VDI in saved state however no configuration for save delay?

I have a 2012 R2 VDI collection (personal, unmanaged) that is not configured for Save Delay.  However, I have many VDI that resort to a Saved State when not in use.  Is this saved state an included feature of 2012 R2 and is that different than
the save delay?

Hi Jason,
Thank you for posting in Windows Server Forum.
Have you find any relevant log related to this issue on host and guest side?
When a user connects to the VM collection, RDS and Hyper-V should wake up the VM and restore it to a running state.  Is this not happening in your collection?
To save resources, the VMs in a collection will not all be in a running state all the time unless the admin manually changes their state via the RDMS console.  
(Quoted from this thread, by “dgeddes
[MSFT]”)
Apart from this, you can refer beneath articles.
1.Lab Ops 6 – Setup VDI in Windows Server 2012R2
2. Disable save state on virtual machines in Hyper-V
Hope it helps!
Thanks.
Dharmesh Solanki

Similar Messages

  • "This virtual machine is configured for 64-bit guest operating systems. However, 64-bit operation is not possible.  This host does not support Intel VT-x"

    Hi, I have installed vmware 5.5 hypervisor on hp G8 microserver. I have created one vm as windows 2008 R2. I have also install vmware workstation 11 on this vm. In this workstation when I tried to run vmware 5.5 hypervisor I come across "This virtual machine is configured for 64-bit guest operating systems. However, 64-bit operation is not possible.  This host does not support Intel VT-x" this statement. Which shows that the host machine does not support virtualization and for that you need to go in Bios and enable it but in present case as host machine is also a vm and you would not find much detail of Bios when you log into the Bios therefore, I am pretty much stuck here. I don't see any information in relation to this. Now my question is:
    1. Can we run ESXi inside a vm which is already sitting on ESXi?

    I moved the discussion from VMware Workstation to Nested Virtualization which contains several hints on what's possible and what needs to be configured to make things work.
    André

  • VDI is automatically going to down and become 'Saved' state

    We are testing the HYper-V 2012 and Windows 8 Enterprise 32 bit. We have created Personal Desktop collection and Created VDI. But this VDI's are frequently going Down automatically and if we check in Hyper-V, the VDI state is showing as 'Saved'. Anybody
    can help us as we are going to decide whether to go with Microsoft or VMware for Virtualization
    Thanks in advance

    the VM should not be going into a saved state when the user is connected.  RDS will only change the state of the VM when an admin chooses to do so manually, or when we need to wake up a VM or after a user logs off. 
    What is the state of Hyper-V when this is happening?  How many VMs are running and does the Hyper-V server have resources available?  are you using dynamic memory on your VMs?
    Don Geddes - SR Support Escalation Engineer - Remote Desktop Services - Printing and Imaging

  • WARNING: No saved state for javax.swing.JTable

    Hi All,
    I have a JTable component in my code and I used Netbeans to add swing components. However, I get this warning after I run my app:
    WARNING: No saved state for javax.swing.JTable[jTable1,0,0,329x80,alignmentX=0.0,alignmentY=0.0,border=,
            flags=251658568,maximumSize=,minimumSize=,preferredSize=,autoCreateColumnsFromModel=true,
            autoResizeMode=AUTO_RESIZE_SUBSEQUENT_COLUMNS,cellSelectionEnabled=false,editingColumn=-1,
            editingRow=-1,gridColor=javax.swing.plaf.ColorUIResource[r=128,g=128,b=128],
            preferredViewportSize=java.awt.Dimension[width=450,height=400],rowHeight=16,rowMargin=1,
            rowSelectionAllowed=true,selectionBackground=javax.swing.plaf.ColorUIResource[r=51,g=153,b=255],
            selectionForeground=javax.swing.plaf.ColorUIResource[r=255,g=255,b=255],showHorizontalLines=true,
            showVerticalLines=true]What is the reason of this? If I need to catch this exception, how can I add it with netbeans?
    Edited by: Darryl Burke -- broke a long line into several lines

    Set the name property of your JTable, it's a Netbeans thing, rather than a Java problem. table.setName("MyTable");Have a look at this thread for details: SessionStorage warning while program is running
    Please only post Java related questions here and post Netbeans questions to a netbeans forum/mailing list, thanks.

