WD external hard drive seems to crash my Mac just by being connected to it

Is this even possible?
I apologize in advance if the question is too obviously n00b, or if it's been answered (I did search before posting), or if it's in the wrong forum.
I have a brand-new MBP, late 2008, and I was going to use a WD Elements 1.5 TB external drive for backup (Time Machine) and cloning (CCC). After about a month of use, my MBP started developing strange symptoms like some discussed elsewhere on these forums (apps apparently launching but invisible in the Finder, Finder unable to launch, Disk Utility saying my MBP's drive was failing, WD drive randomly disconnecting itself, and much more) and essentially became unusable. Three different Apple Geniuses were unable to help me. The third one was the most helpful and understanding and sent my MBP off to be repaired. I got it back with the message that they couldn't find anything wrong with it either.
They did a clean install of 10.6.2 and I created a new user account. Everything went fine until I tried to migrate some of my files only (no apps) from the WD drive. Then my clean new MBP began exhibiting the same symptoms as before.
So I did another clean install and created another new user account and didn't touch the WD drive. Everything has been running well for about a week now.
To test if the WD drive itself was the problem, I connected it to my family eMac this morning. The eMac (which admittedly isn't all that fast to begin with, of course) immediately began running slower and the WD drive began to randomly eject itself. I disconnected the drive and am sending it back to WD.
I'm just happy to have my MBP up and running again, though the loss of all my backed-up data is hard to take. I have two questions for the group, if you don't mind:
(1) Is it possible that the WD drive caused all these problems on my poor Macs? I'm going to assume that it is, but I'm curious and would like to understand (briefly) how.
(2) Is it safe to open and use any of the files I recovered from that drive, or should I just trash them to be on the safe side? I feel extremely snake-bit.
Thank you in advance for reading this, and for responding if you care to!

Those WD drives are junk and do not play well with Macs and most likely did cause all of your problems. Only WD seems to know the real reason why.
Those recovered files should be fine. I would no longer trust that drive with important data.

Similar Messages

  • How can I use my external hard drive on both pc and mac, but also being able to use it to back up my mac data?

    I want to be able to transfer some of my files from my laptop to my macbook, but not all of them. I have a NTFS external hard drive and I have heard about reformatting it so that it can read/write across both systems, but can I still use this hard drive to back up the data on my macbook? If I can, how should I go about reformatting the hard drive?

    FORMAT TYPES
    FAT32 (File Allocation Table)
    Read/Write FAT32 from both native Windows and native Mac OS X.
    Maximum file size: 4GB.
    Maximum volume size: 2TB
    You can use this format if you share the drive between Mac OS X and Windows computers and have no files larger than 4GB.
    NTFS (Windows NT File System)
    Read/Write NTFS from native Windows.
    Read only NTFS from native Mac OS X
    To Read/Write/Format NTFS from Mac OS X, here are some alternatives:
    For Mac OS X 10.4 or later (32 or 64-bit), install Paragon (approx $20) (Best Choice for Lion)
    Native NTFS support can be enabled in Snow Leopard and Lion, but is not advisable, due to instability.
    AirPort Extreme (802.11n) and Time Capsule do not support NTFS
    Maximum file size: 16 TB
    Maximum volume size: 256TB
    You can use this format if you routinely share a drive with multiple Windows systems.
    HFS+ ((((MAC FORMAT)))) (Hierarchical File System, a.k.a. Mac OS Extended (Journaled) Don't use case-sensitive)
    Read/Write HFS+ from native Mac OS X
    Required for Time Machine or Carbon Copy Cloner or SuperDuper! backups of Mac internal hard drive.
    To Read HFS+ (but not Write) from Windows, Install HFSExplorer
    Maximum file size: 8EiB
    Maximum volume size: 8EiB
    You can use this format if you only use the drive with Mac OS X, or use it for backups of your Mac OS X internal drive, or if you only share it with one Windows PC (with MacDrive installed on the PC)
    EXFAT (FAT64)
    Supported in Mac OS X only in 10.6.5 or later.
    Not all Windows versions support exFAT. 
    exFAT (Extended File Allocation Table)
    AirPort Extreme (802.11n) and Time Capsule do not support exFAT
    Maximum file size: 16 EiB
    Maximum volume size: 64 ZiB
    You can use this format if it is supported by all computers with which you intend to share the drive.  See "disadvantages" for details.

