6F5C3CB-75B8-41C4-B52E-138235EB4B34/Maci ntosh HD/System/Library/Frameworks/Ruby.framework/Versions/1.8/usr/lib/ruby/gems/1.8/ gems/net-ssh-1.1.4/lib/net/ssh/proxy
    Aborting backup because indexing of file failed.
    Other details:
    My external drive is a WD 1TB drive. The partition for the Time Machine Backup is formatted as Mac OS Extended (Journaled), as is my Macintosh HD. The Partition Map Scheme on the external drive is GUID Partition Table.
    I have tried reformatting the external drive for good measure, but this doesn't seem to solve any problems. I also tried searching for the file that the error message says NO Copying for (/System/Library/Frameworks/Ruby.framework/Versions/1.8/usr/lib/ruby/gems/1.8/g ems/net-ssh-1.1.4/lib/net/ssh/proxy/...) but I'm unable to find the files. I can get as far as /System/Library/Frameworks, but can find no folder in Frameworks titled Ruby.
    Please help.

    The Ruby folder is probably hidden. That is why you don't see it.
    You may want to add System/Library/Frameworks to the exempted sync list until you can figure out which file is causing this. You can do this by opening Time Machine Preferences ( > System Preferences > Time Machine) and clicking on Options…
    After that click the small + key and browse to the folder you want to exempt from the sync. In your case: Macintosh HD > System > Library > Frameworks
    Next hit the exclude button with the Frameworks folder highlighted.
    Try your backup again and see if it fails.

  • Ca I stop TM from formatting external drive prior to backup?

    I bought an external drive to backup my Mac and my Pc. It is formatted as Fat32, acceptable both to Mac and Pc.
    When I tried to use Time Machine it asks to format the external drive -- which means it will be formatted for Mac only. Is there a way to force Time Machine to accept Fat32 and proceed with the backup?
    If not, is there an easy to check list of files or folders that should be backed up manually?
    Thankx. Roxy

    You cannot use a FAT32 drive for a Time Machine backup destination. FAT32 doesn't support the required features that let Time Machine store multiple copies of files and directories in the way it does.
    You have two basic options.
    One is to format the disk as HFS+ (including partitioning the drive to have a separate Mac and a PC partition)
    Two is to create a disk image on the FAT drive and use the disk image as your backup destination. As a disk image, the necessary file links work and are hidden from the FAT disk.
    At no level, though, will the PC be able to read files directly from the Time Machine backup.

  • External Drive for Storage/Backup?

    Ok so I think I'm at the point where it would be a smart idea to back up all my valuable data (as if there was never a smart time to do this?)
    Now my question is this: Can an external Hard Disk be used on both my G5 and relatives MacPro at the same time? As in I can dump some files on it from the G5, then plug in into the MacPro and do the same - having seperate storage folders on the Drive for each computers backup?
    I've never attempted to do an external drive backup before. I've only ever done it with burning DVDs. So if I'm missing something or this sounds like a silly question please forgive!
    Thank you in advance!

    I am not too sure you can simultaneously connect one drive to two different machines, in fact I am quite sure you can't and I think that is what you were asking, vs. partitioning it with two partions (easy) and using it on one or the other mac at separate times.
    Note by easy I mean it uses the mac partitioning scheme and thus it cannot boot an intel.
    As pointed out, there are guides to formating one drive with 2 partitions so it can have two different bootup disks, on PPC and one intel. I would not bother. Seems daunting and if you are unsure of PATA vs. SATA then forget learning that very complex operation.
    These drives of adequate (or even quite massive) size don't cost enough to bother. Buy two drives, firewire only and partition one GUID for the intel and the traditional mac format for the other.
    And I think you should just buy two already made external (FIREWIRE) drives from LaCie or OWC and not get into buying raw drives, cases and the like and assembling them - you don't save a whole lot if anything, and a lot of these cases are rubbish pure and simple.
    Judging by increasingly unhappy posts about the "PC brand" external drives (Maxtor, WD, Iomega) trying to mosey into the mac world I would avoid them like the plague.

