WD Java or WD Abap??

Hi,
In latest presentations about EHP4 and ESS/MSS, I came to know that SAP will prefer WDA for writing business applications. Especially with FPM for WDA this seems catching up very fast. If ESS/MSS is re-written in WDA (Labs are too fast at this!), will the WDJ still be having same importance or preference?
Also if we take typical implementaion scenario - we always have a abap pool developing custom applications using abap workbench, will there be a chance of seeing such java pool developing custom applications using NWDI/CE?
I have seen NWDI as a pain point in many implementations (not even it is costly the installation and configuration also requires considerable time and effort), is there any chance SAP will ship it free with CE similar to ABAP workbench?
Earlier I used to hear rumors about abap being replaced by java and within 3 years I am now hearing rumors that abap will continue to rule!
I dont know if this is right place to put these questions but i found the discussions here very interestingu2026hoping to see a reply.
Edited by: Paranidharan Gandhi on Oct 15, 2009 1:42 PM

Hi,
Correct, SAP intends to convert ESS/MSS to WDA in the next year or so.
As far as relevance of WDJ is concerned, if you followed the discussion on SDN on BSP vs Web Dynpro, or ABAP vs. JAVA, you'd realise that they don't lead anywhere other than the fact that SAP will keep on investing in ABAP as well as JAVA for foreseeable future. It is the organization's choice which tools they prefer to use for custom development. However, if Oracle does end up acquiring Sun (thus JAVA), SAP might have to come up with a different strategy over the next few years.
NWDI: I'd presonally suggest moving away from NWDI. CTS+ support is being added to all latest product releases. Unless the organization is involved in serious JAVA development work, value offered by NWDI shoud be evaluated critically.
Regards,
Shehryar

Similar Messages

BI Java and BI ABAP -RSPLAN issue

Hi All
We are working with BI system ,using BI 7.0 Java and BI ABAP as separate systems on same host.
Already run the template intaller for BI Java and ABAP integration.
But facing some issue ,when going ot BI ABAP and RSPLAN and clicking the Start Mideller
it is opening a browser as http://host:8000/sap/public/myssocntl?sap-client-XXX
Since this is not correct and it should open BI Java portal instead of ABAP stack page.
Instead this should open a Url like this http://host:5XX00/webdynpro/dispatcher/sap.com/biplanworkbench1/Modeler?
I check on BI ABAP system under SAP Reference IMG -> SAP Customizing Implementation Guide-> SAP NetWeaver _> Business Intelligence-> BI Integrated Planning -> Settings for Starting the Planning Modeler.
There the default Url is BEx Portal Server and the url is
http://host:5XX00/webdynpro/dispatcher/sap.com/biplanworkbench1/Modeler
Can anybody let me know why this is going to ABAP server instead it should go to Java.
Regards
Ajay
Edited by: Ajay Sandal on Mar 10, 2009 2:31 PM

Hi Ajay ..
Good news that ur issue is resolved ..
I have somewhat similar issue .. Hopu u can put some light ..
I have Bi 7.o with Add on java ,
In RSPLAN from ABAP system , modular page is not coming . if i click on start moduler button in RSPLAN ..portal page is coming up and i have to give logging details .
Please suggest .
Thanks

Impact of Installing BI Java on an ABAP only BI 7.0 system

Afternoon Everyone,
I'm looking to answer a couple of questions around installation of BI Java on an ABAP only BI 7.0 system.
Firstly, I am looking for some guidelines around common problems we would expect to see if a BI java stack is implemented on a BI 7.0 system that is currently ABAP only. I would like to be able to gauge the impact of any such exercise, so we can translate that into extra project effort (both technically and functionally).
Secondly, I am looking for suggestions around the areas where the post Java install regression testing should be focused so we can ensure the existing functionality of the system is unaffected by the install & activation of the BI Java stack.
Id be really grateful for any input you would be able to provide around these questions!
Thanks
Tim.