  • My external hard drives seem to be mixed up in lr4 and I don't know how to fix them

    My external hard drives seem to be mixed up in lr4 and I don't know how to fix them! Help!

    The file opened and cropped in photoshop was a camera raw file?
    In File>Save for Web pick Jpeg from the drop-down

  • ITunes cannot locate purchased music.  It was stored on an external hard drive that has crashed.  How can I recover the songs?

    iTunes cannot locate purchased music.  It was stored on an external hard drive that has crashed.  How can I recover the songs?

    Hello, nwestpha. 
    Thank you for visiting Apple Support Communities. 
    You may find this article helpful in locating your missing media.
    iTunes: Finding lost media and downloads
    http://support.apple.com/kb/TS1408
    Cheers,
    Jason H.

  • Any EASY, simple to use external hard drives that are PC and Mac interchangeable?

    I have a new Mac Book Pro, running Mountain Lion.  I am new to Mac; my old laptop is a Dell running Windows 7.
    I would like to move over ALL my pictures and files from the Dell to an external hard drive (EHD) that is also Mac-compatible.  I want all the pictures and documents SAVED and easily retrievable on the EHD, but probably don't really need *ALL* of them on the Mac.
    Does anyone know of an EHD that will do this?  One that is really super easy to use and won't need "reformatted".  (I don't want to have to try to deal with that!)
    I just want to put ALL my stuff from my Dell on an EHD, then move over SPECIFIC items from that EHD to my Mac. 
    Any advice?  Recommendations?  THANK YOU!

    Bob,
    I'm sorry, my message was unclear!  No, I'm not looking to hook up two computers at one time to one EHD.
    I'm just looking to be able to use one EHD, and go back and forth between it and the Mac or Dell, getting stuff off one, and putting stuff onto the other. 
    I have all my old Dell files and photos already on the EHD.  I was afraid that once I formatted the EHD that those files from my Dell that were already there would somehow no longer be accessible to transfer to the Mac?  But it sounds like this isn't so?
    So, to clarify: I would like to continue to have access to the files on the EHD (from the Dell).  Once I format the EHD, will those files still be accessible to me, to either leave "as is", or transfer to the Mac, now or later?
    THANK YOU!

  • MacBook Pro - Finder Error Code 0 even though the external hard drive is setup as journaled Mac OS Extended

    Hi guys
    It's starting to irritate me that I still can't copy folders of more than 4GB to my external hard drives. I've checked some websites that told me that the external hard drive should be setup as "Mac OS Journaled", but when I check this via Disk Utility, I find out that they are. What is another solution for this problem, cause it takes a lot of time to select folders within folders within folders to copy to the external hard drive, instead of just copy and paste the main folder...
    Thanks in advance!
    Bob

    Okay so today I've erased one of my external hard drives, and reformatted it as "Mac OS Journaled". If I copy a huge folder on it from my MacBook to the external HD, there's nothing wrong and it goes fine.
    But then when I try to replace the folder with a more up-to-date version on my MacBook, the Error Code 0 shows up again.
    So: reformatting didn't work out. Putting huge folders on it goes fine, but replace them with a newer version of the huge folder, doesn't work.
    Any solutions? Please?
    Thanks guys!

  • How can i format my external hard drive to write files from Mac without loosing the files that i alredy have on my external hard when i used it with windows?

    How can i format my external hard drive to write files from Mac without loosing the files that i alredy have on my external hard when i used it with windows?
    I have been using Windows to write files to my 1TB WD external hard drive and I do not want to format to loose the files capacity of around 500GB
    Someone, Please help

    Hi Allen,
    Is there any way to store the back up to Mac and restore after formating?

  • How do I restore data from an external hard drive back to a restored mac?

    how do I restore data from an external hard drive back to a restored mac?