  • Read only external drive

    I'm trying to copy some photos from my Macbook Pro to an external drive, but the drive is coming up as read only.
    When I plug it into a PC its fine and I've amended the properties to share all.
    Any ideas?
    I could copy them to a memory stick a couple at a time, but that could take some time.

    It's likely the drive was formatted on your PC... in which case, it will be formatted as NTFS.  This is a proprietary format that only Microsoft uses.  OS X can read NTFS formatted drives, but it cannot natively write to them.  If you plan on sharing the drive between a Mac and a PC, you can reformat the drive as FAT32 (NOTE: this will erase everything on the drive, so be sure to have a copy of your data elsewhere)... OR, you can install something like NTFS-3G (free) which will allow your Mac to write to NTFS formatted drives:
    http://www.macupdate.com/app/mac/24481/ntfs-3g

  • Formatting external drive for storage/backup/video files

    Hi,
    I just purchased a 500mb My Book Pro external drive for use with my imac duo which runs Windows XP via bootcamp. This computer is shared by three family with very different skills and needs. My dilemma. I want to format the drive so that the imac can be backed up easily three users. It is formated Fat32 and is supplied with Restrospect Express 7.5 backup software. It would be nice to backup the modestly used windows sector, but that's a secondary consideration. My problem is that one user has a lot of larger than 4 gb video files which are too large the Fat 32 format. My notion is to segment the backup drive so that I leave 300 mb in fat 32 to facilitate backup with supplied software, and segment a second 200 gb drive using mac os extended so that the user can manually move her video files for storage/backup on the backup drive. Is there a simpler solution? For example, if I formatted the entire 500gb as mac os extended, could I still run the retrospect backup software? If not, is there a reasonably priced alternative software? And finally, with either Fat32 or Mac OS extended, can I move files from the Windows platform? Would I be better off just biting the bullet and telling my daughter to make her own arrangements to compress and backup her video files or get her own hard drive, thus leaving the backup drive to the simple factory supplied software solution?
    G-4 and iMac core duo   Mac OS X (10.4.9)   use emacs and imacs at work location

    Hi,
    I just purchased a 500mb My Book Pro external drive
    for use with my imac duo which runs Windows XP via
    bootcamp. This computer is shared by three family
    with very different skills and needs. My dilemma. I
    want to format the drive so that the imac can be
    backed up easily three users. It is formated Fat32
    and is supplied with Restrospect Express 7.5 backup
    software. It would be nice to backup the modestly
    used windows sector, but that's a secondary
    consideration. My problem is that one user has a lot
    of larger than 4 gb video files which are too large
    the Fat 32 format. My notion is to segment the backup
    drive so that I leave 300 mb in fat 32 to facilitate
    backup with supplied software, and segment a second
    200 gb drive using mac os extended so that the user
    can manually move her video files for storage/backup
    on the backup drive. Is there a simpler solution? For
    example, if I formatted the entire 500gb as mac os
    extended, could I still run the retrospect backup
    software? If not, is there a reasonably priced
    alternative software? And finally, with either Fat32
    or Mac OS extended, can I move files from the Windows
    platform? Would I be better off just biting the
    bullet and telling my daughter to make her own
    arrangements to compress and backup her video files
    or get her own hard drive, thus leaving the backup
    drive to the simple factory supplied software
    solution?
    G-4 and iMac
    core duo   Mac OS X (10.4.9)   use emacs
    and imacs at work location
    Hello,
    You're indeed in a pickle. If you use Bootcamp and want the HD accessible via the Mac and WinXP, then you don't want to format it as Mac HFS because WInXP wouldn't be able to access it. If you go FAT32 then both WInXP and Mac OS can access it, but you face the dilemma of the 4GB threshold.
    If you format as NTFS, then you eliminate the 4GB threshold but then Mac OS cannot access it.
    I have a similar dilemma, which is why i use Parallels more than Bootcamp. I have 2 external FW HD's (160GB/250GB), both formatted to Mac HFS. The 160GB i have partitioned as 50GB and 100GB. I have a bootable backup of Mac OS residing on the 100GB partition (yay to SuperDuper!) and some other stuff on the remaining 50GB. The 250GB is exclusive for movies (cough..cough..bittorrent) and for streaming via Orb 2.0 to my Treo. I have WinXP running in Parallels, and Vista Ultimate via Bootcamp. In Parallels, i can access my external HD's via Parallel's Shared Folders but in Vista (Bootcamp) since the HD's are in a non-Windows recognised formatting, they're not accessible (which is a bummer, as i'm loving Win media center).
    What you can do is partition the HD the way you're thinking and format (one part Mac HFS and the other NTFS), but my best recommendation is that with the falling prices of HD's nowadays, why not just get a seperate HD do what you want with it. I spied a WD MyBook 500GB USB HD at CompUSA for $129.99 (no mail-in rebate nonsense) and similar good prices at Bestbuy and Newegg.com.
    iMac 17" 2GHZ C2Duo 2GB RAM 160GB HD   Mac OS X (10.4.9)  