  • Saved state is not backuped in HyperV backup for Win2012R2

    I am trying to backup Win2012 R2 VM on my Win2012 R2 hyperv host using VSS.
    Before starting backup my vm is in Saved status.
    But after backup I cant find saved state file *vsv and *bin file in the backup so I am loosing whatever contains I have in saved state.
    Its working fine on Win2008. Is there any change in VSS/Saved state behavior in Win2012R2?
    hypervbackup is the utility  I used to run backup.
    Thanks In advance. Please let me know if more details are required.

    Hi Sir,
    According to your description , one thing came into my mind .
    In 2008/R2 , to backup VM online the hyper-v vss writer must be registered , if not , the VM will run into saved state untill accomplishing  the backup .
    http://blogs.technet.com/b/askcore/archive/2008/08/20/how-to-enable-windows-server-backup-support-for-the-hyper-v-vss-writer.aspx
    If you are in that case ( hyper-v VSS writer was not registered in 2008/R2 ) , actually the backup will perform a file based backup  , it will keep the VSV file there .  
    If you do same backup in 2012 R2 (select VM's folder then backup) , the VSV file should be backed up .
    In 2012/R2 you do not to manually register vss writer , you just need to select VM and backup .
    Best Regards,
    Elton Ji
    Please remember to mark the replies as answers if they help and unmark them if they provide no help. If you have feedback for TechNet Subscriber Support, contact [email protected] .

  • Supported Configurations for VDI 3.1

    I have a question about the supported configurations for VDI 3.1.
    We have a small office where we would have only about 12-15 desktops and would be using the VirtualBox virtualization platform with VDI. The standard vbox configuration recommends 4-5 servers depending on whether you have one of the VirtualBox hosts sharing a machine with the primary VDI node or not. The only other supported configuration is a single host configuration where everything resides on one physical host (and thus one big single point of failure).
    My question is can you have a modified version of the single-host configuration for small office environments? For example, I have two X4240 servers with 4x 136GB hard drives each. I know the VDI hosts need to be on three different hosts to satisfy the MySQL clustering configuration. So can I have something like the following on only three boxes?
    [Sun VDI Primary] on a small (Dual Core CPU, 2 or 4GB RAM) X86 server
    [Sun VDI Secondary + Virtual Box desktop services + Storage services] on X4240 (2x Quad Core CPU, 16GB RAM)
    [Sun VDI Secondary + Virtual Box desktop services + Storage services] on X4240 (2x Quad Core CPU, 16GB RAM)
    I'm just trying to design a configuration for a small office environment that uses the fewest servers but at the same time is not one big single point of failure as would be the case with a single host configuration.
    Any suggestions would be welcomed...
    Thanks in advance,
    -Ken

    Just simply load balancing? Or something more?I often encounter potential customers who'd be interested to buy Sun VDI but they shy away from such thoughts because they realise that the VMware ESX license costs they would have to spend money for will be killing them financially. And they don't see VirtualBox as a "good enough" alternative: It's a "toy", it can't do live migration (e.g. with VMware if they wanted that feature one day they could simply license it and "unlock" it), it's not a bare metal hypervisor ....
    So now I could at least counter the point about VirtualBox not being able to do live migrations because now it can do that and there are no additional licenses to pay and no features to unlock. The feature is there from start. So that's good.
    But the other issues remain: it's not "bare metal". It would have been nice to have some sort of true "VirtualBox Server" or "VirtualBox for VDI -- Bare Metal Edition". Sun had such a product in the pipelines: "Sun xVM Server" ... but this product was killed after EA #2. Silly move, IMHO. It would have been wiser to finish this product and then have Sun VDI support it as virtualisation backend as well.
    Talking of which: Any chance that Sun VDI might one day support the various XEN-based products that exist? If I am not mistaken Sun's "xVM" hypervisor in Solaris/OpenSolaris is in principle just another XEN implementation too. And then there is "Oracle VM" .... so in light of the merger with Oracle I'd say it would make sense if Solaris xVM and Oracle VM/Xen were supported as well. I find it odd that XEN-based products which are widely used in certain circles (e.g. Universities) are being omitted but that there is support for Microsoft Hyper-V which is so brand new and still so lacking in the features department that it is hardly used by anyone except by some paid "early adopters" ...