Hi,
Pls Look at note 917950, esp. Problem_Analysis.zip in Attachments for the Installing BI Java on an ABAP only BI 7.0 .
For Some more thoughts ,pls chk below link
https://www.sdn.sap.com/irj/sdn/threadmessageid=3034054#3034054
What are the pros and cons of installing java+abap stack for portal?
WAS 6.4 with Java or ABAP + Java
http://help.sap.com/saphelp_nw70/helpdata/en/29/ff9036e1e4b603e10000009b38f889/frameset.htm
*pls assign points,if info is useful*
Regards
CSM reddy

Error while calling java program from ABAP

Hi Experts,
We are trying for RFC inbound scenario.
We followed the below blog
/people/gregor.wolf3/blog/2004/08/26/setup-and-test-sap-java-connector-outbound-connection
We are working with SAP JCO 3.0.2
We are getting the error : 'STFC_CONNECTION' could not be found in the server repository.
After I run the Java server program if I execute the RFC destination directly from SM 59 it is showing successful messages.
If I stop the java program then this RFC is failing. Based on this we concluded that RFC to Java connection is working fine.
But as mentioned in blog if we call the RFC Destination from ABAP program it is giving the below error,
'STFC_CONNECTION' could not be found in the server repository.
If we test the RFC destination using RFC_TRUSTED_CHECK standard FM we are getting the below error.
'RFCPING' could not be found in the server repository.
We create the RFC destination of Type : TCP/IP as exactly mention in the blog.
Please help us in resolving this issue.
Thanks
Prince

Pabi,
Using the RFC connection,we can establish a link between Java and SAP.
Afterwards,hope we can call Java program from ABAP.
Below is the sample piece of code to establish RFC connection(link) between Java and SAP.
DATA: REQUTEXT LIKE SY-LISEL,
      RESPTEXT LIKE SY-LISEL,
      ECHOTEXT LIKE SY-LISEL.
DATA: RFCDEST like rfcdes-rfcdest VALUE 'NONE'.
DATA: RFC_MESS(128).
REQUTEXT = 'HELLO WORLD'.
RFCDEST = 'JCOSERVER01'. "corresponds to the destination name defined in the SM59
CALL FUNCTION 'STFC_CONNECTION'
   DESTINATION RFCDEST
   EXPORTING
     REQUTEXT = REQUTEXT
   IMPORTING
     RESPTEXT = RESPTEXT
     ECHOTEXT = ECHOTEXT
   EXCEPTIONS
     SYSTEM_FAILURE        = 1 MESSAGE RFC_MESS
     COMMUNICATION_FAILURE = 2 MESSAGE RFC_MESS.
IF SY-SUBRC NE 0.
    WRITE: / 'Call STFC_CONNECTION         SY-SUBRC = ', SY-SUBRC.
    WRITE: / RFC_MESS.
ENDIF.
Regards,
Sree

Abap+ java stack or Abap stack

Hi All,
How to know whether a system is ABAP+ JAVA stack or JAVA stack.
In our system EP6.0 which is JAVA stack holds JC00 which is a java instance direcory. In BW system we have SCS20 and Dvebg...00 directories is it ABAP+ JAVA stack or ABAP stack with J2ee engine services.
Please suggest me...
Thanks,
Subhash.G

In the forder structuer usr\sap\<SID> if you have DVEBMGS<XX> then it's ABAP and if it's JC<XX>, then it's JAVA. Also if under DVEBMGS<XX> you have j2ee and SDM folder then it's a dual stack that is both ABAP and JAVA.
As for the URL if it's a dual stack then using the browser use the user j2ee_admin and the specified password, else if it is only java then use administrator user and the specified password.
If it's a dual stack you can also login using sapgui.
If in case its single stack AS_ABAP
THere will one be a single node i.e. no message server and enque server. The folder stur would be /usr./sap/<SID>/ and tou would find
DVEBMG SYS folders only.
IF in case its single stack Java server then
In mmc. you will find, 2 nodes one for message server, enque server and the other for the SDM, dispatcher and server0
the foder struct would be
/usr/sap/<SID?
JC><CIno> SCS<no>
Now in case if you have double stack i.e. AS-java and AS-ABAP you would will find these things in mmc
Message server and enque server
disp+work, message server and wp
the folder struct would be
/usr/sap/<SID>/
DVEBMG<no> SCS<no>

How to call java program from ABAP

Hi Experts,
My requirement is to call java programs from ABAP. For that i have set up SAP JCO connection by using this link http://www.sdn.sap.com/irj/scn/weblogs?blog=/pub/wlg/739. [original link is broken] [original link is broken] [original link is broken] Connection gets sucessfully. After this how to call java program from ABAP as per our requirement. Please help me out.
Also i tried this way also.. but while executing the DOS Command line appear & disappear in few seconds. So couldnt see the JAVA output. Please help me out to call java programs in ABAP..
DATA:command TYPE string VALUE 'D:Javajdk1.6.0_20 injavac',
parameter TYPE string VALUE 'D:java MyFirstProgram'.
CALL METHOD cl_gui_frontend_services=>execute
EXPORTING
application = command
parameter = parameter
OPERATION = 'OPEN'
EXCEPTIONS
cntl_error = 1
error_no_gui = 2
bad_parameter = 3
file_not_found = 4
path_not_found = 5
file_extension_unknown = 6
error_execute_failed = 7
OTHERS = 8.
Thanks.