  • Hold entire iTunes library on external drive including iPhone backups

    I have successfully moved my iTunes library to an external drive.  This allows me to plug the external into any of my Macs, hold Option while launching iTunes, and manage the library.  That way, I can use either mac as my home sharing server and can travel with any laptop I'd like. 
    Now I'd like to incorporate my iOS backups so I don't have to use a single computer to sync my phones and iPads.  I travel quite a bit and take different laptops with me.  While I'm home I want to use my Macbook Pro.  Is it possible to sync my iPhone with any computer as long as I'm running an installation of iTunes from an external hard dirve?

    http://osxdaily.com/2009/09/11/iphone-backup-location/ - your iPhone files are backed up at the following location:
    in Mac OS X:
    ~(your home directory)/Library/Application Support/MobileSync/Backup/

  • External Drive ejects unexpectedly

    I am trying to use a WD Passport 1T external hard drive with my MacBook Pro but everytime I use the USB port it is recognized but shortly afterwards it ejects itelf from my system. How can I prevent this?

    Once you resolve the ejection issue and the availability stabilizes, be sure to do a Repair Disk on the external drive with Disk Utility. Random forced dismounts like you are experiencing are great for corrupting the data on the drive.

  • Installing lion onto external drive frozen during OSX install

    I was trying to install lion into a clean hardrive, using lion recovery.
    it's downloaded the first part, and the imac has restarted once and loaded up the "install Mac  OS X " page, it said it was going to take 25mins to install.
    It's frozen, about 20% into so install, and now i have the beach ball mouse pointer. and nothing is working.
    how can i fix this?

    You will need to force quit the installer by shutting down the computer. When you restart look in your Applications folder to see if you still have the Lion installer application. If your do, then I suggest doing the following:
    Make Your Own Mountain/Lion Installer
    1. After downloading Mountain/Lion you must first save the Install Mac OS X Mountain/
        Lion application. After Mountain/Lion downloads DO NOT click on the Install button.
        Go to your Applications folder and make a copy of the Mountain/Lion installer. Move
        the copy into your Downloads folder. Now you can click on the Install button. You
        must do this because the installer deletes itself automatically when it finishes
        installing.
    2. Get a USB flash drive that is at least 8 GBs. Prep this flash drive as follows:
      a. Open Disk Utility in your Utilities folder.
      b. After DU loads select your flash drive (this is the entry with the mfgr.'s ID and size) from the left
          side list. Click on the Partition tab in the DU main window.
      c. Under the Volume Scheme heading set the number of partitions from the drop down menu to one.    
          Set the format type to Mac OS Extended (Journaled.) Click on the Options button, set the
          partition scheme to GUID then click on the OK button. Click on the Partition button and wait until
          the process has completed.
      d. Select the volume you just created (this is the sub-entry under the drive entry) from the left side
          list. Click on the Erase tab in the DU main window.
      e. Set the format type to Mac OS Extended (Journaled.) Click on the Options button, check the
          button for Zero Data and click on OK to return to the Erase window.
      f. Click on the Erase button. The format process can take up to an hour depending upon the flash
         drive size.
    3. Use Lion DiskMaker 2.0 to put your installer clone onto the USB flash drive.
    Note: The term Mountain/Lion used above means Lion or Mountain Lion.
    To reinstall Lion on the external drive:
    Partition and format the external drive properly:
    1. Open Disk Utility in your Utilities folder.
    2. After DU loads select your hard drive (this is the entry with the mfgr.'s ID and size) from the left side list. Click on the Partition tab in the DU main window.
    3. Under the Volume Scheme heading set the number of partitions from the drop down menu to one. Click on the Options button, set the partition scheme to GUID then click on the OK button. Set the format type to Mac OS Extended (Journaled.) Click on the Partition button and wait until the process has completed.
    4. Select the volume you just created (this is the sub-entry under the drive entry) from the left side list. Click on the Erase tab in the DU main window.
    5. Set the format type to Mac OS Extended (Journaled.) Click on the Security button, check the button for Zero Data and click on OK to return to the Erase window.
    6. Click on the Erase button. The format process can take up to several hours depending upon the drive size.
    Boot from the flash drive you made. Select the external drive as the target, then install Lion.