  • Saved State Backup on Server 2012 R2 and DPM 2012

    Hello, Our environment in currently in transition with planned migration to 2012 R2. In the mean time, we have a 5 node 2008 R2 hyper-v cluster with CSV.  We are currently using DPM 2012 for our backup.  I have read multiple postings about child
    partition backup and saved state and all that seems to make relative sense.
    What I have noticed is that in our existing environment (2008 R2 Hyper-v, DPM 2012) that all 2012 R2 Virtual servers setup in our hyper-v cluster show 'Backup Using Saved State'.  All virtual 2003 - 2008 R2 servers on the same cluster show as 'Backup
    using Child Partition Snapshot'.
    So, the question: is this normal and the only way virtual 2012 R2 servers can be backed up in our environment? Or, is there some configuration on the virtual 2012 R2 servers that needs to be done so that the Hyper-v VSS writers show that it can be backed
    up using Child Partition Snapshot. (Yes, I viewed the Hyper-V VSS Writer Caption: for each system on all the nodes and no, I am not talking about what is displayed in DPM 2012 since I understand it may not truly reflect the current backup method)

    Have you already checked typical reason for DPM doing saved state backup? If not, find them below.
    Also, do your VM have
    SCSI controller added? Prior to using Veeam as our primary backup solution, we leveraged DPM and confronted the very same issue. Fortunately, by adding ISCSI controllers to VMs in question we were able to solve the problem.
    Conditions when DPM fails to back up Hyper-V virtual machines in an online state
    By default, System Center 2012 – Data Protection Manager (DPM) performs a backup of a Hyper-V Virtual Machine (VM) in an online state. However, DPM cannot back up a Hyper-V VM in an online state, if one or more of the following
    conditions are true:
    Backup (Volume Snapshot) Integration Service is disabled or not installed.
    The virtual machine has one or more dynamic disks.
    The virtual machine has one or more non-NTFS based volumes.
    The virtual machine Cluster Resource Group in a cluster setup is offline.
    The virtual machine is not in a running state.
    A ShadowStorage assignment of a volume inside the virtual machine is explicitly set to a different volume other than itself.
    An App-V drive is installed on the virtual machine that creates a non-NTFS volume.
    These conditions are set by the Hyper-V writer. In such a case, the VM is put in a saved state before a snapshot of host volumes are taken (except when the VM is turned off) for a backup. The Hyper-V writer adds the VM in the following format:
    For offline backups: Backup Using Saved State\<VMName>
    For online backups: Backup Using Child Partition Snapshot\<VMName>
    Additional reason if we have less than 300MB free space on a volume in the guest.
    Kind regards, Leonardo.

  • IPad revert to preconfigured saved state on cold boot?

    We're looking to create a saved state for all the apps and OS settings for our many iPads that would reset automatically on a cold boot. Apple Configurator seems to require too much finagling. We're just looking for some kind of scripted solution that could recall our preconfigured settings for each iPad, restoring it to our business's preferred "pristine" condition whenever the iPad is started from a fully off state.
    I've searched for this everywhere online, but I'm not finding what seems like a very common need for a business that relies on iPads.
    Thanks in advance for any resources/apps/info you can provide!

    Is it the same keyboard you tried on all occassions?
    Sometimes there is a little gap, when the I/O-port metal bracket is not in properly.
    Have you tried PS2 mouse and keyboard? Is there any mentioning of this in Device Manager.
    Windows is keen on having USB-things hot-plugged, while that is totally wrong for PS2-things.

  • OER Atrifacts Store Setup and Configuration for CVS.