    Hello, Esmin77.  
    Thank you for visiting Apple Support Communities.  
    I see you want to restore your MacBook Pro from an external drive.  Here is an article that may help you with this process if you used Time Machine to backup these files.  
    OS X Yosemite: Recover your entire system
    Cheers, 
    Jason H.  

  • I cannot get my photos to download off my memory card to an external hard drive through bridge on a mac book pro.

    i cannot get my photos to download off my memory card to an external hard drive through bridge on a mac book pro. it comes up with a message Cannot write to specified directory. Please choose a different directory.

    Do not store them in the Cloud.  It isn't really storage.  For iTunes purchases, for example, it is just re-downloading a purchase.  If a label decides to no longer make the item available it will disap[pear from the cloud and that will be it for you.
    You can't store items on an external drive simply by dragging them there.  That's too complicated for iTunes and how it is set up to work.  I know I post on this 10x a week and there's many other posts discussing this.  I suggest you browse a bit first.  Your options are basically to either put your whole library on the eternal drive (which is a nuisance if you don't want to drag it everywhere with you), or to copy individual items to the external drive, delete them from the internal drive, then re-add them as new items (re-adding to playlists, etc.).

  • My recent iTunes purchases are not on my external hard drive (my pc crashed) can I get these purchases recovered?

    My PC (aka POS***) crashed and I knew it was going to happen sooner rather than later, so I backed up my music onto an external hard drive. I failed to back up my music regularly and I have lost a month's worth of purchases. Is there any way to get the past month's purchases restored into my library, since they are in my purchase history? If so, how?

    Downloading past purchases from the App Store, iBookstore, and iTunes Store

  • Reformatting External Hard drive: Disk Utility crashes near the end

    I recently updated to Leopard and emptied off my external hard drive and then wanted to (zero out data &) reformat it and start fresh so as to use it with the new Time Machine feature.
    However, near the end of reformatting it with Disk Utility the progress just stopped and after giving it some time I did a force quit and sure enough it came to light that it had crashed. Since then I've tried again several times to the same result. I even tried doing it of the Disk Utility on the install CD and it crashed with one minute left!!
    Any help or advise would be greatly appreciated!

    Use a more powerful utility such as DiskWarrior, or a product such as those listed here.
    (108710)

  • My external hard drives seem to slow down my iMac

    Hello,
    I've encountered an odd situation in that the external hard drives I use to hold all of my files seem to slow down the performance of my iMac. I have two Lacie 1 tb externals plugged into my 2006 2.0 Ghz iMac with 2 gig of ram. I've had these two externals for about two months and for the same amount of time, any other item (ipod, card reader, thumb drive) I'd plug in would take several min to mount onto my computer. From there, the data transfer from my external or internal hard drive is slightly delayed and slower as well.
    I unmounted these externals today and plugged in a thumb drive to test and it immediately mounted to my computer! I never thought an external could effect the mounting of other, smaller, externals!
    I'm just wondering if there's anything I can do to fix this problem? My itunes music files are stored on my externals and I'm a photographer, so I'd need regular access to my externals to get to my pictures.
    Thanks for all your help. I can usually find the answer to my problem by browsing around in discussions, but I find this situation to be a bit of a unique one!

    kromedomio wrote:
    Sorry, It's connected to my iMac via Firewire 400. I have the externals connected to each other via Firewire 800.
    In regards to types of files, I have my itunes library, photo (Raw Canon 50d files), Adobe (photoshop, indesign, illustrator) and Word files all on the external. I basically moved everything off my internal and store it all on my external now, so I'm accessing it a lot through the day.
    I'm wondering just why you did that. Surely you know that F/W 400 is much slower than your internal HD?
    I'd be inclined to move things that involve heavy I/O during editing (photos and videos, especially) back to the internal. I suspect you'll see a large improvement.

  • Maxtor Mini External Hard Drive slows or crashes my macbook

    I recently bought a Maxtor Mini external hard drive since I work with a number of large files, mostly CS3. Anytime I plug in my external hard drive, my computer slows down (trying to save a jpg, takes 15 minutes, copying a 20MB file from the external to the internal hard drive takes around 20 minutes). Anytime I open ANY application on the macbook, while the Maxtor is plugged in, the macbook crashes.
    When I bought the Maxtor, I formatted it for my Mac, with the CD that came with the external hard drive.
    Any suggestions?!
    thanks!