  • Setting up a 1tb (2-500gb) external drive to do backup and file storage

    I bought a WD 1tb (uses 2 500 GB drives). I want to use one of the drives for backup and one for storing and working with large video and photo files. How do I set this up? RAID 0 HFS+ or RAID 1. Am confused about how to partition this so that one of the drives is a backup for reliability. Seems like RAID 0 would not allow me to do this and RAID 1 just mirrors everything on both drives.
    Help?

    alright ... here we go ...
    every drive has to be formatted ... whether you do or you buy it that way ...
    most likely one is formatted NTFS, and the other FAT32, especially since you can write to one and not the other ...
    did you use both with windoze ???
    Mac OS X uses HFS+ but can write to FAT32 ...
    what you are going to have to do is copy all the data over to your local disk and reformat the externals ... both of them ... using disk utility (in Utilities folder in /Applications - the Erase tab) ...

  • Recovering files from external drive clobbered during 10.6.3 update

    I have an external FW drive (500 GB WD MyBook) that was clobbered during the upgrade to 10.6.3 (The Mini this was attached to is part of the everything seemed to complete normally but the Mac wouldn't restart crew). The drive cannot be attached during boot-up, or the Mac will never get past the spinning pinwheel. If the drive is attached after boot-up, it mounts without any troubles, and DiskTools finds nothing wrong with the drive. If the drive is accessed, what ever process is using the drive will eventually "freeze". It's not a complete freeze, because the programs are still semi-functioning, it's just that what ever process is accessing the drive will not complete. For example:
    1) The Finder starts copying files, but part way through, progress stops. The Finder is still semi-usable, and the animation in the copy progress box continues, but there is no actual progress in the amount of data copied.
    2) Data Rescue 3 recovers 377.5 MBs quickly and then makes no further progress even though the "Elapsed Time" counter continually updates. I've let it run for four hours and there was no progress past 377.5 MBs.
    3) Trying to shut-off Spotlight indexing on the drive via Terminal.app results in "mdutil -i off /Volumes/driveName" never completing, but I can open another Terminal window and navigate the directory structure, 'ls', delete small files, etc.
    It seems that the problem is sustained reads; however, even if the drive is just connected, something problematic will be encountered. Usually when this happens, the only recourse is to shut down because Force Quitting the blocked app doesn't succeed. Sometimes, the shutdown works fine, other times the drive must be disconnected in order for the rest of the system to shut down correctly.
    Can tar and/or cp in the Terminal be set to copy all of the Mac file data (I haven't Googled that yet)? Is there an "UnstopableCopier" equivalent for the Mac?
    Any other ideas how to copy the files I need to recover off this drive? The plan is to salvage what I can and then reformat/replace the drive.
    Ray

    Update. It's most likely hardware trouble. I was able to get all the files off, but it took about a dozen tries. Each attempt would fail, sometimes after 1,000+ files, sometimes after less than a dozen. I could always go back and restart the copying where the previous attempt failed, so there were no corrupted files.
    The problem seems like something's wrong with either the drive, the enclosure, or the firewire port/software. Now I just need to find out which. Any suggestions?
    Ray

Maybe you are looking for