    Hello,
    My question is related to proper configuration of a CVS based Artifact Store in Oracle Enterprise Repository.
    I've attempted to configure a CVS Artifact Store from within OER's Asset Editor (as described on page 27 of the OER Configuration Guide & pages 92-93 of the OER Admin Guide.) I have also ensured that this new Artifact Store is selected in the dropdown for the Submission Upload Artifact Store system setting on the OER Admin page. However, my configuration settings for the Store appear to be incorrect and I haven't found a CVS example that has been thorough enough to infer the proper settings.
    So I'm hoping someone can assist me who has been through configuring a CVS Artifact Store for OER. I'll try to provide detailed information below with the hope that it may be of assistance.
    First, analogous CVS settings that are configured for my standard CVS plug-in in Oracle Workshop. These settings are for the pserver protocol, but I think they will provide some value to someone who has experience in configuring a CVS Artifact Store.
    The standard Eclipse CVS plug-in settings for our enterprise repository location:
    Connection Type: pserver
    User: sampleuser
    Password: Pa55wd
    Host: dev003
    Repository Path: /cvs/Integration
    This translates to repository location --> :pserver:sampleuser:Pa55wd@dev003:/cvs/Integration
    (Which is the root of our enterprise CVS repository)
    Now…within this repository location above there is a module (Development/OER-POC) that is located in:
    /cvs/Integration/Development/OER-POC
    …and checked out into a project called "Sandbox" located in the default workspace in Oracle Workshop.
    Additionally, within the organization we also have HTTP access to CVS. This previous example XSD I just mentioned has an HTTP URI of:
    http://dev003:8080/viewcvs/viewcvs.cgi/Development/OER-POC/src/schemas/ExtOfAddrRef/v1/ExtOfAddrRef.xsd?cvsroot=Integration
    Now as I have attempted to properly set up the configuration for the OER Artifact Store I have "translated" the above information into the following entries on the Artifact Store setup screen:
    Name: CVS Enterprise Store
    Type: Raw SCM
    Hostname: dev003
    SCM Location: Integration (??? Not sure if this has been inferred correctly. If not what should be specified here.)
    SCM Type: CVS
    Download Path URI Suffix: cvsroot=Integration (??? Not sure if this correct based in previous information?)
    Download Path URI: (??? Not sure what should be specified here. I have inferred several logical options but they have not worked.)
    Finally, when I referenced page 62 of the ORE Core Registrars Guide PDF the "Additional Development documentation" link (http://devwiki.flashline.com/index.php/B02831) states:
    • "All files from an SCM will be URL addressable. The SCM (or a third party) must provide a way to get a particular file based on a URL. In other words, we are not going to use any client libraries to write code that will retrieve us a file from an SCM. "
    • "Added concept of a 'download path' to an artifact store. For example, consider our development environment. Eclipse will have SCM information (i.e. cvs.flashline.com), eclipse/cvs project information (i.e. projects/framework/modules/com.flashline.geneva.rbac), and file/cvs file information (i.e. /code/com/flashline/geneva/rbac/base/RoleContextPersistBroker.java?rev=1.66). Using this info, a fileinfo's uri can be set. The artifact store will then allow us to specify a download base path such as http://cvs.flashline.com/viewcvs/viewcvs.cgi/."
    To conclude my questions are:
    1) Based on the comments in the Registrar's Guide it seems clear that the intent of an Artifact Store is purely for the support of downloading the physical artifact that corresponds to an OER asset. I would conclude that "Raw SCM" based Artifact Stores do not intend to support direct check-ins for the various SCM systems. (rather assets/artifacts in Eclipse would be manually checked in from within the IDE environment). If someone could confirm whether this is correct that would be much appreciated.
    2) Based on the information I supplied for the example enterprise CVS repository...what would the appropriate settings be for these fields on the Artifact Store setup screen:
    a) SCM Location
    b) Download Path URI Suffix
    c) Download Path URI
    3) Since the "CVS" SCM Type does NOT specify fields for username and password (unlike when you select other potential SCM Types in the Store setup screen); how should one handle credentials in CVS repositories?
    Thanks in advance to any assistance.
    ~Todd

    Hello user642477,
    I'm facing the same problem.
    It seems to me that the Oracles's guide line don't give enough information. I'll try to fixed it and whether I'm able to do so far I'll be in touch...
    By the way, how could you browse to the link: http://devwiki.flashline.com/index.php/B02831? When I try it so a page cannot be displayed message is displayed.
    Regards
    felipe

  • QoS Configuration for NME-AIR-WLC

    Hello,
    I have a question on the correct QoS configuration for a VoIP deployment. I have followed the steps referenced here but have two questions..
    1) The last recommendation in the list is to set DCA channel sensitivity to High to avoid changes during business hours. I think this should be Low? The manual states "Low—The DCA algorithm is not particularly sensitive to environmental changes."
    2) The recommendation is to trust dscp on AP uplinks and to trust cos on the WLC uplink. However I can't find any configuration guidelines for configuring QoS if the WLC in question is an NME hosted in a 2921.
    2a) The link between the switch and the 2921 is an 802.1q trunk so should I trust cos on this link rather than dscp?
    2b) What configuration should be on the 2921? Create a policy-map and apply it to the uplink port?
    2c) Should there be a service policy assigned to the In1/0 interface for the WLC itself?
    Any thoughts appreciated.
    Thanks,
    Dave

    Well I appear to have answered question 2 after I stopped being lazy and did some packet captures.
    No configuration required on 2921 as packets captured from In1/0 and Gi0/0 show correct DSCP markings on RTP and SCCP packets.
    Would still be interested to know on question 1 though.