    You shouldn't need any CD provided by the manufacturer to format the drive. I can't see any particular format type causing that problem though. If you don't have anything you need on the drive now... try formatting it using Disk Utility (in your Applications/Utilities folder).
    http://www.larryjordan.biz/assets/articleimages/lj_journal01.jpg
    Try that first and see what happens. Like I said... I don't really see any particular format causing the problem you are having... but since we don't know what the CD you used did, it's best to start clean.
    Do you know if you actually installed anything on your computer from the CD?

  • How do I retrieve my iphoto library from the Time Machine back-up drive, when the original iphoto library was on a separate external hard drive that has crashed?

    I recently backed up my iMAC and Simpletech external hard-drive to a 1 TB WD Passport  external hard drive, using Time Machine's back-up utility.  Today, I tried to access my iphoto library from the back-up drive, but received a message saying "the iPhoto library is a Time Machine back up, and so cannot be used as the main library.  Relaunch iPHoto with options key held down to choose another library."  Since my Simpletech died on me, what other iPhoto library is it expecting me to access?  I know approximately 169 GB were backed up, and my iPhoto library is roughly 54 GB. 
    Angie in Charlotte

    Thanks.  I will try going through TM.  Since my Simpletech is on the way out, I'll be plugging in a new external hard drive (other than the back-up drive) and trying to restore the library to the new drive.  Any advice or warning if this is NOT the right thing to do?
    Meanwhile, that is a great tip to do an alternate back-up using a different means.  It's been tough to figure out how to "preserve access" to digital images and files for posterity, knowing the hardware will always fail/obsolesce sooner or later, and that "clouds" are only as good as their consistent and reliable accessibility.  Upping the odds with redundancy will help dull the edge of my "access anxiety", though logically, it can never relieve it.  Will look into
    Carbon Copy Cloner.

  • My external hard drive seems to have a problem ?

    movies played from my my external hard drive lag or either very slow, almost anything i open from my external lags, what does this mean ???but if i transfer them to my laptop and open them they work perfectly ! i tried to repair it but this happened .....

    Streaming content from an external HD is always going to be slower than if the content is local on the SSD. Especially if you're using USB2 with hi-def content, it'll be even worse. For example, I had a 176GB copy of a 1080p movie that I tried to stream over USB2 and the movie was unplayable on my machine. It'd show 5-10 seconds of video, buffer, skip 8-10 seconds and then repeat the cycle.
    Moving to FireWire 800, Thunderbolt of USB3 will definitely improve (if not completely eliminate) these problems. Otherwise for media that requires constant disk read access, you'll want to run it locally.

Maybe you are looking for

  • Can't make purchases from a specific app?

    I bought about $200 worth of things from an app, and tried entering a new card to make more purchases. Now I keep getting an error saying it cannot contact itunes store, like it is locked out, but I can buy other things on other apps just fine... How

  • New subsites appear to be unavailable in Sharepoint 2013

    When trying to visit any subsite within the SharePoint 2013 (SP1) farm, the following error appears on subsites that previously were available to any user: Sorry, something went wrong File Not Found. Furthermore, when looking at the event logs on the

  • Need help on setting up router

    Hi, I have a WRT54G wireless G router. I have a problem connecting to the internet through the router. If I connect an internet cable directly from my modem to my laptop, the internet works fine. If I connect the modem to the router and the router to

  • BDC for CKECP- Item fields are not captured

    Hi all I recorded transaction CKECP using shdb. In that if we click 'Show/hide item view' the item wise details to be entered appears. items were entered. Transaction recorded. But the item fields are not appearing in the recording. Can somebody expl

  • CS5 not opening up. (Kubota plugin bug)

    When I try to open photoshop on it's own or by using Bridge it just brings up the blue box and then it just sits there. I have had to force quit many times on my MAC. I have restarted my computer. I checked all of my updates and they are all current