This depends on the version of your Netweaver Java AS. If you are running 7.0, you will have to use the Jco framework. The Jco framework is deprecated since 7.1 though. If you want to build a RFC server in 7.1 or higher, it is adviced that you set it up through JRA.
Implement an RFC server in 7.0:
http://help.sap.com/saphelp_nw04/helpdata/en/6a/82343ecc7f892ee10000000a114084/frameset.htm
Implement an RFC server in 7.1 or higher:
http://help.sap.com/saphelp_nwce72/helpdata/en/43/fd063b1f497063e10000000a1553f6/frameset.htm

How to restart Java Engine in ABAP+JAVA dual stack installation ?

Dear Experts
if i use stopsap r3 in this dual stack installation - it stops both ABAP & JAVA Web Application Servers.
I want to restart only JAVA Weba pplication server.
How do it ?
Thaks in Advance !
Rgds

But theoritically they are 2 indpeendent installations like
AS ABAP
AS JAVA
..Do you aggree ?? really am not good on basics!!
During the installation also - if select AS ABAP & AS JAVA - it will become dual installation
and it does not show
any dependency while installing that AS JAVA requires AS ABAP.[Installation Component Selection and Dependency Screen shot|http://i303.photobucket.com/albums/nn153/S0002919350/SAP%20Issues/Oracle_Patches.jpg]
Installation Component Selection and Dependency Screen shot
Is it because if AS ABAP is down - AS JAVA UME is 001 client - and Java authentication fails ?
Can we de attatch from ABAP UME for my requirement like - running JAVA WAS alone w/o ABAP.
Regards
PR
Regards
Edited by: P.R. SRINIVAS on Jun 16, 2008 4:15 PM

Java Maping and ABAP Mapping

Hello,
Pls let me know about Java Maping and ABAP Mapping
Also pls provide good simple scenario blogs for Java Maping and ABAP Mapping.
Regards

Hi Ranchit,
Check these links for Mappings
https://www.sdn.sap.com/irj/servlet/prt/portal/prtroot/docs/library/uuid/9202d890-0201-0010-1588-adb5e89a6638
https://websmp102.sap-ag.de/~sapdownload/011000358700003604872004E/MappingXI30.pdf (Need Service Makrket place ID)
https://www.sdn.sap.com/irj/sdn/go/portal/prtroot/docs/library/uuid/8a57d190-0201-0010-9e87-d8f327e1dba7
JAVA Mapping BLOGS
/people/prasad.ulagappan2/blog/2005/06/29/java-mapping-part-i
/people/prasad.ulagappan2/blog/2005/06/29/java-mapping-part-ii
/people/prasad.ulagappan2/blog/2005/06/29/java-mapping-part-iii
/people/stefan.grube/blog/2006/10/23/testing-and-debugging-java-mapping-in-developer-studio
ABAP Mapping Blogs
https://www.sdn.sap.com/irj/servlet/prt/portal/prtroot/docs/library/uuid/e3ead790-0201-0010-64bb-9e4d67a466b4
/people/sameer.shadab/blog/2005/09/29/testing-abap-mapping
Sachin
Message was edited by:
Sachin Dhingra

Regarding Java mapping and ABAP Mapping

Hello,
If I suppose to do Java mapping or ABAP mapping, Is there any pre requisite to perform these two mappings?
If exist what they are?
How to perform them?
Thank you