  • DPM Saved State Limitation

    DPM cannot backup a VM in snapshot/online mode if that VM has a volume that has VSS enabled and it set to store those snapshots on a different volume.  
    1. Is this a limitation of DPM or the HyperV VSS writers?  
    2. Can other backup products that use the HyperV VSS writers backup the VM while it's online?
    3. If a virtualized domain controller is being backed up by DPM as a VM, is Active Directory being backed up properly?  If the Virtual DC is begin backed up with saved state mode, is AD backed up properly?
    http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/hh757970.aspx

    Hi,
    Q1. Is this a limitation of DPM or the HyperV VSS writers?  
    A1. This is a limitation of the Hyper-V integration components installed in the Guest.
    Q2. Can other backup products that use the HyperV VSS writers backup the VM while it's online?
    A2. 3RD party backup products that utilize VSS snapshots should be able to perform online backups like DPM if they support Hyper-V guest protection. However, they will also be effected by any integration component limitations as in question 1
    above. 
    Q3a. If a virtualized domain controller is being backed up by DPM as a VM, is Active Directory being backed up properly?
    A3a.  It's kind of a loaded question - Active directory is protected as part of SystemState protection. That provides more flexibility of how and what gets restored in a more granular form. For actual "Active directory" protection, you should
    also perform systemstate backups. With that said, an online backup is considered application consistent and will contain a consistent AD for that point in time, and should the DC be restored, the AD will be in a good clean state.  
    Q3b.  If the Virtual DC is begin backed up with saved state mode, is AD backed up properly?
    A3b.  All saved state backups are considered crash consistent - the same as if you turned off a machine or power outage occurred without doing a clean shutdown, so that would not be desirable state for a DC. 
    Please remember to click “Mark as Answer” on the post that helps you, and to click “Unmark as Answer” if a marked post does not actually answer your question. This can be beneficial to other community members reading the thread. Regards, Mike J. [MSFT]
    This posting is provided "AS IS" with no warranties, and confers no rights.

  • Backup of windows 2012 Child Hyperv Server as saved state instead of Snapshot

    I have a windows 2012 DPM server runing DPM 2012, with rollup patch applied.  Im backing up several child servers ruuning on a windows 2008 R2 Hyperv server.  All the windows 2008 child servers backup fine using snapshot, however the 2012 server
    running as a child does a saved state backup, it does not have any dynmic disks.
    Any ideas why?
    Richard

    Hi,
    First, SCS DPM 2012 does not support being installed on a Windows server 2012 or protecting Server 2012 until after SCS 2012 Sp1 ships later this year.
    System Center DPM 2012 is not supported running on Windows Server 2012 until we release System Center SP1 later this year.  We have had reports of DPM 2012 console crashes when navigating to the recovery tab if DPM 2012 is installed on Windows server
    2012.  This issue is fixed in SP1.
    If you are already in this condition,  I recommend you backup the DPMDB, rebuild the DPM server using Windows 2008 R2 install DPM 2012, then restore your current database. The process is explained in the below technet article.
    Recovering DPM servers
    http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/jj244606.aspx
    We also do not support protecting Windows Server 2012 using SCS DPM 2012 until after SC SP1 is released.   Please do not expect any support for DPM 2012 running on Windows Server 2012, or issues while protecting data sources in Windows Server
    2012.
    However, with that said here are the general conditions that make a VM go into a saved state during backup.
    Protecting Hyper-V machines
    http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/hh757866.aspx
    Conditions when DPM fails to back up Hyper-V virtual machines in an online state
    By default, System Center 2012 – Data Protection Manager (DPM) performs a backup of a Hyper-V Virtual Machine (VM) in an online state. However, DPM cannot back up a Hyper-V VM in an online state, if one or more of the following
    conditions are true:
    Backup (Volume Snapshot) Integration Service is disabled or not installed.
    The virtual machine has one or more dynamic disks.
    The virtual machine has one or more non-NTFS based volumes.
    The virtual machine Cluster Resource Group in a cluster setup is offline.
    The virtual machine is not in a running state.
    A ShadowStorage assignment of a volume inside the virtual machine is explicitly set to a different volume other than itself.
    An App-V drive is installed on the virtual machine that creates a non-NTFS volume.
    These conditions are set by the Hyper-V writer. In such a case, the VM is put in a saved state before a snapshot of host volumes are taken (except when the VM is turned off) for a backup. The Hyper-V writer adds the VM in the following format:
    For offline backups: Backup Using Saved State\<VMName>
    For online backups: Backup Using Child Partition Snapshot\<VMName>
    Additional reason if we have less than 300MB free space on a volume in the guest.
    Please remember to click “Mark as Answer” on the post that helps you, and to click “Unmark as Answer” if a marked post does not actually answer your question. This can be beneficial to other community members reading the thread. Regards, Mike J. [MSFT] This
    posting is provided "AS IS" with no warranties, and confers no rights.

  • Deployment Issue: The saved State dictionary contains inconsistent data and might have been corrupted.

    Hi,
    I have been working on a C# project. It all works fine except the installer. I can install the project but if I then repair it and then try to un-install it I get the following error:
    "An exception occured while uninstalling. This excepion will be ignored and the uninstall will continue. However, the application might not be fully uninstalled after the uninstall is complete --> The saved State dictionary contains inconsistent data and might have been corrupted."
    This error happens whenever I try to un-install/repair/modify it having previously tried to repair it. It seems that in repairing it the .InstallState file becomes corrupted. I can un-install it by replacing the .Installstate file with a working version. However the end users will not know how to do this. Is there any way of fixing this?
    Just in case it is important: It's a Framework 2 project, built in VS2005, it consists of a windows service and a forms application the service relies heavily on SOAP.
    Thanks for any help,
    Joe

    I've got almost the same problem
    I can't uninstall service that was just installed with install util. Error message is
    An exception occurred during the uninstallation of the .Service.WindowsService.ProjectInstaller installer.System.ArgumentException: The savedState dictionary contains inconsistent data and might have been corrupted.
    There was no repair or modify after install.
    Then I had removed .InstallState file and installUtil did not find any problem in savedState dictionary ;-)
    I checked InstallState file but have not found any visible problem with it
    Please take a look if you know what is InstallState file
    https://onedrive.live.com/redir?resid=5622404b58b0055f!132&authkey=!AA0PsRyTJUTdPgk&ithint=file%2cInstallState
    Regards

  • Hard Drive configuration for speed

    I've got a question regarding the best hard drive configuration for my mac pro. I'm looking to increase the boot speed, application load speed and particularly the speed with which hard drive intensive photoshop processes complete. Right now I'm just using some normal SATA II drives. I'd appreciate it if you could give me some feedback on the various options I am currently considering.
    -2x 64GB SSD in a RAID 0 for OS X and applications with some large SATA drives for storage
    -4x 300GB VelociRaptor 10k RPM SATA HDD in a RAID 0
    -2x 147GB SAS 15k RPM HDD in RAID 0 with some large SATA drives for storage
    I am particularly in the dark about the controllers I'd use for each solution. Clearly, I would absolutely require a PCIe card for the SAS drives, but would there be a marked advantage to using a hardware RAID card for the SATA drives over the software RAID in OS X? Also, how easy is it to get the mac pro to boot off drives connected to a controller card rather than the standard setup? And lastly, if there is good reason to use a card, are there any in particular that you would recommend?
    Thanks a lot!