Hello jyotsna,
Java mapping can be used when you have complex mapping structures.
We can do most of the times for our requirements through Graphical mapping.
When the structures are very complex to build you can go for SAX (Simple API for XML) or DOM (Document Object Model) parsers.
Message mapping internally generates DOM parser.
Java Mapping in XI
https://www.sdn.sap.com/irj/sdn/advancedsearch?cat=sdn_all&query=java+mapping&adv=false&sortby=cm_rnd_rankvalue#
SAP Network Blog: Implementing a Java Mapping in SAP PI
/people/carlosivan.prietorubio/blog/2007/12/21/implementing-a-java-mapping-in-sap-pi
Java Mapping (SAP Library - Partner Connectivity Kit)
http://help.sap.com/saphelp_nw04/helpdata/en/e2/e13fcd80fe47768df001a558ed10b6/frameset.htm
SAP Network Blog: XI Java Mapping Helper (DOM)
/people/alessandro.guarneri/blog/2007/03/25/xi-java-mapping-helper-dom
SAP Network Blog: Testing and Debugging Java Mapping
/people/stefan.grube/blog/2006/10/23/testing-and-debugging-java-mapping-in-developer-studio
Binary Conversion in XI - Java Mapping - Code Gallery - Wiki
https://www.sdn.sap.com/irj/sdn/wiki?path=/display/snippets/binary%2bconversion%2bin%2bxi%2b-%2bjava%2bmapping
SAP Network Blog: "JAVA MAPPING", an alternate way of reading a CSV file
/people/rahul.nawale2/blog/2006/07/18/java-mapping-an-alternate-way-of-reading-a-csv-file
ABAP mappings run on ABAP Stack and are developed in the ABAP workbench of the Integration Server.
You normally do not need to use the ABAP mappings and is preferable for someone with ABAP programming background. I should say JAVA functions would suffice any complex scenarios.
refer step by step guides for ABAP Mapping
ABAP Mapping
https://www.sdn.sap.com/irj/sdn/advancedsearch?cat=sdn_all&query=abap+mapping&adv=false&sortby=cm_rnd_rankvalue#
How to Use ABAP Mapping in Exchange Infrastructure 3.0 (NW2004)
https://www.sdn.sap.com/irj/sdn/go/portal/prtroot/docs/library/uuid/5c46ab90-0201-0010-42bd-9d0302591383
SAP Network Blog: Testing ABAP Mapping
/people/sameer.shadab/blog/2005/09/29/testing-abap-mapping
SAP Network Blog: How to call XI ABAP Mapping via RFC
/people/ricardoandres.maienza/blog/2007/04/06/how-to-call-xi-abap-mapping-via-rfc
SAP Network Blog: XI: ABAP mapping logs - more standard = better visibility
/people/michal.krawczyk2/blog/2006/09/20/xi-abap-mapping-logs--more-standard-better-visibility
SAP Network Blog: Dynamically sending a mail to the PO creator using XSLT- ABAP Mapping
/people/rahul.nawale2/blog/2006/11/01/dynamically-sending-a-mail-to-the-po-creator-using-xslt-abap-mapping
You need to provide the name of your mapping program maually , you see it is an input box.
just provide the name of abap mapping program it will work.
and one more thing you cannot test abap mapping program in integration builer you need to test in abap only.
use tcode: SXI_MAPPING_TEST for testing abap mapping
Thanks,
Satya
Reward points if it is useful..

User mapping when installing JAVA addin for ABAP

Hi,
I have installd SAP ABAP on a domain.
As the ABAP went fine and successfully gets installed.
When I am installing JAVA addon for ABAP it is throwing an error lke the users are not mapped.
So can any one guide me where actually I should map the SAP users in a domain.
Prashanth

Your question is very vague, please post the full error.
As this is a java add-in it should user ABAP as datasource so no user mapping should be required.
User mapping is used where java and backend system use different datasources and the naming conventions are different...
Theres not enough information here to give you an objective answer.
Regards
Juan

Calling Java program from ABAP

Hi All,
my ABAP program downloads one file to one folder. Then one Java program is running to Encrypt the file.
Now , they want to call the JAVA program in ABAP, so that they can encrypt the file before downloading.
Is it possible to call a Java program from ABAP ? If Yes, please give me the detailed procedure.
Thanks
pabi

Pabi,
Using the RFC connection,we can establish a link between Java and SAP.
Afterwards,hope we can call Java program from ABAP.
Below is the sample piece of code to establish RFC connection(link) between Java and SAP.
DATA: REQUTEXT LIKE SY-LISEL,
      RESPTEXT LIKE SY-LISEL,
      ECHOTEXT LIKE SY-LISEL.
DATA: RFCDEST like rfcdes-rfcdest VALUE 'NONE'.
DATA: RFC_MESS(128).
REQUTEXT = 'HELLO WORLD'.
RFCDEST = 'JCOSERVER01'. "corresponds to the destination name defined in the SM59
CALL FUNCTION 'STFC_CONNECTION'
   DESTINATION RFCDEST
   EXPORTING
     REQUTEXT = REQUTEXT
   IMPORTING
     RESPTEXT = RESPTEXT
     ECHOTEXT = ECHOTEXT
   EXCEPTIONS
     SYSTEM_FAILURE        = 1 MESSAGE RFC_MESS
     COMMUNICATION_FAILURE = 2 MESSAGE RFC_MESS.
IF SY-SUBRC NE 0.
    WRITE: / 'Call STFC_CONNECTION         SY-SUBRC = ', SY-SUBRC.
    WRITE: / RFC_MESS.
ENDIF.
Regards,
Sree