    2. No. Do not make two partitions unless you do not plan to use Boot Camp Assistant to install Windows on that partition. If you plan to create a Boot Camp partition then you must partition the drive as one Mac OS X volume. Boot Camp Assistant will then create the Windows volume.
    3. This drive must be repartitioned and reformatted as follows:
    Extended Hard Drive Preparation
    1. Open Disk Utility in your Utilities folder.
    2. After DU loads select your hard drive (this is the entry with the mfgr.'s ID and size) from the left side list. Click on the Partition tab in the DU main window.
    3. Set the number of partitions from the drop down menu to two. Use the graphic resizer to set the desired sizes for each volume as you want. Set the format type to Mac OS Extended (Journaled.) Click on the Options button, set the partition scheme to GUID (only required for Intel Macs) then click on the OK button. Click on the Partition button and wait until the process has completed.
    4. Select the first volume you just created (this is the sub-entry under the drive entry) from the left side list. Click on the Erase tab in the DU main window.
    5. Set the format type to Mac OS Extended (Journaled.) Click on the Options button, check the button for Zero Data and click on OK to return to the Erase window.
    6. Click on the Erase button. The format process can take up to several hours depending upon the drive size.
    7. Select the second volume you created and repeat Steps 4-6.
    4. Now here I don't know what you think is your best option. You can buy any two hard drives you want. The ones I identified were only an example of what you could purchase for under $300. There are others, slightly more expensive, that would work, and you would still be under your $300 budget. The Samsung drives are good drives and reasonably priced, but they are just one of several alternatives. You should do some checking on your own before making your decision. I'm just giving some guidance, not trying to tell you what you should do. I've provided three sites where you can read reviews and benchmarks before you decide. You need to "own" your decision.
    As for how you configure these two drives that's a secondary issue. I would recommend using them for backup. Two possible arrangements are a Mirrored or a Striped RAID array. A mirrored RAID array would create one volume that has a 1 TB capacity. Everything saved to that volume is essentially saved twice - once on one drive then a copy is mirrored to the other drive. This is not what you described in your Item 4. That's not how it works. Anything saved to the mirrored RAID array is saved the way I described it just above. It makes no difference where the files come from.
    Now you can use the mirrored RAID array as a Time Machine backup drive if you want, but then you should not use it for other data storage. You would need the entire capacity as backup for both of the 500 GB drives you currently have. A mirrored RAID provides some data redundancy by having a copy of everything one each drive. Thus, if one drive fails the other drive still functions and your data backup is intact. Mirrored RAIDs are generally no faster than an individual drive that makes up the array.
    The second suggestion was to make a Striped RAID array. This type of array produces one volume that is twice the size of the the two drives that make up the array. Thus, you would have a single volume that is 2 TBs in size. You can use this volume for your Time Machine backups also. Striped RAIDs do not provide any data redundancy. If one drive fails all the data stored on the RAID will be lost. However, Striped RAIDs are nearly twice as fast as either drive that makes up the array. This would give you very fast storage and backup.
    You could also just leave the two drives to operate independently. Use on for Time Machine backups, use the other for more storage space.
    Other possibilities abound. It's pretty much up to you to decide what will fit best into your needs today and in the future. Don't feel obliged to do what one person tells you. Five different users on the Discussions will give five different opinions.
    I suggest you educate yourself a bit on backup and restore by reading the FAQ about backup and restore at The XLab FAQs.
    Following is more information on RAIDs:
    RAID Basics
    For basic definitions and discussion of what a RAID is and the different types of RAIDs see RAIDs. Additional discussions plus advantages and disadvantages of RAIDs and different RAID arrays see:
    RAID Tutorial;
    RAID Array and Server: Hardware and Service Comparison>.
    Hardware or Software RAID?
    RAID Hardware Vs RAID Software - What is your best option?
    RAID is a method of combining multiple disk drives into a single entity in order to improve the overall performance and reliability of your system. The different options for combining the disks are referred to as RAID levels. There are several different levels of RAID available depending on the needs of your system. One of the options available to you is whether you should use a Hardware RAID solution or a Software RAID solution.
    RAID Hardware is always a disk controller to which you can cable up the disk drives. RAID Software is a set of kernel modules coupled together with management utilities that implement RAID in Software and require no additional hardware.
    Pros and cons
    Software RAID is more flexible than Hardware RAID. Software RAID is also considerably less expensive. On the other hand, a Software RAID system requires more CPU cycles and power to run well than a comparable Hardware RAID System. Also, because Software RAID operates on a partition by partition basis where a number of individual disk partitions are grouped together as opposed to Hardware RAID systems which generally group together entire disk drives, Software RAID tends be slightly more complicated to run. This is because it has more available configurations and options. An added benefit to the slightly more expensive Hardware RAID solution is that many Hardware RAID systems incorporate features that are specialized for optimizing the performance of your system.
    For more detailed information on the differences between Software RAID and Hardware RAID you may want to read: Hardware RAID vs. Software RAID: Which Implementation is Best for my Application?
    OS X has software for creating RAIDs by using Disk Utility. Open Disk Utility and select DU Help from the Help menu. Search for "raid" without quotes. You will find information on how to set up mirrored and striped RAIDs using Disk Utility.

  • Best Mac Pro Configuration for Editing

    Hey guys. I'm looking to upgrade my editing capabilities from a iMac G5 to a Mac Pro computer system. I pretty much want to go all out on this thing, as I don't look to upgrade again anytime soon. I will be working with a fresh copy of Final Cut Studio 2.
    I was wondering, however, about what would be a good configuration for the hardware itself, more specifically the video cards that are available now.
    Which video card would be the best for HD video editing and manipulation? I was thinking about just getting the most expensive one, but I have heard some video cards are made for one thing more than another, and I want to make sure that I get the right configuration the first time.
    Again, money is not too much of an issue as this will be an expense for my business.
    Any help would be appreciated.
    Message was edited by: Troy Minassian

    Well I'll try not to be too vague here but I think it's going to be easier for me to give you a few hints but mostly talk about where to do more research.
    First: Formats -
    With good ol' DV, any off-the-shelf, completely stock, Mac Pro will handle it - absolutley NO sweat. Just add 1 (or more) iternal SATA drives for capturing media, and you're off to the races. HDV...this could go either way. In theory, again, a basic Mac Pro can handle this. The format's total throughput is no more than DV. However, my thought is that using straight HDV in it's "native" format can be a real pain in the butt. Cruise over the Final Cut forum and do a search for a phrase like "HDV" & "Yuck" and you'll end up with a big long list of issues. I'll not go too far into detail, but HDV is a highly compressed format with a GOP-structure. Dealing with GOP-structured media in an NLE is not pretty.
    The good news is if you're even considering something like an Io HD then the HDV issues can be conquered with it. You would use the Io HD to transcode the HDV to Apple's ProRes codec on the fly. That's what the IoHD does. It's an external capture card whose form factor makes it nice and portable. So you'd come out of your camera or deck - into the Io HD - and out via firewire to your computer. The one "trick" is: you're married to ProRes. That's the one & only codec this box does. (To the best of my knowledge, that is.) Anyway, that's not necessarily a bad thing. Just good to know going into it. Here's a review of the Io HD over at the creativecow.net. And by the way, if you've never hung out over there, note that it's a great resource for help. Tons of in-the-know pros hang out there.
    As far as AVCHD, I'm personally not too familiar with it. I know that it too is not very intensive to deal with - per se. But the whole tapeless concept is still somewhat new and as such has it's share of "gotchas". For that I'd do a search over there on Apple's Final Cut forum. I know a search for AVCHD is going to turn up many many posts.
    Regarding the RED. Again, it's so new it's got it share of workflow bumps to be aware of. (Personally, I love the concept of what this camera is all about. I checked it out and NAB and was really impressed with where they're going with it.) But for better info on that, I'd steer over to the Final Cut forum here and the Final Cut form over at the COW. Further, the camera has it's own forum over at the COW. And another great source of info is reduser.net. This camera is sweeping the industry. But it's changing the workflow quite a bit too.
    Second: Processing -
    As far as overall CPU power goes....Sure! A higher clock speed is basically going to be a faster machine. Here's some stats. But what's the cost? The 3.2 is faster than the 2.8. Is this worth $1600 to you? Only you can answer that question. For me: I just spent a month vacillating over a new machine purchase. I had originally "decided" months ago to get a new Mac Pro Eight 2.8. Then I thought I might save some loot and buy a G5. Then I thought, No! That's a dumb idea.... I could spend only about $600 more and get a refurb'ed 2.66 Quad core. Then I figured I could spend $800 more than that and end up - right back where I started - with a new 2.8 8-Core. So for me, the $1400 more, to go from a used G5 to a new 2.8 Octo, just made sense. But the point is: it's a completely personal decision. For me, that overall margin of money/performance made a lot of sense! On the other hand, did it make sense for me to spend $1600 more and get the 3.2 instead of the 2.8? Not at all! So only you are going to be able to decide if $1600 buys you enough of a performance hike.
    Then, Extras -
    Too, you're going to want to add as much RAM as you can afford. The other big question is storage. You've mentioned a spectrum of formats. On the one hand you've got your DV. Again a single SATA drive will be more than enough to capture to and playback from. But with ProRes HQ you're getting more demanding on the drives. For this, you'd want to now add, let's say, 3 more internal drives and stripe them together into a capture RAID. But you could even go up a few steps and get something like the CalDigit HD Pro and get multiple streams of HD playback with the security of a hardware-controlled RAID 5 scenario. So there's a couple of different ways to go here....However, if you start with very very fast, reliable drives, you're setting yourself to handle higher-end formats. Drive speed can be a killer. But if you start at the top you can basically head off any format woes for the future. (For a while....Nothing's completely future-proof in this game.)
    Finally, Monitoring -
    You've got to figure out how to look at/hear the media outside-of-the-computer. Meaning - you're going to need external monitoring equipment: Video and Audio. Again this will open more questions for you. But these items are key to your knowing what you're REALLY working with. So you really need a NTSC monitor, an audio mixer/control surface of some sort and some powered speakers. The Final Cut forums will be good places to research what others are using in these arenas.
    Anyway, good luck with it all! You've already discovered a great resource: this forum. If I were you, I'd start to spend more time on the Final Cut forums. These types of queries will get solid answers over there. I'd recommend establishing the habit of performing a search when you've over there though. The chances of someone else, already asking the same thing that you're investigating, is quite high. Almost guaranteed. Enjoy!

Maybe you are looking for