Call Java Pgm from ABAP

Hi All,
I need to call a Java function from ABAP. Currently i work on client machine and i have a sample java program with me. What do i need to do in order to execute that Java program from ABAP se38 program?
1. Should i place that java program on server in order to execute?
2. How to maintain RFC Destination in SM59? what is meant by program id and gateway mentioned in in SM59 under create option.
Can some one help me with this regard?
Points will be awarded!!
Thanks in advance,

://www.sdn.sap.com/irj/sdn/go/portal/prtroot/docs/library/uuid/59ef6011-0d01-0010-bfb0-b51381e00509
http://www.erpgenie.com/abap/bapi/example.htm
Reward points if it is useful...

Java Stack and ABAP Stack

Hi Experts,
i am now confused about these two stacks: Java Stack and ABAP Stack.
for IR objects, like DT, MT, SI, MM, SM, Action, Process Integration Scenario
for ID objects, like profile agreements, receiver determination, interface determination,
1. where are these objects stored in? Java or ABAP stack?
and i know Adapter Engine is run on JAVA Stack while Integration Engine is on ABAP Stack.
2. how do they call the objects stored in different stack during processing?

Hi,
1. where are these objects stored in? Java or ABAP stack?
These objects are basically developed on the JAVA stack, when they are activated their runtime version is created on ABAP stack, which you can check in SXI_CACHE transaction.
2. how do they call the objects stored in different stack during processing?
Runtime versions of these objects are responsible for the execution of the interfaces.
-Supriya.

Accessing the Par file or java methods in ABAP programming at ECC from EP

Hi experts,
Can we access par file or java methods in ABAP programming (ECC side)which are at Enterprise portal side .If it is possible please
let me know the procedure.Thanks for your help.
Thanks and Regards,
Venkat

Hi Das,
The mentioned wiki is for uploading the par file ,but my question is diffrent.This file or java method need to be used in ABAP side.
Thanks and Regards,
venkat

How is the interface between the Java Stack and ABAP stack is achieved?

How is the interface between the Java Stack and ABAP stack is achieved?..Please send me the answer to [email protected]

Hi,
By interface, I assume you mean the connection between the ABAP and the Java stacks in a double stack system.
The connection from Java to ABAP is through JCo connections defined in the WebDynpro section of the J2EE start page. So Java to ABAP requests are processed through JCo.
The connection from ABAP to Java is through RFC connections defined in TA SM59. The ABAP to Java requests are processed through RFC.
Refer https://dsd.esco-salt.com/StartPage/documents/integration/3.html for detailed explanation.
The UME can be maintained in either ABAP or in JAVA depending on the persistence.
Refer: http://help.sap.com/saphelp_nw70/helpdata/en/5b/5d2706ebc04e4d98036f2e1dcfd47d/frameset.htm
Check UME data source configuration.
Some quick FAQs can be found at:
https://www.sdn.sap.com/irj/servlet/prt/portal/prtroot/docs/library/uuid/ad47eb90-0201-0010-7cb2-ddfa5ed879ec
Hope this helps.
Best Regards,
Srividya.R

System time for Java Stack and ABAP Stack of PI

HI,
     We have a scenario in which we have a synchronous flow of data. In the forward flow we have used field UZEIT in an RFC Lookup to register the inbound time and in the reverse flow we have used current time function of SAP PI mapping. PI time is the local time of the server, However UZEIT is 4 hours ahead compared to PI time.
Both the Java and the Abap stack are installed on the same server.
Kindly let us know the reason for the difference in time on both the stacks.
Regards,
            Milan Thaker

Hi,
   Yes I am refering to the System->Status time in ABAP Stack. Could you please tell me where can I check the System time of JAVA stack. I got one XML file in UME which refers to some timestamp in com.sap.security.core.usermanagement but I failed to locate this field. Please let me know where can I find the Java stack time and how can that be synchronized with ABAP.
         Also, is there any time zone settting in JAVA for UTC , the way we have in ABAP
Regards,
              Milan Thaker

WD Java or WD Abap??

Similar Messages

Maybe you are looking for